Top Banner

of 224

Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

Jun 03, 2018

Download

Documents

Scott Hendrix
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    1/224

    Soil and ealth Library

    This document is a reproduction of the book or other copyrighted material you requested. It was prepared on Tuesday, 6 November

    2012 for the exclusive use of Jason Heller, whose email address is [email protected]

    This reproduction was made by the Soil and Health Library only for the purpose of research and study. Any further distribution or

    reproduction of this copy in any form whatsoever constitutes a violation of copyrights.

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    2/224

    !"#$"# '(#)*'" +#($,-.#/(+0.$ .- ( /($1

    *'" -.2$)0$3 .- ",+

    45!0660(/ !(##"$ 4(#+6"57 888

    !"#$%&'( *+ ,'--.$/ 0(1+ 2 ,34"5&6.$& *.7 8'$% 95&-$543-.: 4; !$'7( ,34"5&6.$&

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    3/224

    9.:5#03'+ ; ? 4; @5""5#A @#$$.( B#$-".;/ 000

    C.A#$%&/ '$5D5(#" E3'-#-5'(&/ ".--.$&/ #(: "5-.$#$; A#-.$5#" 4; @.$(.$ F$6#$:/1'G;$5D6- H ? 4; @.$(.$ F$6#$:

    I"" $5D6-& $.&.$J.:+ *' G#$- 'K -65& 4''% A#; 4. $.G$':31.: '$ 3-5"5L.: 5( #(; K'$A '$4; #(; A.#(&/ .".1-$'(51 '$ A.16#(51#"/ 5(1"3:5(D G6'-'1'G;5(D/ $.1'$:5(D/ '$ 4; #(;5(K'$A#-5'( &-'$#D. #(: $.-$5.J#" &;&-.A/ 75-6'3- G.$A5&&5'( 5( 7$5-5(D K$'A -6.

    G34"5&6.$+

    0(E35$5.& &6'3": 4. #::$.&&.: -' !"#$%&'( *+ ,'--.$/ 0(1+/ M(. ,#$% IJ.(3./ *.7 8'$%/ *+N+

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    4/224

    R.# I.Q"#+ S(#T"6"#"7 UAVA

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    5/224

    9 .$+"$+,R.#"W.#) Q5 !"#$"# '(#) X0

    8$+#.)2F+0.$ X000

    EYI* 8 H'().W E6(5

    < V.$$0$3 +'" U(,Z > 0( R.#$16 'K @6' M(. C.#""; 0& V'. #(: 9'$'-6; #(: W6.5$ B';@.$(.$ #& M.:5G3&

    I( 0(-.$5'$ 95#"'D3. B.D5(&

    D H.$ ($) U.+'"# [#"3(#0.2, ($) Y6.$" DKX35.- 9.&G.$#-5'(

    ,#-

    ? V"#(06") >= 9'5(D -6. C5D6- W65(D I U#A5"; Y#(R.""5(D !#$&N51-'$2N51-5A

    V#1% U$'&- Y..-& V3(. B$;:.

    EYI* 88 &)2F(+0.$

    B \2+ +. 4"(+ +'" [(/" BK 9'7( #(: M3- 5( R#5(- T'35&

    8$+"#,"F+0.$< Y'-5J#-5'( #(: R."KZ5A#D. ,&;16'"'D; B$.#%5(D 9'7( -6. U5[.: C.#"5-;

    8$+"#,"F+0.$\ ];G('&5& W' RG'%#(.^ I *.7 B.D5((5(D 5( -6. B''% B3&5(.&& !#&-5(D MKK -6. N51-5A_& ,'&5-5'(^ U5$&- B$.#%-6$'3D6

    ] 9.$P"#,0.$ =< 0(-' !#"5K'$(5#

    8$+"#,"F+0.$ Y#&"'7 #(: C'D.$&^ ]3A#( ,'-.(-5#" #(: 9.-.$A5(5&A!'(J.$&5'( 5( B.J.$"; ]5""&

    F("5D6-.(A.(- T'&-

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    6/224

    K ^2",+

    IGG.(:5[^ I ,65"'&'G6.$_& FJ#"3#-5'('K -6. ",+ W$#5(5(D DB=

    *'-.& D]= I1%('7".:DA.(-& DKB

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    7/224

    R.#"W.#) B8 @FC*FC FC]IC9

    *'0, Q..Z +"66, +'" ,+.#5 .- /5 60-"A U2F' .- 0+ 0, 0$ /5 W.#),7 ($) 0$+'" W.#), .- /5 -(/065 ($) -#0"$), ($) F6.," (,,.F0(+", 0$ .&-/ (, +'"5+(6Z") W0+' +'" (2+'.#7 /5 -#0"$) 4066 4(#+6"5A

    Y, '" "X:6(0$,7 8 ).$`+ +'0$Z +'(+ +'" ,+.#5 .- /5 60-"7 /5 :"#,.$(6)#(/(7 0, P"#5 0/:.#+($+A *'" :(0$+"# [".#30( \`a""--" :2+ 0+ :"#-"F+65W'"$ ,'" ,(0)7 b!'"#" 8 W(, Q.#$ ($) W'"#" ($) '.W 8 '(P" 60P") (#"

    2$0/:.#+($+A 8+ 0, W'(+ 8 '(P" ).$" W0+' W'"#" 8 '(P" Q""$ +'(+ ,'.26) Q" .- 0$+"#",+Ab!'06" 8 '(P" ( :(,+7 8 (/ $.+ /5 :(,+A 8 #"F.3$0T"7 '.W"P"#7 +'(+

    :".:6" (#" 0$+"#",+")7 ($) ,0$F" ( ,+.#5 W066 "P"$+2(665 Q" W#0++"$7 8W($+ +. ,2::.#+ 0+, Q"0$3 :#","$+") (FF2#(+"65A

    8 (/ :(#+0F26(#65 :6"(,") +'(+ 4066 W($+") +. W#0+" +'0, ,+.#5A 8 '()#"() '0, Q0.3#(:'5 .- +'" :'06.,.:'"# S2)W03 !0++3"$,+"0$7 ($) Z$"W+'(+ '" W(, (Q6" +. W"(P" +.3"+'"# +'" ,+.#5 .- ( 60-" ($) +'"(Q,+#(F+0.$, 0$ +"#/, .- W'0F' ( 60-" +(Z", :6(F"A

    Y, 8 #"() +'#.23' +'" /($2,F#0:+7 8 W(, ,+#2FZ Q5 +'" c2.+(+0.$-#./ a0"#Z"3((#) +'(+ 4066 2,", +. .:"$ +'" -0-+' F'(:+"#A 8+ ,""/, +.

    :0"#F" +. +'" '"(#+ .- W'(+ '(::"$")1 b!'(+ .2# (3" $""), 0,")2F(+0.$A Y$) ,. +'0, 0, W'(+ '(::"$")1 [.) F'.," ( /($ W'. (6,.

    $"")") +. Q" ")2F(+")7 ($) ")2F(+") '0/ G$5J#-5&&5A./,. +'(+ '" /03'+ Q" (Q6" +. +"(F' .+'"#, -#./ '0, .W$ "X:"#0"$F"Ab

    8 +#265 )0) $"") +. Q" ")2F(+")A Y$) [.) )0) +(Z" /" ($) ")2F(+"/"@2$F.$P"$+0.$(6657 ($) J.$; :#0P(+"651 -.# ( 6.$3 +0/" $. .$"70$F62)0$3 /5,"6-7 Z$"W +'(+ ($5+'0$3 W(, '(::"$0$3A

    *'0, 0, W'(+ )0) '(::"$A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    8/224

    8$+#.)2F+0.$!'(J51-5'(& #(: 5:.#& 1#A. -' 65A/ &' -' &G.#%/ K$'A -6. &34&'5"+ ].6#: # G$'G6.-51 &;AG#-6; 75-6 -6. :#7(5(D &.(-5A.(-& 'K -6. #D./ 75-6-6. A'': 'K -6. :3A4 A#d'$5-;+ + + + ]5& 7#; 'K -65(%5(D #(: K.."5(D$.G$.&.(-.: -6. -$3. IA.$51#/ #(: $.G$.&.(-.: 5( # A.#&3$. -6. 76'".3"-$#ZA':.$(/ $#:51#" 7'$":+

    eS.'$D. R#(-#;#(# f'( @5""5#A V#A.&g

    8 -0#,+ '"(#) (Q.2+ .&- .$ ( #(0$5 (-+"#$..$ 0$ U(#F'

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    9/224

    F.$F"(6/"$+ .- /5 ,+2:.#@+'" (::"(#($F"7 $.+ +'" #"(60+57 .-(6"#+$",,A

    *W. W""Z, 6(+"# 8 Q"3($ +'" -0#,+ W""Z"$) .- +'" .&-+#(0$0$3A 45+'" "$) .- +'" ,"F.$) W""Z"$) 8 $. 6.$3"# '() 0$,./$0(A 8 $. 6.$3"#+(Z" :066, .- ($5 Z0$)A.&-0, ( +#(0$0$3 :#.3#(/ 0$ +'" "X:($,0.$ ($)+#($,-.#/(+0.$ .- F.$,F0.2,$",, W'0F' W(, -.2$)") Q5 !"#$"# '(#)0$ 9(60-.#$0( 0$

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    10/224

    Q" ,2,+(0$") 0$ ($ 2$+#($,-.#/") "$P0#.$/"$+7 (/0),+ 2$+#($,-.#/")#"6(+0.$,'0:, ($) 3#.2:,A *'2, '0, :#.3#(/ -.F2,", $.+ .$65 .$0$)0P0)2(6, Q2+ (6,. .$ +'" #"6(+0.$,'0:,7 0$,+0+2+0.$,7 ($) ,.F0(6 0,,2",+'(+ :#.P0)" +'" "$P0#.$/"$+ -.# 0$)0P0)2(6 F.$,F0.2,$",,A

    O.# (#" +'" F.$)0+0.$, -.# +#($,-.#/(+0.$ :#","$+7 0$ '0, P0"W7W'"$ :".:6" (#" '2$3#5A *'2, '(#) '(, 6(2$F'") ( :#.3#(/ W'.,"3.(6 0, +'" "#()0F(+0.$7 W0+'0$ +W"$+5 5"(#,7 .- )"(+' Q5 ,+(#P(+0.$ .$+'0, 36.Q"A

    8+ /03'+ Q" +'.23'+ +'(+ .2# c2",+0.$@W'"+'"# .&- /(++"#,j@'(, Q""$ ($,W"#")A Y$5 3#.2: W0+' ,. 6(#3" ($) #(:0)65 3#.W0$3 (F.$,+0+2"$F57 ($) W0+' ,2F' (/Q0+0.2, 3.(6,7 '(, +. Q" +(Z"$ ,"#0.2,65A!"#$"# '(#)`, 0$-62"$F" 0, .QP0.2,65 F.$,0)"#(Q6"A

    42+ +'(+ 0, $.+ #"(665 +'" c2",+0.$A !'"$ :".:6" (,Z7 (, +'"5 .-+"$).7 W'"+'"# .&-0, b-.# #"(67b 0+ 0, $.+ 0+, :#(F+0F(6 0/:(F+ .# :.+"$+0(6 (,( ,.F0(6 :'"$./"$.$ +'(+ F.$F"#$, +'"/A *'"5 /(5 "P"$ '.6) +'(+(3(0$,+ 0+A *'" c2",+0.$7 #(+'"#7 0, '.W .&-F./:(#", W0+' .+'"#

    :#.3#(/,7 )0,F0:60$",7 ($) #"6030.$, 0$ +'" F'(#+0$3 .- +'" '2/($ ,:0#0+A8, 0+ ( 6"30+0/(+" +'".#"+0F(6 F.$+#0Q2+0.$j 8, 0+ ( :#(F+0F(67 +"F'$0F(60$$.P(+0.$j 8, 0+ ( $"W #"6030.$j !'(+ ).", 0+ '(P" +. ,(5 (Q.2+ +'"

    '2/($ F.$)0+0.$j !'(+ ).", 0+ ). +. 0$,:0#"7 +#($,-032#"7 .# (+ 6"(,+"X:6(0$ '2/($ Q"'(P0.#j Y$) W'(+ Z0$), .- /"(,2#",7 W'(+ F#0+"#0(7F($ .$" -(0#65 Q#0$3 +. Q"(# 0$ "P(62(+0$3 0+j

    *'"," (#" 6"30+0/(+" c2",+0.$,7 ($) +'"5 F(/" +2/Q60$3 0$+. /5.W$ /0$) 0$ Y:#06

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    11/224

    +. /.FZ +'" :#.F",,A *. +'.," W'. +#0") +. :6"(," .# 0/:#",, '0/ .# +.F(+F' '0, (++"$+0.$7 '" W(, :.60+"65 0$)0--"#"$+@/"($W'06" 6"()0$3+'"/ 0$+. +'"0# .W$ ,:"F0(6 +#(:A Y+ .+'"# +0/",7 (, ,./" .- +'" 3#.2:

    Q"3($ +. b3"+ .-- 0+7b +. "/"#3" -#./ +'" $"+W.#Z .- ,"6-C)"F":+0.$ 0$+'"0# 60P",7 '" Q"F(/" 3"$+6" ($) F./:(,,0.$(+"7 "P"$ /.+'"#0$3A

    d" :2$F+2#") 0662,0.$,A d" 2$/(,Z") /.+0P",A d" :#.Q")#(+0.$(60T(+0.$,A d" 6(23'") (+ '5:.F#0,5A Y, '" W.#Z") W0+' 2, '")0,F"#$") F'(#(F+"#7 /.+0P"7 "P"$ 60-" ,+.#5 (6/.,+ 0$,+($+($".2,65A d"(::"(#") +. Z$.W W'(+ .$" W(, D'5(D +. ,(5 ($) 0//")0(+"652$)"#,+..) W'(+ .$" :5: ,(5A d" ,""/")7 /.#".P"#7 +. Q" (Q6" +. ,(5(6/.,+ ($5+'0$3 +. ($5Q.)51 +'"#" W(, $. )./0$(+0.$ 0$ '0,2$/(,Z0$3 .- -(k()",A

    H./"+0/",7 W'(+ '" ,(0) ,""/") F(6F26(+") +. "P.Z" :(0$") .#,'.FZ") .# ,2#:#0,") #"(F+0.$, -#./ +'" 3#.2:A Y, W" #"(F+")7 '"

    :.0$+") .2+ '.W "(,5 0+ W(, +. b:2,' .2# Q2++.$,Ab e"+ $.+'0$3 ($5.$"F.26) ). +. b3"+ Q(FZb (+ '0/ ,""/") +. W.#ZA *#(0$"", W.26) 5"667F2#,"7 W"":7 :#.+",+7 Q"F./" 0$)03$($+7 ,26Z@($) '" W.26)7F'2FZ60$37 6(5 Q(#" +'" b:(5C.--,b 0$ +'"," #"(F+0.$,A 8$ '0, (F+0.$, ($).Q,"#P(+0.$, +'"#" W(, ( F./Q0$(+0.$ .- W(#/+'7 ,"6-CF.$+#.67 ($)

    ,:.$+($"0+5 $.+ +. Q" (Fc20#") +'#.23' ,'""# )0,F0:60$"7 #":"+0+0.$7 .#0/0+(+0.$Ad" ,+..) 0$ -#.$+ .- 2,@+'0, +(667 ,6"$)"#7 0//(F26(+"65 )#",,")

    Q62"C"5") /($@0$ -266 P0"W7 -.# ,0X+""$ '.2#, "(F' )(57 +W.,2FF",,0P" )(5, 0$ ( #.WA O.+ .$F" )0) '" 6"(P" +'" #../ -.# -..) .##",+A O.+ .$F" )0) '0, (++"$+0.$ .# F.$F"$+#(+0.$ ,6(FZA d" '() P0#+2(665+.+(6 #"F(66 .- ($5+'0$3 ,(0) +. '0/ Q5 ( +#(0$"" ($) W.26) #"-"# Q(FZ +.+'0$3, ,(0) "(#60"# W0+' /0$2+" (FF2#(F5A d" #"/"/Q"#") W'5 "(F' .-2, '() "$#.66")f ($) '" Z$"W W'(+ W" +'.23'+ .2# :#.Q6"/, W"#"A Y+/0)$03'+ '" ,""/") (, F6"($ ($) W"66 :#",,")7 ($) (, -#",'7 (, '" '()

    Q""$ (+ "03'+ . F6.FZ +'(+ /.#$0$3A S0Z" /.,+ +'0$3, '" )0)7 +'0, W(,(6,. ( Z0$) .- A A A )"/.$,+#(+0.$A

    !"#$"# W(, 5.2$3@'" W(, +'0#+5C,0X +'"$@5"+ '" ,""/") (+

    .$F" ( F'06) ($)7 U"#60$C60Z"7 ($ 0//"$,"65 .6) ($) W0," /($ W'.'() "X:"#0"$F") "P"#5+'0$3 ($) ,""$ +'#.23' "P"#5.$"A 8$ +'(+ '.+"6 Q(66#../ '" F#"(+") ( F./:6"X :,5F'.6.30F(6 ,:(F"7 0$ W'0F' 8 ,"$,")( #../0$",, +'(+ 8 '() $.+ :#"P0.2,65 "X:"#0"$F")A

    8 W(, $.+ ,0/:65 5AG$.&&.: Q5 +'0, /($ !"#$"# '(#) ($) '0,.&-+#(0$0$3A 8 W(, /.P")A \$ +'" ,"F.$) )(57 +. /5 (,+.$0,'/"$+7 '","(+") .$" .- 2, .$ +'" ,+(3" Q",0)" '0/ ($)7 0$ -#.$+ .- +'" .+'"# +W.'2$)#") ($) -.#+5C$0$" .- 2,7 6") '0/ Q(FZ7 ,+": Q5 :(0$-26 ,+":7+'#.23' '0, Q0#+' +#(2/(A *. ). +'0, '" 2,") ( +"F'$0c2" W'0F' '"F(66") +'" b+#2+' :#.F",,7b :#.Q0$3 )"":"# ($) )"":"# 0$+. +'" Q.)065,"$,(+0.$,7 "/.+0.$,7 (++0+2)",7 ,+(+", .- /0$)7 ($) /"/.#0", .- +'0,0$)0P0)2(6A *'0, W(, ( /.,+ :.W"#-26 +'0$3f 3#()2(665 +'"#" W(,

    )0,:6(5") Q"-.#" 2, +'" +#2+' (Q.2+ +'0, +#(0$""`, 60-"A Y$) (, +'" +#2+'W(, +.6)7 +'" :#.Q6"/ P($0,'")A Y$.+'"# /($ 3.+ #0) .-@!"#$"#W.26) ,(5 b)0,(::"(#")b@( Q(FZ(F'" -#./ W'0F' '" '() ,2--"#") -.#-0-+""$ 5"(#,A Y 5.2$3 W./($ W(, #"60"P")7 (+ 6"(,+ +"/:.#(#0657 .- '"#F'#.$0F (,+'/(A

    *. /"$+0.$ +'"," 0$F0)"$+, /(5 /(Z" +'" +#(0$0$3 ,""/ /")0F(6.# :,5F'.+'"#(:"2+0FA *'(+ W.26) Q" /0,+(Z"$A !"#$"# W(, +#(0$0$32,7 (, '" '() ,(0) '" W.26)7 +. /(,+"# :#.Q6"/,A *'"," :(#+0F26(#

    :'5,0F(6 :#.Q6"/, '(::"$ +. Q" (/.$3 +'" /.,+ )#(/(+0F ($) "(,065)",F#0Q(Q6"A O.# '() !"#$"# F2#") ($5.$"A d" '() $.+ F2#") /5

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    12/224

    0$,./$0(7 $.# ( Q(FZ(F'"7 $.# ( F(," .- (,+'/(A I(+'"#7 '" F#"(+") (,0+2(+0.$@'" W.26) F(66 0+ ( bF.$+"X+b .# ( b,:(F"b@0$ W'0F' W"F.26) )"(6 W0+' .2# .W$ 066,A

    H. -(# ,. 3..)A42+ W'(+ 8 W0+$",,") ($) "X:"#0"$F") )2#0$3 +'" -.2# )(5, .- +'"

    .&-+#(0$0$3 (6,. )0,+2#Q") /"A 8 '() $. -#(/"W.#Z +. "X:6(0$ .#0$+"#:#"+ W'(+ W(, 3.0$3 .$A 8 F.26) '(#)65 Q"60"P" +'(+ (66 W(, (, 0+

    :2#:.#+") +. Q"A !'(+ !"#$"# W(, ,(50$3 ,""/") ( /0X+2#" .- +'")"":7 +'" .QP0.2,7 ($) +'" #0)0F26.2,A

    *'" .$65 /"+(:'.#, ($) 0/(3", +'(+ 8 '() (+ /5 )0,:.,(6 +.)",F#0Q" W'(+ 8 W(, W0+$",,0$3 W"#" #"6030.2,A 8 #"F(66") +'" 40Q6",+.#0", (Q.2+ +'" '"(60$3, (+ +'" E..6 .- 4"+'",)( ($) (+ 9(:"#$(2/Ae"+ +'" 3#"(+"# :(#+ .- +'" +#(0$0$3 W(, :'06.,.:'0F(67 $.+ #"6030.2,7 0$F'(#(F+"#A Y, ( '0,+.#0($ ($) :'06.,.:'"#7 8 F.26) ,"" b0$-62"$F",Ab 42++'"," '() $.+'0$3 +. ). W0+' 0+7 #"(665A *'0, /($ !"#$"# '(#) ,:.Z"b(, .$" '(P0$3 (2+'.#0+5 ($) $.+ (, +'" ,F#0Q",Ab d" W(, ( b/($ .-Z$.W6")3"AbM$ 7#& 6.h U5 W.#6) Q"3($ +. Q#0,+6" W0+' c2",+0.$/(#Z,A 9.$+#()0F+.#5 c2",+0.$, Q./Q(#)") /"A d.W F.26) +'0, Q"'(::"$0$3j !(, 8 +'" P0F+0/ .- /(,, '5:$.,0,j V0) +'0, /($`, :.W"#

    60" 0$ /5 .W$ $(0P"+"j d.W F.26) 0+ Q" +'(+ 8 '() $"P"# '"(#) .-($5+'0$3 60Z" +'0, Q"-.#"j 8, +'0, -#(2)j d.W F.26) ,2F' ( :"#,.$ Q").0$3 W'(+ '" ,""/") +. Q" ).0$3j !(, '" ( F'(#6(+($j 8- +'0, W(,#"(67 0+ W(, 0$F#")0Q65 0/:.#+($+A Y$) 0- 0+ W(, ( -#(2)7 '.W F.26) 8 Q"-(660$3 -.# 0+j !'. W(, +'0, /.,+ 0/:#.Q(Q6" :"#,.$7 +'0, g.'$$5Y::6","") .- F.$,F0.2,$",,7 +'0, b+#($,-.#/"#bj

    Y, +'" +W. W""Z"$), .- +'" +#(0$0$3 W"$+ Q57 8 3#()2(665 Q"3($ +. :0FZ 2: Q0+, ($) :0"F", .- 0$-.#/(+0.$ (Q.2+ '0/A R0#,+ (Q.2+ ",.+"#0F)0,F0:60$", +'(+ '" '() ,+2)0")A *'"$ ,./".$" +.6) /" +'(+ '" W(, (-.#/"# F(# ,(6",/($A Y$ ",.+"#0F )0,F0:60$" 0$)"")l S(+"#7 +.W(#) +'""$) .- +'" ,"F.$) W""Z"$)7 8 '"(#) +'(+ '0, #"(6 $(/" W(, g(FZI.,"$Q"#37 ($) +'(+ '" W(, -#./ E'06()"6:'0(A 8 '"(#) +(6", (Q.2+ '0,

    :(,+7 b+'0FZ W0+' W0P", ($) $"-(#0.2, )""),Ab R0$(665 8 W(, +.6) +'(+ '"

    '() Q"F./" "$603'+"$") W'06" )#0P0$3 .$" )(5 .$ ( 9(60-.#$0(-#""W(5A I !#"5K'$(5# K$..7#;i Y$) W'(+7 -.# +'(+ /(++"#7 (Q.2+ +'.," )0,F0:60$",7 ,.CF(66")7 +'(+

    '() ")2F(+")7 /.6)")7 ,'(:") '0/ )2#0$3 ( /.,+ :"F260(# ,:0#0+2(6.)5,,"51 U(XW"66 U(6+T ($) 9(#6 I.3"#,7 i"$7 H2Q2)7 HF0"$+.6.357'5:$.,0,7 [",+(6+7 "$F.2$+"#A !'(+ ( F./Q0$(+0.$l 9($ ($5 .- 0+ #"(665

    Q" +(Z"$ ,"#0.2,65j

    U.,+ .- +'"," c2",+0.$,7 8 -.2$)7 F.26) Q" 30P"$ ,+#(03'+-.#W(#)($,W"#,A e"+ +'"#" (#" ,./" .Q,+(F6", 0$ +'" W(5 .- ()"c2(+" ($,W"#,+. c2",+0.$, (Q.2+ !"#$"# '(#) ($) (Q.2+ .&-+U($5 .- +'",".Q,+(F6", ,+"/ -#./ .2# .W$ 3"$+060+5A *'"5 F62,+"# 0$ +'" F.$+#(,+70)"$+0-0") 6.$3 (3. Q5 +'" 3#"(+ Y/"#0F($ :'06.,.:'"# [".#3"

    H($+(5($(7 Q"+W""$ +'" b3"$+""6 +#()0+0.$b 0$ Y/"#0F($ :'06.,.:'5($) +'" ,:0#+ .- b(33#",,0P" "$+"#:#0,"Ab < Y, H($+(5($( :2+, 0+7 b*'"Y/"#0F($ !066 0$'(Q0+, +'" ,Z5,F#(:"#f +'" Y/"#0F($ 8$+"66"F+ 0$'(Q0+,+'" F.6.$0(6 /($,0.$Ab *'" 3"$+""6 +#()0+0.$ ($) +'" F.6.$0(6 /($,0.$#":#","$+ +'" :.60+" 5"+ F"$,.#0.2,7 F.$P"$+0.$(6 5"+ :#"+"$+0.2,7+"##0Q65 "(#$",+7 ,+"#06"7 ($) 2$'(::5 Y/"#0F($ 0$+"66"F+ ($) 0+,(3.$0T") F.$,F0"$F"A R"W Y/"#0F($ :'06.,.:'"#, '(P" Q""$ (Q6" +.W#"$F' +'"/,"6P", -#"" -#./ +'0, +#()0+0.$7 W'0F' H($+(5($( ,"", (,+'" F'0"- "$"/5 .- P03.# ($) 0/(30$(+0.$ 0$ F26+2#(6 60-"A *'2, '(#)7($) '0, :'06.,.:'0F(6 ")2F(+0.$7 '"6) :(#+0F26(# -(,F0$(+0.$ -.# /" (, (

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    13/224

    :'06.,.:'"# ($) ")2F(+.#A R.# 8 W(, ( 3"$+""6 :'06.,.:'"#7 ($) '0, W(,P0+(6 ($) 60P0$3 :'06.,.:'57 :'06.,.:'5 0$ +'" #(WA

    !"#$"# '(#) 0,7 0$)"")7 ($5+'0$3 Q2+ 3"$+""6A 8$ +'" W'.6" .&-(::#.(F'7 $.+ h2,+ 0$ +'" +#(0$0$37 +'"#" 0, ( /.FZ0$37 ($ 0##"P"#"$F"7 (,(+0#"7 ( '2/.#7 #"/0$0,F"$+ .- S"$$5 4#2F"A &P"#5Q.)5 ($)"P"#5+'0$3 0, 2: -.# c2",+0.$1 +'.," W'. (#" +#50$3 +. Q" b'0:b (#"F'(66"$3") h2,+ (, /2F' (, +'.," W'. (#" b,+#(03'+Ab *'" +#(0$"#bW.#Z, F6.," +. +'" /(+"#0(6Ab ["$+""6 Y/"#0F($ F./")0($, ,2F' (,4.Q d.:" /(0$+(0$") ( )0,+($F" -#./ +'" +'0$3, (+ W'0F' +'"5 :.Z")-2$f +'"5 )0) $.+ 0$+#2)"A *'"5 #"6"(,") ($X0"+5 Q2+ )0) $.+ F./" F6.,""$.23' +. +'" Q.$" +. 3"$"#(+" /.#"A *'" .&-+#(0$0$3 0, $.+ (+ (66 4.Qd.:"1 0+ 0, P"#5 /2F' S"$$5 4#2F"@'03'65 0$+#2,0P"7 ($) P"#5b).W$Ab

    '(#) 0, (6,. +'" P"#5 "/Q.)0/"$+ .- Y/"#0F($ !066A 8$+#2,0P"($) (33#",,0P"65 "$+"#:#0,0$37 '0, :'06.,.:'5 '(, Q""$ F(66") .$" .-b-0$(6 F(2,"7b 0$ W'0F' W.#6), (#" F#"(+") ($) 3.P"#$") Q5 0$+"$+0.$73.(6,7 ($) :2#:.,",f 0$ W'0F' ($ 0)"( 0, +'" /.,+ :.W"#-26 +'0$3 0$ +'"2$0P"#,"A 8- +'" 3"$+""6 +#()0+0.$ '(, $"P"# #"(665 2$)"#,+..) Y/"#0F($!0667 '.W #"()065 F($ 0+ F./:#"'"$) .# ($(65T" ( /""+0$3@,2F' (,

    !"#$"# '(#) 0,@Q"+W""$ Y/"#0F($ !066 ($) M$5.(-#" 8$+"66"F+j*. ($,W"# (66 +'"," c2",+0.$, 0$ +"#/, .- +'" Z$.W$ c2($+0+0", .-+'" 3"$+""6 +#()0+0.$ 0,7 +'"$7 -(# -#./ "(,5A *'0, /($ ($) +'",")0,F0:60$", (#"7 -.# +'" 3"$+""6 +#()0+0.$7 2$Z$.W$ c2($+0+0",7 ($) (#"+'"#"-.#" /5,+"#0",A !'"#" +'"#" 0, /5,+"#5 +'"#" 0, -($+(,5f ($) W'"#"+'"#" 0, -($+(,5 +'"#" 0, Q"60"-A d"$F" ,2F' c2",+0.$, +"$) +. Q"($,W"#") 0$ +"#/, .- F./:"+0$3 Q"60"-,1 ,./" Q"60"P" +'(+ '(#) 0, (,(0$+f .+'"#,7 +'(+ '" 0, +'" /.,+ Q6(+($+ -#(2)A

    '(#)7 '.W"P"#7 ).", $.+ Q"60"P" 0$ Q"60"-A*'0, Q..Z (0/, +. :"$"+#(+" Q"60"- Q5 :#","$+0$3 +'(+ "X:"#0"$F"

    W'0F' 0, F(:+2#") 0$ ( 60-" ,+.#5A 8+ +"66, +'" ,+.#5 .- ( #.32" 3"$02, ($)Y/"#0F($ .#030$(6 W'.," :"#,.$7 60-"7 ")2F(+0.$7 :#.3#(/7 (#" (66 (+0,,2"A 8+ 0, +'" ,+.#5 .- '(#)`, 60-"7 ")2F(+0.$7 ($) +#($,-.#/(+0.$7 ($)

    +"66, '.W ( :..# Q.5 -#./ E'06()"6:'0(7 ( F(# ,(6",/($ $(/") g(FZI.,"$Q"#37 ( 60(#7 ($ 0/:.,+.#7 ($) ( W0-"C)","#+"#7 3.+ +. +'(+9(60-.#$0( -#""W(51 '.W '" Q"F(/" ( /($ .- 0$+"3#0+5 ($)F./:(,,0.$A 8+ 0, (6,. ( 2$0P"#,(6 ,+.#5 .- +'" ,"(#F' -.# +#2" 0)"$+0+5($) -.# H"6-A

    @+ @+ B#$-".;/ 000 ,5.:A'(- ,5(.& Y'(-1"#5$Z M#%"#(:!#"5K'$(5#

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    14/224

    !"#$"# '(#)

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    15/224

    EYI* 8 H'().W E6(5

    M( #"" A#--.$& 'K K#1- 0 #A G.$K.1-"; 6'(.&-^ 0 1#( &-#-. :#-.&/ #1-& 'K-$.#&'(/ + + + .-1+/ 75-6 #4&'"3-. J.$#15-;+ B3- '(1. 0 &-#$- 1'(K.&&5(D -6.76;Z#(:Z76.$.K'$. 'K A; Q"'(P0.2# f#& '(. 5& .[G.1-.: -' :' 5( #4''%g/ 0 4.1'A. &' .(-.$-#5(.: 4; -6. G.$&'(#" :$#A# 'K 5- #"" -6#-.J.$;-65(D 0 G3- :'7( 6#& # 7'(:.$K3" #0$3'K -$3-6^ 0 K.." A;&."K

    D$'75(D K$'A # G#$-513"#$ G.$&'( 5(-' # 3(5J.$" :.&5D(+ e*5D." 9.((5&/ 9(#), .- 8)"$+0+5

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    16/224

    \O& V.$$0$3 +'" U(,Z T5%. M.:5G3&/ 7. "5J. 5( 5D('$#(1. 'K -6. :.&5$.& -6#- 'KK.(: A'$#"5-;/

    -6. :.&5$.& -6#- (#-3$. 6#& K'$1.: 3G'( 3&/ #(: #K-.$ -6.5$ 3(J.5"5(D 7.A#; G$.K.$ -' #J.$- '3$ D#L. K$'A -6. &1.(.& 'K 165":6'': eR5DA3(: U$.3:

    0* RFIC!] MU @]M M*F CFITT8 0R *'0, 0, ( ,+.#5 (Q.2+ +#2" ($) -(6," 0)"$+0+57 ($) (Q.2+ W'. "(F' .- 2,#"(665 0,A 8+ 0, F.2F'") 0$ +'" -.#/ .- +'" 60-" '0,+.#5 .- ,./".$" $(/")!"#$"# '(#)7 ($ 0/:.,+.# Q5 )",+0$5 ($) Q5 F'.0F"7 W'. W"$+ .$ (-(+"-26 h.2#$"5 .- ,"6-C)0,F.P"#5A

    Y$ 0/:.,+.# 0, ,./".$" W0+' ( -0F+0+0.2, :(,+A *'" -0#,+ +'0$3 +.6"(#$ .$ +'" #.() +. .$"`, .W$ +#2" ,"6- 0, +'(+ .$" 0, $.+ W'. .$"+'0$Z, .$" 0,A &(F' :"#,.$7 W0+'.2+ "XF":+0.$7 '(, ( -0F+0+0.2, :(,+f

    "(F' .- 2, 0,7 :#"F0,"657 ($ 0/:.,+.#A8$ ,"++0$3 .-- 0$ ,"(#F' .- +#2" 0)"$+0+57 .$" ,+":, 0$+. ( 6(Q5#0$+'7( /(T"7 ( +2$$"6 .- 6.P"7 ( '(66 .- /0##.#,7 ( )"#"60F+ 3#(P"5(#)7 ( 6.$3C$"36"F+") (#F'".6.30F(6 ,0+"A !'(+"P"# /"+(:'.# .$" 2,",7 :(#+ .- +'"+(,Z 0, +. 2$F.P"# ($) +. F.$-#.$+ .$"`, (FF2/26(+") /(,Z,7 )0,+.#+")0/(3",7 /26+0:6" -(6," 0)"$+0+0", (+ F#.,,C:2#:.,",A \$" /2,+ :""6(W(5 $.+ .$65 +'" /(,Z, .$" Z$.W, ,. W"667 +'.," +'(+ .$" +'0$Z, .$"0, W"(#0$3 $.W7 Q2+ ( '.,+ .- .+'"# /(,Z,@+'.," +'.23'+ .- ($) +'.,"$"P"# F.$,0)"#")7 $"P"# "P"$ 0/(30$")@+'(+ .$" W"(#, 0$ +'" F.2#,".- 60-"A U.,+ .- +'" /(,Z, W" W"(# '(P" Q""$ +'"#" 6.$3"# +'($ W" F($#"/"/Q"#f W" Q"F(/" 0/:.,+.#, 0$ F'06)'..)A Y$) W" F.$+0$2" +.W"(# +'"/ +'#.23'.2+ .2# 60P",A E(#().X0F(6657 (6+'.23' W" Q"c2"(+'.2# /(,Z, 60Q"#(665 +. .2# F'06)#"$7 W" (6,. W"(# +'"/ -0#/65 +. .2#

    3#(P",AY/.$3 +'.," .Q,+(F6", 650$3 0$ +'" W(5 .- W'. W" #"(665 (#"7

    :#"P"$+0$3 2, -#./ "X:.,0$3 .2# -(6," 0)"$+0+0", ($) 2$F.P"#0$3 .2#+#2" 0)"$+0+57 0, ( ,"$+0/"$+(6 ($) #./($+0F $.+0.$ (Q.2+ +'" :(,+7 0$

    :(#+0F26(#7 (Q.2+ F'06)'..)7 +'(+ +0/" W'"$ +'" /.,+ 0$+#(F+(Q6"7 +'"/.,+ 2$50"6)0$3 .- (66 -(6," 0)"$+0-0F(+0.$,@0)"$+0-0F(+0.$, W0+' .2#.W$ :(#"$+,@W"#" 6(0) ).W$ 0$ .2# :,5F'",A G$)"#$"(+' +'.,","$+0/"$+(6 F'06)'..) ,F"$",7 +'.," .6) ($"F).+", ,""/0$365 ,.2$0/:.#+($+ ($) 0$,03$0-0F($+ 0$ +'"/,"6P",7 0, +'" )#(/( .- +'").$$0$3 .- +'" /(,ZA

    VMF I*9 9MCMW]8 I*9 W]F0C BM8 bU($ 0, P06"7 Q2+ :".:6" (#" W.$)"#-26Ab *'0, +'.23'+ -62++"#") +'#.23'/5 /0$) (, 8 W(, ,0++0$3 W0+' g." ($) V.#.+'5 I.,"$Q"#3 (#.2$) +'"0#)0$0$3C#../ +(Q6" 0$ E65/.2+' U""+0$37 ( ,2Q2#Q .- E'06()"6:'0(A 8'() Q""$ +(6Z0$3 W0+' +'"/7 -0#,+ ,":(#(+"657 +'"$ +.3"+'"#7 -.# ( W""ZA8$ -#.$+ .- 2, .$ +'" +(Q6" W(, ( :06" .- :'.+.3#(:', +'(+ V.#.+'5 '()#..+") .2+ .- ,"P"#(6 (6Q2/, ($) )#(W"#,A O.W +'" ,+.#5 W(, F./0$3

    Q(FZ (3(0$7 (, V.#.+'5 .# g." 0)"$+0-0") "(F' :'.+.3#(:' ($) +'"/"/.#5 +'(+ W"$+ W0+' 0+A

    Y, ,'" :0FZ") 2: ($.+'"# :'.+. .- ( ,/060$3 Q(Q5 W0+' Q6.$)F2#6,7 :6(50$3 (+ +'" Q"(F'7 V.#.+'5 F.$+0$2") '"# ,+.#5 .- !"#$"#`,

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    17/224

    Q0#+'A@.$(.$_& Q0#+'A H0$F"

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    18/224

    "/Q#(F") '"# 0$+. +'" -(/065 ($5W(5A *'" 96(2,.$, W"#" ( 60++6",6.W"#A b!'"$ 8 ,+(#+") 3.0$3 .2+ W0+' g."7b V.#.+'5 "X:6(0$")7 b/5/.+'"# W(#$") /" +'(+ +'0, W(,$`+ 3.0$3 +. W.#Z .2+A 42+ 8 W(,)"+"#/0$") +'(+ 0+ W.26)Ab

    *'"5 W"#" /(##0") .$ Y232,+ DN7 >A 45 "(#65 ?7 +'"/(##0(3" W(, 0$ +#.2Q6"7 ($) g." ($) V.#.+'5 ,":(#(+") -.# ( 5"(#A&P"$+2(665 +'"5 W"#" #"F.$F06") ($) V.#.+'5 Q"F(/" :#"3$($+A *'(++"#/0$(+") +(6Z .- )0P.#F"7 ($) +'" /(##0(3" ,2#P0P")A

    V.#.+'5 ($) g." '() Q""$ /(##0") Q5 ( #(QQ0 0$ ( ,5$(3.32"7 ($)V.#.+'5 Q"3($ )./",+0F 60-" (, +'" /0,+#",, .- ( Z.,'"# Z0+F'"$A Y,

    :(#+ .- ($ (3#""/"$+ W0+' g."7 ,'" #"+2#$") -#./ '"# ,":(#(+0.$ +. (Z0+F'"$ +'(+ W(, $. 6.$3"# Z.,'"#7 ($) +. ( '.2,"'.6) W'"#" #"6030.$W(, -.# ( +0/" +. #"/(0$ ($ .:"$ c2",+0.$A !'"$ V.#.+'5 ($) g."

    Q#.23'+ +'"0# 0$-($+ ,.$ './" +. +'"0# (:(#+/"$+ .$ 9'",+$2+ H+#""+ 0$!",+ E'06()"6:'0(7 0$ H":+"/Q"# B7 +'"5 (3#"") +'(+ '" ,'.26) $.+

    Q" Q(:+0T") 2$+06 '" W(, .6) "$.23' +. F'..," -.# '0/,"6-AH. +'" /(++"# F.$+0$2") -.# +'" $"X+ +'#"" 5"(#,7 2$)"-0$")7 2$+06

    +'" ,:#0$3 .- J7 W'"$ g." )0) +'" 2++"#65 2$"X:"F+")A d" ,2))"$653.+ .6)C+0/" #"6030.$7 ($) Q"F(/" ( -2$)(/"$+(60,+ 9'#0,+0($A 8-

    V.#.+'5 W.26) $.+ Q"F./" ( g"W7 g." W.26) Q" +'" .$" +. F'($3"A 8+'(::"$") 60Z" +'0,Ag." W(, /($(30$3 ($ (66C$03'+ #",+(2#($+7 (+ BD$) ($) 4(6+0/.#"

    0$ !",+ E'06()"6:'0(7 W'"#" '" W.#Z") -#./ "6"P"$ .`F6.FZ (+ $03'+2$+06 ,"P"$ 0$ +'" /.#$0$3A O"(# )(W$ .$" /.#$0$37 (#.2$) +'" +0/"W'"$ +'" /06Z/($ ($) +'" )#2$Z, F(/" 0$7 ( /($ (+ g."`, F.2$+"#"XF6(0/") .P"# '0, $"W,:(:"#1 b*'.," )(/$ g"W,A 8 F($`+ ,+($) +'"/A8 '(+" +'"/Ab Y$.+'"# /($7 ($ 8+(60($7 6..Z") .P"# ($) #":60") c20"+651b!"667 8 ).$`+ '(+" +'"/A 8 6.P" +'"/A U5 ,(P0.# W(, ( g"WAb g." Q"3($+(6Z0$3 W0+' '0/7 ($) -0$(665 (FF":+") '0, 0$P0+(+0.$ +. 3. +'"-.66.W0$3 R#0)(5 "P"$0$3 +. ( 4(:+0,+ U0,,0.$ b+. '"(# ( g"W :#"(F'9'#0,+Ab

    45 R#0)(5 "P"$0$37 g." '() F.6) -""+A V.#.+'5 W(, .2+ -.# +'"

    "P"$0$37 ($) '"# ,0,+"# 4(#Q(#( W(, Q(Q5C,0++0$3A g." W(, (,6"":7 ($)4(#Q(#( W(, 0$,+#2F+") +. +"66 ($5 F(66"#, +'(+ '" W(, .2+A S0++6" +W.C5"(#C.6) !"#$"#7 '.W"P"#7 '() Q""$ 60,+"$0$3A !'"$ +'" 9'#0,+0($(##0P") (+ ,"P"$ .`F6.FZ7 !"#$"# ,F#(/Q6") .2+ .- '0, F#0Q7 #($ +. +'"'"() .- +'" ,+(0#,7 6..Z") ).W$7 ($) ,'.2+")1 bV())5 5&'"#"A d"`, 0$

    Q") (,6"":Ab!"#$"# '() 30P"$ (W(5 '0, -(+'"#`, W'"#"(Q.2+,7 ($) g." '() +.

    3"+ 2:7 ($) )0) 3. +. +'" U0,,0.$7 ( )0/65 603'+") '(667 ( ,+.#"-#.$+/0,,0.$7 (F#.,, -#./ +'" E'06()"6:'0( H(P0$3, R2$) H.F0"+5 .$ !(6$2+H+#""+A 8$ +'" /(Z",'0-+ :26:0+7 ( 5.2$3 /($ #"() -#./ +'" 4"(+0+2)",Ab8 60,+"$")7b g." #":.#+,7 b($) 8 W(, "$+'#(66")A !'(+ '" ,(0) '0+ /"60Z" ( ,6")3"'(//"#A 8 6.W"#") /5 '"() ($) ,(0)7 `8- W'(+ +'0, /($ 0,,(50$3 0, +'" +#2+'7 S.#)7 30P" /" ( 60++6" Q0+ .- 0+A`

    H'.#+65 (-+"#W(#)7 g." /"+ ($.+'"# g"W +2#$") 9'#0,+0($7 ( :#"(F'"# $(/") YQ#('(/ U.,", i"3"67 W'. Q"F(/" +'" /.,+0/:.#+($+ ,:0#0+2(6 0$-62"$F" 0$ '0, 60-"A i"3"6 '() Q""$ +#(0$") 0$E.6($) +. Q" ( #(QQ07 ($) '() Q"F./" ( 9'#0,+0($A *#(::") .$ ( P0,0+ +.&$36($) W'"$ d0+6"# /(#F'") .$ E.6($)7 i"3"6 '() "/03#(+") +. +'"G$0+") H+(+", Q5 W(5 .- 9($()(A R.# 5"(#, (-+"#W(#)7 g." I.,"$Q"#3,2::.#+") '0/ -0$($F0(6657 F.$+#0Q2+") +. '0, #"$+7 -") '0/ ($) F6.+'")'0/A g." W"$+ (#.2$) W0+' '0/ :#"(F'0$3 ,(6P(+0.$ ($) +'"-.#30P"$",, .- ,0$, -#./ ,+#""+ F.#$"#,7 ($) 0$ :#0,.$, ($) F'2#F'",A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    19/224

    bg." /()" 40665 [#('(/ ,.2$) 60Z" '" W(, ,0++0$3 F#.F'"+0$37b#":.#+, O.#/ V($.--A b!'"$ g." W(, ( 4(:+0,+7 +'"#" W(,$`+ ( ,.26W0+'0$ ( /06" W'. )0)$`+ '"(# (Q.2+ 0+A d" '() ($ 0$F#")0Q65 6(#3"P.0F"A Y$) '" W.26) +(6Z -.# '.2#, .$ "$)Ab i"3"6 -.#/") ( 3#.2:7 +'"9'#0,+0($ *",+0/.$5 +. +'" g"W7 ,:.$,.#") Q5 +'" 4(:+0,+ 9'2#F'A g."I.,"$Q"#3 :(#+0F0:(+") 0$ +'0, 3#.2:7 ($) ,"#P") .$ 0+, 4.(#) .-V0#"F+.#, -.# /($5 5"(#,A

    V.#.+'5 W(, ,2#:#0,")@($) $.+ "$+0#"65 :6"(,")@Q5 g."`,F.$P"#,0.$A g." '() F./" #.2$) +. '"# :.,0+0.$ 0$ ( P"#5 5$$5-#-5(DW(5A b!'"$ g." Q"F(/" ( 4(:+0,+7b V.#.+'5 #"F(66,7 b+'"#" W(, $./.#" ,/.Z0$37 )#0$Z0$37 .# 3.0$3 +. +'" /.P0",Ab V.#.+'5 (++"$)")/0,,0.$ /""+0$3, W0+' g." -#./ +0/" +. +0/" 0$ +'.," "(#65 )(5,7 Q2+W.26) $.+ F.$,0)"# 4(:+0,+ 0//"#,0.$ -.# '"#,"6-A H'" '"6) +. +'"&:0,F.:(6 9'2#F'7 W'"#" ,'" +(23'+ H2$)(5 HF'..6A m8$ +'" "(#65-0-+0",7 g." W.26) Q"F./" ($ &:0,F.:(60($ +..7 h.0$0$3 '0, W0-" ($)F'06)#"$A d" #"/(0$, ( F.$,"#P(+0P" 9'#0,+0($ +.)(5An

    H. 0+ W(, +'(+ !"#$"# '(#)@+'.23' Q5 )",F"$+ '(6- g"W0,'@ )0) $.+ #"F"0P" ( g"W0,' 2:Q#0$30$3A 4"-.#" g."`, F.$P"#,0.$7 +'" Q.5W"$+ #"326(#65 +. &:0,F.:(6 H2$)(5 HF'..6f (-+"#W(#)7 40Q6" #"()0$3

    ($) 9'#0,+0($ :#(5"# Q"F(/" :(#+ .- +'" '.2,"'.6) #.2+0$"A !"#$"#F.$+0$2") +. (++"$) +'" &:0,F.:(6 9'2#F' #"326(#657 W(, Q(:+0T") g.'$E(26 I.,"$Q"#37 W(, F.$-0#/")7 ($) ,"#P") -.# "03'+ 5"(#, (, ($(F.65+" (+ +'" (6+(#A

    b!"#$"# W(, -.$) .- '0, g"W0,' 3#($):(#"$+,7b V.#.+'5 ,(0)Ab!" 2,") +. ,:"$) E(,,.P"# (+ +'"0# '.2,"A 42+ '" $"P"# '() ( 4(#U0+TP('7 .# ($5+'0$3 60Z" +'(+A *'" Q"60"- +'(+ 9'#0,+ W(, +'" ,(P0.#W(, W0+' 2, (66 +'" W(5 +'#.23'Ab

    b8 +(23'+ '0/ 40Q6" ,+.#0",7b g." #"F(66,A b8 ,:.Z" +. '0/ (Q.2++'"," +'0$3, "P"#5 +0/" 8 '() ( F'($F"A 8 W(, .$ -0#" W0+' #"6030.$Ai"3"6 ($) 8 W.26) ,0+ 0$ +'" 60P0$3 #../ +(6Z0$3 (Q.2+ #"6030.$ ($) +'"40Q6"7 ($) !"#$"# W.26) W(+F' 2, 60Z" ( '(WZA i"3"67 W'. W(,F'06)6",,7 6.P") !"#$"#7 ($) F(66") '0/ '0, .W$ F'06)Ab

    *'" I.,"$Q"#3, /.P") -#./ +'" "$)6",, #.W '.2,", ($)2$F'($30$3 #..-+.:, .- !",+ E'06()"6:'0( +. +'" $"03'Q.#0$3 ,2Q2#Q.- 4(6( 95$W5) 0$

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    20/224

    +'0$3, '" /()" 0$ ,F'..6@8 ,+066 '(P" ( )"/0+(,," ,:..$ '.6)"# +'(+ '"/()" -.# /"7b ,'" ,(0)7 :.0$+0$3 +. +'" )0$0$3C#../ W(66A

    *'" #"6(+0.$,'0: .- ,.$ +. /.+'"# 0$)"") ,""/") 0)5660FA b8#"/"/Q"# '.W7 -#./ +0/" +. +0/"7 V.#.+'5 W.26) W(6Z /" +.Z0$)"#3(#+"$7b !"#$"# +.6) /"A b8+ W(, ( 6.$3 W(6Z7 0+ W.26) +(Z"(Q.2+ ($ '.2#A 8 #"/"/Q"# .$" (2+2/$ /.#$0$3 P0P0)65A 8+ W(,

    Q"(2+0-267 F#0,: ($) F6"(#A *'" 6"(P", '() -(66"$ -#./ +'" +#"", ($) 6(5(6.$3 +'" 3#.2$)A *'"5 W.26) F#2$F' ($) F#(FZ6" 2$)"#-..+A Y, W"W(6Z") (6.$37 W" :(,,") ( ,+#"(/ +'(+ #($ :(#+W(5 (6.$3 +'" #.()AV2FZ, W"#" ,W0//0$3 0$ 0+A !" ,+.::")7 8 -") +'"/7 W" +(6Z") (Q.2++'"/A

    bV.#.+'5 W(, W.$)"#-26 +. /"A H'" 3(P" /" F#")0+ -.# Q"0$3 (Q6"+. F.//2$0F(+" ($) +. 6"(#$A H'" ($,W"#") /5 c2",+0.$,7 ,'" W(,$`+F.$)",F"$)0$3A !" '() F.$P"#,(+0.$, 0$ W'0F' /5 .:0$0.$ F.2$+")A8$ +'" ,:(F" ,'" 3(P" /" 8 +#265 "X:($)")A H'" W(, #"(665 /5 32#27(6/.,+ ( i"$ /(,+"#A d"# (--"F+0.$ W(, /")0(+") Q5 ( 6.+ .- )0,F0:60$"($) +#(0$0$3A H'" "X:"F+") ($) )"/($)") ( 6.+ -#./ /"A Y$) 8 '()3#"(+ #",:"F+ -.# '"#Ab

    @FC*FC IR MF90,QR *'0, 0)5660F ,"++0$3 '() ( 3#0//"#7 )(#Z"# ,0)"A 4"30$$0$3 0$ JW'"$ !"#$"# W(, +'#""@$.+ 6.$3 (-+"# g."`, F.$P"#,0.$ +.9'#0,+0($0+5@!"#$"# /"+ W0+' ( ,"#0", .- P0.6"$+ (FF0)"$+,A

    V.#.+'5 '() 3.$" 0$+. +'" Z0+F'"$ .$" "P"$0$37 (-+"# W(Z0$3-#./ ( $(:7 +. :#":(#" )0$$"#A H'" W(, ,+066 W"(#0$3 :5h(/(,A b8 '() (

    :(#0$3 Z$0-" 0$ /5 '($), ($) ,./" ,:0$(F'7b ,'" +.6) /"A bg2,+ .2+,0)"+'" Z0+F'"$ +'"#" W(, ( -0#" ",F(:" 6($)0$37 W'"#" 8 '() ( Q2,'"6 -266 .-

    :.++0$3 ,.06A !"#$"# #($ .2+ +'"#" ,. c20FZ65 +'(+ 8 F.26)$`+ ,+.: '0/($) ,+(#+") +#50$3 +. '(//"# $(06, 0$+. +'" Q2,'"6 Q(,Z"+A 8 W(,+"##0-0")7 Q2+ )0)$`+ W($+ +. (6(#/ '0/7 6",+ '" +2#$ ($) -(66A !" W"#"+'#"" ,+.#0", 2: ($) 0+ W(, ($ .:"$ -0#" ",F(:"7 W0+' 0#.$ #(060$3,7W'0F' )0)$`+ :#.P0)" /2F' :#.+"F+0.$ -.# ( ,/(66 Q.5A 8 +'.23'+ +. +(Z"

    '0/ Q5 +'" '($)7 Q2+ Q"-.#" 8 F.26) /.P" +'"#" W(, ( ,/(66 )266 ,.2$)7($) '" W(, 3.$"A d" '() )#.::") '0, '(//"# .P"# +'" #(060$37 6"($").P"# +. ,"" W'"#" 0+ W"$+7 ($) -"66 ).W$A

    b8 #2,'") .2+ ($) ,(W '0/ 650$3 .$ +'" F.$F#"+"A 8 +'.23'+ '" W(,)"()A 8 ).$`+ Z$.W '.W 8 3.+ ).W$ +'.," +W. -603'+, .- ,+(0#,A !'"$ 8#"(F'") '0/7 +'"#" W(, $. Q6..) ,+#"(/0$37 Q2+ +'"#" W(, '"(P5F6.++") Q6..) 0$ '0, "(#,A d" W(, 60-"6",, ($) W0+'.2+ F.6.#A 8 :0FZ")'0/ 2: ($) #($ +. +'" -#.$+ .- +'" Q206)0$3A 8 '() +. 3"+ '0/ +. +'"'.,:0+(6 -(,+A 8 W(, ,+($)0$3 .$ +'" :(P"/"$+7 '.6)0$3 ( F'06) 8 +'.23'+W(, )"()7 h2,+ '.:0$3 ( F(# W.26) :(,, Q5A !" '() $. F(# (+ +'" +0/"Ag." '() W.#Z") (66 $03'+ ($) '" W(, (,6"":A 8 5"66") +. /5 5.2$3"#

    Q#.+'"#7 &))0"7 W'. W(, 3.0$3 +. Q(Q5C,0+ -.# /" +'(+ "P"$0$37 +. W(Z"g." 2:A

    bR.#+2$(+"65 ( F(# F(/" Q57 ($) ,+.::")7 ($) )#.P" 2, +. +'"'.,:0+(6A 8 +'.23'+ !"#$"# W(, )"()7 Q2+ +'"$ 8 '"(#) '0/ 3#.($A!'"$ W" 3.+ +. +'" '.,:0+(67 +'"5 +..Z '0/ 0$+. +'" "/"#3"$F5 #../($) F2+ '0, F6.+'", (W(5A 8 '"(#) '0/ 3#.($ (3(0$A U"($W'06" g."(##0P")A d" ,(W +'(+ !"#$"# W(,$`+ Q#"(+'0$37 F(66") +'" ).F+.#7 ($)+'"5 -.#F") (0# 0$+. '0, 62$3, ($) 3.+ '0/ Q#"(+'0$3 (3(0$Ab

    !"#$"# #"/"/Q"#") +'" ":0,.)"A b\))65 "$.23'7b '" ,(0)7 b8#"/"/Q"# W'(+ +'" #../ 6..Z") 60Z"7 ($) 8 F($ ,"" +'" ).F+.#`, -(F"

    Q"-.#" /" $.WA 8 (F+2(665 )0") +'"$A U5 Q.)5 '() Q""$ ,'.P") .-- +.

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    21/224

    +'" ,0)"A 8+ W(, ($ 0$+"#$7 $.+ +'" #"326(# (++"$)0$3 :'5,0F0($7 W'.3(P" /" +'" /.2+'C+.C/.2+' #",2,F0+(+0.$Ab

    V.#.+'5 F.$+0$2") '"# ,+.#5A b&P"$ +'.23' '" W(, $.W Q#"(+'0$37 8 )0)$`+ Z$.W W'"+'"# '" W.26) ,2#P0P"A 8 #($ (-+"# +'").F+.# ($) (,Z") '0/ W'"+'"# +'"5 ,'.26)$`+ 3"+ ( ,:"F0(60,+A `U()(/7`'" ,(0)7 8 (/ ( ,:"F0(60,+A YFF.#)0$3 +. /")0F(6 ,F0"$F" +'0, F'06) '(,$. Q2,0$",, 60P0$3A e.2 ,'.26) ,(5 5.2# :#(5"#,A`

    b8 ,+(#+") +. :(F" +'" '.,:0+(6 '(667 2$(W(#" +'(+ 8 W(, ,+066 0$ /5 :5h(/(,A Y, 8 W(6Z") ).W$ +'" '(66 8 ,(W ( :(0$+0$3 .- g",2, W0+' +'"60++6" F'06)#"$ (66 (#.2$)A 8 :#(5")1 E6"(," [.)7 6"+ /" '(P" '0/ +.#(0,"A` *'"$ 8 Z$"W '" W(, 3.0$3 +. 60P"7 ($) 8 W(, ,2))"$65 (W(#" .-/5 :5h(/(,7 ($) 8 W"$+ './"A 8 )#",,")7 ($) +'"$ W"$+ Q(FZ ($)(,Z") +. Q" W0+' '0/ W'"$ '" F(/" +.A *'"5 )0)$`+ W($+ /" +'"#"7 Q2+,(0) +'(+ 8 F.26) ,+(5 ,0$F" 0+ W(, ( Q.#)"#60$" F(,"A *'"5 +.6) /" +'(+'" W.26) '(P" ( +"##0Q6" '"()(F'" W'"$ '" F(/" +.7 ($) /03'+ Q"0$F.'"#"$+A *'"5 W"#" ($+0F0:(+0$3 ,"#0.2, Q#(0$ )(/(3"A

    b*'" ).F+.#, ,'(P") .-- '0, Q6.$) F2#6,7 ($) /()" +W. 0$F0,0.$,7.$" .$ "0+'"# ,0)" .- '0, ,Z266A *'(+ W(, (66A *'"#" W(, $. -2#+'"#,2#3"#5A d0, ,Z266 W(, F#(FZ") 60Z" ($ "337 Q2+ +'" ).F+.# ,(0) +'(+ 0-

    '" W"#" +. +.2F' '0/ '" /03'+ Z066 '0/A `g2,+ 6"+ '0/ Q"7` '" ,(0)Ab!"#$"# #"F.P"#")7 ($) (-+"# ,"P"#(6 /.$+', #"+2#$") './"7W'"#" '" '() +. 6"(#$ +. W(6Z (66 .P"# (3(0$A V2#0$3 +'" $"X+ +W. 5"(#,'" /"+ .$" (FF0)"$+ (-+"# ($.+'"#A Y, +'" /.$+', W"$+ Q57 '" #($ (#26"# ).W$ '0, +'#.(+f '" W(, Q()65 ,F(6)")f ($) '" -#(F+2#") '0, ,Z266(3(0$ 0$ ($ (2+./.Q06" (FF0)"$+A Y6+.3"+'"#7 )2#0$3 +'0, +0/"7 '" ,:"$+.P"# ( 5"(# 0$ +'" '.,:0+(6A !'"$ '" W(, $"(#65 -0P"7 +'" (FF0)"$+,,+.::") -.# ( +0/"7 (, ,2))"$65 (, +'"5 '() Q"32$A *W. 5"(#, :(,,")c20"+65 Q5A

    *'"$7 0$

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    22/224

    .$" ($) +'" ,(/" ,+#.Z"@+. "$(F+ +'" :2$0,'/"$+ ($) +. .QP0(+" +'"$"") -.# 0+A

    !'5 W.26) !"#$"# $"") +. :2$0,' '0/,"6-j\$" :.,,0Q6" "X:6($(+0.$ F./", -#./ +'" W#0+0$3, .- H03/2$)

    R#"2)A YFF.#)0$3 +. R#"2)7 :#""/0$"$+ (/.$3 +'" )#(/(, .-F'06)'..) (#" +'" Q(++6" W0+' +'" -(+'"# -.# +'" 6.P" .- +'" /.+'"#AH""0$3 +'0, (, +'" Z"5 +. 2$)"#,+($)0$3 +'" :,5F'"7 R#"2) )",F#0Q")+'" \")0:2, F./:6"XA &(F' F'06)7 R#"2) +"(F'",7 0, -.#".#)(0$") +.#""$(F+ H.:'.F6",`, )#(/( .- +'" Z0$3 W'. 2$W0++0$365 Z066") '0,-(+'"# ($) +..Z '0, /.+'"# +. W0-"A *'" :,5F'.6.30,+ 9A [A g2$3F.$+",+") +'" R#"2)0($ (FF.2$+A V#(W0$37 60Z" R#"2)7 .$ /5+'.6.30F(6,.2#F",7 g2$3 ,(W +'" -(/065 #./($F" .- F'06)'..) 0$ 6",, ,"X2(6+"#/,7 ($) (, 6",, 0/:.#+($+ F(2,(665A 8+ #":#","$+")7 '" +'.23'+7 ('"#.0F )#(3.$ -03'+ W0+' +'" R0#,+ E(#"$+,7 ($ (#F'(0F ,+#2336" W0+' +'"(#F'"+5:(6 [#"(+ U.+'"# ($) *"##0Q6" R(+'"#7 $.+ W0+' +'" :"#,.$(6

    :(#"$+,A!'(+"P"# +'" 6(#3"# 0$+"#:#"+(+0.$7 +'"#" 0, 60++6" ).2Q+ +'(+

    P0#+2(665 "P"#5 ,/(66 Q.5 ).", 3#.W 2: 0$ ( Q(++6"C,F(##") ($)"/.+0.$CF'(#3") ,"++0$3f +'(+ '" 0, "$+W0$") "/.+0.$(665 W0+' '0,

    /.+'"#f ($) +'(+ '" 2$F.$,F0.2,65 '(#Q.#, F./:"+0+0P"7 "P"$/2#)"#.2,7 -""60$3, +.W(#) +'" ,. /2F' 6(#3"#7 +'#"(+"$0$37 -"(#C0$,:0#0$3 -(+'"#C#0P(6 W'. ,""/, +. Q6.FZ '0, W(57 :#"P"$+0$3 '0,)",0#"A H. /2F' +#($,:0#", -#./ +'" 6.30F .- +'" .#)0$(#5 ,0+2(+0.$(6.$"7 c20+" (:(#+ -#./ +'" 0$,+0$F+2(6 ($) (#F'"+5:(6 -#(/"W.#Z, +'(+R#"2) ($) g2$3 :#.P0)"A

    *'0, -(/065 #./($F"7 ,. R#"2) ($) g2$3 (3#""7 #"(F'", ( :"(Z .-0$+"$,0+5 0$ +'" +'0#) ($) -.2#+' 5"(#,7 ($) Q5 +'" "$) .- +'" -0-+' 5"(#3.", 2$)"#3#.2$)A *'" Q.5 /.P", 0$+. ( 6(+"$F5 :"#0.)7 W'"#"0$ +'",+#0P0$3, .- +'" "(#60"# :"#0.) :"#,0,+ .$65 0$ ( #":#",,") ,+(+"A !0+' +'".$,"+ .- :2Q"#+57 +'" -(/065 #./($F" 0, #"P0P0-0") ($) F'(#3") W0+' +'""$"#35 .- ().6",F"$F"A

    !'(+ F.$F"#$, 2, '"#" 0, $.+ +'" "P"$+2(6 ().6",F"$+ #",.62+0.$

    .- +'" -(/065 #./($F"7 Q2+ +'" F'06)'..) "X:"#0"$F" .- 0+A9./:"+0+0P"$",, ($) 62,+ "#2:+ 0$+. +'" 0)5660F b0$$.F"$F"b .-F'06)'..)A Y66 +'0, +(Z", :6(F"7 '.W"P"#7 Q"6.W +'" ,2#-(F" .- (F.$,F0.2,$",, +'(+ 0, 0+,"6- h2,+ ,2#-(F0$3A *'" F'06) $"P"# c20+" Z$.W,W'(+ 0, '(::"$0$3f 0+, :(#"$+, #(#"65 ).A

    *'" W'.6" )#(/( 0, (33#(P(+") Q5 +'" :,5F'.6.30F(6 :'"$./"$.$ .- :#.h"F+0.$ m+'" F(,+0$3 .$+. +'" "X+"#$(6 "$P0#.$/"$+.- 2$F.$,F0.2, ,+(+",7 -""60$3,7 +'.23'+,7 +'(+ (#" 0$ -(F+ 0$+"#$(6 +..$","6-nA *'2, /(5 .$" :".:6" .$"`, ,2##.2$)0$3, W0+' .$"`, .W$W.#,+ (,:"F+A R.# 0$,+($F"7 ( Q.5 W'. 0, 3(1'(&15'3&"; (33#",,0P"+.W(#) '0, -(+'"# W0667 Q5 +'" /"F'($0,/ .- :#.h"F+0.$7 "X:"#0"$F" '0,-(+'"# (, Q"0$3 (33#",,0P" -'7#$: 65A/ #"3(#)6",, .- +'" #"(6 -""60$3,.- +'" -(+'"#A

    d.W 0, +'" ,/(66 Q.5 +. )"(6 W0+' '0, 2$F.$,F0.2, -"(# .- '0,-(+'"#j \$" W(5 0, :#.P0)") +'#.23' +'" /"F'($0,/ .- 5:.(-5K51#-5'(+*'" Q.5 2$F.$,F0.2,65 0)"$+0-0", W0+' '0, -(+'"#A ]. 4.1'A.& 65&

    K#-6.$+d" /(Z", 0$+"#$(6 '0, -(+'"#`, 0/(3"7 P(62",7 P0"W:.0$+A *'0, 0,( ,2#P0P(6 ,+#(+(3"/ +. -"$) .-- +'" -(+'"#`, )0,(::#.P(61 +'" -(+'"#W.26) $.+7 0+ 0, :#",2/")7 (++(FZ '0, .W$ P0"W:.0$+A

    \2+ .- +'0, 0$+"#$(60T(+0.$ .- :(#"$+(6 0/(3",7 +'"#" )0,+066, W'(+0, F.//.$65 F(66") F.$,F0"$F"A 8+ /(5 Q" ( ,+"#$ +(,Z/(,+"#7 (#":.,0+.#5 .- '(#,' F.//($)/"$+,7 ,"P"#" .2+ .- (66 :#.:.#+0.$ +. +'","P"#0+5 .- +'" #"(6 :(#"$+,@($) (6,. 0##(+0.$(6 ($) 0$F.$,0,+"$+A 8+

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    23/224

    F.//($), Q.+' be.2 .23'+ +. (F+ 60Z" 5.2# -(+'"#7b ($) be.2 .23'+('- +. (F+ 60Z" 5.2# -(+'"#@(+ 6"(,+ 0$ /(++"#, #"6(+0$3 +. +'" /.+'"#Ab

    V.", +'" R#"2)0($ (FF.2$+ "X:6(0$ !"#$"#`, F'06)'..) (FF0)"$+,j8 (,Z") '0/A

    bY, ( F'06)7b '" #":60")7 b8 W(, $"P"# F.$,F0.2,65 (-#(0) .- /5-(+'"#A O.# W(, +'"#" ($5 #"(,.$ +. Q"A O.$+'"6",,7 /5 (FF0)"$+, (#",2,:0F0.2,@:(#+0F26(#65 0$ +'"0# +0/0$3A 9.0$F0)0$3 (, +'"5 )0) W0+'+'" (::"(#($F" ($) :(,,0$3 .- +'" \")0:2, F./:6"X7 +'"5 /(5 W"66'(P" Q""$ W(5, +. )"(6 W0+' +'" 2$F.$,F0.2, :#",,2#", .$ /"7

    :(#+0F26(#65 +. :2$0,' /5 F./:"+0+0P"$",, W0+' g."7 ($) +. F(+F'V.#.+'5 , (++"$+0.$Ab

    *'" ,(/" "X:6($(+0.$7 !"#$"# :.0$+") .2+7 F.26) 0$+"#:#"+ +'"$"(#C)#.W$0$3A g."`, )":(#+2#" 0$+. +'" (#/5 ($) #"/.P(6 -#./E'06()"6:'0( W.26) '(P" 30P"$ !"#$"#@+'#.23' $. (F+ .- '0, .W$7

    Q2+ Q5 +'" 3#(F" .- [.)7 (, 0+ W"#"@:#"F0,"65 W'(+ '" W($+")1 ,.6" :.,,",,0.$ .- '0, /.+'"#A *'"$ g." /"+ W0+' 65&(FF0)"$+7 6"()0$3V.#.+'5 +. +#(P"6 +. '0, ,0)" ($) 6(P0,' (++"$+0.$ .$ '0/A R#./ (R#"2)0($ P0"W:.0$+7 +'" ,F"$" .- +'" #"2$0+") -(/065 F.26) '(P" Q""$0$+.6"#(Q6" -.# +'" F'06)A d0, 6.$3C#":#",,") F./:"+0+0P"$",, W0+' g."

    W.26) "/"#3" (3(0$@($)7 (3(0$7 Q" :2$0,'")A bY$ "5" -.# ($ "5"7 ($)( +..+' -.# ( +..+'Ab 8- .$" W0,'", ($.+'"# )"()7 ($ (::#.:#0(+" :2$0,'/"$+ 0, +. Q"7 .$","6-7 )"()A *. W0,' )"(+' .$ ( :"#,.$ W0+'W'./ .$" 0, 2$F.$,F0.2,65 0)"$+0-0") 0, +. .#)"#7 0$ +'" 2$F.$,F0.2,7.$"`, .W$ "X"F2+0.$A

    Y$) ,. 0+ A#; '(P" Q""$ W0+' !"#$"#A !'(+"P"# +'" #"(6"X:6($(+0.$ /(5 Q"7 60++6" g(FZ I.,"$Q"#3 W(, c20+" 2$F.$,F0.2, .- (66+'"," +'0$3,7 ($) 0+ W.26) Q" 2: +. !"#$"# '(#)7 /($5 5"(#, 6(+"#7 +.)0,F.P"# +'" :(++"#$, 0$ '0, :(,+7 ($) +. F./:6"+" '0, #"6(+0.$,'0: W0+'0+A !'"$ '" )0) ). ,.7 '" W.26) F'..," :(++"#$, .- ($(65,0, ($)"X:6($(+0.$ +'(+ )0--"#") -#./ R#"2)`,A

    U"($W'06"7 !"#$"# ($) V.#.+'5 #"+2#$") +.3"+'"# -#./ R.#+92,+"# +. E'06()"6:'0(A \P"# +W. 5"(#, W.26) :(,, Q"-.#" g." W.26)

    #"+2#$ +'"#" :"#/($"$+65A U"($W'06"7 60-" W(, 0$)"") :"(F"-26 ($)0)5660FA S0-" W(, ,:6"$)0)A R.# ( 6.$3 +0/" !"#$"# W.26) '(P" $.(FF0)"$+,A

    I* 0*WFC0MC 90ITMSQF BFS0*R V2#0$3 +'"," 5"(#, 0$ 4(6( 95$W5) W0+' V.#.+'57 !"#$"# Q"3($ ($0$+"#0.# )0(6.32"7 ( :#0P(+" F.$P"#,(+0.$ +'(+ '" )0) $.+ #"P"(6 +. .+'"#,-.# /($5 5"(#,A

    !" +(6Z") (Q.2+ +'0, .$" ,2$$5 (-+"#$..$ 0$ *0Q2#.$7 ( :"$0$,26((+ +'" "$) .- U(#0$ 9.2$+57 ,+#"+F'0$3 ,.2+'W(#) 0$+. +'" H($R#($F0,F. 4(5A !" '() h2,+ ,(06") (F#.,, +'" Q(5 -#./ H($ R#($F0,F.7

    :(,+ +'" [.6)"$ [(+"7 :(,+ Y$3"6 8,6($) ($) 4"6P")"#"7 ($) 0$+. +'"*0Q2#.$ ).FZA !" +0") 2: .2# Q.(+ ($) F(/" (,'.#" -.# 62$F'A !"#$"#

    Q"3($ +. +(6Z (Q.2+ +'" :6(F" .- #"6030.$ 0$ '0, F'06)'..)Ab8 W(, P"#5 #"6030.2, (, ( F'06)7b '" #"F(66")A b8 2,2(665 ,:"$+ +'"W""Z"$), W0+' /5 3#($):(#"$+,7 :(#+0F26(#65 )2#0$3 +'" W(#7 Q"F(2,"/5 /.+'"# W.#Z") -266C+0/" +'"$7 /($(30$3 ( #",+(2#($+A H. +'"F'2#F' 0$ W'0F' 8 3#"W 2: W(, $.+ H(0$+ Y,(:'`,7 .2# :#.:"# :(#0,'F'2#F' +'(+ W(, c20+" F6.," +. .2# (:(#+/"$+ 0$ 4(6( 95$W5)A H(0$+Y,(:'`, W(, 6.W F'2#F'A 8 #"(665 3#"W 2: 0$ ( '03' &:0,F.:(6 F'2#F'7W0+' F.$-",,0.$ ($) 0$F"$," ($) (66 +'(+A *'0, W(, +'" 9'2#F' .- +'"d.65 O(+0P0+57 +'" &:0,F.:(6 F'2#F' 0$ ["#/($+.W$ W'"#" /53#($):(#"$+, 60P")A 8 W(, ($ (6+(# Q.5 +'"#" -.# "03'+ 5"(#,7 ($) .-

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    24/224

    F.2#," 6"(#$") +'" #0+2(6 ($) +'" 60+2#35 P"#5 W"66A 8 W.26) 603'+ +'"F($)6",7 ($) #0$3 +'" Q"667 ($) /(#F' 0$ :#.F",,0.$A *'" :#0",+ W(, (-#0"$) .- /5 3#($):(#"$+, ($) W.26) F./" +. )0$$"# .$ H2$)(5"P"$0$3, -#./ +0/" +. +0/"A

    b8+ W(, (+ +'0, +0/" +'(+ 8 -0#,+ Q"3($ +. 6"(#$ ,./"+'0$3 .- &(,+"#$#"6030.2, +'.23'+7 +..A *'0, W(,$`+ .#030$(665 .2+ .- ($5 )",0#" -.#,:0#0+2(6 (++(0$/"$+A 8+ W(, .$65 6(+"#7 0$ ,+2)50$3 ,:0#0+2(6 )0,F0:60$",7+'(+ 8 '"(#) (Q.2+ ,:0#0+2(6 (++(0$/"$+Ab !"#$"# :(2,")7 ())0$37b8$F0)"$+(6657 +'"#" 0, $. ,2F' +'0$3 (, (++(0$/"$+ W'"$ 0+ F./", +.

    Q"0$3 ,:0#0+2(6Ab8 #"/"/Q"# '.W 8 -0#,+ 3.+ 0$+. 5.3(A 8 '() +(Z"$ +'" +#(0$

    ).W$+.W$ -.# /5 )#2/ 6",,.$A 8 W(, "6"P"$ .# +W"6P"A 8 '() h2,+ Q"32$ +. 3. ).W$+.W$ Q5 /5,"6-A 8 3.+ .2+ .- +'" 6",,.$ "(#657 ($)W(, W(6Z0$3 +.W(#) +'" +#(0$ ,+(+0.$A 8 ,+.::") 0$ ( Q..Z,+.#" $"(#U(#Z"+ H+#""+7 ($) -.2$) ($ .6) 2,") Q..Z .$ d(+'( e.3(A 8 +..Z 0+'./"7 ($) )0) (66 +'" "X"#F0,", ($) :#(F+0F",7 +'" Q#"(+'0$3 ($)

    :.,+2#",7 (66 .- +'(+Ab8 (,Z") !"#$"# W'"+'"# '" '() 0$,+#2F+0.$ 0$ 5.3( .# +(6Z") W0+'

    ($5.$" (Q.2+ 0+A b\' $.7 8 )0) +'0, .$ /5 .W$A *'"#" W(, $.Q.)5 W0+'

    W'./ 8 F.26) '(P" )0,F2,,") 0+A *'0, W(, ($ 0$+"#$(6 )0(6.32"7 .$"W0+'.2+ "X+"#$(6 "X:#",,0.$A !"667 8 ,2::.," +'(+ +'"#" W(, &'A."X+"#$(6 "X:#",,0.$7 Q2+ $. .$" W.26) '(P" Z$.W$ W'(+ 8 W(, ).0$31 8F($ #"/"/Q"# W(6Z0$3 ).W$ 90+5 S0$" YP"$2" +#50$3 +. W(6Z W0+'.2+"X:"$)0$3 "$"#35A 8 3.+ .$" 6"3 +. -6.(+ (6.$3 W0+'.2+ "--.#+A 8 F.26)$"P"# 3"+ Q.+' 6"3, +. W.#ZA 8 #"/"/Q"# +'" "6(+0.$ 8 '() (+ (F'0"P0$3+'(+ "--.#+6",, /.+0.$ W0+' .$" 6"3A

    b8+ W(,$`+ h2,+ :'5,0F(6 )0,F0:60$", +'(+ 8 W"$+ 0$+.7b !"#$"# ,(0)Ab8 (6,. '() F.$P"#,(+0.$, (Q.2+ [.) W0+' /5,"6-A

    bS0Z" ( 6.+ .- Z0),7 8 #"/"/Q"# :2TT60$3 .P"# +'" c2",+0.$, +'(+F(/" 2: 0$ F.$-0#/(+0.$ F6(,,",A 8 W.$)"#") W'"+'"# +'"#" #"(665 W(,( [.)7 W'(+ (66 +'(+ 8 W(, +(23'+ +. Q"60"P" 0$ #"(665 /"($+A 8 W.$)"#")W'5 [.) /()" 0+ ,. Q()j !'5 )0) '" /(Z" W(# ($) -(/0$"j 8 (6,.

    (,Z") W'"+'"# 8 W(, #"(665 #",:.$,0Q6"A 8 ).$`+ +'0$Z 8 :2+ 0+ +'(+ W(5+'"$A 8 W.26) '(P" ,(0)1 9($ 5.2 3"+ (W(5 W0+' Q#"(Z0$3 +'" #26",j!'5 ). 5.2 '(P" +. Z"": +'" #26",j

    b8 +'.23'+ +. /5,"6- +'(+ 0- [.) (6#"()5 Z$.W, "P"#5+'0$3 8`/3.0$3 +. ).7 0+ ).",$`+ /(++"#1 8 /03'+ (, W"66 ). ($5+'0$3A 42+ +'(+)0)$`+ ,""/ +. W.#Z "0+'"#A 4"F(2," 8 F.26) .$65 ). W'(+ 8`/ 3.0$3 +.). Q"F(2," [.) (6#"()5 Z$.W, 8`/ 3.0$3 +. ). 0+A 8 3.+ ,. /0$)

    Q.336") +'(+ "P"$+2(665 8 h2,+ 3(P" 2: ($) +#0") +. -0$) ,./" .+'"# :#0$F0:6" 0$ +"#/, .- W'0F' +. 60P"A

    b*'(+ W(,$`+ +'" -0#,+ +0/" 8 3.+ +($36") 0$ :'06.,.:'0F(6c2",+0.$,7b !"#$"# ())")A b8 W(, (#.2$) ,0X 5"(#, .6) W'"$ 8 -0#,++#0") +. -032#" .2+ '.W -(# .2+ ,:(F" 3.",A 8 Q"3($ +. W(+F' /5,"6-W(+F'0$3 /5,"6-A Y$) +'"$ 8 W.26) W(+F' /5,"6- W(+F'0$3 /5,"6-

    W(+F'0$3 /5,"6-A Y$) +'"$ 8 W.26) W(+F' /5,"6- W(+F'0$3 /5,"6-W(+F'0$3 /5,"6- W(+F'0$3 /5,"6-A *'"#" W(, $. "$)7 ($) 8 #"(60T")+'(+ +'"#" W(, $.$"A 8 #"/"/Q"# 3.0$3 +'#.23' (66 .- +'(+ .2+ 0$ +'"-0"6)7 650$3 0$ +'" +(66 3#(,,7 0$ +'" W(#/ ,2$603'+A *'"#" W(, ( -""60$3.- ,:(F"7 .- 0$-0$0+5A 8+ W(, ( ,.#+ .- /")0+(+0P" +#($F"Ab

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    25/224

    *!\ H.$ ($) U.+'"#@6#- #"" &6'3": 7. #4'3- -6#- G#$-513"#$ 63A#( 4.5(D 76' 7#&

    1#"".: A'-6.$h + + + @6#-.J.$ 7. 75"" #"7#;& 4. -'' A316/ -'' K#"&./ -'' 5(#:.E3#-./ #(: .J.( -'' A5&".#:5(D+ + + + B3- '(. 76'3(:.$&-#(:& 1#( (' "'(D.$ G3- &316 #( .('$A'3& "'#: 'K &5D(5K51#(1./'$ $.&G'(&545"5-; #(: :3-;/ -6. 7.5D6- 'K #"" 6.#J.( #(: 6.""/ 3G'( -6.7.#% #(: .$$5(D 63A#( 4.5(D 5( (..: 'K "'J./ 1#$./ 3(:.$&-#(:5(D #(:

    K'$D5J.(.&&/ 76' 7#& '3$ A'-6.$+ e!+ S+ V3(D

    I !]0, MUU W]F MT9 BTM!j 8$ +'" (2+2/$ .-

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    26/224

    *'"#" W(, ,./" :.0$+ 0$ +'" 0$+"$,0+5 .- +'(+ F.$P"#,(+0.$A Y-+"#+'" Q6"(Z 5"(#, .- )":#",,0.$ ($) W(#7 ( /..) .- ($+0F0:(+0.$ ($) '.:"W(, 0$ +'" (0#A g."7 -.# 0$,+($F"7 W(, -0$(665 3.0$3 +. Q" (Q6" +. 3. +.F.66"3"@2$)"# +'" [8 Q066A bg." 2,") +. F./:6(0$ ( 6.+7b O.#/ V($.--+.6) /"A bd" W.26) ,(57 `8 F.26) '(P" Q""$ ( 6(W5"#7 ( ).F+.#7 5.2$(/" 0+A 8$,+"()7 '"#" 8 (/ ,60F0$3 ,(6(/0A` b H. g." "$+"#") *"/:6"G$0P"#,0+57 +. W.#Z -.# ( )"3#"" 0$ -..) ,F0"$F", ($) /($(3"/"$+A d""$+"#") ($ 0$+"$,0P" :#.3#(/7 (0/") (+ F#(//0$3 ( -.2#C5"(# F.2#,"0$+. +W. ($) ( '(6- 5"(#,f ($) '" +'#"W '0/,"6- 0$+. ,+2)"$+ (F+0P0+0",7

    Q"F./0$3 :#",0)"$+ .- '0, F.66"3" F6(,, ($) (6,. .- +'" P"+"#($,`(,,.F0(+0.$A d" W(, #(#"65 (+ './" )2#0$3 +'" )(5,A V.#.+'57/"($W'06"7 F.$+0$2") +. W.#Z -266 +0/" (+ +'" #",+(2#($+7 ($) +. F(#"-.# !"#$"# (+ './"A

    W]F TI!CMRRF I!!09F*W Y, '" W(, 3#.W0$3 2:7 !"#$"# '() .-+"$ W.$)"#") W'5 '" '() $.

    Q#.+'"#, ($) ,0,+"#,A bd" F.26)$`+ 2$)"#,+($) 0+7b V.#.+'5 +.6) /"A bd"W($+") +. Z$.W W'"+'"# [.) )0)$`+ 60Z" '0/Ab 42+ 0+ '() (6W(5, Q""$AAA ($ (F()"/0F c2",+0.$A

    8$ +'" 6(+" ,2//"# .-

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    27/224

    Q"F(/" 2:,"++0$3A 8+ W(,$`+ h2,+ +'(+ 8 W(, '(P0$3 +($+#2/,A U5 .W$/.+'"# +'.23'+ +'(+ 8 W(, '(P0$3 ( $"#P.2, Q#"(Z).W$A

    b!'"$ 8 #"(60T") +'" "--"F+ +'" /")0F0$" W(, '(P0$3 .$ /"7 8,+.::") +(Z0$3 0+A e"+ 0$ +'" (-+"#/(+' .- (66 +'(+7 8 )0)$`+ '(P" +'"#",.2#F", +. ,+($) Q(FZ -#./ +'" ,0+2(+0.$ +. )0,F.P"# W'(+ W(,'(::"$0$3A *'" F6.," F.//2$0F(+0.$ +'(+ !"#$"# ($) 8 '() "$h.5")-.# ,. 6.$3 h2,+ ,""/") +. "P(:.#(+"A 8 6.,+ +.2F' W0+' '0/Ab

    V2#0$3 +'"," /.$+', g."@W'. W(, 0$ +'" /0))6" .- '0, -0$(65"(# (+ F.66"3"@W(, .$ +'" P"#3" .- -(060$3 ( F'"/0,+#5 F.2#," +'(+W(, #"c20#") -.# 3#()2(+0.$A !"#$"# '() Q""$ '"6:0$3 '0, -(+'"# W0+''0, ,+2)0", (66 (6.$37 ($) '() "P"$ F.(F'") '0/ .$ H'(Z",:"(#" ($)E6(+.A O.W '" #2,'") 0$ +. ,(P" '0/ (+ F'"/0,+#5A

    b*'0, W(, /5 F'($F"7b !"#$"# +.6) /"A b8 #"/"/Q"# P0P0)65W'(+ ( :#.Q6"/ /5 -(+'"#`, )0--0F26+5 W0+' F'"/0,+#5 W(,A 8+ W(,0$+"#-"#0$3 W0+' ,./"+'0$3 +'(+ '" ($) /5 /.+'"# '() 0$P",+") ,./2F' 0$1 '0, 3.0$3 +. F.66"3"A *'"5 W"#" 3.0$3 +. Q"30$ ( W'.6" $"W60-" -#./ +'"#"A d"6:0$3 '0/ W(, ( W(5 -.# /" +. /(Z" ($ 0/:.#+($+F.$+#0Q2+0.$ 0$ ( '.2,"'.6) W'"#" 8 -"6+ 0$F#"(,0$365 W.#+'6",,Ab

    !"#$"# #"() +'" Q..Z,7 )0) +'" "X"#F0,",7 +2+.#") g." .$ +'"

    /(+"#0(67 ($) W(0+") $"#P.2,65 -.# +'" #",26+,A 42+ '0, +2+.#0$3 W(, 0$P(0$A g." -(06") +'" F'"/0,+#5 "X(/0$(+0.$7 ($) ,'.#+65 +'"#"(-+"# '()+. )#.: .2+ .- F.66"3"A !'"$ V.#.+'5 ,+.::") W.#Z0$3 +. '(P" +'"0#

    Q(Q57 g." +..Z .P"# '"# h.Q (+ +'" #",+(2#($+ .$ 90+5 S0$" YP"$2"A&P"#5 /"/Q"# .- +'" -(/065 -"6+ )"-"(+")A b*'" '.##.# .- /5 60-" (++'0, +0/"7b !"#$"# +.6) /"7 bW(, +'(+@P"#5 ,2))"$65@+'"#" $.6.$3"# ,""/") +. Q" ($5 W(5 -.# /" +. F.$+#0Q2+" +. /5 -(/065Ab

    R.# 5"(#, V.#.+'5 '() Q""$ +. '"# ,.$ '0, K.AA. 5(&G5$#-$51./'0,,.2#F" .- F#"(+0P0+5 ($) (/Q0+0.$7 '0, /2,"A O.# W(, +'" #"6(+0.$,'0:.$"C,0)")A O.+'0$3 /.#" (--"F+, +'" F'06) +'($ +'" 2$60P") 60-" .- '0,

    :(#"$+,f ($) V.#.+'57 )0,,(+0,-0") ($) )0,(::.0$+") 0$ '"# /(##0(3"7)":"$)") .$ '"# ,.$ -.# '"# .W$ )"P"6.:/"$+7 -.# F./:($0.$,'0:7 -.##"6(+")$",,A *'"$7 h2,+ (+ ( +0/" W'0F' 0,7 0$ ($5 F(,"7 F#0+0F(67 W'"$

    +'" Q.5 W(, #"(F'0$3 :2Q"#+57 W'"$ ,2F' ( #"6(+0.$,'0: /2,+ :"#-.#F"F'($3"7 "P"#5+'0$3 W(, F./:60F(+") Q5 +'" (::"(#($F"7 -.# +'" -0#,++0/"7 .- ,0Q60$3,A H2F' /2F' 5.2$3"# ,0Q60$3, 30P" $. F(2," -.#.#)0$(#5 ,0Q60$3 #0P(6#5A !'(+ 0, #","$+")@Q0++"#65@0, $.+ ,. /2F'+'" ,0Q60$3 (, +'" 6.,, .- +'" /.+'"#@W'. ).",$`+ ,""/ +. $"") 65A($5/.#"A g2,+ (+ +'" /./"$+ W'"$ '" 0, Q"30$$0$3 +. ,"$," +'(+ +'"#"0, ( 60/0+ +. +'"0# #"6(+0.$,'0:7 +'(+ '" F($$.+ Q" '"# 6.P"#7 +'" ,.$6"(#$, +'(+ $"0+'"# F($ '" #"/(0$ '"# F'06)A

    U(++"#, W0+' '0, -(+'"# W"#" $. Q"++"#A 45 30P0$3 V.#.+'5 '-6.$ F'06)#"$7 g." )"/.$,+#(+") '0, ,2:"#0.#0+5 .P"# '0, ,.$ +W0F"-.6)A \$+'" .+'"# '($)7 g."`, ,'.#+F./0$3,@(, 0$ '0, W"(Z$",, 0$ ,F'..6CW.#Z@$.W Q"F(/" "P0)"$+ +. '0, ,.$ -.# +'" -0#,+ +0/"A !"#$"#`, .$65'.:"7 (, 0+ W"#"7 W(, +. "X:6.0+ +'0, W"(Z$",,7 ($) +. /(Z" '0,

    -(+'"#@($) +'"#"Q5 V.#.+'5@)":"$)"$+ .$ '0/A 45 F.66(Q.#(+0$3W0+' g." 0$ ( F.//.$ "$+"#:#0,"7 +'" W"66CQ"0$3 .- +'" -(/0657 '"W.26) (+ .$" ,+#.Z" :#.:0+0(+" Q.+' /.+'"# ($) -(+'"#A !'"$ +'0, )0)$.+ ,2FF"")7 +'" Q.5 -(06") $.+ .$65 (, '0, -(+'"#`, #0P(6 Q2+ "P"$ (, '0,(665A

    !"#$"# $.W -"6+ W.#+'6",,7 2,"6",,7 #")2$)($+7 ,2:"#-62.2,AV2#0$3 +'" W(# 5"(#,7 60-" 0$ +'" (:(#+/"$+ (+ 4(6( 95$W5) '(),""/") +. #"P.6P" (#.2$) '0/A O.W '" -"6+ +'(+ +'"#" W(, $. 6.$3"#($5 #"(,.$ -.# '0/ +. Q" +'"#" (+ (667 +'(+ '" W(, 0$+#2)0$3A d" W(,7 (+6"(,+ -#./ '0, .W$ :.0$+ .- P0"W7 F(,+ .2+ ($) .2+F(,+A *. '0/ 0+

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    28/224

    ,""/") +'(+ $.+'0$3 +'(+ '" W.26) ). W.26) "P"# Q" (FZ$.W6")3")f+'(+ '" F.26) $. 6.$3"# ). ($5+'0$3 #03'+A Y$) ,.7 0$ ( Z0$) .-#"+(60(+0.$7 '" Q"3($ +. ). "P"#5+'0$3 W#.$3A

    9F,F*9F*!F I*9 0*9F,F*9F*!F !'"$ 8 Q#.23'+ 2: +'"," /(++"#, W0+' !"#$"#7 -.# +'" -0#,+ +0/" 0$ .2#F.$P"#,(+0.$,7 -.# $. /.#" +'($ ( -60FZ"# .- ( /./"$+7 '" 6..Z") ,()A!" W"#" ,0++0$3 0$ '0, )"$7 .$ +'" ,"F.$) -6..# .- R#($Z60$ d.2," 0$H($ R#($F0,F.A YF#.,, -#./ 2,7 .$ +'" W(667 /.2$+") (3(0$,+ ($Y-#0F($ W..6 #237 '2$3 F.6.# :'.+.3#(:', .- "(F' /"/Q"# .- '0,-(/0651 '0, /.+'"# ($) -(+'"#7 '0, -0#,+ ($) ,"F.$) W0-"7 '0, ,"P"$F'06)#"$A H6.W65 '" Q"3($ +. .:"$ 2: +'(+ ,.6"/$ /./"$+ .-F.$F"$+#(+") "/.+0.$A 9"#+(0$65 +'0, W(, +'" 2$'(::0",+ +0/" .- /560-"7b !"#$"# ,(0)A be"+ 8 F($`+ +"66 5.2 W'(+$.#""; '(::"$")A Y66 8 F($). 0, +"66 5.2 (Q.2+ /5 "X:"#0"$F" -6.(+ U5 "X:"#0"$F" W(, "$+($36")0$ /5 W066 +. (P.0) /5 /.+'"#`, )./0$(+0.$ ($) +. ,'.W '"# +'(+ 8 W(,#03'+A

    b8$ +(6Z0$3 (Q.2+ +'0, :"#0.) 8 W($+ +. ,+#",, +'(+ +'0, 0, .$65 '.W/(++"#, &..A.: +. /" +'"$A O.$" .- +'"," .6) "P"$+, '(, ($5+'0$3 +.

    ). W0+' /5 /.+'"# (, ,'" 5&.# W0+' /5 Q(,0F "X:"#0"$F" .- '"#Abd(P0$3 "/:'(,0T") +'" ,2Qh"F+0P" (,:"F+ .- '0, (FF.2$+7 !"#$"# Q"3($ +. ($(65T" +'" ,+.#5 0$ +"#/, +'(+ '" $.W 2,", 0$ +'" .&-+#(0$0$3A

    bU5 /.+'"#`, #"-2,(6 +. #"(F+7 +. +(Z" /" +. +'" ).F+.# W'"$ 8 Q#.Z" /5 $.," W(,7 .$ .$" 6"P"67 +#0P0(6A 42+ ($ 0$F0)"$+ 0, /.#" +'($0+, .2+"# /($0-",+(+0.$7 ($) +'" :.0$+ 0, W'(+ 8 /()" .2+ .- 0+A 8 ,(W 0+(, ( Z0$) .- "h"F+0.$ -#./ F'06)'..)A

    b_0#+2(665 "P"#5.$"7 W'06" '" .# ,'" 0, 3#.W0$3 2:7 '(, ($"X:"#0"$F" W'0F' 0, F.$F":+2(60T") (, ( ,'(#:7 ,2))"$ 6.,, .-,2::.#+7b !"#$"# .Q,"#P")A b!'(+ 8 /"($ Q5 `,2::.#+` 0, +'" 0/:60F0+(3#""/"$+ +'(+ /5 :(#"$+, W.26) +(Z" F(#" .- /"@W0+' (66 +'"F'06)0,' 6.P"7 F(#"7 :#.+"F+0.$7 +'(+ ( ,+(+" .- )":"$)"$F" 0/:60",A

    b8 ).$`+ /"($ +'(+ :(#"$+, $"F",,(#065 $.#""; :' W0+')#(W +'"0#

    ,2::.#+ (+ ,./" :(#+0F26(# +0/"A Y F'06) &..&+'"/ (, '(P0$3 ).$" ,.1'" +(Z", +'" 0$F0)"$+ ($) F.$F":+2(60T", 0+ +. A.#( +'(+AbY-+"# +'" 6(F#.,," 0$F0)"$+7 ( :(++"#$ .- F.$-60F+ W(, ",+(Q60,'")

    0$ /5 60-" 0$ W'0F' +'#"" +'0$3, Q(++6") .$" ($.+'"#1 /5 ($320,' .P"#+'" 6.,, .- /5 /.+'"#`, ,2::.#+7 /5 #",0,+($F" +. '"# )./0$(+0.$7 ($)/5 ,+#2336" +. :#.P" /5,"6-A 8+ W(, ( F.$-60F+ (/.$3 +'#"""X:#",,0.$,@`8 W($+ 5.2# 6.P" ($) ,2::.#+7` `e.2 F($`+ )./0$(+" /"7``8`66 ,'.W 5.2A`

    bS0Z" /($5 +""$C(3"#,7 8 W(, 2$(Q6" +. F.//2$0F(+" /5 6.P" -.#/5 -(/065 Q"F(2," 8 Q"F(/" ,+2FZ 0$ :#.P0$3 /5,"6-A *. '(P"F.//2$0F(+") /5 6.P" W.26) '(P" /()" /"@0$ A; "5",@/.#"P26$"#(Q6"7 6",, 0$)":"$)"$+A

    b*'2,7 (-+"# +'0, 0$F0)"$+7 "P"#5 F#0+0F(6 .Q,"#P(+0.$ +'(+ /5

    /.+'"# /()"7 '"# "P"#5 (++"/:+ +. F.##"F+ /"7 8 0$+"#:#"+") (, ( -2#+'"##"Q2--A &P"#5 (++"/:+ ,'" /()" +. Q" F.$F060(+.#57 8 0$+"#:#"+") (, ( :6.5 +. Q#0$3 /" Q(FZ 2$)"# '"# )./0$(+0.$A *'" ,0+2(+0.$ )"+"#0.#(+")(FF.#)0$365Ab

    !"#$"# F'2FZ6")A bY, 8 ,:"(Z .- +'0,7 0+ ,.2$), (, 0- 8 F(#"-2665-032#") .2+ W'(+ +. ).A \- F.2#," 8 )0)$`+A *'" :(++"#$, Q"'0$) /5

    Q"'(P0.# W"#" 2$F.$,F0.2, +. /" +'"$Ab8+ /(5 ,.2$) F#(T5A 8+ W(,7 0$ -(F+7 0$,($"A Y, ( F'06)7 8 '()

    2$F.$,F0.2,65 -.#/") +'" :.0$+ .- P0"W +'(+ /5 ,2#P0P(6 )":"$)") .$/5 /.+'"#`, F.$+#.660$37 )"+"#/0$0$37 )./0$(+0$3 /5 "$P0#.$/"$+ ($)

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    29/224

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    30/224

    Q"A 8 W.26) '(P" ,+.::") #",0,+0$3 '"#A *'(+ W.26) $.+ '(P" Q""$,2Q/0,,0.$A 8+ W.26) '(P" Q""$ +#($,F"$)0$3 +'(+ ,+2:0) 3(/"A

    bI",0,+($F" ($) +'" $"") +. )./0$(+" ($) Q" #03'+ )",+#.5 5.2#(Q060+5 +. (66.W +'0$3, +. Q"A !'"$ 5.2 '(P" $. (Q060+5 +. (66.W +'0$3,+. Q"7 5.2 '(P" $. (Q060+5 +. Q" #",:.$,0Q6" -.# +'"/ (, +'"5 (#"A !'"$5.2 F($$.+ Q" #",:.$,0Q6" -.# +'" W(5 +'0$3, (#"7 5.2 '(P" $. ,:(F"A!'"$ 5.2 '(P" $. ,:(F"7 5.2 '(P" $. (Q060+5 +. F#"(+"A 8+ 0, 0$ F#"(+0$3+'(+ 5.2 ",+(Q60,' +#2" 0$)":"$)"$F"A

    bH. +'"," :(++"#$, F2+ /" .-- $.+ .$65 -#./ /5 /.+'"#7 Q2+ (6,.-#./ /5 .W$ F#"(+0P" (Q060+5A *'0, 0/:.P"#0,'") /5 60-"7 ($) +.2F'")"P"#5+'0$3 8 )0)Ab

    !"#$"# #"-6"F+")A b*. -.F2, .$ +'"," :(++"#$, ).",$`+ /"($ +'(++'0, 0, +'" .$65 W(5 +. 0662/0$(+" W'(+ '(::"$")A Y R#"2)0($7 -.#"X(/:6"7 W.26) :.0$+ .2+ '.W 8 W(, 3.0$3 +'#.23' :2Q"#+5A R#"2),(5, +'(+ (66 3#.W0$3 Q.5, (#" (++#(F+") ,"X2(665 +. +'"0# /.+'"#,AG$c2",+0.$(Q65 +'0, W(, '(::"$0$3 +. /"A 8+ W(,$`+ .P"#+ .- F.2#,"A 8+W(, 2$F.$,F0.2,A

    bO"0+'"# .- 2, F.26) (FZ$.W6")3" W'(+ W(, 3.0$3 .$A H'" /(5'(P" '() F"#+(0$ F.$,0)"#(+0.$, (Q.2+ W'(+ ,'" F.26) ($) F.26)$`+ -""6f

    W'(+ ,'" F.26) ($) F.26)$`+ ,(5A !" F.26)$`+ F.//2$0F(+"A H. W" Q"F(/" $2++5 (Q.2+ .2# #"6(+0.$,'0:A U5 /.+'"# '($)6") +'0, Q5,'.P0$3 /" .2+A 8 '($)6") 0+ Q5 :2,'0$3 Q(FZ 0$@W'06" :#.+",+0$3 (66+'" W'06" +'(+ 8 W($+") .2+A

    b8$ ($5 F(,"7 +'" "X:6($(+0.$ 5.2 F'..," 0, (6/.,+ 0##"6"P($+A *'"-(F+ 0,7 8 W(, +#(::") 0$ /5 ,+.#57 0$ +'" W(5 8 F.$F"0P") /5 60-"A U5,+.#5 F(/" +. )"-0$" W'. 8 W(,A d() 8 Q""$ (Q6" +. 6"+ V.#.+'5 Q"7 8/03'+ '(P" -.2$) .2+ "(#60"# W'. 8 $.#""; W(,A

    b*'"$ 0+ F.26) '(P" Q""$ )0--"#"$+A U5 /.+'"#`, +#"/"$).2,"$"#357 ($) '"# 2$"X:#",,") F(:(F0+5 -.# "/.+0.$7 F.26) '(P" F./".2+ (, 6.P"7 ($) F.26) '(P" Q""$ W.$)"#-2665 $2#+2#0$3AG$-.#+2$(+"657 8 W(, $.+ (+ +'(+ +0/" (Q6" +. +2#$ .2# #"6(+0.$,'0:(#.2$)A *'0, W(, ($ (Q,.62+" -(062#" -.# /"Ab

    R.# +'#"" 5"(#, +'" Q(++6" #(3")A R.# +'#"" 5"(#, !"#$"# #(06")(3(0$,+ '0, ,0+2(+0.$7 ,""Z0$3 +. W0$ Q(FZ '0, /.+'"# , (++"$+0.$ 0$ ($5W(5 '" F.26)A Y$) +'"$ AAA 0+ W(, (, 0- '" #"(60T") +'(+ '0, 32#2 '()30P"$ 2: .$ '0/A Y$) '" 3(P" 2:A

    *'0, '(::"$") (#.2$) +'" +0/" +'" -(/065 /.P") (W(5 -#./ 4(6(95$W5)A *'" (:(#+/"$+ '() #(:0)65 Q""$ 3#.W0$3 +.. ,/(66A Y$.+'"#F'06)7 d(##57 W(, Q.#$ 0$ g($2(#5

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    31/224

    Y Q0++"# ,+#2336" -.66.W")f Q2+ g." ($) V.#.+'5 '"6) .2+7 ($) !"#$"##"+2#$") +. O.##0,+.W$ d03' +. F./:6"+" '0, ,"$0.# 5"(#A

    Y6+'.23' +.6"#(Q65 ,2FF",,-26 0$ F.$P"$+0.$(6 +"#/,7 +'(+ 5"(#W(,7 -.# .$" .- !"#$"#`, +(6"$+,7 ( +0/" .- :(,,0P0+5 ($) )#0-+0$3A d""$3(3") 0$ ,:.#+,1 '" #.)"7 ($) :6(5") 6(F#.,,"7 ($) W"$+ ,W0//0$3Ad" W(, .$ +'" ,+(-- .- +'" ,F'..6 $"W,:(:"#7 ($) W(, ( /"/Q"# .- +'"E#",, 962Q ($) +'" 9#"(+0P" !#0+0$3 962QA d" (,,0,+") 0$ +'" )0#"F+0.$.- +'" ,"$0.# :6(57 ($) :6(5") +'" #.6" .- +'" Q(,Z"+Q(66 :6(5"# 0$ (

    :"#-.#/($F" .- b\2# U0,, 4#..Z,Ab d0, -"66.W ,+2)"$+, Z$"W '0/ (,b+'" Q#(0$Ab d" Q"F(/" -(,F0$(+") Q5 H'(Z",:"(#"`, :6(5 ]#A".-/ (,+.#5 .- ( 5.2$3 :#0$F" ($) '0, :(#"$+,7 .- 2,2#:(+0.$ ($) Q"+#(5(6A d"/"/.#0T") 0+ -#./ Q"30$$0$3 +. "$)7 ($) -#"c2"$+65 c2.+") :(#+, .- 0+(6.2)A Y$) '" W.$ +'" &$360,' YW(#)A &XF":+ -.# '0, &$360,' ($)

    :'5,0F, F6(,,",7 '.W"P"#7 '" W(, $. 6.$3"# /2F' 0$+"#",+") 0$ ,F'..6Ad0, (++"$+0.$ W(, "6,"W'"#"A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    32/224

    *dI&& [ #"3(#0.2,($) Y6.$"

    W6. $."5D5'3& ".#:.$ + + + .[-.(:& -6. G$'4".A 'K 65& 5:.(-5-; -' -6.4'$:.$& 'K .[5&-.(1. 5( -6. %('7( 3(5J.$&.k '-6.$ 63A#( 4.5(D& 4.(:#"" -6.5$ .KK'$-& -' #:'G- #(: K3"K5"" -6. :.G#$-A.(-#"5L.: 5:.(-5-5.&76516 -6.; K5(: G$.G#$.: 5( -6.5$ 1'AA3(5-5.&+ + + + *' 7'(:.$ -6#- 6.5& &'A.-65(D 'K #( '": A#( f# :'06.,.:'2,7 #(: # : '(.g 76.( 65D.ZA#-.& #$. ;'3(D/ '$ -6#- 6. $.A#5(& &'A.-65(D 'K # 165": 76.(-6.; #D. 75-6 K5(#"5-;+

    eF$5% ]+ F$5%&'(

    XQ0FW 9FR,FCIW0M*

    d0, (++"$+0.$ W(, W0+'0$A \2+W(#)657 '" Q"F(/" )"+(F'") ($) (6..-Ab*'"," .2+W(#) +'0$3, W"#" (6/.,+ 0$F0)"$+(67b !"#$"# +.6) /"Ab8 '() Q"32$ +. )"+(F' /5,"6- -#./ /5 ,2##.2$)0$3,@-#./ /5-(/0657 /5 -#0"$),7 /5 +"(F'"#,A !'(+ W(, 3.0$3 .$ W0+'0$ #"/.P")/" -#./ +'" W.#6) (#.2$) /"A O.# W(, +'"#" ($5.$" W0+' W'./ 8F.26) +(6Z (Q.2+ 0+A

    bY, 8 3#"W .6)"#7 ($) W"$+ 0$+. '03' ,F'..67 +'0, 6(FZ .- ($5.$"W0+' W'./ 8 F.26) ,'(#" W'(+ W(, /.,+ 0/:.#+($+ +. /" Q"F(/"0$F#"(,0$365 ,03$0-0F($+A 8 Q"F(/" P"#5 /2F' (6.$"@($) P"#5 6.$"65A

    b45 +'0, +0/" 8 W(, Q"F./0$3 (W(#" .- /5 0$+"6603"$F"A 42+ /5-(/065 :2+ /" .$ ")3" (Q.2+ 0+A *'"5 W.26) $.+ 6"+ 0+ Q"7 Q2+ (FF6(0/")0+7 ($) :#(0,") ($) "/Q(##(,,") /" W'"$ 8 6"+ 0+ ,'.W7 ($) Q"#(+") /"W'"$ 8 :2+ 0+ (W(5A *'0, .--"$)") /5 ,"$," .- (::#.:#0(+"$",,7 ($) 8

    Q"3($ +. Q" 0$+"66"F+2(6 .$65 0$ :#0P(+"Ab8+ ,""/") +. /" +'(+ /5 -(/065 F.26) $.+ #"(665 #",:.$) +. /5

    0$+"6603"$F"A Y+ )0,F2,,0.$ .$ +'" 6"P"6 .- .:0$0.$7 +'"5 W"#" 3..)f Q2+.$ +'" 6"P"6 .- (Q,+#(F+0.$7 +'"5 W"#" 2$"(,5A *'"5 W"#" $.+ :#.Q0$3.# #"-6"F+0P"A *'"5 )0) $.+ +#5 .2+ 0)"(,f +'"5 :#.$.2$F") 2:.$ +'"/A8$ +'.," -(/065 F.$P"#,(+0.$, .# )"Q(+",7 P(62(Q6" -.# /" (, +'"5 W"#"7+'"#" W(, 60++6" :#.F",, .- )0,,"F+0.$7 ($(65,0,7 ,5$+'",0,A !'"#"(, 8W(, Q5 $.W )0,,"F+0$3 "P"#5+'0$3 +'(+ 8 "$F.2$+"#")1 ( $.P"67 ( Q..Z.$ '.W +. ,2#P0P" 0$ +'" W..),7 ( +#"(+0," .$ /.2$+(0$ F60/Q0$37 ()0(6.32" .- E6(+.`,@W'(+"P"#A

    b*'" ,(/" W(, +#2" .- /5 +"(F'"#, ($) -#0"$),A U5 .6)#"6(+0.$,'0: W0+' /5 -#0"$) d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

    b8 W(, 0$+"#",+") 0$ +'" :#.Q6"/, .- '2/($ "X0,+"$F"7 '2/($#"6(+0.$,'0:7 6.P"7 ,"X7 +'" :2#:.," .- 0+ (667 P(62",7 "+'0F,7 0$+"3#0+5A 8

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    33/224

    F.26) $.+ )0,F2,, ,2F' +'0$3, W0+' /5 -(/0657 ,F'..6 -#0"$),7 .#+"(F'"#,A 8+ ,""/, +'(+ ($ ()26+ F.26) $.+ #"()065 +(6Z (Q.2+ ,2F' +'0$3,W0+' ( +""$C(3"# W0+'.2+ ,./"'.W /(Z0$3 +'" #"6(+0.$,'0: ,2,:"F+A*'0, W(, "P"$ +#2" .- /5 Q",+ +"(F'"#A d" ()/0#") +'" +'0$3, +'(+ 8W#.+" -.# '0/7 ($) '" ,2::.#+") /" ,2Q+65A 42+ W" F.26)$`+ #"(665 +(6Z(Q.2+ 0+A !" '() +. Z"": ,./" )0,+($F"A 8+ W(, (66 #03'+ +. W#0+" (Q.2+,2F' +'0$3,7 Q2+ $.+ +. +(6Z (Q.2+ +'"/A *'(+ W(, -.#Q0))"$ 0$+0/(F5A

    b8 -(6,"65 3"$"#(60T") /5 :"#F":+0.$7 ($) ,"+ /5,"6- "P"$ /.#"(:(#+7 F.$F62)0$3 +'(+ /.,+ .+'"# :".:6" )0) $.+ "X:"#0"$F" )"":65A 8,(W :".:6" (, ,'(66.WA *'0, W(, -..60,' (, 8 $.W Z$.W7 Q2+ 8 +..Z+'"0# (Q,"$F" .- "X:#",,0.$ (, ( ,03$ .- +'" (Q,"$F" .- )":+' .-"X:"#0"$F"A

    b!'"#"(,7 8 +'.23'+ +'(+ 8 W(, 3(0$0$3 -#./ /5 #"()0$3 +'" P"#5)":+' .- "X:"#0"$F"A *'2, 8 W(, ( +#2" ,.:'./.#"7 +'0$Z0$3 +'(+ 8 '())0,F.P"#") 60-"A

    b8 Z$"W +'(+ +'"#"7.$. :".:6"7 60P0$3 ($) )"()7 W'. '() :"$"+#(+") )"":65 0$+. +'"," /(++"#,A 42+ $. .$" W'./ 8 Z$"WA *'".$65 :6(F" W'"#" 8 F.26) -0$) Q.+' 0$+"66"F+ ($) )":+' .- "X:"#0"$F"W(, 0$ Q..Z,A

    b\$ ($.+'"# 6"P"67 8 W(, (6/.,+ 3#"3(#0.2,7b !"#$"# ,(0)7 ,/060$3W#565A b8 (##($3") ( 3#.2: -.# /5,"6- W0+' W'0F' 8 F.26) '(P" '"(#+5 Q2+ ,2:"#-0F0(6 #"6(+0.$,'0:,7 .$" +'(+ 8 F.26) "$+"# ($) W0+')#(W -#./(, 8 F'.,"7 ( 3#.2: +. W'0F' 8 W(, $.+ )"":65 (++(F'")A \$ +'0, 6"P"67 8

    :(#+0F0:(+") W0+' /5 ,F'..6 -#0"$),7 /.,+ .- W'./ W"#" (+'6"+",A!'06" F"#+(0$65 $.+ Q"0$3 '"66CQ"$+ +. Q" :(#+ .- +'" 3#.2:7 8 "P"$"$3(3") 0$ ,./" F.$P"$+0.$(6 ,+#2336" -.# +""$C(3" ,.F0(6 :.,0+0.$A42+ W'"$ :2,' F(/" +. ,'.P"7 6"(#$0$3@Q5 W'0F' 8 ).$`+ /"($,F'..6W.#Z@W(, /.#" 0/:.#+($+ +. /" +'($ /5 ,.F0(6 60-"A *'(+`,W'5 8 $"")") ( 3#.2: -#./ W'0F' 8 F.26) #"+#"(+A

    bY, 8 )"+(F'") -#./ (66 +'"," 3#.2:,7 -#./ -(/0657 -#0"$),7 ,.F0(660-"7 8 Q"3($ +. .Q,"#P" +'"/A 8 Q"3($ +. )"P"6.: ($ (6/.,+ E#.2,+0($0$+"#",+ 0$ +'" W.#6) .- /($$"#, ($) /.#(6,A 8 Q"3($ +. ,"" +'(+ /.,+

    :".:6" '() 30P"$ 2:7 +'(+ +'"5 3.+ $. ,(+0,-(F+0.$ -#./ 60-"7 ($) 6")60P", #0P"$ W0+' '5:.F#0,5A G$)"#$"(+' ( +'0$ P"$""#7 8 ,(W)",:"#(+0.$A

    b*'"#" W(, .$" Z0) (+ ,F'..6 W0+' W'./ 8 F.26) +(6Z7b !"#$"#,(0)A bd" W(, ( Q#0660($+ -"66.W $(/") 40667 F./:"+"$+ 0$ /(+'"/(+0F,($) ,F0"$F"7 W'. Q"F(/" ( $(2+0F(6 "$30$""#A d" W(, $.+ +'" 0$P"$+.#+5:"A d" '() ( /.#" (Q,+#(F+ Z0$) .- 0$+"66"F+A R#./ +0/" +. +0/" 8W.26) )#.: .2+ .- /5 ,.F0(6 ,"+ ($) ,:"$) +0/" W0+' '0/A d" )0)$`+

    Q"6.$3 +. ($5 ,.F0(6 ,"+A d" W(, 0$)":"$)"$+A e"+ ,./"'.W W" $"P"#",+(Q60,'") ( #"(6 #"6(+0.$,'0:A

    b8+ W(, /5 ,"$0.# &$360,' +"(F'"# W'. /.,+ '"6:") /" +. "X:#",,/5,"6- )2#0$3 +'0, +0/"A d" +(23'+ /" W'(+ ")2F(+0.$ F.26) Q"

    :.+"$+0(665A

    bd0, $(/" W(, V.$(6) !A H'(--"#A d0, F6(,, W(, .:"$ Q50$P0+(+0.$ (6.$"7 ($) W(, #",+#0F+") +. (Q6" ,+2)"$+,A 8+ W(, F.66"3"&$360,'A 8$ -(F+7 +'" /($ W(,$`+ +"(F'0$3 &$360,'f '" W(, +"(F'0$36"(#$0$3A d" )0)$`+ ). +"(F'"# ,+2--A d" )0)$`+ F.(F' ($5 +"(/,A Y$) '"W"$+ +. (, -"W -(F26+5 /""+0$3, (, '" F.26)A 8 W.$ ($ (W(#) -.# +'"W.#Z 8 )0) 0$ '0, F6(,,A U5 /.+'"# W"$+ 2: +. +'($Z '0/ (+ 3#()2(+0.$AH'" +.6) '0/ +'(+ 8 F.26)$`+ '(P" ).$" 0+ W0+'.2+ '0/A d" ,(0)7 `e",7+'(+`, #03'+7` ($) W(6Z") (W(5A 8+7#& #03'+7 ($) '" Z$"W 0+A d" W(, $.+(+ (66 :"#,.$(6 0$ '0, #"6(+0.$,'0:,A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    34/224

    b*'" -0#,+ +'0$3 '" )0) W(, +. (,Z 2, +. W#0+" ,./"+'0$3A&P"#5.$" W"$+ './" ($) W.#Z") 60Z" '"66 +#50$3 +. :6"(," '0/A !'"$+'" :(:"#, F(/" 0$7 '" :2+ +'"/ 0$ ( :06"7 ($) +'"$ ,'.P") +'"/ .-- '0,)",Z 0$+. +'" W(,+"Q(,Z"+@W0+'.2+ 6..Z0$3 (+ ($5 .- +'"/A d" ,(0)+'(+ '" Z$"W +'(+ +'"5 W"#" $.+ W'(+ '" W($+")A !" '()7 '" ,(0)7W#0++"$ ,+.#0",1 ,+2-- W" '() /()" 2:7 '() -032#") .2+7 '() )#"(/+ 2:Ad" ,(0) '" )0)$`+ W($+ ($5 #3-6'$& 0$ +'"#"A !'(+ '" W($+") 0, W'(+#"(665 '(::"$")A d" W($+") 2, +. W#0+" -#./ .2# "X:"#0"$F"Ab

    !"#$"# Q"(/")A b8 3.+ 0+l 8 3.+ "X(F+65 W'(+ '" ,(0)7 ($) 8 ,(+).W$ ($) W#.+" 0+ h2,+ (, 0+ W(,A 8 )0)$`+ +#5 +. /(Z" 0+ 6..Z 3..)A 8W#.+" ,+2-- +'(+ ,2#:#0,") '0/A d" W.26) #"() +'" :(:"#, (6.2),./"+0/",A d" W.26) ,+(#+ #"()0$3 /0$"7 ($) '(6-W(5 ).W$ +'" -0#,+

    :(3" '" W.26) ,+.: ($) F.$+0$2" #"()0$3 +. '0/,"6-A d" W.26) ,(5 +'(++'0, W(, +.. ()26+ +. #"() (6.2)A !#0+0$3 Q"F(/" +'" .$65 /")02/ 0$W'0F' 8 F.26) "X:#",, /5,"6-A H'(--"# :#.P0)") +'" ,:(F" 0$ W'0F' 8F.26) ). +'0,7 ($) '" (::#"F0(+")7 ($) c20"+65 (FZ$.W6")3")7 W'(+ 8W(, ).0$3A

    b&P"$+2(6657 '" F(66") /" ( .$"CF560$)"# g(/", g.5F"@g(/",g.5F" '0/,"6- Q"0$3 ($ "03'+CF560$)"# g(/", g.5F"A

    bU.,+ .- +'" +0/" 8 W#.+" ,'.#+ ,+.#0",A 42+ '" (6,. +(23'+ 2,",,(5 W#0+0$3A Y$) W" '() +. "X:($) .2# P.F(Q26(#0",Abd" '() ( 3#"(+ 3#()0$3 ,5,+"/A \$" 3#(//(+0F(6 "##.# W(, 47

    +W. W(, 97 +'#"" W(, V7 -.2# ($) 5.2 -(06")A d" ,(0) '" )0)$`+ 60Z" +.3#()" :(:"#,7 ($) 0- '" F.26) -0$) -.2# /0,+(Z", c20FZ65 '" )0)$`+ '(P"+. #"() +'" #",+ .- +'" :(:"#A d" 3.+ ($$.5") .$" )(5 Q"F(2," :".:6"W"#"$`+ :2$F+2(+0$3 F.##"F+65A d" ,(0) W" '() Q""$ +'#.23' "6"P"$5"(#, .- ,F'..67 ,+066 '()$`+ 6"(#$") +. :2$F+2(+"7 ($) W"#" $.W 3.0$3+. +(Z" .$" )(5 .2+ .- F6(,, ($) 6"(#$ .$F" ($) -.# (66A Y$) W" )0)A

    b!" ,+2)0") 60+"#(+2#" +..7b !"#$"# ,(0)A b8 3.+ +2#$") .$ +.H'(Z",:"(#" ($) +. E6(+.7 ,./" .- W'.," W.#Z, 8 '() #"() "(#60"#A!'(+ 0$+"#",+") /" (Q.2+ H'(Z",:"(#" W(, $.+ H'(Z",:"(#" +'"

    :6(5W#03'+A 8 W(, 0$+"#",+") 0$ '0, :'06.,.:'5A 8 W($+") +. 2$)"#,+($)

    60-" ($) .+'"# :".:6" ($) /5,"6-A 8+ W(, '"#" +'(+ 8 F(/" +. ,"" +'(+,./" :".:6" Z$"W :.W"#-2665 ($) 0$,03'+-2665A *'"5 )0)$`+ h2,+ '(P" ( :06" .- Z$.W6")3"f +'"5 F.26) :0"#F" 0$+. +'" :06"A 8 (6,. #"/"/Q"##"()0$3 "A"A F2//0$3,7 *'".).#" V#"0,"#7 ($) *'./(, !.6-"A 8 W(,",:"F0(665 0/:#",,") Q5 g(/", g.5F"7 :(#+0F26(#65 Q5 I ,'$-$#5- 'K -6.

    I$-5&- #& # 8'3(D Y#(+ bY, ( #",26+ .- W'(+ 8 W(, #"()0$37 8 F.$F62)") +'(+ #"(60+5 W(, (

    Q(FZ (66"5A U($5 :".:6" /2,+ 3. +'#.23' ( )(#Z :"#0.) (, +""$C(3"#,W'"#" #"(60+5 0, )0#+5 ($) ).W$A

    b8 Q"3($ +. ,"" +'" ,'(/ 0$ 60-"f +'(+ #"(60+5 0, $.+ .$ +'" ,2#-(F"7+'(+ 0+ 0, )(#Z ($) )0#+5 0$ +'" ,"$," .- Q"0$3 '0))"$A 8 ).$`+ /"($ `)0#+5`0$ +'" F.$P"$+0.$(6 /0))6"CF6(,, ,"$,"A G$)"# +'" 0$-62"$F" .- +'"$.P"60,+,7 +'" F.$P"$+0.$(6 ,"$," .- )0#+5` Q"F(/" 0##"6"P($+7 "P"$

    /"($0$36",, -.# /"A !'(+ W(, )0#+5 W(, 6(FZ .- 0$+"3#0+57 $.+"(#+'0$",,A *'(+ 0, W'(+ /(Z", :".:6" )#(QA E".:6" '() )0#+5 60++6","F#"+,A &(#+'0$",,7 Q5 F.$+#(,+7 Q"3($ +. Q" (::"(60$3 ($) (66.W(Q6"A 8+(+ 6"(,+ W(, #"(6A

    bY3(0$ 8 :"#F"0P") +'(+ W'(+ W(, #"(6 W(, $.+ ,:.Z"$ (Q.2+AE".:6" )0) $.+ )0,F2,, W'(+ W(, #"(665 3.0$3 .$ W0+' +'"/A e"+ +'"0#)0#+5 60++6" ,"F#"+, W"#" )0#+5 .$65 Q"F(2," +'"5 W"#" '"6) (, ,"F#"+,@ ($) 0$)"") ,"F#"+, W'0F' +'"5 '"6) +. Q" )0#+5A E".:6" )"/"($") +'"0#.W$ "X:"#0"$F"A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    35/224

    bH"P"#(6 :6(5, ,2::.#+") /" 0$ +'0, "X:"#0"$F"7b !"#$"# W"$+ .$7b:(#+0F26(#65 *"$$",,"" !0660(/,`, W6. S"#&& Y.(#D.$5. ($) IR-$..-1#$ *#A.: 9.&5$.+ W6. S"#&& Y.(#D.$5./ /.#" +'($ ($5+'0$3"6,"7 ,+(+") +'" c20"+ )",:"#(+0.$ 2$)"#650$3 60-"A 8 0)"$+0-0") W0+' 0+,'"#.7 *./A *./ -""6, +#(::") Q5 '0, -(/065@'0, $(330$3 /.+'"# ($)'0, F#0::6") ,0,+"#A R0$(6657 '" #2$, (W(5 -#./ './"A

    b8 W.26) ,+(5 2: (66 $03'+ +. #"()7b !"#$"# +.6) /"A b8 W.26),+2)5 2$+06 +'" ,2$ F(/" 2:A 8 W.26) 3. +. ,6"": -.# ($ '.2# .# +W. ($)+'"$ W(Z" 2:7 Q2+ 8 .-+"$ F.26)$`+ 3"+ (W(Z" "$.23' +. 3. +. ,F'..6A 8,:"$+ /5 6(,+ 5"(# 0$ ,F'..6 +'0, W(5Ab

    b8+ W(, +"##0Q6"7b V.#.+'5 +.6) /"A b8 Z":+ $(330$3 '0/7 +#50$3 +.3"+ '0/ .2+ .- Q") -.# ,F'..6A *'" Z0), W.26) /(Z" Q"+, (Q.2+W'"+'"# '" W(, 3.0$3 +. /(Z" +'" ,F'..6 Q2,A d" W.26) F./" +"(#0$3(#.2$) +'" F.#$"# (+ +'" 6(,+ /0$2+" +. F(+F' 0+A \$" /.#$0$3 +'",F'..6 :#0$F0:(6 F(66") ($) +'#"(+"$") +. "X:"6 '0/ 0- '" )0)$`+ F./".$ +0/"A

    b!"#$"# W(, ,+066 ,6"":0$37 ,. 8 W.Z" g." ($) +.6) '0/7 ($) (,Z")'0/ +. 3"+ !"#$"# .2+ .- Q")A g." ,+.#/") 0$+. '0, #../7 :0FZ") '0/

    2: Q.)0657 #03'+ .2+ .- Q")7 ($) ,+..) '0/ .$ '0, -""+A *'"$ '" :2$F'")'0/ 0$ +'" "5"A !"#$"# -6"W (F#.,, +'" #../Ab8 W(, 2:,"+7b V.#.+'5 ,(0)A b8 '() $.+ /"($+ -.# g." +. '0+ '0/A

    42+ g." W(, ($$.5")A d" '() W.#Z") (66 $03'+7 ($) '() .$65 Q""$(,6"": -.# (Q.2+ ($ '.2#A 8 '() :266") '0/ .2+ .- Q") +..A !"#$"#)0)$`+ 3"+ +. ,F'..6 (+ (66 +'(+ )(5A d" '() +. Q($)(3" '0, "5" ($) '"W.26)$`+ 6"+ /" '"6: '0/ W0+' 0+A d" W"$+ .-- +. ["#/($+.W$ +. ,+(5W0+' '0, 3#($)/.+'"#A R#./ +'(+ +0/" .$7 '" #($ '0, .W$ 60-"Ab

    *'0, W(, $. (FF0)"$+A *'0, W(, $.#" :2$0,'/"$+A 8 ,:.Z" +.!"#$"# (Q.2+ +'" F.$-62"$F" .- -.#F", "$+"#0$3 0$+. +'0, 0$F0)"$+A

    b8 '() (6W(5, +'.23'+ +'(+ /5 -(+'"# ,(W +'0$3, +'" W(5 8 )0)7b!"#$"# ,(0)A bd(P0$3 0)"$+0-0") W0+' '0/7 8 W.26) $(+2#(665 (,,2/"+'(+ '" (3#"") W0+' A.i *'0, W(, ,. "P"$ +'.23' 8 ,(W '0/ (, +(Z0$3 (

    6.+ .- $.$,"$," -#./ /5 /.+'"#Ab!'"$ '" :2$F'") /"7 '" ,'0-+")@(+ 6"(,+ -#./ /5 :.0$+ .-P0"W@-#./ '0, $.#/(6 :.,0+0.$7 W'0F' 8 ,(W (+ W.#,+ (, #"6(+0P"65$"2+#(67 (, ,0/:65 3.0$3 (6.$3 W0+' /5 /.+'"#A 8$,+"()7 '" (F+0P"65+..Z '"# :.,0+0.$A 8$,+"() .- Q"0$3 ( -"66.W +#(P"6"# W0+' /"7 '"

    Q"F(/" +'" "$"/5 +..Ab*'(+ Q6.W F.$-0#/") (66 /5 W.#,+ -""60$3,A !'(+ 0+ ,(0) +. /"

    W(,7 `["+ .2+ .- '"#"A e.2 (#" $.+ W($+") (#.2$) '"#" ($5/.#"A` b

    ,IW !"#$"# )0) $.+ W($+ +. #"+2#$ './"7 ($) W.26) '(P" ,+(5") 0$["#/($+.W$ W0+' '0, 3#($):(#"$+, '() +'(+ $.+ Q""$ +.. -(# (W(5-#./ '0, 30#6 -#0"$)7 E(+A R.# '" W(, (6,. 0$ +'" +'#.", .- '0, -0#,+

    3#.W$C2: #./($F"1 3#.W$C2:7 Q2+ W0+' (66 +'" 2$Q"(#(Q6"7 :($+0$37).360Z" (#).# .- ().6",F"$F"Ab8`66 $"P"# -.#3"+ +'" )(5 8 /"+ '0/7b E(+ 9(/:Q"66 +.6) /"A !"

    ,(+ +(6Z0$3 0$ +'" 60P0$3 #../ .- '"# (:(#+/"$+ 0$ H($ R#($F0,F.7 W'"#",'" 0, ( /"/Q"# .- +'" .&- ,+(--A mH'" ,+066 F(##0", +'" $(/" .- '"#,"F.$) '2,Q($)7 -#./ W'./ ,'" 0, )0P.#F")A d"# /(0)"$ $(/" 0, E(+R#5An E(+ 0, ($ (++#(F+0P"7 F'""#-267 ($) P26$"#(Q6" Q6.$)" W./($7 W0+'( Z""$ ,"$," .- '2/.#A H'" W(, .QP0.2,65 (/2,") Q5 '"# ,+.#5A R#./+0/" +. +0/" '"# P.0F" :"(6") W0+' 6(23'+"#A H'" W(, (6,. (+ +0/", .$+'" P"#3" .- +"(#,A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    36/224

    b*'" -0#,+ +0/" '" W(6Z") +'#.23' .2# './"#../ )..# (+ O.##0,+.W$ d03' HF'..67 (+ +'" Q"30$$0$3 .- .2# h2$0.# 5"(#7 8 +..Z.$" 6..Z (+ '0/7b ,'" +.6) /"7 b($) ,./"+'0$3 /(30F(6 '(::"$")A 8F($$.+ :2+ 0+ 0$+. W.#),A 8 Z$"W +'(+ 8 W(, 3.0$3 +. Q" /(##0") +. '0/($) +'(+ '" W(, 3.0$3 +. Q" -(/.2, ($) ,2FF",,-26A `*'0$3, (#" 3.0$3+. Q" 3#"(+l` 8 +'.23'+ +. /5,"6-Ab

    *'"5 W"#" 0$ ,"P"#(6 F6(,,", +.3"+'"#f ($) (#.2$) +'" "$) .- O.P"/Q"# +'"5 W"$+ .2+ -.# +'" -0#,+ +0/"A

    b!'"$ 8 -0#,+ -"66 -.# '0/7 /5 -#0"$), +'.23'+ 8 W(, F#(T5A d"W(, $"W (+ ,F'..6 ($) ,""/") (##.3($+A d" W(, P"#5 .2+,:.Z"$7b E(+,(0)A b42+ -.# /" '" '() W'(+ 0+ W(, 3.0$3 +. +(Z" -.# W'(+"P"# '" W(,3.0$3 +. ). 0$ 60-"Ab

    E(+ 60P") F6.," +. +'" '03' ,F'..6 ($)7 (, +'" 5"(# W.#" .$7!"#$"# Q"3($ +. ,:"$) /.#" ($) /.#" +0/" W0+' '"#A d" W.26) 3.'./" W0+' '"# (-+"# ,F'..6 ($) ,+(5 -.# )0$$"#A bU5 /.+'"# 2,") +.,(5 ,'" +'.23'+ '" W.26) $"P"# 3. './"7b E(+ ,(0)A b42+ W" W"#" 0$6.P"Ab

    *'"5 (6,. ,:"$+ W""Z"$), +.3"+'"#7 3.0$3 (#.2$) W0+' +W.-#0"$), W'. 6(+"# /(##0")A *'"5 W"$+ +. /.P0",7 +. Q(,Z"+Q(66 3(/",7

    +. ,W0//0$3 /""+,7 ($) +. +'" -..+Q(66 3(/",7 W'"#" E(+ W(, ( )#2//(h.#"++"A *'"5 W"$+ +. +'" :6(5'.2," 0$ +'" :(#Z ($) +. ( +""$C(3"'($3.2+ -.# '(/Q2#3"#, ($) /06Z ,'(Z",A *'"5 W.26) )#0P" .P"# -#./+0/" +. +0/" +. S.W"# U"#0.$ -.# :(#+0", W0+' !"#$"#`, .6) -#0"$),AS(+"# +'"5 (++"$)") +'" h2$0.# ($) ,"$0.# :#./, ($) +'" ,F'..6

    Q($c2"+,A H"P"#(6 +0/", +'"5 :6(5") '..Z"5 -#./ ,F'..67 3.0$3 +. +'","(,'.#" .# +. _(66"5 R.#3" E(#ZA

    8$ +'" )"$,"65 :(FZ") ($) (#)"$+ "X:"#0"$+0(6 +0/" .- ($().6",F"$+ 30#6 ($) Q.5 +'"5 )#"W P"#5 F6.,"A R.# '0, W#0+0$3 F6(,,7!"#$"# W#.+" ( :."/7 #"-"##0$3 +. E(+7 F(66") bH2$#0,"Ab

    H2//"# ,2$#0," 0, ( '.$"5C'(0#") 30#6!#03360$3 '"# +.",7

    9#.2F'") .$ +'" /.,,C,.-+ Q62" '(T" .- ( '066f*'" '(0#C+'0$7 3.6)"$ ,+#($), ,:"FZ6") W0+' ,'0//"#0$3)"W)#.:,A

    O. /.#$0$3 '"#(6)7*'0, F'06) .- 6(Q.#0$3 $03'+7U(+2#") /.#$0$3 0$ ( /./"$+f4"6.$3, +. ( )0(/.$)C-6"FZ") F(#Q.$ $03'+A

    I0$30$37 Q6"(#5C"5") /.#$0$37V(TT6", -2667 '"(P5AHW"(+C,.(Z") ,+0FZ0$3 ,'""+,79#5 -0P" /.#" /0$2+",A

    d"(P57 .::#",,0P" (0# ,+($)0$3 ,+(#Z7S0Z" ( F.#$"#") ($0/(6@-#03'+"$")7 :.$)"#.2,7 :#"/.$0+0.2,A46(FZC3#""$ 3#(,, Q066.W0$3 0$ c20P"#0$3 -"(#7G$)"# -6""+0$3 3#(5CQ6(FZ7 '(T") -2#57H+066@c20"+ ,+066@:.$)"#.2, ,+066A

    E(+ ($) !"#$"# '() Q""$ 3.0$3 +.3"+'"# -.# $"(#65 ( 5"(# Q"-.#",'" /"+ '0, -(/065A 8$ +'" -(66 .-

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    37/224

    +. 0$+#.)2F" '"# +. '0, W0)"# -(/065A d" +..Z '"# +. ,"" d"6"$"7 .$" .-'0, -(P.#0+" F.2,0$,7 g."`, $0"F"7 +'" )(23'+"# .- '0, Q#.+'"# R#($ZAd"6"$"7 (6.$" (/.$3 +'" /"/Q"#, .- +'" -(/0657 '() ,2::.#+") '0/W'"$ '" '() W($+") +. 3. 0$+. +'" U(#0$",A d"6"$" #"/"/Q"#,!"#$"# (+ +'0, +0/" (, b,"(#F'0$3Ab b8 ).$`+ +'0$Z 0+ 0, #./($+0F0T0$3 +.,(5 +'(+ '" '(, #"(6 )":+'A 8 -"6+ 0+ +'"$7 ($) 8 -""6 0+ $.WA 42+ 8 ).$`++'0$Z +'(+ +'"#" W(, ($5 )"-0$0+" )0#"F+0.$ +. '0, ,"(#F' 5"+A d" W(,+#50$3 +. -0$) .2+ W'"#" '" -0+ 0$7 W'"#" '" W(, 3.0$37 ($) W'(+ '" W(,3.0$3 +. ).A d" Z$"W ( 6.+ .- &$360,' 60+"#(+2#"7 ($) 0+ W(, -2$ +. +(6ZW0+' '0/A E(+ )0)$`+ ,(5 /2F' W'"$ W" W"#" +.3"+'"#7 Q2+ ,'".QP0.2,65 ().#") '0/Ab

    !"#$"# W.26) +(6Z W0+' d"6"$" (Q.2+ W#0+0$3A bd" W#.+" W"667 Q2+ '" '() 3.++"$ 0$+. +#.2Q6" .P"# 0+ W0+' V.#.+'5A d" '() W#0++"$,./" +'0$3, +'(+ W"#" ,2::.,") +. Q" ()P($F") ,"X2(665 -.# +'" +0/"Abd"6"$" W(, #"-"##0$3 +. bH2$#0,"b ($) +. ($ ",,(5 "$+0+6") bd0,E#","$F"7b ,"+ 0$ ( F'2#F' F.$-",,0.$(67 W'0F' !"#$"# '() W#0++"$ -.#'0, &$360,' F6(,,A *'" ",,(5 ,:"(Z, .- ,0$ ($) +"/:+(+0.$7 ($) .- +'"

    :(#().X", .- )",+0$5 ($) -#"")./1

    *'" )..# ,F#(:") F6.,") Q"'0$) /"A 8 Z$"6+ ).W$ c20"+65 .$ +'"#") P"6P"+ F2,'0.$ ($) ,60) /5 (#/, +. +'" ,0)", .- +'" ,+($)A 8$+'" O(/" .- +'" R(+'"# ($) .- +'" H.$A A A A *'" (0# 0$ /5 62$3,

    :2,'") (3(0$,+ /5 F'",+ Q"F(2," 0$ ,:"(Z0$3 ,. ,.-+657 8 )0)$`+2," 0+ -(,+ "$.23'A

    A A A ($) .- +'" d.65 ['.,+A Y/"$A

    46",, /"7 R(+'"#7 -.# 8 '(P" ,0$$")A 8 +W0#6") +'" +'2/Q+(FZ +'(+'.6), +'" :#(5"# F(#) 0$ :6(F" ($) W'"$ +'" :#0",+`, P.0F" )#.::")8 W"$+ .$A

    8 F.$-",, +. Y6/03'+5 [.)7 +. 46",,") U(#5 &P"#C_0#30$7 +. (66+'" H(0$+,7 ($) +. 5.27 R(+'"#7 +'(+ 8 '(P" ,0$$") P"#5 /2F' 0$+'.23'+A A A A

    W6. R#5(- R75-65(_& ,$#;.$ B''% W(, .:"$") +. +'" 60,+ .- ,0$, ($)8 W"$+ ).W$ 0+ #(++60$3 +'"/ .--7 "XF":+ +'(+ .$" 8 F.26) $"P"#

    Q#0$3 /5,"6- +. +"66 +'0, /($ W'. W(, /5 -#0"$) (, W"66 (, /5 :#0",+ ($) W'. Z$"W /" Q5 +'" ,.2$) .- /5 P.0F"A 8+ W(,$`+#"(665 ( ,0$7 -.# 8 (6W(5, h2)3") Q5 (,Z0$3 /5,"6- 0- 8 W.26) ).+'0, +'0$3 0- g",2, W"#" ,+($)0$3 0$ -#.$+ .- /"A 8 6.P") '"# ($)($5+'0$3 +'(+ '(::"$") W(, 3..) ($) '(::"$") .$65 Q"F(2," .-6.P"A

    Y, +'" :#0",+ +(6Z") 8 +'.23'+ .- +'" ,/06" +'(+ /5 F.$-",,0.$/03'+ Q#0$3 +. [.)`, -(F"A \- F.2#,"7 (66 +'(+ 8 ). ($) (/ +. ).W(, W#0++"$ 0$ +'" Q..Z, 6.$3 Q"-.#" 8 W(, Q.#$7 Q2+ ,+066 5.2F.26)$`+ ,(5 +'" )"P06 W0+' 0+ ($) ). (, 5.2 #"(665 :6"(,")A !"667 832",, 5.2 F.26)$`+ ,(5 0+ Q"F(2," 0+ W(, W#0++"$ +'(+ 5.2 W.26)$`+AR2$$57 5.2 F($ ). W'(+ 5.2 W($+ Q2+ +'"#" 0, .$65 .$" +'0$3 +.).7 ,. 5.2 ). 0+A

    *'0, +0/" 8 W(,$`+ 3.0$3 +. ). ($5+'0$3 W#.$31 8 ,(0) +'(+ /($5+0/", Q"-.#"7 Q2+ +'0, +0/" 8 /"($+ 0+A V(/$ 0+7 $.+'0$3 W(, 3.0$3+. /(Z" /" ,0$A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    38/224

    8$ g2$" !"#$"# 3#()2(+") -#./ '03' ,F'..6A Y6/.,+0//")0(+"65 (-+"#W(#)7 '" W"$+ +. O"W e.#Z 90+5 -.# ( '.60)(5A *'"$'" #"+2#$") './"7 W'"#" -.# ,"P"#(6 W""Z, '" 6(5 Q#..)0$3 (Q.2+ +'"'.2,"7 +"/:.#0T0$37 /(#Z0$3 +0/"A !'(+ W(, '" +. ). $.Wj

    R.# ( W'06"7 '" ",F(:") -#./ '0, +'.23'+, Q5 :6(50$3 W0+' +'"F'06)#"$A

    b\$" .- +'" +'0$3, +'(+ +'"5 2,") +. ,"66 0$ *0/", Hc2(#" 0,+2#+6",7b !"#$"# ,(0)A b*'"5 '(P" +'" &/:0#" H+(+" 4206)0$3 :(0$+") .$+'" Q(FZ .- +'"/7 .# +'"5 :#0$+ 5.2# $(/"7 .# W'(+"P"#A 8 3.+ /5 ,0,+"#g.($ .$" .- +'","A 8 '() +'" /($ W#0+" g.($ .$ +'" Q(FZ .- +'" +2#+6"($) '() 0+ /(06") Q(FZ +. +'" '.2," 0$ E65/.2+' U""+0$3A

    bY -"W W""Z, 6(+"# 8 W"$+ './"A 8 W(, ,0++0$3 0$ +'" 60P0$3 #../($) /5 ,0,+"# F(/" 0$ F#50$3A !0+' +'.," 3#"(+ Q03 #(FZ0$3 ,.Q, +'(+.$65 ( -0P"C5"(#C.6) 0, F(:(Q6" .-7 30($+ (6603(+.# +"(#, #.660$3 ).W$ '"#F'""Z,A 8 :2+ /5 (#/, (#.2$) '"# ($) :266") '"# 2: .$+. /5 6(: ($)'"6) '"#A Y-+"# ( W'06" ,'" F(6/") ).W$ ( Q0+ ($) 8 (,Z") '"# W'(+W(, +'" /(++"#A Y$) ,'" ,(0)7 `*'" +2#+6" )0")7` ($) ,+(#+") +. F#5 (66.P"# (3(0$A 8- 5.2`#" -0P" 5"(#, .6) 5.2 F($ /(Z" ( Q",+ -#0"$) .2+ .- (+2#+6"A

    bU5 60++6" +'#""C5"(#C.6) Q#.+'"#7 d(##57 W(, ,+($)0$3 0$ -#.$+ .-+'" F'(0# 60Z" ( Q0#) ).3 '.$.#0$3 +'" :.0$+A 8+ W(,$`+ '0, +2#+6"7 ,. +'"+#(3")5 )0)$`+ #"(665 +.2F' '0/A 42+ '" W(, ,.6"/$ -.# +'" .FF(,0.$A*'"$ 8 ,(0)7 `!"667 8 32",, W"`66 '(P" +. Q2#5 +'" +2#+6"A` g.($ ,+.::")F#50$3 ( 60++6"7 ,. 8 Z$"W 8 W(, .$ +'" #03'+ +#(FZA 8 Z":+ 3.0$3A 8 ,(0)7`e"('7 W"`66 3"+ ( /(+F'Q.X7 ($) W"`66 60$" +'" /(+F'Q.X ($) W"`66/(Z" ( 3#(P",+.$"7 ($) W"`66 '(P" ( W'.6" -2$"#(6A` 45 +'0, +0/" +'"#"W(, $. /.#" F#50$3A *'"#" W"#" /(+F'", ,:066") -#./ +'" /(+F'Q.X (66.P"# +'" Z0+F'"$ -6..#7 ($) d(##5 Q#.23'+ +'" ,:()"A 8 6") "P"#5Q.)5.2+,0)"A !" 60$") +'" F(,Z"+ W0+' +0$-.06 ($) )23 +'" 3#(P" ($) /()" ('"(),+.$"A !" W"#" #"()5A 8 ,(0)7 `!"667 g.($7 W" '(P" +. 3"+ +'"+2#+6"A !'"#" 0, 0+j` H'" ,(0)7 `8+`, 0$ +'" )"$A` H. W" W"$+ Q(FZ 0$ +'"'.2," ($) 0$+. +'" )"$7 ($) $. +2#+6" W(, +'"#"A 8 3.+ ).W$ .$ /5

    '($), ($) Z$"", ($) W(, 6..Z0$3 (#.2$) 2$)"# +'" -2#$0+2#" -.# +'"+2#+6"A H2#" "$.23'7 2$)"# .$" .- +'" ,.-(,7 +'"#" W(, +'" +2#+6"7W(6Z0$3 (6.$3A

    bH. 8 ,(0)7 `g.($7 g.($7 W" ).$`+ '(P" +. '(P" +'" -2$"#(67 +'"+2#+6"`, (60P"A` H'" 6..Z") .2+#(3")7 ($) ,(0)7 `a066 0+l a066 0+l a066 0+l` b

    H2F' )0,+#(F+0.$, W"#" .$65 +"/:.#(#5A !"#$"#`, +'.23'+, +2#$")(3(0$ ($) (3(0$ +. +'" c2",+0.$ .- W'(+ +. ).A 8+ W(, ( )"60F(+"c2",+0.$A d0, 60-" W(, .P"#F./" W0+' 0$"#+0(7 :(,,0P0+57 0$)"F0,0.$A

    d" W(,$`+ W.#Z0$37 ($) '() $. #"(6 :6($, +. 3"+ ( h.QA \- F.2#,"0+ W(, (,,2/") +'(+ '" W.26) 3. +. F.66"3"7 Q2+ '" '()$`+ "P"$ (::60")76"+ (6.$" +(Z"$ ()/0,,0.$ +",+,A b*'0$3, W"#" 6..,"C"$)")7b '" ,(0)A b8

    h2,+ 6"+ +'0$3, ,60)"A 8 W(, #"650$3 .$ V.#.+'5 +. +"66 /" +. (::65 -.#F.66"3"A 8 +.6) /5,"6- +'(+ 0- ,'" )0)$`+ F(#" 8 )0)$`+ F(#" "0+'"#A Y$) 8

    )0)$`+ +'0$Z ,'" F(#")Ab42+ V.#.+'5 W(, $.+ $(330$3 '0/ ($5 6.$3"#f $.# W(, +'"0##"6(+0.$,'0: ,. 0$+"$,"A bH'" '() Q"F./" /.#" .#)0$(#5 -.# /"7b!"#$"# ,(0)A b8 -"6+ +'(+ ,'" W(, ).$" W0+' /" $.W +'(+ 8 '() -0$0,'")'03' ,F'..67 +'(+ ,'" "X:"F+") /" +. 6"(P" +'" '.2,"Ab

    O.$" .- +'" .::.#+2$0+0", +'(+ $.W :#","$+") +'"/,"6P", ,""/")+. 6"() ($5 :6(F" +'(+ '" W($+") +. 3.7 ($) ,./" :.0$+") 0$ )0#"F+0.$,+'(+ '" )0) $.+ W($+ +. :2#,2"A *'0, W(, +#2" "P"$ .- F.66"3"A b8 W.26)'(P" 60Z") +. F.$+0$2" +. ). +'" +'0$3, +'(+ 8 '() ).$" .$ /5 .W$ ($)

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    39/224

    0$ /5 &$360,' F6(,, )2#0$3 /5 ,"$0.# 5"(#7b '" ,(0)A b42+ 8 )0)$`+ ,"",F'..6 (, ( :6(F" +. :2#,2" 0)"(,Ab d" W#.+" ( :."/ (Q.2+ '0, -2+2#"1

    @6#-_& 5( -6. !#$:& !'(+`, 0$ +'" F(#),j*"(F'"#, ,(5 F.66"3"A*'" /($ 0$ +'" Q62"C)5") (#/5 F6.+'",7W'. "(+, '0, )0$$"# 0$ +'" )#23,+.#"7,(5, 5.2`66 -0$) ( './" 0$ +'" (#/5A

    !'(+`, 0$ +'" F(#),j[0#6, ,(5 +W. F($ 60P" (, F'"(:65 (, .$"A*'" Q6(FZC,20+") /($ W0+' +'" '.66.W /.2+'7W'. )#0$Z, '0, +"( ($) #"(), +'" :(:"#7).",$`+ ,(5 ($5+'0$3A

    !'(+`, 0$ +'" F(#),j*'" )0+F')033"# ,(5, /(Z" ( /0$+76"(#$ ( +#()"7 ,.$A

    *'" (), 0$ +'" /(3(T0$" ,(51bo

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    40/224

    b!" W"#" :6($$0$3 +. 3. ,W0//0$3 +'(+ "P"$0$37b O.#/ +.6) /"Ab!" W"#" ,0++0$3 +.3"+'"# (+ /5 :6(F" +(6Z0$37 ($) +'"$ !"#$"#"XF2,") '0/,"6- +. +"6":'.$" E(+A d" +(6Z") W0+' '"#@8 F.26)$`+ '"(#W'(+ +'"5 W"#" ,(50$3@+'"$ '2$3 2: +'" :'.$" ($) F(/" Q(FZ 0$+.+'" #../A d" W(, (Q,.62+"65 W'0+"A 8 (,Z") W'(+ W(, +'" /(++"#7 ($)'" ,(0)7 E(+ 0, :#"3$($+A` b

    !"#$"# '() '() ($.+'"# b(FF0)"$+Ab 8+ '() '(::"$") ( -"W/.$+', "(#60"#7 ,'.#+65 (-+"# +'(+ Q0++"# /.#$0$3 0$ E65/.2+' U""+0$37W'"$ g." '() :266") '0/ #.23'65 .2+ .- Q") ($) ,+#2FZ '0/ 0$ +'" "5"A

    O.#/ F.$+0$2") '0, (FF.2$+A b!'"$ 8 (,Z") !"#$"# W'(+'" W(, 3.0$3 +. ). (Q.2+ E(+7 '" #":60") +'(+ '" )0)$`+ Z$.WA d"'() h2,+ (,Z") '"#7 .P"# +'" :'.$"7 W'"+'"# ,'" W($+") +. 3"+/(##0")A

    b8 +#0") +. +(6Z '0/ .2+ .- +'(+A d" W(, .$65 ,"P"$+""$ 5"(#,.6)A 8 +.6) '0/ $.+ +. #2,'b '"()6.$3 0$+. ( /(##0(3"7 ($) .--"#")+. 30P" '0/ +'" /.$"5 -.# ($ (Q.#+0.$A 8 W(, 3.0$3 W0+' ( $2#,"(+ +'" +0/" ($) 8 +'.23'+ 8 F.26) (##($3" 0+A 42+ '" ,(0) +. /""/:'(+0F(6657 `8 ).$`+ W($+ +. ). +'(+A` b

    !"#$"# #"+2#$") +. E'06()"6:'0( 0//")0(+"65A b!")0,F2,,") +'" W'.6" /(++"# F(#"-2665 +'"$7b E(+ +.6) /"A b*'"#"W(, $. $"") -.# 2, +. 3"+ /(##0")A 8 F.26) '(P" :2+ +'" Q(Q5 .2+-.# ().:+0.$A !" )0)$`+ +'0$Z .- 0+ (, ( F(+(,+#.:'"A !" W"$+.P"# (66 +'" :#., ($) F.$, ($) )"F0)") +'(+ W" #"(665 W($+") +.3"+ /(##0")A !" W"#" 0$ 6.P"Ab

    O. .$" "6," W(, ,. ,2#"A *'" 0)"( .- ($ (Q.#+0.$ F(/" 2:(3(0$ ($) (3(0$A !"#$"#`, 2$F6" g0/ 96(2,.$ ($) .+'"# -#0"$),(6,. P.62$+""#") +. '"6: (##($3" .$"A 42+ !"#$"# #"h"F+") +'"0)"( -6(+65@(, )0) V.#.+'5A *'" 0)"( W(, $"P"# /"$+0.$") +.E(+A

    V.#.+'5 W(, +"##0Q65 2:,"+A b!'"$ !"#$"# F(/" './" ($),(0) +'(+ '" W(, 3.0$3 +. /(##5 E(+7 0+ W(, 60Z" ( )"(+' $.+0F" +./"7b V.#.+'5 ,(0)A b8 '() :2+ ,. /2F' 0$+. '0/7 ($) :6($$") -.#'0/ +. 3. +. F.66"3"A 8 ,(W +'(+ 3#"(+ :.+"$+0(6 3.0$3 ).W$ +'")#(0$A &P"$ +'" :#0",+ (+ /5 /.+'"#`, F'2#F' ,(0) +. /"7`V.#.+'57 5.2 Z$.W +'"5 ).$`+ '(P" +. 3"+ /(##0")A` &P"$ +'"

    :#0",+ W(, $.+ 0$ -(P.# .- 0+l 8 #":60") +'(+ (, 8 ,(W 0+ '" )0)0$)"") '(P" +. 3"+ /(##0")A *'(+ W(, "X(F+65 W'(+ '() +. Q").$"Ab

    \::.#+2$0+5 '() Q"F./" .Q603(+0.$A !"#$"# ($) E(+ W"#"/(##0") 0$ E(+`, F'2#F'7 *#0$0+5 &P($3"60F(6 ($) I"-.#/")9'2#F'7 .$ H":+"/Q"# D]7 7 h2,+ +'#"" W""Z, (-+"# '0,

    "03'+""$+' Q0#+')(5A

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    41/224

    R\GI V"#(06") *..:".& #(: G5(&/ (..:".& #(: G5(&/@6.( # A#( A#$$5.& 65& -$'34". 4.D5(&+

    eY'-6.$ S''&.

    ]5& (#-3$. 7#& ('- $.A'$&.".&&/ 43- -' .&1#G. K$'A # -$#G 6. 6#& -'#1- 75-6'3- G5-;+

    @ W.((.&&.. @5""5#A&

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

    !0+' '0, /(##0(3" +. E(+7 !"#$"# 6.,+ '0, F'($F" -.# ,2F' (/.#(+.#02/A d" W(, $.W +. "$/",' '0/,"6-7 Q"F./0$3 /.#"($) /.#" )"":65 .P"#F.//0++") +. W'(+ '" W(, $.+A d" '()$.W'"#" +. F./" -#./ ($) $.W'"#" +. 3.A 8+ W(, +'" b'.6.F(2,+.- .$"`, "X:"#0"$F" .$ +'" (6+(# .- F.$-.#/0+5Ab < d" '() b).$" +'"#03'+ +'0$3b (Q.2+ '0,A /(##0(3"A d" ($) E(+ '() :#.)2F") $. Q(,+(#)

    ($) $. (Q.#+0.$A 8+ W(, ($ "X:"$,0P" ,.#+ .- #03'+".2,$",,7 ( F.,+65'.$.#A *'.23' '" )0) $.+ ,"" 0+ +'"$7 +'" ,(F#0-0F" 0$P.6P") W(, (6/.,+'"#.0FA

    V0,F2,,0$3 P(#0.2, /0,2,", +. W'0F' +'" 9'#0,+0($ ).F+#0$" .-,(F#0-0F" /(5 Q" :2+7 ($ "/0$"$+ +'".6.30($ '(, W#0++"$1 b*. ,(F#0-0F".2#,"6P", 0,7 0+ 0, ,(0)7 +. #"(60T" +'" 0/(3" .- +'" F#2F0-0")7 W'"#"(, +'","6-C,(F#0-0F0$3 /(5 ,0/:65 Q" /2+06(+0$3 '0/,"6-7 :2#:.,0P"65)",+#.50$3 +'" ,W""+$",, .- "X0,+"$F" 0$ +'" $(/" .- 0662,0.$7 0$ .#)"#+. /(Z" '0/,"6- ( '"#. 0$ '0, .W$ "5",A A A A *'" "+'0F .- ,(F#0-0F"0$)"") :#.P0)", ( ,5/Q.60,/ 2$)"# W'0F' (66 ,.#+, .- F#2"6+0", /(5 Q"

    :"#:"+#(+")7 $.+ ,. /2F' 2:.$ +'" W"(Z (, 2:.$ +'.," W'. '(P" Q""$)"F"0P") Q5 ( -(6," 0/(3" .- 3..)$",,Ab D

    H2F' '"#.0,/7 ,2F' :#0)"7 ,2F' ,(F#0-0F"7 0, +'" ,+2-- .- ,.(:

    .:"#(A !'(+ 0, ,.(: .:"#(j Y/"#0F($ +"6"P0,0.$ .# #()0. )#(/( 0, (,'#0$" +. 2$F.$,F0.2, F.$P"$+0.$,7 +. ",+(Q60,'") F26+2#(6 $.#/,A 8+"/Q#(F", )"(+'7 :0+57 (P(#0F"7 ($) 62,+7 ($) ",+(Q60,'") W(5, .- )"(60$3W0+' +'"/A *'"#" 0, 60++6" #../ 0$ 0+ -.# +#2" +#(3")57 .# F./")57 .#0#.$5A Y66 +'"," 0$P.6P" ,./" (++"/:+ .$ +'" :(#+ .- +'" 0$)0P0)2(6 +.+#($,F"$) +'" $.#/f ($) ,2F' (++"/:+, 0$P.6P" (+ 6"(,+ ( -60FZ"# .-F.$,F0.2, (W(#"$",,A Y ,.(: .:"#( F#0,0, 0,7 +'"$7 ($ (++(FZ .$F.$P"$+0.$ -#./ W0+'0$ +'" -#(/"W.#Z .- F.$P"$+0.$A 8+ /(5 +",+ +'"-#(/"W.#Z7 Q2+ /(5 $.+ +#($,F"$) 0+A 8+, F'0"- c2",+0.$ 0,7 b!'. F($

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    42/224

    3"+ (W(5 W0+' W'(+jb 8+, F'0"- (,,2/:+0.$ 0, +'(+ '" W'. -6.2+,F.$P"$+0.$ /2,+ F./" +. 3#0"-A

    !"#$"# W(, (Q.2+ +. Q"F./" +'" P066(0$ 0$ '0, .W$ ,.(: .:"#(A&(F' :(#+5 0$ +'" )#(/( /2,+7 -.# ( +0/"7 :6(5 -#./ '0, .W$ :.,0+0.$A9./")57 +#(3")57 ($) 0#.$5 (Q($).$ +'0, ,F"$"A

    I UIY0T8 YI* Y-+"# P0,0+0$3 O.#/ ($) Y$0+( 0$ Y+6($+0F 90+57 !"#$"# -.2$) ( h.QW0+' ($ "/:6.5/"$+ (3"$F5 +'(+ ,:"F0(60T") 0$ '0#0$3 ($) +#(0$0$3)"#"60F+,A 45 6(+" Y232,+ '" -.2$) ( Q"++"#C:(50$3 h.Q 0$ +'"#"-#03"#(+.# .- ( /"(+C:(FZ0$3 -0#/A \$ H(+2#)(57 H":+"/Q"# D]7 '"($) E(+ W"#" /(##0")7 ($) W"$+ (W(5 -.# ( Q#0"- '.$"5/..$ (+ U.2$+Y0#5 S.)3"7 0$ +'" E.F.$.,A

    H'.#+65 (-+"#W(#)7 +'"5 $",+6") 0$+. ($ (:(#+/"$+ .$ !(,'0$3+.$S($"7 0$ +'" ["#/($+.W$ ,"F+0.$ .- E'06()"6:'0(A \$ U(#F' 7

    bU(##0(3" W(, -.# /"7b !"#$"# ,(0)7 b+#265 ( Q2#)"$A *. ,(5 +'(+8 0$+"$)") +. `/(Z" +'" Q",+ .- 0+` 0, +#2" Q2+ .P"#,+(+")A 8 ,2Q/0++") +.0+A 8 /()" 2: /5 /0$) +. ). ,./"+'0$3 :.,0+0P" W0+'0$ +'"F0#F2/,+($F",A 42+ /5 :"#,:"F+0P"@,""0$3 60-" (, ,2--"#0$3@

    :#.P0)") +'" F.$+"X+ -.# /5 /(##0(3"7 ($) -.# W'(+"P"# '(::"$")W0+'0$ 0+7 W'"+'"# :.,0+0P" .# $"3(+0P"A *'(+ :"#,:"F+0P" F(/" -#./ /5

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    43/224

    .Q,"#P(+0.$ .- /5 -(/065@$.+ h2,+ g." ($) V.#.+'5 Q2+ (6,. ,"P"#(62$F6",A 8+ ,""/") +. Q" +'" F.//.$ "X:"#0"$F" +'(+ (66 .- 60-"7 60Z" /5/(##0(3"7 W(, ,./"+'0$3 +'(+ 5.2 W"#" ,+2FZ W0+'7 ($) +'(+ 5.2 :2+ 2:W0+'@)"F"$+65A *'0, P0"W7 W0+' (66 0+, -(6," `$.Q060+57` 0, +'"

    :"#,:"F+0P" .- ,./".$" W'. 0, (+ +'" /"#F5 .- F0#F2/,+($F",7 W'. 0,$.+ +'" (2+'.# .- '0, .W$ 60-"A *'0, 0, '.W 0+ W(, -.# /"Ab

    V2#0$3 +'" -0#,+ 5"(# ($) ( '(6- .- +'" /(##0(3"7 !"#$"# '"6) ($2/Q"# .- )0--"#"$+ h.Q,A Y -"W /.$+', (-+"# +'" /(##0(3"7 '" 6"-+ +'"/"(+C:(FZ0$3 :6($+ ($) +..Z ( h.Q Q#0"-65 (+ +'" #",+(2#($+ ($) '"(6+'F62Q W'"#" g." W(, W.#Z0$3A O"X+7 -.# $"(#65 ( 5"(#7 '" W.#Z") (, (,(6",/($ -.# ( '"(+0$3 ($) :62/Q0$3 F.$+#(F+0$3 F./:($57 W'0F' '()

    h2,+ Q#($F'") 0$+. +'" #"/.)"60$3 Q2,0$",,A !"#$"# 6"(#$") ",+0/(+0$3AY$) '" 3.+ '0, -0#,+ +(,+" .- ,(6", ,2FF",,A

    8$ R"Q#2(#5

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    44/224

    3#(F0.2,65Ab d" c20FZ65 Q"F(/" +'" +.: ,(6",/($ 0$ +'" )"(6"#,'0:, -.#W'0F' '" W.#Z")A bd" )"P"6.:") 3#"(+ -#0"$),'0:, W0+' +'" -"66.W,+'(+ '" W.#Z") W0+'7b O.#/ V($.-- ,(0)A bd" W.26) +(Z" '(6- ( ).T"$325, +. 62$F' ($) :0FZ 2: +'" +(QA d" W.26) Q25 "P"#5Q.)5 )#0$Z,AU(Z0$3 /.$"5 W(, 0/:.#+($+ +. '0/7 $.+ Z"":0$3 0+A 8+ W(, -2$$5 +.,"" '0/ 0$ +'(+ F./:($5A d"#" W(, ( Z0) .$65 ( F.2:6" .- 5"(#, .2+ .-'03' ,F'..6A d" '() $"P"# 3.$" W0+' ($5.$" ,"#0.2,65 "XF":+ -.# E(+7($) '" '() +W. Z0),A *'"#" '" W(,7 +W"$+5C.$" 5"(#, .6)7 0$ W0+' (

    Q2$F' .- F(# )"(6"#,7 /"$ W'. W"#" '03' 60P"#, ($) F.$,+($+65 #2$$0$3.-- +. Y+6($+0F 90+5 .# !06)W..) -.# +'" W""Z"$) +. ,'(FZ 2: .#W'(+"P"#A !"#$"# '() $"P"# ).$" ($5 .- +'"," +'0$3,7 ($) '" '() (66+'" .Q603(+0.$, .- ($ .6) /(##0") /($Ab

    Y+ +'0, +0/" !"#$"# ,+(#+") #2$$0$3 (#.2$) W0+' .+'"# W./"$A b8+W(,$`+ .QP0.2, (+ -0#,+7b E(+ ,(0)A b42+ 6(+"# 8 Q"3($ +. -0$) "P0)"$F"Ad" W.26) 3. .-- ($) ,(5 '" W.26) Q" #03'+ Q(FZ7 ($) $.+ F./" './"-.# '.2#,A 8 )0)$`+ Q#0$3 +'0, 2: W0+' '0/ +'"$7 ($) +'0$3, h2,+ 3.+W.#,"A !'"$ 8 +'0$Z .- (66 +'(+ ,'.26) '(P" Q""$ ,(0) ($) $"P"# W(,7 83"+ )0,F.2#(3")A 8+ 3.+ +. +'" :.0$+ W'"#" 8 W.26)$`+ ,(5 ($5+'0$3

    Q"F(2," 8 )0)$`+ W($+ ( -03'+ +. ,+(#+Ab

    N0!WMC2N0!W0Y &P"#5.$" "6," 0$ '0, "$P0#.$/"$+7 !"#$"# F'(#/")A E(+7 '.W"P"#7

    Q"F(/" '0, bP0F+0/Ab H'" W(, +'" W0-" .- ( F(# ,(6",/($7 Q2+ '() $.F(# ($) F.26) $.+ )#0P"A H'" W(, b,+2FZ (+ './" W0+' +'" F'06)#"$Ab!"#$"#`, W.#,+ (,:"F+ W(, #","#P") -.# '"#A 8+ W(, (6/.,+ (, 0- '"$"")") +. '(P" '"# (#.2$) +. P0F+0/0T"A Y:(#+ -#./ +'"0# c2(##"6,7F.//2$0F(+0.$ Q"+W""$ +'"/ W0+'"#") (W(5 0$+. +'" "XF'($3" .-0$-.#/(+0.$A !'"$ !"#$"# W(, './"7 '" W.26) 03$.#" '"#7 :#"-"##0$3+. #"() .# W(+F' +"6"P0,0.$A d" W.26) #":#0/($) +'" F'06)#"$.FF(,0.$(6657 Q2+ (:(#+ -#./ +'(+ :6(5") 0$F#"(,0$365 60++6" :(#+ 0$ +'"0#2:Q#0$30$3A

    8 (,Z") !"#$"# (Q.2+ '0, #"6(+0.$,'0: W0+' E(+A !" W"#" (+

    H+($-.#) G$0P"#,0+5 -.# +'" W""Z"$)7 W'"#" '" W(, 6"()0$3 (W.#Z,'.:A V2#0$3 +'" 62$F' Q#"(Z7 W" -.2$) ( ,"F62)") :(+0. W'"#"W" F.26) ,0+ 0$ +'" '.+ ,2$ ($) +(6ZA *'"#" !"#$"# +#"(+") /" +. ()0,:(,,0.$(+" (FF.2$+ .- '0, -0#,+ /(##0(3"A

    b*'0, :(#+ .- /5 60-"7b '" ,(0)7 bW(, .$" 6.$3 )0,(,+"#A 8 /",,")2: (6/.,+ "P"#5+'0$3 8 +.2F'")A e.2 F.26) 3. ).W$ ( 60,+1 /5#"6(+0.$,'0: W0+' /5 :(#"$+,7 /5 (F()"/0F #"F.#) 0$ '03' ,F'..67 /5(::60F(+0.$, -.# F.66"3"7 3"++0$3 E(+ :#"3$($+A Y$) +'"$@(-+"# 8 W(,.$F" 0$P.6P") 0$ ( +""$C(3" /(##0(3"@'(P0$3 +W. F'06)#"$ 0$ #(:0),2FF",,0.$A

    b!" F.26) 3. .P"# "(F' "P"$+ 0$ +'0, :"#0.)7 6..Z (+ +'"F0#F2/,+($F",7 ($) )0,F2,, +'" #(+0.$(6" Q"'0$) 0+A 42+ +'(+ W.26) Q"

    Q.#0$3 ,.(: .:"#(7 ($) W.26) 3"+ $.W'"#" $"(# +'" &'3$1. .- Q"'(P0.#

    60Z" +'(+AbS"+ /" 30P" 5.2 ($ "X(/:6"A !'(+ E(+ ,(0) (Q.2+ .2# 6(FZ .-F.//2$0F(+0.$ 0, (FF2#(+"f 5"+ +'" ,.2#F" .- +'" +#.2Q6" W(, $.+ 6(FZ.- F.//2$0F(+0.$A 8+ 0, +#2" +'(+ 8 $"P"# F(66") .$ '"# +. 0$+"#(F+ W0+'/" 0$+"66"F+2(665 .# "/.+0.$(665f 8 +..Z /5 -(062#" +. ,'(#" W0+' '"# +.F#2"6 6"$3+',A 42+ +'0, W(, ( Q5C:#.)2F+7 $.+ +'" ,.2#F" .- .2#

    :#.Q6"/,Ab*'"#"`, ($.+'"# .QP0.2, "X:6($(+0.$ .- W'(+ W(, '(::"$0$3 +.

    2, +'(+ (6,. :'.&(_- #"(F' ,.2#F"A 8+ W.26) Q" "(,5@($)7 (3(0$7(FF2#(+"@+. ,(5 +'(+ E(+`, :(#(/"+"#,@'"# "X:"F+(+0.$,7 (/Q0+0.$,7

  • 8/12/2019 Bartley 1978 Werner Erhard the Transformation of a Man the Founding of Est

    45/224

    ($) -($+(,0", (Q.2+ +'" -2+2#"@W"#" /.#" F.$P"$+0.$(6 +'($ /0$"AY6+'.23' ,'" '()$`+ :6