Appendix A - WV Department of Environmental Protectiondep.wv.gov/daq/Air Toxics/Documents/Appendix A - Air...39 145 13 2001 20.32 49.2 21.11 43.5 24.65 43.2 45 Y 22.0 Y 39 145 13 2002

west virginia department of environmental protection

Appendix AAir Monitoring Data

Promoting a healthy environment.

Huntington, WV PM2.5 Redesignation & Maintenance Plan Appendix: Page A - 1

This page intentionally left blank.


Table of Contents

2.5Cabell County, WV PM Air Monitoring Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 5

2.5Boyd County, KY PM Air Monitoring Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 7

2.5Lawrence County, OH PM Air Monitoring Data.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 9

2.5Scioto County OH, PM Air Monitoring Data. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 11

2.5Raw PM Air Monitoring Data.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 13

EPA Design Value Report. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 23

Technical Support Document for EPA’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking for Approval andPromulgation of Air Quality Plans: Determination of Attainment of the 1997 Fine ParticulateStandard [76FR27290, 11MAY2011]. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 90


[This page intentionally left blank.]


# State Code or Tribal Indicator (TT)

County Code or Tribal Code

Site_ID Number

Design Value Year

DV Year: Arithmetic Mean

DV Year: 98th Percentile

Year ‐ 1: Arithmetic Mean

Year ‐ 1: 98th Percentile



Daily Design Value

Daily Validity Indicator

Annual Design Value

Annual Validity Indicator

54 11 6 2000 17.60 39.6 18.41 43.3 41 N 18 N54 11 6 2001 17.50 44.6 17.60 39.6 18.41 43.3 43 Y 17.8 Y54 11 6 2002 16.73 45.7 17.50 44.6 17.60 39.6 43 Y 17.3 Y54 11 6 2003 15.45 33.0 16.73 45.7 17.50 44.6 41 Y 16.6 Y54 11 6 2004 15.18 30.9 15.45 33.0 16.73 45.7 37 Y 15.8 Y54 11 6 2005 18.13 40.5 15.18 30.9 15.45 33.0 35 Y 16.3 Y54 11 6 2006 14.97 30.1 18.13 40.5 15.18 30.9 34 Y 16.1 Y54 11 6 2007 16.62 39.4 14.97 30.1 18.13 40.5 37 Y 16.6 Y54 11 6 2008 14.14 27.4 16.62 39.4 14.97 30.1 32 Y 15.2 Y54 11 6 2009 12.03 22.5 14.14 27.4 16.62 39.4 30 Y 14.3 Y54 11 6 2010 13.18 28.0 12.03 22.5 14.14 27.4 26 Y 13.1 Y

Cabell County, WV PM2.5 Air Monitoring Data




# State Code or Tribal Indicator


Site_ID Number

Design Value Year







Daily Design Value


Annual Design Value


21 19 17 2000 16.01 34.1 14.92 33.5 34 N 15.5 N21 19 17 2001 15.49 37.7 16.01 34.1 14.92 33.5 35 N 15.5 Y21 19 17 2002 15.54 39.4 15.49 37.7 16.01 34.1 37 Y 15.7 Y21 19 17 2003 13.93 33.8 15.54 39.4 15.49 37.7 37 Y 15.0 Y21 19 17 2004 13.29 30.3 13.93 33.8 15.54 39.4 35 Y 14.3 Y21 19 17 2005 16.01 36.1 13.29 30.3 13.93 33.8 33 Y 14.4 Y21 19 17 2006 13.76 28.6 16.01 36.1 13.29 30.3 32 Y 14.4 Y21 19 17 2007 14.34 38.5 13.76 28.6 16.01 36.1 34 Y 14.7 Y21 19 17 2008 12.06 24.3 14.34 38.5 13.76 28.6 30 Y 13.4 Y21 19 17 2009 10.94 23.5 12.06 24.3 14.34 38.5 29 Y 12.4 Y21 19 17 2010 11.23 26.2 10.94 23.5 12.06 24.3 25 Y 11.4 Y

Boyd County, KY PM2.5 Air Monitoring Data






Site_ID Number

Design Value Year







Daily Design Value


Annual Design Value


39 87 10 2000 17.35 40.2 17.90 34.2 37 N 17.6 N39 87 10 2001 17.67 41.0 17.35 40.2 17.90 34.2 38 Y 17.6 Y39 87 10 2002 15.48 42.4 17.67 41.0 17.35 40.2 41 Y 16.8 Y39 87 10 2003 14.25 29.3 15.48 42.4 17.67 41.0 38 Y 15.8 Y39 87 10 2004 13.71 31.2 14.25 29.3 15.48 42.4 34 Y 14.5 Y39 87 10 2005 16.97 38.5 13.71 31.2 14.25 29.3 33 Y 15.0 Y39 87 10 2006 14.39 30.8 16.97 38.5 13.71 31.2 34 Y 15.0 Y39 87 10 2007 14.97 35.2 14.39 30.8 16.97 38.5 35 Y 15.4 Y39 87 10 2008 10.84 16.5 14.97 35.2 14.39 30.8 28 N 13.4 N39 87 10 2009 10.84 16.5 14.97 35.2 26 N 12.9 N39 87 10 2010 10.84 16.5 17 N 10.8 N39 87 12 2008 13.12 27.6 28 N 13.1 N39 87 12 2009 11.33 21.4 13.12 27.6 25 N 12.2 N39 87 12 2010 12.09 25.1 11.33 21.4 13.12 27.6 25 Y 12.2 Y

Lawrence County, OH PM2.5 Air Monitoring Data




# State Code or Tribal Indicator (TT)


Site_ID Number

Design Value Year







Daily Design Value


Annual Design Value


39 145 13 2000 21.11 43.5 24.65 43.2 43 N 22.9 N39 145 13 2001 20.32 49.2 21.11 43.5 24.65 43.2 45 Y 22.0 Y39 145 13 2002 16.65 42.1 20.32 49.2 21.11 43.5 45 Y 19.4 Y39 145 13 2003 14.69 32.8 16.65 42.1 20.32 49.2 41 Y 17.2 Y39 145 13 2004 12.95 29.4 14.69 32.8 16.65 42.1 35 Y 14.8 Y39 145 13 2005 16.24 40.3 12.95 29.4 14.69 32.8 34 Y 14.6 Y39 145 13 2006 14.32 30.5 16.24 40.3 12.95 29.4 33 Y 14.5 Y39 145 13 2007 13.99 37.5 14.32 30.5 16.24 40.3 36 Y 14.8 Y39 145 13 2008 12.14 24.4 13.99 37.5 14.32 30.5 31 Y 13.5 Y39 145 13 2009 10.86 21.8 12.14 24.4 13.99 37.5 28 Y 12.3 Y39 145 13 2010 11.80 24.4 10.86 21.8 12.14 24.4 24 Y 11.6 Y

Scioto County, OH PM2.5 Air Monitoring Data






Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year

Exceptional Data Type

Daily Pollutant Standard Daily Standard Statistic

# Warning: Computed design values represent snapshot of data at time report was run and this may be incomplete data.# Report Date: 20110329

39 145 13 88101 2004 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2005 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2008 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2010 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2009 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2003 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 12 88101 2009 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2000 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2001 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2003 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2002 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2007 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2001 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2006 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2008 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2005 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2010 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2004 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2008 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2000 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2003 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2010 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2000 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2006 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2007 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2008 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2009 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2009 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2004 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2006 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2003 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2004 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2010 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2002 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2002 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 12 88101 2008 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2005 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile21 19 17 88101 2007 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2002 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 10 88101 2001 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2000 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2005 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2006 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 87 12 88101 2010 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2007 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile39 145 13 88101 2009 0 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile54 11 6 88101 2001 2 PM25 24‐hour 2006 Annual 98th Percentile

# 47 records written.




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year

# Warning: Computed design values represent snapshot of d# Report Date: 20110329

39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Daily Standard Level

Annual Pollutant Standard Annual Standard Statistic

Annual Standard Level

35 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 1535 PM25 Annual 2006 Annual Weighted Mean 15




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Units Code Units Name

105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)105 Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


STREET ADDRESS Site Latitude

4862 GALLIA 38.7541674862 GALLIA 38.7541674862 GALLIA 38.7541674862 GALLIA 38.7541672128 S. 9TH 38.519722HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133450 Commerce Drive 38.5081144862 GALLIA 38.7541674862 GALLIA 38.7541674862 GALLIA 38.7541672128 S. 9TH 38.519722HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.4241332924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672128 S. 9TH 38.5197222128 S. 9TH 38.519722HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.4241332924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672128 S. 9TH 38.5197222128 S. 9TH 38.5197222128 S. 9TH 38.5197222128 S. 9TH 38.519722HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.4241332924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591674862 GALLIA 38.7541672128 S. 9TH 38.5197222128 S. 9TH 38.519722HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.4241332924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.459167HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133450 Commerce Drive 38.5081142924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591672924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT 38.4591674862 GALLIA 38.7541672128 S. 9TH 38.519722HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133450 Commerce Drive 38.5081144862 GALLIA 38.7541674862 GALLIA 38.754167HUNTINGTON ‐ MARSHALL UNIVERSITY 38.424133




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Site Longitude

DV Year: Creditable Count

DV Year: Complete Quarters


‐82.9175 118 4 12.94974548‐82.9175 120 4 16.23595569‐82.9175 348 4 12.14028931‐82.9175 116 4 11.79855911

‐82.665556‐82.4259 119 4 15.45031106

‐82.659301 116 4 11.32720821‐82.9175 66 1 21.1084058‐82.9175 117 4 20.32459832‐82.9175 117 4 14.6937069

‐82.665556 118 4 15.4849277‐82.4259 120 4 16.61689562

‐82.640556 114 4 15.48683871‐82.640556 115 4 13.75978199‐82.640556 120 4 12.05510753‐82.665556 118 4 16.97468371‐82.665556

‐82.4259 117 4 15.17975642‐82.4259 114 4 14.13657704

‐82.640556 113 4 16.01008747‐82.640556 110 4 13.9320291‐82.640556 119 4 11.23454023‐82.665556 95 2 17.34801847‐82.665556 119 4 14.38991935‐82.665556 118 4 14.96713994‐82.665556 11 1 10.83636364

‐82.4259 111 4 12.02704342‐82.640556 116 4 10.9410454‐82.640556 120 4 13.29403802

‐82.9175 120 4 14.31810808‐82.665556 117 4 14.25229885‐82.665556 117 4 13.71177896

‐82.4259 116 4 13.17602564‐82.640556 116 4 15.54125821

‐82.4259 114 4 16.7338698‐82.659301 98 4 13.11982407‐82.640556 116 4 16.01356785‐82.640556 117 4 14.34172619

‐82.9175 118 4 16.65358354‐82.665556 108 4 17.67384524

‐82.4259 114 4 17.59829‐82.4259 117 4 18.13183948‐82.4259 118 4 14.97160714

‐82.659301 117 4 12.09474202‐82.9175 120 4 13.98666667‐82.9175 117 4 10.85850575‐82.4259 116 4 17.49889888




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


DV Year: Substituted Mean

DV Year: Mean Complete


DV Year: 98th Complete

DV Year: Certification

Y 29.4 Y YY 40.3 Y YY 24.4 Y NY 24.4 Y NNY 33 Y YY 21.4 Y NY 43.5 Y NY 49.2 Y NY 32.8 Y YY 42.4 Y YY 39.4 Y NY 37.7 Y YY 28.6 Y NY 24.3 Y YY 38.5 Y YNY 30.9 Y YY 27.4 Y YY 34.1 Y NY 33.8 Y YY 26.2 Y NY 40.2 Y NY 30.8 Y YY 35.2 Y N

6.20909091 N 16.5 N YY 22.5 Y NY 23.5 Y NY 30.3 Y YY 30.5 Y YY 29.3 Y YY 31.2 Y YY 28 Y NY 39.4 Y YY 45.7 Y YY 27.6 Y YY 36.1 Y NY 38.5 Y NY 42.1 Y NY 41 Y NY 39.6 Y NY 40.5 Y YY 30.1 Y YY 25.1 Y NY 37.5 Y NY 21.8 Y NY 44.6 Y N




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Year ‐ 1: Creditable Count

Year ‐ 1: Complete Quarters


Year ‐ 1: Substituted Mean

117 4 14.6937069118 4 12.94974548120 4 13.98666667117 4 10.8585057511 1 10.83636364 6.359090909114 4 16.733869898 4 13.11982407101 3 24.6465909166 1 21.1084058118 4 16.65358354108 4 17.67384524118 4 14.97160714113 4 16.01008747116 4 16.01356785117 4 14.34172619117 4 13.71177896

119 4 15.45031106120 4 16.6168956297 3 14.92364069116 4 15.54125821116 4 10.941045440 1 17.89861111 12.55118 4 16.97468371119 4 14.38991935118 4 14.96713994114 4 14.13657704120 4 12.05510753110 4 13.9320291120 4 16.23595569118 4 15.4849277117 4 14.25229885111 4 12.02704342114 4 15.48683871116 4 17.49889888

120 4 13.29403802115 4 13.75978199117 4 20.3245983295 2 17.34801847119 4 18.41480799117 4 15.17975642117 4 18.13183948116 4 11.32720821120 4 14.31810808348 4 12.14028931114 4 17.59829




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Year ‐ 1: Mean Complete


Year ‐ 1: 98th Complete

Year ‐ 1: Certification

Year ‐ 2: Creditable Count

Y 32.8 Y Y 118Y 29.4 Y Y 117Y 37.5 Y N 120Y 21.8 Y N 348N 16.5 N Y 118Y 45.7 Y Y 116Y 27.6 Y YY 43.2 Y NY 43.5 Y N 101Y 42.1 Y N 117Y 41 Y N 95Y 30.1 Y Y 117Y 34.1 Y N 97Y 36.1 Y N 120Y 38.5 Y N 115Y 31.2 Y Y 117N 11Y 33 Y Y 114Y 39.4 Y N 118N 33.5 N NY 39.4 Y Y 114Y 23.5 Y N 120N 34.2 N NY 38.5 Y Y 117Y 30.8 Y Y 118Y 35.2 Y N 119Y 27.4 Y Y 120Y 24.3 Y Y 117Y 33.8 Y Y 116Y 40.3 Y Y 118Y 42.4 Y Y 108Y 29.3 Y Y 118Y 22.5 Y N 114Y 37.7 Y Y 113Y 44.6 Y N 114NY 30.3 Y Y 110Y 28.6 Y N 116Y 49.2 Y N 66Y 40.2 Y N 40Y 43.3 Y NY 30.9 Y Y 119Y 40.5 Y Y 117Y 21.4 Y N 98Y 30.5 Y Y 120Y 24.4 Y N 120Y 39.6 Y N 119




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Year ‐ 2: Complete Quarters


Year ‐ 2: Substituted Mean

Year ‐ 2: Mean Complete


4 16.65358354 Y 42.14 14.6937069 Y 32.84 14.31810808 Y 30.54 12.14028931 Y 24.44 14.96713994 Y 35.24 17.49889888 Y 44.6

NN

3 24.64659091 Y 43.24 20.32459832 Y 49.22 17.34801847 Y 40.24 18.13183948 Y 40.53 14.92364069 N 33.54 13.29403802 Y 30.34 13.75978199 Y 28.64 14.25229885 Y 29.31 10.83636364 2.70909091 N 16.54 16.7338698 Y 45.74 14.97160714 Y 30.1

N4 15.48683871 Y 37.74 12.05510753 Y 24.3

N4 13.71177896 Y 31.24 16.97468371 Y 38.54 14.38991935 Y 30.84 16.61689562 Y 39.44 14.34172619 Y 38.54 15.54125821 Y 39.44 12.94974548 Y 29.44 17.67384524 Y 414 15.4849277 Y 42.44 14.13657704 Y 27.44 16.01008747 Y 34.14 17.59829 Y 39.6

N4 13.9320291 Y 33.84 16.01356785 Y 36.11 21.1084058 Y 43.51 17.89861111 12.0909091 N 34.2

N4 15.45031106 Y 334 15.17975642 Y 30.94 13.11982407 Y 27.64 16.23595569 Y 40.34 13.98666667 Y 37.54 18.41480799 Y 43.3




Site_ID Number

Parameter Code

Design Value Year


39 145 13 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200539 145 13 88101 200839 145 13 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200954 11 6 88101 200339 87 12 88101 200939 145 13 88101 200039 145 13 88101 200139 145 13 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200721 19 17 88101 200121 19 17 88101 200621 19 17 88101 200839 87 10 88101 200539 87 10 88101 201054 11 6 88101 200454 11 6 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200021 19 17 88101 200321 19 17 88101 201039 87 10 88101 200039 87 10 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200739 87 10 88101 200854 11 6 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200921 19 17 88101 200439 145 13 88101 200639 87 10 88101 200339 87 10 88101 200454 11 6 88101 201021 19 17 88101 200254 11 6 88101 200239 87 12 88101 200821 19 17 88101 200521 19 17 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200239 87 10 88101 200154 11 6 88101 200054 11 6 88101 200554 11 6 88101 200639 87 12 88101 201039 145 13 88101 200739 145 13 88101 200954 11 6 88101 2001


Year ‐ 2: 98th Complete

Year ‐ 2: Certification

Daily Design Value


Annual Design Value


Y N 35 Y 14.8 YY Y 34 Y 14.6 YY Y 31 Y 13.5 YY N 24 Y 11.6 YY N 26 N 12.9 NY N 41 Y 16.6 Y

25 N 12.2 N43 N 22.9 N

Y N 45 Y 22 YY N 41 Y 17.2 YY N 41 Y 16.8 YY Y 37 Y 16.6 YN N 35 N 15.5 YY Y 32 Y 14.4 YY N 30 Y 13.4 YY Y 33 Y 15 YN Y 17 N 10.8 NY Y 37 Y 15.8 YY Y 32 Y 15.2 Y

34 N 15.5 NY Y 37 Y 15 YY Y 25 Y 11.4 Y

37 N 17.6 NY Y 34 Y 15 YY Y 35 Y 15.4 YY Y 28 N 13.4 NY N 30 Y 14.3 YY N 29 Y 12.4 YY Y 35 Y 14.3 YY Y 33 Y 14.5 YY N 38 Y 15.8 YY Y 34 Y 14.5 YY Y 26 Y 13.1 YY N 37 Y 15.7 YY N 43 Y 17.3 Y

28 N 13.1 NY Y 33 Y 14.4 YY N 34 Y 14.7 YY N 45 Y 19.4 YN N 38 Y 17.6 Y

41 N 18 NY Y 35 Y 16.3 YY Y 34 Y 16.1 YY Y 25 Y 12.2 YY Y 36 Y 14.8 YY N 28 Y 12.3 YY N 43 Y 17.8 Y


UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

DESIGN VALUE REPORT

Mar. 29, 2011Report Request ID: 852997 Report Code: AMP480

Selection Criteria Page 1

User ID: ADX

State County CitySite Parameter POC AQCR UAR CBSA CSAEPA

Region Method Duration Begin Date End Date

21

39

39

39

54

019

087

087

145

011

0017

0010

0012

0013

0006

GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS

PROTOCOL SELECTIONS

Parameter

Classification Parameter Method Duration

DESIGN VALUE

SELECTED OPTIONS

USER SITE METADATA

MERGE PDF FILES

QUARTERLY DATA IN WORKFILE

WORKFILE DELIMITER

SINGLE EVENT PROCESSING

Option Type Option Value

STREET ADDRESS

YES

NO

,

INCLUDE EVENTS

GLOBAL DATES

2000

Start Date End Date

2010

Tribal

APPLICABLE STANDARDS

Standard Description

Ozone 8-Hour 2008

PM10 24-hour 2006

PM25 24-hour 2006

PM25 Annual 2006


UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCYAIR QUALITY SYSTEM

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT

Report Date: Mar. 29, 2011

Notes:1. Warning: Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year).2. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ('*').

Page 1 of 66

Pollutant:Standard Units:

.075Level:Ozone 8-Hour 2008NAAQS Standard:Annual 4th MaximumStatistic:

1

Poc

76

ValidDays

31

PercentComplete

.070

4thMax

Y

CertValidDays

PercentComplete

4thMax Cert

ValidDays

PercentComplete

4thMax Cert

10

PercentComplete

.070

DesignValue

N

D. V.Validity

Ozone(44201)Parts per million(007)

Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017

REPORT INCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH EXCEPTIONAL EVENT FLAGS.

Design Value Year: 2001

STREET ADDRESS

2000 1999KentuckyState:

2924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT

2001

*

3 - Year






Page 2 of 66



1

Poc

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.102

4thMax

Y

Cert

76

ValidDays

31

PercentComplete

.070

4thMax

Y

CertValidDays

PercentComplete

4thMax Cert

44

PercentComplete

.086

DesignValue

N

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2002

*

3 - Year






Page 3 of 66



1

Poc

240

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.088

4thMax

Y

Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.102

4thMax

Y

Cert

76

ValidDays

31

PercentComplete

.070

4thMax

Y

Cert

76

PercentComplete

.086

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2003

*

3 - Year






Page 4 of 66



1

Poc

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.068

4thMax

Y

Cert

240

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.088

4thMax

Y

Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.102

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.086

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2004

3 - Year






Page 5 of 66



1

Poc

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.082

4thMax

Y

Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.068

4thMax

Y

Cert

240

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.088

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.079

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2005

3 - Year






Page 6 of 66



1

Poc

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.079

4thMax Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.082

4thMax

Y

Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.068

4thMax

Y

Cert

100

PercentComplete

.076

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2006

3 - Year






Page 7 of 66



1

Poc

244

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.072

4thMax Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.079

4thMax Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.082

4thMax

Y

Cert

100

PercentComplete

.077

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2007

3 - Year






Page 8 of 66



1

Poc

242

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.073

4thMax

Y

Cert

244

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.072

4thMax Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.079

4thMax Cert

99

PercentComplete

.074

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2008

3 - Year






Page 9 of 66



1

Poc

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.066

4thMax Cert

242

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.073

4thMax

Y

Cert

244

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.072

4thMax Cert

99

PercentComplete

.070

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2009

3 - Year






Page 10 of 66



1

Poc

244

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.072

4thMax Cert

245

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.066

4thMax Cert

242

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.073

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.070

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

21-019-0017



STREET ADDRESS



2010

3 - Year






Page 11 of 66



1

Poc

210

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.074

4thMax Cert

ValidDays

PercentComplete

4thMax Cert

ValidDays

PercentComplete

4thMax Cert

33

PercentComplete

.074

DesignValue

N

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

39-087-0012



STREET ADDRESS

2009 2008OhioState:

450 Commerce Drive

2010

3 - Year






Page 12 of 66



1

Poc

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.081

4thMax

Y

Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.096

4thMax

Y

Cert

213

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.105

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.094

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS

1999 1998West VirginiaState:

HUNTINGTON - MARSHALL UNIVERSITY

2000

3 - Year






Page 13 of 66



1

Poc

207

ValidDays

97

PercentComplete

.087

4thMax Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.081

4thMax

Y

Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.096

4thMax

Y

Cert

98

PercentComplete

.088

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2001

3 - Year






Page 14 of 66



1

Poc

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.097

4thMax

Y

Cert

207

ValidDays

97

PercentComplete

.087

4thMax Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.081

4thMax

Y

Cert

98

PercentComplete

.088

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2002

3 - Year






Page 15 of 66



1

Poc

209

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.080

4thMax

Y

Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.097

4thMax

Y

Cert

207

ValidDays

97

PercentComplete

.087

4thMax Cert

98

PercentComplete

.088

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2003

3 - Year






Page 16 of 66



1

Poc

206

ValidDays

96

PercentComplete

.066

4thMax

Y

Cert

209

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.080

4thMax

Y

Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.097

4thMax

Y

Cert

98

PercentComplete

.081

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2004

3 - Year






Page 17 of 66



1

Poc

214

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.082

4thMax

Y

Cert

206

ValidDays

96

PercentComplete

.066

4thMax

Y

Cert

209

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.080

4thMax

Y

Cert

98

PercentComplete

.076

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2005

3 - Year






Page 18 of 66



1

Poc

213

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.081

4thMax

Y

Cert

214

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.082

4thMax

Y

Cert

206

ValidDays

96

PercentComplete

.066

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.076

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2006

3 - Year






Page 19 of 66



1

Poc

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.089

4thMax Cert

213

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.081

4thMax

Y

Cert

214

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.082

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.084

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2007

3 - Year






Page 20 of 66



1

Poc

210

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.070

4thMax Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.089

4thMax Cert

213

ValidDays

100

PercentComplete

.081

4thMax

Y

Cert

99

PercentComplete

.080

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2008

3 - Year






Page 21 of 66



1

Poc

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.061

4thMax Cert

210

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.070

4thMax Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.089

4thMax Cert

98

PercentComplete

.073

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2009

3 - Year






Page 22 of 66



1

Poc

209

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.068

4thMax Cert

211

ValidDays

99

PercentComplete

.061

4thMax Cert

210

ValidDays

98

PercentComplete

.070

4thMax Cert

98

PercentComplete

.066

DesignValue

Y

D. V.Validity


Site ID

|||

|||

|||

|||

54-011-0006



STREET ADDRESS



2010

3 - Year






Page 23 of 66

Pollutant:Standard Units:NAAQS Standard:

Statistic:Statistic:

Site-LevelPM2.5 - Local Conditions(88101)Micrograms/cubic meter (LC)(105)PM25 24-hour 2006 / PM25 Annual 2006Annual Weighted MeanAnnual 98th Percentile

Level:Level:



1535 State Name: Kentucky

Site_ID /STREET ADDRESS

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2000 1999 1998

21-019-00172924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT

113 4 34.1 16.0 N 97 3 33.5* 14.9* N * 34 N 15.5 N






Page 24 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2001 2000 1999


114 4 37.7 15.5 Y 113 4 34.1 16.0 N 97 3 33.5* 14.9* N 35 N 15.5 Y






Page 25 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2002 2001 2000


116 4 39.4 15.5 Y 114 4 37.7 15.5 Y 113 4 34.1 16.0 N 37 Y 15.7 Y






Page 26 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2003 2002 2001


110 4 33.8 13.9 Y 116 4 39.4 15.5 Y 114 4 37.7 15.5 Y 37 Y 15.0 Y






Page 27 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2004 2003 2002


120 4 30.3 13.3 Y 110 4 33.8 13.9 Y 116 4 39.4 15.5 Y 35 Y 14.3 Y






Page 28 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2005 2004 2003


116 4 36.1 16.0 N 120 4 30.3 13.3 Y 110 4 33.8 13.9 Y 33 Y 14.4 Y






Page 29 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2006 2005 2004


115 4 28.6 13.8 N 116 4 36.1 16.0 N 120 4 30.3 13.3 Y 32 Y 14.4 Y






Page 30 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2007 2006 2005


117 4 38.5 14.3 N 115 4 28.6 13.8 N 116 4 36.1 16.0 N 34 Y 14.7 Y






Page 31 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2008 2007 2006


120 4 24.3 12.1 Y 117 4 38.5 14.3 N 115 4 28.6 13.8 N 30 Y 13.4 Y






Page 32 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2009 2008 2007


116 4 23.5 10.9 N 120 4 24.3 12.1 Y 117 4 38.5 14.3 N 29 Y 12.4 Y






Page 33 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2010 2009 2008


119 4 26.2 11.2 N 116 4 23.5 10.9 N 120 4 24.3 12.1 Y 25 Y 11.4 Y






Page 34 of 66




Level:Level:



1535 State Name: Ohio


|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2000 1999 1998

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

95

66

2

1

40.2

43.5

17.3

21.1

N

N

40

101

1

3

34.2

43.2

*

17.9

24.6

*

N

N

*

*

37

43

N

N

17.6

22.9

N

N






Page 35 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2001 2000 1999

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

108

117

4

4

41.0

49.2

17.7

20.3

N

N

95

66

2

1

40.2

43.5

17.3

21.1

N

N

40

101

1

3

34.2

43.2

*

17.9

24.6

*

N

N

38

45

Y

Y

17.6

22.0

Y

Y






Page 36 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2002 2001 2000

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

118

118

4

4

42.4

42.1

15.5

16.7

Y

N

108

117

4

4

41.0

49.2

17.7

20.3

N

N

95

66

2

1

40.2

43.5

17.3

21.1

N

N

41

45

Y

Y

16.8

19.4

Y

Y






Page 37 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2003 2002 2001

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

117

117

4

4

29.3

32.8

14.3

14.7

Y

Y

118

118

4

4

42.4

42.1

15.5

16.7

Y

N

108

117

4

4

41.0

49.2

17.7

20.3

N

N

38

41

Y

Y

15.8

17.2

Y

Y






Page 38 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2004 2003 2002

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

117

118

4

4

31.2

29.4

13.7

12.9

Y

Y

117

117

4

4

29.3

32.8

14.3

14.7

Y

Y

118

118

4

4

42.4

42.1

15.5

16.7

Y

N

34

35

Y

Y

14.5

14.8

Y

Y






Page 39 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2005 2004 2003

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

118

120

4

4

38.5

40.3

17.0

16.2

Y

Y

117

118

4

4

31.2

29.4

13.7

12.9

Y

Y

117

117

4

4

29.3

32.8

14.3

14.7

Y

Y

33

34

Y

Y

15.0

14.6

Y

Y






Page 40 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2006 2005 2004

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

119

120

4

4

30.8

30.5

14.4

14.3

Y

Y

118

120

4

4

38.5

40.3

17.0

16.2

Y

Y

117

118

4

4

31.2

29.4

13.7

12.9

Y

Y

34

33

Y

Y

15.0

14.5

Y

Y






Page 41 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2007 2006 2005

39-087-0010

39-145-00132128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

118

120

4

4

35.2

37.5

15.0

14.0

N

N

119

120

4

4

30.8

30.5

14.4

14.3

Y

Y

118

120

4

4

38.5

40.3

17.0

16.2

Y

Y

35

36

Y

Y

15.4

14.8

Y

Y






Page 42 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2008 2007 2006

39-087-0010

39-087-0012

39-145-0013

2128 S. 9TH

450 Commerce Drive

4862 GALLIA

11

98

348

1

4

4

16.5

27.6

24.4

*

10.8

13.1

12.1

*

Y

Y

N

118

120

4

4

35.2

37.5

15.0

14.0

*

N

N

119

120

4

4

30.8

30.5

14.4

14.3

*

Y

Y

28

28

31

N

N

Y

13.4

13.1

13.5

N

N

Y






Page 43 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2009 2008 2007

39-087-0010

39-087-0012

39-145-0013

2128 S. 9TH

450 Commerce Drive

4862 GALLIA

116

117

4

4

21.4

21.8

11.3

10.9

*

N

N

11

98

348

1

4

4

16.5

27.6

24.4

*

10.8

13.1

12.1

*

Y

Y

N

118

120

4

4

35.2

37.5

15.0

14.0

*

N

N

26

25

28

N

N

Y

12.9

12.2

12.3

N

N

Y






Page 44 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2010 2009 2008

39-087-0010

39-087-0012

39-145-0013

2128 S. 9TH

450 Commerce Drive

4862 GALLIA

117

116

4

4

25.1

24.4

12.1

11.8

*

N

N

116

117

4

4

21.4

21.8

11.3

10.9

*

N

N

11

98

348

1

4

4

16.5

27.6

24.4

*

10.8

13.1

12.1

*

Y

Y

N

17

25

24

N

Y

Y

10.8

12.2

11.6

N

Y

Y






Page 45 of 66




Level:Level:



1535 State Name: West Virginia


|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2000 1999 1998

54-011-0006HUNTINGTON - MARSHALL UNIVERSITY

114 4 39.6 17.6 N 119 4 43.3 18.4 N * 41 N 18.0 N






Page 46 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2001 2000 1999


116 4 44.6 17.5 N 114 4 39.6 17.6 N 119 4 43.3 18.4 N 43 Y 17.8 Y






Page 47 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2002 2001 2000


114 4 45.7 16.7 Y 116 4 44.6 17.5 N 114 4 39.6 17.6 N 43 Y 17.3 Y






Page 48 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2003 2002 2001


119 4 33.0 15.5 Y 114 4 45.7 16.7 Y 116 4 44.6 17.5 N 41 Y 16.6 Y






Page 49 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2004 2003 2002


117 4 30.9 15.2 Y 119 4 33.0 15.5 Y 114 4 45.7 16.7 Y 37 Y 15.8 Y






Page 50 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2005 2004 2003


117 4 40.5 18.1 Y 117 4 30.9 15.2 Y 119 4 33.0 15.5 Y 35 Y 16.3 Y






Page 51 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2006 2005 2004


118 4 30.1 15.0 Y 117 4 40.5 18.1 Y 117 4 30.9 15.2 Y 34 Y 16.1 Y






Page 52 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2007 2006 2005


120 4 39.4 16.6 N 118 4 30.1 15.0 Y 117 4 40.5 18.1 Y 37 Y 16.6 Y






Page 53 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2008 2007 2006


114 4 27.4 14.1 Y 120 4 39.4 16.6 N 118 4 30.1 15.0 Y 32 Y 15.2 Y






Page 54 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2009 2008 2007


111 4 22.5 12.0 N 114 4 27.4 14.1 Y 120 4 39.4 16.6 N 30 Y 14.3 Y






Page 55 of 66




Level:Level:





|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

Wtd.Mean

98thPerctil Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||Cred.Days

Comp.Qrtrs

98thPerctil

Wtd.Mean Cert.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

|||DesignValue

ValidInd.

24-Hour Annual2010 2009 2008


116 4 28.0 13.2 N 111 4 22.5 12.0 N 114 4 27.4 14.1 Y 26 Y 13.1 Y






Page 56 of 66


Statistic:

PM10 Total 0-10um STP(81102) Design Value Year: 2000

Micrograms/cubic meter (25 C)(001)PM10 24-hour 2006Annual Estimated Days > Standard


Level:150 State Name: Ohio

Site ID POC STREET ADDRESS

||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.

||| Estimated Quarter Cert.

|||EstimatedExceedances

ValidityInd.

2000 1999 1998

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

54-011-0006

1

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA


0

0

0

4

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

4

4

3

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

Y

Y

N

*

Count QuarterExceedances

0

0

0

QuarterCountExceedances

0

0

0

Count#CompleteExceedances

0

0

3 - Year






Page 57 of 66


Statistic:




Level:150 State Name: Kentucky


||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2001 2000 1999

21-019-0017

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

54-011-0006

1

1

1

1

2924 HOLT ST, FIVCO HEALTH DEPT2128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA


0

0

0

1

4

4

Y

0

0

0

4

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

4

4

3

Y

Y

0

0

0

0

N

Y

Y

N

*

*


0

0

0


0

0

0


0

0

0

3 - Year






Page 58 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2002 2001 2000

21-019-0017

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

54-011-0006

1

1

1

1


4862 GALLIA


0

0

0

4

4

4

Y

Y

Y

0

0

0

1

4

4

Y

0

0

0

4

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

0

N

Y

Y

N

*


0

0

0


0

0

0


0

0

0

3 - Year






Page 59 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2003 2002 2001

21-019-0017

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

1

1

1


4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

4

4

4

Y

Y

Y

0

0

0

1

4

4

Y 0

0

0

N

Y

Y

*


0

0


0

0

0


0

0

0

3 - Year






Page 60 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2004 2003 2002

21-019-0017

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

1

1

1


4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

4

4

4

Y

Y

Y

0

0

0

N

Y

Y


0

0


0

0


0

0

0

3 - Year






Page 61 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2005 2004 2003

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

Y

Y


0

0


0

0


0

0

3 - Year






Page 62 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2006 2005 2004

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

Y

Y


0

0


0

0


0

0

3 - Year






Page 63 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2007 2006 2005

39-087-0010

39-145-0013

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

Y

Y


0

0


0

0


0

0

3 - Year






Page 64 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2008 2007 2006

39-087-0010

39-087-0012

39-145-0013

1

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

450 Commerce Drive

4862 GALLIA

0

0

0

0

3

4

0

0

4

4

0

0

4

4

Y

Y

0

0

0

N

N

Y

*

*


0

0

0


0

0


0

0

3 - Year






Page 65 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2009 2008 2007

39-087-0010

39-087-0012

39-145-0013

1

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

450 Commerce Drive

4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

0

0

0

0

3

4

0

0

4

4

0

0

0

N

N

Y

*

*


0

0


0

0

0


0

0

3 - Year






Page 66 of 66


Statistic:






||| Estimated

#CompleteCert.

|||Estimated

#CompleteCert.



ValidityInd.

2010 2009 2008

39-087-0010

39-087-0012

39-145-0013

1

1

1

2128 S. 9TH

450 Commerce Drive

4862 GALLIA

0

0

4

4

0

0

4

4

0

0

0

0

3

4

0

0

0

N

N

Y

*

*


0

0


0

0


0

0

0

3 - Year


UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGIONS III, IV, and V

Technical Support Document

EPA’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking For

Approval and Promulgation of Air Quality Plans; Determination of Attainment of the 1997 Fine Particulate Standard

January 2011


2

Technical Support Document

I. INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………...…........3

II. CLEAN AIR ACT REQUIREMENTS FOR FINE PARTICULATE (PM2.5) ATTAINMENT.3

A. PM2.5 Attainment Requirements …………………………………………………….………3 B. Determination of Attainment ……………………………………………………….….........4

III. MONITORING NETWORK ………………………………………….………………..………5 IV. LAWRENCE COUNTY HOSPITAL MONITORING SITE .……………………..…………..6 V. EPA’S ANALYSIS ……………………………….………………………..…………………..6 A. Analysis of Air Quality Data……………………………………………..…………………6

B. Addressing Missing Data……………………………………………………..……………..6 C. Additional Analysis………………………………………………………………..……….14 D. Air Quality in 2010…………………………………………………………………...…….14

VI. CONCLUSION……………………………………………………………………..………….14

APPENDIX A Annual Means for the Huntington-Ashland Area PM2.5 FRM monitors……...………..16


3

I. INTRODUCTION On April 1, 2010, Ohio requested that EPA determine that multiple areas, including the Huntington-Ashland Area, are attaining the 1997 annual fine particulate (PM2.5) National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS). In addition, pursuant to 179(c)(1) of the Clean Air Act, EPA is required to make a determination about the status of this area as of its attainment date. This technical support document specifically addresses the Huntington-Ashland PM2.5 nonattainment area, including portions in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio (hereafter referred to as “the Huntington-Ashland Area” or “the Area”). In this technical support document, EPA provides information supporting: the proposed determination that the Huntington-Ashland Area has attained the 1997 annual PM2.5 NAAQS (hereafter referred to as “the annual PM2.5 NAAQS” or “the standard”) and that the area has attained the 1997 annual PM2.5 NAAQS by its applicable attainment date of April 5, 2010. In this technical support document, EPA:

- summarizes the statutory and policy requirements for PM2.5 nonattainment area SIPs and EPA’s policy concerning attainment.

- provides a description of the air quality monitoring network for the Huntington-Ashland Area PM2.5 nonattainment area

- provides a description of the air quality monitoring network for the Huntington-Ashland Area - describes the Lawrence County Hospital (LCH) monitoring site, and provides an explanation

for monitor shutdown; - describes our detailed analysis of our proposed determination of attainment, including our

analysis of the air quality data, and the methodology used for substituting for missing data; - describes air quality trends in the Huntington-Ashland Area - summarizes our conclusions on the proposed determination of attainment with respect to

EPA requirements. II. CLEAN AIR ACT REQUIREMENTS FOR FINE PARTICLE (PM 2.5) ATTAINMENT A. PM2.5 Attainment Requirements

In 1997, EPA established the health-based NAAQS for PM2.5, setting an annual standard at 15.0 micrograms per cubic meter (ug/m3) based on a 3-year average of annual mean PM2.5 concentrations, and a 24-hour standard of 65 ug/m3 based on a 3-year average of the 98th percentile of 24-hour concentrations. EPA established the standards based on significant evidence and numerous health studies demonstrating that serious health effects are associated with exposures to particulate matter.

On January 5, 2005, (70 FR 944) EPA finalized its air quality designations and classifications across the country with respect to the 1997 PM2.5 standard. These designations became effective on April 5, 2005. The Huntington-Ashland Area was designated nonattainment for the 1997 annual PM2.5 NAAQS (See 40 CFR 81.349 (West Virginia), 40 CFR 81.318 (Kentucky), and 40 CFR 81.336 (Ohio).

These designations triggered the Clean Air Act’s requirements under section 172(c), which


4

requires the submission of an attainment plan for each designated nonattainment area. EPA’s PM2.5 implementation rule, published on April 25, 2007 (72 Fed. Reg. 20586) specifies that states must submit attainment plans for their nonattainment areas to the EPA by no later than three years from the effective date of designation, that is, by April 5, 2008. EPA’s PM2.5 implementation rule outlines the SIP requirements for the attainment plan, which includes among other things, the submission of an attainment demonstration showing the air-quality improvements expected to result from national and local control measures, an analysis of reasonably available control measures (RACM), including all reasonably available control technology (RACT), reasonable further progress plan, and contingency measures. EPA’s implementation rule also sets the attainment date in these areas as April 5, 2010, and the determination would be based on data from 2007-2009 (72 FR 20600).

The states of West Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio, are subject to these requirements since several

counties in the states are located in a PM2.5 nonattainment area. The Huntington-Ashland Area is composed of some or all of the following counties in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio: Cabell, Mason (part) and Wayne Counties in West Virginia; Boyd and Lawrence (part) Counties in Kentucky; and Adams (part), Gallia (part), Lawrence, and Scioto Counties in Ohio.

B. Determination of Attainment

Under EPA regulations at 40 CFR 50.7, the annual primary and secondary PM2.5 standards are met when the annual arithmetic mean concentration, as determined in accordance with 40 CFR part 50, Appendix N, is less than or equal to 15.0 ug/m3. Data handling conventions and computations necessary for determining whether areas have met the PM2.5 NAAQS, including requirements for data completeness, are listed in Appendix N of 40 CFR Part 50. A year meets data completeness requirements when at least 75 percent of the scheduled sampling days for each quarter have valid data. The use of less than complete data is subject to the approval of EPA, which may consider factors such as monitoring site closures/moves, monitoring diligence, and nearby concentrations in determining whether to use such data. If this proposed determination of attainment is made final, EPA will have met its statutory obligation pursuant to section 179(c)(1) of the Clean Air Act (CAA) to make a determination based on the Area’s air quality data as of the attainment date whether the area attained the standard by that date. Additionally, as a result of such determination, the requirements for Kentucky, Ohio or West Virginia to submit an attainment demonstration and associated RACM, a RFP plan, contingency measures, and any other planning SIPs related to attainment of the 1997 annual PM2.5 NAAQS within the Huntington-Ashland Area would be suspended until such time as: a) the area is redesignated to attainment, at which time the requirements would no longer apply; or, b) EPA determines that the area has violated the annual PM2.5 NAAQS, at which time, the area would be required to submit such plans. See 40 CFR 51.1004(c). A determination of attainment does not shield an area from other required actions such as New Source Review (NSR), conformity and emission inventory requirements, and provisions to address pollution transport, which would require emission reductions at sources or other types of emission


5

activities contributing significantly to nonattainment in other areas or states, or interfering with maintenance in those areas.

Determinations as to whether individual areas have attained the PM2.5 standards and thus qualify for the application of a determination of attainment are being made in the context of rulemakings for individual areas. This Technical Support Document (TSD) provides an explanation of EPA’s analysis used to determine whether the Huntington-Ashland Area has attained the annual PM2.5 standard by the applicable attainment date.

III. MONITORING NETWORK

The Huntington-Ashland Area currently has three air monitoring locations; one each in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio. West Virginia also has a collocated monitor in place at the site for quality assurance purposes. The primary monitor, and not the collocated monitor, is used to determine compliance with the PM2.5 NAAQS. Since the collocated quality assurance monitor takes many fewer readings than the primary monitor, its average annual values may be unrepresentatively high even if only a few high values are recorded. (See 40 CFR Part 50, Appendix N, 3(d)(1). Two monitoring locations for Ohio are listed in Table 1 due to the LCH monitor shut-down and Ironton DOT start-up during the 2007-2009 time period. Table 1 shows the monitor design values (DVs) (i.e., the 3-year average of annual mean PM2.5 concentrations) for the years 2007-2009. The area DV is the highest annual mean measured for a federal reference method (FRM) monitor that had complete data in a county.

Table 1.— 2007-2009 Design Values for the 1997 Annual PM2.5 NAAQS for the Huntington-Ashland Area Monitors in

Micrograms per Cubic Meter (ug/m3).

Site Name County Site Number Annual Average Concentration

(μg/m3) Huntington Cabell 54-011-0006 14.31

Ashland Primary (FIVCO) Boyd 21-019-0017 12.4

Lawrence County Hospital Lawrence 39-087-0010 13.32

1 West Virginia has a collocated monitor in place at the same site for quality assurance purposes. The primary monitor, and not the collocated monitor, is used to determine compliance with the PM2.5 NAAQS. Since the collocated monitor takes fewer readings than the primary monitor, its average annual values may be unrepresentatively high. See 40 CFR Part 50, Appendix N, 3(d)(1). 2 Data from the Lawrence County Hospital and Ironton DOT sites were incomplete due to shut-down of the Lawrence County Hospital site and startup of the Ironton DOT site in February 2008.


6

Ironton DOT Lawrence 39-087-0012 12.23

EPA meets annually with each state to discuss any problems or issues concerning states’ air

monitoring data and/or network. In addition, EPA and the states communicate many times during the year so that issues can be addressed as they show up. EPA regulations require states to submit annual network plans to their respective Regions. These plans outline the current networks and any proposed changes in the upcoming 18 months. Regions 3, 4, and 5 have been able to approve these plans due to the quality of the West Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio monitoring networks.

IV. LAWRENCE COUNTY HOSPITAL MONITORING SITE

The LCH monitor operated until February 11, 2008, when monitoring was discontinued permanently at the site due to the building demolition. Because the monitor at this location could not be replaced, a new site in this county was established at the Ironton DOT starting when monitoring at the LCH ended. As a result, the Ironton DOT monitor did not obtain any data for 2007 and did not obtain complete data for the first quarter of 2008. Nevertheless, the available data for the remainder of 2008 and all of 2009 indicate attainment at this monitor. As discussed in greater detail below, the monitors in Lawrence County were the only monitors in the Huntington-Ashland Area without valid attaining DVs for 2007-2009 due to incomplete data. This monitor historically measured lower concentrations than other monitors in the Area, including, for example, the monitor in Cabell County, West Virginia.

V. EPA’S ANALYSIS A. Analysis of Air Quality Data EPA has reviewed the ambient air monitoring data for PM2.5, consistent with the requirements contained in 40 CFR part 50 and recorded in the EPA Air Quality System database for the Huntington-Ashland Area from 2007 through the present time. Currently all monitors are measuring concentrations averaging well below the annual standard of 15.0 ug/m3. The highest DV for the most recent 3 years, 2007-2009, for the Huntington-Ashland Area is 14.3 ug/m3, based on monitoring data collected in West Virginia at the Huntington monitor. All 3-year averages of the annual mean PM2.5 concentrations are below the NAAQS from 2007-2009. In order to determine whether the NAAQS has been attained for the LCH monitor, EPA has applied a recently developed procedure to address the missing data, and determine valid DVs for the monitor for the annual standard for 2007-2009. EPA’s procedure is described in the following section. 3 The Lawrence County Hospital Site was shut-down in February 2008. The Ironton DOT site began operation in 2008 after the Lawrence County Hospital Site ceased monitoring.


7

B. Addressing Missing Data

Additional analysis was necessary for the LCH monitor (site number 39-087-0010) because this monitor is no longer operating (due to building demolition) but recorded a violation in the most recent three year period in which it collected complete data. An objective statistical method was used to determine if this monitor would likely have met the NAAQS in subsequent time periods.

The general concept behind the statistical method is to establish a linear regression relationship between the monitor of interest and another “comparison monitor” in the nonattainment area based on data obtained when the monitor of interest was still operating. The method then estimates concentrations at the monitor of interest for the period after monitor shutdown by applying a linear regression to the more recently observed concentrations at the other monitor. The results are checked with an additional statistical technique, known as bootstrapping, to verify if the conclusion of attainment is correct.

The monitor of interest in this analysis is the LCH monitor. This site ceased monitoring in

February 2008 and had an incomplete DV of 12.9 µg/m3 for 2007-2008. The goal of this methodology is to appropriately fill in the missing data from the quarters 1-4 of 2008, and quarters 1-4 of 2009 to judge whether this location would likely have monitored attainment of the NAAQS had the monitor continued to operate. The Huntington-Ashland Area has two monitoring locations with complete data for 2007-2009, listed in Table 1 above, both of which are similar enough to warrant comparison to the LCH monitor. Criteria to be met

EPA established criteria to assure that the DV for the LCH monitor in the Huntington-Ashland Area, as estimated by the method, was robust enough to allow consideration of the results in a weight of evidence decision. EPA established criteria both for the operating period of the comparison monitor and for the number of days of samples that the comparison monitor and the LCH monitor have in common. EPA has not established bright lines or specific requirements for determining DVs for monitors with less than complete data. Operating period

In order to provide satisfactory concentration estimates for the LCH monitor for the period after the monitor shut down, comparison monitors in the Huntington-Ashland Area would need to have operated from well before from February 2008 to the end of 2009. Operation for a substantial period before February 2008 is necessary to support a robust regression relationship with concentrations at the LCH monitor, and operation from February 2008 to the end of 2009 is necessary to support concentration estimates for this period. Paired samples

Pairs of sample data for the LCH monitor and comparison monitors from the most recent 20-quarter period of operation of the LCH monitor were used. Comparison monitors were required to have


8

at least 100 historical sample pairs in common with the target monitor during this period. When there were more than 100 pairs in the 20-quarter period, all available pairs were used. In addition to the 100 pairs over the 20-quarters, comparison monitors were required to have at least 20 paired days of data in common with the LCH monitor for each quarter (adding together the number of days in a given calendar quarter [Q1, Q2, Q3, or Q4] across the various years in the 20-quarter period).

Both comparison monitors, Ashland Primary and Huntington, met the eligibility criteria of 100 pairs over the 20-quarters, and at least 20 paired days of data in common with the LCH monitor for each calendar quarter. Method for determining DVs Step 1 – Organize data and perform linear regression(s) between the LCH monitor and the comparison monitors.

For both the Ashland Primary and the Huntington monitors, all the available paired data within the 5-year period described above were used to develop a linear regression expressing concentrations at the LCH monitor in relation to concentrations at the comparison monitor. Step 2 – Select candidate monitor

The Huntington-Ashland Area has 2 monitors which could have been used as comparison monitors, Ashland Primary and the Huntington. The following steps were used to select the comparison monitor. 1) Comparison monitors were placed into order of highest correlation (highest r-squared in the linear regression) of concentrations with concentrations at the LCH monitor. The comparison monitor showing the highest correlation of concentrations with concentrations at the LCH monitor was used first. 2) Using the regression equation relating concentrations at the LCH monitor and the comparison monitor, estimates of the 24-hour average concentrations at the LCH monitor were made for each day after this monitor was shut down that the monitor otherwise would have been scheduled to measure concentrations, except that no estimate was made if the comparison monitor had no valid measurement. The estimates were combined with any reported data at the LCH monitor in the recent 3-year period and the data capture rates were computed for each originally incomplete quarter. 3) If performing the process in #2 results in all 12 quarters at the LCH monitor having at least 75 percent of scheduled values, the comparison monitor was selected for use in the remaining steps. If 75 percent of the scheduled values for the LCH monitor were not obtained, the steps in #2 were repeated for the next best correlated comparison monitor. This process was repeated until the LCH monitor had at least 75 percent of the number of values expected under its original operating schedule. Step 3 – DV Computed


9

The 3-year DV was calculated using the actual observations at the LCH monitor and the regression-based estimates of daily concentrations. The resulting DV for the LCH monitor was 13.3 µg/m3, which is below the annual PM2.5 NAAQS. Step 4 –Statistical confidence of a DV below the NAAQS checked

In order to show that there is a minimal probability that the actual DV (had the LCH monitor operated more days) was above the annual PM2.5 NAAQS, further analysis was performed as follows:

(a) Residuals were calculated from the regression. (b) A bootstrap analysis was performed, repeating the regression-based substitution in Step 2

but adding to each estimated 24-hour value that substitutes for a missing scheduled monitored value a plus or minus residual that has been randomly drawn (with replacement) from the pool of regression residuals. This step randomly applies real residuals from the linear regression to the imputed current-period target values.

(c) Repeat (b) for a total of 1000 runs. (d) For each of the 1000 bootstrap trials, the 3-year DV was calculated. This provides a

pseudo confidence interval for the partially imputed current-period DV for the target. (e) Since none of the 1000 runs resulted in a DV above the annual PM2.5 NAAQS, the LCH

monitor was considered to have met the annual PM2.5 NAAQS. Determining the DV for Lawrence County Hospital (AQS ID: 39-087-0010)

The analysis described above was performed to estimate concentrations at the LCH monitor. The results of the regressions can be found in Table 2. The LCH monitor is identified in this table as Site A. The comparison monitors in this table are all identified in this table as Site B. The Ashland Primary monitor (AQS ID: 21-019-0017) had the highest correlation with the LCH monitor and met the operating period and paired data eligibility criteria for being the comparison monitor. The results of the regression between the LCH monitor and the Ashland Primary monitor are shown in Figure 1. Estimates for the missing data for quarters 1 thru 4 of 2008 and for quarters 1 thru 4 of 2009 for the LCH monitor were made. These quarters were the quarters with less than 75 percent data capture. As a result of filling in the missing data, the LCH monitor now had 32, 30, 31, 30 values for quarters 1 thru 4 for 2008, respectively, and 30, 30, 27, 31 values for quarters 1 thru 4 of 2009, respectively. A DV of 13.3 μg/m3 was calculated for the LCH monitor when the missing data was filled in, as shown in Figure 2.

The statistical confidence of the DV was checked using the method outlined in Step 4 above. The results of the 1000 bootstrap trials provided the following results: 243 DVs) of 13.2 µg/m3, 223 DVs of 13.3 µg/m3, 177 DVs of 13.1 µg/m3, 157 DVs of 13.4 µg/m3, 81 DVs of 13.0 µg/m3, 61 DVs of 13.5 µg/m3, 21 DVs of 13.6 µg/m3, 19 DVs of 12.9 µg/m3, 8 DVs of 13.7 µg/m3, 6 DVs of 12.8 µg/m3, 2 DVs of 12.7 µg/m3, and 2 DVs of 13.8 µg/m3. None of the 1000 bootstrapping trials resulted in a violating DV, which provides statistical confidence that the air quality at the LCH monitor is below the annual PM2.5 NAAQS.


10


2007 Q1 2007 Q2 2007 Q3 2007 Q4 2008 Q1 2008 Q2 2008 Q3 2008 Q4 2009 Q1 2009 Q2 2009 Q3 2009 Q4390870010 93% 100% 100% 97% 35%210190017 93% 97% 97% 100% 94% 100% 100% 100% 97% 97% 90% 97%540110006 100% 97% 100% 100% 87% 93% 94% 100% 97% 84% 90% 94%391450013 100% 100% 97% 100% 100% 97% 87% 97% 97% 94% 97% 97%

Site BQuarterly Data Capture, 2007-2009

npairsQ1 npairsQ2 npairsQ3 npairsQ4 corr

Huntington 390870010 390870010 12.9 inc-a 12.9 inc-a 128 146 151 146 1Huntington 390870010 210190017 12.4 A 12.4 A 119 131 145 141 0.86384Huntington 390870010 540110006 14.3 A 14.3 A 124 145 148 137 0.855279Huntington 390870010 391450013 12.3 A 12.3 A 128 143 149 144 0.833266

DV status Site A

DV Site B

DV status Site B

20-quarter look (2003-Q2 - 2008-Q1)

Area Site A Site B DV Site A

Table 2. Correlation and data capture for monitors used to determine a DV for Lawrence County Hospital site.


v_a

0

10

20

30

40

50

v_b

0 10 20 30 40 50

Figure 1 Concentrations at Lawrence County Hospital (site 390870010, labeled “v_a”) compared to concentrations at Ashland (site 210190017, labeled “v_b”).

The linear relationship between the two monitors is: Concentration at Lawrence County Hospital = 2.293135 + 0.882184 * concentration at Ashland. The correlation coefficient was 0.86384.


13

Figure 2. Results for Lawrence County Hospital site after filling in missing data for all quarters of 2008, and all quarters of 2009


14

C. Additional Analysis Additional statistical analysis was performed for the LCH monitor using a different comparison monitor. EPA re-ran the analysis using data from the Huntington monitor (site number 54-011-0006), a monitor that is similarly correlated with the LCH monitor as the Ashland Primary monitor. The results of the analysis using the Huntington monitor as the comparison monitor produced an estimated 2007-2009 DV at the LCH of 13.1 µg/m3, which is also below the NAAQS of 15.0 ug/m3. That is, the concentration estimates provided by the method described herein indicate a DV at LCH that is below the annual PM2.5 NAAQS, regardless of which area monitor is used as the basis for the estimates. D. Air Quality in 2010

The states have submitted monitoring data for 2010. EPA examined 2008 to 2010 data as an indication of whether the area continues to attain the standard. Table 3 shows the average concentration at each of the sites in the Huntington-Ashland Area. All sites have average concentrations well below the standard, with average values ranging from 12.2 to 13.1 µg/m3. Therefore, EPA believes that 2008 to 2010 data, interpreted in conjunction with data from 2007 to 2009, supports a determination that the Huntington-Ashland Area is attaining the annual PM2.5 NAAQS.

Table 3.— 20008- 2010 annual average PM2.5 concentrations for the Huntington-Ashland Area monitors in micrograms per

cubic meter (ug/m3).

Site Name County Site Number Annual Average Concentration

(μg/m3) Huntington4 Cabell 54-011-0006 13.1

Ashland Primary (FIVCO) Boyd 21-019-0017 11.4

Ironton DOT Lawrence 39-087-0012 12.2

VI. CONCLUSION EPA is proposing to determine that the Huntington-Ashland Area has attained the annual 1997 PM2.5 NAAQS by its attainment date of April 5, 2010. 4 West Virginia has a collocated monitor in place at the same site for quality assurance purposes. The primary monitor, and not the collocated monitor, is used to determine compliance with the PM2.5 NAAQS. Since the collocated monitor takes fewer readings than the primary monitor, its average annual values may be unrepresentatively high. See 40 CFR Part 50, Appendix N, 3(d)(1).


15

EPA has reviewed the ambient air monitoring data for PM2.5, consistent with the requirements contained in 40 CFR part 50 and recorded in the EPA Air Quality System database for the Huntington-Ashland Area. The 3-year averages of the annual mean PM2.5 concentrations continue to be below the NAAQS of 15.0 ug/m3. EPA has concluded that use of less than complete data from the LCH monitoring site is warranted for determining attainment of the NAAQS. The States of West Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio have been diligent in the number and placement of PM2.5 monitors in the nonattainment area. The monitor at LCH was shut down due to a planned building demolition and could not be replaced. In light of such facts, EPA employed a procedure using a statistical method to estimate concentrations at the LCH monitor for the remainder of the time period at issue; and, the resulting analysis supports a finding of attainment of the annual PM2.5 NAAQS at this location. As provided in 40 CFR 51.1004(c), if EPA finalizes this determination, it would suspend the requirements for this area to submit attainment demonstrations, reasonably available control measures, reasonable further progress plans, and contingency measures related to attainment of the 1997 annual PM2.5 NAAQS so long as the Area continues to attain the 1997 annual PM2.5 NAAQS.


16

Appendix A

Annual Means for the Huntington-Ashland Area PM2.5 FRM monitors


Kentucky Boyd 210190017 15.1 NA 15.5 NA 14.9 A 14.3 A 14.4 A 14.4 A 14.7 A 13.4 A 12.4 AOhio Lawrence 390870010 17.6 NA 16.8 NA 15.8 NA 14.5 A 15.0 A 15.0 A 15.4 NA 13.4 inc-a 12.9 inc-aOhio Lawrence 390870012 13.1 inc-a 12.2 inc-aOhio Scioto 391450013 22.0 NA 19.4 NA 17.2 NA 14.8 A 14.6 A 14.5 A 14.8 A 13.5 A 12.3 AWest Virginia Cabell 540110006 17.8 NA 17.3 NA 16.6 NA 15.8 NA 16.3 NA 16.1 NA 16.6 NA 15.2 NA 14.3 A

2003-2005 2004-2006 2005-2007 2006-2008Annual Design Values

2007-2009state_name county_name 2002-20042000-2002 2001-2003site 1999-2001
