AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria Monitoring and Evaluation in the Transition Toyin Jolayemi – APIN Ltd Seema Meloni - Harvard
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Monitoring and Evaluation in the
Transition
Toyin Jolayemi – APIN LtdSeema Meloni - Harvard
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 2
Background
Harvard supporting sites since 2004 Since 2008, APIN has been funded by CDC Nigeria
to transition sites from Harvard
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 3
Service Delivery
Based on National Guidelines and Harvard/APIN protocols
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 4
Overall Enrollment
Jul-Dec 08 Jan-Jun 09 Jul-Dec 09 Jan-Jul 10
NIMR
New on Care 1,344 1,400 1,271 1,169
New on ART 970 755 653 661
Current on Care 6,700 7,261 7,741 7,932
Current on ART 4,684 4,922 5,157 5,510
LUTH
New on Care 1,048 1,077 928 896
New on ART 657 811 705 691
Current on Care 5,188 5,661 5,962 6,317
Current on ART 3,989 4,237 4,623 4,960
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 5
QA/QI (1): Continuity of Care
Jul-Dec 08 Jan-Jun 09 Jul-Dec 09 Jan-Jul 10
NIMR
% of patients with ≥1 clinical visit in the last 6 months and 6 months apart
70.5 68.6 76.7 71.5
% of ART patients who had ≥1 pharmacy pick-up and/or ≥1 clinical visit in the last 6 months
51.4 67.9 71.5 72.3
LUTH
% of patients with ≥1 clinical visit in the last 6 months and 6 months apart 82.5 81.8 83.9 84.4
% of ART patients who had ≥1 pharmacy pick-up and/or ≥1 clinical visit in the last 6 months
55.8 61.2 64.9 68.4
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 6
QA/QI (2): OIs including TB
Jul-Dec 08 Jan-Jun 09 Jul-Dec 09 Jan-Jul 10
NIMR% of patients who were screened for TB by clinical symptoms during the past 6 months 97 97.9 98.4 97.8
% of patients initiated on TB treatment within 2 months of confirmed TB diagnosis 38.3 53.9 68.8 79.8
% of patients with at least one CD4 count ≤350 on CPT 49.5 87.4 87.7 87.5
LUTH% of patients who were screened for TB by clinical symptoms during the past 6 months 95.9 97 97.2 97.4
% of patients initiated on TB treatment within 2 months of confirmed TB diagnosis 58.8 62.1 56.4 53.3
% of patients with at least one CD4 count ≤350 on CPT 48.8 68.5 80.1 78.7
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 7
QA/QI (3): Patient Monitoring
Jul-Dec 08 Jan-Jun 09 Jul-Dec 09 Jan-Jul 10
NIMR
% of new patients who got baseline CD4 91.3 90.0 85.6 83.5
% of patients who got ≥1 CD4 assessment during 6-month review period
94.9 96.1 75.7 88.5
LUTH
% of new patients who got baseline CD4 92.6 92.7 92.0 94.5
% of patients who got ≥1 CD4 assessment during 6-month review period
90.7 84.9 87.9 90.8
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 8
Cohort Analysis
Date Range for 6 Month CD4 Count Jul-Dec 08 Jan-Jun 09 Jul-Dec 09 Jan-Jul 10
Starting Cohort Date Range Aug 07 - Jan 08 Feb 08 – Jul 08 Aug 08 – Jan 09 Feb 09 – Jul 09
NIMR
# of patients in the starting cohort 536 1141 752 800
# with baseline CD4 count 481 (90%) 980 (86%) 685 (91%) 727 (91%)
Median baseline CD4 count 142 143 157 144
# from the starting cohort still picking up ART at month 6 435 (82%) 948 (83%) 602 (80%) 672 (84%)
# with CD4 count at month 6 361 (83%) 790 (83%) 516 (86%) 436 (65%)
Median CD4 count at month 6 251 309 336 318
LUTH
# of patients in the starting cohort 526 547 588 709
# with baseline CD4 count 511 (97%) 518 (95%) 563 (96%) 658 (93%)
Median baseline CD4 count 143 144 145 188
# from the starting cohort still picking up ART at month 6 472 (90%) 389 (71%) 402 (68%) 544 (77%)
# with CD4 count at month 6 302 (64%) 329 (85%) 353 (88%) 453 (83%)
Median CD4 count at month 6 291 284 294 325
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 9
Clinical Outcomes
Jul-Dec 08 Jan-Jun 09 Jul-Dec 09 Jan-Jul 10
NIMR
% with VL≤400 after 6 months on ART
82 79.9 84.2 79.4
LUTH
% with VL≤400 after 6 months on ART
70.3 70.1 74.2 81
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 10
Transition of QA Efforts
APIN Central Central QA committee in place QA indicators harmonised with
GON QA/QI toolkit in place Training on QA/QI framework
and processes Mentoring of Sites
Site Site QA committee in place including
focal person and data staff QA framework/plans in place QA activities ongoing Sites starting to run data for QI Training on QA/QI framework and
processes
Technical Assistance from Harvard QA /QI SOP and QUiC tool developed; Analysis for QI Support training and provide TA on QA/QI
Wednesday, April 19, 2023
AIDS Prevention Initiative Nigeria
Wednesday, April 19, 2023 11
Summary
Development of tools to monitor the impact of transition on clinical outcomes is critical.
Methods of analysis and ultimate significance require empirical approach.
Increased communication with transitioned site personnel and patients will inform the process.