Top Banner
Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality [email protected] 517 284-6745
49

Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality [email protected]

Feb 28, 2021

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Air Dispersion Modeling:

What the heck is it?

Jim Haywood

Michigan Department of Environmental

Quality

[email protected]

517 284-6745

Page 2: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Who will you hear from?

• Jim Haywood

Senior Meteorologist

• Jenifer Dixon

OEA Air Specialist

2

Page 3: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Webinar Set Up • All lines will be muted

• Questions can be sent to us via the

question/chat box

• We will

record

webinar

and post

online

Page 4: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Modeling and Permits

You’ve submitted your application form, site

description, technical information, and

regulatory summary….

Did you consider

modeling?

Page 5: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Modeling and Permits

AQD Permit

Engineers

I agree! I’ll get this over to modeling!

This new process needs

modeling!

Page 6: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Why Model? • Identify impacts from the construction or

modification of facilities that are seeking a

permit to install/operate air emission

sources.

• AQD Policy and Procedure AQD-22

(March 3, 2015)

Page 7: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

When Model? • You are a major OR minor source

• Emissions submitted do not demonstrate

protection of Air Quality standards

• Examples:

– Poor dispersion

– Close proximity to sensitive groups

– Potential existing problems in the area

Page 8: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

What is modeling

and how is it

done?

Page 9: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Mission: Determine Impacts

from Emissions

Page 10: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Measuring Impacts:

Pre-Permit/Construction

Page 11: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Measuring Post-Permit Impacts:

Where to Locate?

Page 12: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Monitor Impacts: Coverage

Page 13: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Monitor Impacts: Coverage

Page 14: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Can AQ Models Help With

These Problems?

Page 15: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Air Quality Models are

Computer Simulations of

Pollutants in the Atmosphere

Page 16: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Virtual Monitors Over Entire

Affected Area

Page 17: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Predicting Locations &

Magnitude

Page 18: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Basic Modeling Elements:

Stack Parameters Meteorology

Building Wake Effects Terrain Features

Page 19: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Stack Parameters

• Emission Rate

• Stack Height

• Temperature

• Stack Diameter

• Flow Rate

• Stack Orientation

Page 20: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Stack Orientation

Page 21: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Building Wake Effect

Page 22: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Building Wake Effect

Page 23: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Meteorology

• Wind Speed

• Wind Direction

• Temperature

• Precipitation

• Upper Air Data

• Surface Features

• Representativeness

Page 24: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Meteorology

Representativeness

Page 25: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Meteorology

Representativeness

LANSING IRON MOUNTAIN

Wind Direction

Page 26: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Terrain Features

Page 27: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Terrain Features

Page 28: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

There’s the Devil in the Details…

Page 29: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Other Considerations…

• Ambient Air

• Receptor spacing

• Fugitive Dust

• Secondary Pollutants

• Background Concentration

• Other Nearby Sources

• Additional Impacts

Page 30: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Ambient Air: Where Do You

Model? “the portion of the atmosphere, external to buildings, to which

the public has general access”

Page 31: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Receptor (Virtual Monitors)

Spacing Area Coverage and Spacing Sufficient to Identify the Location and

Magnitude of the Highest Ambient Impact

Page 32: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Receptor (Virtual Monitors)

Spacing Area Coverage and Spacing Sufficient to Identify the Location and

Magnitude of the Highest Ambient Impact

Page 33: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Fugitive Dust Modeling

Page 34: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Secondary Pollutants: O3

Page 35: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Secondary Pollutants: PM2.5

Reaction Sun

Ammonia

Products of Fuel

Combustion

NOx and SO2

Solvents

Water

Vapor

Indirect Formation

of Particles

Page 36: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Total Ambient Impact

Total Impact is Your Proposed Process

PLUS

Nearby Sources Background +

Page 37: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Additional Impacts

Soil Deposition Vegetative Damage

Fogging and Icing Odors

Page 38: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

CREATE AN INPUT FILE FOR THE MODEL

RUN THE MODEL

Page 39: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Model Predictions Pass:

Permit Process Continues!

Page 40: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Model Predictions Fail:

Then What?!?!?

Page 41: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Model Predictions Fail:

Reduced Impact Strategies

Page 42: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

How Accurate Are the Models?

Page 43: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

AERMOD: EPA Preferred

Model

Simulates transport and dispersion from multiple points, area, and volume sources;

Employs hourly sequential meteorological data to estimate concentrations for averaging times ranging from one hour to one year.

Steady state plume dispersion model for assessment of pollutant concentrations from a variety of sources;

Page 44: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

AERMOD SOFTWARE

EPA

$Free

Page 45: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

AERMOD SOFTWARE

Lakes Environmental

$1,599

BEE-LINE

Software

$1,350

Breeze Software

$1,495

Page 46: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

QUESTIONS???

Page 47: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

What’s Coming Up?

Stack Testing: What is it and why is it necessary?

February 24, 2016 at 10:00AM

Air Monitoring: History and Rationale

March 16, 2016 at 10:00AM

Please join us!

Page 48: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Wrap Up

• Recording

• Materials

• Evaluation

Page 49: Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? · 2016. 2. 26. · Air Dispersion Modeling: What the heck is it? Jim Haywood Michigan Department of Environmental Quality HaywoodJ@Michigan.gov

Michigan Department of

Environmental Quality

800-662-9278

www.michigan.gov/deq

Sign up for email updates

Follow us on Twitter @MichiganDEQ