American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment

Page 1 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=1' data-page='1' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 1: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 2 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=2' data-page='2' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 2: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 3 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=3' data-page='3' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 3: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 4 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=4' data-page='4' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 4: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 5 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=5' data-page='5' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 5: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 6 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=6' data-page='6' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 6: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 7 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=7' data-page='7' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 7: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 8 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=8' data-page='8' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 8: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 9 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=9' data-page='9' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 9: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 10 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=10' data-page='10' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 10: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg' width='140' height='200' /> Page 11 <img data-url='document/american-civil-liberties-union-garth-circuit-judge-mei-ying-liu-and-shu-fang.html?page=11' data-page='11' class='cut-thumb lazyload' alt='Page 11: American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment' loading='lazy' src='' data-src='https://reader033.cupdf.com/reader033/viewer/2022052816/60a9ae825f30ce2bf1453cba/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg' width='140' height='200' />

American Civil Liberties Union...Garth, Circuit Judge: Mei Ying Liu and Shu Fang Chen (the "Plaintiffs") appeal from the District Court's sua sponte order dismissing their employment

Documents