IPIA Report #1022016 Agriculture Sector Needs Assessment Report Balkh Province December 05 – December 13, 2015 USWDP Training Room, Balkh University Hamid Faisal Agribusiness Program Manager [email protected]Phone: 0798-987200 Kevin T. McNamara Ph.D. Professor of Agriculture Economics [email protected]Phone: 077-9813162 Don Breazeale, Ph.D. Agriculture Education Advisor [email protected]Phone: 0785-854-634 January 20, 2016
34
Embed
Agriculture Sector Needs Assessment Report Balkh Province · PDF fileAgriculture Sector Needs Assessment Report Balkh Province . December 05 – December 13, ... Survey Questionnaire
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
IPIA Report #1022016
Agriculture Sector Needs Assessment Report Balkh Province
Introduction Afghanistan’s economy is largely agrarian with agriculture responsible for an estimated 23% of annual
GDP, industry accounting for 21% and services 55% (World Fact Book: Afghanistan, 2015). The World
Bank estimates that the agriculture sector was responsible for 50% of GDP growth in 2013. Half of all
Afghan household incomes are derived at least in part from production agriculture, and, agriculture—
production, processing, marketing and distribution—has the greatest promise of new job growth.
Agricultural processing accounts for an estimated 90% of all manufacturing in Afghanistan (World Bank
2014). Despite the potential of and recent growth in agriculture, Afghanistan remains one of the most food-
insecure nations in the world (D’Souza and Jolliffe 2012).
While postharvest agriculture has become the central focus for economic and job growth by the Afghan
government, development organizations, private investors, and donors (MoCI 2013), Afghan universities
do not offer educational programs that teach skills related to postharvest jobs, and no university in the
country offers degrees in agribusiness or farm management. This gap creates a void in college educated
Afghans with the skills needed to support expansion of the economy through postharvest, value-added
agriculture activities. Business growth is stifled due to lack of Afghans with training in the skills needed to
support growth in the economy.
In an effort to fill the gaps in an area critical to the needs of the Afghan economy, Purdue University (West
Lafayette, IN USA) has partnered with the faculties of agriculture at Balkh, Kandahar, Khost, Kunduz, and
Nangarhar universities to establish new undergraduate degrees in agribusiness. This effort is part of the
USAID-funded University Support and Workforce Development Program (USWDP), a project designed to
strengthen the quality and relevance of academic programs across all sectors so graduates will have the
skills needed to secure employment throughout Afghanistan. A major objective of developing a new degree
program in agribusiness making certain that students graduate with a strong foundation in agribusiness
skills that are needed immediately in the Afghanistan economy and, thus, offer students potential for
meaningful employment with competitive salaries. To achieve this objective of relevance, stakeholder—
both private and public--involvement must be an integral focus of characterizing the real needs and
challenges in Afghanistan postharvest industries and development of a curriculum that responds to these
needs and challenges.
IPIA Report #1022016
2
Connecting the University with the Broader Agricultural Sector Stakeholder or industry input into curriculum development is a foundation of modern curriculum
development (Edgar 2014). University faculty maintain on-going, formal and informal, interact with
individuals in stakeholder and industry groups to gain insight into the issues and challenges they are facing,
and to make certain that the skills integrated into the curriculum prepare students for successful job
placement (Johnston et. Al., 2014). While this practice is the norm for universities in the U.S., it is not for
Afghan universities. In fact a common criticism of Afghan universities is that they have no meaningful
contact with stakeholders and that, consequently, university curriculum lacks currency and relevance. As
Purdue initiated USWDP partnerships with the 5 faculties of agriculture for development of agribusiness
programs, the faculties agreed that an industry assessment would be a foundational activities to achieve
several critical tasks related to establishing a BS degree program in agribusiness. These tasks are:
1) Introduce potential stakeholders/employers to the faculty of agriculture; 2) Gain insight into the major challenges/issues faced by each business and the different industries
related to the broader agricultural sector; 3) Learn from industry the management and technology skills competencies critical for new
employees; 4) Make university faculty members aware of industry—private and public—and their needs.
In order to carry out industry assessments for the 5 target institutions, enumerator training program was
organized at Balkh University with the Faculty of Agriculture at Balkh University hosting two faculty
members from the each other four universities. The training, conducted by USWDP professional staff from
Kabul and from Purdue, familiarized the faculty members with the questionnaire and provided an
opportunity for the participants to practice their interviewing by interviewing each other. The first two days
of the training included instruction on surveys and questionnaire design methodology, qualitative research
methodology, interviewing techniques, and demonstrations on conducting interviews. Training participants
were introduced to the actual questionnaire to be used for the industry assessment and taught how to ask
the questions as part of a conversation rather than simply asking each question individually. The participants
also practiced interviewing each other to gain practical experience.
The 10 participants were broken into 3 groups and for the next five days each team was in the field
interviewing agribusiness firms in and around Mazar-e-Sharif. The practice interviewing was followed by
two days of training on data entry, spreadsheet use, and data analysis. Participants completed summary
sheets and answered specific questions concerning the survey findings. The final day involved completing
data entry, filling out the M&E evaluation questionnaires, and, most importantly, planning how to move
IPIA Report #1022016
3
forward with the bridge program at their respective institutions as well as how they will conduct a similar
survey in their own regions.
Objectives of the Balkh Assessment The overall objective of the assessment was to establish develop an industry-university dialogue to set
curriculum priorities for the agribusiness BS program through close cooperation with the agribusiness firms
in Balkh Province. All research involving human subjects was approved by the Purdue University
Institutional Review Board. The Balkh Province assessment was a training program to teach staff from each
of the participating universities how to conduct similar surveys in their own provinces, while completing
the process in Balkh. The Balkh site was used for training purposes so that the participants would be able
to gain some experience and understanding of survey interviews to provide clarity and direction as the five
universities begin development of agribusiness curriculums.
Description of Firms Interviewed Agriculture in Afghanistan is quite diversified. The agribusiness sector reflects these same trends. The 39
firms interviewed represented a diverse group. This sample diversity was intentional in order to gain a fuller
understanding of the sector and how the university might interact with the firms. The firms ranged in size
from a small woman’s group with 4-5 members packaging and selling fruit to a very large company with
52 administrative staff and hundreds of skilled and unskilled workers transporting and selling cooking oil,
milling wheat and marketing building / construction supplies and involving import / export activities. The
majority of the firms interviewed could be classified as “medium size” although there were some “large”
firms as well. Medium sized firms would have from approximately 10 to 30 employees and large firms
would have 40 or more employees, including a couple with more than a hundred employees. Small firms
had less than 10 employees.
Products produced by firms interviewed ran the gamut from nursery/ornamental plants, wheat milling, milk
soybeans, cakes and biscuits. Many of these firms are involved with importing and exporting activities. The
processing activities were concentrated on wheat milling, cooking oil, and poultry products.
Employee numbers are directly related to firm size as would be expected. Overall the firms reported
relatively low levels of education for their employees. However, most of the firms also had at least one or
more B.Sc. employees. Some of the firms with technical products such as certified seed production also
report M.Sc. employees and a couple of firms reported Ph.D.’s, although upon further examination, these
folks turned out to be M.D.’s who owned the firms. The examples ranged from one of the largest firms with
IPIA Report #1022016
4
approximately 80 B.A., BSc. and baccalaureate employees and a medium sized nursery/ornamental
business with no university level employees including the owner himself.
Although markets exits, most of these firms face tariff challenges related to competition and/or increased
costs for their own inputs. Electricity outages also contribute to production costs. For example, one miller
said that every time the power goes out it costs his firm approximately $70 to restart everything. And he
often suffered from multiple outages every day. High electrical costs also contribute to high water pumping
charges for the nursery/ornamental firms in particular. Security and transportation costs are also challenges.
Wheat was reported to be imported from Kazakhstan and soybeans from Ukraine. Although wheat is a main
product of Afghan farmers, much of it is grown for home use and the rest is often of low quality requiring
blending for flour production with imported wheat. Wheat costs for imports from Kazakhstan and Ukraine
were reported as $300/ton and $600/ton respectively. Herat wheat sells for about $290/ton. Respondents
said Kazakhstan was main source.
Relationships between Industry and University As in many countries, agricultural education is organized around a very different model from the U.S.
Under the US land-grant model, universities are closely engaged with public and private agriculture entities
to get stakeholder input on curriculum, extension training needs and research agendas. Although Afghan
universities are responsible for agriculture education, they are not responsible for extension or research
programs. Those two components are the responsibility of the Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and
Livestock (MAIL). The regional offices of MAIL are referred to as DAIL’s. As stated indirectly by the
several faculty members, “There has never been any reason to interact with clientele off campus because
we are a teaching institution.” Historically, MAIL has had contact with private industry, albeit somewhat
tenuously. In addition, MAIL has had little formal communication or cooperation with the universities.
The typical Afghan agricultural university does not have contact with private agriculture firms either—for
placement, curriculum development, or other reasons. Given these circumstance, there is little wonder that
the survey respondent noted that “universities, led by MoHE, have developed a curriculum in isolation
that in most cases is unresponsive to private industry.” In addition, the universities have evolved into a
system that teaches some theoretical knowledge but not applied or practical skills. Most Faculties of
Agriculture offer little if any practical training. One of the repeated themes of industry during the survey
was that “university graduates have a lot of theoretical knowledge, but they don’t know how to actually do
anything.” Many of the industry people surveyed said they preferred to “hire graduates after they have a
IPIA Report #1022016
5
few years of employment experience.” The problem is, however, how do graduates gain experience if
industry will not hire them?
In the last few years, perhaps due to some influence of foreign projects, channels of communication have
begun to improve between agriculture universities and the broader agriculture sector—public and private.
For example, in Balkh the DAIL Director said he had provided, “some limited equipment to Balkh
University.” However, it should be noted that this was only due to the graciousness of the DAIL Director
and there was not a formal agreement. During discussions with the Director, he mentioned that perhaps,
“We should establish an MOU with the university.” However, without additional follow up the idea will
likely not proceed. The Balkh DAIL Director said he does encourage “providing internship opportunities
for university students.”
Responses from private sector survey industry responses consistently expressed support for cooperating
with the university as they recognize that the universities represent a potentially untapped source of
knowledge. The Faculty members participating in the survey (as enumerators) also recognized the need to
establish communication channels with industry. The problem remains, however, how to establish formal
communication channels and cooperate in improving graduate’s skill levels? The bright spot is that all of
the parties involved are open to cooperation. All realize that graduates require a different type of education
then they currently receive in order to be ready for the job market upon graduation. The participants seem
to understand that mutual respect and cooperation will be required, because the current system is not
producing the desired results—job market ready graduates.
Awareness of other Parties Challenges and Needs Not surprisingly, both the private sector and the universities suffer from a severe shortage of funding for
any real reforms. Faculty members need graduate education and are under paid, university facilities are
generally in poor condition, laboratories and equipment are in ill repair or non-existent, electrical power is
unstable, and universities have limited operating budgets. Private industry faces many of these same
challenges along with a dearth of skilled employees. However, the private sector and universities both
generally have very dedicated Faculty members and employees.
The survey conducted in Balkh generated some consistent needs from the private sector related to employee
skills. Marketing, communication and technical skills were listed as the most important by industry. A
detailed analysis and breakdown of the skill rankings can be found in a following section of this report.
IPIA Report #1022016
6
The problem is that at the current time, private industry does not find new graduates with relevant skills,
the skills needed by industry—public or private. However, there was considerable interest and willingness
on the part of industry representatives to assist the university in curriculum development. The most
consistent response of industry was to provide internship opportunities for students. The DAIL Director
also indicated the same and reiterated that he already accepts many interns from the university.
Determining the skills survey respondents required was straight forward. The difficult challenge will be
identifying specific, economy relevant skills needed and implementing curriculum changes to address these
needed skills. USWDP/Purdue already is aware of numerous university regulations that tend to stymie many
innovative ideas. Changing a curriculum or developing a new one can be quite cumbersome and time
consuming. In addition, restructuring curriculum to focus on practical, allied skill development is a new
idea for most Afghan universities and MoHE. And, it is not clear that university faculty members have the
academic training to develop and implement a curriculum with industry relevant skills. .
Many of the regulations may have well intended reasoning, but seem designed to inhibit change. Everything
from hiring new M.Sc. people to implementing new courses presents numerous challenges. Working
through the university’s administration and with MoHE personnel will be crucial. However, it should be
noted that even those two administrative bodies can be resistant to changes they cannot understand or
control. Change will happen more easily if private industry will take a more active role. Advisory
committees are one method for this to take place. If nothing else, private industry input will apply pressure
to the universities. Developing a new curriculum may turn out to be the easiest part of this endeavor.
Overcoming bureaucratic hurdles may be the hardest part of updating the curriculum to address employer
needs.
Perceptions and Attitudes toward Cooperation It was evident that all parties involved in the Balkh agriculture industry assessment, private-public industry
and the university, agree that curriculum changes are required if academic programs are to address industry
employee skill needs. In our interviews and interaction with faculty everyone was positive about moving
forward with collaboration and coordination. However, the question remains, how will these changes
actually be implemented? For example, survey respondents indicated that past efforts implementing
internship programs have run into many problems such as transportation issues for students, lunch or lunch
money, and whether the students will be paid. In addition, there are questions about what the interns can
contribute (they lack relevant skills) and the balance between interns’ actual learning experiences and
providing manual labor for the firm.
IPIA Report #1022016
7
Firms are not aware of the challenges involved in hosting an intern and Faculty members are unaware of
the day-to-day realities faced by firms and they often lack the very skills that students are trying to acquire.
Therefore, it is imperative that there be an environment of cooperation between the university and industry.
Turf battles and bureaucratic hurdles must be overcome if the internship opportunities are to provide
meaningful experiences for the students.
Industry can play a powerful role in this transition. As mentioned before, industry representatives can serve
on advisory committees, allow students to conduct research projects under industry conditions, host field
trips for classes, speak to classes at the university, and cooperate with Faculty members so that “real life”
issues are addressed in class. In turn, Faculty members must be willing to move out of their comfort zones
and learn new techniques and more practical “hands-on” learning activities that can be incorporated in to
the curriculum. Another issue that Faculty members have raised is their need extra remuneration since they
are “doing” extra work. None of these ideas will be easy to implement, but if change does not take place
nothing will change and students will remain unemployed due to a lack of relevant skills.
Ranking of Skills as Perceived by Agribusinesses Afghanistan is primarily an agricultural country as the majority of people remain subsistence farmers. As a
result, universities have concentrated on producing agronomy and animal science graduates—a strong focus
on production agriculture. However, economic growth is tied to postharvest value added activities. While
production is important there is a critical need for agribusiness and postharvest value added education. As
reported earlier, curriculum changes need to respond to the needs of the growing agribusiness sector and
their required employee skills, which means a shift in the balance of academic programs in agriculture
faculties away for production toward agribusiness and value added postharvest education. The Balkh
Province Agriculture Assessment sought to identify the skills most relevant for the agribusiness sector in
Balkh Province to lead this shift.
The survey was prepared and reviewed by several people with intimate knowledge and experience working
with the Afghan agribusiness sector. The survey was based on the AGRIMASS survey originally developed
by Litzenberg and Schneider (1987). However, many changes were made to the survey in order for it to
more accurately reflect the Afghan situation. Data for the study were gathered using a structured face-to-
face interview with owners and managers representing agribusiness firms in Mazar-e-Sharif, Balkh
Province, Afghanistan. A 4-point Likert scale was used to show the relative importance of each
characteristic where 1 = not important and 4 = very important.
IPIA Report #1022016
8
Five groups of skills were developed; (1) Business and Economics, (2) Computer and Information
Technology, (3) Technical, (4) Communication and (5) Personal Qualities. Each of these main groups has
several subtopics lists under each of them. The following Table shows the rankings by the Afghan
agribusiness sector of the main groups.
Table 1 Most Valued Skills by Agribusiness
Skill Groups Average Value
1. Personal Qualities Skills 3.76 2. Communication Skills 3.61 3. Business and Economic Skills 3.51 4. Technical Skills 3.12 5. Computer / Information Technology Skills 2.97
The rankings from Balkh Province are quite similar to previous surveys of agribusiness skills by a number
of authors over the last 20 + years in several different countries including Armenia, Australia, Canada,
Uganda, and the U.S. Despite the heavy reliance of technical training in the agronomic and animal sciences
disciplines taught in Afghan universities, private industry ranks three other skill groups above technical
(production) skills. As in the other countries Personal Qualities and Communication Skills are highly sought
after, as can been seen from the rankings. Business and Economics Skills are ranked third followed by
Technical and finally by Computer / Information Technology Skills.
Table 2
Subtopics from Skill Groups Sub-Skills Average Value
1. Loyalty to Organization 3.90 2. Sales / Marketing 3.85 3. Foreign Language (English) 3.74 4. Positive Work Attitude 3.74 5. High Moral and Ethical Standards 3.74 6. Work without Supervision 3.72 7. Provide Leadership 3.71 8. Management 3.64 9. Email Writing 3.64 10. Finance and Accounting 3.62
None of the technical agricultural production skills such as agronomy or animal science that are currently
taught were ranked in the top 10 subtopics. Eight of the top ten subtopics were related to “soft skills” that
involve working with people and the number 2 position is sales/marketing. Only the number 10 position is
IPIA Report #1022016
9
a bit more technical, but rather than a hard science it was for finance and accounting that is normally part
Total Firms 39 The respondents were grouped into ten categories by firm type with the number of responding firms
provided to the right. Abroad range of firm types were sought out and therefore some of the types only had
one respondent. Only one of the 39 firms was owned by a women which wasn’t surprising given the cultural
environment related to conducting business in Afghanistan.
Availability and Sources of Technical Assistance The majority of agribusiness firms indicated that technical assistance is either unavailable (10%) or
sought from outside of Afghanistan (44%) particularly from Iran, Pakistan and India (Table 4).
Agribusiness firms at Balkh indicated that in most cases they receive training and information on new
production practices from NGOs like FOA, USAID, and SALT International etc (36%) while (21%)
reported that employee training is most frequently obtained/sought from outside Afghanistan (Table 5). A
much smaller percentage of agribusiness firms self-reported using government (3%). Importantly, 69% of
agribusiness firms indicated that they “never” use the university as a source of technical assistance or
employee recruitment (Table 6).
Table 4 Availability of Technical Assistance for Agribusiness firms
Technical Assistance is: % agreeing with Statement
IPIA Report #1022016
10
Sought from outside of Afghanistan 44 Available Locally 38 Unavailable 10 Not Needed 8
Table 5 Sources of Information / Training for Current and New Production Practices
Source % Agribusinesses Reporting
NGOs 36 Employees trained outside of Afghanistan 21 Self-research 21 Private consultants available locally 10 Equipment or Machinery salespeople 5 Experience from within company 3 Government 3 No Need 3
Table 6 Frequency with which Agribusinesses Utilize Universities for Technical Assistance or Employee
Recruitment
Frequency % agreeing with Statement
Never 69 From Time to Time 18 Rarely 8 Regularly 5
Challenges to Agribusiness firms Agribusinesses were asked to describe the challenges to operating their businesses. The lack of sufficient
capital and business loans (27%) and unfair competition/foreign products (20%) were the most frequently
self-reported challenges by agribusinesses (Table 7). Lack of government policy and support (14%), Lack
of Technology/skilled workers (8%) Lack of security (5%), stable electricity (5%), high taxes, corruption
(5%) and corruption (2%) are all mentioned as challenges to the production and operation of the
IPIA Report #1022016
11
agribusiness firms. Due to these challenges none of the firms surveyed operated in full production
capacity.
Table 7
Challenges Faced by Agribusiness Firms in Balkh
Challenge % Agribusiness Firms Reporting
Lack of Sufficient Capital and Business Loans 27 Unfair Competition/Foreign Products 20 Lack of Governmental Policy and Support 14 Lack of Quality Raw Materials & Machinery 12 Lack of Technology/Skilled Workers 8 Lack of Security 5 Stable Electricity / Power 5 High Taxes 5 Corruption 2
Summary and Conclusions There is an overall recognition by the faculty who participated in the assessment that their universities
would benefit from closer collaborative efforts with agribusiness firms. They also realize that the survey
data can help them design more appropriate agribusiness curriculums. The firms surveyed also responded
positively that they would like to help the universities produce more qualified graduates.
Expecting that these university faculty and firms will immediately work together to bring about change is
a bit too optimistic, at least in the short-run. Realignment of the current curriculum and direction for new
degree programs in agribusiness will take time. The inability to fund new staff positions will have to be
overcome, although it should be noted that DM Babury has committed to finding new positions for the
agribusiness programs at the 5 target universities. No one expects that the Faculties involved will cease
teaching technical classes. However, the identification of these skills as the most important business skills
enforces some sense of urgency. The results of this survey should be made available to Faculty members,
administrators, agribusiness firms, and most importantly, to students.
Implications There are a number of clear implications as a result of this survey: (1) it is evident that the current
curriculum being taught by the participating Faculties is no longer relevant based upon the opinions
expressed by the firms interviewed. It simply does not address the skills needed by private industry; (2) The
participating Faculty members have little, if any, contact or understanding of private industry and this
results in a misunderstanding of the required employee skills; (3) In general, the private sector has little
IPIA Report #1022016
12
understanding of the university, although some of them do allow student interns; (4) Both parties expressed
interest in collaborating to produce better prepared graduates; and (5) There are several bureaucratic hurdles
that will need to be overcome in order to design and implement an agribusiness curriculum. The challenge
for the Balkh University Faculty of Agriculture is development of the institutional and staff capacity to
restructure and develop its academic programs to meet the needs of the economy.
IPIA Report #1022016
13
Appendices
Appendix 1: Agenda
Day Time Topic Instructor
Day 1 - Saturday, December 05, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 9:30
Introduction, Purdue-USWDP Agribusiness efforts, Purpose of the Ag Sector Needs Assessment, Training Logistics
Hamid Faisal
9:30 – 10:30 Pre-test
Dr. Khyber Survey design and methodology
10:45 – 11:00 Tea break
11:00 – 12:00 Design and development of a questionnaire Dr. Khyber
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
Introduction to Qualitative Research
Defined and Explained Dr. Donald Breazeale
Nature of Qualitative Research
Develop Explanations of Social Phenomena
Methods of Collecting Qualitative Data
Interaction with Individuals or Groups
01:00 – 03:30 Interviews
Unstructured, Semi-Structured and Structured
Focus Groups
Requires Collective Discussion
Action Research
Practical Interventions
IPIA Report #1022016
14
Day 2 – Sunday, December 06, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 10:45 Pre-testing and Survey methods Dr. Khyber
10:45 – 11:00 Tea break
11:00 – 12:00 Data Collection Dr. Khyber 12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 – 03:30
Balkh Agribusiness Sector Survey
Dr. Donald Breazeale
Overview of Questionnaire
Approach to Private Sector
Interview Practice
Group Interviews
Discuss the list of Ag sector firms Hamid Faisal Call 10 target companies for the next
day visit
Day 3 – Monday,
December 07, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 12:00 Interviews Don, Hamid & Faculty Members
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 - 04:00 Interviews Faculty Members
4:00 - 4:30 Data Entry and Submission of questionnaires to Hamid Faisal Hamid & Faculty Members
Day 4 – Tuesday, December 08, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 12:00 Interviews Don, Hamid & Faculty Members
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 - 04:00 Interviews Faculty Members
4:00 - 4:30 Data Entry and Submission of questionnaires to Hamid Faisal Hamid & Faculty Members
IPIA Report #1022016
15
Day 5 – Wednesday, December 09, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 12:00 Interviews Don, Hamid & Faculty Members
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 - 04:00 Interviews Faculty Members
4:00 - 4:30 Data Entry and Submission of questionnaires to Hamid Faisal Hamid & Faculty Members
Day 6 – Thursday, December 10, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 12:00 Interviews Don, Hamid & Faculty Members
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 - 04:00 Interviews Faculty Members
4:00 - 4:30 Data Entry and Submission of questionnaires to Hamid Faisal Hamid & Faculty Members
Day 7 – Saturday, December 12, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 12:00 Data Entry and Summary of the questionnaires
Don, Hamid & Faculty Members
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 - 03:00 Meeting with Chancellor Alkozai Don, Hamid & Faculty Members
Day 8 – Sunday,
December 13, 2015
8:30 – 9:00 Registration Hamid Faisal
9:00 – 12:00 Develop a plan for conducting Ag sector assessments at Kandahar, Khost, Kunduz and Nangarhar
All
12:00 – 01:00 Lunch and Prayer break
01:00 - 03:00 Reimbursements, Training Evaluation forms, USWDP forms, and award of Certificates
Hamid Faisal
IPIA Report #1022016
16
Appendix 2: Survey Questionnaire
Balkh University Faculty of Agriculture, Agriculture Sector Needs Assessment
Date / تاریخ _______________________ Enumerator’s Name نام شمارنده یا پرسشگر / __________________________ Enumerator’s phone number شماره تلیفون پرسشگر _____________________
1. Business name نام فابریکھ یا شرکت/ ___________________________________________
2. Business Address/ ادرس شرکت _______________________________________________
3. Name of the interviewee/ نام مصاحبھ شونده ______________________________________
4. Title in the business / مقام در شرکت ___________________________________________
13. Where do you sell your products? (check all that apply): محصوالت تولیدی بھ کجاھا فروختھ و توزیع میگردد؟ (تمام موارد مرتبط انتخاب شود)
Direct distribution to consumer توزیع مستقیم بھ مصرف کننده / Local markets مارکیتھای محلی / Wholesalers/Distributer عمده فروشان و توزیع کنندگان/ Exported; Country (ies) include: صادرات: کشورھای شامل /
14. What are production capacities and current production levels? If not currently at capacity, what are the challenges:
و سطح تولید روزانھ فابریکھ را یاد آور گردیده و چالشھایی کھ سطح تولید روزانھ با ظرفیت تولیدی ظرفیت تولیدی فابریکھ فابریکھ مساوی نیست را عنوان کنید.
15. What technologies are absent or could improve processes: بود بخشد:تکنالوجیھای تولید و پروسس غایب کھ میتوانند سطح تولید و پروسس را بھ
16. How do owner/operators receive information/training on current and new production practices مالکان و یا کارکنان فابریکھ، معلومات و آموزشھای الزم را در بخشھای مختلف تولید چگونھ بدست می آورند
IPIA Report #1022016
18
17. When technical assistance is needed, it is: ھنگام نیاز بھ کمکھای تخنیکی، این کمکھا :
Unavailable موجود نیست/ Available locally در محیط و منطفھ موجود است/ Technical assistance is not needed. نیازی بھ این کمکھا نیست/
Technical assistance is sought outside of Afghanistan افغانستان جستجومیشود/ در خارج از
18. How are potential new employees recruited and selected? کارکنان جدید چکونھ استخدام و یا انتخاب میگردند؟
20. Have you used the university as a source of technical assistance or employee recruitment? آیا تا بھ حال از پوھنتوت بعنوان منبع کمکھای تخنیکی و یا استخدام کارکنان استفاده نمود اید؟
Never ھیچگاه/
Rarely /بھ ندرت From time to time /بعضی اوقات
Regularly بطور مرتب/
IPIA Report #1022016
19
If you hire university graduates, do they meet your skill need? کھ شما ضرورت دارید برآورده میتواند؟اگر شما فارغ التحصیالن پوھنتون ھا را استخدام میکنید، پس آیا آنھا نیاز مھارتھای الزم
No خیر Yes بلی
21. Does your firm interact with the university? If, so, how? Are there support activities or employment training that could be provided to you by the university?
مکاری/تشریک مساعی دارد؟ اگر بلی، چطور؟ آیا نیاز بھ کدام آموزش در رابطھ بھ کاریابی یا آیا شرکت شما با پوھنتون کدام ھ ھم دیگر موارد کھ پوھنتون میتواند حمایت کند دارید؟
22. Would you be willing to accept interns from the university?
؟ قبول نمایدتون از پوھن میخواھید محصلین "کار آموز" راآیا
No خیر Yes بلی _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
IPIA Report #1022016
20
Section Two Skills, Qualities and Experiences Needed
الزم دوم: مھارتھا، خصوصیت و تجارببخش
QUESTION: How required would employees with the following skills, qualities and experiences be to your company?
چقدر مورد نیاز شرکت شما است؟ تجارب ذیلسوال: موجودیت کارکنان با داشتن مھارتھا، خصوصیات و
1 2 3 4
Not Important
Somewhat Important
Important
Very Important
N/A
تا حدی مھم ھیچ مھم نیست است
بیسیار مھم مھم است است
مورد ندارد/پاسخ وجود ندارد
Business and Economics Skills
مھارتھای تجارتی و اقتصادی
1 Sales and Marketing فروشات و بازاریابی
2 Management مدیریت
3 Human resource planning and Management مدیریت منابع بشری
4 Finance and Accounting مالی و حسابداری
5 Inventory Management مدیریت ذخیره / گدام داری
IPIA Report #1022016
21
Computer and Management Information Skills مھارت ھای کمپیوتر و تکنالوجی معلوماتی
1 Microsoft Office programs (e.g. word processing, spreadsheets, data bases) برنامھ ھای کمپیوتر (ورلد، ایکسل، دیتابیس)
2 Use computers in managerial decision-making استفاده از کمپیوتر در تصمیم گیری مدیریتی
3 Information Technology (IT) تکنالوجی معلوماتی
Technical Skills مھارت ھای تخنیکی
1 Crop production Knowledge دانش تولید غلھ جات
2 Animal production knowledge دانش تولید گوشت و مالداری
3 Food processing technology تکنالوجی پروسس مواد غذایی
4 Transportation and distribution of Agriculture products توزیع و ترانسپورتیشن محصوالت زراعتی
IPIA Report #1022016
22
Communication Skills مھارت ھای ارتباطات
1 Good Listener and Instructor رھنما کننده خوبشنوینده و
2 Express creative ideas verbally and in writing اظھار نظریات/اندیشھ ھای خالق
3 Professional telephone skills با مشتریان –مھارتھای حرفھ ای تیلیفون
4 Write technical reports, memos and letters نوشتن راپور ھای تخنیکی، یادداشت ھا و مکتوب ھا
5 Foreign language skills (English Language) مھارت لسان خارجی (انگلیسی)
6 E-mail writing skills مھارت نوشتن و بلدیت با ایمیل
Personal Qualities خصوصیات شخصی
1 Loyalty to the organization وفاداری بھ شرکت
2 Positive work attitude / personality / ability to work hard روش و رفتار مثبت / شخصیت خوب / توانایی انجام کارھای دشوار
3 High moral / ethical standard روحیھ باال / اخالق خوب
4 Work without supervision Self-confidence and ability “to take a chance” and handle stress / failure
IPIA Report #1022016
23
توانایی انجام کار بدون نظارت / اعتماد بھ نفس / اداره کردن فشار روانی، ناکامی
5 Provide leadership and make decisions توانایی رھبریت و تصمیم گیری
Any other needed skills specific to the business identified by the owner/operator:
کارکنان مھم دیگر شناسای شده و پیشنھاد میشود: یا مھارتھای الزم دیگری کھ توسط مالک فابریکھ
Average Part 1: Workshop/Training The workshop/training objectives were met. 4.6 The length of the workshop/training was appropriate. 4.6 The content of this workshop/training was relevant to your job. 4.7 The overall quality of the workshop/training was good. 4.3 You received enough information before the workshop/training. 4.0 The facility where the workshop/training was held was appropriate 4.3
Average Part 2: Workshop/Training Materials: The workshop materials were useful. 4.6 You are likely to use the workshop materials in the future. 4.6 The quantity of the training materials was appropriate. 3.9
Average Part 3: Workshop/Training Trainers: Dr. Donald Breazeale 4.4 Dr. Khyber Khishki 3.5 Hamid Faisal 4.9
IPIA Report #1022016
28
Appendix 6: Balkh Support letter
IPIA Report #1022016
29
Appendix 7: Photos
Dr. Donald Breazeale (Purdue University) trains faculty members on conducting the ag sector needs assessment survey at Balkh Province
IPIA Report #1022016
30
Professor Mohammad Taib (Nangarhar University) and Senior Teaching Assistant Rafiullah Rahimzai interview one another to pilot test the survey questionnaire.
Groups A, B, and C work on entering survey data into a spreadsheet.
IPIA Report #1022016
31
The president of Almobashir food processing company gives a tour of the production unit to the faculty members
Dr. Donald Breazeale, Hamid Faisal, Rafizullah Rahimzai (Nangarhar University) and Professor Mohammad Arif Shamshi (Balkh University) visits Afghan Soybean Factory at Balkh Province
IPIA Report #1022016
32
Group photo
Group photo with Professor Mukmel Alkozai “Chancellor of Balkh University”