1 10/04/2008 www.sensor-ip.org Peter Verweij, Stefan Sieber, Dirk Pohle, Johnny Roller, Katharina Fricke, Jan-Erik Wien, Katharina Helming, Cesare Pacini, Hördur Haraldsson et al. Leibniz-Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research e.V., Wageningen University and Research Centre, Green world research - amongst others SIAT Sustainability Impact Assessment Tool Methodology and Functionality of Prototype II
22
Embed
Audimax 01 Sieber IALUC Berlin Apr08tran.zalf.de/home_ip-sensor/conference/03_pdf/Audimax_01_Sieber_IALUC... · Project aim – Focus for SIAT To deliver ex-ante Impact Assessment
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
www.sensor-ip.org110/04/2008 www.sensor-ip.org
Peter Verweij, Stefan Sieber, Dirk Pohle, Johnny Roller, Katharina Fricke, Jan-Erik Wien, Katharina Helming, Cesare Pacini, Hördur Haraldsson et al. Leibniz-Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research e.V., Wageningen University and Research Centre, Green world research- amongst others
SIATSustainability Impact Assessment Tool
Methodology and Functionality of Prototype II
2www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Structure
Rationale
Methodology
Development
Prototype II
Acknowledgements
3www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Rationale
Project aim – Focus for SIAT
To deliver ex-ante Impact Assessment Tools (SIAT) to support decision making on policies related to multifunctional land use in Europe and in targeted third countries (since Dec. 2006)
IA- Guidelines (EC 2005)
1 Identifying the policy problem
2 Defining the objective
3 Developing the main policy options
4 Analysing the impacts5 Comparing the options6 Outlining policy monitoring and evaluation
4www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Methodology
Land use
functions
Agriculture ForestryNature
ConservationTransport
Infrastructure Energy Tourism
Production Economic SocialEnvironmental Cultural Ecologic
Multifunctionality
Thresholds
Targets
Region x Region y Region ... Region ... Region ... Region n
SustainabilityChoice Space
SustainableDevelopment
Thresholds
Targets
Region x Region y Region ... Region ... Region ... Region nRegion x Region y Region ... Region ... Region ... Region n
SustainabilityChoice Space
SustainableDevelopment
Approach – SIAT Implementation
5www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Development
Methods – Complementary Application
Evolutionary rapid development & operational prototyping (Guida 1999)Requirement analysis by stakeholder involvement (Wiegers 2003).
(1) Reviewing and benchmarking of existing knowledge
(2) Adjustment of basic requirements
(3) Develop a simplistic Prototype
(4) Group discussions with end users
(5) Targeted input by expert interviews
(6) Final negotiation with regard to given capacities
6www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Prototype II
Classification – Novel Model ChallengesComparative static Meta-Model
Trade offs across 6 sectors
SIA, policy impacts / valuation
Response protocols & knowledge rules
Stakeholder-validation
Server-based application
Flexibility (OpenMI)
Approx. 30 indicators, NUTX-level
Indicators, LUF, Thresholds
Transparency, Traceability
Definition
Methods
Results
7www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Prototype II
Response Protocol – Functionality
Modelling framework
Indicator value
Interim results (land use)
Indicator 1
Indicator 2
Interim result
Policy variable
8www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use
Prototype II
System Integration – State of the Art
Conceptual Design
Software Architecture
GUI design
Visualisation (mapping,
graphs, bar charts etc.)
Policy Case, Instruments
Indicator knowledge rules
Thresholds
Fact sheets & information
sheets
End User Tool Knowledge basef(x)=3X3+2
Text: The idicator isthe knowledge thatImplies.
Current integration state:
- 105 fact sheets- Respective long versions- 10 indicators - 10 causal chains- 1 policy case, 3 instr.(+1 in process)
Current integration state:
- complete system integration
- (to display full storyline)- graphical re-design- new GUI
9www.sensor-ip.org
Sustainability Impact Assessment of multifunctional land use