Auditing Kansas City Government Douglas Jones, City Auditor Office of the City Auditor Kansas City, Missouri Association of Government Accountants, Kansas City Chapter March 18, 2015
Auditing Kansas City Government
Douglas Jones, City AuditorOffice of the City AuditorKansas City, Missouri
Association of Government Accountants, Kansas City ChapterMarch 18, 2015
Agenda City Auditor’s Office history & background
What does the City Auditor’s Office do?
Discussion of recent audits
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 2
How long has Kansas City had a city auditor? Kansas City has had a city auditor since at
least 1898
The city auditor’s duties in 1898 and 1909 were primarily related to the city’s accounts and taxes
Interesting provisions◊ 1898 city auditor fined $100 to $1,000 if
annual statement on city finances not submitted
◊ 1909 city auditor issued licenses to saloons, beer houses, tippling houses, and dramshops
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 3
Why audit local government?What should an audit charter address?Government auditing◊ Provides transparency and accountability◊ Identifies areas for improvement
Elements for a government audit charter◊ Organizational independence◊ Qualifications for the chief audit executive◊ Authority to audit all departments, offices,
boards, activities, agencies, and programs◊ Required use of recognized auditing standards◊ Unrestricted access to records and employees
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 4
What does the Kansas City Charter say about the city auditor? Council shall appoint an auditor Auditor shall be a CPA or someone trained and
experienced in governmental or business investigation or administration
Auditor shall keep the Council informed about the city’s financial affairs, investigate the work of all departments, periodically report results, and make investigations directed by Council
Auditor shall not be responsible for keeping accounts
Auditor shall have access to all books, records, and employees of the city
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 5
What is the City Auditor’s Office audit environment? City Auditor has 13 bosses
Developing and maintaining good working relationships is important
City has 20 departments, almost 6,900 employees, and next year’s budget is about $1.47 billion
Audit universe covers airports to zoo
City Auditor’s Office has 12 positions and a $1.3 million budget
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 6
What does the City Auditor’s Office do?We’re not the IRS or CPAs
We conduct performance audits evaluating department and program performance to improve city operations and strengthen city government’s accountability to the public
We may occasionally conduct limited scope research projects that are not audits
We don’t conduct financial audits
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 7
How we conduct performance auditsWe follow Government Auditing Standards
In general our audit work involves◊ Interviewing city management and staff◊ Reviewing the city charter; code of ordinances;
city and department policies, procedures, and practices; and contracts or agreements
◊ Identifying and comparing recommended practices to city policies, procedures, and practices
◊ Evaluating and analyzing data
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 8
Recent performance audits Traffic Management Center Citywide Overtime Fire Code Inspection Program Disposition of City-Owned Surplus Personal Property Security of the Municipal Court Docketing System Managing Community Center Facility Use: Hockey
League at Line Creek Kansas City Regional Police Academy: Are All Costs
Included in Academy Fees? City's Performance Under the HUD Memorandum of
AgreementOffice of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 10
Traffic Management Center(October 2013)
Why we did the audit◊ Public safety◊ Efficiency of city’s system of roadways◊ New city function◊ Use of federal grant funds◊ Staffing may not be adequate
Audit Objective – Is the Public Works Department effectively using the Traffic Management Center to manage traffic?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 11
Traffic Management Center – What we found Center was not staffed to meet Public Works’
traffic signal management goal
Center not used to full potential
No plan for funding center operations
Excavation work can damage fiber optic cables
Public Works and Water Services needed a process for handling broken cables
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 12
Traffic Management Center – What we recommended Evaluate the goals of the Traffic Management
Center and staff the center to meet the goals
Ensure that operating funds are identified and available before capital improvement projects are built or expanded
Develop a procedure for reporting, repairing, and paying for fiber optic cable damaged by Water Services
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 13
Traffic Management Center – What the media reported Kansas City traffic audit raises eyebrows
Millions of dollars spent on technology could help you behind the wheel, but instead a shiny new building in Kansas City has been running on empty.(KSHB-TV 41 10/03/2013)
Staffing Low, Audit Says City manager says KC will hire more people next year to monitor street conditions. (KC Star 10/06/2013)
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 14
Citywide Overtime(November 2013)
Why we did the audit◊ Overtime costs are significant◊ Employee health and safety concerns◊ Equity and potential legal issues
Audit Objective – Is the city effectively managing the use of overtime?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 15
Citywide Overtime – What we foundOvertime hours and costs increased
significantly between 2010 and 2013◊ 86% concentrated in Fire, Water Services,
Public Works, and Aviation departments
Multiple factors (collective bargaining, minimum staffing…) drive overtime
Overtime rules and practices not applied consistently
Departments pushing limits of safe and healthy amounts of overtime
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 16
Citywide Overtime – What we recommended Evaluating the need to change and/or
renegotiate some overtime provisions in the city code or collective bargaining agreements
Providing written procedures and training on overtime practices
Requiring a written early clock-in policy
Monitoring individual’s cumulative overtime hours and frequency
Tracking overtime and performing periodic analysis
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 17
Citywide Overtime – What the media reported KCMO audit shows city's soaring cost of
overtime Audit reveals overtime costs in KCMO have increased significantly over the past four years…(KSHB-TV 41 11/25/2013)
City auditor: KC paid $17.8M in overtime pay in fiscal 2013 Kansas City paid 42.1 percent more overtime pay in fiscal 2013 than it did in fiscal 2010... (Kansas City Business Journal 11/25/2013)
Overtime Outlays Surge Costs have soared 58 percent, from $11.3 million in 2010 to $17.8 million in 2013… (KC Star 11/26/2013)
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 18
Fire Code Inspection Program(January 2014)
Why we did the audit◊ Opportunities for operational improvements◊ Concerns about completeness of database
Audit Objectives◊ Are the Fire Prevention Division’s internal
controls over the fire inspection program adequate?
◊ Is the Fire Prevention Division’s inspection database of commercial and multifamily structures reasonably complete?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 19
Fire Code Inspection Program – What we found Prioritizing inspections could improve
inspection timeliness◊ 20% of annual inspections in 2013 were late◊ 171 structures requiring permits were not
inspected in 2012 (lost revenue $21,400) No written policies and procedures to direct
inspectors in the inspection process or guide administrative staff activities
Database reasonably accurate, but some structures needed to be added (additional revenue $19,000)
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 20
Fire Code Inspection Program – What we recommended Analyze options for prioritizing inspections
Develop written policies and procedures to direct the work of inspectors and administrative staff
Implement mitigating controls to compensate for inadequate segregation of duties
Continue obtaining address information from other city departments to update the fire inspection database
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 21
Fire Code Inspection Program – What the media reported Audit asks KCFD to improve timeliness of
inspections It seems this is a program that’s being run very well, but there are clearly areas that can be improved, said John Sharp, chair of the city’s Public Safety and Emergency Services Committee. (Northeast News 01/29/2014)
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 22
Disposition of Surplus Personal Property(February 2014)
Why we did the audit◊ Department management asked for the audit◊ Using surplus property can save money◊ Selling surplus property generates revenue
Audit Objective – Are safeguards adequate to protect city-owned surplus personal property?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 23
Disposition of Surplus Property – What we found Inventory records and disposition
documentation could be improved◊ Some items not in database◊ Receipt of some items not documented◊ Surplus management software needed
enhancements
Policies and procedures to protect assets need to be strengthened◊ Inadequate segregation of duties◊ P&Ps could have been more comprehensive
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 24
Disposition of Surplus Property – What we recommended Strengthen documentation as items move
through the surplus property process
Improve functionality of the database
Increase safeguards over security of surplus property
Improve compliance with city requirements for handling surplus property transfers
Expand written policies and procedures
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 25
Security of the Municipal Court Docketing System (February 2014)
Why we did the audit◊ System contains criminal justice information◊ Electronic records are the only source◊ Security weaknesses could compromise system
data and operations
Audit Objective - Are controls in place to protect the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information in the IMDS Plus system?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 26
Security of the Docketing System – What we foundMunicipal court needed to improve controls◊ Access rights not terminated timely◊ Security awareness not always provided or
documented◊ No written policies & procedures regarding the
protection of criminal justice information
REJIS had not◊ Updated its disaster recovery plan◊ Finalized its incident response procedure◊ Established a geographically removed alternate
processing siteOffice of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 27
Security of the Docketing System – What we recommendedDevelop requirements for protecting criminal
justice information and adopt written policies and procedures to meet established requirements
Encourage REJIS to update and periodically test its disaster recovery plan; finalize its incident response procedure; and establish a geographically removed disaster recovery site
Develop criteria for future information technology service provider contracts
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 28
Managing Community Center Use –Hockey League at Line CreekWhy we did the audit◊ Patron complaint about how hockey league fees
were handled◊ Patron confusion about who operated the
hockey league
Audit Objective - Did Parks and Recreation Department staff follow established rules and procedures in managing community center facility use for the summer adult hockey league at Line Creek?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 29
Managing Community Center Use –What we found Staff operated a non-parks league privately◊ Staff members’ dual roles confused participants
and could develop into a conflict of interest◊ Payments not collected and processed as
regular Parks Department transactions
Staff did not follow board policy requiring groups to obtain permission to charge fees on Parks property
Records were inadequate to determine league payments
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 30
Managing Community Center Use –What we recommended Issue current policies and procedures and
train community center staffs on methods of providing league activities
Identify revenue by community center program or activity
Provide additional training to community center staffs on use and capabilities of RecTrac
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 31
Managing Community Center Use –What the media reported Audit faults hockey league operation at Line
Creek Community Center For three summers, a 23-team adult hockey league was using space Kansas City owned, under the guidance of city employees, but the city didn’t know about it.(KC Star 4/23/2014)
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 32
Police Academy: Are All Costs Included in Academy Fees? (November 2014)
Why we did the audit◊ Requested by Board of Police Commissioners
Audit Objective - Has the Kansas City, Missouri Police Department established fees and charges at the Police Academy that reflect all costs of providing services?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 33
Police Academy Fees – What we found KCPD does not consider all costs when setting
academy fees
KCPD can strengthen process for reviewing and updating academy fees◊ Fees last increased in 2012◊ Long-term forecasting of needs or costs and
benchmarking fees was not done
Expanded fee policy will encourage consistent and transparent fee setting◊ Fee policy should address cost recovery goals◊ KCPD subsidizes other agencies’ participation
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 34
Police Academy Fees – What we recommended Calculating full costs of all training and facility
use, conducting long-term forecasting, and periodically benchmarking academy fees
Annually presenting full cost, forecasting, and benchmarking data to the Board for consideration when approving academy fees
Incorporating language into the fee policy to address cost recovery goals
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 35
City’s Performance Under MOA with HUD (December 2014)
Why we did the audit◊ The MOA requires the City Auditor’s Office to conduct
an annual performance audit of the city’s performance under the agreement
Audit Objective - Did the city fulfill its obligations under the Memorandum of Agreement between the city and HUD from April 1, 2013 to April 30, 2014?
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 36
City’s Performance Under MOA with HUD – What we foundMost performance deadlines met, but five
extensions requested after missing deadlines
City addressed most long-term reform measures, but◊ Three subrecipient contracts executed before
HUD’s approval◊ Funding reimbursements not requested in a
timely manner
Additional steps needed to implement new HOME regulations
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 37
City’s Performance Under MOA with HUD – What we recommended Recommendations made to ensure◊ Compliance with the MOA’s development
deadlines, extension requests, and approvals of subrecipients
◊ Reimbursement of CDBG/HOME grant funds requested from HUD at least monthly
◊ The city is prepared to implement HUD’s new HOME regulations
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 38
Audits currently in progress Information Security (March 2015) City Property Leases (April 2015) Public Works Street-Related Permit Fees Need
Review and Adjustment (April 2015) Accuracy and Validity of 311 Data (April 2015) Protection of Personally Identifiable Information
(April 2015) Governance Assessment 2015 (August 2015) Street Maintenance Activities (tbd) Streetcar Management Agreement (tbd)
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 39
Are audit reports available to the public? Audit reports, memoranda, annual reports,
annual audit plans, peer review reports, and other documents are available on◊ Our website kcmo.gov/cityauditor◊ The city’s open data portal data.kcmo.org
We ask the public for their audit ideas kcmo.gov/cityauditor/submit-audit-ideas
Twitter @KCMO #kcmocityauditor
Office of the City Auditor – Kansas City, Missouri 40