Alice SCOTUS Decision

8/12/2019 Alice SCOTUS Decision

1/21

"#$%&' ('&)&*)+ (,-(./0 -/012 34"5$6%%789:

;(-/< =>?@? &A &: B?7:&8%?2 7 :6%%789: #>?7C)*A?+ D&%% 8? @?%?7:?C2 7: &:8?&)E C*)? &) F*))?FA&*) D&A> A>&: F7:?2 7A A>? A&G? A>? *'&)&*) &: &::9?CH->? :6%%789: F*):A&A9A?: )* '7@A *B A>? *'&)&*) *B A>? ,*9@A 89A >7: 8??)'@?'7@?C 86 A>? 0?'*@A?@ *B I?F&:&*): B*@ A>? F*)J?)&?)F? *B A>? @?7C?@H$?? "#$%&' (%)%&*JH+&%,-$% .$/0&, 1 23/0&, 4-56344 KH $H 53"2 55LH

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

$6%%789:

MNO,/ ,(0P(0M-O(; P-QH N-IH 7H ,N$ .M;R

O;-/0;M-O(;MN /- MNH

,/0-O(0M0O -( -S/ K;O-/I $-M-/$ ,(K0- (T MPP/MN$ T(0-S/ T/I/0MN ,O0,KO-

;*H "5U3VWH M@E9?C 17@F> 5"2 34"XYI?F&C?C Z9)? "V2 34"X

P?A&A&*)?@ M%&F? ,*@'*@7A&*) &: A>? 7::&E)?? *B :?J?@7% '7A?)A: A>7A C&:[

F%*:? 7 :F>?G? B*@ G&A&E7A&)E \:?AA%?G?)A @&:]2^ $5&56 A>? @&:] A>7A *)%6

*)? '7@A6 A* 7) 7E@??C[9'*) B&)7)F&7% ?_F>7)E? D&%% :7A&:B6 &A: *8%&E7[

A&*)H O) '7@A&F9%7@2 A>? '7A?)A F%7&G: 7@? C?:&E)?C A* B7F&%&A7A? A>?

?_F>7)E? *B B&)7)F&7% *8%&E7A&*): 8?AD??) AD* '7@A&?: 86 9:&)E 7

F*G'9A?@ :6:A?G 7: 7 A>&@C['7@A6 &)A?@G?C&7@6H ->? '7A?)A: &) :9&A

F%7&G #"+ 7 G?A>*C B*@ ?_F>7)E&)E B&)7)F&7% *8%&E7A&*):2 #3+ 7 F*G'9A[

?@ :6:A?G F*)B&E9@?C A* F7@@6 *9A A>? G?A>*C B*@ ?_F>7)E&)E *8%&E7[

A&*):2 7)C #5+ 7 F*G'9A?@[@?7C78%? G?C&9G F*)A7&)&)E '@*E@7G F*C?

B*@ '?@B*@G&)E A>? G?A>*C *B ?_F>7)E&)E *8%&E7A&*):H

0?:'*)C?)A: #A*E?A>?@2 ,N$ .7)]+2 D>* *'?@7A? 7 E%*87% )?AD*@]A>7A B7F&%&A7A?: F9@@?)F6 A@7):7FA&*):2 B&%?C :9&A 7E7&):A '?A&A&*)?@2

7@E9&)E A>7A A>? '7A?)A F%7&G: 7A &::9? 7@? &)J7%&C2 9)?)B*@F?78%?2 *@

)*A &)B@&)E?CH P?A&A&*)?@ F*9)A?@F%7&G?C2 7%%?E&)E &)B@&)E?G?)AH MB[

A?@ 8$9*:$ JH ;)? ,*9@A >7: %*)E >?%C A>7A b"4"2 D>&F> C?B&)?: A>? :98c?FA

G7AA?@ ?%&E&8%? B*@ '7A?)A '@*A?FA&*)2 F*)A7&): 7) &G'%&F&A ?_F?'A&*)

B*@ d \e%f7D: *B )7A9@?2 )7A9@7% '>?)*G?)72 7)C 78:A@7FA &C?7:Hg >*?

*-@$)%$-# A-, B-9&@39), C)%D-9-EF JH BF,$)' G&%$@*6 H#@52 `aV KH $H

hhh2 hhhH O) 7''%6&)E A>? b"4" ?_F?'A&*)2 A>&: ,*9@A G9:A C&:A&)E9&:>'7A?)A: A>7A F%7&G A>? \ d89&%C&)eEf 8%*F]e:fg ^ *B >9G7) &)E?)9&A62

D>&F> 7@? &)?%&E&8%? B*@ '7A?)A '@*A?FA&*)2 B@*G A>*:? A>7A &)A?E@7A?


2/21

3 MNO,/ ,(0PH 75,N$ .M;R O;-gN$6%%789:

A>? 89&%C&)E 8%*F]: &)A* :*G?A>&)E G*@?2 :?? B)F- 4-99)0-,)%$7& (&,?

7$@&* JH C,-/&%D&3* 2)0-,)%-,$&*6 H#@52 àa KH $H hhh2 hhh2 A>?@?86

\A@7):B*@Ge&)Ef^ A>?G &)A* 7 '7A?)A[?%&E&8%? &)J?)A&*)2 $'56 7A hhhH

P'H ÙaH

#8+ K:&)E A>&: B@7G?D*@]2 A>? ,*9@A G9:A B&@:A C?A?@G&)? D>?A>?@

A>? F%7&G: 7A &::9? 7@? C&@?FA?C A* 7 '7A?)A[&)?%&E&8%? F*)F?'AH àa

KH $H2 7A hhhH OB :*2 A>? ,*9@A A>?) 7:]: D>?A>?@ A>? F%7&Gg: ?%?G?)A:2

F*):&C?@?C 8*A> &)C&J&C97%%6 7)C \7: 7) *@C?@?C F*G8&)7A&*)2^ \A@7):[

B*@G A>? )7A9@? *B A>? F%7&G^ &)A* 7 '7A?)A[?%&E&8%? 7''%&F7A&*)H H'56

7A hhhH P'H LU"LH

#"+ ->? F%7&G: 7A &::9? 7@? C&@?FA?C A* 7 '7A?)A[&)?%&E&8%? F*)F?'A? 78:A@7FA &C?7 *B &)A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?G?)AH K)C?@ \A>? %*)E:A7)C[

&)E @9%? A>7A de7f) &C?7 *B &A:?%B &: )*A '7A?)A78%?2g ^ G-%%*@D)9: JH8?

*-#2 X4V KH $H a52 aL2 A>&: ,*9@A >7: B*9)C &)?%&E&8%? '7A?)A F%7&G:&)J*%J&)E 7) 7%E*@&A>G B*@ F*)J?@A&)E 8&)7@6[F*C?C C?F&G7% )9G?@7%:

&)A* '9@? 8&)7@6 B*@G2 $'567A L"UL3i 7 G7A>?G7A&F7% B*@G9%7 B*@ F*G[

'9A&)E \7%7@G %&G&A:^ &) 7 F7A7%6A&F F*)J?@:&*) '@*F?::2 C),:&, JH

I9--:2 X5L KH $H `WX2 `VXU`Vì 7)C2 G*:A @?F?)A%62 7 G?A>*C B*@ >?CE[

&)E 7E7&):A A>? B&)7)F&7% @&:] *B '@&F? B%9FA97A&*):28$9*:$2 à" KH $2 7A

`VVH OA B*%%*D: B@*G A>?:? F7:?:2 7)C 8$9*:$ &) '7@A&F9%7@2 A>7A A>?

F%7&G: 7A &::9? 7@? C&@?FA?C A* 7) 78:A@7FA &C?7H () A>?&@ B7F?2 A>?6

7@? C@7D) A* A>? F*)F?'A *B &)A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?G?)A2 $5&56 A>? 9:? *B

7 A>&@C '7@A6 A* G&A&E7A? :?AA%?G?)A @&:]H N&]? A>? @&:] >?CE&)E &)

8$9*:$2 A>? F*)F?'A *B &)A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?G?)A &: \ d7 B9)C7G?)A7%

?F*)*G&F '@7FA&F? %*)E '@?J7%?)A &) *9@ :6:A?G *B F*GG?@F?2g ^ $0$'52

7)C A>? 9:? *B 7 A>&@C['7@A6 &)A?@G?C&7@6 #*@ \F%?7@&)E >*9:?^+ &: 7

89&%C&)E 8%*F] *B A>? G*C?@) ?F*)*G6H ->9:2 &)A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?[

G?)A2 %&]? >?CE&)E2 &: 7) \78:A@7FA &C?7^ 8?6*)C b"4"g: :F*'?H P'H LU"4H

#3+ -9@)&)E A* A>? :?F*)C :A?' *B B)F-g: B@7G?D*@]< ->? G?A>*C

F%7&G:2 D>&F> G?@?%6 @?j9&@? E?)?@&F F*G'9A?@ &G'%?G?)A7A&*)2 B7&%

A* A@7):B*@G A>7A 78:A@7FA &C?7 &)A* 7 '7A?)A[?%&E&8%? &)J?)A&*)H

P'H "4U"aH

#&+ \$&G'%6 7''?)C&)E F*)J?)A&*)7% :A?':2 :'?F&B&?C 7A 7 >&E>

%?J?% *B E?)?@7%&A62^ A* 7 G?A>*C 7%@?7C6 \D?%% ])*D) &) A>? 7@A^ &: )*A

\-3ED^ A* :9''%6 A>? \ d&)J?)A&J? F*)F?'Ag ^ )??C?C A* G7]? A>&:

A@7):B*@G7A&*)H B)F-6 *3? &)A@*C9FA&*) *B 7 F*G[

'9A?@ &)A* A>? F%7&G: C*?: )*A 7%A?@ A>? 7)7%6:&:H ;?&A>?@ :A7A&)E 7)

78:A@7FA &C?7 \D>&%? 7CC&)E A>? D*@C: d7''%6 &A2g ^ B)F-2 *3? 9:? *B 7) 78:A@7FA &C?7 \ dA* 7 '7@A&F9%7@ A?F>)*%*E&F7%

?)J&@*)G?)A2g ^ 8$9*:$2 *3


3/21

5,&A? 7:< `L5 KH $H hhhh #34"X+$6%%789:

:*@A *B \7CC&A&*)7% B?7A9@e?f^ A>7A '@*J&C?: 7)6 \'@7FA&F7% 7::9@7)F?

A>7A A>? '@*F?:: &: G*@? A>7) 7 C@7BA&)E ?BB*@A C?:&E)?C A* G*)*'*%&k?

A>? e78:A@7FA &C?7f &A:?%BH^ B)F-2 *3*C F%7&G C*?: )* G*@? A>7)

:&G'%6 &):A@9FA A>? '@7FA&A&*)?@ A* &G'%?G?)A A>? 78:A@7FA &C?7 *B &)[

A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?G?)A *) 7 E?)?@&F F*G'9A?@H -7]&)E A>? F%7&G ?%[

?G?)A: :?'7@7A?%62 A>? B9)FA&*) '?@B*@G?C 86 A>? F*G'9A?@ 7A ?7F>

:A?'YF@?7A&)E 7)C G7&)A7&)&)E \:>7C*D^ 7FF*9)A:2 *8A7&)&)E C7A72

7Cc9:A&)E 7FF*9)A 87%7)F?:2 7)C &::9&)E 79A*G7A?C &):A@9FA&*):Y&:

\e'f9@?%6 dF*)J?)A&*)7%H g B)F-2 `aa KH $H2 7A hhhH ,*):&C?@?C \7: 7)

*@C?@?C F*G8&)7A&*)2^ A>?:? F*G'9A?@ F*G'*)?)A: \7CeCf )*A>&)E H H H

A>7A &: )*A 7%@?7C6 '@?:?)A D>?) A>? :A?': 7@? F*):&C?@?C :?'7@7A?[

%6H^ H'567A hhhH l&?D?C 7: 7 D>*%?2 A>?:? G?A>*C F%7&G: :&G'%6 @?F&A?

A>? F*)F?'A *B &)A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?G?)A 7: '?@B*@G?C 86 7 E?)?@&FF*G'9A?@H ->?6 C* )*A2 B*@ ?_7G'%?2 '9@'*@A A* &G'@*J? A>? B9)FA&*)[

&)E *B A>? F*G'9A?@ &A:?%B *@ ?BB?FA 7) &G'@*J?G?)A &) 7)6 *A>?@ A?F>[

)*%*E6 *@ A?F>)&F7% B&?%CH M) &):A@9FA&*) A* 7''%6 A>? 78:A@7FA &C?7 *B

&)A?@G?C&7A?C :?AA%?G?)A 9:&)E :*G? 9):'?F&B&?C2 E?)?@&F F*G'9A?@

&: )*A \-3ED^ A* A@7):B*@G A>? 78:A@7FA &C?7 &)A* 7 '7A?)A[?%&E&8%?

&)J?)A&*)H H'567A hhhH P'H "XU"aH

#5+ .?F79:? '?A&A&*)?@g: :6:A?G 7)C G?C&7 F%7&G: 7CC )*A>&)E *B

:98:A7)F? A* A>? 9)C?@%6&)E 78:A@7FA &C?72 A>?6 A** 7@? '7A?)A &)?%&E&[

8%? 9)C?@ b"4"H P?A&A&*)?@ F*)F?C?C 8?%*D A>7A &A: G?C&7 F%7&G: @&:?

*@ B7%% D&A> &A: G?A>*C F%7&G:H M)C A>? :6:A?G F%7&G: 7@? )* C&BB?@[

?)A &) :98:A7)F? B@*G A>? G?A>*C F%7&G:H ->? G?A>*C F%7&G: @?F&A?

A>? 78:A@7FA &C?7 &G'%?G?)A?C *) 7 E?)?@&F F*G'9A?@i A>? :6:A?G

F%7&G: @?F&A? 7 >7)CB9% *B E?)?@&F F*G'9A?@ F*G'*)?)A: F*)B&E9@?C A*

&G'%?G?)A A>? :7G? &C?7H ->&: ,*9@A >7: %*)E \D7@)e?Cf H H H 7E7&):A^&)A?@'@?A&)E b"4" \&) D76: A>7A G7]? '7A?)A ?%&E&8&%&A6 dC?'?)C :&G'[

%6 *) A>? C@7BA:G7)g: 7@AHg ^ B)F-2 *37A A>?

:6:A?G F%7&G: 7@? '7A?)A ?%&E&8%? D*9%C >7J? ?_7FA%6 A>7A @?:9%AH

P'H "aU"LH

L"L TH 5C "3aV2 7BB&@G?CH

-S(1M$2 ZH2 C?%&J?@?C A>? *'&)&*) B*@ 7 9)7)&G*9: ,*9@AH $([

-(1MQ(02 ZH2 B&%?C 7 F*)F9@@&)E *'&)&*)2 &) D>&F> mO;$.K0m 7)C .0/Q/02

ZZH2 c*&)?CH


4/21

"""""""""""""""""

"""""""""""""""""

#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $96?@$A* ?;%) 97%8%98 %) )9)/ +MR,3M4,R 1&;'


5/21

2 TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


6/21

$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45 -67%8%98 9: &;' $9


7/21

4 TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


8/21

+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#4567%8%98 9: &;' $9


9/21

i TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


10/21

,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#4567%8%98 9: &;' $9


11/21

S TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


12/21

R$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#4567%8%98 9: &;' $9


13/21

#3 TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


14/21

##$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#4567%8%98 9: &;' $9


15/21

#2 TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


16/21

#-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#4567%8%98 9: &;' $9


17/21

#4 TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


18/21

#+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#4567%8%98 9: &;' $9


19/21

#i TU@$A $6JV/ "#$U0 XT>Y @>?fU67%8%98 9: &;' $9


20/21

#,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


21/21

"""""""""""""""""

"""""""""""""""""

#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

067689:6;< =/< >?@>ABB%@C

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

D?/ #-E2FG

9HI$J $6;K6;97I6D K7:/ H7L< KJ7I7I6DJ; "#$H0

M9DN ID7J;D97I6D9H J7 9H/

6D O;I7 6P $J;7I6;9;I 76 7QJ .DI7JL 0797J0 $6.;7 6P

9KKJ9H0 P6; 7QJ PJLJ;9H $I;$.I7R=A@' #F< 23#4S

=.07I$J 067689:6;< T%&U TU?V =.07I$J WID0M.;W(@X =.07I$J M;J:J;Y?%@< >?@>ABB%@C/

I (XU'B' &? &U' Z%'T &U(& (@[ \>](%V &U(& V'B'][ X'^

)>B%_') ( V'&U?X ?` X?%@C _A)%@')) X?') @?& aA(]%`[ () (

bcB?>'))d A@X'B e#3#/f $%&'(% Z/)*++,'< +g# ./ 0/ +F-< g#4

123#35 10&'Z'@)< =/< >?@>ABB%@C %@ YAXCV'@&5h )'' (])? -. /0

$%&'(%< +4+ P/ -X F4-< F,2 1$9 P'X/ 233G5 1L[i< =/< >?@>AB^

B%@C5 1\7U'B' %) @? )ACC')&%?@ %@ (@[ ?` &UR'S '(B][ RJ@C^

]%)US >?@)%X'B(&%?@ ?` cB?>')) c(&'@&) &U(& cB?>'))') `?B

?BC(@%j%@C UAV(@ (>&%Z%&[ T'B' ?B 'Z'B U(X _''@ c(&'@&^

(_]'f5/ 9) %@ $%&'(%< U?T'Z'B< I `AB&U'B _']%'Z' &U(& &U'

V'&U?X >](%V) (& %))A' (B' XB(T@ &? (@ (_)&B(>& %X'(/ $`/

+g# ./ 0/< (& g#F 1?c%@%?@ ?` 0&'Z'@)< =/5/ I &U'B'`?B' Y?%@

&U' ?c%@%?@ ?` &U' $?AB&/

Alice SCOTUS Decision

Documents