Bevzenko, New Pledge Law

7/24/2019 Bevzenko, New Pledge Law

1/43

()

:

1

.. ,

, ,

, - 1 2014 . - . , - , .

: ; ; ; ; - .

BATTLE FOR THE LAW OF REAL SECURITY:THE THIRD STEP IN REFORMING RUSSIAN

PLEDGE LAW2

R.S. BevZeNKO,

Ph.D. in Law, Profssor of th Russian School of Priat Law,Partnr of Pepeliaev GroupLaw Firm

1 - , . , ,

.

2 This article was developed in conjunction with the EBRD, which has been involved in the reform of

Russian law of secured transactions. However, the opinions and interpretations expressed in thearticles remain the authors sole ones.


2/43

()

9

The paper is dealing with the last reform of the Russian pledge law that was enteredinto force on July 1, 2014. It contains the analysis of the routes and sources of thereform, particularly their liaison with the previous legislation and case law. The author

examines the possible difficulties of interpretation and application of the new pledge lawwhich the economic actors may face with and offers the ways for their resolution.

Keywords: real security; pledge; mortgage; hypothec; charge; lien; foreclosure.

; , -

. - .

1

1.

, -. 90- ( 29 1992 . 2872-I ( 1992 .)) (1995 .),

, - : ( 1992 . 1994 .) , . , - (1996 ., -, 1992 . de facto ). - : , - (- , -

), 2008 ., - , : , . - ( 30 2008 . 306- - -

1 . ( ): . . .: . . -, 1895. . 16.


3/43

2 2015 15

10

), . : -, - (

6 2011 . 405- - - ( 405-)).

, , ( 23 2009 . 58 , 17 2011 . 10 ( -

10)), : - . , - : - . - , ( , - 2008 .) , - . ( 2014 . 21 2013 . 367- - -

( - ) ), ?

, , . , , - : , - , , , , - . , - ( , .) - - . , , .

: -

-


4/43

()

11

( ) ( , -

, .); , , ,

- , , . , - , , , ( ) , -

, . ( -, ), ., , , - 16 1998 . 102- (- ) ( ).

-

, - , ( ) . , , . , , - .

, , , , . , - , .

2.

- . , , - . , , .. -

.


5/43

2 2015 15

12

, .

, -

. . - , - , .

, . , - , -. , ( -, ), , ,

, - ; - 1. , (, , ) ( ), . , - , - - . , .

. , , , - 100; . , , - 150. . - , , - , , , -, . - ( ) : , - ; , .

, , - : - .

1 , - (, , -

) , ,

, ,

.


6/43

()

13

20 . , , - : , , -

, , , ( ).

, . , 1994 . , , 1964 ., - . , 1964 . , , 1922 . , ( ) , -

- ; , - ( )1.

, , - , - . - ( ), . -

. 20.4 , , . . -

, -, - . , . 20.4 ( . ).

, - , , - 3 . 23 . , , (. . 1 . 334, . 334.1, . 2 . 335, 335.1, 336, 339.1( ) .. ).

( ) (. 2 . 334 . 2 . 341 ), , -

1 . : .., .. . .: - .-, 1965. . 1920.


7/43

2 2015 15

14

, , , .. , ( -

), ( ) , . , , , - 1.

, - . - , (. 1. 334.1 ). , ( -

; . 5 . 488 ) ( ; . 1 . 587 ).

- . - . 5 . 334 , , - , , -

. , - . , - , , -. ... . - , , , .

, - . 2. 174.1 - .

- ; . : , - ? ,

1 -: - , -

.

() () -

.


8/43

()

15

, ? , . , : , , -

. ; , - . , . 5 . 334 , , , -, , .

( ) (- ) - ( ());, ( -

, ..)). - . , , . -, .

, , , - - . -, ( ,

). , , , - . , - . , ( , , ) -, . , , , , ( ) - .

, , - , , -, (). -, . 2 . 174.1 (, , , - , , ).

. , -

( . 2


9/43

2 2015 15

16

. 335 ) , , ( , - ,

), . ,

( ) - ( . ).

3. ,

3 . 23 , , .

, , , . , - 3 . 23 -, 1 , - , 2 - , - - .

3 . 23 - - 1992 .

1992 . -. , 1992 . - ; 1998 .1

, 1992 . de facto , 1992 . . , , - 1992 ., , , - . , , 1992 . - , -, . -, , 2000- . 1992 ., - ( de facto

1 . . 1 15 1998 . 26 -

, -

.


10/43

()

17

, - !)1.

1992 . 1992 . ( - , , ) - 1992 . -, , 1992 . 1 2014 .

. . 4 . 334 - (

. 20.4 , - ), .

, - , , - 2. - - .

- , .

, , . (, ( ) ;

1 , :

1992 ., , -

,

, ,

. (., , . 15 -

10).

2 , , , -

, , -

. , ,

. 2 . 3 ( , -

, ).

, , -

, ,

(., , . 4 23

2012 . 14 ,

).

,

: , ,

.


11/43

2 2015 15

18

, .) , -, . - , -

. -

. . -, .. - 3 . 23 .

. - ( , -

, - , , , - , ) -, , 1 2014 . - .

: , , ?

, , ( . 4 . 334 ) , .

. - lexspecialis , , - . , , 3 . 23 . - lex specialis, ... !

lex specialis? , , - , , . , , , - - , - . , , , 19961997 . -, 2014 . ,

. ...


12/43

()

19

, (, , lex specialis1): lex

posterior derogat priori. 3 . 23 , , - , - . , , - . , - .

4. .

. 335 -, , , - , -2, , , .

- . , - , (, , - ). , - , , - (, ), (, - , ). , , , - . ( -

1 lex posteriori lex specialis -, (.: Kieninger E.-M., Linhart K.German Report // European Review of Private Law. 2012. Vol. 20. Issue 1. P. 109110; Lindroos A.Addressing Norm Conicts in a Fragmented Legal System: The Doctrine of Lex Specialis// NordicJournal of International Law. 2005. Vol. 74. P. 27, 41). ,

.

2 , -

(. ).


13/43

2 2015 15

20

) : -

, , - . -, ( - , ), , , -. , , .

, , , - , . .

. , - ; . -

, . , - , , - .

, - . , - : . -, -, , -, 1.

- ( ) , , , -

1 -

: ,

, ; , -

.


14/43

()

21

, , - . , ,

( ), - . , - de facto .

. , - , (

). (, ) , - . - - , ., , 1.

1 2014 . ,

- . , , - , - .

, - , , .

. 335 , ,

1 , , ,

. -

-

. , , , -

, ,

; ,

-

. , contra legem ,

( 13 2011 . 4408/11),

, .


15/43

2 2015 15

22

- . 364367 , , .

?

, , -, . , - , . - , . -,

, , - .., , - , , , -.

, 1, : .

(-

, , ) , - . , , , - , , , -, (-, .). , , , -, .

, - 2.

1 , ,

, ; -, , : , , , .

2 . ,

, , : , -

(, , , -

, ). , -


16/43

()

23

. , , - - ; -

. , , . : - ( ) , ? , , , , 1, .. - .

. , - , , : , -

, - . - , -, -, ?

, , -? ? , - , ? , - , ?2

, , , , ( ; 18

). , , , : , , - .

1 .

2 -. , : - (. 13 10). . 335 . 1 . 367

, , -

: - . , ( , -) ,

( ) ( 18 2011 . 6977/11; 13 2011 . 39-11-5; . 37 12 2012 . 42; . : - .. - :

12 2012 . 42 , 23 2012 . 14 - , . .: , 2013).

,

-

.


17/43

2 2015 15

24

- . 364367 , . ,

, , -, : - , . : 1) - ( , - ), ; 2) , , - ,

. , . 335

, -, .. , , 1.

, -, , - - , - ?

.-, :

. . 5 . 488 , , , , - , - -.

(, , -) . , ,

1 , ,

(, , , -

) , -

.

, ,

;

( , -

, ..) , ,

, .


18/43

()

25

: , , - , - , , -

, , . , , , ( ) .

-, , , - (, ), - -. , (

), 1. , , .

-, , , . ( ), - , , . , , . -

, , -, ( ) ., ,

, . - . , , ( , ), , . . -, , , - , . - : - , , , , ( ), - - , , - .

1 , probatio diabolica.


19/43

2 2015 15

26

, - . , - , -

(, -, ..), - .

, - . , 20112012 . , 1 , - , -

2.

5. :

- , (-) . , . 339 , -, .

, , , - .

, -: . 43 6 8 1 1996 . , - ( 6/8) , [] , -, , , -

, , , - 3.

1 26 2011 . 2763/11, 7 2012 .

16513/11.

2 6 2011 . 9555/11.

3 10 (. 13) , -

: -

() ,

.


20/43

()

27

, : . 339 , . , , ,

, - , -. . 43 6/8 . 1 . 339 : , - , , , - - .

, - , -

; , . , - - , - () , , , . , , -, ,

, . - , .

- , , . , , , , ( ), - ( -), , - ( , 1), .

, , - , .

.

1 -

, .


21/43

2 2015 15

28

, . 1 . 339 [], - , , , -

. - , - , -, .

, - .

? .-, , -

. -

. , , , ___ ____ ___________201_ ., (), , .

-, . 339 , - , -

( ). , - , , ___ ____ ___________201_ . ( ) , ___, - ___ ______, , - , - . , -, , - , .

-, , - ( ) ( ).

, - , ,

:


22/43

()

29

, , , , , , ,

, , , () - ( . 2 . 339 ). , - : , (, -, (, )) . - , -

-. , , .

, , , , - , - , , . . 1 . 1 . 352 ? -

, , ( ), (. 4 . 367 ). , .

, -, ( - ).

- , () .

6. : .

, - .

, ,

, -


23/43

2 2015 15

30

. , . 2 . 339 -,

, - - 1.

, - . , , , () ; - .

, - , . - .

, - , , .. ( ) .

, , -

, , : (. . 357 ). . , - , , (. 2 . 357 ). , - , , . , -; . 352 , - 2.

- floating charge( ), - . - .

1 1 2015 . (. 2 . 3 21 2013 .

367-).

2 , -

: ,

.


24/43

()

31

-, , , - . -

: - .

-, - , . , (fixedcharge), , , . : 1.

, , - , - ( ) , , . , - , 2; - , . ,

. , , , , - ; - .

, , , , , - , -. -, - 3, .. ,

1 . foating charge, : Btter M.Recognition of English Fixed andFloating Charges in German Insolvency Proceedings under the New European Regulation on Insolvency

Proceedings // Journal of Corporate Law Studies. 2002. Vol. 2. P. 213; Ferran E.Floating Charges:The Nature of the Security // The Cambridge Law Journal. 1988. Vol. 47. Issue 2; Pennington R.R.The Genesis of the Floating Charge // The Modern Law Review. Vol. 23. Issue 6; Worthington S.Floating Charges: An Alternative Theory // The Cambridge Law Journal. 1994. Vol. 53. Issue 1.

2 . .

3 , -

. -

,

.


25/43

2 2015 15

32

. , , - , , - , ,

(, , ) - - . , , . , - -, , - . , - , . , , , ,

, , , .

, , -, 1.

, , - , , , - (, , .. (. )).

, - ( ..), , -, . , , , - .

, -, , .

: , , - , , , . ; .

.

1 , , (. . 25 10

).


26/43

()

33

, - . -

. , . 2 . 334 . : , - . - . , : - , - - ( ).

- . - , -, ; .

, - ( , ) . - (, .), , ,

, , . , - (. . 2 . 334, . 2 . 345 ).

, , .

( ) , , . . 5 . 345

: , , - , - , () .

, , .

, , . -

, . , ,


27/43

2 2015 15

34

, . - ( , ) . -

. , , -

, , - : ( ; ; ; , ), (

.), - ex officio. - - , (, -, , ).

. , . 2 . 345 - : .

, (. 64 69), , - , , .

, . , : -, ; -, , -

, , , . . 2 . 345 , , -

- - , , - . - , ; , -

.


28/43

()

35

7. , :

, . , , , , , , -, .

, , - - .

, ,

, : , - . , -, , .

, (, erga omnes, .. ), : - , - . (-

, , - ) , , .

, , , .. .

.

(, , ) -

. , , , ; , , : , - ( ). -, , - . , - , , ,

, .


29/43

2 2015 15

36

- ; , , - (, ..),

. , - . , , - .

? -. , .. , , , - . ,

, .

. - , . - ( ) , , , - . -

, 1.

- , - - 1) 2) , - . , . , , , -

.. 3 . 23 - 339.1, . ?

, (, , , - ) .

1 , , -

, , ,

, . ,

: , -

, .


30/43

()

37

(-, ) , : , -

. - . - ( !) . 2 . 8.1 .

, - .

-, (), - (. . 11 ), , 1.

-, ; 2.

-, , - ( , ..); - .

-, , - ; .

, , , , . , . 339.1 -

3 (, ) - (. 3 . 339.1). - , -

1 , (

405-), -

, ..

. , , , -

, , -

.

2 , -

,

. . 21 8 1998 . 14-

,

; -

, .

3 ,

. , -

.


31/43

2 2015 15

38

; - (, ) , -

. ( - ) , () . ( -) : 1.

- : . -,

, , - -. , , - . - ( ), - .

, , : , -

? - 2

1 , , , -

(Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)) -

(ling system), ,

, ,

, . ,

nancial statement

(Hamwijk D.Public Filing with Regard to Non-Possessory Security Rights in Tangible Assets as Con-templated by the DCFR: Of No Benet to Unsecured (Trade) Creditors // European Review of Private

Law. 2011. Vol. 19. Issue 5. P. 613614). , : -

, , -

(Montague W. Uniform Commercial Codes Article 9: When Filing isNot Required to Perfect a Security Interest // Kentucky Law Journal. 19631964. Vol. 52. P. 422).

( , , ).

(effec-

tiveness)

(Draft Common Frame of Reference ( DCFR)).

2 , (.. -

) (Antragsprinzip)

(VlietL. van. The German Grundschuld// Edinburgh Law Review. 2012. Vol. 16. Issue 2. P. 150 ( - : http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=2071814)).


32/43

()

39

, , - : -

. 4 . 339.1 [] - , , . -, , , - . , , , , . , -

, , -, , - , , .

. .1 - (. - 11 1993 . 4462-I) ( - ); 1.

,

., ( -, ) , , - , . - , , , , , -, , . ( . 103.2 ). - , - , - . .

: - 2. ,

1 , ,

, .

2 : http://reestr-zalogov.ru.


33/43

2 2015 15

40

, (. 103.7).

, - - , . , - .

, , .

, : ( ) ().

(VIN)1, - 2. - ( , , ) ; , .

, , . -

- . , - 3.

. . 4 . 339.1 : - ,

1 , -

. , -

, , .

2 . , (,

..); , , ,

, , , ,

, . , -

.

3 ( , )

(, , , -

). , -

, : -

, , , , ..

.


34/43

()

41

, , , , - . . 10 . 342.1

: , , 4 339.1 , - , , , , - , , , , . - .

(, ), -: , - , , , - , ( . 4. 339.1 ). , - .

-, .

, . , - ( - ). , - ( - ) , , , . , .

, . 2 . 1 . 352 : , , - .

,

.


35/43

2 2015 15

42

, 1. . 25 10 , -

. 2. , , .

. 25 10 , -, , .. -. , , , ,

, - , . . 302 . , . 302 - , .

. 25 - 10. - ( ) ,

. , - . - ( , , - 3) ( ) , .

, , -

1

10 2007 . 1107-12, 12 2011 . 74-11-4, 20 - 2012 . 16-11-24, 9 2012 . 18-12-39.

2 20 2007 . 215--, 15 2008 . 323--, 15

2010 . 942--, 22 2012 . 498--, 22 2014 . 754-, 5

2014 . 1142-.

3 , -

. -

, -

.. (.:

.. // : -

, / . . .. -

.. . .: , 2010. . 130150).


36/43

()

43

: - , ,

, .

8. :

, .

, -

.

(- - (. )), - ( ).

, , - (, - -

), , , : . ()

. 50 , 80, - : 40. ( , 50, 30.)

-: - . , ; .

, - pro rata - , ( .). , -

, . ,


37/43

2 2015 15

44

, -. ,

- .

, , .

, , , - ( , ) ( ).

- (. 13 15 - 30 2014 . 214- - , . 201.9 26 2002 . 127- ()). , - , (, ,

), pro rata, .. - . , -

, . , , - 100 , - 50 , . - .

, . -, , 100, - . , , - , , 50. . 387 , 1/2 -. , - . 80. : ?

, 40, ..

pro rata. -


38/43

()

45

, , -, : - , (, , -

, , ). , , - ( 80 + 50 = 130 100), 10.

, , , - - pro rata, . . 335 , , - ( -

) - .

: -, , - . , , , - , ( - )1.

. - ( . 1 . 335.1 ). , - - . , - , , .

- . - , , - , . , , , -

1 . . 30 12 2012 . 42 , : .

, - (, ..). ,

, .


39/43

2 2015 15

46

- - . - (

, , , ) , , - .

, - .

,

(. 2 . 342.1 ). - , , - (. 6 . 342.1 ). , - .

9.

- . - , .

: , ., , -1, , .

- ?

(. 1 . 349 ), (. 1 . 348 ). , , - (. . 1 . 348 ). , -

1 , ,

: -

, .


40/43

()

47

, ( ). - , , -

- (, .). , - , .

- , - , .. . ,

, - . , - , - - ( . 1 . 349 ).

. 1 . 349 : , -

, - . , -, . (. 3 . 1 ), 1.

( - ) : . 2 . 348 - -, , - 5% , . , - , . , -

1 . . (4) . IX. 7:103 ( -

( ) -

, , )

. (1) . IX. 7:112 DCFR( - ).


41/43

2 2015 15

48

, - ; , : , -

..

, (. . 2. 348 : , , - ).

, , - , 12 (. 3 . 348

). , - .

( ) , (. 4 . 349 ), -, , (. 5 . 349 ).

- ( -

), - (. 6 . 349 ). ( - ), , -, - . , , - , (.. -) 1.

- -

1 , , -

, -

(. 10

2012 . 15085/11).


42/43

()

49

, , (- ) .

, -

, , (. 7 . 349 ).

, - (. 3 . 349 ):

) , - , - 1;

) - , - , - ;

) , , - .

, - . - -, , ., , , - , - , , - .

REFERENCES

Bevzenko R.S.Pravovye pozitsii Vyshchego Arbitrazhnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Fede-ratsii po voprosam poruchitelstva i bankovskoi garantii: Kommentarii k Postanovleni-yam Plenuma Vyshchego Arbitrazhnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 12 iyulya 2012 g.No. 42 O nekotorykh voprosakh razresheniya sporov, svyazannykh s poruchitelstvomi ot 23 marta 2012 g. No. 14 Ob otdelnykh voprosakh praktiki razresheniya sporov,svyazannykh s osparivaniem bankovskikh garantii [Bevzenko R.S.Precedents of the

1 :

.


43/43

2 2015 15

50

Supreme Commercial Court of the Russian Federation in the Law of Personal Security(Suretyship and Guaranty): Comments on the Plenary Session Decisions of the SCC RFNo. 42 On the Selected Questions of the Suretyship Cases and No. 14 On the Selected

Questions of the Banking Guaranties Cases] (in Russian). M., 2013.Btter M.Recognition of English Fixed and Floating Charges in German Insol-

vency Proceedings under the New European Regulation on Insolvency Proceed-ings // Journal of Corporate Law Studies. 2002. Vol. 2. P. 213.

Ferran E.Floating Charges: The Nature of the Security // The Cambridge LawJournal. 1988. Vol. 47. Issue 2.

Hamwijk D.Public Filing with Regard to Non-Possessory Security Rights in Tan-gible Assets as Contemplated by the DCFR: Of No Benefit to Unsecured (Trade)Creditors // European Review of Private Law. 2011. Vol. 19. Issue 5.

Ioffe O.S., Tolstoy Yu.K.Novyi Grazhdanskii kodeks RSFSR [New Civil Code ofthe RSFSR] (in Russian). Leningrad, 1965.

Kieninger E.-M., Linhart K.German Report // European Review of Private Law.2012. Vol. 20. Issue 1.

Kohler J.Shekspir s tochki zreniya prava (Sheilok i Gamlet): Per. s nem. [Kohler J.Shakespeare from the Jurisprudence Standpoint (Shylock and Hamlet): Translatedfrom German] (in Russian). St. Petersburg, 1895.

Lindroos A.Addressing Norm Conflicts in a Fragmented Legal System: The Doc-trine of Lex Specialis// Nordic Journal of International Law. 2005. Vol. 74. P. 27.

Makovskaya A.A.Dobrosovestnost uchastnikov zalogovogo pravootnosheniyai raspredelenie riskov mezhdu nimi [Makovskaya A.A.Good Faith in the Pledge Lawand the Distribution of Risks] (in Russian)// Main Issues of Private Law: Collectionof Articles to the Anniversary of Dr. habil., Prof. Alexander L. Makovsky / V.V.Vitryansky, E.A. Sukhanov (eds.). M., 2010.

Montague W. Uniform Commercial Codes Article 9: When Filing is Not Requiredto Perfect a Security Interest // Kentucky Law Journal. 19631964. Vol. 52. P. 422.

Pennington R.R.The Genesis of the Floating Charge // The Modern Law Review.Vol. 23. Issue 6.

Vliet L. van. The German Grundschuld// Edinburgh Law Review. 2012. Vol. 16.Issue 2 (available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=2071814).

Worthington S.Floating Charges: An Alternative Theory // The Cambridge LawJournal. 1994. Vol. 53. Issue 1.

INFORMATIONABOUTTHEAUTHOR

Bevzenko R.S. (Moscow) Ph.D. in Law, Professor of the Russian School of

Bevzenko, New Pledge Law

Documents