Top Banner
FULL PAPER Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability 1 Leng Pau Chung, 2 Mohd Hamdan Bin Haji Ahmad, 3 Dilshan Remaz Ossen, 3 Malsiah Hamid 1 PhD Candidate, 2 Executive Director, 3 Senior Lecturer 1, 3 Department of Architecture, Faculty of Built Environment University Teknologi Malaysia, 81310, Johor Bahru, Johor MALAYSIA 2 Institute Sultan Iskandar of Urban Habitat and Highrise, University Teknologi Malaysia, 81310, Johor Bahru, Johor MALAYSIA The application of the CFD in building industry would probably be one of the useful tools to go sustainable. Numerical modeling of building with solar chimney using computational fluid dynamic (CFD) technique has contributed to the prediction of indoor thermal environment, which save time, cost, energy and resources. Natural ventilation in residential is being increasingly proposed as an alternative for mechanical ventilation, which could reduce the operational cost, energy consumption and carbon-dioxide emission. The performance of the air well has been empirically proven to reduce the indoor air temperature and increase the air velocity in the passive way. In this case, CFD is applied to predict the thermal performance of room with modified air well in a measured existing single story terraced house. The comparison of indoor air temperature between the field measurement and modeling simulation was done and the result of CFD was observed to predict the functionality of modified air well shaft. The analysis shows that under highest temperature condition in 2012, which is 35°C, indoor environment with modified air well could reduce air temperature from 1 to 4C compared to the existing condition. By incorporate CFD in architectural practice, this application could be useful for the designer of building industry in Malaysia that promotes natural ventilation in passive strategy. 1.0 Introduction Building industry as one of the major industries in the world has important roles to play with, which has high significant impact on the ecosystem and living environment. The energy usage of commercial and residential buildings has gradually increased from 20% to 40% in the developing countries in last ten years, especially the building sector which consumed 8 % to 50% of the sum of energy usage in the development. (R. Saidur et al., 2010) (Pérez-Lombard L, 2008) In
18

Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Dec 27, 2015

Download

Documents

Nelson David

The application of the CFD in building industry would probably be one of the useful tools to go sustainable. Numerical modeling of building with solar chimney using computational fluid dynamic (CFD) technique has contributed to the prediction of indoor thermal environment, which save time, cost, energy and resources. Natural ventilation in residential is being increasingly proposed as an alternative for mechanical ventilation, which could reduce the operational cost, energy consumption and carbon-dioxide emission. The performance of the air well has been empirically proven to reduce the indoor air temperature and increase the air velocity in the passive way. In this case, CFD is applied to predict the thermal performance of room with modified air well in a measured existing single story terraced house. The comparison of indoor air temperature between the field measurement and modeling simulation was done and the result of CFD was observed to predict the functionality of modified air well shaft. The analysis shows that under highest temperature condition in 2012, which is 35°C, indoor environment with modified air well could reduce air temperature from 1 to 4ᴼC compared to the existing condition. By incorporate CFD in architectural practice, this application could be useful for the designer of building industry in Malaysia that promotes natural ventilation in passive strategy.
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

FULL PAPER

Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

1Leng Pau Chung, 2 Mohd Hamdan Bin Haji Ahmad, 3 Dilshan Remaz Ossen, 3

Malsiah Hamid

1PhD Candidate, 2 Executive Director, 3Senior Lecturer 1, 3 Department of Architecture, Faculty of Built Environment University Teknologi Malaysia, 81310, Johor Bahru, Johor

MALAYSIA 2 Institute Sultan Iskandar of Urban Habitat and Highrise, University Teknologi Malaysia, 81310, Johor Bahru, Johor

MALAYSIA

The application of the CFD in building industry would probably be one of the useful tools to go sustainable. Numerical modeling of building with solar chimney using computational fluid dynamic (CFD) technique has contributed to the prediction of indoor thermal environment, which save time, cost, energy and resources. Natural ventilation in residential is being increasingly proposed as an alternative for mechanical ventilation, which could reduce the operational cost, energy consumption and carbon-dioxide emission. The performance of the air well has been empirically proven to reduce the indoor air temperature and increase the air velocity in the passive way. In this case, CFD is applied to predict the thermal performance of room with modified air well in a measured existing single story terraced house. The comparison of indoor air temperature between the field measurement and modeling simulation was done and the result of CFD was observed to predict the functionality of modified air well shaft. The analysis shows that under highest temperature

condition in 2012, which is 35°C, indoor environment with modified air well could

reduce air temperature from 1 to 4ᴼC compared to the existing condition. By incorporate CFD in architectural practice, this application could be useful for the designer of building industry in Malaysia that promotes natural ventilation in passive strategy.

1.0 Introduction

Building industry as one of the major industries in the world has important roles to play with, which has high significant impact on the ecosystem and living environment. The energy usage of commercial and residential buildings has gradually increased from 20% to 40% in the developing countries in last ten years, especially the building sector which consumed 8 % to 50% of the sum of energy usage in the development. (R. Saidur et al., 2010) (Pérez-Lombard L, 2008) In

Page 2: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Malaysia, the energy consumption rate demanded by industrial sector consists of 44%, followed by commercial and residential sectors which consists of 34% and 21% respectively. The high energy consumption rate mainly occurs during the operational stage of the building. According to literature data, approximate 50 to 60% of electricity consumed by the air conditioning, especially industrial and residential buildings in Malaysia. (Nikpour et al., 2013) The massive construction and poor building design which do not accountable for the environmental impact aspects directly giving the significance implications to the environment. (Zhai, 2006) The high dependency of mechanical ventilation in buildings in order to provide thermal comfort and habitable living environment with good air quality in the indoor is common nowadays. With no exception, the usage of air conditioning in the residential area of Malaysia has increased significantly since approximate 85% of the housing in Malaysia is brick and concrete housing. (Malaysia, 2000) According to review and national census of Malaysia, the total household numbers with air conditioning has increased from 13,000 in year 1970 to 775,000 in year 2000 (Malaysia, 2003, Tetsu Kubota et al., 2011). Thus, the issue of the building design should be concerned in order to maximize the thermal comfort through the passive strategies before opt for mechanical ventilation system.

In recent years, Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) has been identified as the most sophisticated airflow modeling techniques that can generate the prediction analysis of airflow, heat transfer and contaminant transportation around and inside the buildings. CFD is widely applied in building design over few decades. The contribution of the CFD includes analyzing the impact of the building exhausts to the environment, predicting the smoke and fire risks, designing the natural ventilation system of building, identifying the indoor environment quality and so forth. (Zhai, 2006) Incorporation of CFD in the architectural process enabled the designer to overview the thermal performance of the building that functions well in responds to the microclimatic factors. The pre-determined design decision made, however, is more cost effective compared to the post-construction amendment. Thus, CFD simulation result is important to determine the performance of the building in pre-construction stage.

1.1 Sustainability and natural ventilation in tropical climate

Sustainability ensured the equilibrium between the nature environment and human which allowed the healthy growth of social, economic and other major conditions that involve present and future generations. (EPA, 2011) In the context of built environment, sustainable building should come with dynamic and flexible idea, which allows adaptation occurred to fit the requirements and functions changes. (Berardi, 2013) In the tropical region, climatic factor significantly affects the microclimate and thermal comfort of a building. Responds to this matter, sustainable building expectedly to design with “breathable” strategies that accommodate occupants with thermal comfort without the use of any mechanical ventilation system.

Efficient natural ventilation system in residential building is one of the important criteria to achieve healthy building. Passive comfort ventilation considered as a fundamental requirement which is one of the natural ventilation strategy that employ the movement of air for physical cooling. According to Givoni B., high air velocity will accelerate the convective heat transfer and evaporative heat loss, which reduce the thermal discomfort of the human body. (Givoni.B., 1998) The physiological cooling eases the body discomfort and induces thermal comfort. In the

Page 3: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

indoor environment, natural ventilation strategies could be the categorized into cross ventilation, single-sided ventilation and stack ventilation. Stack ventilation has higher potential to induce air movement under static or low wind condition, especially in Malaysia context compared to cross and single-sided ventilation method. Most of the buildings limited by the spatial design and regulations control, and thus reduce the possibility to have more than one opening per room. Single-sided ventilation is less efficient, compared to the cross ventilation. Unfortunately, most of the enclosed space in buildings is fitted with single sided opening due to the constraints. Single-sided ventilation has less potential to induce thermal comfort. In order to increase the pressure differences between the indoor and outdoor, an opening is needed to create the pressure. Under the limitations and constraints, solar chimney is an alternative for the cross ventilation which provide pressure differences that induced stack ventilation.

In this paper,field measurement was carried out in a 3m x 4m x 3m (height) intermediate room attached with 1m x 2m x 5m (height) in single-storey building located at Kuching, Sarawak. The field measurement is to validate the CFD simulation software which was applied in the prediction stage. For the field experiment stage, air temperature and relative humidity were selected as the main variables to identify the thermal environment for the measured house. The field measurement was carried out by using the HOBO air temperature and relative humidity data logger, HOBO air velocity data logger and HOBO weather station. The simulation was carried out by Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) to compute the air well and room thermal performance.

1.2 Malaysia’s Climate Condition

Malaysia located at equator, lies between 1° and 7° North latitude and 100° and 120° East longitudes. Malaysia complemented by Peninsular of Malaysia and Sabah and Sarawak located at Borneo Island. The study is conducted at Kuching, which is the capital of Sarawak, which covers an area of 1,863 km² the biggest state in Malaysia. Kuching has the population of 325,132, which is the most populous city in Sarawak (Malaysia, 2010). Malaysia experienced hot and humid climate throughout the year. However, the dominant climatic characteristic in Malaysia governs by the seasonal wind and rainfall, which is Northeast and Southwest Monsoon that happened respectively at November to March and May to September. During April and October, the inter-monsoon season happens.

For the microclimate case study, according to the year 2012 meteorological data in Kuching, Sarawak, the max and min monthly air temperature fluctuated between 22°C and 35°C while relative humidity ranged from 44% to 100% as shown in figure 1 and 3. This shows that the local climate is greatly influenced by the wind and solar radiation. In general, most of the city in Malaysia received 6 hours solar radiation per day while Kuching received only 5 hours per day. The mean monthly intensity of global solar radiation varies from 318.38 Wh/m to 226.37 Wh/m as in figure 2. Generally, the mean global solar radiation decreases while the wind velocity increase, which resulted in high air temperature and low humidity. During the Northeast Monsoon season, the solar radiation is generally lower compared to the Southwest Monsoon season due to the rainfalls.

Page 4: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Figure 1: Mean monthly air temperature (°C) and relative humidity (%) (Data obtained from Kuching Meteorological Station, 2012)

Figure 2: Mean monthly global solar radiation (Wh/m) and wind speed (Km/h) (Data obtained from Kuching Meteorological Station, 2012)

25

25.5

26

26.5

27

27.5

28

76

78

80

82

84

86

88

90

JAN FEB MAC APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC

Air

tem

per

atu

re (

°C)

Rel

ativ

e H

um

idit

y (%

)

Kuching 2012 :Mean Monthly Air Temperature (°C) and Relative Humidity (%)

Relative Humidity (%) Dry Bulb Temperature (°C)

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

JAN FEB MAC APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC

Win

d S

pee

d (

Km

/h)

Glo

bal

Rad

iati

on

(W

/mh

)

Kuching 2012: Mean Monthly Global Radiation (Wh/m) & Wind Speed (Km/h)

Global Radiation (Wh/m) Wind Speed (Km/h)

Page 5: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Figure 3: The maximum monthly air temperature (°C) & relative humidity (%)

Figure 4: The maximum monthly global radiation (Wh/m) & Wind speed (Km/h)

According to figure 1, the variations of air temperature control the evaporation of water into the air and it regulate the air humidity and saturation. Under the unsaturated condition, the air temperature is inversely proportional to the relative humidity. Figure 3 shows the maximum monthly air temperature and humidity in Kuching in year 2012. The highest air temperature within year 2012 reported as 35°C which appear during April, May, June, August and September while the maximum relative humidity reported as 100% throughout the year.

1.3 Typical terrace housing in Malaysia The field experiment was conducted at a single storey terrace house in

Kuching, Sarawak. The growth of the Sarawak’s property market since 2010 has shown the positive sign in the Malaysia housing stock. There was 65% take up rate and 10 to 15% new launches on the recent projects in year 2010, reported by Sarawak Housing & Real Estate Developers’ Association. Nearly over half of the

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

JAN FEB MAC APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC

Air

Tem

per

atu

re (

°C)

Rel

ativ

e H

um

idit

y (%

)

Kuching 2012: The Maximum Monthly Air Temperature (°C) & Relative Humidity (%)

Relative Humidity (%) Air Temperature (°C)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

1500

1550

1600

1650

1700

1750

1800

1850

1900

JAN FEB MAC APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC

Win

d S

pee

d (

Km

/h)

Glo

bal

Rad

iati

on

(W

h/m

)

Kuching 2012: The Maximum Monthly Global Radiation (Wh/m) & Wind Speed (Km/h)

Global Radiation (Wh/m) Wind Speed (Km/h)

Page 6: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

new projects in 2010 located at Kuching city area, which means that large numbers of the young Sarawakians and expatriates entering the market have injected more demands on the housing at capital of Sarawak. (Oxford, 2011) The increase of the housing demands has aroused the attention of the developers, who goes for better architectural design with economical solutions. Thus, field experiment is necessary to understand the current thermal performance of the typical terrace housing. (Figure 5) The typical terrace house as shown in figure 5 is facing north. The typical size is about 17m in depth and 6m in width are divided by a 6m width road.

Figure 5: Location (left) and outlook (right) of Field Experiment House in Kuching, Sarawak

2.0 Research Methodology

This study involved the field measurement and computational fluid dynamic (CFD) to predict and estimate the thermal performance. The methodology of the study was carried out in the followings flow:

2.1 Field Measurement

The field measurement of the study was carried out in 16 May 2012 from 12am to 11pm in the single storey terrace house located in Yen Yen Housing area, Matang in Kuching, Sarawak. The field survey is to determine the environmental condition of a typical terrace house in Malaysia. The house comprises of 3 rooms and a shared living and dining area. The window of the test room is facing the south

Measurement

• field measurement to obtain the thermal performance of existing terrace house

Validation

• Validation of the CFD software by using the field measurement result

Prediction

• Prediction of thermal performance of the modified air well and room in CFD

Page 7: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

while the living and master bedroom is facing north. In this case study house, living cum dining space received ventilation from front and back window while master bedroom and room 2 experience single sided ventilation. Other than that, room 1 is considered as intermediate room, which is dependent on the openings facing the internal space to gain ventilation. The air well is located between bedroom 1 and bedroom 2, however, only bedroom 2 attached to the air well. Sliding windows (1.5m height and 1.5m width, 0.8m above the floor) were installed at all rooms except window at bedroom 2 which attached to air well, where the louvres windows (1.2m width and 1.5m height) were installed. In addition, the bathrooms openings are above the ceiling level (dotted line as stated in figure 6). The case study house is separated by 230mm thick party wall and the all walls are not insulated for heat transmission. The internal walls and structure wall are built with 150mm and 200mm thick brick respectively. The roofing of the case study house was made from clay tiles while insulated with aluminum sheets. All the external windows was opened during day time and closed from 12am to 7am for security purpose. The measuring instruments were set up at outdoor and indoor as stated in the table 1.0 and figure 6. The results from the measuring were input into the CFD simulation for accurate calculation on prediction of thermal performance in the next step.

Figure 6: Position of measuring instruments: global weather station ( ∆ ), HOBO U12 temperature and humidity logger (O), HOBO U12 air velocity logger

(X)

Space Data Type Equipment Time Interval

Measuring Point

Master bedroom

Air temperature

Relative humidity

HOBOware U12 air temperature and relative humidity data logger

15 minutes 1.5m from floor level

Bedroom 1 Air temperature

Relative humidity

Air velocity

HOBOware U12 air temperature and relative humidity data logger & air velocity data logger

15 minutes 1.5m from floor level

Page 8: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Air well Air temperature

Relative humidity

Air velocity

HOBOware U12 air temperature and relative humidity data logger & air velocity data logger

15 minutes 1.5m from floor level

Bedroom 2 Air temperature

Relative humidity

HOBOware U12 air temperature and relative humidity data logger

15 minutes 1.5m from floor level

Living + Dining Air temperature

Relative humidity

HOBOware U12 air temperature and relative humidity data logger

15 minutes 1.5m from floor level

Outdoor Air temperature

Relative humidity

Solar radiation

Wind velocity

Wind direction

HOBOware U30 weather station

15 minutes 2m from floor level

Table 1: Measuring instrument details and method

In this study, there are 3 types of measuring instrument involved: the HOBO U30 global weather station which used to measure the wind velocity, wind direction, solar radiation, air temperature and relative humidity; HOBO U12 air temperature and humidity loggers which were installed at master bedroom, air well, dining and living space, bedroom 1 and bedroom 2 while HOBO U12 air velocity logger were placed at air well and bedroom 2. All the measuring instruments were calibrated with the thermal data logger prior to the experiment to ensure the reliable result for the field measurement were obtained. All the indoor measuring instruments were placed 1.5m above the floor and the global weather station was placed 2m above the floor. The time intervals for the measuring instrument logging were set 15 minutes apart from 12am to 11pm of 16 May 2012. However, the focus of discussion only scope into outdoor climate condition, air well and bedroom 2 from 8am to 7pm.

2.2 CFD Simulation

In this study, in order to predict the thermal performance of the modified air well based on the existing air well, CFD simulation plays an important role. Validation of CFD software based on the field experiment results has been done by researchers before proceed with the research experiment. (Bangalee et al., 2013, Evola and Popov, 2006, Mohammad Baharvand et al., 2013)

Designbuilder was chosen as the CFD simulation software in this study. Some literature has validated this CFD software and the result is reliable.(DesignBuilder, 2012, Mohammad Baharvand et al., 2013) Designbuilder is developed by

Page 9: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

EnergyPlus, which is the U.S. DOE building energy simulation program for building modeling task such as ventilation, cooling, heating, energy flows and so forth. (DesignBuilder, 2013) The initial condition of the simulation was input with the field experiment result in stage 1, which obtained from 8am to 7pm of 16 May 2012 in Kuching, Sarawak (as shown in table 2).

Time Air Temperature (°C) Humidity (%)

Wind Speed (m/s)

Solar radiation

(Wh/m²)

Wind Direction (°)

8am 24.1 100 0 30 160

9am 25.4 97 0.03 760 160

10am 27 90 0 730 140

11am 32 80 0.1 881 120

12pm 32 72 0.2 992 140

1pm 32 64 0.1 1000 120

2pm 33.2 63 0.14 760 130

3pm 33.5 45 0 852 180

4pm 35 33 0.02 510 0

5pm 34 30 0.1 311 200

6pm 30 89 0 112 140

7pm 30 96 0 25 160

Table 2: Field Measurement Input Data for CFD simulation obtained from HOBO U30 weather station at 16 May 2012

In this study, the scope of experiment concentrate on the air well and bedroom 2, which is the room attached with air well and ventilated by single-sided opening. A layer of adiabatic component was modelled at the external surface of air well and bedroom, which is being used when the modelled space has similar conditions in term of shading, reflection and visualisation with adjacent space. Other than that, it could also reduce the complexity of the model and saving the simulation time. The boundary condition of CFD program was brought over from the simulation results. Designbuilder applied domain-decoupled technique that separating the simulation of external airflow fields and internal airflow fields. (Jiru.E.T and Bitsuamlak.G.T, 2010) Furthermore, in the technical option setting, “calculated” module is preferred over “scheduled” module where the natural ventilation and infiltration are calculated based on the total window openings and natural ventilation criteria. CFD in Designbuilder applied Cartesian type-grid system. In this study, the total amount of cells generated from this grid system is 32 numbers (x-direction) x 49 numbers (y-direction) x 51numbers (z-direction) with max ratio 14.83. The calculation in CFD applied the standard k-ɛ turbulent model with 5000 iterations.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1 Field measurement results: outdoor climate condition and indoor thermal environment In order to understand the thermal performance of the indoor environment, the outdoor climatic condition should be given the priority in research since the indoor environment very much dependent on the outdoor climate condition. According to

figure 7, the outdoor air temperature reached 35°C at 4pm and during this hour the

relative humidity was only 33%. Inverse condition happened when the air

Page 10: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

temperature at its lowest, which is 24.1°C at 8am where the humidity was 100%.

According to (Humphreys et al., 2011) the neutral air temperature needs to be

maintained at 26 to 28°C. Thus, from the recorded data, 8am to 10am were

considered as comfort condition and it maintain the comfort level of indoor environment. The solar radiation reached the highest intensity at 12pm and 1pm,

which are 992 Wh/m² and 1000Wh/m² respectively on 16 May 2012. The outdoor air

velocity pattern fluctuated between 0 m/s to 0.2m/s. The outdoor air flow is more dynamic during afternoon (0.1 – 0.2m/s from 11am to 2pm) and more static at late evening (0 – 0.1m/s at night time). More than 90% of the wind originates from south west – south direction. Thus, utilization of prevailing wind direction to improve ventilation could be an alternative. However, wind getting weak when it flows near to the ground. Thus, wind driven ventilation in the indoor environment could be challenging in Malaysia.

Figure 7: Measured Outdoor, Bedroom2 and Air well Air temperature and

Relative Humidity on 16 May 2012

Figure 8: Measured Outdoor, Bedroom 2 and Air well Air velocity and wind

direction on 16 May 2012

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

8am 9am 10am 11am 12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm 4pm 5pm 6pm 7pm

Air

te

mp

era

ture

(°C

)

Re

lati

ve h

um

idit

y (%

)

Measured Outdoor, Bedroom 2 and Air well Air Temperature (°C) and Relative Humidity (%) on 16 May 2012

Outdoor Air temperature (°C) Bedroom 2 Air temperature (°C)

Air well Air temperature (°C) Air well Relative humidity (%)

Outdoor Relative humidity (%) Bedroom 2 Relative humidity (%)

0

50

100

150

200

250

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

8am 9am 10am 11am 12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm 4pm 5pm 6pm 7pm

Win

d D

ire

ctio

n (

°)

Air

ve

loci

ty (

m/s

)

Measured Outdoor, Bedroom 2 and Air well Air velocity (m/s) and wind direction (°) on 16 May 2012

Outdoor Air velocity (m/s) Bedroom 2 Air velocity (m/s)

Air well Air velocity (m/s) Wind Direction (°)

Page 11: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Figure 9: Measured Solar Radiation on 16 May 2012

For the indoor environment, generally the air temperature in the bedroom was lower compared to the outdoor temperature. The average air temperature of bedroom from 8am to 7pm is 0.87% lower than the average outdoor temperature.

The average air well temperature is 6.51°C higher compared to the outdoor due to

the radiation which heat up the building fabric. This helps the air well to create temperature differences on the top and indoor to accelerate the wind speed. The relative humidity of the indoor environment slightly higher compared to the outdoor environment, especially the bedroom. The highest humidity recorded as 100% during daytime before 10am while the lowest recorded as 33% where the air temperature was at its peak. The air velocity of the bedroom maintained in 0 to 0.02m/s while the air well air velocity fluctuated from 0.016 to 0.039m/s around 3pm to 5pm. 3.2 Validation of CFD: bedroom 2 as case study Validation of the CFD model with the field experiment was carried out by comparing the air temperature and air well of the bedroom2. Percentage of deviation was calculated and shows in the figure 10, 11 and 12. Generally, the CFD simulation results show the differences less than 10% for both air temperature and air velocity. The air temperature shows the maximum differences of 8.54% between outdoor and bedroom at 12pm while 90% of the time the air velocity shows the highest deviation at 10% between the measured and simulated results. According to (Nugroho, 2007) within the range of 10%, the simulation software is accepted as the research tool. Therefore, the use of Designbuilder as thermal performance prediction tool in the building is validated.

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

8am 9am 10am 11am 12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm 4pm 5pm 6pm 7pm

Sola

r ra

dia

tio

n (

Wh

/m²)

Measured Solar Radiation (Wh/m) on 16 May 2012

Outdoor Solar Radiation (Wh/m²)

Page 12: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Figure 10: Comparison of the bedroom 2 temperature result between field

measurement and simulation on 16 May 2012

Figure 11: Comparison of the bedroom 2 relative humidity result between field

measurement and simulation on 16 May 2012

-50

-30

-10

10

30

50

20

22

24

26

28

30

32

34

8am 9am 10am 11am 12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm 4pm 5pm 6pm 7pm

De

viat

ion

(%

)

Air

Te

mp

era

ture

(°C

) Comparison of the bedroom 2 temperature result between field

measurement and simulation on 16 May 2012

Measured Air temperature (°C) Simulated Air Temperature (°C) Deviation (%)

-50

-30

-10

10

30

50

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

8am 9am 10am 11am 12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm 4pm 5pm 6pm 7pm

De

viat

ion

(%

)

Re

lati

ve h

um

idit

y (%

)

Comparison of the bedroom 2 relative humidity result between field measurement and simulation on 16 May 2012

Measured Relative humidity (%) Simulated Relative humidity (%) Deviation (%)

Page 13: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Figure 12: Comparison of the bedroom 2 air velocity result between field

measurement and simulation on 16 May 2012

3.3 Prediction of new air well model: improve the indoor thermal environment

The air velocity and air temperature in this stage were calculated using CFD simulation at 4pm on 16 may 2012 since the highest air temperature of 35°C was recorded. The average air velocity and air temperature was recorded at 1.5m from the floor. According to table 3, five geometries air well: 0.5 x 0.5m, 1 x 0.5m, 1 x 1m, 2 x 0.5m and 2 x 1m were simulated. All models were tested under no wind condition from outdoor environment. Great turbulence happened on the existing air well model, where the air velocity could hit 0.11 to 0.13 m/s under buoyancy thermal condition but the bedroom temperature is the highest among 4 other models and similar to

outdoor temperature, which is 35.04°C. The differences of air temperature between

air well and room for the existing model (2 x 1m) is the highest, which is 0.8°C.

Model 0.5x0.5m gives the dynamic air velocity differences between two spaces, which is 60% differences between air well and bedroom. Higher pressure in the narrow shaft inlet creates higher pressure and causes the air change the direction when it reached the shaft opening which attached to the room. However, the narrow shaft limits the up flow turbulence from the air well outlets. Thus the convective turbulence flow within the room is weak compared to the original model.

The 0.5 x 0.5m model gives the lowest bedroom temperature among 5

geometries, which is 30.74°C. This is due to the solar gain from the radiation and

convection is lower in narrow shaft compared to the wide opening on the air well shaft. Among 5 geometries, model 2 x 1m shows the highest air temperature and air velocity in both air well and bedroom, which are 0.039 m/s and 0.035m/s as well as

35.89°C and 35.04°C respectively while model 0.5x 0.5m gives the lowest air

temperature in both air well and bedroom, which is 30.74°C and 30.69°C. However,

model 0.5x0.5m shows the lowest air velocity in bedroom while model 1x0.5m shows the lowest air velocity in air well. This phenomenon shows that the greater depth of the air well is preferable for turbulence to occur.

-50

-30

-10

10

30

50

0

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

0.03

0.035

8am 9am 10am 11am 12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm 4pm 5pm 6pm 7pm

De

viat

ion

(%

)

Air

ve

loci

ty (

m/s

) Comparison of the bedroom 2 air velocity result between field measurement

and simulation on 16 May 2012

Measured Air velocity (m/s) Simulated Air velocity (m/s) Deviation (%)

Page 14: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

Figure 13: Air velocity (m/s) and air temperature (°C) generated by 5 air well

geometry sizes on 4pm at 16 May 2012

According to figure 13, air velocity of the room and air well is inversely proportional while the air temperature for both is similar and dependent on each other. This could be influenced by the height of the air well, where solar radiation and convection happened and directly warm up the air in the room from the air well. Generally, air velocity in the air well is higher compared to the room since the warm air at the top of air well shaft heated by radiation via the building skin resulting in temperature differences. From the five geometries, model 2 x 0.5m shows ideal

result since both air well and room have the lowest temperature, which is 30.95°C

and 30.87°C respectively among others and the air velocity for air well and bedroom

shows the great differences, which is 0.038m/s and 0.017m/s. The findings shows that the air well with rectangular form tends to accelerate the air velocity in the air well compared to the uniform geometry. This means that the rectangular geometry has higher potential to reduce the heat gain directly from the solar radiation and in the same time could accelerate the buoyancy air flow speed in the air well shaft.

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.5x0.5 1x0.5 1x1 2x0.5 2x1

Air

Te

mp

era

ture

(°C

)

Air

Ve

loci

ty (

m/s

) Air velocity (m/s) and air temperature (°C) generated by 5 air well

geometry sizes on 4pm at 16 May 2012

Bedroom 2 Air Velocity (m/s) Air Well Air Velocity (m/s)

Bedroom 2 Air Temperature (°C) Air Well Air Temperature (°C)

Outdoor Air Temperature

Existing Air Well Size

Page 15: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

CFD simulation Air Well Size

0.5 x 0.5m

1 x 0.5m

1 x 1m

Page 16: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

2 x 0.5m

2 x 1m (original size of air well)

Table 3: CFD slices show the air flow pattern (colour arrow) and air temperature (filled colour slices) of the modified air well with existing room

4.0 Conclusion

The purpose of the study is to shows the CFD as the prediction tool for thermal performance in building industry. The thermal performance is first verified through the field measurement in order to understand the thermal condition of the existing terrace house. The next step would be validation of the CFD software in order to make sure the viability of the software for research task. The last step is to find out the appropriate geometries of the air well size which suit the existing room size to improve the ventilation of the room.

From the results of the CFD, although the configurations of the modified air well have the gap to achieve the thermal comfort range in the tropics, which is 28 to

32°C under the condition with 80 to 90% humidity and 1m/s air velocity, however the

basic configuration of air well shaft which effectively promote the air flow and shed

Page 17: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

the solar radiation has been investigated. The rectangular geometry with size 2.0x1.0m is the appropriate size compared to the uniform size air well. Further exploration on the length of the air well shaft and the material to improve the stack ventilation in building especially in hot and humid condition is important. In conclusion, CFD simulation software is a useful tool that save up times, cost and man power that enable research to be done in sustainable way.

Acknowledgment

The authors would like to thank Institute Sultan Iskandar of Urban Habitat & Highrise for the financial support and assistance from research grant.

Reference

BANGALEE, M. Z. I., MIAU, J. J. & LIN, S. Y. 2013. Computational techniques and a numerical study of a buoyancy-driven ventilation system. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 65, 572-583.

BERARDI, U. 2013. Clarifying the new interpretations of the concept of sustainable building. Sustainable Cities and Society, 8, 72-78.

DESIGNBUILDER 2012. An Inter-program Analysis of Computational Fluid Dynamics Based on PHOENICS and DesignBuilder Software. Newcastle: Northumbria University.

DESIGNBUILDER. 2013. Energyplus [Online]. U.S. Department of Energy. Available: http://www.designbuilder.co.uk/content/view/29/44/ [Accessed 28 November 2013 2013].

EPA, U. S. E. P. A. 2011. What is sustainability? What is EPA doing? How can I help? [Online]. United State: EPA. Available: http://www.epa.gov/sustainability/basicinfo.htm [Accessed 14 November 2013 2013].

EVOLA, G. & POPOV, V. 2006. Computational analysis of wind driven natural ventilation in buildings. Energy and Buildings, 38, 491-501.

GIVONI.B. 1998. Climate considerations in building and urban design, New York, John Wiley & Sons,INC.

HUMPHREYS, M. A., NICOL, J. F. & RAJA, I. A. 2011. Field Studies of Indoor Thermal Comfort and the Progress of the Adaptive Approach. Advances in Building Energy Research, 1.:1, 55-88.

JIRU.E.T & BITSUAMLAK.G.T 2010. Application of CFD in Modelling Wind-Induced Natural Ventilation of Buildings - A review. The International Journal of Ventilation, 9.

MALAYSIA 2000. General Report of the Population and Housing Census. Malaysia: Department of Statistics Malaysia.

MALAYSIA 2003. National Energy Balance 2003. Malaysia: Ministry of Energy, Water and Communication.

MALAYSIA 2010. Population Distribution by Local Authority Areas and Mukims. Malaysia: Department of Statistics, Malaysia.

MOHAMMAD BAHARVAND, MOHD HAMDAN BIN AHMAD, TABASSOM SAFIKHANI & MAJID, R. B. A. 2013. DesignBuilder Verification and Validation for Indoor Natural Ventilation. J.Basic Appl. Sci Res, 3, 182-189.

NIKPOUR, M., KANDAR, M. Z. & MOSAVI, E. 2013. Investigating Daylight Quality Using Self-Shading Strategy in Energy Commission Building in Malaysia. Indoor and Built Environment, 22, 822-835.

NUGROHO, A. M. 2007. Solar Chimney Geometry for Stack Ventilation in Malaysia Terrace House. PhD Open Access, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia.

OXFORD 2011. Off the Peninsula. In: MALAYSIA, O. B. G. (ed.) The Report: Malaysia 2011. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford Business Group Malaysia.

PÉREZ-LOMBARD L, O. J., POUT C. 2008. A review on buildings energy consumption information. Energy and Buildings 40, 394-398.

Page 18: Application of CFD in Prediction of Indoor Building Thermal Performance as an effective pre-design tool towards sustainability

R. SAIDUR, M. HASANUZZAMAN , S. YOGESWARAN, H.A. MOHAMMED & HOSSAIN, M. S. 2010. An end-use energy analysis in a Malaysian public hospital. Energy 35, 4780-4785.

TETSU KUBOTA, SANGWOO JEONG, DORIS HOOI CHYEE TOE & OSSEN, D. R. 2011. Energy Consumption and Air Conditioning Usage in Residential Buildings of Malaysia. Journal of International Development and Cooperation, 17, 61-69.

ZHAI, Z. 2006. Application of Computational Fluid Dynamics in Building Design: Aspects and Trends. Indoor and Built Environment, 15, 305-313.