WHITE PAPER enParadigm Simulation-based workshops for your middle and senior management Amul: The untold story An enParadigm paper on Amul’s strategic ‘fit’, which gives it a unique market position and makes it virtually immune to imitation by competition.
An enParadigm paper on Amul’s strategic ‘fit’, which gives it a unique market position and makes it virtually immune to imitation by competition.
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
WHITE PAPER
enParadigm Simulation-based workshops for your middle and senior management
Amul: The untold story An enParadigm paper on Amul’s strategic ‘fit’, which gives it a unique market position and makes it virtually immune to imitation by competition.
1. Executive Summary
2. What is strategic ‘fit’?
3. The Amul story
4. Amul’s strategic fit
5. About enParadigm
Contents
3
4
5
6
8
enParadigm | White Paper | Amul’s strategic fit | 2
enParadigm | White Paper | Amul’s strategic fit | 3
We all know Amul as one of India’s most recognized brands – as a bellwether that
has shaped a significant portion of the country’s economic and agrarian history.
One of Amul’s primary achievements (which is often ignored) is it established that
cooperatives can also be competitive, sustainable, independent and profitable
in the face of national, and even well-muscled international commercial rivals.
This paper explores how Amul built its strategic ‘fit’ as a farmer-owned, profit-
distributing co-operative as well as a lean, market-savvy, R&D-oriented corporate
entity.
First, it created a set of powerful, scalable, sector-specific competitive advantages
that helped it take a leadership position in its market. Next, it ensured these
activities complemented each other, creating a network of interdependent
advantages that are, by design, very difficult for competitors to imitate.
Amul’s strategic ‘fit’ is a clear and uniquely Indian addition to celebrated examples
like Southwest Airlines, Starbucks and Ikea.
Executive Summary
Strategic fit is a network of interdependent and complementary differentiators
designed to provide the company with a unique and sustainable competitive
advantage. From the company’s perspective, it is the process of taking up a clear
strategy based on unique activities relevant to the market – and then
building/matching all its resources and capabilities to strengthen this unique-ness.
For example, Southwest Airlines, a US-based carrier, has been profitable for 41
consecutive years now. Its recipe is a strategic fit, which it achieved by orienting
and developing all its capabilities with a single target customer in mind – the low-
cost flier looking for point-to-point routes between small towns and secondary
airports. While this part seems simple enough, it managed to shape every activity -
from aircraft selection to crew training to ticketing – into a set of differentiators that
supported (and were supported by) the other differentiators.
The Southwest Airlines Strategic ‘fit’ What is Strategy, Michael Porter, 1996
What is strategic ‘fit’
enParadigm | White Paper | Amul’s strategic fit | 4
Amul began as a cooperative movement nearly 70 years ago, and has grown into a
federation of many cooperatives - 1,44,500 dairy cooperative societies across 188
districts in 22 Indian states. Their success has been built around combining the
advantages of a cooperative and a corporate model. It’s core strength lies in its
stated principles of a) Linking milk producers and consumers directly and eliminating
the middle-man, b) Ensuring milk producers also control up-stream activities like
processing and marketing, and c) Professional, commercially-sound management to
keep them competitive.
Amul operates on a 3-tier model, with cooperative entities at state, district and
village level. The village co-ops function as daily procurement cells. Milk then flows to
processing units at the district level, while the state unit coordinates marketing,
access, pricing and supply to consumers. It has also established a daily flow of cash
in the opposite direction – cash gets all the way back to village c-ops and farmers are
paid on the same day. This creates an intrinsically credit-efficient system which Amul
has utilized to full effect.
The Amul model With inputs from the IJSER Jan-13 paper by
Dr. Ruchira Prasad and Dr. Rupali Satsangi, ISSN 2229-5518
State Milk Federation
District Milk Unions
Village Dairy Co-ops
Market (consumers)
Member producers
Milk Payment
Milk & milk products
Sales revenue
Bonus Dividend
Additional price diff.
Cattle feed Vet. and AH services Rural health schemes
Financial/tech. support for setup, expansion &
upgrades
Marketing direction, distribution support
The Amul story
enParadigm | White Paper | Amul’s strategic fit | 6
Amul’s strategic fit is based on a network of complementary and interdependent
differentiators
Product Variety
Reach & availability
Affordable prices
Quality Massive,
loyal supplier base
Decentralized, networked
supply chain
Lean processing & distribution
Financial security
Health benefits Equity
participation
Products at all price points
Outsourced non-core activities
Heavy IT integration
Surplus/deficit balancing
Tight inventory control
No credit, all-cash transaction
TQM and Kaizens
Cold-chain highways
Across the country
Cattle feed and vet. services
No-frills marketing, utilizing umbrella branding and