Top Banner
WWW .EVANS-DIXON.COM Nutrient TMDLs; What’s the Deal? Aimee Davenport
22

Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

Jan 22, 2017

Download

Environment

Kevin Perry
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Nutrient TMDLs; What’s the Deal?

Aimee Davenport

Page 2: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Point Sources v. Non-Point Sources

v.

Page 3: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Topics

• TMDL Basics

• Key Legal Issues in TMDLs

• Chesapeake Bay TMDL Litigation

• Implications for Impaired Waters in Missouri

Page 4: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

TMDL Basics

• Section 303(d) of the Clean Water Act contains:

– Requirement to identify impaired waters.

– Requirement to develop Total Maximum Daily Loads (“TMDL”) when technology based effluent limits are insufficient.

Page 5: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

TMDL Basics

• States must develop impaired waters lists and TMDLs for impaired waters (303(d) Lists)

• States submit the lists and then the TMDLs to EPA for approval

• EPA is supposed to develop lists and TMDLs when states fail to act

• Significant litigation in the 1990s

– American Canoe Association v. EPA

Page 6: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

TMDL Basics

• Section 303(d) requires that TMDLs be developed at a level necessary to implement the applicable water quality standards…

Page 7: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

TMDL Basics

• TMDL has three components: – Waste Load Allocation (“WLA”) – the portion of the daily

load allocated to point sources

– Load Allocation (“LA”) – the portion of the daily load allocated to non-point sources

– Margin of safety

• Friends of the Earth v. EPA (D.C. Circuit 2006) - TMDLs must be set on a daily basis.

Page 8: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

TMDL Basics

• Cases from several circuits have held that EPA’s ability to force states to implement TMDLs is through:

– Objecting to NPDES permits.

– Withholding grant money from states.

Page 9: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

TMDL Legal Issues

• Point Sources versus Non-point Sources

• Among the primary sources for nutrient pollutant

loads are non-point sources

• EPA’s regulatory authority extends only to point

sources

Page 10: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Key Question

• How do you create a TMDL to meet water quality

standards if you can’t regulate some of the primary

sources of pollutant loads?

– Chesapeake Bay TMDL – Six Bay states and District of Columbia to implement/enforce Watershed Implementation Plans, associated benchmarks, timeframes, and EPA backstops if WIPS are insufficient

Page 11: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

American Farm Bureau Federation v. EPA (July 6, 2015)

• Farm Bureau challenged TMDL after its adoption in 2010

• Main issues included:

– EPA exceeded authority by:

• Setting multiple WLAs

• Inserting timeframes

• Requiring that states provide reasonable assurance that load reductions from non-point sources will occur

Page 12: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

American Farm Bureau Federation v. EPA (July 6, 2015)

• Crux of Farm Bureau’s argument:

– “Total” Maximum Daily Load must consist of a single number specifying the amount of a pollutant that a water can accommodate without adverse impact.

Page 13: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

American Farm Bureau Federation v. EPA (July 6, 2015)

• Unanimous decision – Court Disagreed

• Its decision hinged on agency deference under Chevron v. NRDC (1884)

– Did Congress directly address issue in statute?

– If not, then was agency’s interpretation permissible?

– If yes, then deference to agency

Page 14: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

American Farm Bureau Federation v. EPA (July 6, 2015)

• Court determined:

– Statute does not contain express language defining what “total” means in TMDL;

– That nothing in CWA prohibits EPA from developing detailed TMDLs; and

– That EPA’s interpretation of what can be included in TMDL was not arbitrary and capricious (i.e. reasonable policy decision)

Page 15: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

American Farm Bureau Federation v. EPA (July 6, 2015)

• “Cooperative federalism” emphasized – the partnership between EPA and states, and that Congress’ declared national goals in the CWA suggest that the TMDL definition “is broad enough to include allocations, target dates, and ‘reasonable assurance’ provisions.”

– State-specific clean-up plans/EPA approval

Page 16: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Implications

Page 17: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

It’s Bigger…Badder…

Page 18: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Implications

• MDNR Nutrient Reduction Plan (What of the existing nutrient TMDLs already in effect?)

• Higher scrutiny to achieve non-point source reductions in all TMDL

• More details regarding implementation

• Water Quality Trading

Page 19: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

For the Regulated

Page 20: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

For the Regulated

• The ruling does not address:

– A scenario where non-point sources are not adequately considered as contributors to nutrients, or

– Where a state has not provided reasonable assurance that necessary load reductions will occur

Page 21: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Reminders

• Stay involved in TMDL process – beginning of the permitting process

• Ask for all relevant information

• Provide DETAILED comments

• Consider elevating issues where warranted

Page 22: Aimee Davenport, Evans & Dixon, Nutrient TMDLs; What's the Deal?, Missouri Water Seminar, September 10-11, 2015, Columbia, MO

WWW.EVANS-DIXON.COM

Questions?

Aimee Davenport

Evans & Dixon L.L.C.

501 Cherry Street

Columbia, Missouri 65201

(573) 607-1010

[email protected]