Behavioral Finance Pauline Shum Schulich School of Business York University
Dec 29, 2015
2
Agenda
1. What is behavioral finance?
2. Behavioral biases and their implications for investment beliefs and decision making
3
1. What is behavioral finance?
Relatively new school of thought Gradually recognized as a legitimate field in
finance in the 1990s
A marriage of psychology and finance It says psychology plays a role in
financial decision making Is it a surprise that we are human?
4
1. What is behavioral finance?
Cognitive errors and biases affect investment beliefs, and hence financial choices
Poses a challenge to the traditional idea that markets are always efficient
5
1. What is behavioral finance?
Why should we care?
To better understand our own investment behavior, and that of others set the right incentives for clients, pension plan design
To better understand asset management companies and active strategies that base their investment philosophy on behavioral finance
Even retail banking is talking to customers about it (e.g., CIBC Imperial Service: Investor Psychology 101)
6
2. Behavioral biases
Summary of well-known cognitive errors and biases, and their impact on investment beliefs and decision making
7
Overconfidence
Better than average: “I’m a better than average driver.”
Illusion of control “I won’t have a car accident.”
Overconfidence
As applied to investments, overconfidence may lead to excessive trading
“Trading is hazardous to your wealth” by Barber and Odean (2000)
Find that portfolio turnover is a good predictor of poor performance: Investors who traded the most had the lowest returns net of transaction costs
Mostly confined to one particular gender…8
9
Why don’t they learn?
Why don’t overconfident investors learn from their mistakes?
Self-attribution bias Attribute successes to their own ability Blame failures on bad luck
11
Narrow framing
Loss aversion may be a consequence of narrow framing
Narrow frame of evaluation Limited set of metrics in evaluating investments Myopic behavior even though investment is long-
term Obsessive about price changes in a particular
stock Can lead to over-estimation of risk
12
Narrow framing/loss aversion
Consequence:
Tendency to sell winners too soon, and hang on to losers for too long E.g., Nortel “If I haven’t realized the loss, then it isn’t yet a
loss.”
13
Myopic loss aversion
Example: Currency hedging Influenced by recent events or stick with
long-term view? Combination of loss aversion and
representativeness
14
Representativeness
Making decisions based on recent history, or a small sample size
Believe that it is representative of the future, or the full sample
Representativeness
May lead to “excessive extrapolation” Erroneously think that recent performance is representative of longer term prospects
Results: Investors chase past winners Overreacts to glamour stocks (e.g., Technology
bubble) Overreacts to bad news which may be temporary
(thus creating “value opportunities”) Creates short-term momentum, but long-term reversal
in returns
15
16
Representativeness Let’s look at performance of portfolio managers
55 21
11
9
14
21
12
12
10
55
Quartile 1998-2001 2002-2005 1998-2001 2002-2005
1
2
3
4
Based on a sample of 220 U.S. equity managers (Wood, 2006)
17
Representativeness
Another example of excessive extrapolation: Sample size
Erroneously think that a small sample size is representative of the population E.g. opinion of a car vs. investing in the car
company
18
Regret Avoidance
Leads to procrastination and inertia Status quo bias Good intentions but poor follow-through
Results in delayed saving and investment choices Defined Contribution Plans: A significant
number of accounts are kept in their default allocation for a long time
19
Ambiguity aversion
Sticking with the familiar Results in under-diversification Home bias, local bias Bias is more substantial if take into
account human capital
20
Impact on committee decision making
Lack of diversity in membership could pose a problem
Common knowledge syndrome: less willing to share unique or different information for the sake of social cohesion
It takes 16 similarly-minded committee members to generate the diversity of 4 different-minded members
Final Note Some empirical findings are more respected in
the profession than others More controversial studies: Stock market returns
affected by number of hours of sunshine, seasonal changes …etc.
More and more asset management companies are using the “behavioral finance” buzz word (mostly value strategies)
21