Attendance Boundary Task Force Report Board Presentation June 21, 2012 Presented by: Jim Dobson & Mary Hardin Young 1
Attendance Boundary Task Force Report
Board PresentationJune 21, 2012
Presented by: Jim Dobson & Mary Hardin Young 1
• Goals and Objectives• Create Cleaner Feeder Patterns• Eliminate Non-Contiguous Boundaries• Review Decisions for Over-Crowding /
Under-Enrollment• Examine Impact from Schools of Choice
Purpose of Attendance Boundary Task Force
2
• Amy Whitten - Freeport• Charlie Watters – Kit Carson• Corrie Buckmaster – Theodore
Judah• Crystal Hoff - Planning• Enrique Flores – Hubert Bancroft• Jim Dobson - Planning• Kim Delfino - Parent• Kionne Cochran - Parent• Leise Martinez - Rosemont• Lois Graham – Community• Mary Hardin Young – Area
Assistant Superintendent
• Olivia Caballero – Parent• Peter Lambert – C. K.
McClatchy• Reginald Brown – Martin Luther
King Jr.• Ron Hill - Transportation• Ryan Toby - Parent• Sam Starks - Community• Ted Appel – Luther Burbank• Tiffany Hunter-Green - Parent• Tom Lee - Facilitator• Virgil Price - Community
Attendance Boundary Task Force Members
3
• October 12, 19 & 26, 2011• November 2, 9 & 16, 2011• January 18 & 25, 2012• February 1 & 8, 2012
Attendance Boundary Task Force Meeting Dates
4
• Benefits of a true or clean feeder pattern:• Builds strong communities as neighborhood students and
families continue educational pathways together, from elementary through high school
• Allows articulation between educators, from elementary to middle school and from middle school to high school, and provides consistent/cohesive educational plan for students
• Promotes “branding” of schools, and school pathways, from primary grades throughout high school; builds school pride and positive reputations
• Builds parent and community confidence in our schools
Goal # 1 – Clean Feeder Patterns
5
• Criteria for consideration in creating clean feeder patterns:• Split feeder• Impediments to safe travel• Proximity to nearby schools• Natural pathways from neighborhoods• Site capacities• Self-identification of neighborhoods with schools
Elementary School Middle School High School
Goal # 1 – Continued
6
• Middle Schools to High Schools
Current Feeder Patterns
Kit Carson
Albert Einstein
California
Fern Bacon
John Still
Rosa Parks
Sam Brannan
Sutter
Will C Wood
John F Kennedy
CK McClatchy
Hiram Johnson
Luther Burbank
Rosemont
7
I-5
Fre
eport
Blv
d
Florin Rd
I-5
CapitalMall
Broadway
15th
St
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
Richards Blvd
Busi
ness
80
21st
St
16th
St
South
(Hw
y 9
9)
Fra
nklin
Blv
d
Blv
dJr
MLK
Sacram
entoF
ranklin
Blv
d
47th Ave
Meadowview Rd
US 50
J St
Folsom
Sto
ckton B
lvd
Florin Rd
Frwy
(Hw
y 99)Elvas
Broadway
Blvd
Inn R
d
Exw
y
Pow
er
65th
St
Arden
Way
How
e A
ve
Fair Oaks
Flo
rin-P
erk
ins R
d
Watt A
ve
Blvd
Folsom Blvd
US 50
Bra
dshaw
Rd
S W
att A
ve
Jackson Rd
Florin Rd
ROSEMONTHIRAMJOHNSON
CK MCCLATCHY
JOHN FKENNEDY
LUTHERBURBANK
AlbertEinstein
Will C.Wood
Rosa Parks
FernBacon
JohnStill
Kit Carson
Sutter
California
SamBrannan
Sacramento City Unified School District
Middle SchoolAssignment Areas
2012/2013
Split Feeders
Architectural ResearchConsultants, Incorporated
Water
Railroad
Major Road
Map Source: Sacramento AreaCouncil of GovernmentsTIGER file.
Executive Airport Runways
(areasV5MSHS1213bndonlySplitsAll.wor)
Middle School
School Locations
High School
Assignment Area
HIGH SCHOOL
ALBERT EINSTEINCALIFORNIAFERN BACONJOHN STILLKIT CARSONROSA PARKSSAM BRANNANSUTTERWILL C. WOOD
• Proposed
Clean Feeder Patterns
Kit Carson
Albert Einstein
California
Fern Bacon
John Still
Rosa Parks
Sam Brannan
Sutter
Will C Wood
John F Kennedy
CK McClatchy
Hiram Johnson
Luther Burbank
Rosemont
9
I-5
Fre
eport
Blv
d
Florin Rd
I-5
CapitalMall
Broadway
15th
St
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
Richards Blvd
Busi
ness
80
21st
St
16th
St
South
(Hw
y 9
9)
Fra
nklin
Blv
d
Blv
dJr
MLK
Sacram
entoF
ranklin
Blv
d
47th Ave
Meadowview Rd
US 50
J St
Folsom
Sto
ckton B
lvd
Florin Rd
Frwy
(Hw
y 99)Elvas
Broadway
Blvd
Inn R
d
Exw
y
Pow
er
65th
St
Arden
Way
How
e A
ve
Fair Oaks
Flo
rin-P
erk
ins R
d
Watt A
ve
Blvd
Folsom Blvd
US 50
Bra
dshaw
Rd
S W
att A
ve
Jackson Rd
Florin Rd
ROSEMONTHIRAMJOHNSON
CK MCCLATCHY
JOHN FKENNEDY
LUTHERBURBANK
AlbertEinstein
Will C.Wood
Rosa Parks
FernBacon
JohnStill
Kit Carson
Sutter
California
SamBrannan
Sacramento City Unified School District
Middle SchoolAssignment Areas
2012/2013
EliminateSplit Feeders
Architectural ResearchConsultants, Incorporated
Water
Railroad
Major Road
Map Source: Sacramento AreaCouncil of GovernmentsTIGER file.
Executive Airport Runways
(areasV5MSHS1213ElimSplitsAll.wor)
ProposedAssignment Area
Middle School
School Locations
High School
HIGH SCHOOL
ALBERT EINSTEINCALIFORNIAFERN BACONJOHN STILLKIT CARSONROSA PARKSSAM BRANNANSUTTERWILL C. WOOD
• Elementary Schools to Middle Schools
Current Feeder Patterns
Sam Brannan
Will C Wood
Pony Express
Caleb Greenwood
David Lubin
Fr. Keith B Kenny
Hollywood Park
Woodbine
Bret Harte
Chavez/Kemble
Nicholas
Kit Carson
California
Fern Bacon
Rosa Parks
Sutter
11
I-5
Fre
eport
Blv
d
Florin Rd
I-5
CapitalMall
Broadway
15th
St
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
Richards Blvd
Busi
ness
80
21st
St
16th
St
South
(Hw
y 9
9)
Fra
nklin
Blv
d
Blv
dJr
MLK
Sacram
entoF
ranklin
Blv
d
47th Ave
Meadowview Rd
US 50
J St
Folsom
Sto
ckton B
lvd
Florin Rd
Frwy
(Hw
y 99)Elvas
Broadway
Blvd
Inn R
d
Exw
y
Pow
er
65th
St
Arden
Way
How
e A
ve
Fair Oaks
Flo
rin-P
erk
ins R
d
Watt A
ve
Blvd
Folsom Blvd
US 50
Bra
dshaw
Rd
S W
att A
ve
Jackson Rd
Florin Rd
AlbertEinstein
Will C.Wood
Rosa Parks
FernBacon
JohnStill
Kit Carson
Sutter
California
SamBrannan
JamesMarshall
Sequoia
O. W. Erlewine
Isador Cohen
AbrahamLincoln
A. M. Winn
Golden Empire
HubertBancroft
Mark Twain
Earl Warren
JosephBonnheim
Tahoe
ElderCreek
Camellia Basic
Peter Burnett
Parkway
Nicholas
Edward KembleCesar Chavez
Susan B.Anthony
Ethel Baker
FruitRidge
Fr. Keith B. Kenny
OakRidge
PacificClaytonB. Wire
Maple
Theodore Judah
David Lubin
Washington
WilliamLand
Jedediah Smith
Crocker/Riverside
John D. Sloat Basic
MarkHopkins
H. W. HarknessWoodbine
JohnStill
Hollywood Park
BretHarte
EthelPhillips
Sutterville
JohnCabrillo
Collis P.Huntington
CarolineWenzel
Matsuyama
PonyExpress
John Bidwell
CalebGreenwood
GenevieveF. Didion
MartinLutherKing
Sacramento City Unified School District
Elementary SchoolAssignment Areas
2012/2013
Split Feeders
Architectural ResearchConsultants, Incorporated
Water
Railroad
Major Road
Map Source: Sacramento AreaCouncil of GovernmentsTIGER file.
Executive Airport Runways
(areasV5ESMS1213bndonlySplits.wor)
Elementary School
School Locations
K8 School
Middle School
Assignment Area
MIDDLE SCHOOL
BRET HARTECALEB GREENWOODDAVID LUBINEDWARD KEMBLEFR K B KENNYHOLLYWOOD PARKNICHOLASPONY EXPRESSWOODBINE
• Elementary Schools to Middle Schools
Clean Feeder Patterns
Sam Brannan
Will C Wood
Pony Express
Caleb Greenwood
David Lubin
Fr. Keith B Kenny
Hollywood Park
Woodbine
Bret Harte
Chavez/Kemble
Nicholas
Kit Carson
California
Fern Bacon
Rosa Parks
Sutter
13
I-5
Fre
eport
Blv
d
Florin Rd
I-5
CapitalMall
Broadway
15th
St
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
Richards Blvd
Busi
ness
80
21st
St
16th
St
South
(Hw
y 9
9)
Fra
nklin
Blv
d
Blv
dJr
MLK
Sacram
entoF
ranklin
Blv
d
47th Ave
Meadowview Rd
US 50
J St
Folsom
Sto
ckton B
lvd
Florin Rd
Frwy
(Hw
y 99)Elvas
Broadway
Blvd
Inn R
d
Exw
y
Pow
er
65th
St
Arden
Way
How
e A
ve
Fair Oaks
Flo
rin-P
erk
ins R
d
Watt A
ve
Blvd
Folsom Blvd
US 50
Bra
dshaw
Rd
S W
att A
ve
Jackson Rd
Florin Rd
AlbertEinstein
Will C.Wood
Rosa Parks
FernBacon
JohnStill
Kit Carson
Sutter
California
SamBrannan
JamesMarshall
Sequoia
O. W. Erlewine
Isador Cohen
AbrahamLincoln
A. M. Winn
Golden Empire
HubertBancroft
Mark Twain
Earl Warren
JosephBonnheim
Tahoe
ElderCreek
Camellia Basic
Peter Burnett
Parkway
Nicholas
Edward KembleCesar Chavez
Susan B.Anthony
Ethel Baker
FruitRidge
Fr. Keith B. Kenny
OakRidge
PacificClaytonB. Wire
Maple
Theodore Judah
David Lubin
Washington
WilliamLand
Jedediah Smith
Crocker/Riverside
John D. Sloat Basic
MarkHopkins
H. W. HarknessWoodbine
JohnStill
Hollywood Park
BretHarte
EthelPhillips
Sutterville
JohnCabrillo
Collis P.Huntington
CarolineWenzel
Matsuyama
PonyExpress
John Bidwell
CalebGreenwood
GenevieveF. Didion
MartinLutherKing
Sacramento City Unified School District
Elementary SchoolAssignment Areas
2012/2013
EliminateSplit Feeders
Architectural ResearchConsultants, Incorporated
Water
Railroad
Major Road
Map Source: Sacramento AreaCouncil of GovernmentsTIGER file.
Executive Airport Runways
(areasV5ESMS1213elimSplits.wor)
Elementary School
School Locations
K8 School
Middle School
ProposedAssignment Area
MIDDLE SCHOOL
BRET HARTECALEB GREENWOODDAVID LUBINEDWARD KEMBLEFR K B KENNYHOLLYWOOD PARKNICHOLASPONY EXPRESSWOODBINE
• Clayton B. Wire• Peter Burnett• Sequoia• Theodore Judah
Goal # 2 - Eliminate Non-Contiguous Boundaries
15
• Non-Contiguous Maps
Goal # 2 - Eliminate Non-Contiguous Boundaries
16
• Reviewed:• Elder Creek ES• Tahoe ES• Ethel Phillips ES• Bret Harte ES• Sutter MS• Fern Bacon MS• Burbank HS• Kennedy HS
Goal # 3 - Review Decisions for Over-Crowding / Under-Enrollment
17
• Task Force reviewed process for Schools of Choice and impact on enrollment
• The review of information led the Task Force to conclude that Schools of Choice draw students district-wide with no one School of Choice impacting an individual attendance area
Goal # 4 - Impact from Schools of Choice
18
• Many families prefer a neighborhood school• Navigating the system could be challenging and
costly for parents• Opportunity to attend School of Choice may
not be priority• Desirability of program could impact
enrollment• Concerns about equity of access and fairness of
enrollment process• Current open enrollment process already gives
options for parents
Discussion of No Boundary Policy
19
• Creating clean feeder patterns does not alter the reality of district enrollment and capacity challenges, but can affect the sites that are over and/or under enrolled through loss or addition of students
• Seeing the full impact of boundary changes may take time as families/neighborhoods adjust and schools continue to build connections to families
Implications from Proposed Changes
20
• School staff should put transition support in place for neighborhoods and students new to the school
• While the Boundary Task Force has created clean feeder patterns for most schools, there are Schools of Choice that lay outside of the paradigm
Implications from Proposed Changes
21
• Two Year Phase-In• Year 1: 2012-2013
• Community input (allow 3 months)• Notifications to impacted schools &
communities• Parents may enroll in new school now• Educate parents on options for 2013-2014
• Students remain with parent transportation
• Students to neighborhood school• Year 2: 2013-2014
• Implement changes to boundaries
Timeline for Implementation
22
• Approve timeframe to implement changes in 2013-2014
• District staff to create communication and community engagement plan
• Begin gathering community input in August• Bring back to Board as Conference/Action in
Fall
Attendance Boundary Task Force Recommendations
23
Questions
24
25
Fre
epor
t Blv
d
Florin Rd
I-5
47th Ave
Meadowview R
Rosa Parks
FB
JohnStill
Edward KCesar
John D. Sloat Basic
MarkHopkins
H. W. HarknessWoodbine
JohnStill
Huntington
CarolineWenzel
Matsuyama
PonyExpress
John Bidwell
eveion
artinutherKing
Sacramento
Frankl
47th Ave
Meadowview Rd
Florin Rd
Frwy
(Hwy 99)E
xwy
Will C.Wood
Rosa Parks
FernBacon
John
ElCr
Camellia B
Parkway
Nicholas
Edward KembleCesar Chavez
PacificClaytonB. Wire
n D. Sloat Basic
MarkHopkins
H. W. HarknessWoodbine
Collis P.Huntington
Bidwell
itall
ay
15th
St
chards Blvd
Bus
ines
s 8021
st S
t
16th
St
(Hw
y 9
US 50
J St
Folsom
Elvas
Broadway
Blvd
ArdenWay
How
e Ave
Fair Oaks
Kit Carson
Sutter
nia
HubBan
T h
Theodore Judah
David Lubin
Washington
WilliamLand
erside
BretHarte
CalebGreenwood
dway
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
South
(Hw
y 99)F
ranklin Blvd
Blvd
JrM
LK
US 50
Stockton B
lvd
BroadwaCalifornia
amnan
Mark
Tahoe
Peter BEthel Baker
FruitRidge
Fr. Keith B. Kenny
OakRidge
Maple
h Smith
Crocker/Riverside
Hollywood Park
BretHarte
EthelPhillips
Sutterville
ohnbrillo
Fre
epor
t Blv
dFlorin Rd
I-5
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
CK MCCLATCHY
JOHN FKENNEDY
SamBrannan
I-5
Fre
epor
t Blv
d
CapitalMall
Broadway
15th
St
Sutterville Rd
Fruitridge Rd
Richards Blvd
Bus
ines
s 8021
st S
t
16th
St
South
(Hw
y 99)F
ranklin Blvd
Blvd
JrM
LK
Sacra
47th Ave
US 50
J St
Folsom
Stockto
CK MCCLATCHY
FernBacon
Sutter
California
SamBrannan
Elvas
Blvd
Pow
er
65th St
owe A
ve
Fair Oaks
Flo
Watt A
ve
Blvd
Folsom Blvd
US 50
S
Jackson Rd
ROSEMONTHIRAMJOHNSON
AlbertEinstein
Fre
epor
t Blv
d
Rd
Fruitridge Rd
South
Franklin B
lvd
Blvd
Jr
Sacramento
Franklin B
lvd
47th Ave
Meadowview Rd
n Blvd
LUTHERBURBANK
Rosa Parks
FernBacon
JohnStill
Bus
ines
s 80
South
(Hw
y 99)F
ranklin Blvd
Blvd
JrM
LK
Sacramento
h Ave
US 50
J St
Folsom
Stockton B
lvd
Florin Rd
Elvas
Broadway
Blvd
Inn Rd
Exw
y
Pow
er
65th St
rdenWay
How
e Ave
Fair Oaks
Florin-P
erkins Rd
HIRAMJOHNSON
Will C.Wood
FernBacon
Kit Carson
Sutter