Laboratoire Roberval UMR 7337 UTC-CNRS http://roberval.utc.fr 10.11.2016 AP242 and JT Standards Assessment: a focus on management of GD&T and PMI Julien Le Duigou, Alexandre Durupt and Benoît Eynard
Laboratoire Roberval
UMR 7337 UTC-CNRS
http://roberval.utc.fr
10.11.2016
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment: a focus on management of GD&T and PMI
Julien Le Duigou, Alexandre Durupt and Benoît Eynard
Foreword
2
Currently General Chairman of AIP-PRIMECA : Division of the French Society of Mechanical Engineering on Factories of the Future – integrated design and advanced manufacturing
From 2007 to 2012: Full Professor at the Université de Technologie de Compiègne and Dean of the Department of Mechanical Systems Engineering
From 1999 to 2007: Assistant Professor in charge of the MSc program on Information Technology for Mechanical Engineering (CAx, PDM, PLM, ERP)
1999 PhD on Computer Integrated Manufacturing at the University of Bordeaux
Recognized academic expert in the field of product lifecycle management, collaborative design, systems engineering, mechatronic design, digital factory, lean management, eco-design and sustainable manufacturing
Expert on the above mentioned fields for AFNOR, AIF, ANR, IFIP WG 5.1 and cooperation with numerous industrial partners
Outlines
3
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment:
• New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
• Standards Review: AP242 and JT
• Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
• Main Results
• Synthesis and main outcomes
Outlines
4
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment:
• New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
• Standards Review: AP242 and JT
• Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
• Main Results
• Synthesis and main outcomes
New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
5
Global and Extended Enterpise
Manufacturing Processes
Products
… …
…
…
…
…
Design Manufacture Use Disposal
Design Manufacture Use Disposal
Design Manufacture Use Disposal
Main concepts of Product Lifecycle Management
6
(Le Duigou, 2011)
Main concepts of Product Lifecycle Management
7
(Kibamba, 2011)
Main concepts of Product Lifecycle Management
8
(Danjou, 2015)
Main concepts of Product Lifecycle Management
9
J.-Y. Delaunay, « background and use of STEP AP 242 in the European Aerospace and Defense Industries», 2014
Outlines
10
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment:
• New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
• Standards Review: AP242 and JT
• Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
• Main Results
• Synthesis and main outcomes
Standards Review: AP242 and JT
11
• First choice has been done – to be in the ISO context
• Second choice - work in Model BasedDefinition (3D) context
• Assess the geometric definition
• And also the GD&T and PMI
Standards Review: AP242 and JT
12
Standards Review: AP242 and JT
13
ISO 14306 - ISO JT for Visualization
(Pfouga & Stjepandić, 2015)
Standards Review: AP242 and JT
14
Integration in 3D models of GD&T and PMI according to contributions of ASME Y14.5 or UNM / GPS at ISO level
Standards Review: AP242 and JT
15
Integration in 3D models of GD&T and PMI according to contributions of ASME Y14.5 or UNM / GPS at ISO level
Outlines
15
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment:
• New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
• Standards Review: AP242 and JT
• Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
• Main Results
• Synthesis and main outcomes
Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
17
LegacyFormat
AP242
JT
Analysis principles :- viewers- browsers
Part based on geometric features
CAD: Catia V5, Creo, NX Translators: CoreTech., DatakitToolkits: JT2Go, OCC viewer,STEPfileAnalyzer, WinMerge
Part based on NURBS Assembly
Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
18
LegacyFormat
AP242
JT
LegacyFormat
AP242
JT
LegacyFormat
AP242
JT
Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
19
Overview of assessment protocols regarding use cases vs legacy CAD vs AP242 / JT
Outlines
19
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment:
• New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
• Standards Review: AP242 and JT
• Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
• Main Results
• Synthesis and main outcomes
Main Results
21
1) Translated geometric definition are globally OK with Validation Properties check
Main Results
22
1) Translated geometric definitions are globally OK with Validation Properties check
Main Results
23
1) Translated geometric definitions are globally OK with Validation Properties check
Main Results
24
2) Translated PMI specifications are
MODERATELY SATISFACTORY
Main Results
25
2) Translated PMI specifications are
MODERATELY SATISFACTORY
Main Results
26
2) Translated PMI specifications are
MODERATELY SATISFACTORY
Outlines
27
AP242 and JT Standards Assessment:
• New PLM Challenges in the Digital Transformation
• Standards Review: AP242 and JT
• Assessment Protocols and Use Cases Definition
• Main Results
• Synthesis and main outcomes
Conclusions
28
• GOOD results on geometric definition on AP242 and JT
…some troubles on assembly but it sounds it is a question of mistake in using translators than wrong definition in the
standards
• More DIFFICULTIES in translating PMI on JT then AP242 …
…clarifying semantic representations and graphical presentations
Future Work
29
• More use cases, more criteria, more translators or direct translator in CAD systems!
• Method without toolkit for browsing and processing of JT binary files
• Question still open on exact geometric definition vs tessellated definitionvs large model rendering, and on associativity between PMI withgeometry (exact or tessellated)
The role of MBD and 3D Models as unquestionnalable backbone Digital Transformation of company?
Bibliography
30
Danjou Ch., Le Duigou J., Eynard B., Manufacturing Knowledge Management based on STEP-NC standard: a Closed-Loop Manufacturing Approach, International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing, in pressEynard B., Bosch-Mauchand M., Integrated Design and Smart Manufacturing, Concurrent Engineering: Research and Applications, vol. 23, n° 4, pp. 281-283, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1063293X15607367Danjou Ch., Le Duigou J., Eynard B., Closed-Loop Manufacturing process based on STEP-NC, International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12008-015-0268-1 Sriti M.F., Assouroko I., Ducellier G., Boutinaud Ph., Eynard B., Ontology-based approach for product information exchange, International Journal of Product Lifecycle Management, vol. 8, n° 1, pp. 1-23, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1504/IJPLM.2015.068011 Assouroko I., Troussier N., Ducellier G., Eynard B., Boutinaud Ph., Survey on standards for product data exchange and sharing: application in CAD/CAE interoperability, International Journal of Design and Innovation Research, vol. 5, n°10, pp. 9-15, 2010 Belkadi F., Troussier N., Eynard B., Bonjour E., Collaboration based on Product Lifecycles Interoperability for Extended Enterprise, International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing, vol. 4, n° 3, pp. 169 -179, 2010, http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12008-010-0099-z
Thanks for your attention