Sheet6Rating Scale
RatingDefinition9Row extremely more important8Row very strongly
to extremely more important7Row very strongly more important6Row
strongly to very strongly more important5Row strongly more
important4Row moderately to strongly more important3Row moderately
more important2Row equally important to moderately more
important1Row and column equally important1/2Column equally
important to moderately more important1/3Column moderately more
important1/4Column moderately to strongly more important1/5Column
strongly more important1/6Column strongly to very strongly more
important1/7Column very strongly more important1/8Column very
strongly to extremely more important1/9Column extremely more
important
Sheet1CR Value =0.065Reasonable ConsistencyPairwise
comparisonsFactorWeightMaximum ValueItem NumberItem
Number12345678910Core Competencies54.80%54800Item
DescriptionABCDTechnical
Competencies5.60%56001A1.007.000005.000003.00000Functional
Competencies11.50%115002B0.141.000.333330.20000Working
Condition28.10%281003C0.203.001.000.25000Total100%1000004D0.335.004.001.0051.0061.0071.0081.0091.00101.005Sum1.6816.0010.334.45
STANDARDIZED
MATRIXABCDWeight1A0.600.440.480.6754.8%2B0.090.060.030.045.6%3C0.120.190.100.0611.5%4D0.200.310.390.2228.1%5678910
CI and CR
worksheetABCDSUMSUM/Weight1A0.550.390.570.842.364.302B0.080.060.040.060.234.073C0.110.170.110.070.464.034D0.180.280.460.281.204.295678910
count4.00lambda max4.174 CI0.058CR0.06constant0.9
Saatys CIr values for matrices are given by the following
tableSize of MatrixRandom Consistency
(CIr)10120230.58340.90451.12561.24671.32781.41891.459101.4910
CoreCR Value =0.092Reasonable ConsistencyPairwise
comparisonsItem NumberItem Number12345678910Factor Core
ValueWeightMaximum ValueItem
DescriptionIUOCCSOACHINTTWInterpersonal Understanding
(IU)5.10%2794.81IU1.000.500000.250000.333000.250000.33300Organizational
commitment
(OC)11.4%6247.22OC2.001.000.333002.000000.500000.25000Customer
Service Orientation
(CSO)23%126043CSO4.003.001.003.000000.200002.00000Achievement
Orientation
(ACH)14%76724ACH3.000.500.331.001.000001.00000Initiative/Proactive
(INT)30.3%16604.45INT4.002.005.001.001.002.00000Teamwork and
cooperation
(TW)16.2%8877.66TW2.004.000.501.000.501.00Total100%5480071.0081.0091.00101.005Sum16.0011.007.428.333.456.58
STANDARDIZED
MATRIXIUOCCSOACHINTTWWeight1IU0.060.050.030.040.070.055.1%2OC0.120.090.040.240.140.0411.4%3CSO0.250.270.130.360.060.3023.0%4ACH0.190.050.040.120.290.1514.0%5INT0.250.180.670.120.290.3030.3%6TW0.120.360.070.120.140.1516.2%78910
CI and CR
worksheetIUOCCSOACHINTTWSUMSUM/Weight1IU0.050.060.060.050.080.050.346.732OC0.100.110.080.280.150.040.766.713CSO0.200.340.230.420.060.321.586.874ACH0.150.060.080.140.300.160.896.375INT0.200.231.150.140.300.322.357.746TW0.100.460.110.140.150.160.815.0178910
count6.00lambda max6.571 CI0.114CR0.09constant1.24
Saatys CIr values for matrices are given by the following
tableSize of MatrixRandom Consistency
(CIr)10120230.58340.90451.12561.24671.32781.41891.459101.4910
TechnicalCR Value =0.097Reasonable ConsistencyPairwise
comparisonsItem NumberItem Number12345678910Factor Technical
ValueWeightMaximum ValueItem
DescriptionExpertiseExperienceEducationCertificationExpertise
(EXP)43.6%2441.61Expertise1.003.000003.000002.00000Experience29.1%1629.62Experience0.331.003.000003.00000Education
(EDU)10.3%576.83Education0.330.331.000.50000Certificate17.0%9524Certification0.500.332.001.00Total100%560051.0061.0071.0081.0091.00101.005Sum2.174.679.006.50
STANDARDIZED
MATRIXExpertiseExperienceEducationCertificationWeight1Expertise0.460.640.330.3143.6%2Experience0.150.210.330.4629.1%3Education0.150.070.110.0810.3%4Certification0.230.070.220.1517.0%5678910
CI and CR
worksheetExpertiseExperienceEducationCertificationSUMSUM/Weight1Expertise0.440.870.310.341.964.492Experience0.150.290.310.511.254.323Education0.150.100.100.080.434.174Certification0.220.100.210.170.694.085678910
count4.00lambda max4.261 CI0.087CR0.10constant0.9
Saatys CIr values for matrices are given by the following
tableSize of MatrixRandom Consistency
(CIr)10120230.58340.90451.12561.24671.32781.41891.459101.4910
FunctionalCR Value =0.077Reasonable ConsistencyPairwise
comparisonsItem NumberItem Number12345678910Factor Functional
ValueWeightMaximum ValueItem DescriptionRBSCTCTOATLRelationship
building (networking)
(RB)7%8051RB1.000.500000.250000.500000.25000Self control
(SCT)14%16102SCT2.001.000.333002.000000.33300Conceptual Thinking
(CT)28.5%3277.53CT4.003.001.001.000001.00000Organizational
awareness (OA)13.5%1552.54OA2.000.501.001.000.20000Team Leadership
(TL)37%42555TL4.003.001.005.001.00Total100%1150061.0071.0081.0091.00101.005Sum13.008.013.589.502.78
STANDARDIZED
MATRIXRBSCTCTOATLWeight1RB0.080.060.070.050.097.0%2SCT0.150.120.090.210.1214.0%3CT0.310.380.280.110.3628.5%4OA0.150.060.280.110.0713.5%5TL0.310.380.280.530.3637.0%678910
CI and CR
worksheetRBSCTCTOATLSUMSUM/Weight1RB0.070.070.070.070.090.375.282SCT0.140.140.100.270.120.775.473CT0.280.420.290.130.371.495.234OA0.140.070.290.130.070.705.245TL0.280.420.290.670.372.035.49678910
count5.00lambda max5.343 CI0.086CR0.08constant1.12
Saatys CIr values for matrices are given by the following
tableSize of MatrixRandom Consistency
(CIr)10120230.58340.90451.12561.24671.32781.41891.459101.4910
WorkingCR Value =ERROR:#DIV/0!ERROR:#DIV/0!Pairwise
comparisonsItem NumberItem Number12345678910Factor Working
ConditionWeightMaximum ValueItem
DescriptionComfortAccidentHazardousHealthyComfort Level
(CL)10.40%2922.41Comfort1.000.333000.333000.50000Accident Risk
(AR)42.70%11998.72Accident3.001.002.000003.00000Hazardous
(HZ)32.80%9216.83Hazardous3.000.501.004.00000Healthy
Level14.10%3962.14Healthy2.000.330.251.00Total100%2810051.0061.0071.0081.0091.00101.005Sum9.012.173.588.50
STANDARDIZED
MATRIXComfortAccidentHazardousHealthySUMWeight1Comfort0.110.150.090.060.4210.4%2Accident0.330.460.560.351.7142.7%3Hazardous0.330.230.280.471.3132.8%4Healthy0.220.150.070.120.5614.1%5678910
CI and CR
worksheetComfortAccidentHazardousHealthySUMSUM/Weight1Comfort0.100.140.110.070.434.092Accident0.310.430.660.421.824.263Hazardous0.310.210.330.561.424.324Healthy0.210.140.080.140.574.075678910
count4.00lambda max0.000
CIERROR:#DIV/0!CRERROR:#DIV/0!constant0.9
Saatys CIr values for matrices are given by the following
tableSize of MatrixRandom Consistency
(CIr)10120230.58340.90451.12561.24671.32781.41891.459101.4910