An explanation of new EEC & British standards for terrorist CBRNe events 2010 www.hazmathood.com 1
Dec 17, 2015
An explanation of new EEC & British standards for terrorist CBRNe events
2010
www.hazmathood.com1
CEN WA 43 AND 44EUROPEAN DIRECTIVES FOR DEFENCE & PROTECTION OF
BUILDINGS & VICTIMS FROM TERRORIST CBRN EVENT
www.hazmathood.com
2
The Hazard
• Toxic atmospheres• Fire and smoke• Explosion (dust)• Terrorism CBRN• Pandemic• Industrial accident
www.hazmathood.com3
The risk
• Current focus on victim support• No current protection for victims• No protection for potential victims• Emergency services will be overloaded• Loss of citizen confidence post 1st event
www.hazmathood.com4
The threat
• Terrorism with us for 2 generations• Only a matter of time for dirty bomb• All business have fire alarms and procedures• Buncefield Chernobyl Bhopal• Asbestos dust in most pre 1999 buildings• Travel issues
www.hazmathood.com5
Vulnerability assessment
• 73% of fire victims die from smoke inhalation• 3 breaths of smoke unconscious• 53% of 9/11 victims have new lung problems• 11% of 9/11 victims suffered eye injury• It was illegal to issue PPE to potential victims
www.hazmathood.com6
Government awareness
• Go in Stay in Tune in• Fire services equipped with decontamination• Temporary mortuaries enlisted• Freezer lorries engaged• Power stations and waste disposal crematorium• 200,000 body bags purchased• 8000 police trained in terrorism CBRN response
www.hazmathood.com7
Victim protection
Lungs filled with contamination can’t be washed
www.hazmathood.com8
Wearing a protective hood through toxic atmosphere during evacuation is part of the new EEC new
guidelines and standards CEN WA 43
Gap analysis
• No time to assess hazards or risk• Victims use is not occupational• No time for training or fit testing• Cost and storage issues• Required to travel from “Hot Zone” to safety• 80 -20 Rule strip and wash ignores lungs
www.hazmathood.com9
The problem
• Potential victims not protected • Illegal to issue protection PPE 2002 regs • PPE regulations for occupational use only• Victims could never be protected • All resources on helping the victim• No planning to protect the victim
www.hazmathood.com
In an emergency you have no time to make assessments
10
European Solutions 2010
• New Guidelines & Standards CEN WA 43-44• Adopted by BSI • Duty holders identified• Standards of protection recommended• Victims and potential victims protected • Initial responders protected
www.hazmathood.com11
Duty Holders
• Employers• Facility and Security managers• Venue and large public issues• Travel & passenger safety• Visitors and trespassers
www.hazmathood.com12
www.hazmathood.com
Standards
• BSI British Standards Institute
• OSHA Occupational health & safety administration
• ISO ISO/TC 223 Jan 2006 investigating
• CEN European Committee standardisation
13
www.hazmathood.com
Respirator fit testing
• Cannot be worn with beard, spectacles• Leaks with beard growth• Leaks when speaking or moving• Leaks at perimeter seal due to filter efficiency• Better filtration increases leakage
14
www.hazmathood.com
Standard Description Filter class NPF
EN149 Filtering face piece FFP1FFP2FFP3
412.550
EN140 Half mask P1P2P3Gas
4125050
EN136 Full face mask P2 P3Gas
1710002000
CEN WA 43 PM750 P3 Gas 100015
Live saving performance
www.hazmathood.com16
EN136 respirator NPF of 1000
PM750 escape hood NPF of 1000
www.hazmathood.com
Filter efficiency
Challenge level (CFU)
Total CFU recovered
Filtration efficiency
6.9x106 0 >99.999999%
Data provided by Nelson laboratories USA
Challenge level (PFU)
Total PFU recovered
Filtration efficiency
4.2 x106 0 >99.999998%
17
www.hazmathood.com
Breathing resistance
• Resistance to inhalation does not exceed 15 mm water at air flow rate of 30 liters per minute.
• Resistance to exhalation does not exceed 5 mm water at air flow rate of 30 liters per minute.
18
www.hazmathood.com
Accumulation of CO2
• After 10 minutes of use, accumulation of Carbon Dioxide does not exceed 3% above the average human concentration of any wearer without the mask. (NIOSH Statement of Standard for CBRN Respirator, September 30, 2003, paragraph 3.4.2 requirements).
• The CO2 data recorded for the last 5 minutes took into account the last 5 breaths, that were mathematically compared to the CO2 accumulation found on the subject tested prior to use of the mask.
19
www.hazmathood.com
Respirator fit
• Different sizes• Fit testing requirement • Training requirement• Maintenance requirement • Inspection training requirement• Filter choices
20
www.hazmathood.com
New EEC recognised PM 750
• One size will fit 90% of the population over the age of 6 years, from 5% of the lower level, up to 95% of the higher level.
• The twin seal around the neck provides the single point diametrical closure.
21
www.hazmathood.com
Communications
• Frontal communication – the mask does not hamper quality of visibility more than 70%.
• The requirement is for movement of the head sideways and upwards and downwards.
• Verbal communication – speaking and hearing – for a distance of 2 meters between two users.
• The use of cellular telephone is possible whilst wearing the mask.
22
www.hazmathood.com
No training required
PM750 requires No fit testing No maintenanceNo training in Don or DoffNo inspection requirements No Record keeping
23
Categories of Stakeholder
Category Category of responder
Description Duty
1 Duty Holder Security -facility manager
Short time at scene to raise alarm training required. WA 44
2 Initial responder Security –first aid-ambulance-police
Initial reconnaissance or rescue. Trained WA 44
3 Professional responder
Directing initial operations
Trained in sophisticated equipment
4 Emergency services
Prolonged time at scene
No mitigation suitable PPE and training required
5 Victim and potential victim
Visitor to building or venue occupant
Protect themselves by reducing further exposure
www.hazmathood.com24
Time at scene
Category Time at scene and duties
1 5-15 minutes warm zone
2 5-15 minutes warm zone arrives at onset of event probable contact with casualties
3 30 minutes Hot Zone 1 -2 hours warm zone arrives 15 minutes +after incident
4 3 hours warm zone arrives +15 minutes after incident
5 15 minutes or site specific requirements assessed by duty holders
www.hazmathood.com25
Standards of protectionPersonnel category
Minimum NPF*
PPE type application
Duty holder 500 PAPR BS8486 EN397 PM750**
5-15 minutes warm zone
Professional responder
10,000 SCBA or closed circuit breathing apparatus
30 minutes Hot Zone . 1-2 hours warm zone
Emergency services
1000 Full face mask EN 14387 filterPM750**
3 hour warm zone
Clean up work
Depends on assessments
SCBA -PAPR -Full face-CCBA
Risk assessments required
Victim 50 Mask Escape Hood BS 8468 PM750**
15 minutes protection in warm zone depending on hazard
www.hazmathood.com
* Nominal Protection Factor ** Hazmat Hood specification26
Hazard assessments
www.hazmathood.com
Hazard Assessments Typical Response
Fire & smoke Planned response Evacuation
Explosion Planned response Shelter in Place
CBRN CEN WA 44 Victim or potential victim
Industrial accident CEN WA 44 Victim or potential victim
27
CEN WA 44 Training
• Selection & use of PPE in CBRNe incidents• CBRN threats and hazards• Decontamination of personnel• Evacuation considerations• Interaction with Emergency Services• Shelter in Place issues• Resilience
www.hazmathood.com28