Research Report Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase turnover in vivo in rhesus macaque striatum: A microPET study O.T. DeJesus a, * , L.G. Flores a , D. Murali a , A.K. Converse b , R.M. Bartlett a , T.E. Barnhart a , T.R. Oakes b , R.J. Nickles a a Medical Physics, University of Wisconsin Medical School, 1530 Medical Sciences Center, 1300 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA b Keck Imaging Laboratory, Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706, USA Accepted 25 June 2005 Available online 1 August 2005 Abstract The aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AAAD) is involved in the de novo synthesis of dopamine, a neurotransmitter crucial in cognitive, neurobehavioral and motor functions. The goal of this study was to assess the in vivo turnover rate of AAAD enzyme protein in the rhesus macaque striatum by monitoring, using microPET imaging with the tracer [ 18 F]fluoro-m-tyrosine (FMT), the recovery of enzyme activity after suicide inhibition. Results showed the AAAD turnover half-life to be about 86 h while total recovery was estimated to be 16 days after complete inhibition. Despite this relatively slow AAAD recovery, the animals displayed normal movement and behavior within 24 h. Based on the PET results, at 24 h, the animals have recovered about 20% of normal AAAD function. These findings show that normal movement and behavior do not depend on complete recovery of AAAD function but likely on pre-synaptic and post-synaptic compensatory mechanisms. D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. Theme: Neurotransmitters, modulators, transporters and receptors Topic: Monoamine synthesis Keywords: Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase; Protein turnover; MicroPET imaging; Parkinson’s disease 1. Introduction The aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AAAD) (EC 4.1.1.28) is the second enzyme in the biosynthetic pathway to important monoamine neurotransmitters—dopamine (DA), norepinephrine (NE) and serotonin (5-hydroxytrypt- amine or 5 HT). AAAD converts l-DOPA to DA which in turn is converted in NE neurons by dopamine h-hydrox- ylase (DhH) to NE while 5-hydroxytryptophan is converted by AAAD to 5 HT. Because the AAAD enzymic Km is higher than the normal levels of cerebral l-DOPA, conversion of l-DOPA to dopamine is rapid and has led many to believe that AAAD is not involved in dopamine regulation. However, there is now accumulating evidence that pre- and post-synaptic mechanisms alter AAAD activity via regulatory processes [6,29]. Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a movement disorder characterized by a dramatic reduction in dopamine levels in the terminals due to degeneration of nigrostriatal dopamine neurons. Since its introduction in 1967 [7], dopamine replacement using l-DOPA has remained to be the most effective therapy to ameliorate PD symptoms. Thus, AAAD is thought to play the important role as rate- limiting step in l-DOPA therapy in PD. Because changes in AAAD activity have clinical consequences [21], better understanding of AAAD function is needed. One important aspect of AAAD function which needs elucidation is its turnover rate in vivo. In this study, AAAD turnover rate in normal non-human primate striatum was assessed in vivo by monitoring recovery of AAAD function after irreversible 0006-8993/$ - see front matter D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.brainres.2005.06.086 * Corresponding author. Fax: +1 608 262 2413. E-mail address: [email protected] (O.T. DeJesus). Brain Research 1054 (2005) 55 – 60 www.elsevier.com/locate/brainres
6
Embed
Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase turnover in vivo in rhesus macaque striatum: A microPET study
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
www.elsevier.com/locate/brainres
Brain Research 1054
Research Report
Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase turnover in vivo in
rhesus macaque striatum: A microPET study
O.T. DeJesusa,*, L.G. Floresa, D. Muralia, A.K. Converseb, R.M. Bartletta,
T.E. Barnharta, T.R. Oakesb, R.J. Nicklesa
aMedical Physics, University of Wisconsin Medical School, 1530 Medical Sciences Center, 1300 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USAbKeck Imaging Laboratory, Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706, USA
Accepted 25 June 2005
Available online 1 August 2005
Abstract
The aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AAAD) is involved in the de novo synthesis of dopamine, a neurotransmitter crucial in
cognitive, neurobehavioral and motor functions. The goal of this study was to assess the in vivo turnover rate of AAAD enzyme protein in the
rhesus macaque striatum by monitoring, using microPET imaging with the tracer [18F]fluoro-m-tyrosine (FMT), the recovery of enzyme
activity after suicide inhibition. Results showed the AAAD turnover half-life to be about 86 h while total recovery was estimated to be 16
days after complete inhibition. Despite this relatively slow AAAD recovery, the animals displayed normal movement and behavior within 24
h. Based on the PET results, at 24 h, the animals have recovered about 20% of normal AAAD function. These findings show that normal
movement and behavior do not depend on complete recovery of AAAD function but likely on pre-synaptic and post-synaptic compensatory
mechanisms.
D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Theme: Neurotransmitters, modulators, transporters and receptors
[19]. After purification, FMDOPA was authenticated by 13C-
and 1H NMR spectroscopy and validated by in vitro studies
using rat kidney and striatal homogenates. Consistent with
the results of Bey at al. [4], our in vitro results showed that
FMDOPA has IC50 value comparable to those of other
AAAD inhibitors–carbidopa, benserazide and NSD 1015–in
inhibiting AAAD activity in these rat tissue homogenates
(unpublished results).
2.2. Radiotracer synthesis
The PET tracer [18F]FMTwas prepared by the method of
Namavari et al. [20]. Briefly, to achieve regioselective
electrophilic radiofluorination, [18F]F2, produced as previ-
ously described [24], was bubbled into a fluorodichloro-
methane solution of a protected stannylated m-tyrosine
derivative purchased from ABX Biochemicals (Radeberg,
Germany). After removal of SnF2 and other by-products
using silica minicolumn, protective groups in the [18F]-
intermediate were removed by refluxing in 48% hydro-
bromic acid. The product [18F]FMT was purified using a
semi-preparative HPLC (Alltech C18 column, 10 A, 250 �10 mm) with a mobile phase which consisted of 0.02 M
NaOAc pH 3.5 and made up with sufficient NaCl to be
isotonic. The HPLC fraction containing the product was
collected and sterilized by filtration through a 0.22 A filter
into a vented sterile vial prior to administration into the
subjects.
2.3. Animal imaging: PET and MRI studies
Two male rhesus monkeys (designated as AT 97 and AU
18), both 7 years old and weighing 8 kg, were used in this
study. The animals were anesthetized with ketamine (15 mg/
kg IM) to allow administration dl-FMDOPA (25 mg/kg)
into the peritoneum. Both animals were scanned serially at
different times ranging from 4 h up to 8 days after
FMDOPA injection. The animals were fasted overnight
before each PET study. On the day of the PET study,
anesthesia was initially induced with ketamine (15 mg/kg
IM) to allow the transport of the animals to the Keck
MicroPET Laboratory at the University of Wisconsin
Waisman Center. Anesthesia during the scan was main-
tained with isoflurane (1%–2% in oxygen). The protocol
used in these studies was approved by the UWAnimal Care
and Use Committee in compliance with NIH regulations on
the use of non-human primates in research.
The microPET P4 scanner used in this study is a
commercial dedicated small animal research scanner (22 cm
bore) from Concorde Microsystems (Knoxville, TN). The
calculated image resolution, using filtered back projection
reconstruction, in 8 cm axial � 19 cm transaxial field of view
(FOV), is 2 � 2 � 2 mm3 with 2% sensitivity at center [27].
The anesthesized animal was positioned prone in the scanner
bed with its head comfortably immobilized in a stereotactic
holder (with ear, mouth and eye orbit bars) orienting the brain
such that the PET slices paralleled the orbitomeatal (OM)
line. Heart rate, SPO2, respiratory rate and temperature were
monitored throughout the scan and body temperature was
controlled using a loose-fitting wrap blowing warm air
around the animal (Bair Hugger, Arizant Healthcare, Eden
Prairie, MN). A 15-min transmission scan using a 68Ge point
source was performed to verify proper positioning and for use
in post-acquisition correction for photon attenuation. Data are
recorded in list mode, permitting maximum post-analysis
flexibility in time averaging. A 90-min dynamic 3D acqui-
sition was begun simultaneously with the intravenous
administration of 3.5–5.4 mCi [18F]FMT. Each animal had
previously undergone magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on
an Advantx 1.5 T instrument (General Electric Medical
Systems, Waukesha, WI) under ketamine sedation. MR
imaging included a spoiled gradient-echo (SPGR) sequence,
a 3D acquisition reconstructed into contiguous 1.3-mm
coronal slices providing good differentiation between gray
matter and white matter.
2.4. PET image and region of interest analysis
After the scan, the list mode data were binned into
sinograms with 20 frames (5 � 1 min, 5 � 2 min, 5 � 5 min
and 5 � 10 min) and corrected for dead time and random
coincidences. Images were then reconstructed with Con-
corde Microsystems proprietary software using OSEM,
correcting for detector sensitivity and attenuation. The
images were converted to Analyze format using an in-house
imaging software program called SPAMALIZE [22].
Images were then smoothed with a 3 mm Gaussian filter
in Spm99. The PET image was manually co-registered to
each animal’s anatomical and stereotaxic MRI T1 weighted
image using SPAMALIZE and a region of interest (ROI)
approach was used. Striatal and cerebellar regions were
identified and drawn on the MRI T1 weighed images. The
ROIs were then applied to the co-registered PET images for
generating time activity curves (TACs) for the subsequent
Patlak analysis [23]. The Patlak Ki values obtained were
Fig. 1. Time course of FMT PET images of monkey 1 (AU18) Showing recovery of AAAD Activity. Pairs of transaxial (top) and coronal (bottom) views of the
striatum at different times after FMDOPA injection are shown. The head of the caudate separate from the putamen is seen at 0, 97 and 192 h images in the
coronal slices. The normalized images are displayed in a hot metal scale wherein black, red, orange, yellow and white correspond to increasing levels of
radioactivity.
O.T. DeJesus et al. / Brain Research 1054 (2005) 55–60 57
taken from a linear least squares fit of the time frames 15–
20 corresponding to 41–90 min of the scan. Patlak Ki
values are the model outcome measures related to AAAD
activity [9].
3. Results
Both animals were scanned twice before FMDOPA
treatment. Baseline Ki values of 0.01025 min�1 and
0.01030 min�1 for one animal (AU97) and 0.01112 min�1
and 0.00959 min�1 for the other (AU18) were obtained and
the mean test–retest reproducibility is about 5.4%. Four
hours after dl-FMDOPA treatment, microPET results
Fig. 2. Patlak plots calculated from PET data showing AAAD recovery for
monkey 1 (AU18). The slope, Ki, is the striatal uptake constant (using
cerebellum as reference tissue) for the irreversible tracer [18F]FMT and is a
model outcome measure related to AAAD activity.
showed complete inhibition of [18F]FMT uptake in subject
AU18. The PET images for subject AU18 (Fig. 1) show the
time course of [18F]FMT uptake in the caudate-putamen
regions in two views, transaxial (parallel to the OM line)
and coronal. Patlak plots based on these images for monkey
AU18 are shown in Fig. 2. The fractional recovery of
AAAD activity in both animals is plotted in Fig. 3, where
recovery in each animal is expressed as fraction of the
measured Ki relative to the mean baseline Ki for that
subject. Fitting the data in Fig. 3 to a simple exponential
equation showed good correlation (r = 0.94) and the half-
life of AAAD recovery is estimated to be 86 h after
treatment. Further, in Fig. 3, about 80% recovery was
observed within 192 h while complete AAAD recovery was
estimated to take about 16 days after FMDOPA treatment.
After recovering from anesthesia after dl-FMDOPA
treatment, both animals were bradykinetic and assumed
Fig. 3. Fractional AAAD recovery, calculated as ratios of Ki(t) at time = t to
baseline Ki(t = 0) for each animal, as a function of time after FMDOPA
administration for the 2 animals (circles for AU-18 and squares for AT-97).
Fitting the data to a simple exponential show a half-life of recovery of 86.4
h (r = 0.94).
O.T. DeJesus et al. / Brain Research 1054 (2005) 55–6058
crouched postures but were able to feed. However, both
animals appeared normal in their behavior and movement
within 24 h.
4. Discussion
The use of PET imaging to assess enzyme turnover in
vivo in monkeys was first reported by Arnett et al. [2] in the
study of MAO B turnover by irreversible inhibition with l-
deprenyl, a selective MAO B suicide inhibitor. This method
was later extended to assessing MAO A and MAO B
turnover in humans [11]. In the present study, a similar
approach was used to assess the turnover rate of striatal
AAAD enzyme in vivo in the primate brain after suicide
inhibition. While the study of Arnett et al. [2] used the same
compound, [11C]-l-deprenyl, both as PET imaging agent
and as suicide inhibitor, in the present study, an AAAD
substrate, [18F]FMT, was used as imaging agent but a
different compound, FMDOPA, was used as suicide
inhibitor. A subtle difference between these two approaches
arises from the tracer kinetic properties of the imaging
agents utilized, with each assessing a different aspect of
enzyme function. The tracer kinetics measured with
covalently bound [11C]-l-deprenyl reflects enzyme protein
levels while the tracer kinetics of a substrate such as
[18F]FMT, wherein the [18F]-labeled product formed is
essentially trapped, measures enzyme activity.
The mechanism for the suicide inhibition of AAAD by
FMDOPA was proposed by Maycock et al. [18] to involve
adduct-formation between the FMDOPA-derived inhibitor
and the AAAD enzyme. Recent crystal structural analysis of
AAAD by Burkhard et al. has provided additional insights
into the mechanism of FMDOPA suicide inhibition [5].
AAAD is a tightly associated a2-dimer belonging to the a-
family of pyridoxal 5V-phosphate (PLP)-dependent enzymes
[1]. In the first step in enzyme action, the co-factor PLP is
anchored in the active site of AAAD by an extended
hydrogen bond network through its phosphate group while
the protonated pyridine nitrogen stabilizes the carbanionic
Schiff base intermediate formed with the substrate [5].
FMDOPA, like l-DOPA, is thought to form this Schiff base
intermediate with the enzyme-bound PLP co-factor, with the
carboxylate group forming hydrogen bonds with His 192 in
the enzyme active site [5]. Elimination of carbon dioxide
yields a decarboxylated FMDOPA quinoid intermediate
which, instead of being released as FMdopamine analogous
to dopamine release after l-DOPA decarboxylation, under-
goes fluoride elimination leaving a reactive alkylating
electrophile which then forms a covalent bond at the
enzyme’s active site. This alkylation reaction essentially
blockades the AAAD active site thereby incapacitating the
enzyme. In order to recover decarboxylation function,
synthesis of new AAAD protein in the dopamine cell
bodies becomes necessary. New protein synthesis requires
gene transcription of new AAAD mRNA followed by
translation into new AAAD enzyme proteins as demon-
strated by Li et al. in vitro in PC12 cells using the dopamine
inhibitor NSD 1015 [17]. New AAAD enzyme protein
synthesized in the nigral cell bodies is then delivered by
axoplasmic transport to the striatal terminals [12]. Monitor-
ing recovery of striatal enzyme activity using a substrate as
tracer allows the estimation of the combined rates of AAAD
protein synthesis and axonal transport.
The inhibitor dose used in this study was selected based
on the report by Jung et al. evaluating the effects of dl-
FMDOPA in mice [14]. In mice, 4 h after the administration
of 25 mg/kg FMDOPA, AAAD activity in the kidney and
heart was almost completely inhibited while whole brain
AAAD was inhibited about 28% of control [14]. In contrast,
after administration of 25 mg/kg FMDOPA, both macaques
in this microPET study showed complete striatal AAAD
inhibition at 4 and 26 h, respectively. Although peripheral
AAAD activity was not assessed in this study, evidence for
significant peripheral AAAD inhibition, which would slow
[18F]FMT plasma clearance and allow more unmetabolized
[18F]FMT to enter the brain, can be inferred from the
normalized PET images shown in Fig. 1 wherein images
obtained at 4 h and 49 h after FMDOPA treatment showed
higher background radioactivity compared to the images at
the three other time points.
Consistent with the notion that AAAD protein synthesis
occurs in the nigral dopamine cell bodies, Gardner and
Richards found that AAAD recovery after FMDOPA
inhibition in synaptosomal fractions (P2 fraction) in the
mouse brain lagged the recovery in sub-cellular fractions
rich with cell bodies (S2 fraction) by about 2 days [12].
Based on axonal length consistent with the mouse brain,
axonal transport rate of 1–6 mm/day was estimated [12].
Although, we can identify the substantia nigra in the PET
images and calculate nigral Ki values, the sample of two
animals did not provide sufficient power to obtain statisti-
cally significant measure of AAAD recovery which would
have been useful in estimating axoplasmic transport rate
under these conditions.
Although complete AAAD recovery was not observed
until an estimated 16 days after the total enzyme blockade
by suicide inhibition (Fig. 3), both animals displayed normal
movement and behavior within a day. This is not
unexpected because of known plasticity of the dopamine
system and suggests that compensatory mechanisms are
involved [30]. In mice, 6 h after the highest single
FMDOPA dose used (500 mg/kg) was given wherein
complete AAAD inhibition is assumed, dopamine levels
on a per gram whole brain basis dropped to less than 40% of
control. Because of higher dopamine concentration in the
striatal terminals, the drop in synaptic dopamine levels in
the striatum is likely larger. In this study, based on the PET-
estimated half-life of AAAD recovery of 86 h, 24 h after
treatment, one can estimate the recovered AAAD activity to
be about 20% of control. The observed behavioral and
motor recovery at this level of AAAD activity suggests that
O.T. DeJesus et al. / Brain Research 1054 (2005) 55–60 59
the dopamine levels under this condition are sufficient to
allow normal function. It is likely that compensatory
mechanisms similar to those reported in dopamine deficient
mice wherein normal locomotor activity can be restored
with striatal dopamine levels amounting to 9% of normal
values [26] are involved. Reduced dopamine levels can
trigger upregulation of the rate-limiting conversion of p-
tyrosine to l-DOPA by tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) by post-
translational changes, e.g., phosphorylation [10]. However,
because of much reduced AAAD activity after FMDOPA
inhibition, the rate-limiting step may have shifted from the
TH step to the AAAD step. Another pre-synaptic compen-
satory response may be the downregulation of metabolism
involving re-uptake by the dopamine transporter (DAT)
similar to that seen in pre-clinical PD [16]. On the post-
synaptic side, dopamine receptors may become super-
sensitive because of reduced dopamine levels as first
reported in 6-OHDA-lesioned animals [28] and recently
found in the TH-deficient dopamine depleted mice [15].
Such supersensitivity is likely related to increased levels of
the high affinity states of D2 receptors [25].
It is interesting to note that the symptomatic threshold for
PD is associated with declines in striatal dopamine levels in
the order of about 20–40% of normal levels [13]. A recent
PET study with [18F]FDOPA estimated the PD symptomatic
threshold to be at 47–62% of normal putaminal uptake
values [16]. The recovery of both animals within 24 h after
complete AAAD inhibition may therefore be similar to the
pre-clinical stage of PD but since normal brains are involved
in this study the observed faster motor and behavioral
recovery is a reasonable outcome. A third animal given the
same dose of FMDOPA in the afternoon and whose PET
scan was planned for the following day was found to be
surprisingly alert and displayed normal movement and
behavior the next morning. The seeming lack of FMDOPA
effect on this animal prompted the misguided decision to
forego its PET study.
In summary, the in vivo turnover rate of AAAD enzyme
protein in the rhesus macaque striatum was assessed by
monitoring recovery of enzyme activity after suicide inhib-
ition by microPET imaging using the tracer [18F]FMT.
Results showed that the AAAD turnover half-life is about
86 h and total recovery is estimated to be within 16 days after
complete inhibition. However, normal movement and behav-
ior were observed within 24 h at which time AAAD function
was shown by the PET data to be about 20% of normal
levels. This suggests that pre- and post-synaptic compensa-
tory mechanisms allow recovery of normal movement and
behavior earlier than recovery of AAAD function. FMDOPA
inhibition and microPET imaging, using other pre- and post-
synaptic dopamine imaging agents, in non-human primates
may be useful in elucidating these compensatory mecha-
nisms. Furthermore, a possible use of AAAD suicide
inhibition is in generating a reversible non-human primate
model of pre-symptomatic Parkinson’s disease wherein the
consequences of dopamine depletion on dopamine receptors
and transporters and other dopamine-interacting neurotrans-
mitter systems such as serotonin and GABA, may be
investigated in vivo longitudinally using the appropriate
PET imaging agents.
Acknowledgment
The support of NIH Grant NS 26621 is gratefully
acknowledged.
References
[1] F.W. Alexander, E. Sandmeier, P.K. Mehta, P. Christen, Evolutionary
relationships among pyridoxal-5V-phosphate-dependent enzymes.
Regio-specific alpha, beta and gamma families, Eur. J. Biochem. 219