ALWD Conference 2013 Planning Each Charted Course, Each Careful Step Along The Byway: Two Approaches To Teaching The Formation Of Professional Identity.

ALWD Conference 2013

Planning Each Charted Course, Each Careful Step Along The Byway: Two

Approaches To Teaching The Formation Of Professional Identity To Contemporary

Law Students

Ian Gallacher & David Thomson

Presenters

David Thomson, University of Denver Presenting on an upper-level Discovery law

course that he teaches, which incorporates many opportunities for formation of professional identity

Ian Gallacher, Syracuse University Presenting on formation of professional identity in

the first year legal research and writing course.


What is Professional Identity?


Professional Identity Formation


You can’t “teach” it (we can teach the “floor” – that’s the Ethics class)

talking about “above the floor”We have to create “situations” in which

formation can occurA proposal: GSFPI

An Exercise or Writing Assignment Identification of an ethical quandary by the

student A reflection by the student on their decision Some form of feedback and response

Discovery Law

“Whole-course Simulation”Mock LitigationStudents in RolePreparing documents each weekConfronted with ethical quandariesMust make their own decisionsShare that with me privately in a memoI respond with comments and a rubric


Learning Outcomes Recognize and apply the twelve Federal Rules of Civil Procedure that

pertain to discovery Recognize how and when to use the most common litigation documents Prepare such documents in a simulated litigation Interpret discovery responses from opposing counsel Develop and adjust litigation strategy based on what you have learned Identify and evaluate ethical dilemmas that arise in the discovery context Reflect and Form your identity as a legal professional Consider the complexities of, and developing law surrounding, electronic

discovery Synthesize your case knowledge at specific points in the litigation Take and defend a deposition Compare options and negotiate a settlement with opposing counsel Agree upon terms for a settlement agreement, and draft it collaboratively.


Pedagogy

New teaching materials Lean back vs. Lean forward

Online quizzesClass:

Lecture, discussion, workshop Learn the tools, then discuss how to apply them

Then: DO it


DOing Civil Litigation

Two unequal parties: • Snowboarder vs. Drug Company

Plaintiff and Defendant counsel pairs 8 Witnesses. 2 experts, each student plays a part Each student gets part of the file Uses Discovery Tools to learn the rest of the

facts Prepares / serves Int., Doc. Req., Req. to Admit Answers each from opposing counsel Conducts a Deposition (with a student court rep.) Settles the case


Assessment of Formation of PI

With each discovery document: Memo to meApproach, Strategy, Ethical issues, ReflectionI look for Identification of the ethical issueAnd I look at the Reflection on the issue

Thoughtfully addressed Clearly expressed With depth

• Showing formation of the student’s PI


Ethics/Reflection (20%)

1 Identification of ethical issues is poor or lacking (such as objecting to answer a legitimately focused question). Document and memo seems mechanical and lacks reflection.

2 A few ethical identification errors made. Document and memo show some thoughtful reflection.

3 Only one or two ethical identification errors made in the document and memo. Some thoughtful reflection and clarity of purpose is shown in the document.

4 No ethical identification concerns, and the document and accompanying memo show significant thoughtful reflection in preparing the document.

5 This is a student who is becoming confident with discovery, identifies all ethical grey areas, and uses the simulation to reflect with depth and clarity on decisions made while balancing the various competing concerns.


Model Exercise

Learning Outcome: To experience a mock GSFPI Try to pretend to be a student!

Please review the exercise Identify an ethical issue Make a decision as to how you would resolve it Reflect on that decision Discussion


Some Sample Reflections

“The central ethical dilemma of discovery came into sharp focus during this exercise. I felt torn responding to several of the interrogatories. For each, I tried to imagine standing in front of a judge explaining the choice that I made.”



“Another document I was concerned about producing was the medical record created after the heart attack….In the end, I decided that because this is a highly relevant document I am confident defendants would be able to ultimately obtain, I decided to produce it now. Also, I reasoned that if I objected and then was forced to produce the document, I would be signaling to opposing counsel that the document contained information harmful to my client.”



“Overall, I feel comfortable that these choices strike a fair balance between duty to court and duty to client.”

“I do not want to hide the ball, and would not be able to sleep at night if I was actively hiding information that was clearly discoverable and responsive to their request.”


Today’s Undergraduates Are Less Professional?

38% observed decline in “professionalism” in last five years

43% reported declining work ethic in past five years

Declining Professional Attributes

Acceptance of personal responsibility for decisions and actions

Sense of ethicsPreparation for classes and assignmentsCompleting assignments on timeCompetent verbal and written communication

Increase in Negative Behavior

Inappropriate appearancePoor work ethicUnfocused and apathetic behaviorSense of entitlementBeing disrespectful and rudeLack of time management skills

Study’s Most Significant Results

Younger generation less likely to agree that there are generational differences in those who exhibit “professionalism”

Younger generation more likely to think that the definitions of professionalism should change to reflect their attitudes and behaviors

Empathy In College Students Is Decreasing

Today’s students score 40% lower in empathy than did students of 20-30 years ago

Literary Reading Is Declining

Fewer than half of the adult population read literature

10% decline in literary reading between 1982 and 2002

High School Student Reading Skills

High school students reading at lower level than before

Students being assigned less challenging books to read

Empathy Is Crucial And Is Lacking In Most Of First Year Of Law School

Empathetic response to client’s needs while analyzing legal issues is best definition of “practice ready”

Empathetic switch is set to “off” in first year of law school

Upper level classes reset switch to “on” but that might be too late, especially if we move to two year law degrees

Opportunity For Legal Writing Programs

We’re the only ones to speak about empathy in first year of law school

Empathy is at the core of good writingWe often put students into simulated lawyering

situationsWe’re perfectly placed to begin discussion of

professional identity

Syracuse First Year Legal Writing Program

Every assignment based on a lawyering problemAssignments are traditional in substance and form,

but facts introduce students to variety of lawyering situations which allow students to contemplate issues while working on writing and research skills

Syracuse First Year Legal Writing Program

In addition to core learning outcomes of traditional legal writing program, students encouraged to consider issues related to professional identity

Allows course to be promoted to students, administration, alumni, and prospective employers as an approach to help students graduate as “practice ready”


Planning Each Charted Course, Each Careful Step Along The Byway: Two

Approaches To Teaching The Formation Of Professional Identity To Contemporary

Law Students

Ian Gallacher (Syracuse) & David Thomson (Denver)

ALWD Conference 2013 Planning Each Charted Course, Each Careful Step Along The Byway: Two Approaches To Teaching The Formation Of Professional Identity.

Documents

discovery document

case alwd conference

rubric alwd conference

students pi alwd conference

response slide

ethical identification

ethical quandaries

ethical quandary