Top Banner
BETTER BY MEASURE TWO TALES OF DISRUPTION – PART TWO Class 4 | September 25, 2014 BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014
63

Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

Jun 19, 2015

Download

Business

Rebecca Silver

What business models support the creation of value to civic society, the environment and human health? Better by Measure, a class from the Products of Design masters program at the School of Visual Arts (http://productsofdesign.sva.edu), explores how startups can build value by critically embracing civic, environmental, and human health challenges. The course is taught by Jen van der Meer (@jenvandermeer) and Rebecca Silver (@rgsilver).
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

BETTER BY MEASURE!TWO TALES OF DISRUPTION – PART TWO!Class 4 | September 25, 2014!!

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Page 2: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

OUTLINE!

2!

BUSINESS SCHOOL: LEAN CUSTOMER DISCOVERY – PART TWO!!CUSTOMER DISCOVERY REPORT!!SCIENCE LAB: TWO TALES OF DISRUPTION – PART TWO!!

!

!

Page 3: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

LEAN STARTUP!

BUSINESS SCHOOL!

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Page 4: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 ! 4!

Page 5: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Customer Discovery!

Customer Creation!

Customer Validation!

Company!Building!

The first part of class: develop a hypothesis about each component of the business model.!Customer discovery = a set of experiments to test each hypothesis.!Our goal: find a market to fit your vision, with a large enough addressable market to fit your aspirations.!!

Iteration! Execution!

CUSTOMER DEVELOPMENT!

5!

Page 6: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

What is your product or service? !How does it differ from an idea? !Why will people want it? !Who is the competition and how does your customer view these competitive offerings? !Where’s the market?!What’s the minimum feature set?!What’s the market type?!What was your inspiration?!What assumptions drove you to this?!What unique insight do you have into the market dynamics or into a technological that makes this a fresh opportunity? !

CUSTOMER DEVELOPMENT!

6!

Page 7: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

Product? Service?

Ecosystem? All?

VALUE PROPOSITION!

7!

Page 8: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

Your team values Your vision

Why do you want to do this? Then find a segment, a market, and a value proposition that fulfills this vision.

What do you put on the landing page – the single, clear, compelling message that turns an unaware visitor in to an interested prospect?

TRANSLATING VISION INTO VALUE PROPOSITION!

8!

Page 9: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

SOURCE: Value Proposition Canvas – Osterwalder !

VALUE PROPOSITION!

9!

Page 10: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

VALUE PROPOSITION CANVAS!

SOURCE: Value Proposition Canvas – Osterwalder !

10!

Page 11: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

“Design is not art. Design should solve a problem for humans. We can find the problems that we’re causing for humans by looking for pain points. Usability testing helps us understand the very obvious pain that we’re causing for users, which is fantastic. But beyond discovering user pain in our products, we should be doing user research on various demographics and understanding what in their lives is causing them pain.”!

!

– Laura Klein, UX for Lean Startups!

!

!

PAIN DRIVEN DESIGN!

11!

Page 12: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

As a customer, it has to hurt enough that you would go out of your way to pay for it.!

It has to feel way better than staying the course, stasis, or inertia (which make people sometimes feel warm, and comfortable, and your thing scary, and risky). !

!

!

!

!

WHY PAIN????!

12!

Page 13: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

How do you move beyond superficial needs?!How do you know when someone is telling the truth? !How do you get to unspoken, deeper needs? !

THE PAIN IN PAIN-DRIVEN DESIGN!

13!

Page 14: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

PAIN DRIVEN DESIGN! Artifacts!

Behavior!Expressed Needs!

VISIBLE: IN AWARENESS!IN CONSCIOUSNESS!

HIDDEN, INVISIBLE: !OUT OF CONSCIOUSNESS!

Norms!

Beliefs! Assumptions!

Values!

Plans!

Traditions!Attitudes!

Page 15: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

PAIN DRIVEN DESIGN! What just happened?!EVENTS!

WAYS OF EXPLAINING REALITY: SYSTEMS THINKING !

PATTERNS! What’s been happening?!

TRENDS! What are the common forces at play? !

STRUCTURES! How do processes and organization impact? !

MENTAL MODELS! How does our thinking allow this to persist!

Page 16: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Narrow down to the essential groups of people who will be your first customers.!

!

Warning: this a a different process than brand segmentation, where you generalize customer types based on mindset, psychographics, demographics.!

!

This is a tangible exercise – go out an meet these people, validate that they will be your customer (not just your user) – if you have a multi sided model, then great – validate the multi-sides.!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

CUSTOMER SEGMENTS!

16!

Page 17: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Google !Leapfrog!Foursquare!Fitbit!Facebook!Scholastic!Cherrios!Amazon!Lego!Salesforce.com!Kickstarter!!!!!!!!!!

Dropbox OpenTable

Hootsuite Flickr

Instagram

WhatsApp Whole Foods

Walmart Postmates

Netflix

Organic broccoli farmer

REVENUE GAME – WHAT ARE THE MODELS?!

17!

Page 18: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Users!

Buyers!

Influencers!

Approvers!

Blockers!

!

How the target customer currently purchases goods and services and how much they currently pay for equivalent products!

Their willingness to pay for value versus lowest cost?!

How much budget they have for your type of product?!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

REVENUE PATH: WHO IS YOUR CUSTOMER?!

18!

Page 19: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Selling physical goods!

Selling digital products!

Service per unit!

Service for fixed prices!

Sales of service for future use !

Daily deals/flash sales!

Subscriptions!

Usage fees!

Rental!

Licensing !

Certifications!

Auctions!

Interest/Mgmt fees !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Dynamic pricing

Advertising

Promoted content

Sponsorships

Analytics

Databases

Brokerage

Transaction enablement

Affiliate programs

Marketplace

Freemium –paid w/out advertising

Freemium –paid w/out restrictions

Freemium – paid with additional features

TYPES OF REVENUE: WHAT STRATEGIES WILL YOU TEST?!

19!

Page 20: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Users!

Buyers!

Influencers!

Approvers!

Blockers!

!

How the target customer currently purchases goods and services and how much they currently pay for equivalent products!

Their willingness to pay for value versus lowest cost?!

How much budget they have for your type of product?!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

REVENUE > PRICING!

20!

Page 21: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

How does your product get from your company to your customer?!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

CHANNELS AND DISTRIBUTION!

21!

Page 22: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

What were the channels before there was the internet? !!!!!!!!!!

CHANNELS PRE INTERNET!

Page 23: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

What are the many channels now? !!!!!!!!!!

CHANNELS POST DIGITAL!

23!

Page 24: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

!

!

CHANNEL !

PRO

DU

CT ! Bits

/Virt

ual !

Physical !Ph

ysic

al !

Bits/Virtual !

CHANNEL / PRODUCT!

24!

Page 25: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Product:!Virtual or Physical!!Channel: !Direct or Indirect!!!!!!!!!!!

HOW DO YOU WANT TO GET YOUR PRODUCT TO YOUR CUSTOMER? !

25!

Page 26: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Direct sales through salesforce!Direct sales through web!Direct sales through mobile!Direct sales through mobile app store!OEM!Systems integrator !!What is the complexity of your product/service? !!!!

Dealer !Distribute to retailer !Value added resellers !Sell to distributor !Aggregator!Other!!!!!!!!!!!

WHAT CHANNELS WILL YOU TEST?!

26!

Page 27: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !27

WHAT CAME BEFORE STEVE AND ERIC

Page 28: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

SOCIAL & ENVIRONMENTAL DISRUPTION – PART TWO!

SCIENCE LAB!

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Page 29: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

BACK TO THE EARTH ON FIRE!

29!

!!!

!

Page 30: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

EXERCISE: EXTERNALITIES & FEEDBACK LOOPS!

30!

!!!

!

IN TEAMS OF TWO OR THREE MAP A FEEDBACK LOOP WHICH CONNECTS THE IMPACT TO THE ACTOR. YOU HAVE 5 MINUTES.!

1.  IMPACT: Micro-bead water pollution; ACTOR: Johnson & Johnson!2.  IMPACT: Rana Plaza factory collapse; ACTOR: Walmart!3.  IMPACT: Worker abuse; ACTOR: Mattel!4.  IMPACT: Sup-prime mortgage crisis; ACTOR: Lehman Brothers!5.  IMPACT: Forced child labor use in Cote D’Ivoire; ACTOR: Hershey!6.  IMPACT: Children picking through e-waste in China; ACTOR: Apple!7.  IMPACT: Obesity; ACTOR: The workplace!8.  IMPACT: Human drug resistance to illness; ACTOR: Tyson !!!!

Page 31: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Customer Discovery!

Customer Creation!

Customer Validation!

Company!Building!

Customer Discovery: Defining the problem to solve – going deep and getting to a real pain point for humans on this earth. Considering users that are more marginalized, under the radar. What is possible with the mass adoption of technology. Do we still have to cross a technological chasm?!Customer Validation: Prove that the time is now for these new business models to exist. !Customer Creation: Build a tribe, not just a customer. !Company Building: Build a purpose-driven organization. !

Iteration! Execution!

WHERE WE CONNECT BUSINESS TO SYSTEM!

31!

Page 32: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

EXTERNALITIES GONE WILD!

32!

!!!

!

How culpable is an individual actor playing by the rules of a faulty system for the negative externalities their actions beget? !

What happens when individual actors/companies are able to change or innovate faster than the systems from which they sprung can correct?!

What happens when global dynamic systems spiral out of control?!

!

!

!

!

Page 33: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

‘WICKED’ AND ‘SUPER WICKED’ PROBLEMS!“WICKED” PROBLEMS HAVE NO SOLUTION, YOU CAN ONLY MOVE THE NEEDLE.!•  There is no definitive formulation of a wicked problem!•  Every wicked problem is essentially unique!•  Every wicked problem can be considered to be a symptom of another problem!!SOURCE: Rittel & Weber, Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. 1973.!

!“SUPER WICKED” PROBLEMS SUCH AS CLIMATE CHANGE ARE CHARACTERIZED BY FOUR ADDITIONAL FEATURES:!•  Time is running out; !•  The central authority needed to address it is weak or non-existent; !•  Those who cause the problem also seek to create a solution; and !•  Hyperbolic discounting occurs that pushes responses irrationally into the future!

- SOURCE: Environment.research.yale.edu!!

33!

Page 34: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 ! 34!

WHAT WICKED PROBLEMS DO WE HOPE TO SOLVE FOR?!C

limat

e C

hang

e!

ENVIRONMENTAL !IMPACTS!

SOCIAL !IMPACTS!

HEALTH!IMPACTS!

Chi

ld S

lave

ry!

Infe

ctio

ns D

isea

se!

Page 35: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

KEY ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS CATEGORIES!

35!

ENERGY & CLIMATE CHANGE!

WATER USE!RESOURCE USE & WASTE! WATER POLLUTION!

LAND/BIODIVERSITY LOSS!AIR POLLUTION!

NOTE: This list is not conclusive, but represents some of the key priority issues of concern across NGO, governmental, citizen, activist and for profit communities.!

Page 36: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

KEY ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS CATEGORIES!

36!

ENERGY & CLIMATE CHANGE!

WATER USE!RESOURCE USE & WASTE! WATER POLLUTION!

LAND/BIODIVERSITY LOSS!AIR POLLUTION!Particulate matter pollution!Atmospheric pollution!Indoor air quality!Hazardous substance releases!!!!

Fossil fuel combustion!Glacier/ice/tundra melt!Ocean acidification!Global warming!!!!!!!

Overfishing!Deforestation!Topsoil loss!Invasive species!Species & ecosystem collapse !!!!!Rare earth minerals!

Fossil fuels!Precious metals!Landfills!E-Waste!!!!

Hazardous substance releases!Acidification!Eutrophication!!!!

Drought!Ground water exhaustion!!!!!

NOTE: This list is not conclusive, but represents some of the key priority issues of concern across NGO, governmental, citizen, activist and for profit communities.!

Page 37: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 ! 37!

!!!

!

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS FAQ!

LENS: Predominantly consider through the lens of human utility (i.e. the parable: if a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?)!!

SCOPE: Traditionally consider issues in siloes – we manage water and air pollution as independent issues rather than interrelated systems for example!!

PROCESS: We have the benefit of scientific process of evidence building to “objectively” evaluate impacts (though not everyone believes in “science”)!!

MANAGEMENT: Central authority lacking – existing structures lack teeth and/or are non-inclusive (consider the history of UN climate negotiations, including what happened this week). Only have effective mechanisms (i.e. regulations) to address point sources of impact, when a clear case of cause and effect can be determined (i.e. tragedy of the commons). !!

PRIORITIES: Climate change & water shortages (water use)!

!

Page 38: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

CLIMATE CHANGE IS THE DOMINANT ISSUE OF OUR TIME!

38!

WHICH COUNTRIES ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR CLIMATE CHANGE? CLICK HERE FOR VIDEO!

SOURCE: The Guardian, September 23, 2014!

Page 39: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

CLIMATE CHANGE IS THE DOMINANT ISSUE OF OUR TIME!

39!

CLICK HERE FOR BETTER RESOLUTION!

SOURCE: Ecofys!

Page 40: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

PUBLIC INTEREST IN THIS ISSUE HAS WANED!

40!

!!!

!

Our priorities toward addressing these issues have shifted over time; interest peaks around pending regulation and natural disasters!

!

Trends demonstrate that U.S. citizens/residents lag behind other countries in terms of interest in climate change and other environmental issues!

SOURCE: Google Trends!

Page 41: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

KEY SOCIAL IMPACTS CATEGORIES!

41!

EMPOLYMENT !& WORKERS’ RIGHTS!EDUCATION!

HUMAN RIGHTS & JUSTICE! POLICY & ADVOCACY!

ECONOMY & FINANCE!

SOCIAL RIGHTS & SAFETY!

NOTE: This list is not conclusive, but represents some of the key priority issues of concern across NGO, governmental, citizen, activist and for profit communities.!

Page 42: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

KEY SOCIAL IMPACTS CATEGORIES!

42!

EMPOLYMENT !& WORKERS’ RIGHTS!EDUCATION!

HUMAN RIGHTS & JUSTICE! POLICY & ADVOCACY!

ECONOMY & FINANCE!

SOCIAL RIGHTS & SAFETY!

NOTE: This list is not conclusive, but represents some of the key priority issues of concern across NGO, governmental, citizen, activist and for profit communities.!

Economic prosperity!Resilient economies!Access to capital!Income equality!!!

Access to/universal education!Cost of education!Quality of education!!!!!!!!

Job creation!Unionization & representation!Worker safety!Minimum age requirements!Minimum wage requirements!!!!!Slavery !

Human trafficking!Sexual crimes!Discrimination!Free speech!!!!

Representation!Awareness of issues!!!!

Clean/safe drinking water!Housing!Public safety!Cultural preservation!!!!!

Page 43: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 ! 43!

!!!

!

SOCIAL IMPACTS FAQ!

LENS: Often addressed through the lens of policy and advocacy… sometimes to move the needle in the wrong direction (think of lobbying efforts over social issues)!!

SCOPE: Only have effective mechanisms to address point sources of impact (meaning you can attribute impact to a specific actor)!!

PROCESS: No benefit of scientific or coordinated process to manage impacts!!

MANAGEMENT: Similarly there is no central authority to coordinate efforts; Traditionally address issues in siloes, leading to redundancy in funding and management, and ineffective use of funds!!

PRIORITIES: Employment and job creation; measuring outcomes!

!

Page 44: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

2013 GAVE RISE TO UNREST AND INSTABILITY!

44!

!!!

!

Delays in feedback loops, civil unrest and natural disasters have caused new issues to arise around the globe !

“By the end of 2013, a record high of 51 million people were displaced forcibly worldwide as a result of persecution, conflict, generalized violence and human rights violations”!- The UN, Millenium Development Goals Report 2014!

http://www.ussif.org/files/publications/12_trends_exec_summary.pdf!

Page 45: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

INCOME INEQUALTIY IS A GROWING DESTABILIZING FORCE!

45!

Page 46: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

INVESTMENT IN SOCIAL IMPACT IS INCREASING, BUT HAS A LONG WAY TO GO!

46!

!!!

!

The number of funds and the amount of money invested in Sustainable and Responsible Investing (SRI) has increased over time.!

However SRI is often through the lens of cutting the bad rather than doing good (aka a negative vs. positive “screen”)!

SOURCE: http://www.ussif.org/files/publications/12_trends_exec_summary.pdf!

Page 47: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

KEY HUMAN HEALTH IMPACTS CATEGORIES!

47!

WATER & SANITATION!

MATERNAL & CHILD HEALTH!COMMUNICABLE DISEASE!

OCUPATIONAL & !ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH!

FOOD & NUTRITION!

NON-COMMUNICABLE DISEASE!

NOTE: This list is not conclusive, but represents some of the key priority issues of concern across NGO, governmental, citizen, activist and for profit communities.!

Page 48: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

KEY HUMAN HEALTH IMPACTS CATEGORIES!

48!

WATER & SANITATION!

MATERNAL & CHILD HEALTH!COMMUNICABLE DISEASE!

OCUPATIONAL & !ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH!

FOOD & NUTRITION!

NON-COMMUNICABLE DISEASE!

NOTE: This list is not conclusive, but represents some of the key priority issues of concern across NGO, governmental, citizen, activist and for profit communities.!

Water-borne diseases!Lack of vaccines!Managing disease spread!AIDS!Ebola!!!!!!

Drought & food scarcity!Access to food!Obesity!!!!!!!

Infant mortality!Prenatal care!Family planning!!!!!

Heart disease!Diabetes!Cancer!!!!

Trans-dermal exposures!Indoor air quality!Hard labor!!!!!!

Access to water!Clean water!Sterile sanitation!!!!!

Page 49: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 ! 49!

!!!

!

HEALTH IMPACTS FAQ!

LENS: For global health, started with a focus on tropical and infectious disease (mostly neglected conditions not in the wealthiest of countries) and has expanded to be more encompassing of broader issues!!

SCOPE & MANAGEMENT: People have been thinking about health systems for a long time, but funding in the sector has been siloed into specific disease/impact buckets (i.e. Gates foundation). No central authority in charge of health (the WHO has said they’re not a coordinating agency, in this recent Ebola outbreak)!!

PROCESS: Every place in the world handles health issues differently (which makes it difficult to manage international health concerns and transfer technologies)!!

PRIORITIES: !•  Global Health: Improving access, oversight, regulation and coordination!•  In US: Improving access, reducing spending, move toward more patient-centered

holistic care!

Page 50: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

HEALTH SPENDING AND ADJUSTED D.A.L.Y.!

50!

!!!

!

The U.S. spends more on health (as a function of GDP) than almost all other countries, but has a worse daily adjusted life years rate (DALY) rate than European countries, Australia, Canada, and Japan.!

And we attempt to export our methods & technologies to other countries. !

Page 51: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

MANAGEMENT OF GLOBAL HEALTH!

51!

!!!

!

The global north determines health priorities for the global south and funding is allocated based on these determinations.!

This leads to failures when importing fixes and/or myopic planning, causing often devastating outcomes (like the Ebola outbreak).!

SOURCE: http://gamapserver.who.int/mapLibrary/Files/Maps/ExternalResourcesUSD_2012.png!

Page 52: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

THESE ARE NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE BUCKETS!

52!

IMPACTS FOR ALL !CATEGORIES!•  Water Use & Pollution!!

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS!•  Habitat/Biodiversity Loss!•  Resource Use!

SOCIAL IMPACTS!•  Economy & Finance!•  Education!•  Employment & Workers’

Rights!•  Human Rights & Justice!•  Policy & Advocacy!

HEALTH IMPACTS!•  Communicable Disease!•  Maternal & Child Health!

•  Non-Communicable Disease!•  Occupational Health!

•  Air Pollution!•  Environmental !•  Health!

•  Food & ! Nutrition!•  Occupa-! tional!•  Health !

Climate !•  Change!

Page 53: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

BUT MANAGEMENT OF THESE ISSUES IS SILOED!

53!

Activism!

Mehdiganj citizens against

Coca Cola!

Corporate CSR!

Nike’s The Girl Effect!

Legislation!

Temporary Protected Status for

Immigrants!

Academia!

African Studies!

Industry Orgs.!

Factories in Bangla-

desh!

NGO!

The Ice Bucket

Challenge!

Page 54: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

MECHANISMS TO ADDRESS IMPACTS ARE NOT FULLY EFFICTIVE!

54!

!!!

!

COURT OF PUBLIC OPINON!!VOLUNTARY STANDARDS!!OFFSETTING IMPACT!!DIVESTING FROM IMPACT (Screens/avoidance, divestment, outsourcing)!!PRICE (Global/local market mechanism to internalize externalities)!!LEGISLATION/TAX (Global/local regulatory mechanism)!!!!

Page 55: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

WE LACK A SYSTEM-WIDE PERSPECTIVE ON THESE ISSUES!

55!

SYSTEM DELAYS: System delays are inherent in environmental, social, and human health issues, as many impacts such as drought, climate change, and poverty are cumulative rather than acute. Thus more immediate issues often consume both attention and capital from business, governmental, and NGO, and citizen/community sectors. !!

NON-HOLISTIC THINKING: Addressing these issues challenges actors to reconsider core system-wide beliefs, creating barriers to change from those benefitting from or comfortable with current paradigms.!

Page 56: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

OUR CURRENT SOCIO-POLITICAL PARADIGM HAS GIVEN RISE TO THESE MECHANISMS!

56!

!!!

!

1.0 ) STATE-CENTRIC (1 sector) > Hierarchy & Control! Traditional awareness!

2.0 ) FREE MARKET (2 sectors) > Markets & Competition! Ego-system awareness!

3.0 ) SOCIAL MARKET (3 sectors, conflicting) > Networks & Negotiation! Stakeholder awareness!

- SOURCE: Otto Scharmer, Leading from the Emerging Future!

Page 57: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

OUR GOAL: DESIGN FROM THE EMERGING FUTURE!

57!

!!!

!

1.0 ) STATE-CENTRIC (1 sector) > Hierarchy & Control! Traditional awareness!

2.0 ) FREE MARKET (2 sectors) > Markets & Competition! Ego-system awareness!

3.0 ) SOCIAL MARKET (3 sectors, conflicting) > Networks & Negotiation! Stakeholder awareness!

4.0 > CO-CREATIVE (3 sectors, co-creating) > Seeing & Acting from the Whole!

Eco-system awareness!

- SOURCE: Otto Scharmer, Leading from the Emerging Future!

Page 58: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

EVOLUTION OF ECONOMIC THEORY !

58!

FROM: “The social responsibility of corporations is to increase profits.” !– Milton Friedman, 1970!

!!TO: Businesses must reconnect company success with social progress. Shared value is not social responsibility, philanthropy, or even sustainability, but a new way to achieve economic success. It is not on the margin of what companies do but at the center. We believe that it can give rise to the next major transformation of business thinking.!– Michael Porter, Harvard, Author – Creating Shared Value!

!

$FOR PROFIT!

out to change the world!

$FOR PROFIT!

for… profit!

Page 59: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

HOW YOUR BUSINESSES CAN INTERVENE IN THE SYSTEM!

59!

2. DIRECTLY MITIGATE NEGATIVE !IMPACTS!

1. HELPS SOCIETY ADAPT

TO NEGATIVE IMPACTS

(CAUSED BY OTHERS) !

3. INDIRECTLY MITIGATE NEGATIVE!IMPACTS!

6. AND AVOID CREATION OF !NEW IMPACTS!

5. DIRECTLY CONTRIBUTES TO POSITIVE

IMPACTS!

4. INDIRECTLY CONTRIBUTES TO POSITIVE

IMPACTS!

Page 60: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

TAKING A SYSTEM-WIDE VIEW!

60!

DELAYS: System delays are inherent in environmental, social, and human health issues, as many impacts such as drought, climate change, and poverty are cumulative rather than acute. Thus more immediate issues often consume attention and capital from business, governmental, and NGO, and citizen/community sectors. !

•  CHALLENGE TO YOU: Can shorter-term value be derived from “adapting” to or “mitigating” long-term environmental challenges? Can you design for the emerging future?!

NON-HOLISTIC THINKING: Addressing these issues challenges actors to reconsider core system-wide beliefs, creating barriers to change from those benefitting from current paradigms. !

•  CHALLENGE TO YOU: Can you envision your team’s and company’s values to be inclusive of broader environmental/social values in a way where the environment/society as stakeholder is an inherent, positive force in your company’s ecosystem?!

How might this be realized in your business model? !

Page 61: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

TURING IMPACT ON ITS HEAD – METHODOLOGY!CHANGING VALUES FRAMEWORK (ADAPTED)!!1.  Define goals: Outline your desired financial, environmental, social and health

outcomes/goals. Be specific in terms of what social/environmental/health issues you think you might be able to address and how these can POSITIVELY relate to each other (these should inherently align with your company’s values & value proposition).!

2.  Determine preconditions: Via your systems map and through customer discovery, determining which preconditions need to be achieved to reach the desired outcome. Consider where tradeoffs might occur.!

3.  Define interventions: Evaluate the preconditions to see which leverage points are ripe for business intervention; build a hypothesis about which opportunity should your company/organization should engage in and test it.!

4.  Define metrics: Determine which metrics or indicators you’ll use to test your hypothesis, and ultimately to measure progress toward the outcome.!

61!

Page 62: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

Prepare a presentation – guidelines below:!•  Cover slide – describe your business concept concisely !•  Latest version Business Model Canvas with changes marked before and after !•  Market size (TAM, SAM, Target Market)!Total addressable: how big is the universe!Served available market: how many can I reach with my sales channel?!Target market: who will be the most likely buyers?!•  Propose 2 experiments to test elements of your business model, starting with the value

proposition and customer segments. Talk to at least 10 people in your intended segment. What constitutes a pass/fail signal for each test?!

Social/environmental values:!•  Define goals: outline your desired financial, environmental, social and health outcomes/

goals. !•  Build a hypothesis: by delivering your value proposition, what ecological/social values

are created/eroded and how does this effect the customer? (be specific in terms of what social/environmental/health issues you think you might be able to address; these should align with your company’s values & value proposition). (Note we will explore how to model and test these next week)!

NEXT WEEK PRESENTATION – FULL ASSIGNMENT!

62!

Page 63: Better by Measure: Two Tales of Disruption - Part Two (Class 4, SVA Products of Design 2014)

BETTER BY MEASURE | WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 25, 2014 !

LEAN & CUSTOMER DISCOVERY:!•  Value Proposition Canvas: Business Model Generation!•  Legal Zoom Kauffman Foundation Startup Environment Index 2012!•  Interviewing Users: How to Uncover Compelling Insights: Steve Portigal!•  Universal Methods of Design: Bella Harrington, Bruce Hanington. !•  DSchool Bootcamp Bootleg!•  Founder’s Dilemmas Noam Wasserman. Anticipating and Avoiding the Pitfalls

that can Sink a Startup!

THEORY OF CHANGE:!•  Theory of Change: A Practical Tool For Action, Results and Learning: The

Annie E. Casey Foundation!!ABOUT KEY ISSUES:!•  Millenium Development Goals! !!!

RESOURCES FOR FURTHER UNDERSTANDING!

63!