August 17, 2017 This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). Prepared by Subah-Belleh Associates for Liberia Strategic Analysis (LSA). Disclaimer The author’s views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the united states agency for international development or the united states government. Baseline Survey Final Report Compound 1-Edina Road Rehabilitation Project
63
Embed
Baseline Survey Final Report Compound 1-Edina Road ...pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00N4T7.pdf · Findings, Conclusion and Recommendation ... SBA Subah-Belleh Associates ... is the predominant
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
August 17, 2017 This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development
(USAID).
Prepared by Subah-Belleh Associates for Liberia Strategic Analysis (LSA).
Disclaimer
The author’s views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the
united states agency for international development or the united states government.
List of Acronyms and Abbreviations ....................................................................................................................... 1
List of Tables ................................................................................................................................................................ 2
MAP of Compound 1-Edina Road Catchment Area ........................................................................................... 3
I. Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................................ 4
II. Introduction......................................................................................................................................................... 7
2.2. USAID Program ......................................................................................................................................................... 7
III. Methodology ....................................................................................................................................................... 9
3.3. Survey Questionnaire and Enumeration ............................................................................................................ 10
Key Informant Interviews (KII) for Targeted Information ............................................................................................ 12
Focus Group Discussions (FGD) ......................................................................................................................................... 12
IV. Findings, Conclusion and Recommendation .......................................................................................... 14
4.1. Demographic and Social Characteristics ............................................................................................................ 14
Human Settlement and Population Estimate .................................................................................. 14
4.3. Transportation and Related Conditions............................................................................................................. 22
4.4. Standard Foreign Assistance Indicators .............................................................................................................. 24
Health .............................................................................................................................................. 25
Annex I: Statement of Work ................................................................................................................................................ 27
Annex II: Data Collection Instruments .............................................................................................................................. 31
Annex III: Communities Visited and Data Collection Sources and Numbers Reached ......................................... 52
Annex IV: Mapping Data on All Communities in the Catchment Area ..................................................................... 54
Annex V. List of Agreed Foreign Assistance Indicators ................................................................................................. 58
1
List of Acronyms and Abbreviations
ANC Anti-Natal Care
CSPro Census and Survey Processing System
FGD Focus Group Discussions
FRAMP Feeder Roads Alternative and Maintenance Program
Km Kilometers
KII Key Informant Interviews
LSA Liberia Strategic Analysis
NGO Non-Governmental Organization
SBA Subah-Belleh Associates
SO Site Observation
SOW Scope of Work
USAID United States Agency for International Development
USG United States Government
FTF Feed the Future
2
List of Tables
Table 1:Initial Household Sample Distribution ....................................................................................... 10 Table 2: Sample Distribution for all Data Collection Components ....................................................... 12 Table 3: Demography Characteristics .................................................................................................... 15 Table 4: Household Income and Source of Income ............................................................................... 16 Table 5: Estimated Daily Household Expenditure .................................................................................. 16 Table 6: Household Expenditure ........................................................................................................... 17 Table 7: Characteristics of Housing Structures .................................................................................... 17 Table 8: Household Ownership of Assets ............................................................................................. 18 Table 9: Shop Ownership and Type and Source of Goods Sold ........................................................... 20 Table 10: Means of Transportation of Goods by Shopkeepers ............................................................. 21 Table 11: Daily Income from Shop Sales ............................................................................................... 21 Table 12: Number and % of HHs by Income Generated from Fishing ................................................. 21 Table 13: Average Daily Traffic Volume by Vehicle Type ...................................................................... 23 Table 14: Volume of Traffic by Type of Vehicle and Day of the Week ................................................ 23 Table 15: Average Monthly Vehicle Maintenance and Insurance Cost by Type of Vehicle ................... 24 Table 16: US Government Health indicators and their Baseline Values ............................................... 25 Table 17: US Government Economic Growth Indicators and their Baseline Values ............................ 25 Table 18: Government Education Indicators and their Baseline Values ............................................... 26 Table 19: Selected Governance Indicators and their Baseline Values .................................................. 26
3
Map of Compound 1-Edina Road Catchment Area
4
I. Executive Summary
Background
USAID/Liberia is currently assisting Liberia address some of its road challenges. USAID’s assistance to Liberia’s
rural road sector is the Feeder Roads Alternative and Maintenance Program (FRAMP). The program is currently
working with four counties to expand their capacities to meet annual planning, budgeting, procurement, and
reporting requirements to access resources from the Government of Liberia’s dedicated fund for road
maintenance and rehabilitation. The four counties are Bong, Lofa, Nimba and Grand Bassa. The program “is
funded with a mix of infrastructure, Food for Peace, and Feed the Future (FTF) resources”
Program activities include food and cash for work, rehabilitation of community infrastructure, contracting of
Liberian firms for the rehabilitation of specific road segments in the four counties, and quality assurance provided
by FRAMP. The rehabilitation of the Compound 1 – Edina road is one of the initial projects to be implemented
through awards to local contractors. This baseline survey was commissioned to identify indicators for impact
measurement of the project. This report presents the findings, conclusions, and recommendations of the survey.
1.1. Methodology
A mixed-methods approach was used for conducting the baseline survey. This meant implementing a variety of
methods and tasks, as required and informed by the objectives of the survey. Prominent among the activities
undertaken was the conduct of a one-day reconnaissance visit to the road, followed by a mapping exercise by a
team led by a cartographer with GPS expertise, literature reviews, training of field staff, pre-testing of survey
and reports by other donors engaged in farm to market road rehabilitation and maintenance (SIDA, GIZ);
any other relevant data sources identified by USAID/Liberia
2. In brief meeting with USAID/Liberia technical teams including FTF, Infrastructure, Program Office M&E,
FRAMP, MPW
3. Familiarization visit to road site and meetings with MPW and other County officials
4. Task 1, Mapping including recruitment/training for mapping team and consultations with local and
traditional authorities in collaboration with MPW and FRAMP
5. Task 2, data collection plan. Draft and finalize comprehensive data collection protocol with data
collection instruments for household survey
6. Tasks 3 and 4, traffic counts and transport times/costs data collection (this can be done
simultaneously with finalization of the data collection plan using the mapping team).
7. Translation of data collection instruments into Bassa, if needed
8. Training of enumerators (who may include some/all members of the mapping team) in interview techniques
and data entry using computer-assisted personal interviewing (CAPI). The enumeration team must include
both men and women and should have previous experience with household surveys in rural Liberia
9. Field-testing of data collection instruments
10. Revision of data collection instruments based on field testing
11. Deployment of core team for data collection
12. Tasks 5, 6 and 7: data collection: household survey, KIIs, FGDs. The time required for data
collection in the field depends on the sample size.
13. Task 8 report drafting
14. Task 9 final report
Personnel Requirements
Key personnel for the baseline survey include:
1. Team Leader. Minimum of seven years of experience in social science research and data collection and
analysis in rural settings. Experience leading similar studies preferably in environments similar to Liberia. Fluent
spoken and written English. Excellent writing and analysis skills. Experience and capacity to manage a diverse
team under challenging field conditions. Knowledge of Liberian languages desirable but not required. Advanced
degree in social science desirable.
2. Field Supervisor/Quality Control. Minimum of a good first degree in social science or statistics. Four or
more years of experience with data collection and management in field settings. Excellent local and English
language skills. The position requires an individual who is meticulous and well-organized.
A CAPI specialist should also be considered for the team. The baseline may also require enumerators and
potentially a translator to apply the methods discussed earlier in this SOW.
Budget & Mechanism
The maximum level of funding is USD $86,000 subject to a proposed and detailed budget with budget notes.
LSA will partner with the successful offeror through a subcontract to conduct the study. The subcontractor
may be a firm from Liberia, the US, or a non-prohibited country, per LSA’s USAID Principal Geographic Code
935. Geographic Code 935 authorizes procurement of commodities and services from “any area or country
including the recipient country, but excluding any country that is a prohibited source”.
Deliverables
USAID envisions the following deliverables schedule for the study. All deliverables are subject to approval by
USAID and LSA
30
No. Deliverable Description Proposed
Completion
Date
1. • Draft inception report in Microsoft Word specifying how each of the
research questions will be answered, outlining the study’s methodology,
approach, limitations, data collection and analysis plan, and team roles and
responsibilities. The report should be 30 pages or less, excluding annexes.
Annexes must include, among others:
o Data collection instruments
o All training materials for enumerators
o Comprehensive quality control plan
o Detailed work plan
• Final inception report addressing all feedback, comments, and edits made by
USAID and LSA.
• In-brief presentation in Microsoft PowerPoint to USAID and LSA outlining
the research questions, methodology, limitations, team composition, and
work plan
TBD
2. • Matrix in Microsoft Word with preliminary findings, analysis, conclusions and
recommendations that directly and fully address the research questions
• Preliminary findings presentation to USAID and LSA in Microsoft
PowerPoint
TBD
3. • Draft report in Microsoft Word of no more than 30 pages. It should include
a 3-5-page standalone executive summary, description of the activity, a
limitation and methodology section, and sections answering each of the
research questions with findings, conclusions, and recommendations. The
report must use data visualizations, such as maps, graphs, tables, and
infographics. Findings should be specific, concision and support by analysis,
and recommendations should be specific and practical. The 35-page limit
does not pertain to annexes, which should include all maps, datasets,
transcripts, instruments, work plan, sample frames, etc.
• Final report addressing all feedback, comments, and edits made by USAID
and LSA.
• Presentation of the final report to LSA and USAID in
TBD
31
Annex II: Data Collection Instruments
Household Survey Questionnaire
Module A. Identification
No. Question Response
codes Response
A1 Date of interview DAY MONTH YEAR
A2
Cluster Number
A5 Village Name
A6 Household Number
A7 Enumerator Name/Code
A8 Reviewed by
INSERT SUPERVISOR NAME
A9 Reviewed by
INSERT TEAM LEADER NAME
A10 Data Entry by
INSERT CLERK NAME
A11 Data Entry
INSERT DATE
DAY MONTH YEAR
A12 Data Entry Checked by INSERT
NAME
A13 Data Entry Checked INSERT
DATE
DAY MONTH YEAR
32
Module B. Household Roster
No. Question Response codes Responses
ASK OF THE HEAD OF HOUSEHOLD OR ANOTHER
RESPONSIBLE ADULT MEMBER OF THE HOUSEHOLD.
B1
Hello. My name is _________ and I work for Subah-Belleh Associates
(SBA), a Liberian company based in Monrovia. You may have heard
that USAID is about to work on the Edina Road to make it better for
transporting people and goods. But USAID wants to know how the
improvement of the road condition (explain in simple English) will help
the people living in the towns and villages along the road, from
Compound 1 to Edina. This is because most people believe and have
seen that roads can bring many changes to people and their
community. When the road is good, people will come to buy and sell,
you will travel easily, people will come to your area and do things that
will bring jobs and schools, and health facilities, etc. and you and your
family will benefit. So, before the road work starts, we want to know
about your present condition so that when the road is finished and
you and others start using it, we can come back later and see how
your living condition will change.
You have been selected by chance for this survey and we would very
much appreciate your participation. The survey usually takes about
___ minutes. Your participation is voluntary and you may end the
survey at any time or decide not to answer a particular question.
Your answers will be kept confidential.
Do you agree to participate in the survey?
0 = No >> end
module
0 = Yes
B2
Do you have any questions for me about the survey before we
begin?
ANSWER THEIR QUESTIONS
33
B2. Total Number of Household Members: _____________________
MODULE B3. HOUSEHOLD ROSTER (HEAD OF HH OR RESPONSIBLE ADULT START TIME: HOUR MINUTE
Please tell me the name and sex of each person who lives here, starting with the head of the household. For our purposes today, members of a household are adults
or children that live together and eat from the "same pot". It should include anyone who has lived in your house for 6 of the last 12 months, but it does not include
anyone who lives here but eats separately. AFTER LISTING NAMES, RELATIONSHIP, AND SEX FOR EACH PERSON, ASK QUESTIONS 2A-2C TO BE SURE THAT
THE LISTING IS COMPLETE. THEN ASK APPROPRIATE QUESTIONS IN COLUMNS 1-13 FOR EACH PERSON.
WORK includes jobs in the formal and/or informal sector, full time, part time, or seasonal work that is done within and/or outside the home. Work includes, but is not limited to agricultural daily wage labor, off-farm daily wage labor, income generation activities, sale of goods produced or processed outside the home or at the home, homestead garden or farm (e.g., vegetables, eggs, fish, milk, livestock, artisanal goods), or petty trading. For this indicator, work does not include participating in cash for work, food for work, or conditional transfers and/or productive safety net programs. It does not include either caring for own children, cooking, cleaning or doing other routine chores for own household (e.g., fetching water, collecting firewood) or being involved in agricultural production solely for household consumption.
36
Module C: Housing and Amenities
# Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response
Code Instructions
Resp.
Codes
G
O
T
O
Sup
Please answer the following questions about the house or apartment you and your household currently live
in:
C1 Is this house/apartment:
1=Owned by you or someone in
this household with a mortgage or
loan?
2=Owned by you or someone in
this household free and clear
(without a mortgage or loan)?
3=Rented for cash rent?
4=Occupied without payment of
cash rent?
C2
Which best describes this building?
Include all apartments, flats, etc., even if
vacant.
1=A one-family house detached
from any other house
2=A one-family house attached to
one or more houses
3=A building with 2 apartments
4=A building with 3 or 4
apartments
5=A building with 5 to 9
apartments
C3 Is this house, apartment:
1=Owned by you or someone in
this household with a mortgage or
loan?
2=Owned by you or someone in
this household free and clear
(without a mortgage or loan)?
3=Rented for cash rent?
4=Occupied without payment of
cash rent?
C4 What type of housing structure
does your household live in?
1=Permanent (Concrete wall, floor
& metal roof)
2=Semi-permanent (Walls of dirt
bricks and metal roof)
3=Temporary (Walls of stick and
mud with straw/grass roof)
C5 About when was this building first
built?
C6 How many lots of land is this house
home on?
1=Less than 1 lot
2=1 lot
3=1½ lots
4=2 lots
5=3 lots
6=4 lots
37
7=More than 4 lots
C7
How many separate rooms
are in this
house/apartment?
Rooms must be separated by built-in
archways or walls that extend out at
least 6 inches and go from floor to
ceiling.
• INCLUDE bedrooms, kitchens, etc.
• EXCLUDE bathrooms, porches,
balconies, foyers, halls, or unfinished
basements.
Number of rooms
C8
How many of these rooms are
bedrooms?
Count as bedrooms those rooms you
would list if this house, apartment, or
mobile home were for sale or rent. If
this is an efficiency/studio apartment,
print 0".
Number of bedrooms
C9
How many of these
bedrooms does your
household occupy?
Number of bedrooms
C10
Which of these facilities does your
home contain?
(multiple response)
1=Living room
2=Bathroom
3=Kitchen
4=Pipe-borne water
5=Flush/pour flush toilet
6=Electricity
7=All of the above
8=None
38
Module D. Household Income, Expenditure, and Savings
MODULE D-I. HOUSEHOLD INCOME
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response
Code Instructions
Resp.
Codes
G
O
T
O
Sup
Now, I would like to ask you questions about the money you and your household receive and what you
spend it on. Please try to remember as much as you can.
D1
What are the main income sources
of your family?
(read all the options to the interviewee. 1
important, 2 less important, 3 least
important, 0 none)
•
Source Importance
1.Wage/salary
2.Farming
3. Fishing
3.Husbandry
4.Wood and wood products
5.Tourism
6.Trading
7.Rental income
8.Assisstance of relatives
9.Pensions
10.Poverty funds (State which
one…………………….)
11.Other governmental aids/assistance
(i.e. unemployment wage)
12.In kind aids from the government
(coal etc.)
13. Aids/assistance from NGOs
14.Allowances for elderly
15. Other (please specify)
D2 What is the average monthly
income of the household? •
D3 What is the average yearly income
of the household? •
MODULE D-II. POVERTY
D4 How do you consider yourself?
1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Lower middle-income level
4. Middle income level
5. Higher middle-income level
6. Rich
7. Very rich
MODULE D-III. HOUSEHOLD EXPENDITURE
D5
How much did your household spend on
food each day during the last week (in
L$)?
Day Amount in
L$
Avg.
Spent
One (1)
39
(Ask about the days starting with
previous day/yesterday continue
asking about days backward up to 7
days)
Two (2)
Three (3)
Four (4)
Five (5)
Six (6)
Seven (7)
D6
Did you or any member of your
household spend money to eat food
other than the household general meal
during the last seven days?
1= Yes 2 = No
D7 If yes, how much was spent in L$?
D8
How much did your household spend on
leisure such as beverages and other
recreation during the last week in L$?
D9
How much money did your household
spend on clothing for the last month in
L$?
D10
How much did your household spend on
transportation during the last month in
L$?
D11 How much did your household spend on
health during the last month in L$?
D12
How much money did your household
spend on education during the last school
year (in L$?)
Note: This include school fees, book bags,
copy books, pencils, uniform, recess, tutorial
classes, etc.
D13
How often does your household pay
rent for the dwelling you live in?
ASK HOUSEHOLDS WHO RENT (Q__)
1=Do not pay rent
2=Pay rent per month
3=Pay rent every six months
4=Pay rent per year
D14 How much do you pay in L$?
MODULE D-IV. SAVINGS
D15
Do you and/or any member of
your household engage in (or
have) savings?
1= Yes 2 = No
D16 How much do you save yearly?
D17
What do you and/or members of
your household do, or plan to do,
with the money you/he/she/they
save each year?
1 Engage in business
2 Build House
3 Buy other properties
4 Reserve for emergency
5 Bank for interest
6 Pay for children’s education
7 Other (please specify)
40
Module E. Household Ownership of Assets
MODULE E-I: BASIC HOUSEHOLD ASSETS
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response
Code Instructions
Resp.
Codes
GO
TO Sup
E1 Which of the below listed items is owned by you or any member of your
household?
E1a Bed 1= Yes 2 = No
E1b Mattress 1= Yes 2 = No
E1c Radio/Tape Recorder 1= Yes 2 = No
E1d Mobile Phone 1= Yes 2 = No
E1e TV 1= Yes 2 = No
E1f Chairs 1= Yes 2 = No
E1g Tables 1= Yes 2 = No
E1h DVD Player 1= Yes 2 = No
E1i DSTV 1= Yes 2 = No
E1m Cooking Utensils 1= Yes 2 = No
E1n Eating Utensils-Dishes (bowls, plates,
spoons, cups/glasses, etc.) 1= Yes 2 = No
E1o Water Containers 1= Yes 2 = No
E1p Refrigerator 1= Yes 2 = No
E1q Generator 1= Yes 2 = No
E1r Bicycle 1= Yes 2 = No
E1s Motorbikes 1= Yes 2 = No
E1t Car 1= Yes 2 = No
E1u House (other than the one currently
occupied) 1= Yes 2 = No
MODULE E-II: PRODUCTION ASSETS (OTHER THAN LAND)
E2 Which of the below listed items is owned by you or any member of your
household?
E2a Wheelbarrow 1= Yes 2 = No
E2b Sugar Cane Mil 1= Yes 2 = No
E2c Cassava Grinder 1= Yes 2 = No
E2d Rice mill 1= Yes 2 = No
E2e Power Saw 1= Yes 2 = No
E2f Tractor
MODULE E-III: LAND FOR HOUSING
E3 Does your household own vacant land
for housing? 1= Yes 2 = No
E4 If YES, how much land (in lots)?
E5
What type of ownership or access
does your household have to the
farmland?
1=Deed
2=Tribal certificate
3=Customary land
4=Inheritance
5=Rented
5=Squatters
6=Other (specify):
MODULE E-IV: LAND FOR FARMING
E6
Do you or any member of your
household has any agricultural
land or do farming?
1= Yes 2 = No Section
?
41
E7 How many parcels do you own?
E8 How many parcels do you
cultivate?
E9 What is the size of the parcel
cultivated (in hectares)?
E10 What is the ownership status of
the land?
1. I own and cultivate this land
2. I own but don’t cultivate this
land
3. I rent this land from
someone else
4. I rent out this land
5. I have a shareholder
6. Other (please specify
E11 What is the title deed status of
this land?
1. With title deed
2. Without title deed
3. Customary
4. Other
5. 999. I do not
6. know
Is the land irrigated? 1. Yes 2. No 999. I do not
know
E12 If cultivating the land, what do
you cultivate?
E13
How much did it cost to cultivate
all the crops you grow during the
last farming season (in L$)?
E14
How much of each product did
you harvest the last farming
season?
(Measure by 100-lb bag)
E15 How do you use the products?
(Multiple Response)
1. For subsistence
2. Selling at internal markets
3. Selling at external markets
4. Other
999. I do not know
E16
If products were used for both
subsistence and sale, what
portion (%) was set aside for
consumption and what portion
for sale?
Subsistence/Consumption:
______
Sale: _______
E17
What is the approximate value
received from the sale of
products harvested?
MODULE E-V: OWNERSHIP OF CATTLE AND OTHER DOMESTIC ANIMALS
E18 Does your household own any of the
following cattle?
E18a Goats 1= Yes 2 = No
E18b Sheep 1= Yes 2 = No
42
E18c Cows 1= Yes 2 = No
E18d Pigs 1= Yes 2 = No
E18e Chicken 1= Yes 2 = No
E18f Ducks 1= Yes 2 = No
E19 Are the animals your household owns
for:
1. Household Consumption
2. Sale
3. Both consumption and sale
E20
Please estimate how much does it cost
to take care of all of the cattle each
month?
E21
If sold from time to time, how much
did you receive, on average, each
year?
43
Module F. Household Access to Healthcare, Water, and Sanitation
MODULE E-I: ACCESS TO HEALTHCARE
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response Code
Instructions
Resp.
Codes
GO
TO Sup
F1
In the past month, did any of
your household members attend
a health facility
1= Yes 2 = No
F2 If yes, how far is that facility?
1=Less than 1 Km (Less than 12 minutes’
walk)
2=2-3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
3=4-6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
4=7-10 Km (About 2 or more hours
walk)
F3 How did the family member get
there?
1. Walk
2. Motorbike
3. Vehicle
4. Bicycle
5. Canoe
F4 How much did it cost to get
there (in L$)
MODULE F-II: WATER AND SANITATION
F5
What is the main source of
drinking water for members of
your household?
Protected Sources
1 = Piped into dwelling
2 = Piped to yard/plot
3 = Public Tap/Standpipe
4 = Tube Well or Borehole
5 = Hand pump, Protected Well
6 = Protected Spring
7 = Water from Spring
8 = Bottled Water
Unprotected Sources
9 = Unprotected Spring
10= Rainwater
11= Unprotected Well
12= Surface Water
(River//Stream/Canal/Irrigation Channel)
Other specify
F6 What type of toilet do you use
here?
1 = Flush or pour Flush Toilet
2 = Flush to Septic Tank
3 = Flush to Pit Latrine
4 = Ventilated Improved Pit Latrine
5 = Pit Latrine with Slab
6 = Compositing Toilet
7 = Bucket Toilet
8 = Hanging Toilet/Hanging Latrine
9 = No Facility/Bush/Field
F7 How does your household
dispose of its garbage?
1 = Use services of waste collectors
2 = Bury it
3 = Burn it
44
4 = Dump into Bushes, empty areas
nearby, or swamp
5 = Dump in river, lake, on beach
6 = Dump into drainage
7 = Dump at community dumpsite or
communal bin
8 = Other (specify):
9 = Don’t know
45
Module G: Market
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response Code
Instructions
Resp.
Code
s
GO
TO
Su
p
G1
How far do you or members of
your household travel to the
nearest market?
1=Less than 1 Km (Less than 12 minutes’
walk)
2=2-3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
3=4-6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
4=7-10 Km (About 2 or more hours walk)
G2
Do you and/or any other
member of your household sell
in the market regularly or
seasonally?
1= Yes 2 = No
G3
If YES, what commodities do
you and/or the member(s) of
your household usually sell at
the market?
1 = Food commodities (rice, vegetables, salt,
etc.)
2 = Other cash crops (cocoa, coffee, etc.)
3 = Local breweries (palm wine, cane juice,
etc.)
4 = Palm Oil
5 = Fish
6 = Handcraft
7 = Household provision (soap, hair grease,
etc.)
8 = Clothing
9 = Medicine
Other (specify)
G4 What commodities do you
usually buy from the market?
1 = Food commodities (rice, vegetables, salt,
etc.)
2 = Other cash crops (cocoa, coffee, etc.)
3 = Local breweries (palm wine, cane juice,
etc.)
4 = Palm Oil
5 = Fish
6 = Handcraft
7 = Household provision (soap, hair grease,
etc.)
8 = Clothing
9 = Medicine
Other (specify)
46
Module H: Media Exposure
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response Code
Instructions
Resp.
Codes
GO
TO Sup
H1
Do any member of your
household listen to radio
regularly?
1= Yes 2 = No
H2
If yes, which program do
you/members of your
household listen to?
Multiple response
1. Health program
2. Political program
3. Development program
4. Social program
5. Advocacy program
6. Agriculture program
7. Education program
8. Other
H3
Do any member of your
household watch TV
regularly?
1= Yes 2 = No
H4 If yes, which programs do they
watch most?
1. Health program
2. Political program
3. Development program
4. Social program
5. Advocacy program
6. Agriculture program
7. Education program
8. Other
H5
Do any member of your
household read newspapers
regularly?
1= Yes 2 = No
H6 Which paper(s) do you/they
buy?
H7 How do
you/they get it?
1. From transport driver
2. From travelers coming in
3. From marketers
4. From students who come for weekend
H8
How do you learn about the
local news? Please state the 5
most important channels in
order.
1. National television channels
2. Local radio channels
3. National radio channels
4. Local (county) press
5. National press
6. Internet
7. Posters
8. Brochures
9. Village/Community
announcer/meetings
10. Religious Leader/Place of Worship
11. Teacher
12. Neighbors/friends
13. Other – (please specify)
47
H9
Did you know anything about
the Compound 1-Edina Road
Rehabilitation Project before
today?
1= Yes 2 = No
H10 If Yes, how did you learn about
the project?
1. Local radio channels
2. National radio channels
3. Local (county) press
4. National press
5. Internet
6. Posters
7. Brochures
8. Village/Community
announcer/meetings
9. Religious Leader/Place of Worship
10. Teacher
11. Neighbors/friends
12. Other – (please specify)
48
Module I: Peace and Security
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response Code
Instructions
Resp.
Codes
GO
TO Sup
I1
What kind of crime is common in
this
community?
1. Stealing
2. Raiot/fighting
3. Murder
4. Rape
5. GBV
6. Armed robbery
7. Other (specify)
I2 Where do you go to seek redress
when these crimes are committed?
1. Community grievance committee
2. Community watch team
3. Community leaders
4. Trabal court
5. Police station
6. Civil Court
7. Others
I3 How far is the nearest police
station?
1. Less than 1 Km (Less than 12
minutes’ walk)
2. 2–3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
3. 4–6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
4. 7–10 Km (About 2 or more hours
walk)
I4 How do you go there?
1. Walk
2. Motorbike
3. Vehicle
4. Bicycle
5. Canoe
I5
Are you satisfied with the handling
of your cases when you report
them to the police station?
1. Very satisfied
2. Somewhat satisfied
3. Sometimes satisfied
Not satisfied
I6 How far is the nearest court?
1. Less than 1 Km (Less than 12
minutes’ walk)
2. 2–3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
3. 4–6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
4. 7–10 Km (About 2 or more hours
walk)
I7 How do you go there?
1. Walk
2. Motorbike
3. Vehicle
4. Bicycle
5. Canoe
I8
Are you satisfied with the handling
of your cases when you report
them to the court?
1. Very satisfied
2. Somewhat satisfied
3. Sometimes satisfied
Not satisfied
I9
Are there service providers in your
community providing services such
as:
1. Women rights advocacy
2. Child rights advocacy
3. Health training
4. Agriculture training
49
5. Awareness on immunization
6. Others
50
Module J: Peace and Security
№ Questions and Enumerator
Instructions
Responses and Response Code
Instructions
Resp.
Codes
GO
TO Sup
J1 Do any of your household
members go to the market? 1= Yes 2 = No
1
2
J2 If yes, how far is the market?
1. Less than 1 Km (Less than 12 minutes’
walk)
2. 2–3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
3. 4–6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
4. 7–10 Km (About 2 or more hours walk)
1
2
3
4
J3 How do they get there?
1. Walk
2. Motorbike
3. Vehicle
4. Bicycle
5. Canoe
1
2
3
4
5
J4 How much do they pay to get
there in L$
J5 Do any of your household
members go to the bank? 1= Yes 2 = No
1
2
J6 If yes, how far is the bank?
1. Less than 1 Km (Less than 12 minutes’
walk)
2. 2–3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
3. 4–6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
4. 7–10 Km (About 2 or more hours walk)
1
2
3
4
J7 How do they get there?
1. Walk
2. Motorbike
3. Vehicle
4. Bicycle
5. Canoe
1
2
3
4
5
J8 How much do they pay to get
there in L$
J9
Do any of your household
members go to the GOL
service center?
1= Yes 2 = No
1
2
J10 If yes, how far is the GOL
service center?
Less than 1 Km (Less than 12 minutes’
walk)
2 – 3 Km (About 30 minutes’ walk)
4 – 6 Km (A little over 1 hour walk)
7 – 10 Km (About 2 or more hours walk)
1
2
3
4
J11 How do they get there?
1. Walk
2. Motorbike
3. Vehicle
4. Bicycle
5. Canoe
1
2
3
4
5
J12 How much do they pay to get
there in L$
51
Module K: Perceptions and Expectations
K1. In your perception, what are the most important four problems (development) issues in your
community/village?
1. …………………………………………..
2. …………………......................................
3. …………………………………………..
4……………………………………………….
K2. How was your income status, standard of living when compared to 5 years ago?
1. Better 2. The same 3. Worse
K3. What is the reason for this?
K4. What do you think would be the benefits of the project?
1.For your family 2. For the village 3.For the country
K5. What kind of adverse effects can the project cause?
1.For your family 2. For the village 3.For the country
Thank you very much for your time.
52
Annex III: Communities Visited and Data Collection Sources and Numbers Reached
Community
Types of Data Collection Activities and Numbers Reached
№ of
Household
s
Interviewe
d
№ of
FGDs
conducte
d
№ of KII
conducte
d
№ of
Drivers
Interviewe
d
№ of Shop
Keepers
Interviewe
d
№ of
Passengers
Interviewe
d
№ of
Market
Stalls
observe
d
Days
of
Traffi
c
Coun
t
STRATUM
ONE
Little Bassa 22 4 4 7 6 7 1 3
Zoe Town 26 4 1 3
Edina City 21 4 2 1 3 3
Ndorkru 11 2
Gorr Town 23 4 3
Kros Town 17
Kpepus
Town 17
Joezon 14
Noryou 20 1
171
STRATUM
TWO
Xwaclakpoge
i Town 25
Central
Kingsville 28 5
Kpans town 15
Pitos Town 24
Tarrs Town 21
Varmah 8
121
STRATUM
THREE
Three
Houses 12
Barkar 14
Barlakor 19 1
Central Edina 3
Duncan
Town 7
Maleskore 3
Borbor
Village 5
Juahs Town 4 1
Troublegar
Village 3
70
Compound 1 2 23 3 19 2 3
53
GRAND
TOTAL 362 16 11 30 15 30 3 3
54
Annex IV: Mapping Data on All Communities in the Catchment Area
POLITICAL DEMORGRAPHY GENERAL SERVICE FACILITIES RELIGION
UTM GPS
COORDINATES
SETTLEMEN
T CLAN
DW
EL
UNI
TS
POPUL
ATION
HOUS
EHOL
D
DRINK
WATER
HEA
LTH
SC
HO
OL MILL S
POL
ICE
CHU
RCH
MOS
QUE
EASTIN
G
NORTHI
NG
1 LITTLE BASSA
SONEWEI
N 118 2378 137 Hand Pump Clinic
prim
ary No 3 0
365427.6
0 667066.69
2 KPAIN TOWN
SONEWEI
N 21 315 29
Running
Water No No No 1 0
368131.9
2 667528.41
3 JUAHS TOWN
SONEWEI
N 4 11 4
Running
Water No No No 0 0
369067.0
7 666694.26
4 GAYE TOWN
SONEWEI
N 9 35 10
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 0 0
369624.3
4 667650.00
5 TARRS TOWN
SONEWEI
N 21 95 25
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 1 0
371750.1
7 667086.53
6 KPORS TOWN
SONEWEI
N 10 45 15
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 2 0
372951.3
3 667668.54
7
WILLIAM
MISSION
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 9 90 23
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 1 0
372424.6
9 665621.11
8
GARJAY
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 3 11 4
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
372128.6
7 664712.56
9 SOMA VILLAGE
GBASOH
N 1 15 4
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
372335.2
5 664517.42
10 PITOS TOWN
GBASOH
N 11 58 29
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
372306.6
3 663384.52
11
CENTRAL
EDINA
GOWEN
GBO 9 50 14 Open Well
379857.5
6 655602.00
12 VARMAH
SONEWEI
N 20 66 22
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
370725.8
2 661089.88
13 SAND TOWN
GOWEN
GBO 18 92 18
Running
Water No No No No No
376638.6
1 657577.29
55
14
CENTER
KINGSVILLE
GOWEN
GBO 23 118 36
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
375868.0
6 658349.08
15
BENYONS
TOWN
WENZO
HN 10 41 11 No No No No 0 0
362213.5
7 672387.77
16 KROS TOWN
WENZO
HN 45 195 70 Pump/Water No No No No 1 0
364449.1
8 673367.93
17 JAHN TOWN
SONEWEI
N 13 96 23 Open Well No No No No 0 0
365882.6
9 673234.01
18 BEN LOGAN
SONEWEI
N 22 102 15 Open Well No No No No 1 0
366756.2
0 673408.63
19 SAYE TOWN
SONEWEI
N 18 105 22 Hand Pump No No No No 1 0
367910.3
3 673310.09
20
MYUAH
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 25 130 27 Hand Pump No No No No 1 0
369036.8
4 673639.09
21
OLD LADY
VILLAGE
SONEWEI
N 9 37 15
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
370084.7
0 674300.20
22
ROAD SITE
OFFICE
construct
ion site
office
366825.5
7 672802.79
23
JACKSON
VILLAGE
WENZO
HN 9 63 17 Open Well No No No No 0 0
365729.4
5 675370.63
24 GARANIE
SONEWEI
N 6 27 6
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
365516.8
5 675616.35
25
MASSA
VILLAGE
WENZO
HN 4 23 4 Open Well No No No No 0 0
365313.4
7 675926.39
26
JAYWEE
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 5 14 5 Open Well No No No No 0 0
366789.6
6 676146.31
27 JOEZON
SONEWEI
N 23 135 60
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
365856.7
7 677355.25
28
BOBOR
VILLAGE
SONEWEI
N 6 15 6
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
364160.2
3 671964.93
29 GBAH TOWN
SONEWEI
N 6 24 6
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
365428.0
0 672015.00
30 GORR TOWN
SONEWEI
N 50 194 75 Hand Pump No No No No 1 0
364743.5
1 671527.97
56
31
NORYOU
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 27 121 33
Running
Water No
prim
ary Rice No 1 0
366735.5
5 671539.98
32 ZOE TOWN
SONEWEI
N 65 408 117 Hand Pump No
prim
ary
Sugar
Cane No 1 0
369138.0
0 669614.00
33 ZEON TOWN
SONEWEI
N 20 163 30 Hand Pump No No
Sugar/Ric
e No 1 0
370437.9
3 670909.60
34
GARKONDO
VILLAGE
SONEWEI
N 6 22 11
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
370589.5
8 670663.70
35
GURKPAH
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 15 43 18
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 1 0
371646.9
0 669939.77
36
YORCEE
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 17 63 26
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 1 0
372052.0
2 669279.83
37
TROUBLEGAR
VILLIAGE
SONEWEI
N 4 8 4
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
370307.7
9 668203.23
38
CEEGAR
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 5 13 8
Running
Water No No
Sugar
Cane No 1 0
370605.1
1 668159.36
39 PAYTO TOWN
370585.2
1 669254.66
40 NDORKRU
SONEWEI
N 81 140 81
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
372718.2
2 660494.61
41 PLUNKOR
GOWEN
GBO 17 75 17 Hand Pump No No No No 1 0
377051.2
1 657255.5
42 GBAYU
SONEWEI
N 2
House is
always
closed
366825.6
7 672597.35
43 WOE TOWN
SONEWEI
N 6 24 8
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
372205.8
0 661336.52
44 BARKAR
SONEWEI
N 18 71 17
Running
Water No No No No 0 0
373338.9
5 659989.25
45
JOHNNY
TOWN
GOWEN
GBO 9 43 13 Open Well No No No No 0 0
374160.0
7 659272.97
46
DUNCAN
TOWN
GOWEN
GBO 11 38 11
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
375453.8
4 658588.81
47
NYENHEYAN
VILLAGE
SONEWEI
N 17 67 17
Running/Open
well No No No No 0 0
367758.0
0 664423.00
57
48 BARLAKOR
SONEWEI
N 14 80 16
Running
Water No No No No 1 0
368803.7
8 663342.46
49
THREE
HOUSES
SONEWEI
N 11 79 18 Hand Pump No No No No 1 0
365759.6
0 666589.65
50
XWACLAKPO
GEI TOWN
SONEWEI
N 44 284 44
Running/Hand
Pump No No No No 0 0
365034.7
1 667633.01
51
BARNES
TOWN
GOWEN
GBO 7 25 6 Open Well No No No No 0 0
374395.8
3 659799.21
52 GODBA
GOWEN
GBO 5 14 4 Open Well No No No No 0 0
374651.2
2 660125.29
53 MALESKORE
SONEWEI
N 12 46 9 Open Well No No No No 1 0
366074.0
0 666131.00
54 EDINA CITY
GOWEN
GBO 32 415 112 Hand Pump 1
2-
prim
ary cassava 1 2
380980.1
8 654906.15
55 GUES TOWN
LOVEVILL
E 9 50 11
Running
Water
371752.2
5 675197.04
56
BARWIN
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 14 127 17
Running
Water
366784.3
1 669933.97
57
SOMAYOU
TOWN
SONEWEI
N 14 67 17
Running
Water
368460.8
3 672004.08
58
SAYWLACON
VILLAGE
SONEWEI
N 8 39 10
Running/Open
well
370620.7
9 672560.17
59 KPANS TOWN
LOVEVILL
E 24 192 31
Protected
Well
372827.6
8 671736.15
60 TITOS TOWN 12 51 18
Running
Water 371611.5 673511.33
61
SOUCON
TOWN
LOVEVILL
E 34 170 40
Running
Water
371659.5
5 674345.99
62 WLAKON
LOVEVILL
E 28 208 36
Running/Hand
Pump
371579.3
1 671614.32
63 TAKPA TOWN
SONEWEI
N 21 160 47
Running
Water
369559.4
6 672280.97
64
KPEPUS
TOWN
LOVEVILL
E 36 250 70 Hand Pump
371973.6
5 672879.52
58
65
COMPOUND
ONE
SONEWEI
N 41 518 41
Running/Hand
/Open
365716.3
2 678203.03
1214 8654 1690
Annex V. List of Agreed Foreign Assistance Indicators
USAID requested LSA to select indicators from across the USAID/Liberia portfolio to measure the effects of the Compound 1 – Edina Road
Rehabilitation. The indictors will include standard F indicators and custom indicators. Based on discussions between LSA and USAID on May 11, 2017, the
Edina Road Rehabilitation Project Baseline Survey will take baseline measurements for the following indicators:
Indicator Origin Data Collection Method Comments
EG.3-6 Farmer's gross margin
per hectare obtained with
USG assistance
New and Updated F Indicator Household survey, per
Performance Indicator
Reference Sheet (PIRS)
Subcontract SBA will
measure through
household survey
questionnaire and
according to PIRS
EG.3-7 Farmer's gross margin
per animal obtained with USG
assistance
New and Updated F Indicator Household survey, per PIRS Subcontract SBA will
measure through
household survey
questionnaire and
according to PIRS
EG.3.2-19 Value of smallholder
incremental sales generated
with USG assistance
New and Updated F Indicator Household survey, per PIRS Subcontract SBA will
measure through
household survey
questionnaire and
according to PIRS
Prices of staple goods at the
market
Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
USD profits from sales of
select goods
Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
USD savings from sales of
select goods
Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
59
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Price of fuel Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Transportation cost for goods Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Transportation cost for people Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Frequency of student
attendance
Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Number of school supply
deliveries per quarter
Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Number of visits by
supervisory county-level
government staff
Custom indicator based on
Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will
develop a related question
in the household survey
questionnaire to measure
this indicator
Number of visits by supervisory district-level
government staff
Custom indicator based on Qualitative Assessment of Farm-
to-Market Road
Rehabilitation by LSA in August
2016
Household survey Subcontractor SBA will develop a related question