Top Banner
2000-06-21 AMANDA Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad? Seven Wonders of Modern Astrono The Sharpest The Biggest The Fart The Most Extensive The Swiftest The Deadl The Wierdest www.sciam.com/1999/1299engineering/1299musser.html
44

AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

Dec 14, 2015

Download

Documents

Myra Fox
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

The Wierdest wonder

• Is it good or is it bad?

Seven Wonders of Modern AstronomyThe Sharpest The Biggest The Farthest FlungThe Most Extensive The Swiftest The DeadliestThe Wierdestwww.sciam.com/1999/1299engineering/1299musser.html

Page 2: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA experience

• Bad Calibration of the detector very heavy (“perfect” time constants for

AMANDA-B13 ready first May 2000!) The analysis delayed due to this.

• Good Deployment procedure established. “Easy” to reconstruct neutrinos

Page 3: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA deployment history

Year DetectorNumber

ofdeployed

OM

Totalnumber of

strings

Totalnumber of

OM

1995/1996 AMANDA-B4 86 4 86

1996/1997 AMANDA-B10 218 10 302

1998/1999 AMANDA-B13 125 13 428

1999/2000 AMANDA-II 252 19 680

Page 4: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA data analysis

• The first neutrino candidates published from AMANDA-B4 (data 1996)

• AMANDA-B10 data 1997 analysis in progress for Atmospheric neutrinos Search for WIMP annihilation in the Earth point sources Diffuse flux Neutrinos from GRB and Supernova, magn. monoples, AMANDA-SPASE etc

Page 5: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA data analysis

Atmospheric neutrinos WIMP search from Earth Point sources Diffuse neutrino flux

Neutrinos from GRB Supernova neutrinos Magnetic monopoles AMANDA-SPASE

AMANDA-B10 data is analysed for several different topics with the following in a “final” stage:

Page 6: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA-II Feb. 00

Page 7: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA -candidate

• Early photons are red, late photons are blue. More photons are larger circles

• Bottom of array is toward center of Earth

• The muon is clearly traveling in the upward direction

Page 8: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA -candidate

• Early photons are red, late photons are blue. More photons are larger circles

• Bottom of array is toward center of Earth

• The muon is clearly traveling in the upward direction

Page 9: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Event Rate Predictions

Source_______Rate(/km2yr)Eμ > 1 TeV

SNa RemnantA (GN 3C273 )Mk421, Mk501GR B (Γ flu .ct model)

31-1001-10 fr omγ flux~ a few(fro m arar e burst)

SourceRate(/km2yr sr)Eμ > 1 T _eV ____

AGNA GN jetsGRBAt m

400 -8004510100 0

Point Sources Diffuse Sources

Page 10: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Search Strategies for HE ’s

• Diffuse flux are most difficult to detect, but largest predicted rates.

• GRBs have least background due to time and position correlations.

SourceRejectionmethod____ Background

Diffuse flux 1. up-down (109/yr)(atm.μ)

Po intSource( . . e g A )GN

1. up-down2. direction3. energy?

(10 9/yr)( .atmμ)x(dΩ/2π)

Bursts( . . e g GRB)

1. up-down2. direction3. ti mestamp4. energy?

(10 9 /yr)( .atmμ)x(dΩ/2π)x( /dt3 10x 7)

Page 11: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Signal-background SeparationArb. normalization between signal and BG

Page 12: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

SPASE-AMANDA

• Calibration of absolute pointing

• Calibration of pointing resolution

• Calibration of signal efficiency

SPASE: South Pole Air Shower Experiment

Page 13: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Data Reduction 1997

Observed numberof events

Predicted numberof neutrinos

Triggered 1.2*109 4500

Reconstructed asupgoing track

5.1*104 570

Passing final cuts 193 235

E.g. one of the atmospheric neutrino analysis, 1997.

Page 14: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Atm. : background rejection

• Satisfactory agreement at all stages of analysis

• Rejection criteria are progressively improved, leaving fewer down-going events

• Initially data agrees with BG simulation, but then agrees with atm. signal

103

1

Page 15: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Angular DistributionsTwo distinct analysis techniques, but not independent

(a)MC (normalized)

(b)

Page 16: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Atmospheric Neutrinos

• Stronger selection criteria than point analysis

• Two distinct analysis methods

• Expected number of events depends on analysis efficiency

Page 17: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Search for HE Point Sources

• Concentrate on continuous emission from sources with hard spectra (~E-2)

• Optimize search on Signal to Noise Ratio Aeff depends on rejection requirements

Iterative procedure defined a priori

• Background for this search Poorly reconstructed atmospheric muons Atmospheric neutrinos

Page 18: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Sky Plot of Events

• 1097 events

• No obvious clustering

• Event sample consists of atm. and atm. muons.

Equatorial Coordinates

Page 19: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Significance distribution

• Bin sky according to angular resolution

• Use declination band to estimate background

• No statistically significant excess

Title: /tmp_mnt/u/tornado1/youngs/data/sigma.coguci.24x48.Creator: HIGZ Version 1.23/09Preview: This EPS picture was not saved with a preview (TIFF or PICT) included in itComment: This EPS picture will print to a postscript printer but not to other types of printers

Page 20: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Flux Limit (preliminary)

• AMANDA B10 limits are compared to MACRO limits. SuperK curve is estimated!

• AMANDA-II will complement sky coverage of SuperK

Title: /export/cascade1/youngs/mc_signal_new/nusim_50100/rCreator: HIGZ Version 1.23/09Preview: This EPS picture was not saved with a preview (TIFF or PICT) included in itComment: This EPS picture will print to a postscript printer but not to other types of printers

Page 21: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Point Source Fluxes

• Theoretical predictions are very small

• AMANDA limit assumes source with E-2 spectrum

Figure adopted from Mannheim & Learned

Page 22: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Mk 501 Flux Limit

• Recent diffuse IR measurements imply strong attenuation of TeV photons

• AMANDA can rule out similar neutrino spectrum.

AMANDA

Figure adapted from Protheroe and Meyer, astro-ph/0005349

Page 23: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Search for Diffuse Flux

• OM multiplicity distribution is (weakly) related to energy deposition.

• Distribution is consistent with atm

• New energy estimators will lead to improved limits

Page 24: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Diffuse Flux

• Generally 103 larger than point fluxes

• Atm backgrounds 103 worse

• E2 < 1.6x10-6 GeVcm-2s-1sr-1

AMANDA

Page 25: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMPs from Sun/Earth

Page 26: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Angular Spread of WIMP signal

• Angular spread decreases as WIMP mass increases, reducing atm. background

Page 27: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Cuts for WIMP search

• Optimized cuts for almost vertical upward moving muons.

• The simulated WIMP signal is reduced to 30% after reducing background by 108.

Page 28: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMPs from the Earth

• AMANDA limits comparable to MACRO and Baksan

• AMANDA sensitivity will increase at low mass due to special string trigger and better optimized analyzes

Optimized search for vertical neutrinos (1997 data)

Page 29: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMP search with Ice3

The WIMP search has been tested for two different geometries and the limits are given for 10 years of running

Page 30: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Simulation of WIMPs in Ice3

• Signal neutrinos from WIMP annihilations are simulated with Pythia

• No background simulated, but PMT noise is included

• At least 5 remaining hits after cleaning

• Reconstructed muon angle within 5 degrees of simulated

• This is the best-case limits since since efficiency of future cuts to remove background has not been included.

Page 31: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMPs from the Earth with Ice3

• Ice3 will significantly improve the sensitivity.

Optimized search for vertical neutrinos

Page 32: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMPs from the Earth with Ice3

• Ice3 will completely cover the DAMA area

Optimized search for vertical neutrinos

Page 33: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMPs from the Sun with Ice3

• Ice3 will significantly improve the sensitivity.

Page 34: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

WIMPs from the SUN with Ice3

Page 35: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Search for HE from GRB

Off source

GRB search bin

GRB Position

1 hour 1 hour16 s

BKG - off time BKG - off timeon time

GRB burst

Page 36: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

GRB Science

• Verify fireball model• GRBs may be sources of highest energy cosmic

rays• Test of special relativity

• Search for appearance at m2> 10-17 eV2(Ice3)

• Search for emission in coincidence with Gamma ray detectors

Page 37: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

HE emission from GRB’s ?

10-1

10-6

1 100Burst Duration (s)

Waxman and Bahcall

Combined Limit (90% CL)

Flu

ence

(T

eVcm

-2)

- Not so far

Page 38: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA Supernova detection

• e + p n + e+

• PMT noise increase due to the positrons

• AMANDA records noise on the PMTs over 0.5 sec and summing up total rate over 10 sec intervals

Page 39: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA SN sensitivity

• AMANDA-B10 is monitoring 60% of the Galaxy with 90% detection efficiency for a SN1987 type.

• AMANDA is going to join SNEWS in 2001

Page 40: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Magnetic Monopole detection

Page 41: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA Effective Area

• AMANDA-II 30,000-50,000 m2

• AMANDA-II has nearly uniform response over all zenith angles

Page 42: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Summary and Outlook

• No point sources (AGN, GRB or WIMPS) detected, but more data on tape with bigger array (1998, 1999)

• ~170 atmospheric neutrinos candidates Number depends on efficiency of analysis

• Sensitivity and performance confirmed (to within factor of 2) by atm , background studies, and Spase-AMANDA coincidence events

• AMANDA-II is taking data

Page 43: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

Publications

• Many conference reports and so far X Ph.D. Thesis.

• First neutrino results in Astroparticle Physics 13 (2000) 1, (AMANDA-B4)

• Eight drafts in preparation for submission in autumn 2000 (AMANDA-B10, 1997 data) Atmospheric neutrinos WIMP search Neutrino limits from GRB Point sources Diffuse limit AMANDA-SPASE Supernova Magnetic Monoples

Page 44: AMANDA 2000-06-21 Per Olof Hulth The Wierdest wonder Is it good or is it bad?

2000-06-21

AMANDA

Per Olof Hulth

AMANDA Results

• Supermassive Black Holes (AGN) E-2 point source: (>10 GeV) <10-7 (cm-2s-1)

E-2 diffuse flux : E2< 1x10 GeV cm-2s-1sr-1

• GRB in coincidence with BATSE Cumulative Fluence< 4x10-4 TeVcm-2

• Atmospheric neutrinos (135 live days) ~170 events from 1997, depends on analysis Calibration of sensitivity within factor 2

• WIMPs from the earthAlso, see ICRC99 for limits on relativistic monopoles, search for SNa, ice properties