Mitglied der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft An introduction to Fuel Cells - Status and applications of fuel cell technology - Competing technologies & the market place Dr. Robert Steinberger-Wilckens Institute of Energy Research IEF-PBZ Forschungszentrum Jülich
79
Embed
An introduction to Fuel Cells - HySafe€¦ · Mitglied der Helmholtz-Gemeinschaft An introduction to Fuel Cells - Status and applications of fuel cell technology - Competing technologies
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Mitg
lied
der H
elm
holtz
-Gem
eins
chaf
t
An introduction to Fuel Cells - Status and applications of fuel cell technology - Competing technologies & the market place
Dr. Robert Steinberger-Wilckens Institute of Energy Research IEF-PBZ Forschungszentrum Jülich
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 2/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Overview
• Motivation
• Fuel cell introduction and overview
• Status of Fuel Cell technology today
• Challenges in bringing SOFC to the market
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 3/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
An Introduction to World Energy Issues
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 4/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
The World Needs Energy
7,8
3,9
4,1
3,9
world average 1,8
Consumption per capita 2010 Tonnes oil equivalent 1 toe = 12 MWh = 43,2 GJ
Source: BP
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 5/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
World Population Growth
Source: UN-PP, World Population Prospects 2010
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 6/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
GDP and Energy Consumption
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 7/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
CO2 emissions 2010
0,00 5,00 10,00 15,00 20,00
China
USA
EU-27
India
Russia
Japan
Germany
S.Korea
Canada
Iran
UK
Brazil
Mexico
Italy
Indonesia
France
Australia
Spain
Poland
Ukraine
Algeria
Portugal
[t / (capita * yr.)]
World CO2 Release (2010, per country) CO2 emissions 2010
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000
China
USA
EU-27
India
Russia
Japan
Germany
S.Korea
Canada
Iran
UK
Brazil
Mexico
Italy
Indonesia
France
Australia
Spain
Poland
Ukraine
Algeria
Portugal
[Mt / yr.]
CO2 emissions 2010
0,00 5,00 10,00 15,00 20,00
USA
Canada
Australia
S.Korea
Russia
Japan
Germany
UK
Poland
EU-27
Iran
Italy
Spain
Ukraine
China
France
Portugal
Mexico
Algeria
Brazil
Indonesia
India
[t / (capita * yr.)]Sources: BP 2011/wikipedia
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 8/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Future Scenarios of World Energy Demand
Source: EU Scenarios, 2006
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 9/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Fossil Fuel Reserves to Production Ratio (2010)
Source: BP 2011
reserves: known and economically retrievable
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 10/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
The 2-kW-Society
Source: CEPE, 2002
kW per capita
Switzerland 2002
ecological limit
economical limit (limit of poverty)
social limit
standard deviation of energy consump-tion
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 11/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Finding more efficient ways of supplying energy
improves the world situation under the aspects of
• climate change (GHG abatement)
• avoiding (or postponing) depletion of resources
• securing regional growth by avoiding expenses for energy import
• political stability by avoiding import dependencies
EU oil import quota
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 12/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
The possible roles of fuel cells and hydrogen
• more efficient energy conversion
• lower emissions
• flexibility in fuel choice, including fuels from renewable sources
• increased flexibility in the energy supply system
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 13/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
What is a ‚Fuel Cell‘?
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 14/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Ele
ctro
lyte
porous anode
porous cathode
O2 (air)
Surplus air
H+
Fuel Cell Principle
+ H2O
membrane properties: • gas tight • high ionic
conductivity • low electronic
conductivity
H2
Surplus fuel
PEFC: typical ‚hydrogen fuel cell‘
‚membrane‘
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 15/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
FC History • Definition of terms ‘electrolyte’, ‘electrode’ etc. and various
electrochemical processes by Michael Faraday (1791-1867) • Reverse electrolysis first realised by Sir William Grove 1839
(1811-1896) on basis of his own and Friedrich Schönbein’s (1799-1868) research
• Major contributions to electrochemistry theory by Wilhelm Ostwald (1853-1932)
• First technical developments and patents ca. 1902-1913 (VARTA) • Slow progress due to insufficient understanding of reaction kinetics
and materials’ issues
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 16/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Some Fuel Cell Principal Properties
1. not limited by Carnot efficiency (~ (T1-T2)/T1), only by electrochemical, kinetic and ohmic losses
2. modular 3. low (no) noise 4. exhaust emission predominantely water (and maybe CO2) 5. no moving parts
ergo: • efficient and low-emission energy conversion technology
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 17/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
00,10,20,30,40,50,60,70,80,9
1
373
573
773
973
1173
1373
1573
1773
1973
T1 [K]
eta
Increasing Efficiencies
lim T1 -> ∞
lim T2 -> 0 lim U -> Uo
o
ηc = 1- T2 / T1
T2 = 273 K
0
0,1
0,2
0,3
0,4
0,5
0,6
0,7
0,8
0,9
0,6 0,65 0,7 0,75 0,8 0,85 0,9 0,95 1
U
eta
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 18/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Fuel Cells could replace
• Internal combustion engines (ICE) - in vehicles - in Combined Heat and Power (CHP) units • GenSets (mobile power) • Batteries • Combined Cycle Power Stations • On-board Electricity Generation (Auxiliary Power Units, APU)
and supply decentralised or grid-independent power anywhere at any scale
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 19/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Fuel Cells in Comparison to Their Competitors
battery CHP ignition engine
fuel cell
el. Efficiency n.a. ~ 30-40% n.a. 25 to 55%
Noise ++ - -- + Modularity ++ -- - ++
Weight -- n.a. o + Range -- n.a. + o Costs -- o + -- Emissions n.a. o - ++
Overall Efficiency
n.a. ~ 95% 12 to 18% ~ 90%
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 20/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Competing with Batteries
Source: AZ State Univ
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 21/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Applications of Fuel Cells: Mobile - FC vehicles - special craft - off-road - APU
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 22/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 44/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Reaction MCFC - hydrogen case
Cathode side
2 H2 + 2 CO32- 2 H2O + 2 CO2 + 4 e- Anode side
O2 + 2 CO2 + 4 e- 2 CO32-
Overall reaction 2 H2 + O2 2 H2O
note: CO2 supply necessary on cathode side
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 45/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Reaction MCFC
what‘s wrong here?
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 46/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Fuel Cell Energy, MTU & Ansaldo
material copyright FCE, MTU, AFC
Ansaldo: biomass syn-gas operation
MTU: 17 in total 7 still in operation 250 kW / unit
FCE: off-the-shelf 300 to 3000 kW units 50 units worldwide
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 47/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Technology Status of Fuel Cells & Hydrogen applications
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 48/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
source: CUTE
Clean Urban Transport for Europe - CUTE
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 49/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
CUTE Results
project month cum
ulat
ive
oper
atin
g ho
urs
[100
0 h]
project month
1 00
0 km
• operated for more than
85.000 hours, • covered more than 1.200.000
Kilometres and • carried more than 4 Million
passengers.
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 50/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
CUTE: Hamburg Filling Station
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 51/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Hydrogen Applications and Markets
• Ammonia production • Petroleum refining • Methanol production and Industrial chemicals • Hydrogenation of fats and oils (food industry) • Metallurgy • Electrical power generation • Electronics industry
H2 world market size is comparable in volume with European
natural gas market ( ~500 x 109 Nm³ per year)
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 52/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Existing Hydrogen Distribution Pipelines
Courtesy Air Liquide
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 53/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Daimler f-cell Concept
Source: Daimler FCSem 07
60 built and operated in worldwide clusters (DE, SP, JP, US, etc.) 3.650.000 km (Nov. 2007) 100.000 km with one car (within ~3 years)
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 54/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
PEFC ‚Freeze‘ start
15 W freeze-proof to -20°C operational up to 40°C developed in cooperation with FhG-ISE
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 70/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Cost Projections – Moving Targets
0102030405060708090
100
0 4 8 12 16 20
years
cost
rela
tive
to p
roto
type
cos
t
FCHFCH Sub'sICE highICE high realICE lowICE low real
diesel car with no emissions?
free market vs. regulatory vs. subsidy approach
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 71/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
What Can We Learn From History?
New technologies have been permanently introduced to the markets with varying success. All the problems of costs and market introduction have existed before.
Examples:
mobile phones
mineral oil
photovoltaics
green electricity
unleaded fuel
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 72/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
The Concept of ‚Added Value‘
Consumers will pay a price above the market price for a service or consumable, if they gain some additional performance compared to ‘conventional’ equipment.
This could be:
improved performance (power, size, other technical data)
improved handling
improved utilisability
prestige
fun & recreation
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 73/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 74/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Electric / Fuel Cell Vehicle Concepts
GM HyWire
Toyota study
Sources: various
GM Autonomy concept
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 75/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
… and Frustration Ahead
Lifestyle
Economics
Usefulness
Environment
Cost effectiveness Low O&M requirements
Efficiency Freedom from pollutant emissions Low noise emission Low weight
Prestige Social position ‚Feel‘/emotions
Environmental performance Sustainability
Design ‚soft‘ engineering
consumer design customer design
performance engineering
cost engineering
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 76/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Fuel Cells Will be Immediately Competitive When ....
• carbon dioxide emissions are taxed • fossil energy ressources are depleted • energy inefficiency is taxed (or constrained) • hydrogen becomes abundant
or
• harmful emissions are considered vile by society • noiseless and exhaust-free operation becomes desireable • they supply power for otherwise unserviced locations • they are ‚in‘
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 77/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
The Sailing Ship Effect
The advent of the steam ship in the early 19th century spurred new developments in sailing ship technology
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 78/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction
Safety surprises …
Photographs courtesy of Swain, U Miami
22 & 29 Aug 2011 Slide 79/79 FC&H Summer School 22 Aug – 2 Sep 2011, Viterbo – Technology Introduction