Page 1
1
¥¥::[[êê���� �� �� KK���� �� óó�������������� ��
¥¥TT��ÑÑ��
üü¥¥::ââkk--��ÈÈ Y^Y^XXÑÑ����
Gºþ
³³ ³
³ ,,UU³³ ³³�3N�p��n�9�� fº³00�ý���/å £Ý³0�Wȶ
»t2þ»XL×8��$�~pû³0 à�oWC�úâ ìcÖ!�A��*Lø
��°Ý0¥ �¹¾�ÒBø�0ê ö}CøÍ��T×N»�c0S�sBäõ¹
���»�ÑN) �¾âú�¹¬ ö� �ÒBø�N�Ù� âì¾Q0ê .¾Q
}·n�)Yä�·õ¹O��=ýê CøÍ0ê�Ócõ¹ ���½�n��{�
ýÿL c Q��¸�¹¶�Yý��¹¾-~�@��¹õ¹n\ý ®ó £Ý$
0���¾_!ì �_!ì�oW�aætpû0���%�^�ìn�ýê
(Hermetism� }ãQÉÌh fº³00�ý}cWÈ�¾¹� ½� cQ}¨
��3\»�/~Ø=��º �½�0�ý����Í�� �37$�}t9äIe
600BC F����$' ã��� ·³00�ý ·��v�N góc�Y�sBä¼)�
� c�Éû�º » c�æk w{s¦äÓ�xx ¶hí�E®Ie¶»¡þ
£Ý³0}c-H p³¨Y��ºNOV�ÿ�1`ÿ 8¸ÿ�tÐ ��¬��Ð
« �3É���ýä³0}�Ä/³��� »�ãfà��}#ÿ�º� ³
GG��¡¡³ ³³ ³³0���ý���N����1`·����ÒBø���CøÍ��0S��ìn�ý
ê��_!ì�
ééÔÔ
�m¤|��Æ£`RîH h¯¤|��3?�îH øþ[ê¤|üw@¥:
ÞªkZ¼ûäs ��k-·<˵ ¥:·<ÚûX��Å9�� Q£¥:âk-¢
9���?á� �ük]�� ' ÝZÆ B 17 ê~×UÎ Giordano Bruno
1548 1600�`�ý9 �Galileo Galilei 1564 1642��«ý�-îX¿� 19 ê~¯ê�
`ïê2±Xû}� 20 ê~übÑá�ÞèX �$uø ` ïôÈ �Creationism�
Í; üüÑ��â à ¡�UJr¾�¥·�5 ¾Uá�׳ åÀ�î¥�
S�¥:`k-Xd��9�Ìî �ÇÌàX ´8üZÆÞWÀÒ£Ý2��Û �m
á�¬êXá�GÏ üJE¡ß �·¥:XÔE*Ü/S Issac Newton 1642—1727
� û£�ob2: 20 ê~ÔóûX¥:��´�:¡KÝÅnk-�Ô Ñá�J
� 00ÙÙTT�� ��7 m��[û:�Ñ[êèJ�¬{èJ,
Page 2
2
X
åÀü �Uv|X ��¥:âk-üJd�¹�Jâ¥)�ß�XGÏ Â
lX|� �U��©©�¹���Pythagoras ca. 570—490 BC� £�Ò Plato, 427 347
BC n ¿î� Aristotle 384 322 BC ¹�ªÀ:�â¸à�¥:Xf|à)Ô
³� íI]�Î7-Xà�δ ¹��¸¥:�HK �þU�á�XÂl Já�
ûj�üb½ó[��# åÀ�O¢åD_�¹�â�+09|�½óXG�û¥) à
è â� TTZÆã�X� Æ: k-�ÉíM� U¢ªÀX+Ä9ÑϽó��2
�Ä� Jõ í��]�XÂlZÊÿS �ø�H¹Þ zá�m=î �¾�� �
¹`µ åÀü8�ÑHÚιFÝ° ~�0þT9y� à �b�ö�îà�fÌ
tô åÀX|�ákáÚ´þ�õ¾kà��¡á�§ à´©`<q~ÊÈêÙ�eN
c¯ ��OX�ÈâX
ÔÔ SS��¥¥::dd��XX]]��
1 ¸̧àà��¥¥::XX¥¥))
V�<¹ �·¥:Î�bS� S�¥:Kdb¸à� ¸à�¥:X¥)ZÊî
S ûÈÞùÚÝþÊó Ô½X1Só�600—430 BC�¹HKbà��ó¹êX�ç
!£��i Æ:� Pre-Socratics �·< ÌVãn�nS�GýÑ:��Miletians�
XĦ��Thales� �9�n:��Ionians�X©�¹�� ãûý+¼Þýn:��Eleatics�
Xȼ�� �Parmenides� qÎ �Zeno� ¬Ýξ¹ë� �Ephesus�X?��ýM
�Heraclitus� ξ@JSFË��Thrace�X�ó�ýM�Democritus��� ªÀÍ[mKd
`¾Û=�üXØ¡ð� :È �}2�Ýá ùÈ�à�[â¡N �ó�2X
Ôà Ã� �¥:¥)àÔ ÔÊóÔÛrXõ� h¹È�|�ûXD:`ý[:�
à� zG|Ú�2�Î� àü�6Ô¡UX�= 8ZÔE*ÜĦ�¹ê �D©
�¹���J:�Z
câXé¬ózG�ç�LÊó �430 280 BC� í¹£�ÒX:Á¹�J�ÍO
||XD:èJ`D:�2�� Á¼Þ��X�Ô á4´)ÙákY¯ 7Q0�¡
�2XÛ« à�ԽƹÝBr`¡Uõ�XD:�àB��i�`øîöÎ�b8ó
D:��àä�ù�`ÝϳX|Ú¥: �câXû¥)4n.rÎ� Ôâ�äsó
zG�çà�ê�Hellenistic�Êó�280 BC 200 AD� W¹�+�ݦ�SÃnZEû¢
�Alexandria�X:��Museum���� üS�hRHóÈÍOÎÌVû´ ��Euclid� �
ÎG��Archimedes� n �(� �Aristarchus� �¶Z��Appolonius of Perga� ,¦�
�Ptolemy��S¹xóXÔûMDÚ`ý[:� Ú¸à�¥:|�JÄ
2 [[��áá��XXÂÂll
Page 3
3
¹Þ�S�?þê~��Xà�¥:¥)kV �JrWX!�þJr�d£üZÆ
'Ò��X åÀÔî¾Ñy�JÔ²�þàÆ �U��b[�á� nZEûÊóX
¥:¥)ù¨WÙ.Ñ� ´�û´ � �ÎG� ,¦���U:ÙQ_ÍûÑÆ
£áÃ�× �£�¬ÝÌ'î+0�ô ü8�!X�Ló�Æ£Ì'Ä� ´�8óX
¥:Æ+0�_Vø�¡� Eudamus ��XD:Æ�´"Æ£<¼û� �Ô�ôÇ�X¾
=ßqÒ����Autolycus of Pitane, 360—290 BC� X �ý'¤| �On Moving Spheres�
�¹åÀákáq*Æ:`âóD:+0�XUé`|� ÇbȽX1Só í�Ô��
mÈÔå 8Z¹F_� �Fragments��êÃÈ�Ô´�Ý èJÙÎ�Þ¾Ñóó��L
ó�ÇÈâó+0XUé`ÑÄ
[���¹á� ��øþ2�M^ZÆs´ôä j� �@� 641 HnZEû¢
XûÒ:Z�'Êþ?ë2XÞ�D-fî� �`º?ÌO�XR�û=� ºÔþ
s´ í�ØbS�¥:d�X©�¹��-�2b �- ûü GÍ-êù\¬�
èáÚJµÄ ¥�6Ì[+ ÃÑ�b¡µ�0¢ ¹�J��ÞX�ß`E¡ -
�â9«�¡Í�oÈÄ?� ´"<oZu â9QÌôá±Vé ��½óZÆ
:È -� ¥:¥���í¾ÑóÁþÿ-f·�Ìô a3uÝBÛ º�[�ù
qBZ
¢@�!¯ê~Ô� ¹-�â£�Ò:� Ü� ´8£�Ò+0�-ßáåJ
ñÇ`©Í n ¿î�`ªX:óÍ�3[î�Ä �oÑ�!«þ��� _åX
E¡àmÞM^F= ´8 U¢ªÀXø!X+0�¤�Ωã:�XñÇ õ�Já
T) Jâ ¢@�!â¹�hê~È ©ã:�î��ç �©�¹��:� ¹� �
£�Ò:� XÎ�à ¡ó ü8��ß `�Zû£â©ãÈyÝGX£Ä �Q
o[�´e±,ZÔo¡U�m �àÊ���Zû£2þ�îäÑ U¢�¤�ÎÃ
µ Ã4¼ÑTÈÝV�m�¥ �X9È Z·©ã:�XÎ�Ä�üb ½ó�m�
# âó�m�¹×µ àè^Tâ�m^î ^áõ
3 ÝÝGG©ã©ã��JJ::��XX]]��
�b�#s��B åÀ�ýÆ£´©ù��â©�¹���J:� G�ç©ã:
��Pythagoreans�âà�¥:`Æ:XBÛGÏ à¾ÑqBÈy�B0Î|� ��{
óZUû]� Ô�6 �î:Ù¡y�ô³�É x�©ã:�á�Íà�D:`ý[
:Ýï� || �Çr�ÎX�s àèJñÇ -�ÍHþà�Æ:¥ó�Å�`¡û
E¡ ºÔ�«r�Æ:E¡X:Ùíx� ªÀ¾á��þ}D+�ãX2¬-� J0
ü��Ñ�§ �û �Oüù�X¥:�©\¹t7 lÙ
19 ê~X�ÑÆ:�`Æ:Æ�*¦�Eduard Zeller, 1814—1908�üJ à�Æ:Æ
[Zeller 1955]��S¥�è`D�:��2 x�©�¹���J½ó¼fâD:|Ú`Æ
:ñ|ÑáÌF ªÀ¾á��þ^D+�¹2¬F=Xk-¶'àÆ ª��ÅÅE¡
Z¨ªáâXiè��Hermann Diels, 1848 1922��êVX ¸à�[��ê [Diels 1879]
Page 4
4
¹�ª`�DM�W. Kranz� ÜêX !£��i_� [Diels & Kranz 1951-1952] îÇ3
û'Þ� 20 ê~X£¢êû::Ù×è�M�Walter Burkert, 1931 �üªæÊ·¼+ ¸·
©�¹��:�XôÈâ¥: [Burkert 1972]�y« ª^©ã:�`½óà�Æ:þø
ÚÔ9 x� à�D:J2Îb NÙ X��êÙÔþ�8àÎ�X-���x à
�`à�Úûê �X¥)�ÛÌGX ü!D´"�Ý!£��iÆ:�XÃÑõ��
â ªkÎX§�� þÿ©ã�:Ù`¥)á´GÏ ��J��àÔ D:�à�
Xà2©ã:�X [Burkert 1972, pp.426-427]
�©ãXõ�QuÝÈy�B �V`<oÔZ©ã à�D:`ý[:Xd��
ü¾ 6 `ªü�â�ÈXĦ� ?��ýM ȼ�����ú�ݨªÈ� `.
�X�B6 \â� ©ã�J:�Ôº�(8 ªÀ�-ßXNQ��¹?9X ´8Å
b:Ù¢¥:Æ�à� �Thomas Heath� à�Æ:Æç�¸3ý � W. K. C.
Guthrie�>Guthrie 1962@ ¹ÇÔ¥X©ã:�ç�5=�Charles H. Kahn�>Kahn 2001@`çè
J8�ü©�¹��¹â�Ô¡U�= ï���Philolaus, ca 470—390 BC�X?ÿÐ�Carl
A. Huffman� Ѭ��åby�<¼êÙÌ'¼ÑXô³·� x�©ã�J:�ü¥:
`Æ:ÞÑ�Ý¡Uõ�`¼ûE¡oX
Úiè�X �ê Ï¥äÅ[Jtº�¼�X/ÚÐ�Kathleen Freeman�x� ©ã
� �¥: �k-X-��School�ï�� åÀͪ¾ÅXµÄ`-Æ´"Ô´�¹ �
w´e�ª¼�X�2o£9d �È ªX�î¼fÑÃUÚ´)síhübý[`[
mXô \�̵ªÀ�I~Xsí�guiding principles�á3à���ª�©ã�
X >Freeman 1959, pp. 76-77, 81@ ùÈ�¥D�H9ÅblK�:Ùü" ÕGÕz
XÔQ<Ä 3� ÍÞÄ]�Ôv�X§�¾Ñ� WJá�Â!,üX�B�Ñ`<·
�X �B�Ñó�ÕX ¾�Ø¡áàX|� ð� ÇbwÔ¡|�ÔÝÈáo ÔÃ
Ñ�ó í�"þÿ:ÙXø�Z
�[X|�¹©�¹���K� �ü8åÀáÃÑÍÞÄ]�¡�t¹�| à¾
ÑÐÜåÀx�ÕG ÜÚX�� Ú©ã�J-��' JûüPK-�â:� �¹
åÀøþáÄJü áù��ÚJã��XZÆ ñÇ E¡0ÔÐÄ åÀXÎ�Õz�
�£�üMøÆ: Mÿ�×è�MXº�×� �ÍuÝ.rs��m�ÕX¸·ôÈ3
á`<f8 à�U�ªà�`ü" VÊ,eXÕzSü ûÈÞy¥¸3ý`5=X
�� à¨à�`©ãô�0Ùܼ�Peter Gorman�> Gorman 1979@Xô³��ÈúMøû
`̀ ©©��¹¹������JJ::��
`à�½óÆ:�áÔ� ©�¹��X¡Uûá`<üJ:È -Æ _rÞ
Æ£BuááÃ× àÈübª�ï�X-�zá�:� 3��È ªá��Ô È
�
¹+0XÅ¥� Freeman 1962 àÔ0ÙXÌG¡U+0Ý Freeman 1959 �
à��ê+ÝG¸à�D:X+0Ý Heath 1965(1921); Heath 1998 (1949); Heath ed. 1897 & 1912. � Huffman 1993. 8:x�©ã-�XMU�ó��ãîbÆ:�ÉêÙD:èJ � ï��XÆ:��
é9XD:�É�äs`ÝÅz à2V×è�M�Ä �22¬�� ��: 54 77 I
Page 5
5
t�s �� ü¤¡ã�Þ�ù`�º ($ ÷̤J�X `oÔE*ÜÔ�
ª âà�Ýt�X¸·[â �ªHJ2VªÀw� �^)ÔXô³¥@�û à�^
2báà[âX�îô³�ÜK9 ä�Ô¡!�þ� ¹Ú·[m9¬�Î�X2¬-�
þ-���Jáäs �ªüÑÏ[m9¬�<�Xè� Ì3 ¹�Íà�¡N�2X
Ôï�s í`<ù`��ñ��Karl Jaspers��ç H�Ê· �650 450 BC�XwoÔ
ïû�=XsîJëà´û ��ñ�uݤ�ª �¸�+�X�� ´�V) UZ·
�Ô!�= �O�Z·ªXÊ·
1 ÊÊ·· CC
©ã�S«X ùÈÙÀZ��K<��ÇÈ9°X�Ý°¸ô³ j� �à�
��X¸Õ2±`A�ô³ Mÿ�¹Î�bK@�Homer��!X9Æ¿�Orpheus����
X2¬-� \ÃÑ�©ã-�ÍÕ�¾ã 9ó`Ç$sÑDÙXUá� ¹�J
��'�UöI��gX�É��9 Jõ �¸��`¸È¨úXk-â¥: ÙÀø
þ°¸[âX2m rûAÜ�� ¹�Ì'� Xý[:`D:¹��à wÔåùÑ
�� 1900 BC ª�¹D+`D:�É9ÎX[m� ¹�A�áÃü^¯�=XU Ñ
ÃÑd¾øþ¸Õ[â Ôâ ªXB²ñǹ�ô³U íÛåDzXÈyE¡
åÀà�U¼ãX� ©ãXÊ· 7�¸à�[ê�¥Ê·XÔà ��Ln_
©X�ú�Solon�¨ª½ø· û«����Pindar� �;�R��¦��Aeschylus�`û�
��=Ú�Ú� �Pericles�í¨ªá. àÊ 3�à�ñ|Æ:¤|XÔà JÔ½ó
XÆ:�Ħ� �w�SÐ��Anaximander�`�w�SG��Anaximenes�¨ªá½ Þ
ýn:�X«Æ õÔ Ô2 XFÎ��Xenophanes�`ªàÊ Çb?��ýM`ȼ�
�íáâ Ħ�XD:Hw ¹�oÆ�Í[mûüX¡¡|� �Ä Íª´eÝ¡
UE¡ ´8 ©ãXñÇá�k�Øû°¸[âX)� àÊ3�7üÀ�äSXà�¸
L[ê��¥ 7Ãç´ì�î zád°�S
2 óóGG��__99
Â!¡-,X©�¹��ô�Ýݯ¡�î àèº9áÔ ûÈ^âÎ^º�
�Ë�X�î �ô�Ç2þäÑz^î 8ê üØ¡Æ: ZÆL!� 3ÝáåÊó
�Q �P8�ÈJáÔÈ ´©Xä¾�X�_ åÀ ¾Ñ�Jû'�Ô�:Ù�y
«Ù ½UTĪXóGkV Çbü@�Ý ¯ê~ÈÎ�Xû£2ÖôÈ _Vª0
�2ÖD�X¥FûS ªX¡¡©o`XÔÑo ¹�J!óîz@êX¾Ä�� í`
<9�
BôÈ ©�¹��J2�7à�� à�*!Ȧ�:X'�Î� ����
mT��Mnemsarchus�Ô·!Ï�ü���Samos� w�Øbãn�nS�Xão �¥
� û�î ¥á � � êÙ � ÝG©�¹�����J:�X�m�ê ÙÀ�b@�Ýê~XÝ¡ô� ¹�à�Æ:[��Î�
X©ã:��me) � Guthrie 1987
Page 6
6
GýÑ �Miletus� øÙÑ�à��'ÊëîKêjå�XÔ¼Ñ ªûzób 570 BC Ò
£ÜSPherecydes�NÙ â9´�â'�Á�¶ý��¤��Polycrates�̺à���Z
����X3Æ��Memphis� Sóüw X2m�:4DÚ¹� -�`¾< â9��
�Ȩú ¢à:4ZJ¥:`k- ª`äSó�Z¨²ü�� ÃÑ�¯�UG 530 BC
ºÇX_�
JâuÝî� ªÏ�à��üãûý+¼X¡Ujå��+S�Croton� �"�
£�Åñs%`�ÚMæ ´�ªÿ£�����«�'�Zj¯ûö¢ Ý�îÍåë`
H&�îÇ[GèÈ á���kS¯ÞÛ Î�Z¹ªþ��±ÍZjX-�`�û�
�E¡o ûzü 510 BC �bªXÎ� �+Sy�Z�¥¡U¢ÖS�ý��Sybaris�
X×u£ ¢àéKâ¹¢ÔìJèû�°ý ª��k¹¯9�+SX³�Ü J-�
3k¹üãûý+¼�ç ûà�� �Magna Graecia�Ì¢ÖÈS¯¥)
�ü@�!Aê~ÿºÇ-�A�ZÈQ'Ï �©ãx���áÃ঱y�9-
X'�£2Z�Cylon�U-���Ú$.î��^ªÀÈÄ�? ¢àÔ%'� �Ýø
þHO�k¹�! 'Ê©�¹�����úÔà]� eêVºÔ¡ôÏ�e ´���
H�¢b(rà�Metapontium�àL! ¹�â9�ñ�Ìô¹¢ÝªX�Y £ �2m�
í´©Bn ºÔ¡�S¯y«XÈ©í� -�Jr£«�øs'Ï �ÔsüAê~ÿ
Jâ9�6á �`síü©ã�â 450 460 BC HÈ à2Z�f¹?È�-� ´"
Ú�<¼\A �ü�`s[Burkert 1972, p. 117] ´�V) £8]¡'Ï ©ã-�X�
Ô·QþÇb<oZu �3�ÔJá� ¢8aþÑ6áJ���o`³Ô�� àä
ä_bã� -ëíää�7�Ø� Mÿ��L
3 --������`̀--��
©�¹���Ú¸·Ø¡k-ñÇ`¥:¹��Ü�syncretize�K9XÔï�= �¹
J:È -�Ì'r� ªü�+S�Î�X j��þÝù���X-� WX�5 U
ûÈݹߴM wû'ÞJuÝþû]�
�1� Í-êù�\� ü-Yá�[+ }]þ�X�n±�Z-�Xxà`¶'~_
àè�"XB�-f�I� ¾�ü-�ZAîH�â!��×
�2� 9-ÙO£�Só�hÇ×H�Xù���`�«×³�!Ñó¯9YÈ Èy��©ã
X-Æ ü8�!¾Ñü�)¹ê��
�3� -fO±Õج ü\æ_ ~o:4 ñö �ó �Ý�_X¶'ó�
�4� -ëÚ� �ë �Akousmatikoi�` Dë �Mathematikoi�ø� !Ùȼ¡�
-� âÙíÈo¹�`[m9¬XèÂ`vö �¡æÚ�"Jáù� îÇÃÑ
�ü-���\Aâ-ë¡�.ÜÊ�Î�XÚ;
�5� ô³ Mÿæ³�O A�Êá�ó áü¯�� ¼¡Õ��'�Purification�X¾ã
�Pherecydes �ýn� ü�9 �Æ�)�Ýô ���QJóG�_Íàá�ñÇÔ� � _rÞ ©ãHãûý�!�óX_ÍJ´BÛ�Q �Ä ûÑ�â�Mÿ��£�Ò�:Ù�
�ô��XôÏ �ªT��:4X�_½ü�!¯ê~Æ£�+á�}� Isocrates �ô ZÆ:�?+
î,� Herodotus3ÝÌOk�
Page 7
7
àJuݺÂyÇXU�
¹Þ�5áûÃÑ�2©ãþ�Xïô ¥â à[Ý»S¸·2m AÜ��£�Só¥
)à6äXô³�©Í ´�V) WÀ��Î�Ôþ¹�« Ù Ñ�N; ¹�
�ÂÛ àKÝù��{zXû�k-¶'��ÔU îÇ `�ê~Î7-Â'6X
�n3á´Ì� WÀÔX�UM�� þ�Â�`¹�Ñ�ÝÌà¡Uû
4 óóQQ������BB²²ÚÚ��
-��6ã -�í�Y� ©�-�X�2��óXÑ� ��àÝI�áA B²
Â����É WÀ7�b@�!¯ê~XÆ:L!�Ù[î ûÈù&��ßë´M
�1�I��Soul���óQX�� W�áAX ù�Ô�'�ÇXUÁ U�à,ü ´
8 �'�soma��VUöI�X3g�sema� �Ýó= ÙÀ|á= ZÝI�
�2��ó!JI�üê Þî«áÕ_= �X5§ �ùî�]¬yÇ D:âÆ:
vJ ¹���X�ê¾ãà¡�6áJ�Õ
�3��OâI�Úü�È«uø J BJó! �Gîyài�báà�{Xó= V8
B² ¹�aá��
�4�Hþ[m3ÝJûI� þÿ2�XI�íê��¤ �Xý' þÿI�ξ[mû
I� WÀî�Â�3ÝÃÑÞ��<�NÈàáa¬êXý'
oñÇX d\�Bn WÀ´e`à�X9Æ¿µÄÝ[ÅÞd �`�� Dz �
Ƕ�k-�"3Ñá´GÏ ÃÑâª�ØX�Ú�W Gð��K�³XM� Ýá
ÃÚFGÏ W�îþ ÎÅnX°¸[ê��© Ælá�XK���[êXHKâ¥)
¤oÝýNÈ àèpbo[êP8�ÈXÝ$zx�
5 [m[m��
©ã-�Ôþ��s¹X���É� µÃ¹�=ÑÝJD ºÔþ���Éí
�$ÇX{ó¤oZ`äsÚ àøþ�É`[mïó¹�§XÑ��ÛÌGX o�
É Ú�-,b©�ô� ï���+-X_��� w�ûîD:ÙÑy«�©ã:Ès
`XUåDs�[� 8ê zû£7�b£�Ò`n ¿î�XL! Q!ÙXUé�
ãTT�ÈyX
�1� ©��×DÂXþÿûü`¡Uû ¹�Jâ[m_=�_Vý'�`Î��É�_V�
' �G �J `ä §Ü `µ��� ��ÛÍh _V 1 ·<Î�s�`
½c 2 ·<õcX¾m =ÙÑ�[móäsÚXÎâ àú2Ô�XL 5
� ×è�MÍ8ÕÔeÕz x�±Õ]¬¾á��ÌVüµ(Shaman) ºÂ¿XÔ� X ����
bOiún�£�Ò:�ô³�JÝG$m ^õ�mù�$b@�!ݯê~�J! åÀx�
þ!Kb´"s³Z � é¾ Freeman 1959, p.74 �ÉÝî¡<Ä JBÛã�Ýî¡·� ���ÝV�én �î�X�
Ä
Page 8
8
��s��D�3�`JD�2�§Üàä �¹·<`äâ.Ï �D·<½c JD·
<ËE 10 �ÔÚµ¡UXD ��
�2� x�DÂ!ó�ß�¢ 1 � 2 3 4 ���â´)�ô!ó�ß�¢��� 6 �'�
Íh âê ¾_=X!ó3Íh
�3� ©�x�[móäXÔÎ�sÚ�� ¢ ´$ � the Unlimited ·<ËE�óÎ Ý
$ �Limiters ·<½c� øÙX`ä§ÜóÎÛ= DÂX!ózV8
�4� [mr'X§X� ¹ Ü �ÝÙtÞhû ó`Ôþ.³X ¡�× 1Ù~Ú6
<'�©��á|X ��?× ¤ Ü� �<ý' ¡�× B� ��?
× �¹âÙáÑ¢�Þk�
�5� ý'â2I�gods�Ìh ý'ü�2þNX ¹þ �ether��¤ î{ó$Ç DXó
ä`ÇÌG ´8$ÇX`äâ[m§X3�ÛÌG
�¹ ©�Ô �XÚÇ�üÔþÎ�sí9·�'Ê�Ýƹ�5 àD:í��bsí
`�5øÙ�ÈXsÚ �þÝ�§X J�V´eÝáäs �ô `I��î�Ø
�¹��£�Ò:�Ê·�é¬�È�5`TÕXºÔ¡§X ÇbÈ©��?×à~Ú6
<'¤@X�×`hû óÔî´�BXðÇ íüS�����|ÈXZ¶ â9Q
�,¦�X����ϳ�ª· �üJ!Ý@�!Ýê~X��,F��Eratosthenes�
JâíÝ�A×ê~X¹Q��Nicolaus Copernicus, 1473-1543�`�0¦ Johanns Kepler,
1571-1630 Ìh`�Hàà�Ué©ã8È9�ô¹�È )ÁÔ� �\�x�©
�â�·¥:`<uÝGÏ
6 DD:: ¥¥::¹¹��`̀::��''ÏÏ
8ZÎ�Þ�Æ:ûX �Ç¥"6àÞ:X[m�¹ê ©�¬Ýo��ÛrX
â¸à�D: ¥:�HKÝÈyGÏXõ� �:Ù]�Xú� åÀü8�U�ªX
�ü"�J2¯� ��XÕz ¹8Õz9ß ©�XK'¥:¥â`õ�Æ£áÃ×
�JÑ� 1S || Ô¢è�s íáÃu
�1� ©ã�× D �Jóä §Ü0�&� á¬sÚXÎ�û`¡Uû Jè¤ÎZ
DX sÚ��Û=XsÚ �ÔþÎ�sí û��Sx�ór
�2� �Bï�U��Proclus Lycius, 400—460��¤�©ãXÌîK'D:õ� ÙÀ¸à�
´):síX ¨_Ú� �Theory of Proportions� +áX ©ãnÚ �B!�â
h¡�íî6'X¥� ¹�ýü7h¦60�¥ÚFX�©�� í$éáÃBµ
�3� Ç$�9Æ¿µÄXM� Ç$Ú�´�ü'Êeêâê 3Ñ�x��©�Ô¡�X
sÚ�Ô �ù îý' X ´8 Ý¡¨_�k� ´)¹�×`¨_�X¥�
¹�ýü×`¨_9ÚFú� ¢à{ó¾Ç�diatonic scale� ÑBrÃÑ�ªÀ
Xõ�
� Bn ¿î� �ý' (On the Heavens)�XUé �¹:K 2 � 13 V(293a15-b15) ĦÍ8Ýá
àß© � Taylor 1958, p.450 �J��Æ£á�Ô�:Ùy« �
û�î ¥á ÔB¦ êÙ � ÝGBï�U��ß[�¯V
Page 9
9
�4� Æ: X�É`áÄ ¬Ý¹k� ´) ý[ Ç$�¯¡D:Ü� ¯
N �Quadrivium� Ìô3ÑÎb©ã
¢¹ÞXT9¤� ùÇ�©ã-�üJ��þKÝ2�cûÚÇâ�óXk-`
:�¶' W¶ÝIûâÎêXÑ� záÝNûXµÉ`�� Ì@��ç Jý���
î¸��¬ ·èQû Jr¬�tôbìê�r � J�2�Ú� K[m�9¬
íÂ¥©ã Þýß�´�áÙ Xcûè� Ô�¢:�¹â¥)ùk�ÈÅ�XD
�
ÝÝ SS��ÆÆ::XXQQ¤@¤@ll
à�Æ:�6ä�ûô³ �¢£�ÒÔ� ¬&H£�ÒÔóQ¤X í�ªÕ
Ü£��i�Socrates, 469 399 BC��O ¸ª�×¢�ñK �n¹ñ| :����
« ³� ª.ZøÊû_ �m+áX ͱ) �Dialogues� `Î�:Á�Academy�
Ú:�X�� èJ ô\zê ûz�ª¯�U�387 BC�X_� Þ±©ã-�Z
A�460 BC�Æ£×�îH à Ýû£Í5�� ª@¬`©ã-�X:È ÚÉ�
Ç�= Ý�ñÛéGÏ �|�GÏ�! åÀ�k¼ã©ã:�ü��ZA�âXô
S
1 ©ã©ã::��XXôôSS
©�¹��`£�Ò̱Y�ÔþêÔ üJÈåÀ�¹X¡U©�:Ù ¼fÔE
¾Ýh� ½\¼fàÈm� �Hippasus of Metapontium, ca 500-440 BC� -�ZAÊÑó
�ÄÚÿ×T�¢(úà�Tarentum�`��i¨��Thebes�X�Σ��Archippus�`�S
��Lysis� ��S�-�ä�Xâ\ ï�� ¹� ã¼óàÊ3�£�ÒQ�XnÎ
(��Archytas of Tarentum, ca 428—350�
Íb�Σ�`�S�åÀ�¹áî Çbhê~�óXàÈm�í�þ[Ý]�X
�= ªÃÑÒ£´�¡¯ � _Våê ã�-�¬� ÝÔȬ��7�6X�â
ͦ� áÃ�¨ G¥2 áÑ<�ÚD à�EäÎ- îÇ´8�ØO ª�ÃÑ�
éK �ë â Dë ø�Ú�X� ' oôÈ3ÃÑ¡ô-�£«]¡'Ï�â
ÍbV)¡H«ç¥ó]� ´8K9Ú�E�
^©ã:È ñÇ é$ £�ÒXG��= í� ï��`ªXó$�Î(�
j� £�Òü.H�SS XÊí BÈÒ£k�� ï��X: ÃÑ�ü¡¥�
D 3ÃÑ��Zó�à4Õ B×è�M`?ÿÐX×� h¹�� ï����
3�©��¥<X�Ô�+0 áÄ� �¾ �On Nature� W�n ¿î�Ê·¡
Ã� J�¼ÑÇ�¡-,ü!Äiè�`�DM �ê �X ï��_�[Freeman
1962, pp. 73-77; 1959, pp. 220-232] È¡UX� û¼Ñ:ÙÑy« ͱ) 6º�
� ÝG ï��_Í�+0Xº�|� � Huffman 1993, pp. 1-16
Page 10
10
|�[mÎX`óäX V�û� �Timaeus� JñÇ��k¾¹: îÇÝÔÈ H�
Ñ�ss��¢¹:X�9X �H¼ ͱ) �¥:äÑÔ¡XÔ� àèü�¸
¥kÊó��uÝüSû+�� ÍâêE¡Mÿû Jõ º�£Ä£��i��ͱX
Æî� �Phaedo�Èy¤� ��XøþH&� Simmias ` Cebes � ï��Xó$ à
¹��ó£��i�·�|�XÂl _V���áh¹¾� ��Xã�`¡Uû I�
áAX�B B²X � `ã��� 3Ñ�©ã-�X�� �� î� ï��
©ã:Èü[m�`I�:ø�6ÑÍ£�Ò{óZ¡ûE¡
Çb`£�ÒàÊX�Î(� í�+á$Ú:�`Íá��ÂlÝ¡ûõ�XD:
� ��(úà¢áïU¬X�� o_Zj á�S«åë�� àèm�Þì´á°
ª`£�Ò2��Q üâÙ�ÝzH�¸�Syracuse�0��u�à�7-XEùG�
�367 365 BC� Ò£� %ZªXQ[Freeman 1962, pp. 78-81; 1959, pp.233-239] V�û
� X�¦V�ûá�£ô ��6��ãûý+¼Ôþ¢Ö�¬ï¡X���Õ Ý�x
�ª���Î(�Xê� 8ê Ñ�� �The Republic��X Æ_ �Philosopher King�
3\ÃÑ3�¹ª�s_ ªÍ£�ÒE¡X©Í �Ì'â�X
2 ££��ÒÒXX::��@@åå
ü�hê~�ʹ! �ç !£��iÊó Xà�Æ:Î�Þ�þ <��5
G´��J¥dX�Ú!B êÙJ||o£àÔ Ñ�üãn�n ãûý+¼ @JS
�à��ó¹êX<���`jå� ûV�¢£��iX�:Ô� �L!äää�ÌÆ
:��9T.��� Jâ �b£�Ò�J:ÁX�éo ü�L6äZà�Æ:X��
áÃÑ9X� ©�¹��:�Í8à�Æ:XQ¤@l ÃÑK�G�û0ü
£�ÒÎ�b�L�?Xê� Ï2�L¸·_£ ¡ÏùÑ��¢z��XÔ
E*Ü�ú ªH&Ê·Ô�6«£��iX'�-� ºÔ�6íCÄñêþ�X�}�
â�/ó�=Ú�Ú� [Ý��ü�£`ß\�Õß99�è ä�Ô>sî ü8�
ªX�Õ�9êX JåTüb�î �� ¹ 7] �Ô¬ÂÛ ����rX_K
¥k Mÿ�ª@�XÜS£��iü�å¡�Xå�'ß�uø ØO ¸ªs9X_
î�«�¡ÿ 'ʪîþ�à��H ¾Å3ÅóÕ� �¹�Ô�L �ãûý ë2
�����Z á���S¢� àÊ3�ñö ¡Õ §xß� rS�Ï ���
ÉXûQ�î Èù�8¢�×%¹â|å üûzá¥�H�387 BC�ªñHãûý+
¼`SS â©ã-���S¯xT yº Jè\ÃÑÅ«J0Ϭê �Õ´à¢�
r��@åñ|�|â:�Ñ� ²��L�âG��Î�:Á
£�ÒX ͱ) ùÈ�S�:�4Î�0 Wä:Xº��ßÆáÃ× �Ý
´þU��Ù.X j� W�£�Ò¾ÅX���+ Jõ :��´ÃÚ!âøó !
ómäbÂH 3��£��iOâ�:Áä�X�`ÝHÈ zGªâ©�:ÙxTXÊ
ó .óíäbÚ¥A�UñH�¸F��� �368 BC��Jâ[Taylor 1958, pp. 16-22]
� _V Þ[Ué�X Kahn, Taylor, Huffman ÑÕ8È � ÝG£�ÒXóG�:� �� Taylor 1958 •• Kraut ed. 1992
Page 11
11
�Ô¡UX í�©ã:ÈX[m� $� I�È B²È��ü ͱ) �cØÃ�
8Z!ÄX Æî� ` V�û� Ô�â� � ¹ê ÌV ¬èÝn �Gorgias�
b�Meno� d�+ �Phaedrus� � �The Republic� �� �Theaetetus�
Æ9× �Philebus�Ì� 3à�Ýû£«�©ã:È -���¥ cJX©Í
_rÞ ü !£ Æ:�·� ©ã�!2� �ÇÝ�¥�X-� ��Z£�
Òèß ©ã�J¼���Sbk� ´) ý[ Ç_ ���¥: 7V©�:Ù�w
Ä àåÀ2àX �Ñ�� VII.530d� à ¯N XÈ© 3à���bnÎ(� Í
±) �¾Ý Ñ�� Èy¤�©�¹�� Ûª�«Þ@XÐÜ`[ê-�Zj J
ÑcÙÇ�¡¹J�Ä�©�Xó��ã+Ä � D 600a� àHáʤ� ï��
ãûý:Ù êÙ ¨åÀÈy¥Ì2X�Æ � Æ�×� � �î�£��iê
ÙVV�ûw�.X�=�· äÄ ¥ù©ã:È
6àÔ� åÀQuÝÈy�B �HÝáå �� �� £�ÒñÇXÎ�
¬ G¢9êX'�â��GÔ @å¹D: 6àÞ: [m� I� 9ó��2âÚ
�ûGÔ ÃÑ`©ã:�Xc§ �¥�Çô\ÝG 8ê á�:ÁXIó�Ç��
õãÃÑk¾©ã-� ª.HfóQE=H�¸F� �"3Ý�øñ$ àïV©�
¹��w�Î���E¡o�ã ¢¦zß9 ùȩ�é¬�£�Ò:ÁX�.Ú
$ 3ù�£�Ò:��©�ü�2ÞX ,8 ` aó ªÀGÏ��Û ))¢
ï�� �Î(� ûî�ö ¼�üÄá�?X¯·©ã:Ù��ß[� �Úÿ�£
�Ò�Þ@X!\ î� :ÁÔÝáXD:� `:Áó$ �Æ£<�´+ î�þ
aÜ ©�¯9Zà�Æ:��
3 nn ¿î¿î��XXääÄÄ`̀MMøø
£�Ò«©�XE¡Èyà<6 ªXûó$n ¿î�íáà üH·`�ÕÞª
�©�X-*Æ° àèªXHwáü2¬ûk- 3áüD:êÙ�5Ú� à�ür�
¥: ÙÀý[: �¹ªÍ©�Q±ÕÞ@ �JGÏHJ2V�Ü���´È %
Ô' _rÞ ªÝã��U¹v�Õz9u�`��©�:È Q\ð ª��X©
�¹��ôuÝ�ôß9 �üª+0� Èy|�©�:È�Ø[î _rÞ �Ý
G©�s��mÔ½ 3Ô¡UXÔþ9d
_V 6àÞ: �ÔK��Æ:��Ø�U¼ ÝHHøû�|�©� àè
ÔÔ��2��n`PUX^©�`D:¥)XGÏ ¹�JD:Æ:X��ñÇÈÎ9
`oÆ:�àʹ�üJ! Ý�ç©�¹���:ÙÈobD: ªÀ�Ô�|¯
¼:¥X àè�bL¿J� ªÀx�JsÚ��Û=XsÚ �� ¶�ÝJ
ª_=X<¼ûü�"ÑÎbD àDÂ��"�Hþ¾ �Ôs�X ªÀx�DÂ
X�ô�(OHPHQWV����Ý_=X�ô àHþý�ZKROH�KHDYHQ�Ñ�$Ç_ Ñ�D
� ©ã:�â£�Ò Í±) Ì�¹�JÎ�:ÁXÇXGÏ�º�v| � Þôû�¿³ÖûÁ³II ¹´Jº�
ÚdZ Burkert ` Huffman X�� G£�Ò:��S«XD:Æ:�9¾ ï��à2©ã:� ÛÎ
ÃÑûáû � �� Kahn, 2001, pp. 3-4, 49-62.
Page 12
12
Â
��¯KÈä�Z©�D+2¬��XK'Y� ¹�JâÇ$X�ÛGÏ ��
bß�óû_=3KÝDÂX�î2û ©�¹���:Ùx�r=��D á�á�
ºÝD à�Xär=XD Ã����6 ´�DÂXûüÎ�bÇ$XÇ`Ìý
`�îJª_=�� à üo�´XØ���� ª3à�ávèXMøZ©�
x�J:Ⱦ��b§X`óä àáÑ·�¤|`¬ê _=XÚÉ3áÑó`DÂ�à
�� Ã¹È ¢nãÔ� Èù�X¥:Úû�2HK ©�XDÂ2¬��«�Ôe`
Mø øÙXÚ�ûÈ�8Ô�
4 ©ã©ã::��`̀¥¥::HHKKXXGGÏÏ
ü@�!Aê~ Ħ�`©�¹��j�TKZD:v|�¢ Qn ¿î�âB
wÄ ©ã:�� Ô�|¯¼:¥X ��b[��� ªÀ'Ê�iÝ)K'D:
¥� åÀ¾Ñ,e £�Òí�D:ÔÁ�X||Ù ¹���L:ÁXÎ�Òß`�U
èJ�å _rÞ �LÊóÔ¡UXD:�`ý[:� zG:�¥:X4ÎÙ ´"<
¼â:ÁGÏ�Û àè� êÙ�x�� ©�:Ù 8Z�Î(�¹ê ªÀÙÀ
(1) ?¶��i �Hippocrates of Chios, f.430 BC� Ò0 ´)s� DK J�k¤oM
^Ü-6�lunes�X�B6à �j!ù�×XD:�
(2) �9îU�Theodorus, f.390 BC�: £�ÒXÕÜ Ò�â 3 Ç 17�È�Ý2G�DX
Z�´ÚD
(3) ?�(�Hicetas�`XµM�Ecphantus��f. 400 BC�: Ô�¤Îý'á| à�×¾�Ù
(4) Ä�Ä��Theaetetus, 420—370� �9îUX:ó Ìô¥��Ý 5 ¡7î6' àè
�û´ � ´)s� K 10 ` 13 Xs0Ù �8ZÜS ª�"uÝâ©ã:�X
ÈyGÏ
����ûî�ö�Eudoxus of Cnidus, 408—355 BC�: �Î(�`£�ÒXó$ �L:ÁÔD
ÎXD:� ý[:� �´): ¨_© ¤Îù�n� ü&�©�â¹ä¥©�
Æ�6Ã�ÃÑ ¥â¹ �B �Epicycle�£Äý'¤| Jj��uý'±� ª
´e�¸à�D:X4ÎÙ �
(6) ¼�ü�Menaechmus, f.350 BC� øîöó$ ¥�¹G6FþÚù6{óÚùÆ��
©
8ê £�ÒJª:óV Speusippus Heraclides of Pontus n ¿î�X:óV
Theophrastus Aristoxenus Dicaearchus Eudemus �� 3à��©�:Ù �¹×è�
MákáSx þÿ©ã:ÙÍ¥:¥)Ýõ�áÑún ª�üeÙ ¾�`©ã:�
��Ý´GÏ eêW¾á�� ï��X¥âàÆ à GSÚ©ã:�` ï��¹
�Jó$ÚFÔ9 ¡áÑúx �a� ï��XD:Æ:â[m:`Ìô�X©�:È
�¹Ú| �b�£�Ò�S«`ä¥X:È ¥â Î�GÔ 3J2¾Ý|Ú¥: à�
Ý6àÞ: ¹�]�I� �ó B² !ê��wok-GÔ w3��È ´�¹©
� n ¿î�•6àÞ:•985b25 & 1090a20 •••0Ù B Ý��ô�ûô�³Õô��ø�³�êeX 1984 /ùÂv�Ï¥
Page 13
13
ã ãeê£�Ò��d ÑkSxS�¥:üJ¥d�âk-XÎ�GÔ ÝáÃÚF
XEóGÏ _rÞ ×è�M¾Å��âZü©�ñÇ�X¡û�GÏ ù�¥:¹
0Mÿ�D: �x�ÑóÚI�¢�'X3î·�Î9 � �ê W ¸J�ó9ê
ÑmcX�Uf� Æî� î�©�¼f�·^Èk\Ù. JèÜZáå©�X_
�
5 ©ã©ã::��XXé鬬
¹ÞåÀ|�Z©ã:�`£�Ò�J:Á�ÈXôSGÏ �üJ�����\A
¹â ©ã�Î�X-��i�â�鬹�ä9\�X ×è�M`5=Í8Ñݺ�×
�`Ì��á`<ÌàXß© åÀü8¾�Jû'0ÔÐÄ j��k¼ãX� ©� �
ë ` Dë XÚÿ $éJ2-��ñ�Ý à�©ãñê`-�A«]¡'Ï�â�
!6ä JÚÿXKd� �ë ¨W¼¡-� -�âµÄ Dë í¼¡[m9¬X
vJ ¢ ͱ) Ì�ß9 £�Ò�«E¡PÝk-â¥:ø�6 ´8ª�§x
¹�ª:Á��X©�¼f ¬uÝâ�Ú¢
´8üJñ �ë ` Dë ø�¾Ý�å`�¡�XÚ¢ àèP8ѬSxÍ
�� ©� ��Z�¯ê~ÿGn ¿î�XÊ· ���KZ¬ê ø�Ô�Ø
J� �ÇÃáÌ� Ìf�Ï ��JÚ;È�tÅ �ë ää¬�¹ÿº Â
ÕM^æ_ Äï9óX-�¶' ×è�Mx�ü¸à� �óp; �Middle Comedy,
400 350 BC��Î� �t¹(úà��Tarentini� ©ãfë�Pythagorizusa�êÙÌV8O
��ûá+ 6����Öá 5³_6áþ À�M Ù �� �ë �X�ôm;
�S Dë ô³Xnãó$Íä��L�å�X©� �� ¾áÑxà îàUæ
Ù � �¹ªÀÍ©�X�Ä3£î#[ár _Vnãó$ Aristoxenus XÈ©��µ
Í�F= �ש�±ÍuÝô³êÙá�óX4à îÇȪÀp��O à ûîD
¹©�¾�X Dë h'¬�KÝk-µÄ`¹F ��×X ªÀ�]�X 3áÔn
�D: ÃÑ�[mÎXsÚêÙ$Ú ½óX ï����þQ_$
�ûz�¯ê~ÿ zGnZEû:�HK�! ©ã:��§3Z J Dë �
`¥: D: 2¬��ô³\abnã�Jó$x'� Aristoxenus GwĪ��ZÔ
âÔ·©�:Ù J �ë �`ºÂ ô³ B²ô³íJ9Z�æ:��Cynics� [Burkert
1972, pp. 198-201] �¢S°àÔ í©�¾á��09`Äãüà�k-ã�i�àÆ
8ßDRHÈá�Ý�ç �©ã:� ~?Ìô àèWÈ��ü»KX �£�Ò�
� �Þá�
¯̄ ++@@êê ÎÎ77--XXàà��Îδ́
+@ûÔ³ê üûz@�!Ôê~6ä {óZQo¡ûâp j� WX¼û
� Burkert 1972, p. 211-212. ' üß[ª³�•úxGÏXÎ�ã�
Page 14
14
�õéÈZ+@E`'Xá�n c�à9XSHYì ��ÐÈÀ�[ñ`+@ñÑÎ
� Jõ ñÑ\AZ�î��ûZ `ô³ ¢à{ó�Ic� øÙÑ�ëî-�ÙÀ
Î7-Xô�ÎG'à Ôâ ¸à�¥:XD�zûÈâ8àÊ w3�ùÑ��Ãf
�ûÈ�Caesar Octavian�Uá��`nZEû¢ ¹�ð�-�Xû£`9 �+@�2
`Ȧ�:µÄ�Ïà�[ê `:��ìêXÔ� o@¬ÐÈZS�¸·ê Xé¬
^Wú9Z�ç ¥¸ó �Late Antiquity�
Î7-XHK`¥:XD�Q¸�} �¢�¹9°X�±�³ øþ¼û¬
êÑá�UX ��ûX ���â��¡ÈÕ�ñÛéGÏ �Î7-àÔ ´�J
��ñÇêÙJâ9¥)X2:ÑÅÅÙÍ�à�[êX¡Nδ åÀüÔVU|�
X ��à�δV)ü+@ê =7 Jè�§ÜbÎ7-Xá��ß Çb¥:Xé
¬ í-YßÔV|�
1 àà��[[êêXX==77
7Vó=δX <� �Ì'á�X�ß à�[êδ�ü¸·ê ¥ó0ü
3�Æl`îô'X Î�ÞWÝø5áàèX Ô�î�+@`à�XÈyx� aí�
�²`Èy� î�Jüð�Xô� âa¨�9E¡S�
âÔ�ßXs|o��¯ê~ÿóXnZEûðU ¹�JÌâ»ñÑXÎ� \¾
� ^äsX¸Là�[ê�ó=7�ð� G�� Ȧ�: �ð`¶� üJâ
ÝRHÈ W`'�Ø¡k-µÄÌf�� §Ü â c�+@ñÑûÔ³ê �6ä
�¡�9E¡à�[ê�� ��à6äZëî ��XñÇ`µÄ Ý<6ÞÈy»S
à� àH k-ê ZXÆ:�� G�©�¹��:�¹��£�Ò:� 3Ý`�
b@�!â 9¾ð�àH Úûê ZXëî-� ÙÀdb��X?|�-� db
ø��³X=�- dbȦ�:Xà�ê�þ- ¬ÝäÑ��àÙ��îáàµÄXI
N-� üJñ Î7-¾á��8ëîµÄ�XÔ� ¾�bJ�oM� �¹Ñó�
jàÎ ä�+@ñÑXÑ- ¢à��¸û� ü8�ß� î�âÞÄØ:� -�
XSóf| Î7-´ÃS!X«�Zà�[êcJ ��y«ZWXδ
Çbà�[êü+@ê XÈyô� í¡¹©�¹�����ß ´�©��9
�¥db+ãûý ´8 ¢@�!�Ýê~ñÔ� ©�¹��X©£�Æ£¹ Ô�6
à�� XÓÕü+@S��Roman Forum�ÞªK JâDRHÈ c�à��ä9J9+
@ê á�©ã`nÎ(�ü�ÕZÆ [:ÌVBk��Pliny� S2+�Cicero� ��
� �Horace� 9È��Ovid� 2Yt�Seneca��á�+0�Î� àè+@�È�ù`
<xà©�¹��àó�X� S2+�î><��¡ó� Jèü�Ú©�£L V
�û� Ï¥��Õ[ ¹�£�B+(��Plutarch�Xº���â Í�Õû�¥óÅ°
E¡ Z�áD àÊ ¹ô³ £¹¾Õ 3�¬ÝM^@¾0�MUX©�ó��ã3
ü+@ô� 8ê þôX©�:! [� �ç Pythagorean Pseudepigrapha È�¢ Ô
� 8�ßX|�� Jonas 1958, Ch.1 � ÍÎ7-HKX�� �î [ê k- CX<6VÀ`ÐÄ� Ferguson 1987 �ü�ç ©�¹��¥¹ (Pythagorean Golden Verses)�<��£¹ ÝÕ G¾Â �¹Ý)�
Page 15
15
Ê � ü@�!â �©�¹��:��Neo-Pythagoreanism��ünZEû¢²óZ
2 ©ã©ã::��XXááHH
©�X�ß��ó£�Ò�:ÙøîU�Eudorus, f.25 BC�`à�êX�þ:Ù +
�Philo, 20BC–50AD� ªÀX¹0�U�Ú©�X�5ÎXsÚt¹ r'ê JèX�
¥@£�ÒÆ:� Y^û X ÝG[m���XX¼Ñ ùÄ� [m2: XÎ
X +`÷àÊ ÌôÒ£���Ô·÷fPk ªaÜZà��`à�ñÇ zG
ËÜZ��êX`�5X[m§X 2X�'� � �He� ��àóÎX2÷sí� �
Ø� �Logos� a��àóÎXø¡Ño� ïô2êÄ Þñ �God� ¹�³�2ê
Ä � �Lord� ' J2x�2�î�êÙݬ"�Ú à¾�¡ôJáàX0ü
´8ª�×2XY^û GJáù��Ú· Õ� ��aÜ�þ-Ô2�É`©�
f9�Éøþáà[mϳX~o +X:È` �z÷£ ÝUJÌ¥XñÇ C �
øÙ�úÝÈyGÏí�¹�n uÝeÂX� +ͽó-Mÿ�nZEû¢X�
¼�Clement, ca. 150—214�`ûý �Origen, 185—253��X2:ñÇÝ¡UE¡ ªX+0
z´8k¹û£-,
+�âR-HÈ �Ì»Î�Zî!�©�:Ù J�SÁ-X=��Ò�
�Moderatus of Gades, 50—100 AD��Á®©�¼f x�£�Ò`n ¿î�X¡U:ÈJ
r<kb ï�� �Î(�Xô\ ªXõ�üb�×[m§XXx�áù`<î�Ô
Á àOó}bD 7V´)�Oó}bÒ6 [©�Oó}b+¡ �Ò6 +¡ D
ÂJá�b_=�� kã ù ¬Ô ¨s�kX DÂG_= �ɯ9î
Z ¢�¹ß9 W`�ó� Ò�Xs$ÈÔ� JÈ���B¸�Û� ÇbzºX�
Ø@Ã�Nichomachus of Gerasa, f.100�íKÝþÌ¡Xø6 ª¶�+áD:�`$Ú:
� -ßÒ£S¯�ôXD¡+0 H�åT DÂ2N: �Numerology Theosophy� á
��\D¹þÿû� àèÚ�â2�Ì ! ¡ô!6�Èð�k-Íà�Úûϳ
Xëã WÅÅE¡ZJâX�£�Ò:� `�¸¹Ç 17 ê~XSû¥:�
ýnX�Ð�n��Numenius of Apamea, f.150—176���©��o ª+ÝR¥<
:ãX�K �X �On the Good� JÂÛübå�©�:³ ©ã���S«¸·Ì[
âÔ¬N;Ù ¹ßqõ�£�Ò`£��i ªX��GÔ3� [m2: Gäâ©
� Ý!2 êÄÝþ Í �the three Ones�ü,Ý ïó Î�½c��6X0ü�JP
8ÈXGÏ �É`îüLö�XÎ7-2: Mÿ�J÷�Þñ� ÷$�÷� ÷
I��Ø�� Ý!Ô' -�XÃÑGÏ3�k¼ã ´�_rÞ8-�³Ç�Ýê~ñ!
Î� WXBÛã��GéK��]� È�¯ê~ÿ!6C ü�Ð�n��â �©�
�§3Z Èh¹È����câïKX�£�Ò:� JèÍâÙ{óÅ°E¡ J
[m2: ä�âÙÚ�XK� JÍ©�¹��XÞÛ`2êz�<¬y« �� ð
� Úûê Xk-δë9ZS�Æ:��
í Ý)ä� Ý)�÷ W`($X ÝÕ 6ä[Ýã�XÍ; �
�ÝG�V�ßV�� Kahn 2001, Ch. VII-VIII �
�ÝG +`Î7-GÏXèJ� Runia 1993 Mÿ�I 335 342 X�§
Page 16
16
3 ��££��ÒÒ::��XXHHKK
�£�Ò:� Neoplatonism ï�ÙB+¤Î�Plotinus 205 270�üÞ��«îb
á�£ôXmT��Ammonius Sakkas� ��uÝ«�Ï)��2¬��êÙk-E¡
�H¹â�244 AD�ªk�+@[ñ2}-ü+@�: ¹�ObJ� ª-ßZ+áX 1
´: �Enneads� KÁ�=X¼+Î�Þ�£�ÒÆ:Xϳê`Å9Ô) �J��
�ãä�¡á �y��¸£6ãX£�ÒÆ: ªX [m2: ²�Z£�Òs9X
Í Úû I�Ý�§X ��VÈ��á àH'�åí�ÚÆ:¥)ä�ÌÚ
ûXk-GÔ V Shorey ÛÎ ¡�2Nûà29¾¯º $»�ìêó�Xk-�Ô
ê�ÔÑó¢£�Ò d�+� Xßë£Äk�'î wÌý�ÞXý �ݾÔ!ì
ê«�Ò£êÙÃÑVÑV@ �PØS,X �´F ´6 áÃ�L ¾Ñ¹�N
lzX 0��üX2I JbQáàb Ï)K'_= à�±Í ÀM )� �&
X W��ÝJª_=�ÃAX�ü��d`K´
B+¤Î�»S£�Òûô³X �ªÔ:��k¹�û J¼f¶Æý�Porphyry
of Tyre, 233 305�rsáÃu 1´: �||âêV ¹�B+¤Îô�X�m Ñ�
ªXs� ª¾ÅX+0�Úc J�ÙÀ©�¹��ô� �`·�£�Ò:Ùí¹¶
ÆýX¼f<× Ã�Iamblichus of Apamea, 250 325��·< ª`àóÆ�`ô���9
��Diogenes Laertius, f. 250� 3Ñ�â�mZ©ãô� �ôÇ�[Guthrie 1987] ��h
ê~ �L:ÁU�.:X¥:� Æ:�`2¬��ÙBï�U�ä��£�Ò:�X�
Ý· ª��mX û´ �´)s��ÔKÄ� [Proclus 1970]�2�¡UXà�½óD
:Æm J�3Ôa¤�©ã`ªXõ�
©�¹���«�Û°�¢�©�Ô� �JOÄôUí°�£�Ò��$ �U
´�¢�Ýê~Ô� k-èï!¬k�Á �£�´àÅ«KdbȨúX4ó:
�Astrology�`©o�Theurgy��Éó§ J�+�yZ2Ö`˵F= Í©ãt¹2ê
êô�î&²á£X_Í `¹�:ÙÝ�î9¾�ð$éz[ÝGÏ
´�V) £�¢B+¤Î�Bï�U�øþê~ÈX¥) ô� Mÿ�Wͽó
-îÔ¡UXñÇ�÷9¸�Õ�St. Augustine, 354 430�XÅ�E¡ �£�Ò:�üS�
Æ:ñÇX���!�664nß9 Jó§o ËÀoÔÈÊÁÇ 19 ê~�Ç 20 ê~ñ
HàþD Ô�6��bW���¡NXà�δQ' ºÔ�6í�bW�þ�êXÆ
:ñÇ Ã¹Öháà�å èü Ñ�û á� 16 ê~¹Q�¤Î�|ÈXÊíMÿé
ü©ãý[:�É 17 ê~X�0¦3¬à�åTbD+2¬�� ÕÒü 5 ¡7î6'
9|kþ�Ïhû óX<'�X � ÔÈ� 17 ê~�6 0�:�ÔE*ÜX©
�¹����«�Ô¬Û@ ���vö[m9¬X!E `¥ùNû0üX<U
� ÝG�£�Ò:�X�Ä� Wallis 1972 � Shorey 1938 8ê Mayhall 2004z[Tâ � C�má� � Phaedrus 247C 0Ù B Jowett Å¥�Ï¥(Shorey 42) � Laertius 1965. �¥��•áÆÔ )•(Ýk�åÎ�� 2003) �9 �X©ãô��Þ:�XÔ� � �6X|�� Dodds 1957 Mÿ�J|�©oX�)` ��� Kahn 2001, Ch.IX �
Page 17
17
4 ããôô³³ IINN--����JJªª
@�!âü+@ê Î�X á�ÝÞÄà�Æ:ô³XÊÁ ÈÝ¢Ke`XØ¡
��-� ÙÀà��XÎ7- âÙªk�û�!¹â Jª-�«_àää\�
�¹åÀÍWÀXZ·U�Ä� 8ZåDôê[�¹ê ¾Ñq*½óÎ7--X�Ï
[+ G�ç ÖÃ: �heresiology�[� \L¤X ��ü`�ê~`< ¬Z ´
�ü��ÎóZû£â�ÝGXs�[� ¸-���X�� ��pâK9 o-�X
ÚÉ�Î7-X6äMÿ�Jà�δX0ü¤oZ C`�ö àè 3�0��·ê:
d�X�¥��� 6àÔ� Wâ¥:3à�ÝEóGÏ
oh�?¼X-�´�¢-� �õ ¥d�êÙÊó9ß Ñ´"XäÔþ²Á
�Ï �Z�� åÀ¥èÚWÀ0Vßk9ÚO
�1� IN-� Gnosticism : ÙÀ�çÞÙS¼��Simon Magus� Ð�-��Mandaeanism�
ºúË��-��Valentinianism��� WÀÑ`Î7-ÝK'I² êÙüJ-��
¤�÷ê»z÷£ ´àÎ�Þ�Â�Î7-XÖà _V Ð�-�ÞÛ�ëzÄ
àún÷ ºúË���íKdbÎ7-Y¼ 1945 HüÞ�� Dag Hammadi ¥�
Zä:b 350 AD ºÇX 52 � ¥BM[IN£K Coptic Gnostic Codices �
WÀX�Us�[�
�2� ?|�-� �Hermeticism� ÝÕ?|� �Hermes Trismegistus����N;2,ÿ
�Thoth�Xà�ê� ÝÕ �Thrice Great�ÛJKÝÓ= á= |=Ý�6X¹�
J[�ÙÀôêXà�[ ?|�£L �Corpus Hermeticum�¹� ¥BM[IN£
K �¼Ñ�´
�3� =�- �Manichaeism� �Ýê~ñÎbø��³+¼ -�=�!ób 216 AD J
[�¹ 1970 Hü��¥�X ¥Z=�£K �Cologne Mani-Codex���
?|�-�`=�-KÝÀ�Kd`�Ñ Ã¹��âÎ7-¹ÌÖXk- �Þ
ÄÝO-�á�ü�³ÞKÝð� C àèÑKÝ2�Ì�XM^[m� ÙÀXJø
XÚê`Í� KÝé� >J`%"�É Í ó¹ �gnosis�XUá� ����
k%"XG� Ì�Ñ�+� +¬êÙd£X¡U¹���ï Îb ¡N X���
É ÝO-��TTÑ�³��2¯ IN-� û·_ ' J�ç ó¹ â�
¹åÀÄ� knowledge êÙè¹à��Ä� episteme Xw¡NûX v�X¹�á
à WúÝ 'î ó« �Ç ñÏ' éO÷ Xÿã W´e�¹��Ék-
êX§p ´8 IN-�ù��à�¡N`à��¡µøûô³X�È{= 0�ø
Ù�ÈXãô³ WÔ�6�ÍÎ7-¥óM^ûüXE¡ _V 17 ê~ñHKX�D�
+� Rosicrucianism `E"î Freemasons Ñ��Ôô³à9 ºÔ�6�üà�ô³¹ê
)�ZºÔ¡�¥: GÎb?|�-�X�¥�
�ÝGo-�X�m`|�� (a) Ferguson 2003(1987), pp.300-316 ÐÜ�Ä ÙÀ Dag Hammadi £K
Xº�Â) ¹�IN��â½óÎ7-GÏ �E��!é Jonas 1958 XèJç: (c) Broek & Hanegraaff (ed.) 1998 �[� (d) Broek 1996 þ��[� �
£KX�Â� Ferguson 1987, pp.302-303 �
�ÝG=�-X|�� Oort 1998
Page 18
18
ëîIN-�¬ÝºÔþEà��=�-8ê� WÀþÿû À�ûMÿ� �¹�
#��`.náÏX��µÄ £!ûÜ £þ��ÑùؾÁJïôo`Ç5o¤Îá
àX[m§X Ì2ϳ ¹�XJì]`%" �C ¡Ú;¡ôZü�#�ÐñÇ
`�_��ß¾�¥ùNoXâp 3�âZÎ7-)¹ÑóüÔâ�jàÎ U6kSû
åëXµÄ k-�Oî�Ô!M^Ôï�=`¤oÀM_Êà6äÙD .nXEà-�
`ÂÛ úí�Ýz�No�ãXE=
hh ��êê~~¥¥:: ²²&&ââé鬬
£�ZÝþê~Xô� �S k] Î7-�bü@� 325 H�ï¿:Õûñ
�Constantine�w×�Ñ- ¢à�kZ+@ê ºÔ�6 ünZEû¢ÔâÔ!óûý
[:�,¦� Ptolemy, f.150 AD ¹â à�|Ú¥:�¯9ZÿSXD�Êó Þ[¤
�X�Ø@à `,¦�ûzàÊ jïán�ßèJXö>Ò �Diophantus, ca.200
284� èJ´)<ÍâU$ÂlXéB� �Pappus, ca.290 350��D:�¡ÝáàßzX
ï� ��L:Á6SBï�U�X�Uõ� íübÆ:`D:ÆZ S+@ñÑühê
~ÿ§3 8ÊÎóX+@£¶Þ¤ �Boethius, 480 524�á�µ�Î7- �â�Ñ
Þ�]-÷f àè3�+áÆ:�`D:� ª�O`£�Ò:Ácâ�ð+@ñÑX¹
¿Õ�ûñ�Justinian�ÕÁ�529� 5UZS�¸·DÚô³X§3
¾8�â S�¥:£ZZ��Ô�HX]�!�aÔ�À�¥) ��HJrJ
2NQÔ� à���Z¥:X�� Ïá ²& é¬ �X1S�²�á�¬ê ü8
Zß� Wâk-XGÏ3¢û�àää¬�c� �ÈÎ�¹���X�U
1 ������ÌÌ¢¢ ¢¢������²²&&
7Và�Æ:Ò£ô��ð� â'�k-§Ü �¡�9¹�6ÂE¡+@ê
à�¥:3ÝÌO�X ��â²& £Z ��þÈ��²`ÿSX�ß Wû'ÞÚ
�øþ� j� 7³Î7-îXn_`Âû�ôä¥:� �� X f¦´ô �push
factor� ü@� 430 450 HÈ���ý-��Nestorians�`Î7Ôû���Monophysites�ü
-�]���ùàä�Öà �¿�Ï�¶� ¢àE¡J�� [ê �à�[êü'�
¥)4nÎ� Jâ:Á�ªè ¹D:�oB Â��Simplicius, 490—560��jXAá:
Ù3H¶�q�Jøï¸�UÔê�King Chorsroes I� ³� nZEûX�:�3Ì»�¶
�¯Ñ Jè.�bJS+¼Xµ�mBè�Jundishapur��: èJ � � ü 430
600 HóÈ �Z�Ò\fXÔU �Ô�ZÚà�Æ: ¥:£LÏ¥�'�îüX
ýn[�Syriac�X¹0
Jâ Þ�D-äZà�¥:üð�ó X y�´ô �pull factor� ' ü�k
-²ó�âÔþê~È ����V�����K�ð ¶� ë2 ãûý+Ã`SÁ
- 8�[ê;_´ÃS! 641 HnZEû¢K�âJûÒ:Z�î���=�XJÄ
Page 19
19
����_ñ�Abbasid Caliphate��ÑÈ�� Ô�Î��n ݽc �l®{XÞ�
DñÑ�â ���@¬Z ¢?ê~�ÊÔ� Уè�al-Mansur, 754 775��´!�
©Ñ�Q£L :� à�[ê @3�al-Ma’mum, 813 833�ÈÓ�:�' Î�Ä�
N;� �House of Wisdom�XèJ6`Ò:Z üªÀX��`�Õß ���¨X�
:�µ�=�Hunayn ibn Ishaq, 808 73�`Þü��Ishaq ibn Hunayn, d.910�$ ¹��îî
¡ÔÁXý[:�f�M�Thabit ibn Qurra, 836 901�k¹¢�`Ýϳ�Úû£à�Æ
: ¥: �:L!Ï¥ä���[ àÊ DzXD:ÙÀJ�DúËâ�ã3ô9È�
� ü 9 11 ê~øÝRHÈ �b'�:�èïXó§`�� Þ�DXD:�Mÿ
�·D`ݦ:� �: ý[: �:�²�¥) câJèääSô SkÔ+�Cairo�
SS �Sicily� ¥îº�Cordoba� î¦î�Toledo� 3ä�À�X:���
ºÔ�6 £�Z@� 500 1000 HS�hþê~X¥kÊó `î>¡ÎñÑX
�ùñ© û��bá£Z ü 11 ê~ +@ý�-îÁó \ ��] �The Investitute
Contest�¹��+oðU�o_=ôÎ�Z�ûX��`'�o£ cG{óZøþãÇ
á�X[êpr Gû:HK ä�În` Ý�oX:��X ¹�n���Adelard of
Bath� Ý���Gerard of Cremona��:Ùk¹üSÁ- SS Ȧ�: ï¿:Õõ
��yº�¸à�¥:L! ´àTKZÁ�XÏ¥¤| Ú �� ð�îHà�Æ£¯
Ô9äSXà�¥:âÆ:¢y²& 6ä�ç ½ó[NáH ¤| àè ÞÄøÙ�
fÌ||X ¸·L!`Þ�D:��r3��Zû:Òß û:��J�� è4¤oZ
ÚÇ' È¡UX� û:ä��2:X� üJ¡NX-:`è|�W� ¡�Î�
Xà�Æ:Mÿ�n �î��e`}�©íâÎ7-��Û§ÜK9 ä��Jϳâ|
ÚX £62: �scholastic theology�, J¥)ü 13 ê~È¢û:X÷îo �St. Thomas
Aquinas, 1225 1274���JÄ � Î7-ü6ä�ñ�b¾c§àñõS«Xà�
¡Nδ ü£� ��â²& �â �aõÍ�¥ó�û0ü
¹Þ��Î7-`¸à�¥:øþûô³XÌf0üàÔ üWÀß6 Jª66
FFXãô³ ÌVIN�� 2N���Theosophy� Ø¡d�©��Magic Cabbala
Occultism��� Q«�_ H¡Ìôá±Vé Ë�Z¥: 6àÞ:`2ÖäÑ
XoÑ� µÄ�k-ÞXãô³ zá�4ó� �¥� � ��Alchemy� D+2
¬���¥:ãô³X�2Î� _rÞ ûãô³�Ú ¾á��<6X �ê~¹Ç
�A×ê~:Ùá�èJû´ � n ¿î�`,¦� àèÍb�¥�à�xó à�
óHw GSüÎ7-µÄ`<�=û�¹â ¡N�2¡üJ���J<�¹ß»Á¤
¥:`k-�¹äÚ� ��·¥:B� �m¤|HK¹âX_
2 ¥¥:ã:ãôô³³ ��¥¥��
V�<¹ �·¥:XU���ý[: D:`=Ú: Jd�ünZEû:� �
18 ê~�ÊX�·ê:U��â��9X6 WXd��üw �]��ºÔþd
¬ á� Ç�¬uÝ`<�¥:Æ�XÙX�ß w���¥� �bW�`(� ~�
� û�î ¥á� ,@� �"w êÙ¼
Page 20
20
Ø¡-�Ë� àèZ9¹d: \��î �¹Ä��¥: ãô³ �\¾X
S� �¥� Ô¡Xd�\ÃÑ���°¸¹9X¥2��`�=Ö§T�
Chema ÛJ¥ó GØ¡��sm�Î 8¡ô9���â¬� al-Chemie ²&û�âa
¬ä Alchemy Çb�¥�X�*ô³ÞÑ&b2êZXÝÕ?|� w����`à�
[êXaÜ= àè\ÃÑ�ü+@³�ßXnZEû¢{óX ´�V) â8¬z2ê
�=�Ý�×�WJrÙÀ*-`��ÝGX[�Ý`�î� ?|�[� �Hermetica�
WÀÃÚ�ø¼Ñ �a�½ó¼Ñâ(� 4ó �: Ó= ��ÝG ûÈÎ�b@�
!â �b�ÆÚ¼ÑÙÀ 17 �?|�£L�Corpus Hermeticum� J�ÔÝáX��ç Ó
]� �Emerald Tablet� 8ê¬Ý!ÄIN£K�XD� ¹�ºêø�ôê[� o
ûÈÎ�b 50 200 AD ´8 �¥�Ôãô³üJ dØ3�¥T k- ÆÚXË
Ü= àèü�ÉÞx� !ÙÝ*bâøÙXéÐ ?|�ô³Î�W. ´8Ý�ðÇ
W[«à�¥:ô³ Mÿ�n ¿î�XE¡ G¡�à�δü¥ó0ü ü?|�
�â ¸·-,[�áî £ 200 AD ºÇX�S`��¹è=���Leiden and Stockholm
Papyri�C��§m ��Xr�¹cÈâ ÍÜ���Zosimos of Panopolis, f.300 AD�X Ö
5 Vision í��µ5UX��§Ô
�¥�XÛrèJÃÑ�¢�ê~X���¥:�Ü��Geber, ca. 750 800�`�È
Â��Avicenna, 981—1037�Ô� Wü 13 ê~ô9Sû £�û�è�M�Albertus Magnus,
1206—1280�`+ÆÍ �Roger Bacon, ca 1219 1292�ø!Þ.:ÙXvJ ||àó ¥
� [Ô�VáÜ �¥�Ô�UXÂÛ�r�áà¥2X@ê Mÿ�Ú"�¥2V�
à¬�¥2V¥ Ê àÎ�����Ú·<�û`�îX?Î`·<�¨X�Êøþ
�UXä�ô üØ¡ýz ?í`�9áàJªäÑX��ß�� 2Ü ]� �c
¤��� ªÀ̵ ¡¬êXG�êÄ9¬�Arcana��R��ç �¥Ç �The
Philosopher’s Stone�zG I �Elixir� WºÔþÂÛí�ÏRSóáÕC w�U��
b[NáHÊó2¿�óé�fè£��Paracelsus, 1493—1541�||C=:�6XèJ S
ô³�¥�rtZ � � X�åz àÊ ªü?Î`2¹ê rtZ ¤ 0��Ý
þXä�ô Jèx��Ô9 Xä=�á6b¥2 àùÙÀ�Ý=' �� ¢
16 ê~ñÔ� �¥�¯9ZÔþ�~�
� 16 ê~ß� �¥�XÎ�ûr ��ÍWXHw¯9¬B àèÊÁÇ 17 ê~
ÿàáD ü8ÊóÅÑÔÝáXø!=Ú:�¶���Robert Boyle, 1627—1691�`/SÑ
�Ôxó ¸� �Ç¥"�ÁX�¥:��Alchymist� à/SàÊ3�Zû£�ob2
:XèJ[Dobbs1975; Principe 1988] Ý:Ù|�Jè�� �¥�X¬BXK´ ��
k-=Qâý�-¡ =�Counter- Reformation�XSók] Sk:ÙÍ7³k-�J�Ú
ó�`J k¦ ¢à@å[m9¬XvJ¹Ï�D� ·�
¢ 17 ê~�Ê� 18 ê~�Ê�S�X�¥��Alchymy�@¬��·ê:X�õó J
� Linden ed. 2003. ¹:XÐÔ��¥�XÐÄ �Ô´G�Gb?|�Ù � û�î ¥á +Ýè Í êÙ � ¸à�X=Í'�ë�(Empedocles)`n ¿î�x�Xä[mXÎ�=ü�? è � ó¯Ù Î
�Þ¡�'Ê:Ùy« �ªÀx�`¹�=üÈ y¥ X�?Î`2 øÙÃ�� �È�ô � Gb�¥�`k-XGÏ�JÍþÿ:ÙXE¡ �!é Dobbs 1975, pp. 48-62
Page 21
21
G��=��¶�� ªá��=üX �ô �Element�¤Î���· àèªÍè'_
oâ'ÃGÏXèJ ¸�¥�XÎ��å3²ú ¬ 3�� �Ô ÚJ ÏR�¥Ç
êÙ ê��¥ X�rÂÛ@¬� v�Xä=üXÎ��ô �ÔþÔ�X èJû
XÂÛ �` ÚJvö��¢ÎÕ¥2 êÜ=X�» §Ü �c@¬�è'XT)0
ü Y��John Mayow, 1641—1679� ×���Joseph Black, 1728—1799� 5[¾��Henry
Cavendish, 1731—1810���ü�õó�0XÔ²�4Îûr`Ñ�ñà��å¯ ªÀ
XäpcâÐÈZ�ºõ�Antoine Lavoisier, 1743—1793�`B �Më�Joseph Priestley,
1733—1804�ü 1770 H·XU�û¹0
3 ûûôô³³XXUU����üüww
�¥�üÎ7-û�ûÈÞ��¡ 0�KÝÅ°Æ:ã�Xý[:`=Ú:íáÔ
� W`2:Ô� �ÉÞ dbn ¿î�Æ: è|`�}3à��£6ãX G¹
Ô¡9c· |�£L[� �¹øÙàdzáàX à ý[:á�T!¥) �¹ø
ÙÇ�{óÚ; û�Ñ\s] Ú;�b¹Q��¤Î¹�Èàä�áÃ×` �b�
ý9�w@JÈàÐÈù¡�U Ôâ¹+@ý�-î_�ù 8È�¥:�<6y«à
�� à HJ2+@-î`¥:X�Ôs�r ½ü 13 ê~�ÃÑÆ£Ý�ÌO�
UZ
_rÞ �b�m¤|XE¡ ÔÈ� 19 ê~�6 ¥:�`ZÆ:�Ñ�³X�n
�·¥:�¢[NáHÔ�à� ๠ý'¤ � �=Q�Ä ��ü`�ê~�ñ
�b©Ñê:�`¥:Æ�¾Ö�Pierre Duhem, 1860 1916�XæÊ·�K¼+ [mϳ
�Le Systeme du Monde� à«�Z�ûåì ¾ÖcÚ`ÚdZ¾£�ҹǹQ�`�H
È=V³KX¸L`�¸[� �âüìÕXû££6Æ:+0� =Ú: ý[: [m
�XGÔ èJ }�Jr¢þ0C� àJäp7���A×ê~=Ú:=QXÎ�
� ª¾Å3üS�¥:ÆéKZÔ�=Q îÇÝ�x� S�¥:Æ¢ª!ó7Ô�
' ¾ÖXH'�� G¥:¯9Î�Þ�ää`²ÁX ¡ÝUû]� ©ÑºÔ!
¡U¥:Æ�¥ºË�Alexander Koyre� �ÕÌ¡ã� x�U¬`=Q!�¥:¯9�
�´�]�§pV) ´ÃúxX� S�¥:ƱáÃÑ©�¾Ö�¤ÎXû£Ær à
�O¹�� B`��0η�
åÀUü8|�X J2�]� à¾�J�Ôþ¡U�V G¾Ö�¥�X 13
ê~-îâ¥:XÔ�½ó�U �UKdbÝG !B �Place�X]� n ¿î�
üJ =Ú: �¯KÔ�hVº�|�Z�i���ÔÊ_=X !B J â�U·
�XÎ�Âl`[m§X��ÛÌGX nãx� Ô�='XÏ|V � J� c�
� ÝG�¥�ü 16 17 ê~X@¬� Debus 1987 � ÝG�·ê:Î��ß� McKie 1990 (1952) � ÑÖ 56 UG´�ã�ñê JÊ [mϳ !hKûÈ`ä �îþ¬g 8ê¾-ßû£þÒHÚ
X�� �bJG� Ûøÿø�ø Xá�~o�Jªß�`Ý��X�Õ <¼�KÔâü 1959 Hk¹`äÎ
� � Duhem 1985, Part II. Place. 8��K�©[ [mϳ XÅ[Ý¥� <¥�îþÎ� � Barnes ed. 1995 (1984), Vol. 1, pp. 354-362; or Physics 208a30-213a10.
Page 22
22
û �accidental�X �è�Þ� ¡=�ß4 ó��²@�GJ<�Ú<¤|���H�
�üû �per se�X âÙ´àÝJ ¾ X¬ß!B 8!B�� B�©�ײ@
XÌ ó`&óà�×6�Homocentric spheres�9�n ��Hþ[mk¹ n! �
à�×6X��üw 6 Wì¹�NÈX� w�J!B¬�uÝBn �¹W��Ô
þ&ná|Xr= à¾Ñ��× ü�·ÁÔ9È ÎnX�×��Hþ[mX{Ûs
� uÝÎnX�× Hþ[mX!B3�ä�áBn �É�¸·ý[:XÚ�Î�
Ã� ,¦�XDÚý[ϳQ£�`�ÉÌ�UX ªÏ³�X�BÚ ó<'
X��þ�uÝr=4BX�ÞZ �éK���¥:�V�Õ+Þ�Averroes,
1126—1198�XMø ��ü 13 ê~û�Î�Z|�ÞÄÂlXÁB £û�è�M +Æ
Í ÷îo 9Ó�William of Ockham, 1285 1349���U£6:ÙÑ��+:�È �
8¥<�� ªÀXEà��� ´�V) Ôê�X&ó×6�W�b�Hþ[mX� �
�����În� 4B8!BX���× àè [mÆ£Ù�ZÔÛ �¹&ó×6
XH'GÏ�translation��uÝã�X �þ�eÞX¯Ò îÇÞñ3´©.�_
üeÞ�ÑoX�X�Ô�æZJª2:� 3¸k�îá�,¦�ϳXý[:
�áµ ´8 ü-kzÄÔê�John I�XU�ß È¢�-û�-�£è�Etienne Tempier�
ü 1277 HÀ�È¢û:-\`Jª:Ù� ûî|�8Âl §pâîÙÔÈ�÷ ¹J
ân ¿î�X =Ú: `�Õ+ÞݯÒ�ó· ঱SxÞñÑo XÏ)È©
� B¾ÖXß© üÎ7-`¸à�¥:Xñõ76�U� n ¿î�X�Õ«
�Zåì`]¡'Ï ¢8�â Gb,¦�ϳXØ¡ ¯`|�k¹¾�¯ à�Õ
+Þ�x�X ¾ÝÔê&ó×6!��ÎnXÔß© 3k�@x ��¹â¹
Q���É�Î�¤oZNÈ ´8 ¾Öx� `Z9�ÉDDÌ¡ 7�+@ý�-î
^¥:¢n ¿î�=Ú:X"c·�Î9 ��·¥:XÎ�ÎG'Ã
' ´��Uü¥:¥)Þã�V) W¾á�� 17 ê~X¼�Í��ããXè
àÆ à Ôʹ� Q�¥óü-î�Õâ£62:V¹�ý�� �3�ù�
�¥:âk-GÏ�2� �à��`à��2�´©`<x�Xé�Z
AA §§ÁÁ Y^Y^XXÑÑ��
üS� ¥:`k-ÝVà¢)� à��Î� äSX>ó�ó WÀû� T�
¹Ö Âû�â]¹_�� �bÚ'@G �� GSü 2500 HâX�¹ øÙXE
à dH¬üãÇá��ØB�Î9 _V Å�£$o:X³uûüÄDÊ �´�:�
ó�ªü6Í Õ�$X¬� àÈÎ Þñá��$ w�X±9 ªá�-f H¾
SKÝ\Åk-�Ô åÀ�Ñók�XÔbm£`�2¬ó �)�ó7N�`ó7
¥:Xs��� ¡2¬ó�ÜZ$»�î{ók- âQÝo_=�åÀáÃÑò
³X ã��åÀ�N�� ¾á���óâÇbX�¯ ¡x�`ó�7�Xäk-
�ÔXUô üþã�Þ 3��üþã�Þ å�ÅÅi9k-X� [Einstein 1931]
� �´�: 1926 H 12 Ü 4 ¹È¶=(Max Born)Ñ @é¾ Levenson 2003, pp. 342-343
Page 23
23
à �¢ÚÉàÔ ¥:`k-XEà dJ³üw 6 �åÀü�[XZÆ׳�
�áʺ� �¬þÒÈy6ÍXÂl
�´�:�¤�Xk-�ÔÝÝþUô $» 2¬ó `�NX$z !øÙ�Û
��6Íû¾�5Ê�óÎX@# w´e�� »z÷£ �=Süè�EÈ6ÞñÊ
Xó� âÙ�Û H���á¡2¬ó @#óXÕÒ Øbà��âà�[ê�ÈX
+�×Þñ�áÃÚ· 7¡ôZ¡ÕÒ�ôäX�Úôo \�X WÔÈôæ�
¶�¥:�zá��þ�X�´�:�Þ 6àÔ� k-ÎbÍû¾X@# ¢à{ó
Þñ�É ¥:íÎb�á Y^¡$» @#XÕÒ
à��å£XÞñ�ɨW)� ��¥)Î9XÎ7-íÈ��9 WÔ¡UXï
���ó�É �ÉX9dåÀá�ü8ÅJ �W´e`©ã-�X9óµÄ ¹�I
N-�Áó ó¹ k%X�ÉÝEà�Ø �É�·<X �ÍóQ$zXåì `Y
^8$zXÕÒ WÍÎ7-KÝǬ¡Uû w°°Y� �z÷£ �Ï)ÝG��
.�X'�-Æ Ô�ù¢SÁ-Ô¡UX¥·ñÇ� ��~�Michael de Unamuno�
XwÔk�D� k-��c$X W�Ô¡Y^ûX£"§X �¢k-`k-µÄ�
ÏRX �±,¾ÅXþ' SWä��& à´��¥: êÙN� êÙ'� Ñ�
.á�X ÞñÍ¥: ÍN� Í'� ÑuÝ�U ¸Þñä��UX�k- �å
ÀJáÔUÞñ9-ÐåÀ_=Xóï êÙJbQ 3áÔU�½.>J¹Èx'� à
�ÔU�Ã%åÀ SåÀ!bOiAu ÀMX�ï�£Ôþ`�ÝX7���wo�
b¢ÂêÙ[ê�ѬYÙù8ê�X�ï W�Bêy«XÛ� [Unamuno 1954
(1921), pp. 318-319 0Ù¥[]
I�áA ¹��óµÄ 0�ùE¡�Ç�nI�Xþ9��É íù���
ó�ÉXºÔ6 �'¶î$� �A w��óXóÐ��OU�áAI��,ü ¡
�9È 82I�áA Gâ�'ÝÎ�Âÿ úíWVá��î-Xë ´8 åÀx�
S�k-`¥:XEà dübøÙÑ��UY^û¾XÕÒ k-UY^X �¾ó
QX$ ¥:UY^X í�û¾�{óX$» 2¬ ´¹
Ô§� \¾XéÎZøþ!óÂl j� �¥:âk-ü�Ñô³[ê 6
�ú3ÝÌà d Jõ í�øÙü�·ê XGÏ GWÀZÆÞXû�GÏ�úÆ
£`<�b a3áÃÑ6áZ ¹ßåÀÚ�ø�60TÁ|� ¹0��[X§3
��Ñ[êàÔ JÔ½3�Ô�ûX|o ´e��î`��½cXÎ� à2k
- Æ: ¥: ã � <Ý·Xå£aÜ�ßÍ8�¥óZ�nûE¡ �¹üR�
]÷Ê·QÎ��V|�w�KÝù���à�¡�¾vJâ�É|dXk-¶'
à �Zº�ûԳʷ ±û¼ÑÑ�¬D |�øJ\�k´E´þ Ç�ä�ñÇ
��X �<9êXæ ©ø� WÀ�ñÑXÎ�¤oÎ� 3�Jâ`�-HX�"
[ê�n�� ü8û Cß Ñ�þ�óQW `��ý�¾�'XÕXÆ: ¹�2
�� ¿� �C Oó���ô³�düð�ÿH�äZ'-�HK
'-XñÇ\r� J¥)Zßzá�¾�� �üøþã�Þ W`S�k-XB
ÝUJÌ¥�Ø �Ô WX��Ñ�� SóáÕ �` W3à�âô³¥: G�
� C=:`��:àd Jè)�ZâÙ ºÔ�6 ü<6XÌ��ß 3Ý�Ú¡
Page 24
24
UXÚÿ�k¼ã _V '-X Só �þÝ�ÂXõ�VÉ ÙÀ¢ÊH�Ó¹Ç�
êO �"Â�§pàn S�X �ó í�±ÍX uÝ�{� Jõ Só
��êóQX¬ê`ÊÁ WJáãG]�`I��ÈX�� �¹Ý Q¹²� �È
�Ô¡UX íüb¯ áC Ðéä���Â�¹ÿù X �Ç � ¬'ü 6
àÔ� ü'-�ÉârÉ� ¥:âk-X§Ü�Èy`'ßX JáVS�w� kÁ
óÞñêÙ¤¡[mûsí �ß�!k¹`ä
3� ÞÄÂÖù&§�ðSø¡[êÍû¾ÕzXÚÿ �Ñ�Å« ý'°
�'½ ` ý�ÜÔ �ñÇE¡ <¼�Nâã�ÎXÑiå�[ê ý ` Þ
¡ íä�9°àõ�XVÉ �¹�áaó�û¾�2¬`Ã# 3��#¢J�¥l
d£9¬ êÙv|�kÃ% �óèXX|o 3��È ü�[�2�=ßX�Ñê
GS�óQ$zX�á3ùüK'X�ê�©·� àá��}bY^�êX�5sí
Ú�Z
üS� Y^ê XvJÇ�ÐÈZ¥:`k-XÎ��U ¥:¥)X§pí�î
�Úûâ¾�_à|� âúnZk-XÎ�µÄ _V��êX[m�� I�áA
Ã%â�ó�� à ͱûîD� ÙÀü¥:Ô¯9¥�X�Ôê 6X�àÔ
o�ÉHJþä�î- á�U üßã�� îÇõõ��Xü�ÉÞ ªÀ¬�üá
àßz«oµÄE¡ 7Qóü'��E. R. Dodds�èßà�ô³k-ü@¬�X�M�
�9£Ä �µÄõã\åÑ`<�8»õã U�»X����X 6»Áó,
wTT�üá�Sx`�¾���ß U�øÙJ, QfÌ¯Ò �HàÊ�áà
Xþ��ÇàÔþ�y« [Dodds 1957, p.179]
à åÀ¬�áÑá �m¤|¹� 19 ê~¯ê��]Ík-X'ÏÇ�îä�
ÈQ Xë k-XY^Ñ��úzÚ`¿� 40 E±�2Û°Ô� ä���O[
ê¥)�Æ£��X� Úü[ê.=Z�4BÞ!B�û�J�o <6Þß9Q
V8 �'�Xß©¬��kxó¼ãX üÂ! ¥:`k-´e¬�Øbª�ç øÙ
J, QfÌ¯Ò X�Õ ��ÕH\ÃÑ´$óÈÕß� �¹Øû�Uk-�À
�¾áYÔ GS�½Æ_ã�X�- �Zoroastrianism�`IN-��XÐ�-
�Mandaeanism�3¡ü¤o�x���
3� È�kÅñX� Ýwo»Xk-�ÉÚî ����X 6»Áó,
üåÀß9 �XÃÑûá�,ü àè2�S¯ _V δ�X·Õ ¬�|=X�
Z `ó=¹��:¥TH'X²�¯9 Æ£�ÝoX��ZÊS` ô¾óQXóÐ
ÈÕ Só XóÐbáé[Silver 1997] �_V D�H9åÑo�á�¹´){D�
ãrt ¹�£$åÎ�XÃÑ Æ£ÔaéKZåâ�å�úÝ�üÂÖX|� ¹
�å�úùݾåã��ÇI�XÂl[Penrose 1989 Æï 1993a & 1993b] üÂ!
�X]�¡\�� àè�î+á¥:�3¬ÑÕúnÕz �7VÞê~ݯ�H·
s$ÑX¥)�ó°°Y"'Ê¥:�X�u à� üD�HêÙDþê~�â åX
¥)�úÚ`< ¬åÀÍ� ÍóQX�É w3�´©X�X Ôâ ¹Â!f(%´
°ë� ´�áÙX¥) ¹�<×ê>B¬|X_�ß9 �O�î�6äKÝ!8áÃ
Ç5¼ûÑo S.¹�¹�#äó�Xû�Ý�%° $é3Æ£áa�OÇ àÔ�Ý
Page 25
25
�rã�Z[Grand 2001] þ�â8ê %°XGÏ �Úä��UÂl àoÂlX
k-åz Mÿ�JâÞñ�ÉXGÏ ��Úâ�X ´8 2�ÞµX ¥:�á�¯
9 \ÃÑ7�\·Jâk-�Èôo SøÙ¢ �Þ¡�aÜX%�
����®� 2004 6 e 10 11 �}/VÖ0Ý0��ã@ �<ài�H �
ììÕÕ®®??³³
³³
Barnes, J. ed. 1995(1984). The Complete Works of Aristotle. Vol. 1. Princeton University Press. Levenson, T. 2003. Einstein in Berlin. New York: Random House. Broek, R. van den 1996. Studies in Gnosticism and Alexandrian Christianity. Leiden: Brill. Broek, R. van den and Hanegraaff, W.J. eds. 1998. Gnosis and Hermeticism: from Antiquity to Modern Times.
State University of New York Press. Burkert, W. 1972(1962). Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Debus, A. G. 1987. Chemistry, Alchemy and the New Philosophy 1550-1700. London: Variorum Reprints. Diels, H. 1879. Doxographi Greaci. Berlin. Diels, H. and Kranz, W. 1951-52. Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker. 3 vols. Berlin. Dobbs, B. J. T. 1975. The Foundations of Newton’s Alchemy. Cambridge University Press. Dodds, E. R. 1957. The Greeks and the Irrational. Boston: Beacon Press. Duhem, P. 1985. Medieval Cosmology: Theories of Infinity, Place, Time, Void, and the Plurality of Worlds. ed.
and transl. Roger Ariew. The University of Chicago Press Einstein, A. 1931. The World as I See It. in Carl Seelig (ed.) 1956. Ideas and Opinions. London: Alvin Redman. Ferguson, E. 2003(1987). Backgrounds of Early Christianity. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans. Ferguson, E. 1987. Backgrounds of Early Christianity. Grand Rapids, MI: W. B. Eerdmans Publishing. Freeman, K. 1959. The Pre-Socratic Philosophers, a Companion to Diels, Fragmente der Vorsokratiker. Oxford:
Basil Blackwell. Freeman, K. 1962. Ancilla to the Pre-Socratic Philosophers. Oxford: Basil Blackwell Gorman, P. 1979. Pythagoras, a Life. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Grand, S. 2001. Creation: Life and How to Make It. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Guthrie, K.S. (compil. & transl.) 1987. The Pythagorean Sourcebook and Library. Grand Rapids, Michigan:
Phanes Press. Guthrie, W. K. C. 1962. The Earlier Presocratics and the Pythagoreans. Cambridge University Press. Heath, T. 1965(1921). Greek Mathematics. 2 vols. Oxford: Clarendon Press Heath, T. 1998(1949). Mathematics in Aristotle. Bristol: Thoemmes Press Heath, T. ed. 1897 & 1912 The Works of Archimedes with the Method of Archimedes. New York: Dover. Huffman, C. A. 1993. Philolaus of Croton: Pythagorean and Presocratic. Cambridge University Press. Jonas, H. 1958. The Gnostic Religion: the Message of the Alien God and the Beginnings of Christianity. Boston:
Beacon Press. Kahn, C. H. 2001. Pythagoras and the Pythagoreans: A Brief History. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett. Kraut, R. ed. 1992. The Cambridge Companion to Plato. Cambridge University Press. Laertius, D. 1965. The Lives of Eminent Philosophers. transl. R. D. Hicks. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Linden, S. J. ed. 2003. The Alchemy Reader: from Hermes Trismegistus to Isaac Newton. Cambridge University
Press. Mayhall, C.W. 2004. On Plotinus. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. McKie, D. 1990(1952). Antoine Lavoisier. New York: Plenum. Oort, J. van 1998. Manichaeism: Its Sources and Influences on Western Christianity. in van den Broek and
Hanegraaff, W. J. (ed.) Gnosis and Hermeticism: from Antiquity to Modern Times. 37-51. State University of New York Press.
Penrose, R. 1989. The Emperor’s New Mind. Oxford University Press. Principe, L. M. 1998. The Aspiring Adept: Robert Boyle and His Alchemical Quest. Princeton University Press. Proclus, 1970. A Commentary on the First Book of Euclid’s Elements. transl. G. R. Morrow. Princeton: Princeton
University Press. Runia, D. T. 1993. Philo in Early Christian Literature: a Survey. Minneapolis: Fortress Press. Shorey, P. 1938. Platonism Ancient and Modern. Berkeley: University of California Press. Silver, L. M. 1997. Remaking Eden: Cloning and Beyond in a Brave New World. New York: Avon Books. Taylor, A. E. 1958. Plato, the Man and His Work. New York: Meridian. Unamuno, M. de 1954(1921). Tragic Sense of Life. transl. J. E. C. Flitch. New York: Dover. Wallis, R.T. 1972. Neoplatonism. London: Duckworth. _= 1993. �êåîÝI�ë `�Ôê~ (m�) I 15 ó(1993 H 2 Ü): 102 110 II 16 ó(1993
H 4 Ü): 72 78. Zeller, E. 1955. Outlines of the History of Greek Philosophy. transl. L. R. Palmer. New York: Meridian.