Top Banner
Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015
40

Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Apr 17, 2018

Download

Documents

danghuong
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA

Andrew GrossTCGA Annual Meeting

May 11, 2015

Page 2: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Page 3: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Blessing

● No platform left behind

● Unprecedented cohort sizes

● Panoramic view into the tumor's biology

Page 4: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Blessing

● No platform left behind

● Unprecedented cohort sizes

● Panoramic view into the tumor's biology

The PANCAN Curse● Integrating data is hard● Methods get very

complicated very quickly

Danger Sign- Bruce Stockwell, CC-BY2.0

Page 5: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

How do we break the PANCAN curse?

Page 6: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

How do we break the PANCAN curse?

Simple models

“Simple models and a lot of data trump more elaborate models based on less data.” -Peter Norvig,

Google Director of Research

Page 7: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

How do we break the PANCAN curse?

Incremental and transparent methods

Page 8: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Study goalsBetter understand the tumor phenotype.

Provide scope to molecular events often observed in specific tissue cohorts.

Page 9: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Study goalsBetter understand the tumor phenotype.

Provide scope to molecular events often observed in specific tissue cohorts.

What do all cancers have in common?

What differentiates cancers?

Page 10: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Expression profile for single gene across PANCAN cohort

Page 11: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Expression profile for single gene across PANCAN cohort

Filter unmatched patients

Page 12: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Expression profile for single gene across PANCAN cohort

Filter unmatched patients

Observe sign of change from tumorto normal tissue

Page 13: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Expression profile for single gene across PANCAN cohort

Filter unmatched patients

Observe sign of change from tumorto normal tissue

Count fraction of cohort withover-expression of gene

Page 14: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Null Hypothesis: F_g = 50%, gene is unchanged in tumor cells

Fraction over­expressed: fraction of patients in a cohort with over­expression of a gene

Page 15: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Advantages: – Not sensitive to tissue­specific 

baseline expression– Easy to interpret test statistic– Easy to integrate across tissues, 

data­layers– No statistical assumptions

Disadvantages: 

– Not sensitive to magnitude of differential expression

– Less Powered?

Page 16: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Advantages: – Not sensitive to tissue­specific 

baseline expression– Easy to interpret test statistic– Easy to integrate across tissues, 

data­layers– No statistical assumptions

Disadvantages: 

– Not sensitive to magnitude of differential expression

– Less Powered?

Page 17: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

A simple model of differential expression

Advantages: – Not sensitive to tissue­specific 

baseline expression– Easy to interpret test statistic– Easy to integrate across tissues, 

data­layers– No statistical assumptions

Disadvantages: 

– Not sensitive to magnitude of differential expression

– Less Powered?

Page 18: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What differentiates cancers?

What do all cancers have in common?

Page 19: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What do all cancers have in common?

● Methylation: 704 matched patients● mRNA: 650  matched patients● miRNA: 628 matched patients

Page 20: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What do all cancers have in common?ADH1B is up-regulated in 4% of tumors

Page 21: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What do all cancers have in common?

Mir-21 is up-regulated in 93% of tumors

Page 22: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What do all cancers have in common?

Pathway Enrichment

Page 23: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What do all cancers have in common?

Functional Enrichment

Page 24: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Does this replicate?

8 microarray datasets, 923 subjects

Page 25: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Does this replicate?

8 microarray datasets, 923 subjects

Page 26: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What differentiates cancers?

What do all cancers have in common?

Page 27: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Hypothesis: Genes turned on in the tumors will have levels associated with tumor growth and proliferation.

Page 28: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Correlation of profiles with tumor signature

Patient TCGA-BH-A0BZ

Page 29: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Correlation of profiles with tumor signature

Patient TCGA-BH-A0BZ All Matched Patients

Page 30: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Correlation of profiles with tumor signature

Page 31: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Correlation of profiles with tumor signature

Page 32: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Correlation of profiles with tumor signature

Page 33: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What differentiates cancers?

What do all cancers have in common?

Page 34: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What changes are tissue specific?

Germline MutationsSomatic Mutations

MET is up-regulated in 8% of breast cancers and 75% of other tumors.

Page 35: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What changes are tissue specific?

Germline MutationsSomatic Mutations

MET is up-regulated in 8% of breast cancers and 75% of other tumors.

Page 36: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What changes are tissue specific?

Germline MutationsSomatic Mutations

MET is up-regulated in 8% of breast cancers and 75% of other tumors.

Page 37: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What changes are driver specific?

Page 38: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

What changes are driver specific?

Page 39: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

● We describe a simple analysis method for studying the tumor phenotype

● We define a list of differentially expressed genes, miRNA and methylation sites in a pan­cancer context

● We use these features to stratify patient outcomes and define tissue and driver specific changes in cancer 

Summary

Page 40: Analysis of paired tumor and normal molecular … of paired tumor and normal molecular phenotypes in TCGA Andrew Gross TCGA Annual Meeting May 11, 2015 TCGA is a blessing and a curse

Thanks Ideker Lab