Smart Grid: Smart Grid: Overview of Relevant Overview of Relevant EMC/Electromagnetic Environment, Spectrum, EMC/Electromagnetic Environment, Spectrum, and Security Issues and Standards Development and Security Issues and Standards Development Activities Activities Andrew L. Drozd, iNCE & IEEE Fellow Andrew L. Drozd, iNCE & IEEE Fellow EMC Society Standards Development EMC Society Standards Development Committee Chair Committee Chair ANDRO Computational Solutions, LLC ANDRO Computational Solutions, LLC President/CEO President/CEO Smart Grid EMC Workshop Smart Grid EMC Workshop Santa Clara, CA Santa Clara, CA 27 May 2010 27 May 2010 ANDRO
35
Embed
Andrew L. Drozd, iNCE & IEEE Fellow EMC Society Standards Development Committee Chair
Smart Grid: Overview of Relevant EMC/Electromagnetic Environment, Spectrum, and Security Issues and Standards Development Activities. Andrew L. Drozd, iNCE & IEEE Fellow EMC Society Standards Development Committee Chair ANDRO Computational Solutions, LLC President/CEO Smart Grid EMC Workshop - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Smart Grid:Smart Grid: Overview of Relevant Overview of Relevant EMC/Electromagnetic Environment, Spectrum, and EMC/Electromagnetic Environment, Spectrum, and
Security Issues and Standards Development ActivitiesSecurity Issues and Standards Development Activities
Andrew L. Drozd, iNCE & IEEE FellowAndrew L. Drozd, iNCE & IEEE FellowEMC Society Standards Development Committee ChairEMC Society Standards Development Committee ChairANDRO Computational Solutions, LLC President/CEOANDRO Computational Solutions, LLC President/CEO
• This presentation will cover the key aspects of the Smart Grid "systems of systems" concept design, specifically:– Relevant EMC/electromagnetic (EM) environments for Smart Grid
operation
– Efforts by the IEEE EMC Society and its Standards Development Committee (SDCom) in cooperation with the IEEE P2030 Working Group and in collaboration with industry to define the scope and application of standards to address integrated EM effects
– Illustrations of spectrum sensing and network (cyber) security strategies and potential risks that must be addressed early on in the design cycle.
• Goal: raise awareness of the key EM environment issues and potential impacts in support of an international rollout of the Smart Grid system.
Unique Challenges
• Smart Grid:– A confluence of power and energy, communications, IT, EMC, reliability and
cyber security technologies.• Two things make electricity unique and a challenge for Smart Grid:
– Lack of flow control (Grid Management and control transformation is needed – i.e., communications!)
– Electricity storage requirements (static or dynamic storage and load optimization/power electronics – efficiency!)
– Change either of these and the grid delivery system will be transformed!• NIST specifications
– Prioritization and application• IEEE P2030 Working Group
– Development of guidelines for future Smart Grid technologies and interoperability.
Systems of Systems Interoperability
Smart Grid System Interoperability
Power
Comm IT
Power
Comm IT
Power
Comm IT
Power
Comm IT
Smart Grid Device Interoperability
Source : Xcel and GridPoint
Grid Modernization
• A smart grid has the following characteristics: – Self-healing (fault tolerant)– Active participation by consumers in demand response– Operates resiliently against physical / cyber attack– High power quality– Accommodates all generation and storage options– Enables new applications– Operates efficiently.
• The most important aspect of the modern grid:– Seamlessly integrate many types of generation and storage
systems with a simplified interconnection process.
Grid Modernization
Today’s Electricity …
Power park
Hydrogen Storage
Industrial DG
Tomorrow’s Choices …
Combined Heat and Power
Fuel Cell
e -
e -
Wind Farms
Rooftop Photovoltaics
Remote Loads
Load as a resource
SMES
Smart Substation
Fuel Cell
Multi-Phase Program
• NIST developed a three-phase plan to accelerate the identification of standards and the establishment of testing & certification procedures.
• In Phase 1 establish a high-level reference model for the Smart Grid:– Nearly 80 existing standards identified to support Smart Grid
development– 14 high-priority gaps identified, including cyber security– Documented action plans with aggressive timelines by which
designated Standards Development Organizations (SDOs) are tasked to fill these gaps.
– More than 20 EMC-related standards identified (TF-3 External Standards Committee)
Smart Grid Principle
• Smart Grid technologies better identify and respond to man-made or natural disruptions:– Real-time information enables grid operators to isolate affected areas and redirect
power flows around damaged facilities.– One of the most important issues is resistance to attack
• Achieved through “smart monitoring” of power grids• The basis of control and management of smart grids is to avoid or mitigate the system-
wide disruptions like blackouts.
• The project is bringing together and attempting to harmonize a number of disparate engineering disciplines, namely:– The markets of power and energy distribution– Radio frequency (RF) communications– Information technology (IT)– Cyber security– Reliability– Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC)– Spectrum management.
Integrated Disciplines
Photovoltaic systems
Central GeneratingStation
Step-Up Transformer
DistributionSubstation
ReceivingStation
DistributionSubstation
DistributionSubstation
Commercial
Industrial Commercial
Gas Turbine
DieselEngine
Cogeneration
CogenerationTurbine
Fuel cell
Micro-turbine
Wind Power
Residential
Storage
1.Power System Infrastructure
Control Center
Operators,Planners & Engineers
2. Communications and Information Infrastructure
NIST Framework
*Baseline standards identified – along with consideration of extensions and gaps (e.g., IEEE 1547 Standard for Interconnecting Distributed Resources
with Electric Power Systems) and IEEE P2030 Smart Grid interoperability standards development identified in NIST report.
Cognitive Sensors/Networks
• Spectrum Sensing: Detection of white-spaces
– Multi-dimensional (beyond frequency)
• Spectrum Management:
– Capturing the best available spectrum to meet user requirements
– Providing fair scheduling among coexisting CRs.
• Spectrum Mobility: Maintaining smooth handoffs while transitioning from one TH cell to another.
Space
Frequency
Others…
Distributed Spectrum Sensing
• Spectrum Sensing, i.e., detect the spectrum holes:– Hidden Terminal Problem: What if the primary user’s signal deteriorates at the
• Resist attack to man-made or natural disruptions– Real-time information enables grid operators to isolate affected areas and
redirect power flows around damaged facilities.– Smart monitoring of power grids to avoid or mitigate the system-wide
disruptions like blackouts.– Traditional monitoring is based on weighted least square (WLS) which is
very weak and prone to fail when gross errors (including topology errors, measurement errors or parameter errors) are present.
– New technology of state monitor is needed to achieve the goals of the smart grids.
• Cyber attack– Protect industrial supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA)
systems and secure their interfaces to the power grid.
• High-quality power– Assuring more stable power provided by smart grid technologies will
reduce downtime and prevent such high losses.
EMC for Smart Grid
EMC is an important factor for consideration in standards relating to the Smart Grid, including the work on IEEE P2030. For the Smart Grid to function properly and coexist with other electrical and electronic systems, it must be designed with due consideration for electromagnetic emissions from the grid and for immunity to various electromagnetic phenomena near or from the grid. EMC must be addressed effectively if the Smart Grid is to achieve its potential and provide its benefits when deployed.
Haddam Neck, CT 1997Halon gas release caused by a camera flash.
Interoperability Means EMC
• The situation:
– IEEE – EMC Society believes that for the Smart Grid to achieve its potential it must be reliable, secure and fault-tolerant.
– If the Smart Grid is less reliable, less secure or less resistant to faults than the existing grid, is it ready for deployment?
– EMC is the ability of equipment to withstand its EM environment while not causing disturbances.
– These EM disturbances from or to the power grid have caused degradation, outages, shutdowns and system failures.
– EMC is required for grid components / controls to operate or interoperate reliably.
Southern Illinois 9/25/01Relaying shutdown caused by a radio.
Broad Categories of EMC Events
Indian Point, New York 3/23/08Cooling shutdown caused by a camera.
• Common events (ESD, fast transients, power line disturbances)• RF Interference from various emitters/transmitters• Coexistence of various wireless devices• High-level EM disturbances
– Naturally-occurring lightning surges or geomagnetic storms– Intentional EMI (terrorist acts) or High-altitude Electromagnetic Pulse
(HEMP)
Smart Grid should be immune to these events, or if that immunity fails, fault-tolerant so failures don’t lead to system disruption. Signals should not interfere with others. (control of emissions).
Commonly Occurring EMC Events
• Unintended emissions can cause harmful interference.
• Limits on emissions are critical for interoperability.
• Emissions limits & methods exist and should be used.
• Immunity to EM phenomena must be demonstrated.
• Variety of environments:
– Information Technology Equipment to IEC/CISPR 24
– Substation equipment to IEC 60255-26, 61000-6-5, IEEE 1613
– Wireless devices to various IEEE / IEC Standards.
• Inadequate immunity to interference causes failures.
• EM phenomena that can cause upset:– Electrostatic discharge (from humans or furniture)– Electrical Fast Transients (from switching operations)– Lightning strike (surge, both unipolar and oscillatory)– Radiated RF energy– Conducted RF energy– Power-frequency magnetic fields– Dips & Interruptions.
• Robustness must be demonstrated like never before.• Field failures indicate need for immunity test criteria.
Commonly Occurring EMC Events
Wireless Transmitter EMI
• Wireless transmitters induce RF currents.
• May be fixed in frequency, power & location.
• May be mobile in all three relative to the grid.
• Power levels range from 5W to 1500W.
• Various modulation schemes used.
• Environment simulated by testing variables:– Frequency range
– Power levels
– Modulation
– Criteria for Acceptance.
Coexistence with Wireless Devices
• Co-related issue arising from use of wireless devices.
• Wireless devices can cause and receive interference.
• Coexistence with other devices & incumbents needed.
• Interoperability won’t happen unless this is addressed.
• EMC planning, analysis & research prevents failures.
High-Level EM Disturbances
HEMP
Geomagnetic Storms
IEMI
EMC Concerns
• The EM phenomena identified here causes problems:– Momentary, self-correcting malfunctions
– Localized network failure
– Large-scale interruptions.
• Naturally generated, grid-caused & man-made.
• Unintentionally or intentionally generated interference.
• Results are the same:– Grid doesn’t function as intended
– Grid can’t interoperate if it can’t stay operating.
• EMC Standards need to be referenced in P2030.
Referenced Standards
EMC Standards:
ANSI C63.4 (Emission Measurements)IEEE C37.90.1 (Relay and electric power apparatus surge withstand capability)IEEE C37.90.2 (Relay system withstand capability to radiated EM interference from transceivers)IEEE C37.90.3 (ESD measurements of protective relays) IEEE 1613 (Requirements for Communications Networking Devices Installed in Electric Power Substations)IEEE 473 (EM site survey)IEEE 139 (In-situ measurement of Industrial, Scientific and Medical equipment)IEEE 1560 (RFI filter capability measurement)IEEE 1597.2 (EM computer modeling applications)IEC/CISPR 22 (ITE emissions) and CISPR 24 (ITE immunity)IEC 61326-x series (Electrical Equipment for Measurement, Control and Laboratory use—EMC) IEC 60255-25 (Relay and protection equipment measurements—EMC Emissions)IEC 60255-26 (Relays and protection equipment measurements—EMC Immunity)IEC 61000-6-5 (Immunity for power station and substation environments—EMC)IEC 61000-4-2 (ESD measurements)IEC 61000-4-3 (Radiated immunity measurements)IEC 61000-4-4 (Fast transient/bursts measurements)IEC 61000-4-5 (Surge measurements)IEC 61000-4-6 (Conducted immunity measurements)IEC 61000-4-8 (Magnetic field immunity measurements)IEC 61000-4-11 (Voltage dips/variation immunity measurements)IEC 60439-1 (Cable distribution cabinets for power distribution networks)IEC 60870-2-1(Telecontrol equipment power supply and EMC)
Referenced Standards
HEMP Standards:
IEC 61000-1-3 (Effects of High-Altitude EMP (HEMP) on Civil Equipment and Systems-EMC)IEC 61000-2-9 (Description of HEMP Environment - Radiated Disturbance, Basic EMC Publication)IEC 61000-2-10 (Description of HEMP Environment - Conducted Disturbance – Basic EMC Publication)IEC 61000-2-11 (Classification of HEMP Environments - EMC) IEC 61000-4-25 (HEMP Immunity Test Methods for Equipment and Systems - EMC) IEC 61000-4-32 (HEMP Simulator Compendium - EMC) IEC 61000-4-35 (HPEM Simulator Compendium - EMC) IEC 61000-5-6 (Mitigation of External EM Influences - EMC) IEC 61000-5-8 (HEMP Protection Methods for the Distributed Infrastructure - EMC) IEC 61000-6-6 (HEMP Immunity for Indoor Equipment – EMC Generic Standards)
IEMI Standards:
IEC 61000-1-5 (High Power Electromagnetic (HPEM) Effects on Civil Systems - EMC) IEC 61000-2-13 (High-Power Electromagnetic (HPEM) Environments - Radiated and Conducted EMC) IEC 61000-4-33 (Measurement Methods for High-Power Transient Parameters – T&M Techniques)IEC 61000-4-35 (HPEM Simulator Compendium - EMC)
IEEE P2030 Draft Guide for Smart Grid Interoperability of Energy Technology and Information Technology
Operation With the Electric Power System (EPS), and End-Use Applications and Loads