BHABHA, Faisal. Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in Legal Education

8/16/2019 BHABHA, Faisal. Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in Legal Education

1/44

Osgoode Hall Law School of York University

Osgoode Digital Commons

Od La& S-d$ Ra+c# Pa*+ S+$Ra+c# Pa*+, W+%$ Pa*+, C!+c

Pa*+

2014

Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in LegalEducation

Faisal BhabhaOsgoode Hall Law School of York University , #ab#a@d.+%.ca

F&& -#$ ad add$-$a& +% a-: #5*://d$$-a&c''.d.+%.ca/&+*

3$ A+- $c& $ b+#- - !+ !+ ad * acc b -# Ra+c# Pa*+, W+%$ Pa*+, C!+c Pa*+ a- Od D$$-a& C''. I- #a

b acc*-d !+ $c&$ $ Od La& S-d$ Ra+c# Pa*+ S+$ b a a-#+$d ad'$$-+a-+ ! Od D$$-a& C''.

Rc''dd C$-a-$B#ab#a, Fa$a&, "Ta+d a Pda ! D$+$- $ La& Edca-$" (2014). Osgoode Legal Studies Research Paper Series. Pa*+ 1.#5*://d$$-a&c''.d.+%.ca/&+*/1

http://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/olsrps?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/working_papers?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/working_papers?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/olsrps?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/olsrps/1?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/olsrps/1?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/olsrps?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/working_papers?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/working_papers?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/olsrps?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPageshttp://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/?utm_source=digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca%2Folsrps%2F1&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPages


2/44

OSGOODE HALL LAW SCHOOL

LEGAL STUDIES RESEARCH PAPER SERIES

Research Paper No. 77

Vol. 10/ Issue. 17/ (2014)

Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in LegalEducationBhabha, F. (2014). Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in Legal EducationOsgoode Hall Law Journal, 52(1), forthcoming.

Faisal Bhabha

Editors:

Editor-in-Chief: Carys J. Craig (Associate Dean of Research & Institutional Relations andAssociate Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University, Toronto)

Production Editor: James Singh (Osgoode Hall Law School, York University, Toronto)

This paper can be downloaded free of charge from:http://ssrn.com/abstract=2522924

Further information and a collection of publications from the Osgoode Hall Law School LegalStudies Research Paper Series can be found at:

http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/JELJOUR_Results.cfm?form_name=journalbrowse&journal_id=722488

http://ssrn.com/abstract=2522924http://ssrn.com/abstract=2522924http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/JELJOUR_Results.cfm?form_name=journalbrowse&journal_id=722488http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/JELJOUR_Results.cfm?form_name=journalbrowse&journal_id=722488http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/JELJOUR_Results.cfm?form_name=journalbrowse&journal_id=722488http://ssrn.com/abstract=2522924


3/44

Osgoode Legal Studies Research Paper No. 77

Vol. 10/ Issue. 17/ (2014)

Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in Legal EducationBhabha, F. (2014). Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in Legal Education Osgoode Hall Law

Journal, 52(1), forthcoming.

Faisal Bhabha

Abstract:There is resounding consensus that diversity in legal education is a priority. Yet, NorthAmerican law schools continue to be criticized for failing to reflect the diversity of thesociety that they are training lawyers to serve. With the backdrop of critical scholarship andempirical evidence, this paper is a project of conceptual reorientation. The first partexamines the past 20 years of diversity promotion in legal education and concludes that,

while several advances have been made, especially in increasing numerical representation ofdiverse groups in law schools, the promise of meaningful diversity remains unfulfilled. Thenext part situates the site of reform on the model of professional identity being produced,which the author suggests is out of reach and out of touch for many minority students. Inthe final part, the author elucidates a program of transforming the norm of lawyering that istaught in law school. Grounded in a normative framework of access to justice and equality,the author argues that experiential/clinical learning practices offer a useful method toachieve a more engaged pedagogical commitment to diversity in legal education.

Keywords:Legal education, equality, pedagogy, diversity, access to justice

Author(s):Faisal BhabhaAssistant ProfessorOsgoode Hall Law SchoolYork University, TorontoE: [email protected]

mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


4/44

"

!"#$%&' $ )*&$+"+, "- &./*%'.!,

.0 1*+$1 *&23$!."0

-45647 894:94;

#$%&% '( &%()*+,'+- .)+(%+(*( /$0/ ,'1%&('/2 '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '( 0 4&')&'/25 6%/7 8)&/$9:%&'.0+ 30; (.$))3( .)+/'+*% /) :%0+'+->*3

,'1%&('/2 &%:0'+( *+>*3>'33%,5 #$% +%B/ 40&/ ('/*0/%( /$% ('/% )> &%>)&: )+ /$% :),%3 )>4&)>%((')+03 ',%+/'/2 30;2%&'+- /$0/ '( /0*-$/ '+ 30; (.$))35 F&)*+,%,'+ 0 +)&:0/'1% >&0:%;)&@ )> 0..%(( /) A*(/'.% 0+, %G*03'/27 /$% 0*/$)& 0&-*%( /$0/

%B4%&'%+/'03H.3'+'.03 3%0&+'+- 4&0./'.%( )>>%& 0 *(%>*3 :%/$), /) 0.$'%1% 0 :)&%

%+-0-%, 4%,0-)-'.03 .)::'/:%+/ /) ,'1%&('/2 '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+5

.< #=, &./*%'.!,>


5/44

C

Q%-03 %,*.0/')+ '+ 8)&/$ 9:%&'.0 '( .$0+-'+-5 #$%(% .$0+-%( 0&% )..*&&'+- 0/ 0 /':%;$%+ 30; (.$))3( 0&% *+,%& '+/%+(% 4&%((*&%( >&): 0 10&'%/2 >)&.%(7 :0+2 )> ;$'.$

0&% Q0; L.$))3V #$&%% X'(')+( 0+, 0 K&%,'./')+e fCD"Ng

$//4VHH404%&(5((&+5.):H()3NH404%&(5.>:h0*/*&% )> 30; (.$))3 ,%4%+,( )+ m ,%1%3)4:%+/( '+ 4)3'/'.03 %.)+):27 /%.$+)3)-27

,%:)-&04$2 0+, ().'%/2 /$0/ 0&% &%.)+>'-*&'+- /$% 3%-03 (2(/%:7 /$% :0&@%/ >)& 4&)>%((')+03 (%&1'.%(

0+, /$% (/&*./*&% )> $'-$%& %,*.0/')+5enC W)& ,%>'+'/')+03 4*&4)(%(7 ;$%+ (4%0@'+- )> d3%-03 %,*.0/')+7e E &%>%& /) /$% 4&)1'(')+ )> /&0'+'+- 0+,

%,*.0/')+03 (%&1'.%( /) (/*,%+/( ;$) ;'33 (**33a/':% 30; 4&)>%(()&(7 ;'/$ 0 (:033%&

+*: 40&/a/':% )& 0,A*+./ >0.*3/27 :0+2 )> ;$): :0'+/0'+ 0./'1% 4&)>%((')+03 3'1%(5 ?$%+

(4%0@'+- )> /$% d3%-03 4&)>%((')+7e E &%>%& /) /$% 4&)>%((')+0332 .)+(/'/*/%, .)&4( )> 3'.%+(%, 30;2%&( '+/$% &%3%10+/ A*&'(,'./')+5 93/$)*-$ %1%&2 A*&'(,'./')+ $0( 0 4&)>%((')+03 .)&4( )> 30;2%&(7 /$%&% '(

(*>>'.'%+/ 10&'0/')+ '+ /$% :),%( )> )&-0+'='+- 0+, &%-*30/'+- 30;2%&(b0+, '+ /$% %((')+ '+ /$% 4&)1'+.% )> M+/0&')7 P0+0,05 E (*--%(/ /$0/ /$% &%3%10+.% )> )+% ('=0%&%+.% 4)'+/ >&): ;$'.$ :0+2 0+03)-*%( :02 M+/0&') '+ P0+0,0 0( 0 .0(% (/*,27 %0/*&%( 0+, %B'(/ 0:', &%30/'1%32 .):40&0 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '+ /$% R+'/%, L/0/%(7 0+, +)/'+- /$0/ d;$%+ )+%.0+10(%( /$% 10&')*( 0((%((:%+/( )> >)&:03 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ )1%& /$% 40(/ "ND 2%0&( '/ '( &%:0&@0


6/44

N

E((*%( 0 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 0+, /$% 4&)1'(')+ )> 3%-03 (%&1'.%( '+ 0 4&)>'/a,&'1%+:0&@%/ $0( :%0+/ /$0/ :0&@%/ .)3304(% /%/$%&( /$% >*/*&% )> 30; (.$))3( /) %.)+):'.

'+/%&%(/(5 M+% %>>%./7 %1',%+/ '+ &%.%+/ ,%1%3)4:%+/( '+ 30; (.$))3 0..&%,'/0/')+ 0+,30;2%& 3'.%+('+-7 '( /$0/ 30; (.$))3( 0&% %B4%./%, /) 4&),*.% d4&0./'.%a&%0,2e-&0,*0/%(5\ ?$%/$%& /$'( ;'33 3%0, /) &0,'.03 &%>)&: '+ 4&)>%((')+03 +)&:(7 )& 0

40+,%&'+- /) %(/0%((')+03 &%-*30/')+ 0+, 0..%(( /) A*(/'.%7 ;$'.$ :0@%( '/ &): 0 :)1% '+ /$% 0>/%&:0/$ )> /$%

RL P'1'3 ?0& /) :0@% /$% %,*.0/')+ )> 30;2%&( '.e 0+, :)&% &'-)&)*(5 9+, '/

%+,*&%( /) /$'( ,025S

L%% 93>&%, p I%%,7 '#(%)%)* ,-# ./" 0123%& 0#-,"!!%-) -, 4(5 f8%; 6)&@V #$% P0&+%-'% W)*+,0/')+ >)&/$% 9,10+.%:%+/ )> #%0.$'+-7 "kC"g lI%%, I%4)&/nq L%./')+ )> Q%-03 J,*.0/')+ 0+, 9,:'((')+( /) /$%

O0&7 6"7-#. -, ./" '(!8 9-#&" -) 4(5 :&/--3! (); ./" 0#-,"!!%-)< =(##-5%)* ./" >(7 fP$'.0-)V 9:%&'.0+

O0& 9(().'0/')+7 "kkCg7 )+3'+%V

r$//4VHH;;;50:%&'.0+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ %&%+.%

/) ;$0/ 0 2)*+- 30;2%& +%%,( /) 0.*3/2 :%: 0/ 033 b 30;

(.$))3( %B43)'/ /$%'& (/&0/%-'. 3).0/')+ 0( 4&),*.%&( 0+, ,'(/&'

3%-03 0+, ().'03 @+);3%,-%5e


7/44

c

044&)4&'0/% /) .)+(',%& /$% ':43'.0/')+( )> (4%.'>'. .)::'/:%+/( /) ,'1%&('/2 ;'/$'+

/$% .)+/%B/ )> /$%(% 0./)&(5

E 4&).%%,7 /$%+7 ;'/$ /;) .30':( /$0/ 0&% ,%(.&'4/'1%5 #$% >'&(/ .30':7 ,'(.*((%, '+ K0&/(E 0+, EE )> /$'( 0&/'.3%7 '( /$0/ ,'1%&('/2 4&):)/')+ '( 0 *+'1%&(0332 &%.)-+'=%,

+)&:0/'1% -)03 /$0/ $0( 30;2%&( %(4%.'0332 0( ,'&%./%, a

-)1%&+'+- /$'( 0&/'.3% E )*/3'+% /$%40&0:%/%&( >)& 0 4%,0-)-'.03 4&)-&0: )> ,'1%&('/2 '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+5 E &%,%>'+% /$%

k L%% %),#( +)/% "\ 0+, 0..):40+2'+- /%B/5"D L%% %),#( +)/%( "C7 "\ 0+, 0..):40+2'+- /%B/5"" L%% U'.$0%3 M&+(/%'+7 6(&%(3%F(.%-) (); >");"# -, 4(5@"#! %) G).(#%-< H 6"7-#. ,-# ./" 4(5 :-&%".@ -,

I77"# J()(;( f#)&)+/)V QLRP7 94&'3 CD"Dg7 )+3'+%V

r$//4VHH;;;53(*.5)+5.0H:%,'0H.)+104&'3"Di)&+(/%'+54,>t5 L%% 03() ?%+,2 P*@'%& %/ 037 K%$"#!"J%.@

J-1).! L< H :)(7!/-. -, K%$"#!" 4"(;"#!/%7 %) ./" >'H f#)&)+/)V T'1%&('/2 E+(/'/*/%7 #%, I)-%&( L.$))3 )>

U0+0-%:%+/ 0/ I2%&()+ R+'1%&('/27 CD""g7 )+3'+%V r$//4VHH,'1%&(%.'/2/)&)+/)5.0H;4a

.)+/%+/H*43)0,(HP)*+/(I%4)&/Na>*3354,>t5 P*@'%& %/ 03 %B0:'+% &0.'03 &%4&%(%+/0/')+ '+ 4)('/')+( )>

3%0,%&($'4 ;'/$'+ /$% 10&')*( '+(/'/*/')+( )> /$% 3%-03 .)::*+'/2 )> /$% F&%0/%& #)&)+/) &%-')+5 #$%

/&%+,( ',%+/'>'%, '+ /$%'& &%4)&/ 0&% 3'@%32 &%4&%(%+/0/'1% )> :0+2 8)&/$ 9:%&'.0+ .'/'%( ;'/$ (':'30&

,'1%&('/2 40//%&+(5 E+ /$% R+'/%, L/0/%(7 ;$'3% ^D 4%& .%+/ )> /$% -%+%&03 4)4*30/')+ '( ;$'/%7 0 30;2%&( 0&% ;$'/%5 #$% 9:%&'.0+ 3%-03 4&)>%((')+ '( 3%(( &0.'0332 ,'1%&(% /$0+ :)(/ )/$%&

4&)>%((')+(b&0.'03 ,'1%&('/2 '+ /$% 3%-03 4&)>%((')+ $0( 0./*0332 (3);%, .)+(',%&0t l9O97 ="C. :."7!n5"C L%% O&%++0 O0+,$0&7 d93;02( )+ /$% T%>%+.%V #$% U2/$ )> R+'1%&(03'/2 0+, /$% K%&('(/%+.% )>

K&'1'3%-% '+ Q%-03 J,*.0/')+e fCDDCg "cVC Pu?Q Nc"q T'0+0 6)*+%(7 d#%0.$'+- ?$'/%V P)+(/&*./'+-

Q0;2%& E,%+/'/2 '+ P0+0,'0+ Q0; L.$))3(e '+ Iu F'3:)*&7 %,7 M'-- H!%()AN< 6(&%!DB 0#%$%3"*"B (); 0-!.O

!"&-);(#@ ?;1&(.%-) f#)&)+/)V O%/;%%+ /$% Q'+%(7 CD"Cg5


8/44

S

/$%)&%/'.03 0+, +)&:0/'1% *+,%&4'++'+-( )> 0 ,'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-2 ,%(.&')&:4&)1',%( 0 *+'G*% )44)&/*+'/2 /) ':43%:%+/ +)1%37 0+, :)&% '+.3*('1%7 044&)0.$%( /)

3%-03 %,*.0/')+5 M+ /$'(

#$%&% '( ;',% 0-&%%:%+/ /$0/ ,'1%&('/2 '+ 8)&/$ 9:%&'.0+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '( 04&')&'/25"N #$% &%0()+( >)& ;$2 /$% 4&):)/')+ )> ,'1%&('/2 '( ,%('&0%((')+7 '-1&/!.-)"! ,-# J/()*"< ?P1(3%.@B K%$"#!%.@

(); H&&-1).(2%3%.@ fM//0;0V PO97 "kkNg fP$0'&V #$% Z)+ O%&/$0 ?'3()+g7 )+3'+%V

r$//4VHH;;;5. 93>'.%50(4Btq Q0; L).'%/2 )>

L0(@0/.$%;0+7 J-;" -, 0#-,"!!%-)(3 J-);1&. fCD"Cg 0/ "DNq Q0; L).'%/2 )> U0+'/)


9/44

\

4&0./'.% )> 30; '+ /$% 4&)1'+.% M+/0&')7 :0'+/0'+( 0 &'.$ 0&&02 )> 4&)-&0:( 0+,

'+'/'0/'1%( ,%('-+%, /) 4&):)/% d%G*'/2 0+, ,'1%&('/25e #$'( '+.3*,%( ,%('-+0/'+- 0T'(.&':'+0/')+ 0+, Z0&0((:%+/ P)*+(%3q 0 :%:

?):%+ '+ K&'10/% K&0./'.% ;)&@'+- -&)*47 0+, 0 Z*:0+ I'-$/( U)+'/)&'+- F&)*45

#$% 9:%&'.0+ O0& 9(().'0/')+`( I%4)&/7 ="C. :."7!7 (*--%(/( /$0/ 0 (':'30& %:,'1%&('/2 0+, %G*'/2 $0( )..*&&%, 0.&)(( /$% 9:%&'.0+ 3%-03 4&)>%((')+5"^

E+ 0,,'/')+ /) /$% '+(/'/*/')+03 0+, 4&)>%((')+03 &%.)-+'/')+ )> /$% ,'1%&('/2 4&')&'/27

30; >0.*3/'%( $01% 03() +)/%, /$% ,'1%&('/2 -04( '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+7 0+, .3%0& (/%4(

;%&% /0@%+ /) &%,&%(( $'(/)&'.03 %B.3*(')+5"Y 9 (*&1%2 )> (%1%+/%%+ P0+0,'0+ 30;>0.*3/2 ;%

%3%1%+ (.$))3(5"k M> /$% >0.*3/'%( /$0/ ,) +)/ $01% 0+ %B43'.'/ ,'1%&('/2 4)3'.27 /$% -)03(

8*+01*/7 4"*(3 ?./%&! (); 0#(&.%&" J-DD%..""7 )+3'+%V r$//4VHH30;().'%/25+*5.0H3%-03a%/$'.(a0+,a

4&0./'.%a.)::'//%%Ht5"\ QLRP JG*'/2 0+, 9 L/*,%+/ 0+, W0.*3/2 T'1%&('/2 '+ Q0; L.$))3(V M+% T%0+`(

K%&(4%./'1%e fCD""g k\ E);0 Q I%1 "Sc\ f)*/3'+'+- /$% 0&-*:%+/(7 >&): 0 T%0+`( 4%&(4%./'1%7 >)&

':4&)1'+- ,'1%&('/2 )> '3% ;'/$ 0*/$)&n5 W)& ,'&%./

&%>%&%+.%( /) ,'1%&('/27 (%% "Q*Q ROP W0.*3/2 )> Q0;7 ?P1%.@ (. IRJ 4(5 fd#$% W0.*3/2 .%3%*3 .)::*+'/2 /) 0 1' Q0; 0+, .%+/&03 /) /$'( 4)3'.25e 0/ Cgq K$'3'4 O&2,%+7

dT%0+`( ?%3.):%7e I)%$"#!%.@ -, H32"#.( 9(&13.@ -, 4(5 7 )+3'+%V

r$//4VHH30;(.$))35*03 /$)(% -&0+/%, 0..%(( /) 3%-03

%,*.0/')+5egq M(-)),% Z033 Q0; L.$))37 G1# Z-3%!.%& 6"$%"5 0#-&"!!7 )+3'+%V

r$//4VHH;;;5)(-)),%52)&@*5.0H4&)(4%./'1%a(/*,%+/(HA,a4&)-&0:H04432'+-H&%1'%;a4&).%((tf'+.)&4)&0/'+- d)&:0/')+

(%((')+ >)& (/*,%+/( )> .)3)*& 0+, (/*,%+/( >&): :0&-'+03'=%, Q0;7 4(5 H;D%!!%-)!


10/44


11/44

Y

:)+)4)32 )1%& /$% 4&)1'(')+ )> 3%-03 (%&1'.%(7 0+, &%.)-+'=%( /$0/ /$'( 4&'1'3%-%

.):%( ;'/$ .)+.):'/0+/ ,*/'%(5 #$% 4&)>%((')+ .30':( /) $)3, '/( :%:)&.%( /$0/ 0&% %((')+03 3'1%( 0( ;%33 0( /$% 4&)1'(')+ )> 3%-03 (%&1'.%( /) /$% 4*a30; 3%-03 )&,%& /$0/ &%4&%(%+/( /$% ().'%/2 '/ (%&1%(5 W)& :*.$ )>

/$% -%+%&03 4* /$% 3%-03(2(/%:7 '+(/&*:%+/03 '+ /$% 1'+,'.0/')+ )> .'/'=%+(` 3%-03 &'-$/( 0+, %+/'/3%:%+/(5 9(

3%0,%&( '+ '+>3*%+.% '+ 4)3'/'.( 0+, ().'%/25Cc

W'+03327 /$% -&);'+- ':4)&/0+.% )> %/$'.( &%-*30/')+ $0( 3%, /) 3'+@'+- /$% ,'1%&('/2':4%&0/'1% ;'/$ 3%-03 4&)>%((')+03'(: 0+, 0..%(( /) A*(/'.%5 J:%&-'+- (.$)30&($'4 )+

P0+0,'0+ 3%-03 %/$'.( $0( $'-$3'-$/%, /$% ':4)&/0+.% )> ,'1%&('/2 /) /$% 3%-'/':0.2 )>/$% 3%-03 4&)>%((')+ 0+, /$% 0,:'+'(/&0/')+ )> A*(/'.%5CS #$'( 1'%; $)3,( /$0/ 0 3%-03

4&)>%((')+ /$0/ '( +)/ 044&)4&'0/%32 &%4&%(%+/0/'1% )> /$% ().'%/2 '+ ;$'.$ '/ )4%&0/%(

;'33 /$%4*)&:03 4)3'.27 /$%&% '( 3'//3% %30).*((%, )+ /$% 4*%((')+ 0+,7 %((')+ 0+, '/( '+(/'/*/')+( +%%, /)

.)+/'+*% /) 4&):)/% /$% 0,10+.%:%+/ )> 1'(' .)+,*./ /$0/ '+.)&4)&0/%( :)&03 .)+.%4/( )>

A*(/'.% 0+, %G*03'/27 0+, 4&%(*:0 (/0/*/)&2 $*:0+ &'-$/(7 /$% J()(;%() R%33 -,

6%*/.!7 0+,7 '+ "kYC7 /$% '+.)&4)&0/')+ '+/) /$% .)+(/'/*/')+ )> /$% J()(;%() J/(#."# -, 6%*/.! ();

9#"";-D!5 L%% K0&/ E )> /$% J-)!.%.1.%-) H&.B U`aS7


12/44

k

/$% ,'1%&('/2 )> /$% M+/0&') .)::*+'/27 /) 4&)/%./ /$% ,'-+'/2 )> '+,'1',*03(7 0+, /)

&%(4%./ $*:0+ &'-$/( 30;( '+ >)&.% '+ M+/0&')5eCY #$'( '+.3*,%( 0 d(4%.'03 &%(4)+(''.03327

/) $)+)*& /$% )


13/44

"D

.)*+.'3( 0+, '+ /$% 30; )&:03 0+/'a,'(.&':'+0/')+ 30;(5 #$%'&

(*)& &%>)&:5 W)& 0/ 3%0(/ /$% 40(/ /$'&/2 2%0&(7 8)&/$

9:%&'.0+ 30; >0.*3/'%( $01% 0&/'.*30/%, 0 .)::'/:%+/ /) :0@'+- 30; (.$))3( :)&%&%4&%(%+/0/'1% )> /$% ().'%/2 /$%2 (%&1%q '.'/7 0+, (/*,%+/ 0..)*+/( )> 03'%+0/')+ '+ /$% .30((&)): 0+, '+ (/*,%+/

3'>% (*--%(/ /$0/ /$% ;)&@ )> ,'1%&('/2 '( >0& >&): .):43%/%5 9( E $01% (*--%(/%,7 0

('-+'>'.0+/ .)+/&' $0( +)/ '+%,5 9+,7

:)&% ':4)&/0+/327 /$% ':43'.0/')+( )> $); ,'1%&('/2 '( ,%>'+%, $01% +)/ '+,'1',*03( 0+, -&)*4( /$0/ .)+(/'/*/% 0 ().'%/25E/ :02 &%>%& /) 033 ()&/( )> -&)*+,( )> ,'>>%&%+.%7 '+.3*,'+- +)/ )+32 /$% /24%( )>

-&)*+,( 4&)/%./%, ,'>>%&%+.%5 #$%4)/%+/'03 >)& ,%>'+'/')+03 '+,%/%&:'+0.2 $0( 3%, /) ():% .)+.%&+ 0

,'1%&('/2 ,%1)', )> (*

/$% 30; 0+, 30;2%&'+- '+ )&,%& /) 0..%(( /$% >)*+,0/')+( )> %B.3*(')+5 #$'( +)&:0/'1%

/&0+(>)&:0/')+7 '> *+,%&/0@%+ '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+7 ;)*3, $01% +%.%((0&2 ':43'.0/')+(5E/ ,%:0+,( 0 .&'/'.03 0((%((:%+/ )> ;$0/ '/ :%0+( /) d/$'+@ 3'@% 0 30;2%&e 0.*3/2 .):4)('/')+g5Nc L$%'30 W)(/%&7 dT'>>%&%+.% 0+, JG*03'/2V 9 P&'/'.03 9((%((:%+/ )> /$% P)+.%4/ )> T'1%&('/2e f"kkNg ?'(

Q I%1 "DS 0/ "NNNS [2%; 0/ "C\5N\ L%% #0+)1'.$7 dQ0;`( 9:


14/44


15/44

"C

'+/%&+037 >03(% +%*/&037 4%&(4%./'1%5 I0/$%&7 3%-03 %,*.0/)&( 0&% '+.&%0('+-32 &%03'='+-

/$0/ %>>%./'1% 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ :*(/ a&%1%03'+- 0)&

*+,%&(/0+,'+- )1%&3044'+- 0+, ():%/':%( .)+>3'./'+- +)&:0/'1% (2(/%:( $%34(.)+>&)+/ /$% 4&%((*&%( )> ,'1%&('/25 K3*&03'(/ *+,%&(/0+,'+- )> 30; (%%@( /) 0.$'%1%

,%/0.$:%+/ >&): 3%-03 .%+/&03'(: &%1)31'+- 0&)*+, (/0/% 30;7.&'/'.'(: )> /$% %B.3*('1%+%(( )> (/0/% 30;7 ,%.%+/&03'=0/')+ )> .)*&/a

.%+/%&%, A*,'.'03 (/*,'%(7 %B43)&0/')+ )> +)+(/0/% 3%-03 )&,%&(7

*+1%'3'+- )> '+>)&:03 ().')a3%-03 4&0./'.%(7 0+, 0+ *+,%&(/0+,'+- )>30; 0( 0 :*3/'a.%+/%&%, >'%3, /$0/ ,%03( ;'/$ /$% .)+1%&-%+.% )>

+)&:(7 3).03'/'%(7 (/0/%(7 -3)


16/44


17/44


18/44

"S

/) %G*03'/27 40'&%, ;'/$ 0 ($'%3, >)& -)1%&+:%+/a'+'/'0/%, 0>>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ >)&

,'(0,10+/0-%, -&)*4(5Sk

#$% L*4&%:% P)*&/ )> P0+0,0`( >'&(/ A*,-:%+/ '+/%&4&%/'+- (%./')+ "S %G*03'/2'+1)31%, 0 .30': %G*03'/2 ;)*3, -)1%&+ /$%3%-03 4&)>%((')+5 T%(.&'*33 >)&.% 0+, 0*/$)&'/2 )> /$% L/0/% '+ 4&).*&'+- 0+, %+>)&.'+-

A*,-:%+/( )& )/$%& &%:%,'03 :%0(*&%( ;$'.$ :02 &): /$% ':4)('/')+ )> (*.$ (/0/% 0*/$)&'/2 0+, 4);%&5 O2 0+2

(/0+,0&,7 /$%(% 4);%&( 0+, ,*/'%( 0&% 1'/03 /) /$% :0'+/%+0+.% )> )&,%& '+)*& ().'%/2 0+, /$% ,*% 0,:'+'(/&0/')+ )> /$% 30; '+ /$% '+/%&%(/ )> /$%;$)3% .)::*+'/25\"

R+,%&(/0+,'+- /$% &)3% )> /$% 30;2%& 0( %((%+/'03 /) /$% 0,:'+'(/&0/')+ )> A*(/'.% '+ /$%

4*%((')+03 .):4%/%+.%5 E/ '( +); 0 >*+./')+ )>.)+(/'/*/')+03 .)::'/:%+/( /) %G*03'/25

8< .KN7O65MK

P3)('+- /$% &%4&%(%+/0/')+ -04 '( A*(/ )+% .):4)+%+/ )> 4&):)/'+- 0 .)+.%4/')+ )>,'1%&('/2 /$0/ '( -&)*+,%, '+ %G*03'/25 #$'( '( %B.3*(')+5 E+ P0+0,07 >)& %B0:43%7 /$% $'(/)&2 )>

%B.3*(')+ $0( 3%-03 4&)>%((')+03'(:7 :),%33%, )+ /$% J+-3'($ d-%+/3%:0+7e;0( /$% (/0+,0&, *(%, /) ,%>'+% /$% 0 -)), 30;2%&5 E+ '/(

%>>%./7 /$'( (/0+,0&, )4%&0/%, /) %B.3*,% +)+aJ+-3'($7 +)+a%3'/%(7 0+, ;):%+ >&): /$%

3%-03 4&)>%((')+5

Sk J/(#."# 7 !17#( +)/% CC7 (( "Sf"g 0+, fCg5\D H);#"5! $ 4(5 :-&%".@ -, R#%.%!/ J-31D2%(7 l"kYkn " LPI "cN5\" [2%; 0/ "YY5\C 9++'% I).$%//% o ?%(3%2 K*%7 dO0.@ /) O0('.(V R+'1%&('/2 Q%-03 J,*.0/')+ 0+, C"(/ P%+/*&2

K&)>%((')+03'(:e fCDD"g CD ?'+,()& 6O 9..%(( u*(/ "\^5 L%% 03() O0.@$)*(%7 !17#( +)/% c"5\N [2%; 5


19/44

"\

?'/$ /':%7 /$% 4&)>%((')+ %1)31%,7 >%./ )+ /$% &%4&%(%+/0/')+ -047 0( :)&% ;):%+ 0+, :'+)&'/'%( -0'+%,0..%(( /) /$% 4&)>%((')+5\S Z);%1%&7 &04',32 .$0+-'+- ,%:)-&04$'.( ;)*3, $01% 0+

%1%+ (/&)+-%& ;',%+'+- %>>%./ )+ /$% &%4&%(%+/0/')+ -045 E+ )/$%& ;)&,(7 0( %3'/'(/7&0.'(/ 0+, (%B'(/ ',%0( /$0/ $0, 4%&4%/*0/%, %B.3*(')+ &%.%,%,7 /$%&%%((')+7 /$%

,%:)-&04$'. ,'1%&('>'.0/')+ )> /$% -%+%&03 4)4*30/')+ >0& )*/40.%, /$% %+/&2 )>

:'+)&'/'%( '+/) 30; (.$))3 0+, /$% 4&)>%((')+5\\ #$% 4&) %B.3*(')+7 /$%+b$'(/)&'.0332 3'+@%, /) (2(/%:'. 0+, '+(/'/*/')+03 >'.'%+/ /) @%%4 *4 ;'/$ /$% 40.% )> ().'03

,'1%&('>'.0/')+5\^

9 >3*&&2 )> .&'/'.03 &0.% 0+, >%:'+'(/ (.$)30&($'4 ;):%+ 0+,4%)43% )> .)3)*& '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+5\k 9..)&,'+- /) /$%(% .&'/'.(7 %B.3*(')+0&2 $'(/)&'.03>)&.%( ,', +)/ %104)&0/%7 +)/;'/$(/0+,'+- /$% +0&&);'+- &%4&%(%+/0/')+ -04 0.*3/2 .):4)('/')+ $01%

\c P):40&%, /) )/$%& 4&)>%((')+(7 /$% 3%-03 4&)>%((')+ $0( '.0+/32 )*/40.%, M+/0&') 30;2%&( ;%&% :%: 0 1'(' /$% M+/0&') 4)4*30/')+dg5\^ L%% %2%; 5 L):% )> /$% 40//%&+( )> *+%G*03 0..%(( /) 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 0+, /$% 3%-03 4&)>%((')+ 0&%

%1',%+/ '+ M&+(/%'+`( >'+,'+-(5 L):% :'+)&'/2 .)::*+'/'%( 0&% .):40&0/'1%32 ;%33 &%4&%(%+/%, ;$'3%

)/$%&( 0&% ;)%>*332 *+,%&a&%4&%(%+/%,5 W)& %B0:43%7 $% >)*+, /$0/ 30;2%&a.)::*+'/2 :%: /$% 30; 0+, ().'%/2 :)1%:%+/ )> /$% 30/% "k\D(5 P&'/'.03 &0.% 0+,

>%:'+'(/ (.$)30&($'4 )& /$% Q0(/ L/0-%( )> /$% L).'03 9./'1'(/ L/0/%e f"kkYg NCfCg Q o L). I%1 cDk5\k [':


20/44

"^

%1)31%,7 30; (.$))3( .)+/'+*% /) /%0.$ 0..)&,'+- /) 0 (/0+,0&, )> d;$'/%+%((e ;$'.$7

>)& :0+27 4%&4%/*0/%( 0 -%+%&03'=%, %B4%&'%+.% )> 03'%+0/')+ >&): 30;5^"

93/$)*-$ 3%-03 %,*.0/)&( :02 +)/ +%.%((0&'32 '+/%+, /) 4%&4%/*0/% %B.3*(')+7^C 0+,)>/%+ 0(4'&% /) 30*,0 3%-03 &%0()+'+-7 0+, (/0+,0&,( >)& %103*0/'+- d:%&'/e^c

$01%/$% %>>%./ )> 4%&4%/*0/'+- 0 /&0,'/')+ 0+, 4&0./'.% )> &0.'03 %B.3*(')+5^S P&'/'.( (*--%(//$0/ /&0,'/')+03 30; (.$))3 %103*0/')+ '( $0&,32 :%&'/a)&: +%%,%, /) :0@%/$% >)&: 0+, .)+/%+/ )> 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 0 :)&% '+.3*('1% %B4%&'%+.%7 )+% /$0/ '( :)&%

,'&%./32 &%3%10+/ /) /$% %B4%&'%+.%( )> /$% ,'1%&(% ().'%/2 /$0/ 30; (.$))3( 0&% +);%B4%./%,7 0+, .30':7 /) &%4&%(%+/5

...< !=* -.%'! #$/* "- &./*%'.!, .0 1*+$1 *&23$!."0

^" U0&-032++% u)0+ 9&:(/&)+- o L/%4$0+'% ?'3,:0+7 d#%0.$'+- I0.%H#%0.$'+- ?$'/%+%((V

#&0+(>)&:'+- P)3)& >)&:03 &0.% +%*/&03'/2 0( d0 .30((&)): %+1'&)+:%+/

/$0/ 0./'1%32 %+.)*&0-%( /$% ('3%+.'+- )> :'+)&'/2 (/*,%+/(5 W)&.%, /) (/0+, 040&/ >&): /$%'& );+ (%3>7

:'+)&'/'%( 0&% -%+%&0332 :)&% &%3*./0+/ /$0+ /$%'& ;$'/% .)*+/%&40&/( /) (4%0@ '+ /$% .30((&)):eg5


21/44

"Y

#$% >'&(/ ;01% )> ,'1%&('/2 4&):)/')+ '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ ;0( .$0&0./%&'=%, 0,:'+'(/&0/'1% 0./')+V 0,:'((')+( 0+, .*&&'.*30& )>>%&'+-(5 9>/%&

(*&1%2'+- %0.$ )> /$%(% ('/%(7 E ;'33 4)('/ /$0/ /$%(% :%0(*&%( $01% (%&1%, 0+':4)&/0+/ 4*&4)(% >%& )+32 40&/'03 &%:%,27 4&)1','+- '+.):43%/% :'/'-0/')+ )>

/$% $'(/)&2 )> %B.3*(')+ '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+5

$< !4JPHLHQ $QR5665MK6S $TT5JR4L5UH $NL5MK 5K $NL5MK

9>>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ ;0( ,%('-+%, /) 0,:'/ :%: ',%+/'>'0 '+.&%0('+- /$% &0+@( )> :'+)&'/2

30;2%&( '+ /$% 4&)>%((')+5^Y 9..%(( /) 0+ 0>>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ 4&)-&0: ;0( .)+,'/')+%,)+ :%: 03/%&'+- /$% d))& 30; (.$))3 0,:'((')+7 0+2 *+%0&+%,0,10+/0-% .)+>%&&%, >'&:0/'1% 0./')+ /) /$% '+,'1',*03 %./( 0&% (2(/%:'. 0+, )+-)'+-g /$0/ 0>>%./ '+,'1',*03( >)&:03 0+, '+>)&:03 %B.3*(')+5 Q0;

(.$))3( '/ )&

:)&% &04', (2(/%:'. .$0+-% /$0+ ;)*3, )/$%&;'(% )..*& '+ 0 :)&% d+%*/&03e

0&&0+-%:%+/ )1%& /':%7 0+, /$'( (/&0/%-2 '( :)&% :0+0-%0'.'/7 ;$'.$7

0/ /$% $%'-$/ )> /$% "k\D( 9:%&'.0+ .'1'3 &'-$/( :)1%:%+/7 .)*3, +) 3)+-%& )& )+32 0'&(/a2%0& 30; (/*,%+/( 0/ 9O9a0..&%,'/%, (.$))3(5^k #$)*-$ +)/ /$% )+32>0./)&7 /0&-%/%, 0,:'((')+( ;%&% @%2 /) '+.&%0('+- Q0; L.$))3 9,:'((')+ P&'/%&'0V J103*0/'+- /$% O&)0,aO0(%,

9,:'((')+ K)3'.2 0/ /$% R+'1%&('/2 )> ?'+,()& W0.*3/2 )> Q0;e f"kkYg \" L0(@ Q I%1 SND 0/ SNN5^k I'.$0&, L0+,%&7 d9 L2(/%:0/'. 9+032('( )> 9>>'&:0/'1% 9./')+ '+ 9:%&'.0+ Q0; L.$))3(e fCDDcg S^

L/0+ Q I%1 N\^ 0/ N^c5


22/44


23/44

CD

8)/;'/$(/0+,'+- /$% *&-%+.2 )> /$% &'-$/( &%1)3*/')+ 0+, 0 4);%&>*3 .)+(%G*%+/'03'(/

A*(/'>'.0/')+ /) &%1%&(% ,%.0,%( )> ,'(.&':'+0/')+7 0>>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ $0( 03;02( )& :%0+'+->*3

,'1%&('/2 4&):)/')+5YY

O%.0*(% 0>>'&:0/'1% 0,:'((')+( 4)3'.'%( ,) +)/ ,'&%./32 0,,&%((/$% *+,%&32'+- ().'03 >)&.%( /$0/ .&%0/% %B.3*(')+ '+ /$% >'&(/ 430.%7 ,'1%&('/2 >0./)&( '+30; (.$))3 0,:'((')+( $01% )*+, /) )>>%& )+32 30; (.$))3 /*'/')+7 /$% .)+/'+*%, *(% )> /$% QL9#7kD 30; (.$))3 0((%((:%+/

:%/$),( f+0:%327 -&0,'+- 0+, &0+@'+-g7k" 0+, /':', ':43%:%+/0/')+ )> 0>>'&:0/'1%0./')+ 0/ ():% 9:%&'.0+ (.$))3( $01% d.):)& /$% Q0;

0,:'((')+(7 .)+,*./%, '+ /$% 30/% "kkD(7 >)*+, /$0/ /$% (.$))3`( 0..%(( 4)3'.2

.)+(/'/*/%, d)+% /))3 >)& '+.&%0(%, &0.'03 ,'1%&('/2e *&/$%& &0.'03 ,'1%&('/2

0:)+- :%: /$% 3%-03 4&)>%((')+7 '+.3*,'+- .$0+-%( ,*&'+- 30; (.$))3 0+,>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ 0,:'((')+( 4&)-&0:( .0+ &): +);7 /$% *(% )>

&0.'03 4&%>%&%+.%( ;'33 +) 3)+-%& *&/$%& /$% l,'1%&('/2n '+/%&%(/ 044&)1%, /),02eg5YY u)$0++0 [K T%++'(7 dJ+(*&'+- 0 U*3/'.*3/*&03 J,*.0/')+03 JB4%&'%+.% '+ Q%-03 J,*.0/')+V L/0&/ ;'/$

#$% Q%-03 ?&'/'+- P30((&)):e fCD"Dg "\ #%B ?%(3%20+ Q I%1 \"N 0/ \N"aNC fd9,:'//'+- :)&% (/*,%+/(

)> .)3)& ,)%( +)/ +%.%((0&'32 .)&&%30/% '+/) :)&% .):4%/%+/ 0//)&+%2( )> .)3)& >)&/( 0+, 0 I%,%>'+'/')+ )> U%&'/e fCDD\g YD L/ u)$+x( Q I%1 c"5k" I'.$0&, T%3-0,)7 dI),&'-)x( #%+/$ P$&)+'.3%(V U%&'/ 0+, 9>>'&:0/'1% 9./')+e f"kkSg YN F%) Qu "^""

f0&-*'+- /$0/ (/*,%+/( 0,:'//%, *+,%& 0>>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ 0&% %103*0/%, #1.."# 7 !17#( +)/% ^c7

/$% P)*&/ $%3, /$0/ *('+- &0.% 0( )+% 0:)+- :0+2 >0./)&( '+ *+'1%&('/2 0,:'((')+ ,%.'(')+a:0@'+- ;0(

+)/ *+.)+(/'/*/')+035 L%% SNk RL ND\ fCDDNg5 E+ P0+0,07 ( "SfCg )> /$% J/(#."# 4&)1',%( /$0/ /$%

%G*03'/2 -*0&0+/%% d,)%( +)/ 4&%.3*,% 0+2 30;7 4&)-&0: )& 0./'1'/2 /$0/ $0( 0( '/( ) .)+,'/')+( )> ,'(0,10+/0-%, '+,'1',*03( )& -&)*4( '+.3*,'+- /$)(% /$0/ 0&%

,'(0,10+/0-%, &0.%7 +0/')+03 )& %/$+'. )&'-'+7 .)3)*&7 &%3'-')+7 (%B7 0-% )& :%+/03 )& 4$2('.03

,'(0


24/44


25/44

CC

:'+)&'/2 (/*,%+/( ,) +)/ ,'(044%0& (':432 0.% '+ 0 (/&*./*&0332 0,1%&(% %+1'&)+:%+/5

E/ ,)%( +)/7 $);%1%&7 )+ '/( );+7 &%:%,2 /$% *+,%&32'+- .0*(%( )> %B.3*(')+5

8) ,)*>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ $0( &%:)1%, ():% *3 /) &%:%:>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ $0(

03;02( *3

,'1%&('/2 '+ /$% 30; (.$))3 '+.)&4)&0/'+- ,'1%&('/2 '+/)/$% ;02 ;% *+,%&(/0+, 3%-03 @+);3%,-%7 (@'33(7 &%0()+'+-7 &*3%(7 0+, 0*/$)&'/27 0( ;%33

0( $); /$%(% /$'+-( 0&% .)+1%2%, 4%,0-)-'.03325

8< 3OJJ5NO7OR 4KQ !H4N95KP %HTMJRS V4W5KP "OL65QHJ6 .K65QHJ6

#$% (%.)+, 0&%0 )> >'&(/a;01% ,'1%&('/2 4&):)/')+ '+ /$% 30; (.$))3 .0:% '+ :),%(/

.*&&'.*3*: &%>)&: /$0/ 3%, /) /$% ,'1%&('>'.0/')+ )> .)*&(% )>>%&'+-(5 #$'( 0&%0 $0(

%& /) (%:'+0&( /$0/ >).*( )+ %B4%&'%+/'03 0+,/$%)&%/'.03 4%&(4%./'1%( )> :%: :0&-'+03'=%, .)::*+'/'%( 0( d)*/(',%&e

.)*&(%(5"Dc Q'@% 0>>'&:0/'1% 0./')+ '+ 0,:'((')+(7 &%>)&: /$0/ '+.)&4)&0/%( )*/(',%&

.)*&(%( '+/) /$% .*&&'.*3*: '( A*(/'>'%, )+ %G*'/0)& 4&)1','+- 0 (40.% /)

402 (4%.'03 0//%+/')+ /) /$% &%30/')+($'4 )& Z'&'+- 0+, I%/0'+'+- 0 T'1%&(% Q0; W0.*3/2e fCD""g k\ E);0 Q I%1 "^D^5"Dc 80/0($0 O0@$/ %/ 037 dP)+/'+*'+- M*/(',%&(V 9 P&'/'.03 JB43)&0/')+ )> M*/(',%& P)*&(% J+&)33:%+/ '+

P0+0,'0+ Q%-03 J,*.0/')+e fCDD^g cS M(-)),% Z033 Qu \^"5"DS [2%; 0/ \^c5"D\ [2%; 0/ \kc5


26/44

CN

2%0& (/*,%+/ 4)4*30/')+ )> S"Y '+.3*,%, \k ;):%+5"D^ ?'/$ /':%7 /$% &%30/'1%

%+&)3:%+/ '+ >%:'+'(/ .)*&(%( ,%.3'+%, 0( /$% 10&'%/2 0+, 1)3*:% )> )*/(',%& )>>%&'+-(:*3/'43'%,7 %(4%.'0332 3%-03 %,*.0/')+5 U)(/8)&/$ 9:%&'.0+ 30; (.$))3( 4%&('(/%, '+ 0 >0'3*&% /) 0,%G*0/%32 '+/%-&0/% .&'/'.037

.)*+/%&a,):'+0+/ ,'(.)*&(%( 0+, ().'03 .)::%+/0&2 0%:'+'(/ (.$)30&( /$% 3%-03 &%03'(/( 0+, /$% .&'/'.03 3%-03 (/*,'%( :)1%:%+/ ;'/$

0 &0.%a 0+, -%+,%&a.)+(.')*( %B4)('/')+ )> 30; '+ 033 '/( :0+'>%(/0/')+(V ,)./&'+%7 3%-03

"D^ M(-)),% Z033 Q0; L.$))3 $'(/)&'.03 .30(( &%.)&,( 0..%((%, '3% ;'/$7 /$% 0*/$)&5 #$%(%

>'-*&%( 0&% ,%&'1%, >&): /$% -&0,*0/'+- .30(( 3'(/( )> "k^N 0+, "k^c7 /$% :%: ;$'.$ ;)*3, $01%

.):4&'(%, /$% CQ 0+, NQ .30((%( '+ /$% "k^Ca"k^N 0.0,%:'. 2%0&5"DY [2%; 0/ \k\akY5"Dk L%% I'.$0&, T%3-0,)7 d#$% E:4%&'03 L.$)30&V I%>3%./')+( )+ 0 I%1'%; )> P'1'3 I'-$/( Q'/%&0/*&%e

f"kYcg "NC R K0 Q I%1 S\" f.&'/'G*'+- /$% d.3)(%, .3* 0.0,%:'. 3%-03 .)::%+/0&27 40&/'.*30&32 '+

4&%(/'-')*( 4*>'&:0/'1% 9./')+ 0+, Q%-03 [+);3%,-%e !17#( +)/% C\ 0/

CaS f,%(.&')& P0+0,0`( Q%-039.0,%:2e fCD"Ng ^\ L0(@ Q I%1 ^N 0/ YN f&%>%&&'+- /) /$% P0+0,'0+ 0.0,%:2g5 W)& /$% 9:%&'.0+

%B4%&'%+.%7 (%% L4%+.%&7 !17#( +)/% N f/&0.'+- "ND 2%0&( )> 9:%&'.0+ .&'/'G*% )> ,)./&'+03 3%-03

%,*.0/')+g5""" L%% O&'0+ Q%'/%&7 d9:%&'.0+ Q%-03 I%03'(:e fR+'15 #%B5 K*


27/44

Cc

&%0()+'+-7 '+(/'/*/')+(7 4&)>%((')+03 &%(4)+('&): /$% "kkD()+;0&,(7 0.*3/2 :%:&): (/*,%+/( >)& &0'('+- &0.'03 A*(/'.% '((*%( '+ ,)./&'+03 )&d.)&%e .)*&(%(5""N

#$% .&'/'G*% )> 30; 0( .):43'.'/ '+ $'(/)&'.03 0+, )+-)'+- (2(/%:'. &0.'03 )44&%((')+7;$'.$ ;0( 0 .)&% .30': )> /$% .&'/'.03 &0.% (.$))37 '( 3'+@%, /) /$% 4&0./'.%( 0+,

0((*:4/')+( )> 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 0( ;%335 P*&&'.*30 /'%, /) 044%330/% ,)./&'+% &0/$%& /$0+.)+/%B/*03 *+,%&(/0+,'+-( )> 30;a'+a0./')+ ,':'+'($ /$% &%03'/'%( )> :'+)&'/'%(` 3'1%(

*+,%& /$% 30;5 R+%+-0-%, 0+, )*/:),%, :%/$),( )> '+(/&*./')+7 (*.$ 0( /$% .0(%

:%/$), 0+, L).&0/'. ,'03%./'.7 $%'-$/%+ %B'(/'+- 4);%& ': :'+)&'/2 (/*,%+/(5 9+, 0 >0.*3/2 .):4)('/')+ /$0/ &%:0'+((/0&/3'+-32 %/$+'.0332 $):)-%+%)*( .0*(%( :'+)&'/2 (/*,%+/( /) ,)* .)3)*& *+'G*%32 0 ().'%/25 #$'( $0( 3%, ():% /) .033

>)& 0 4&)-&0: )> :*3/'.*3/*&03 d$24%&%,*.0/')+7e""\ ;$%&% %: /$% .*&&'.*3*:5 #$% A*(/'>'.0/')+ >)& (*.$ 0 4&)0./'1%044&)0.$ /) ,'1%&('/2 .0+ 3*%+.% /$0/ 0//0.$ /) 3%-03 4&)>%((')+03'(:5 #$% -)03 )> 0+%B43'.'/ .)::'/:%+/ /) :*3/'.*3/*&03 %,*.0/')+ '( /) 4&),*.% /$% d9//'.*( W'+.$%( )>

""N I))*+, /$0/ dL/*,%+/( )>

P)3)& %B4%&'%+.%, >0& -&%0/%& 3%1%3( )> (/'-:0 .)+(.')*(+%(( /$0+ /$%'& ?$'/% .)33%0-*%(5e U%0+;$'3%7

d?$'/% RPQ9 Q0; (/*,%+/( )1%&;$%3:'+-32 4&).%%, /$&)*-$ 30; (.$))3 ;'/$)*/ %1%& .)+(.')*(32

/$'+@'+- 0


28/44

CS

/):)&&); /),025e""^ O)/$ ;$'/% 0+, +)+a;$'/% (/*,%+/( (/0+, /) '/ 0+, 3%0&+

>&): 0 ,'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-2 /$0/ '( &))/%, '+ 0 .)::'/:%+/ /) (*&):

%:40/$'='+- ;'/$ /$% .)+,'/')+ )> 0 &0.'03 :'+)&'/25 E+ 0 d:*3/'.*3/*&03$24%&%,*.0/')+e .*&&'.*3*:7 '+(/&*./)&( 0./'1%32 (* /$% -)03 '( /) ,&0; 0//%+/')+ /) 4%&(4%./'1%( )+ 30;/$0/ 0&% 0+032/'.0332 ':4)&/0+/7 /$%+ /$% G*%(/')+ '( ;$%/$%& ,)'+- ()

)4/')+037 (4%.'03'=%,7 (%-&%-0/%, .)*&(%( ;'33 -%+%&0/% /$% @'+, )> .$0+-% +%%,%, /):0@% :0&-'+03 1)'.%( :)&% &%3%10+/ /) :0'+(/&%0: 3%-03 0+032('(5 #) /$% %B/%+/ /$0/.033( >)& 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ &%>)&: '+.3*,% :)&% >).*( )+ 4&0./'.03 @+);3%,-% 0+,

0443'%, (@'33(7 /$% &%3%10+.% )> )*/(',%& .)*&(% :0/%&'03 ;'33 '.0+/5 8)(%&')*( .)+.%4/')+ )> d4&0./'.% &%0,'+%((e .0+ +%-3%./ /$% ':4)&/0+.% )> .*3/*&03

.):4%/%+.'%( 0+, 0+ 044&%.'0/')+ >)& /$% '+/%&4302 )> 30;7 4);%& 0+, 4&'1'3%-%5 L$'>/(

'+ 0..&%,'/0/')+ 0+, (/0+,0&,a(%//'+- )>>%& 0+ )44)&/*+'/2 /) &%)&'%+/ 3%-03 4%,0-)-2/);0&,( '+/%-&0/'+- /$% *+,%&(/0+,'+- )> (*)&:7 >'&(/a;01%

%>>)&/( )1%&a4&):'(% ;'/$ &%(4%./ /) ,'1%&('/25 #$)*-$ +)/ *+'1%&(0332 /&*%7 0 (%-:%+/)> /$% :'+)&'/2 (/*,%+/ .)::*+'/2 ;$) /%+, /) (/&)+-32 ',%+/'>2 0( &0.'03'=%, 0+,

;$) 4%&10('1%32 :0+'>%(/ /$0/ ',%+/'/2 .0+ %B4%./ /) %B4%&'%+.% 30; (.$))3 0(

03'%+0/')+ '+ :0+27 '> +)/ :)(/7 &%(4%./(5 #0&-%/%, 0,:'((')+ .0+ .):% 0/ $'-$4%&()+03 .)(/ >)& :'+)&'/2 (/*,%+/(7 >)&.%, /) .0&&2 '+,'+- &%>*-% '+ )*/(',%&.)*&(%(7 (/*,%+/( &'(@ 4%&:0+%+/32 30 /$'( .0+

$01% /$% %>>%./ +)/ )+32 )> 4%&4%/*0/'+- $'(/)&'.03 40//%&+( )> &0.'03 ,'(0,10+/0-%7 .&%0/'+- +%; 40//%&+( )> '+(',%&a)*/(',%& %B.3*(')+5"CD #$'( .)+/&'&): %+1'&)+:%+/03 >0./)&( 0+, '+(/'/*/')+03

.*3/*&% '+,%4%+,%+/ >&): 0+2 ',%+/'>'0>%./e .0*(%,


29/44

C\

4&)>%((')+7 %1%+ 0( ():% :%: $'(/)&'.0332 %B.3*,%, -&)*4( %B.%3 0+, (*..%%,

'+ .)+1%+/')+03 .0&%%& 40/$( /$0/ :02 4&%1')*(32 +)/ $01% 4%&(4%./'1% .)*&(%( ;'/$ 0//&0./'1% /'/3%(7 0+, 0 (2(/%: )> 4&)>%((')+03.)*+(%33'+- 0+, (*44)&/%, 0..%(( /) /$% .):4%/'/'1% A)< :0&@%/5 Z);%1%&7 ;$'3% /$%

30; (.$))3 '( /$% >)&*: '+ ;$'.$ (/*,%+/( 0&% /24'.0332 >'&(/ '+/&),*.%, /) 30; >'&:(7 '/'( /$% >'&:( 0+, :%: /$% 4&)>%((')+7 +)/ /$% (.$))37 /$0/ ,%/%&:'+% /$%

(/*,%+/(` 0..%(( /) 4&)>%((')+03 /&0'+'+-7 %+/&2 /) 4&)>%((')+03 .*3/*&%7 0+,

)44)&/*+'/'%( >)& %:43)2:%+/5 #$% (.$))3( ,%3'1%& -&0,*0/%( /) /$% 4&)>%((')+ %((')+03 0..%(( >)&:0+2 (/*,%+/(5 E+ M+/0&')7 0( '+ 033 P0+0,'0+ 4&)1'+.%(7 %1%&2 30; -&0,*0/% :*(/

(%.*&% 0 /&0'+'+- 4)('/')+ *+,%& /$% (/%;0&,($'4 )> 0 (%+')& :%: /$%4&)>%((')+5"C" #$'( :0@%( d(/*,%+/(a0/a30;e"CC 3'/%&0332 %((')+b0+,7 '+.&%0('+-327 /) /$% 30; >'&:(b/) 0,:'/ /$%: /) 4&)>%((')+03

:%:)&:03 30; -&0,*0/%/&0'+'+- /$&)*-$ 0&/'.3'+- 4&)-&0:(7 30; >'&:( >033 )*/(',% /$% &%-*30/)&2 4*&1'%; )>

30; ().'%/'%( 0+, /$% QLRP 9&/'.3'+- #0(@ W)&.%7 CS M./))33);'+- ;%


30/44

C^

#$*(7 '> (/*,%+/( %B4%&'%+.% %B.3*(')+ 0+, *+,%&4%&>)&:0+.% '+ 30; (.$))37 /$%2 0&%

:)&% 3'@%32 /) %+.)*+/%& (2(/%:'. )'+>3*%+.% 0+, 0*/$)&'/25 ?$%/$%& '+ /$% 30; >'&:(7 /$% 30; (.$))3(7 )& /$% A*,'.'0&27

&0.'03 0+, %/$+'. :'+)&'/'%( 0&% +)/ )+32 *+,%&&%4&%(%+/%,7 /$%2 0&% 1'&/*0332 0>%& /$%4&):'(% )> 0 (%3>a>*3>'33'+- .0&%%& '+ /$% 30;7 '+ 0 3%-03 .*3/*&% ;$'.$ .%3% 4%&(4%./'1%(5 Z);%1%&7 ;$%+ (/*,%+/(%+/%& /$% 4&)>%((')+7 /$%2 %+.)*+/%& 0 ;)&3, /$0/ '( (3); /) .$0+-% 0+, &))/%, '+ 0

.*3/*&% /$0/ ;'33 044%0& >)&%'-+ 0+, '+$)(4'/0)33);'+- /$% &04', %+/&2 )> ;):%+ '+/) /$% 4&)>%((')+7 "CY &0.'03 ,'1%&('/2 (/0/'(/'.( (*--%(/ /$0/ 0 (':'30& 40//%&+ :'-$/ 03&%0,2 4&),*./')+ +)/ )+32 )> 30;2%&(7 30; '/(%3>5#$&)*-$ ,%.'(')+( 00.*3/2 .):4)('/')+7 (/*,%+/ 0,:'((')+(7 &%(%0&.$ 0+,

"CS :17#( +)/% Y 0/ 'a''7 S7 ^7 k7 "Y5"C\ W)& %B0:43%7 /$% ,0/0 '33*(/&0/% >)& /$% >'&(/ /':% .3%0& %1',%+.% )> :0(('1% ,'(40&'/'%( '3%, ;'/$

/$% Z*:0+ I'-$/( #&' M+/0&') fZI#Mg 033%-'+- (2(/%:'. &0.'03 ,'(.&':'+0/')+ '+ 0 30; (.$))3

,%.0+03 044)'+/:%+/ 4&).%(( 0+, $'-$3'-$/'+- 0 $'(/)&2 )> ;$'/% 4&'1'3%-% '+ 30; (.$))3 -)1%&+0+.%g5"CY L%% "Q*Q #$% Q0; L).'%/2 )> R44%& P0+0,07 J-)!13.(.%-) 6"7-#.< 6".").%-) -, c-D") %) 0#%$(."

0#(&.%&" c-#8%)* >#-17 fQLRP7 CDDYg7 )+3'+%V r$//4VHH;;;53(*.5)+5.0H:%,'0H&%/%+/')+)>;):%+54,>tq

J/()*" -, :.(.1! 6"!"(#&/B STUTOSTUS< 6"7-#. -, ./" b"@ 9%);%)*! :12D%.."; .- ./" 4(5 :-&%".@ -, I77"#

J()(;( fQLRP7 U02 CD"Ng 0/ Nk7 )+3'+%V

r$//4VHH;;;53(*.5)+5.0H?)&@9&%0HT);+3)0,9((%/50(4Bh',jC"c^ckS"^^t5


31/44

CY

.*&&'.*3*:7 30; >0.*3/'%( ,%/%&:'+% /$% @+);3%,-%7 (@'33(7 0+, 4&')&'/'%( /$0/ ,%>'+%

0+, .)+(/'/*/% /$% 30; /) 0 -&%0/%& %B/%+/ /$0+ /$%2 $01% /%+,%, /) 0.@+);3%,-%5"Ck #$% 30; (.$))3 03() /&0+(:'/( 0+, 0((':'30/%( /$% +)&:(7 %((')+03 ',%+/'/25 #$%&% 0&% ':43'.0/')+( /) /$% .30': /$0/ /$% 30; (.$))3%(/0 30;5 #) 0.$'%1% /$'(7 ,'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-2 (%%@( /) :)1% '+'/')+(

0+, >*+./')+( )> 30;2%&'+-5 #$'( '+1)31%( 0 4%,0-)-'.03 0+, 0,:'+'(/&0/'1%&%)&'%+/0/')+ /) 4&),*.'+- 0+ '+(/'/*/')+03 0+, 4&)>%((')+03 .*3/*&%7 &%>3%./%, '+

.*&&'.*3*:7 /$0/ '( %B4&%((32 0+, .):4&%$%+('1%32 9O9a0..&%,'/%, '+(/'/*/')+( /)


32/44

Ck

0( 044)'+/'+- :'+)&'/2 >0.*3/2 :%:

,'1%&('/2 ,) +)/ >3); 0*/):0/'.0332 *4)+ 0,A*(/'+- &%4&%(%+/0/')+5 J1',%+.% (*--%(/(/$0/ :'+)&'/'%( /%+, /) %'/$%& 0((':'30/% '+/%33%./*0332 0+, .*3/*&0332 '+ )&,%& /)

(*..%%, '+ 30; (.$))3 0+, '+ 4&0./'.%7 )& /$%2 ,) +)/ 0((':'30/% 0+, %B4%&'%+.% 30;(.$))3 0+, 4&)>%((')+03 3'>% 0( 03'%+0/')+5 ?$'3% &%4&%(%+/0/')+ '(7 +)&:0/'1%327 0

,%>%+('>'&: /$%'& 430.% '+(',% /$%

30; (.$))35 Z);%1%&7 /$%(% /24%( )> :%0(*&%( )>>%& >03(% .):>)&/V ;$'3% /$%2 :02 %0(%/$% (/*,%+/`( %+/&2 /) 0+, 40((0-% /$&)*-$ 30; (.$))37 /$%2 ,) +)/ 4&)1',% 0 1%$'.3%

>)& :%0+'+->*3 %+-0-%:%+/ ;'/$ ,'1%&('/2 '((*%(7 +)& ,) /$%2 &%()31% >)& /$% :'+)&'/2

(/*,%+/ /$% $):)-%+'='+- 4*33 ;'/$'+ .)+1%+/')+03 3%-03 4%,0-)-25 ?$0/ '( &%G*'&%,'( 0+ 044&)0.$ /) /%0.$'+- 0+, /&0'+'+- /$0/ '+/%-&0/%( .&'/'.03 1)'.%( ;'/$'+ 3%-03

%,*.0/')+ 0+, (.$)30&($'4 0+, %: 43*&03'(/+0&&0/'1%( '+ 3%-03 $'(/)&27 ,)./&'+%7 0+032('(7 0+, &%0()+'+-5 W0& /)) 3'//3% (.$)30&($'4$0( -)), 30;2%&'+-5"N" #$'( (%%:( /) )&

,'>>%&%+/ ;02( /) /$'+@ 0+, .):4%/%+/

(%&1'.% ,%3'1%&27 '+,'1',*03 (%3>a>*3>'3:%+/5

E+,%%,7 '> ,'1%&('/2 ,%:0+,( /$% .%3%>%&%+.% 0( 0 ;02 )> 4&):)/'+-%G*03'/27 /$%&% :*(/ >%&%+.%( /$0/ 0&% .%3% /$% @'+,( )>

+)&:( /$0/ ($04% /$% 4&)>%((')+03 :),%37 )& &0+-% )> :),%3(7 /) ;$'.$ (/*,%+/(0(4'&%5 8)&:0/'1% ;&'/%&( $01% >).*((%, )+ '+>*('+- /$% &%.)+(/&*./%, 30;2%& :),%3

;'/$ 0 .)::'/:%+/ /) A*(/'.%7 %G*03'/27 0+, d,) +) $0&:5e"NC Z); /$'( '+>*(')+ '(

0.$'%1%, '+1)31%( /0'3)&'+- 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ /) 4&)>%((')+03 (%3>a':0-%5

#$% -)03 >)& 0 &%>)&:%, 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ ($)*3, ,'1%&('/2`( 1*3+%&0 ;):%+ 0+, :'+)&'/'%( >&): /$%

"N" #&%1)& P? W0&&);7 dJ/$'.03 Q0;2%&'+- '+ 0 F3)


33/44

ND

4&)>%((')+5"NN O2 &%a)&'%+/'+- 033 0(4%./( )> 3%-03 &%0()+'+-7 0+032('(7 ,)./&'+%7 0+,

4&0./'.% /) 03'-+ ;'/$ /$% 4&0./'.037 :)&037 0+, 4)3'/'.03 .)::'/:%+/( ':43'%, '+ 0,'1%&('/2 %/$'.7 /$% 30; (.$))3 .0+ 3%0, 0 &%>)&: 0-%+,0 /$0/ .0+ %((')+5

8< !H4N95KP !J4K6TMJR4L5MKS .RI7HRHKL5KP .KN7O65MK

#$% 4&':0&2 /$%)&%/'.03 .$033%+-% )> ':43%:%+/'+- ,'1%&('/2 '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '( /)

,%/%&:'+% $); 3%./ /$% 4&)>%((')+03 +)&:( )> 0 &%.)+(/'/*/%, ',%0 )> ;$0/.)+(/'/*/%( 3%-03 0+032('( 0+, 4&0./'.%5 #&0+(>)&:'+- 4&)>%((')+03 +)&:(7 4&0./'.%(7

0+, *+,0:%+/03 ,'(/'+-*'($%( 4&%(%+/ %,*.0/')+03 4&0./'.%(>&): /$)(% )> #)&)+/) '+ "k\Y7 X0+.)*1%& '+ "kcS7 ?'++'4%- '+ "kCD7Z03'>0B '+ "kDD7 )& MB>)&, '+ "YYS5 P)+/%:4)&0&2 .)::)+ 30; 3%-03

%,*.0/')+ /0@%( '/( >)&: >&): (.$%:%( 30*+.$%, '.0/')+ >)& >*+,0:%+/0332 &%a.)+.%4/*03'='+- /$% &)3% )> /$% 30;2%& '+ /$%

3%-03 (2(/%: 0+, '+ ().'%/25"N\ #$% 4&)A%./ )> 3'+@'+- %/$'.( 0+, 4&)>%((')+03'(: /):0'+(/&%0: 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '( 0( :*.$ 03'-+%, ;'/$ /$% ,'1%&('/2 ':4%&0/'1% 0( '/ '( 0

>*&/$%& %B0:43% )> )*/;0&, 4&%((*&%( )+ /$% (.)4% )> ;$0/ '( .)+(',%&%, d&%3%10+/e

0+, d.%+/&03e /) *+,%&(/0+,'+- /$% 30;5"N^ Q%-03 %/$'.( +%.%((0&'32 (4%0@( /)

"NN L%% M&+(/%'+7 !17#( +)/% Yq PO97 '-1&/!.-)"!7 !17#( +)/% ""q 9O97 ="C. :."7!7 !17#( +)/% Y5"Nc I).$%//% o K*%7 !17#( +)/% SN5"NS ? ?%(3%2 K*%7 dE+ K*&(*'/ )> O%//%& U2/$V Q0;2%&(` Z'(/)&'%( 0+, Z'(/)&'%( )> Q0;2%&(e f"kkSg NN

93/0 Q I%1 ^ND 0/ ^\Ca^\N5"N\

#$% %:%&-'+- >'%3, )> P0+0,'0+ 3%-03 %/$'.( ,%:)+(/&0/%( 0 (/&)+- 4*($ /);0&,( '+.)&4)&0/'+-,'1%&('/2 103*%( 0+, A*(/'.% 4&'+.'43%( '+/) /$% :),%3 30;2%&5 L%% "Q*Q 9,0: U T),%@7 dvP0+0,'0+ Q%-03

J/$'.(`V 9 L*)& /$% #;%+/2aW'&(/ P%+/*&2 0/ Q0(/e fCDDYg c\ M(-)),% Z033 Qu "q Z? 9&/$*&(7 d?$2 P0+0,'0+

Q0; L.$))3( T) 8)/ #%0.$ Q%-03 J/$'.(e '+ [': J.)+):',%(7 %,7 ?./%&(3 J/(33")*"! .- 4"*(3 ?;1&(.%-) ^

J-);1&. fMB>)&,V Z0&/ K*


34/44

N"

/$%)&%/'.03 0+, 4&0./'.03 G*%(/')+( 03*%+.%7

+)&:0/'1% %/$'.( 0+, ,'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-2 )1%&304 .)+(',%&0'&:( &%32 )+ 30; >0.*3/'%( /) (*4432 /$%'& %B'(/'+- (%&1'.%(2(/%:( '+>3*%+.% /$0/ /$% 3%-03 0.0,%:2 $0( )1%& /$% ,1.1#" )> /$% 4&)>%((')+ '( )>/%+

*+,%&a%(/':0/%, '+ /$% >0.% )> /$% 4%&.%'1%, ,):'+0+.% )> /$% 4&)>%((')+ f30&-% >'&:(

'+ 40&/'.*30&g )1%& 7#"!"). A)< 4&)(4%./( >)& (/*,%+/(5

933 )> /$'( '( /) %:4$0('=% /$0/ 30; (.$))3( 0&% +0/*&03 3%0,%&( '+ ($04'+- /$% 30; 0+,($)*3, %: /$%

4&)>%((')+5

/< !=*"%, E )%$3!.3* E %*-1*3!."0

>%$" ./" 717%3! !-D"./%)* .- ;-B )-. !-D"./%)* .- 3"(#)d (); ./" ;-%)*

%! -, !1&/ ( )(.1#" (! .- ;"D(); ./%)8%)*B -# ./" %).").%-)(3 )-.%)* -,

&-))"&.%-)!d 3"(#)%)* )(.1#(33@ #"!13.!Q"Nk

E> ,'1%&('/2 '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '( /$% -)037 /$'( 0&/'.3% $0( /$*( >0& (*--%(/%, /$0/'+0,%G*0/% '+(/'/*/')+03 (/&0/%-'%( $01% >0'3%, /) 4&):)/% 0 :%0+'+->*3 .)+.%4/')+ )>

/$0/ -)035 T'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-2 .033( >)& 0 &%a.)+.%4/*03'=0/')+ )> /$% +)&:0/'1% :),%3

)> 30;2%&'+- /$0/ '( 4&),*.%, '+ 30; (.$))35 #$% >)33);'+- (%./')+ 4&)1',%( 0 -%+%&034&)4)(03 )> $); /$0/ .0+ )& ,'(&*4/'+- /$% d(.'%+.% )> 30;e

044&)0.$ /$0/ $0( ,):'+0/%, /$% .)&% )> 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ >)& :)&% /$0+ 0 .%+/*&25 #$'('( +)/ /) /*&+ /$% (/*,2 )> 30; '+/) 0+ 0+/'a'+/%33%./*03 %B%&.'(%7 ).*( )> (@'33( /&0'+'+-7 3%./')+7 d(@'33( /&0'+'+-e .0+ 4&)1',% 0+ %+1'&)+:%+/ ;$%&%7 /) G*)/%

"NY L%% "Q*Q T01', #0+)1'.$7 dQ%0&+'+- /) 9./ Q'@% 0 Q0;2%&V 9 U),%3 P),% )> K&)>%((')+03 I%(4)+(')& Q0; L/*,%+/(e fCDDkg C^ ?'+,()& 6O 9..%(( u*(/ ^S5"Nk u)$+ T%;%27 K"D-(&@ (); ?;1&(.%-)< H) [).#-;1&.%-) .- ./" 0/%3-!-7/@ -, ?;1&(.%-) f8%; 6)&@V

U0.U'330+7 "k"\g 0/ "Y"5


35/44

NC

T%;%27 d3%0&+'+- +0/*&0332 &%(*3/(e5 #) /$'( %+,7 E .)++%./ /$% ,'1%&('/2 ':4%&0/'1% /)

/$% /$%)&27 >)&:(7 0+, (4%.'>'. )*/.):%( )> %B4%&'%+/'03 %,*.0/')+5

$< !9H &MR5K5MK MT &MNLJ5KH

#&0,'/')+03 3%-03 4%,0-)-2 &%3'%( $%01'32 )+ /$% d.0(% :%/$),e )> '+(/&*./')+5 T%(4'/%.*&&'.*3*: :),'>'.0/')+(7 /$% .0(% :%/$), &%:0'+( /$% ,):'+0+/ :),% )> ,)./&'+03'+(/&*./')+ '+ /$% >'&(/a2%0& .*&&'.*3*: 0+, '+ :*.$ )> /$% *44%&a2%0& )>>%&'+-( 0/ 30;

(.$))3( 0.&)(( P0+0,0 0+, /$% R+'/%, L/0/%(5"cD #$% .0(% :%/$), '( &))/%, '+ 0+

*+,%&(/0+,'+- )> 3%-03 0+032('( 0( 0 (.'%+.%5 E/ (%%@( /) )&-0+'=% /$% 30; '+/) 0 (2(/%:)> @+);0&): /$'( 4%&(4%./'1%b;'/$ 0>).*( )+ /$% 0 3%-03 '+(/&*./')+ '(

*+,*32 +0&&);5 #$% 9:%&'.0+ 3%-03 &%03'(/( )> /$% %0&32 CD/$ P%+/*&2 /))@ 0': 0/ '/(%B.%(('1% &%3'0+.% )+ >)&:03'(/'. 0443'.0/')+ )> 4&'+.'43%( *+,%& 0 4&%/%+.% )>+%*/&03'/2 0+, 4&%,'./0*/*&% 30;2%&( >)& /$%.)+/%B/*03 .)+/'+-%+.'%( )> &%03a;)&3, 30;2%&'+-5"cC O%.0*(% /$% .0(% :%/$), :*/%(

)& %B.3*,%( >0./)&( /$0/ 0&% 0&-*02'+- ':40./ )+ :%: :'+)&'/2 -&)*4( ;$) ',%+/'>2 ;'/$ /$% d)/$%&e (',%)> 0 &*3% '+ /$% >0.% )> 0 ,):'+0+/ >&0:% /$0/ /&%0/( &*3%( 0( '+$%&%+/32 ) 3%-03 0+032('( 0+, &%0()+'+-5 #$% .0(%

:%/$), 0((*:%( /$0/ 3%-03 30+-*0-% '( &0/')+03 0+, %>>%./'1%7 /$0/ 4&%.%,%+/( ,%(%&1%&%(4%./7 /$0/ /$% P)+(/'/*/')+ '( 3%-'/':0/%7 /$0/ >)&:03 A*(/'.% '( A*(/7 /$0/ 3'/'-0+/( 0&%

-%+%&0332 %G*037 0+, /$0/ /$% &*3% )> 30; '( /$% )& Q0;2%&aL.$))3(e f"kc^g S\ 603% Qu "NDN 0/ "N"S5"cN P&%+($0;7 dI0.%aP)+(.')*( K%,0-)-27e !17#( +)/% Sk 0/ N\acD5"cc L%% O&'0+ Q%'/%&7 !17#( l)*/3'+'+- /$% 10&')*( (/&0+,( )> /$'( .&'/'G*% ;'/$'+ I%03'(/ ;&'/'+-(n5


36/44

NN

:%/$), &%0()+'+-7 .0+ $01% %B.3*(')+0&2 %>>%./( '+ 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ ;$%+ '/ ,'(.)*+/(

0( '&&%3%10+/ +)+a.)+>)&:'(/ 0+, ,'1%&(% 4%&(4%./'1%(V

lOn%.0*(% )> /$% ,):'+0+/ 1'%; '+ 0.0,%:% /$0/ 3%-03 0+032('( .0+ '+,'1',*03 103*%(7

%B4%&'%+.%(7 0+, ;)&3, 1'%;(7 /$%(% .)+>3'./( (%3,):7 '> %1%&7 &%0.$/$% (*&>0.% )> /$% .30((&)): ,'(.*((')+5 T):'+0+/ ;$0/ /$% .0(% :%/$), .30':( 0( >)*+,0/')+03 /) '/( 4)(/*&% )> +%*/&03'/25 U0+2 30;

4&)>%(()&( ,) $'-$3'-$/ /$% >03(% 4&%/%+(')+( )> +%*/&03'/2 0+, .)3)*&0.*3/2 ;$) 0//%:4/ /) '+/%-&0/%4%&(4%./'1%( f.&'/'.037 &0.'037 >%:'+'(/7 %/.5g '+/) 3%-03 0+032('(7 &'(@ .)&% .)*&(%(5 L/*,%+/ &%(4)+(%( 0&%0 &%>3%./')+ )> /$% 103*%( 0+, 4&')&'/'%( (%/ 0.0,%:'. >&%%,):7 $01% 3'//3% '+.%+/'1% /) d.)&%e (*


37/44


38/44

NS

3< .K -JMR L9H V4JP5K6S V45K6LJH4R5KP *ZIHJ5HKL547 *QON4L5MK

#$% 3%./')+g '( +)/

.):43%/%32 +%; /) 3%-03 %,*.0/')+7 /$)*-$ '/ $0( 0//&0./%, &%1'/03'=%, '+/%&%(/ '+&%.%+/ 2%0&(5"SN K&0./'.03 /&0'+'+- '+ 30; /$&)*-$ 044&%+/'.%($'4 ;0(7 *4 *+/'3 /$% 30/%

"k/$

.%+/*&27 /$% 4&':0&2 :%/$), )> 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ /$&)*-$)*/ /$% .)::)+ 30;;)&3,5"Sc #$% d(.'%+.% )> 30;e 044&)0.$7 4')+%%&%, 0/ Z0&10&, Q0; L.$))3 '+ /$%"Y^D(7 G*'.@32 &%430.%, 044&%+/'.%($'4 0+, /$% %0&32 CD/$ .%+/*&2 >'&(/ &0'(%, /$% ',%0 )> d.3'+'.03e 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 0( 0.):43%:%+/ /) .30((&)):a.%+/&%,7 .0(%a>).*(%, (/*,'%(5"S^ #$% %:%&-%+.% )> /$% Q0;

0+, L).'%/2 :)1%:%+/7"SY 0+, /$% 430.% )> &0,'.03 3%>/ 4)3'/'.( )+ *+'1%&('/2 .0:4*(%(

'+ /$% "k\D(7 -%+%&0/%, 0 +)&:0/'1% >)*+,0/')+ >&): ;$'.$ :),%&+ .3'+'.03 3%-03%,*.0/')+ ;0( tq P0&+%-'% I%4)&/7 !17#(

+)/% c5"Sc L4%+.%&7 !17#( 0/ Ya"D5"SS L4%+.%&7 !17#( 0/ CD5"S\ L4%+.%&7 !17#( 0/ "^aCD5"S^ L%% "Q*Q u%&):% W&0+@7 d?$2 8)/ 0 P3'+'.03 Q0;2%&aL.$))3e f"kNNg Y" R K%++ Q I%1 kD^ 0/ k"D

f.&'/'G*'+- /$% *(% )> .0(% ).*( )+ A*,'.'03 )4'+')+7 /) /$% %B.3*(')+ )> )/$%& &%3%10+/

>0./)&( '+ /%0.$'+- /$% 30;gq [0&3 8 Q3%;%332+7 d#$% P*&&%+/ P&'('( '+ Q%-03 J,*.0/')+e f"kcYa"kckg " u

Q%-03 J,* C"" f.&'/'G*'+- /$% .0(% (/*,2 :%/$), 0+, *&-'+- 0 .*&&'.*30& ($'>/ '+ 30; (.$))3 /);0&,( /$%0.G*'('/')+ )> d.&0>/ (@'33(e7 0+ %0&32 .033 >)& .3'+'.03 3%-03 %,*.0/')+gq"SY L%% O&20+/ F0&/$ 0+, u)2.% L/%&3'+-7 dW&): Q%-03 I%03'(: /) Q0; 0+, L).'%/2V I%($04'+- Q0; >)& /$%

Q0(/ L/0-%( )> /$% L).'03 9./'1'(/ L/0/%e f"kkYg NCfCg Q o L). I%1 cDk5"Sk L%% u%>> F',,'+-( %/ 0357 d#$% W'&(/ ?01% )> U),%&+ P3'+'.03 Q%-03 J,*.0/')+V #$% R+'/%, L/0/%(7

O&'/0'+7 P0+0,07 0+, 9*(/&03'0e '+ W&0+@ L5 O3).$ %,57 '/" >3-2(3 J3%)%&(3 X-$"D"). fMB>)&,V MB>)&, R5

K&%((7 CD""g 0/ NaY5"\D u*3'% U0.>0&30+%7 dO&'+-'+- /$% P3'+'. '+/) /$% C"(/ P%+/*&2e fCDDkg C^ ?'+,()& 6O 9..%(( u*(/ NS 0/

N\5


39/44

N\

/$% 30;2%&7 >&): (/23'=%, /%.$+'.'0+ /) ,2+0:'. ().'03 0./)& 0+, 30; :0@%&5"\" #$'(

044&)0.$ ;0( :)/'10/%, )&:03 &*3%(5 P3'+'.03 (/*,%+/( 3%0&+%, $); /) .$033%+-% 0+, &%a'+/%&4&%/ &*3%(7

4&))& (/*,%+/ .&%0/'1'/2 0+, %+%&-27 ;$'3% 03()$'-$3'-$/'+- /$% ':4)&/0+.% )> (@'33( /&0'+'+- 0+, d3%0&+'+- /$% 4%)43% 0>>%./%, 4%,0-)-20+, 4&0./'.% /$0/ ;)*3, 4);%& ,'>>%&%+/'0/')+5 P3'+'.03 %,*.0/)&( (0; 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 0( 0+

'+(/&*:%+/ )> ().'03 /&0+(>)&:0/')+7 ;$%&%'+ 0 .)::'/:%+/ /) A*(/'.% .)*3, .3'%+/a.%+/&%, 30;2%&'+- 0+, (/*,%+/a.%+/&%,

3%0&+'+-5"\N

M1%& /$% 2%0&(7 .3'+'.03 4&)-&0:( $01% %1)31%, /) '+.)&4)&0/% %B4%&'%+/'03

4%,0-)-'.03 /$%)&'%( 0+, &%>3%./ /$% %(/0)&:*307 .)+('(/'+- )>/$%)&%/'.03 >&0:'+-7 4&0./'.03 '+(/&*./')+7 0+, (/&*./*&%, 4%&()+03 &%>3%./')+5"\c

P3'+'.03 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ 30; (.$))3( 0+, $01% )1%&.):% %0&32 0+/'40/$2/) %0&+ .&%,%+.% 0( 0 103*0 /%0.$'+- 0+, 3%0&+'+-5 8)/ 033

.*&&%+/ .3'+'.( 0&% /'%, /) 0 4&)-&%(('1% )& 3%>/'(/ 4)3'/'.03 )&'%+/0/')+7 /$)*-$ :0+2

(/'33 0&%5"\S L):% 30; >0.*3/'%( $01% .3'+'.( >).*('+- )+ .3'+'.03 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ '+ P0+0,0 ;0(

(/'33 30&-%32 *+&%03'=%,5 L%% I)(% X)21),'.7 dP)+(',%&0 L).'03 U)1%:%+/(he f"kk^g NS M(-)),%

Z033 Qu \"Nq Q*.'% J ?$'/%7 d#$% #&0+(>)&:0/'1% K)/%+/'03 )> P3'+'.03 Q%-03 J,*.0/')+e f"kk^g NS

M(-)),% Z033 Qu \DN 0/ \DS5"\c L%% 8'-%3 T*+.0+7 dJ/$'.03 K&0./'.% 0+, P3'+'.03 Q%-03 J,*.0/')+e fCDDSg u P3'+'.03 Q%- J, ^ 0/ "Y

f0&-*'+- /$0/ /$% ',%03 .3'+'.03 '+(/&*./)& '( (/%%4%, '+ %,*.0/')+ /$%)&2 0+, $0( 4&0./'.% %B4%&'%+.%g5"\S L%% L0:%%& U 9($0&7 dQ0; P3'+'.( 0+, P)33%./'1% U)'+'/')+7 (*


40/44

N^

4&)4%&/2 30;7 044%330/% 0,1).0.2 )& '+a$)*(% &%4&%(%+/0/')+ )> -)1%&+:%+/ 0+,

.)&4)&0/')+(5 T%(4'/% /$% %: .3'+'.03 :%/$),( 0.&)(( (*'%3,(7

.3'+'.03 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ &%:0'+( .)+.%4/*0332 ,'(/'+./ >&): :0'+(/&%0: 3%-03

%,*.0/')+5 P3'+'.03 4&)-&0:(7 ('3)%, 0+, )>/%+ 4$2('.0332 &%:)1%, )& ,'(.)++%./%,>&): /$% 30; (.$))37 0&% 1'%;%, 0( 0+ 03/%&+0/'1% )& .):43%:%+/ /) /$% 033a':4)&/0+/

,)./&'+03 '+(/&*./')+ /$0/ )..*&( '+ /$% 3%./*&% $0335 L/*,%+/( 0&% 0;0&% )> /$% 103*% )>0 .3'+'.03 4&)-&0: /$% (/'-:0 /$0/ :02 0&'(% >&): $01'+- d/)) :*.$e.3'+'.03 %B4%&'%+.% )+ 0 /&0+(.&'4/5 L*.$ (/*,%+/( :02 .3'+'.( $0( 03&%0,2 )3,V W'&(/7 '/ %(.04%( /$% 4%,0-)-'.03 >).*( )+ 0&): >0./( 0+, .)+/%B/7 (*>%&( &%03a3'>% (%//'+-( /) 04432,'1%&(% >)&:( )> 3%-03 @+);3%,-% 0+, 0>%&%+/ (/*,%+/ .):4%/%+.'%( 0+, (@'33 (%/(5"\\ #$'&,327 '/ %:43)2( .&'/'.03 &%>3%./')+

/) +*&/*&% 4&)>%((')+03 0+, 4%&()+03 -&);/$7 (%3>a$%03'+-7 0+, ().'0332 &%(4)+(' /$% 3'1%, ':40./ )> 30; 0+, 3%-03

4&0./'.%5 #$*(7 /$% :0'+(/&%0:'+- )> .3'+'.03 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ )>>%&( 4)(('&): .3'+'.03 %,*.0/')+ )>>%& *+'G*% )44)&/*+'/'%( /)

>*&/$%& :0'+(/&%0: %B4%&'%+/'03 3%0&+'+- 3%-03

%,*.0/')+ 0( 0 1%$'.3% >)& 0,10+.'+- ,'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-25

&< *RI7MX5KP *ZIHJ5HKL547 *QON4L5MK LM )JMRMLH &5UHJ65LX

#$%&% 0&% :0+2 ;02( '+ ;$'.$ %B4%&'%+/'03 %,*.0/')+ .0+ '+/%-&0/% 0+, 4&):)/%

,'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-25 W'&(/7 '/ .0+ &): (*>%&%+/32 0>>%./%, '+,'1',*03( )& -&)*4(5 L*.$ 0 ().')a3%-03 044&)0.$ .0+

&%:%,2 /$% ,%4%&()+03'='+-7 0).*( )> (/*,2 >&): /$% &*3% /) /$% 4&).%((5 W'+03327 0+, 4%&$04( :)(/

':4)&/0+/327 '/ /%0.$%( 3%-03 4&'+.'43%( 0( .)+/%B/*03'=%, 0./(5 #$'( '( '+ .)+/&0(/ /)

/$% .0(% :%/$), 044&)0.$ )> %B/&'.0/'+- /$% &0/')7 0+, /$%+ &0/')+03'='+- /$% >0./(0..)&,'+- /) 4&%a(%/ 0+032/'.03 >&0:%(5 L*.$ ($'>/ 033);( >)& ,%(/0


41/44

NY

%4'(/%:)3)-'.03 0((*:4/')+(7 0+, ;',%+( /$% (.)4% >)& ,'1%&(% .)+/&' 3%-0332 &%3%10+/ @+);3%,-%5"\^

L%.)+,327 %B4%&'%+/'03 3%0&+'+- 4&):)/%( ,'1%&('/2 a/%&:7 $'-$a(/0@%( %B0:'+0/')+( &%;0&, 40&/'.*30& .)-+'/'1% (@'33(

/$0/ )+32 +0&&);32 .04/*&% /$% (@'33 (%/( &%G*'&%, /) a3%0&+'+-5 #$% (/*,%+/ ,'(.)1%&( 0+, 4&),*.%( /$% @+);3%,-% $%&(%3>7:0@'+- .)++%./')+( /$&)*-$ /$% 0./ )> ,)'+-5 9( T%;%2 4*/ '/7 d3%0&+'+- +0/*&0332

&%(*3/(e >&): 40(('1% &%.'4'%+/ )> /$% '+(/&*./)&`( @+);3%,-%7 0( '+ 3%./*&%a .3'%+/( f3'1% )& (':*30/%,g 40&0:)*+/7 (/*,%+/( 0&% :)&%3'@%32 /) ;)&@ 0( .)330*3

:%0(*&% )& 4&%,'./)& )> (*..%(( 0( 0 30;2%&g5"^D #),, J5 K%//2(7 d#$% 9+032/'. P30((&)):e fCD"Cg \D O*>> Q I%1 "CSS 0/ "C\Ya"C^c l+)/'+- /$0/ 4*&%

L).&0/'. /%0.$'+- $0( ,'(044%0&%, >&): RL 30; (.$))3( >)& 0 10&'%/2 )> &%0()+(7 '+.3*,'+- '+%>>'.'%+.2

0+, 03'%+0/')+ 4&),*.%,


42/44

Nk

/$% :0A)&'/2 )> /$% 8)&/$ 9:%&'.0+ 30; (/*,%+/ '.'%+.'%( '+ /&0,'/')+03 %,*.0/')+ .30((&)): )& 3%./*&% .)+/%B/ 0+, 0( 40&/ )> 0./*03 3%-03 4&).%(( .)*3, :0@% %B4%&'%+/'03

3%0&+'+- 0 (*4%&')& :%/$), )> *+,%&(/0+,'+- ,)./&'+%7 0( .):40&%, /) %B/&0./'+-

0&): 044%330/% ,'./05 #$'(7 )> .)*&(%7 ,%4%+,( )+ /$% 010'30(*>>'.'%+/ /$%)&%/'.03 -&)*+,'+- /$&)*-$ .):4%/%+/ (*4%&1'(')+ 0+, >0.*3/2 (*44)&/

/$&)*-$)*/ /$% 3%0&+'+- 4&).%((5 L*.$ '( %((%+/'03 /) %+(*&% /$0/ /$% 103*% )> $0+,(a)+

%B4%&'%+.% '( +)/ &%,*.%, /) :%&% (@'33( 0.G*'('/')+5

E/ '( 03() ':4)&/0+/ /) +)/% /$0/ +)/ 033 %B4%&'%+/'03 %,*.0/')+ )..*&( '+ 0 3'1%a.3'%+/.3'+'.7 0+, +)/ 033 )> /$% '/( )> %B4%&'%+/'03 3%0&+'+- ;'33 +%.%((0&'32 0..&*% /) /$%

(/*,%+/ '+ %0.$ 0+, %1%&2 )+% )> /$%(% (%//'+-(5 JB4%&'%+/'03 %,*.0/')+ 4&)1',%(

-%+%&03 '/( (':432 >&): 3%0&+'+- 3%./')+5 #$'( >)&:*30 .0+ )& %B0:43%7 (':*30/%,%B4%&'%+.%(7 (*.$ 0( &)3%a4302 0+, :))/'+-5 #$% /$'+- /$0/ :0@%( '/ %B4%&'%+/'03 '(

"^C J:'32 95 O%+>%& o P)33%%+ W5 L$0+0$0+7 dJ,*.0/'+- /$% E+1'+('


43/44

cD

>*+,0:%+/0332 +)/ ;$%/$%& /$%&% '( 0 &%03 .3'%+/ )& 0+ 0./*03 '((*%7 )&: )> '+(/&*./')+ '( 4&))& &%>3%./')+ 0)&:0+.% 0+, /$% 4&).%(( 0>/%&;0&,(5

E> %B4%&'%+/'03 %,*.0/')+ '( ,%3'1%&%, '+ 0 :0++%& /$0/ .)+>)&:( /) /$% )& ,'>>%&%+/ 1)'.%( 0+, ,'(/'+./ )& )1%&3044'+- 4%&(4%./'1%( )+7 0+,

%B4%&'%+.%( ;'/$7 /$% 30; 0+, ;$%+ '/ %+.)*&0-%( (/*,%+/( /) .&0>/ /$%'& );+4&)>%((')+03 ',%+/'/27 &0/$%& /$0+ /&2 /) >'/ '+/) 0 4&%,%/%&:'+%, &)3%5

C5 K"&-)!.#1&.%)* 7-5"# #"3(.%-)!/%7!5 Q0; (.$))3( .0+ &%03'-+ 4);%& 0+, .0+%:4);%& (/*,%+/( +)/ A*(/ ;'/$ /$% .&%,%+/'03 )> 0 30; ,%-&%%7 ,'1%&('/2 '+1)31'+- 4&)>%((')+03 &%(4)+(' .$0+-%5

N5 L/':*30/'+- &13.1#" !/%,. '+ /$% 4&)>%((')+ )&-0+'.0332 /$&)*-$ /&0'+'+-(/*,%+/( /) ,%1%3)4 0 ().'0332 &%(4)+('%((')+03 (%3>a':0-%7 /) ,'>>%&%+.%5 E+ /$'( (%+(%7 ,'1%&('/2+%.%((0&'32 '+.)&4)&0/%( 0(4%./( )> /&0+(+0/')+03 >3*%+.27 '+/%&a.*3/*&03

(%+('/'1'/2 0+, -3) ,'1%&('/2 0( 0 -)1%&+'+- >%0/*&% )>

.)+/%:4)&0&2 3%-03 %,*.0/')+ ;)*3, '.0+/5 W*332 ':43%:%+/%,7 ,'1%&('/2

4%,0-)-2 ;)*3, %+0 0..%(( 0+,&%4&%(%+/0/')+7 0 /$'.@%& .)+.%4/')+ )> ,'1%&('/2 0( 0 +)&:0/'1% -)037

($04%, %G*03'/2 0+, 43*&03'(/'. *+,%&(/0+,'+-( )> 30; 0+, 30;2%&'+-5

T'1%&('/2 4%,0-)-2 .0+7 0+, ($)*3,7 /)*.$ )+ 033 0(4%./( )> 30; (.$))3 3'>%7 >&): /$%,)./&'+03 .30((&)): /) .3'+'.03 430.%:%+/( /) .0&%%& .)*+(%33'+-5 #$% @'+,( )>

)*/.):%( /$0/ ;'33 %:%&-% ,%4%+, )+ /$% 40&/'.*30& .)+/%B/ 0+, .'&.*:(/0+.%( '+ 0+2-'1%+ (%//'+-5 W)& /$'( &%0()+7 %,*.0/)&( ($)*3, >).*( )+ ,'1%&('/2a%+$0+.'+-

4&).%((%( &0/$%& /$0+ )+ 0.$'%1'+- (4%.'>'. )*/.):%(5 ?'/$ /':%7


44/44

BHABHA, Faisal. Towards a Pedagogy of Diversity in Legal Education

Documents