SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 1 6th
Hawthorn to Ivy I Surveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to vvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to walk on the sidewalk here at night 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 2 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 1 6th
Hawthorn to Ivy I SUlveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to valk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to walk on the sidewalk here at night 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 2 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 1 6th
Hawthorn to Ivy I SUlveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to valk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to walk on the sidewalk here at night 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 2 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 1 6th
Hawthorn to Ivy I SUlveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to valk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to walk on the sidewalk here at night 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 2 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 1 6th
Hawthorn to Ivy I SUlveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to valk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to walk on the sidewalk here at night 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 2 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 1 6th
Hawthorn to Ivy I SUlveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to valk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to walk on the sidewalk here at night 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 2 of 9
Advan
ced S
treet Lightin
g T
echnolo
gies A
ssessmen
t Pro
ject
Typ
ical T
hro
ug
h-S
treet T
est S
heet (T
est A
rea
1 S
ho
wn
)
Clan
ton amp
Asso
ciates In
c Pag
e 50
January 4
2010
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 3 Laurel Intersection
I Surveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to Vvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to cross the street here as a pedestrian 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 4 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 3 Laurel Intersection
I Surveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It wculd be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to fvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to cross the street here as a pedestrian 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 4 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 3 Laurel Intersection
I Surveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It would be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to fvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to cross the street here as a pedestrian 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 4 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 3 Laurel Intersection
I Surveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It would be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to fvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to cross the street here as a pedestrian 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 4 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 3 Laurel Intersection
I Surveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It would be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to fvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to cross the street here as a pedestrian 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 4 of 9
SD Nighttime Street Lighting Subjective Evaluation TEST AREA 3 Laurel Intersection
I SUlveyor
51 Weather conditions --- Clear __ Cloudy __ Rain__ Fog __
S2 Ground conditions --- Streets Dry __ Streets Wet __
All of the statements in the table below (except 1) refer to the lighting of the immediate area around you during darkness Please rate your level of agreement vvith each of the foliovving statements about the lighting on a 1 to 5 scale with 1 being strongly disagree and 5 being strongly agree
Statements Strongly Disagree Neutral Strongly Dont
Agree Know
1 It would be safe to walk here alone during daylight 1 2 3 4 5 OK
2 It VvOuld be safe to fvalk here alone during darkness hours 1 2 3 4 5 OK 3 The lighting is comfortable 1 2 3 4 5 OK
4 There is too much light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK 5 There is not enough light on the street 1 2 3 4 5 OK
6 The light is uneven (patchy) 1 2 3 4 5 OK 7 The light sources are glaring 1 2 3 4 5 OK
8 It would be safe to cross the street here as a pedestrian 1 2 3 4 5 OK 9 I cannot tell the colors of things due to the lighting 1 2 3 4 5 OK
10 The lighting enables safe vehicular navigation 1 2 3 4 5 OK 11 I like the color of the light 1 2 3 4 5 OK
12 I would like this style lighting on my city streets 1 2 3 4 5 OK
13 How does the lighting in this area compare vvith the lighting of similar city streets at night
Much worse Worse About the same Better Much Better
14 Write additional comments below
Page 4 of 9
Advan
ced S
treet Lightin
g T
echnolo
gies A
ssessmen
t Pro
ject
Typ
ical In
terse
ction
Test S
heet (T
est A
rea
3 S
ho
wn
)
Clan
ton amp
Asso
ciates In
c Pag
e 51
January 4
2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
80 Appendix B Site Measurements
Test Area 1 Site Measurements
Figure 27 Nighttime and Daytime Photos of Test Area 1
I v y
6th Avenue
S t
Balboa Park
Figure 28 Test Area 1 Measured Photopic False Color Rendering
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 52
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 1 - Photopic and Scotopic Data
POLE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 POLE P S P S P S P S
32 38 29 35 22 26 15 17
21 26 21 25 17 2
12 24
12 14 12 13 1
11 08 09
07 07 06 07 06 06 06 06
04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04
03 03 04 03 04 04 04 04
03 02 03 03 04 04 05 05
03 02 04 03 05 05 07 07
03 02 04 03 05 05 07 08
03 03 04 04 06 06 09 1
03 02 04 04 05 05 08 09
03 02 04 04 06 06 08 09
03 02 04 03 05 05 07 07
03 02 04 03 05 04 05 05
04 04 04 04 04 04 05 04
06 06 06 06 06 06 06 06
12 13 11 12 1
11 08 09
21 24 1
21 15 17 11 12
27 34 24 29 19 23 13 16
Ivy
Stre
et
P 14 08 07 05 04 04 06 08 12 14 13 12 08 06 05 05 06 08 09 S 11 09 07 05 04 04 06 09 13 16 16 14 09 06 04 05 06 09 025 P 07 06 05 04 04 04 06 1 15 19 19 16 1 06 05 04 05 06 06 S P S P S
07 04 04 03 02
07 04 03 02 02
05 03 03 03 02
04 03 03 03 02
03 03 03 03 02
04 04 04 04 04
06 07 07 07 07
11 12 14 12 14
18 2
24 21 26
23 29 36 31 38
22 3
36 32 39
18 22 26 23 28
11 12 14 12 15
07 07 07 07 07
04 04 04 04 04
04 04 03 03 03
05 04 03 03 02
07 04 04 03 02
07 04 04 03 03
POLE Balboa Park
Test Area 1 - Luminance Data
POLE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 POLE Lum 086 052 039 019 011 009 008 008 008 008 008 007 01 01 014 015 028 046 065
Ivy
Stre
et Lum 076 048 031 019 014 01 013 012 013 011 012 012 012 01 011 017 031 041 072
Lum 053 039 025 017 012 01 011 012 014 016 015 016 011 012 012 015 025 03 046 Lum 038 032 021 014 012 012 012 016 019 023 021 02 022 013 016 016 022 027 044 Lum 024 022 018 013 011 011 014 021 028 031 03 028 02 016 015 013 016 022 022 Lum 015 017 014 011 013 011 017 025 037 046 043 036 024 016 011 011 014 017 02 Lum 01 009 009 008 009 011 017 028 049 068 065 046 03 016 011 01 011 012 011 Lum 008 007 008 007 009 01 015 027 054 074 085 051 029 018 008 009 009 008 01
POLE
Balboa Park
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 53
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 2 Site Measurements
Figure 29 Nighttime and Daytime Photos of Test Area 2
J u n i p e r
S t
6th Avenue
Balboa Park
Figure 30 Test Area 2 Measured Photopic False Color Rendering
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 54
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 2 - Photopic and Scotopic Data POLE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Juni
per S
treet
P 02 02 02 01 02 03 05 11 33 3 29 19 09 05 03 02 02 03 02 S P S P S
02 03 03 05 05
02 03 03 04 04
02 02 03 03 04
01 02 02 03 02
03 02 03 02 03
03 03 04 03 04
07 05 07 05 06
15 11 15 09 12
31 21 29 17 23
41 28 37 21 28
4 27 37 21 28
26 17 24 14 2
12 08 11 07 1
06 04 06 04 06
03 03 04 03 04
02 02 03 02 03
02 02 03 02 03
02 03 04 04 06
03 03 04 05 06
P 07 06 06 04 02 03 04 07 12 15 15 11 06 04 03 02 04 06 07 S 08 06 08 05 02 03 05 09 17 2 2 15 08 05 04 03 05 08 1 P 15 11 06 04 02 02 03 04 06 07 07 06 04 03 03 04 05 09 14 S P S P S
2 21 27 26 34
14 15 19 18 24
08 08 11 09 12
05 04 05 04 06
02 02 03 02 03
02 02 02 02 01
04 02 03 02 02
05 03 04 02 03
08 04 05 03 04
09 05 06 03 04
1 05 07 03 05
08 05 04 03 04
06 03 04 02 03
04 02 03 02 02
04 03 04 03 04
05 04 05 04 06
07 06 08 07 1
13 12 17 15 21
19 2
27 25 34
P 29 2 09 05 03 02 03 02 02 02 02 02 02 02 03 04 08 17 28 POLE POLE
Balboa Park
Test Area 2 - Luminance Data POLE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Juni
per S
treet
Lum 008 008 007 006 007 011 015 032 051 063 063 046 021 009 009 008 006 006 007 Lum 01 01 008 007 007 011 015 03 049 07 066 038 021 012 -9 007 008 01 01 Lum 012 011 009 007 007 009 012 021 041 051 042 032 018 011 009 008 012 012 018 Lum 018 015 01 007 007 008 01 02 033 037 034 026 014 013 01 008 01 014 024 Lum 03 035 02 012 009 009 01 014 02 022 023 021 013 011 011 011 016 024 047 Lum 052 038 023 014 01 008 008 011 014 017 017 018 01 009 01 014 021 034 058 Lum 072 046 03 014 01 009 009 01 01 016 015 013 01 011 013 016 016 053 086
POLE POLE Balboa Park
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 55
January 4 2010
Figure 1 Nighttime and Daytime Photos of Test Area 4
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 4 Site Measurements
Figure 31 Nighttime and Daytime Photos of Test Area 4
6th Avenue
P a l m
S t
Balboa Park
Figure 32 Test Area 4 Measured Photopic False Color Rendering
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 56
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 4 - Photopic and Scotopic Data
POLE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 POLE P S P S P S P S
5 69 14 17 04 04 06 08
47 64 09 09 03 03 03 03
29 39 05 06 02 02 02 01
14 18 03 03 02 01 01 01
06 07 03 04 01 0
01 0
03 03 02 02 01 0
01 0
01 01 01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0 0 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 01
01 0
01 0
01 0
02 01
01 0
01 0
01 01 02 02
01 0
01 0
01 0
02 01
01 0
01 0
01 0
01 01
02 02 01 01 01 0
01 0
05 06 02 02 01 0
01 0
12 17 03 04 01 01 01 01
38 26 04 05 02 01 01 01
43 64 07 1
02 02 02 02
48 67 11 14 02 03 04 04
Pal
m S
treet
P 03 02 02 01 01 01 01 01 01 01 02 06 02 01 01 01 01 02 02 02 S 03 02 01 01 0 0 0 0 0 01 02 07 02 01 01 01 01 01 02 02 P 02 02 02 01 01 01 01 01 02 02 03 04 04 03 03 03 03 02 01 01 S P S P S
02 02 02 02 02
01 02 01 02 01
01 01 01 01 01
0 01 0
01 01
0 01 0
02 02
0 01 0
02 02
0 02 02 04 05
01 05 06 07 09
01 07 08 15 2
02 11 14 34 47
03 2
24 64 89
04 29 42 57 81
04 3
37 8
57
03 2
28 39 54
03 16 22 2
28
03 1
13 11 15
03 04 05 07 1
01 02 02 05 06
01 02 01 03 03
01 01 01 02 02
POLE
Balboa Park
Test Area 4 - Luminance Data
POLE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 POLE Lum 15 127 104 045 021 012 005 005 003 004 004 004 003 004 005 01 014 083 132 2
Pal
m S
treet
Lum 053 022 015 012 009 007 004 003 003 003 004 005 003 003 004 014 01 016 019 035 Lum 014 01 006 006 004 003 003 003 004 003 004 005 005 004 003 016 004 006 006 008 Lum 027 011 007 004 004 003 003 003 004 004 006 006 006 004 003 008 003 005 007 011 Lum 009 009 006 004 003 003 003 003 003 004 007 017 007 004 004 004 004 005 008 007 Lum 007 006 005 004 003 003 004 003 006 005 009 012 011 009 008 007 008 007 005 004 Lum 008 006 005 004 003 004 006 013 024 033 052 083 093 062 044 028 013 008 006 05 Lum 007 007 006 006 005 008 012 021 052 122 167 166 169 111 057 032 023 015 01 005
POLE
Balboa Park
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 57
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 6 Site Measurements
Figure 33 Nighttime and Daytime Photos of Test Area 6
R e d w o o d
S t
6th Avenue
Balboa Park
Figure 34 Test Area 6 Measured Photopic False Color Rendering
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 58
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 6 - Photopic and Scotopic Data POLE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 P 04 04 04 04 03 04 05 07 09 08 06 05 04 04 04 04 04 S 05 05 06 05 04 06 08 11 13 13 09 07 06 05 05 05 06 P 05 04 04 04 04 04 06 08 1 09 07 05 04 04 05 05 07 S 07 06 05 05 05 06 09 12 14 13 1 07 06 05 07 07 05 P 05 05 04 04 04 05 06 08 09 08 07 05 04 04 05 05 08
Stre
etoo
d
S 08 07 06 06 05 07 09 12 14 13 1 08 06 06 07 07 05 P 06 05 05 04 04 04 06 07 09 08 06 05 04 04 05 06 09 S 1 08 07 06 05 07 09 11 13 13 1 08 06 06 08 09 06 P 08 07 05 03 04 04 05 06 06 06 05 04 04 05 06 08 09
Red
w S 12 1 08 05 05 06 08 09 1 09 08 06 06 07 1 12 14 P 09 07 05 04 03 04 04 05 05 05 05 04 04 05 06 08 1 S 13 1 08 05 05 06 06 08 08 08 07 06 06 07 09 12 14 P 09 07 05 04 03 04 04 04 04 04 03 04 04 04 06 08 1 S 13 1 07 05 05 05 06 06 06 07 04 05 05 06 08 12 14 P 08 06 05 03 03 03 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 04 05 08 09 S 12 1 07 04 04 04 05 06 06 06 05 05 05 06 07 12 14
POLE POLE Balboa Park
Test Area 6 - Luminance Data POLE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Red
woo
dS
treet
Lum 012 019 011 011 01 012 011 015 026 031 024 017 015 014 011 012 016 Lum 023 017 013 011 011 011 014 016 027 032 032 023 018 012 015 014 02 Lum 018 016 013 01 012 012 014 016 026 031 025 02 016 014 014 014 021 Lum 021 017 013 01 012 011 013 019 02 028 026 021 016 015 015 017 024 Lum 015 014 014 01 012 014 02 025 032 019 017 013 015 012 014 028 026 Lum 013 015 012 011 012 017 018 024 025 015 016 012 012 012 015 023 024
POLE POLE Balboa Park
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 59
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 7 Site Measurements
Figure 35 Nighttime and Daytime Photos of Test Area 7
6th Avenue
Balboa Park
Figure 36 Test Area 7 Measured Photopic False Color Rendering
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 60
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area 7 - Photopic and Scotopic Data POLE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 P 07 07 07 07 09 11 17 31 58 76 61 35 18 12 11 11 1 06 07 07 S 04 04 04 06 06 08 12 23 43 58 47 26 13 09 07 07 06 05 04 04 P 09 08 08 09 09 11 17 29 43 67 5 3 18 12 11 11 11 07 09 09 S 06 05 05 06 06 08 12 22 32 51 39 22 13 08 07 07 07 05 06 06 P 12 1 09 09 1 11 16 23 32 51 41 24 17 12 11 12 12 09 12 14 S 08 06 06 06 06 08 11 17 23 39 31 18 12 08 07 08 08 06 08 09 P 15 13 11 1 1 11 14 18 25 36 33 19 15 12 11 12 13 11 15 21 S 1 08 07 07 07 07 1 14 18 27 25 14 1 08 08 08 09 08 1 14 P 24 17 14 11 11 11 12 13 18 24 25 13 1 11 12 13 14 17 23 34 S 16 11 09 08 07 07 09 1 13 18 19 1 07 08 08 09 09 13 16 24 P 33 23 16 12 1 1 11 11 15 17 19 11 09 1 09 12 14 21 29 44 S 23 16 11 08 07 07 07 08 1 12 14 07 06 06 05 08 09 14 2 32 P 41 28 18 12 1 09 09 09 1 11 12 08 08 08 1 11 14 21 35 56 S 29 2 12 08 06 06 06 06 07 08 08 05 05 05 06 07 09 14 25 4 P 43 32 17 12 09 08 08 07 07 08 08 07 08 07 09 1 13 2 4 62 S 31 23 12 08 06 05 05 04 04 05 05 04 05 04 05 06 09 14 29 45
POLE POLE Balboa Park
Test Area 7 - Luminance Data POLE
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Lum 022 019 02 02 022 03 032 097 152 2 16 085 046 036 031 029 032 026 021 023 Lum 027 026 024 023 024 026 051 077 112 181 135 073 043 035 031 033 03 029 026 027 Lum 036 03 026 026 026 027 04 054 078 094 098 065 04 031 032 032 036 033 031 042 Lum 048 035 029 029 029 032 04 048 062 096 093 048 035 033 031 031 038 036 037 053 Lum 062 041 039 03 026 025 031 034 049 062 064 031 031 028 03 034 038 043 053 09 Lum 081 065 039 029 025 024 027 025 038 042 047 029 025 025 031 032 037 054 067 11 Lum 098 07 044 032 026 021 022 022 026 031 034 027 022 022 026 028 039 054 085 135 Lum 119 095 044 031 023 024 02 019 021 024 022 018 022 018 024 025 034 047 09 15 POLE POLE
Balboa Park
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 61
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Nighttime System Comparison Intersections (Test Areas 3 5 8)
Figure 37 Test Area 3
Figure 38 Test Area 5
Figure 39 Test Area 8
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 62
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Nighttime System Comparison Roadway (Test Areas 1 2 4 6 7)
Figure 40 Test Area 1
Figure 41 Test Area 2
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 63
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Nighttime System Comparison Roadway (Test Areas 1 2 4 6 7)
Figure 42 Test Area 4
Figure 43 Test Area 6
Figure 44 Test Area 7
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 64
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Typical Luminous Scene Recorded with RLMMS
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 65
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
90 Appendix C Site Calculations
Road and Pedestrian Conflict Area Criteria for R3 Pavement
Illuminance (lux)
Uniformity Ratio
EavgEmin
Veiling Luminance Ratio
LvmaxLavg Road Pedestrian Conflict Area
Expressway High 14 30 03 Medium 12 30 03 Low 9 30 03
Major High 17 30 03 Medium 13 30 03 Low 9 30 03
Collector High 12 40 04 Medium 9 40 04 Low 6 40 04
Local High 9 60 04 Medium 7 60 04 Low 4 60 04
Table 16 IESNA RP-8 Illuminance Criteria Table
Road and Pedestrian Conflict Area Average Luminance
Lavg (cdm2)
Uniformity Ratio
LavgLmin
Uniformity Ratio
LmaxLmin
Veiling Luminance
Ratio
LvmaxLavg Road Pedestrian Conflict Area
Expressway High 10 30 50 03 Medium 08 30 50 03 Low 06 35 60 03
Major High 12 30 50 03 Medium 09 30 50 03 Low 06 35 60 03
Collector High 08 30 50 04 Medium 06 35 60 04 Low 04 40 80 04
Local High 06 60 100 04 Medium 05 60 100 04 Low 03 60 100 04
Table 17 IESNA RP-8 Luminance Criteria Table
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 66
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Test Area IESNA RP-8 Luminance Criteria Met
IESNA RP-8 Illuminance Criteria Met
1 Induction Collector Low Collector Medium 2 Induction Collector Low Collector Low 3 Induction Collector Low Collector Low 4 LED None None 5 LED Collector Medium Collector Low 6 LED None None 7 HPS (roadway) Major High Major High 8 HPS (intersection) Major High Major High
Table 18 Lighting Systems IESNA Criteria Met
In Table 18 note that while there is a general correlation between the lsquoIlluminancersquo method and the lsquoLuminancersquo method in what level of roadway design is met Test Area 1 shows a disagreement based on the two different calculation methods This is in fact not a surprise because the two methods were never effectively calibrated In fact due to the differing calculations that are performed for the two roadway calculation methods it is impossible to calibrate them so that the calculations will always agree
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 67
January 4 2010
Area by Question
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
100 Appendix D Subjective Survey Results
Ninety five percent confidence intervals were constructed around the mean score for each statement These intervals were also compared across the lighting types Significant differences for responses to the systems are determined by comparing confidence intervals When the intervals do not overlap the difference is considered statistically significant at the 95 confidence level
It is important to note that a statistically significant difference refers to differences in results that most likely (with 95 certainty) did not occur by chance It does not mean that the differences are significant in the practical sense of the word Additionally a difference that is not considered statistically significant does not mean that it may not be important
The confidence intervals for all of the survey statements are shown in the following figures
Respon
se Value
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
S1 S2 S3
Figure 45 Confidence Intervals for Statements S1 S2 and S3
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 68
January 4 2010
S6
Respon
se Value
250
200
150
100
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
300
350
400
450
500
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
S4 S5
Area by Question
Figure 46 Confidence Intervals for Statements S4 S5 and S6
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 69
January 4 2010
S9
Respon
se Value
250
200
150
100
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
300
350
400
450
500
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
S7 S8
Area by Question
Figure 47 Confidence Intervals for Statements S7 S8 and S9
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 70
January 4 2010
S13
Respon
se Value
250
200
150
100
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
300
350
400
450
500
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
Area1
Area2
Area3
Area4
Area5
Area6
Area7
Area8
S10 S11 S12
Area by Question
Figure 48 Confidence Intervals for Statements S10 S11 S12 and S13
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 71
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
110 Appendix E Objective Testing Results
Results of the ANOVA performed on this averaged illuminance data is shown in Table 19 and SNK pairwise comparisons among each lighting type are illustrated in Figure 22 As expected significant differences were found among all lighting types The existing HPS roadway installation had the highest illuminance levels compared to the alternative lighting technologies
Source F-value P-value Significant
Lighting type (Roof sensors only) 11247 lt00001
Lighting Type (Glare Meter Only) 3628 lt00001
Table 19 ANOVA Results for Illuminance Levels for Roof and Glare Sensors for Lighting Locations
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 72
January 4 2010
Sf Goo~E-~ ~
LIGHTING
APPLICABILITY
TeRRITORY
10_ entire IernIory __ by 1he Ulility
- -o 0 (0 )
0 0 10 ) 0 bullbull 10)
0 10lt1 1000) 0 1410 I)
o 0 10 ) 0 0 o 10 ) 0 1 I)
0 o on
0 on o o bull 0 bullbull 10 ) OM (COI ) o 0 10 ) 0 0 bull 10 )
bullbull 0 10)
0 10) 0 141 I)
middot - 0
R_ CaI PU C -tHo 21065-E
m bull
bull om o ~ bull bull om o ~
bull om o ~ bull bull 011 o 12 bull bull 0 O t bull bull om o m bull bull om o ~
bull om o bull o u bull
bull 0 bull bull 0 bull om bull om o w bull om o ~ bull om o 111 I
bull o o oro bull bull om o gt0
bull om o ~ bull bull o o bull bull bull O t bull
sectJf sG ampE-~
Son C_
LI GHTING
APPUCABILfIY
H RRIIORY 11_ entire ernIory __ by he lJiiIy
- - bull 11 bull (1)01) ~ bull 10)
n bull 1~4t 103) o bull -II) 1middot001 bull 1001)
0 bull 1 1 bull bull rO] 10)
0
0 rr o
o bull bull 101) OM 2~ (COI) 00 bull 101) bull 1001) bull bull I) bull 10) o bull IUI
CIoood - Hoi 0 bull m
R_ co PIIC -_ 2H16S-E
alt bull
bull 0 o ~ bull o o ~
bull om o ~ bull 011 0 bull 011 0 1 U bull o 0 bull o ~
bull om o bullbullbull bullbull -
bull om 0 bull bullbull bull o o w bull O o o o bull o o ~ bull o bull o on bull o o bull 11
SDof G ~ E- ~
Son c_
LI GHTING
APpUCAIILrD
UR RIIOBY
w_ entire em __ by he lJiiIy
- -OM 101)
bull (1)01) ~ IOmiddotl
bull 1~4t (IHn) oro bull -II) 11
OM 1 1 0 1 1 bull 1 10)
bullbull 0 U I
0 rr 101) OM 2~ (D ~ I ) 000 101)
1001) bull I) 10)
un lUll
- - bull m
R_ co PIIC -_ 2100S-E
alt bull
bull W ~ bull ~ ~
bull m ~ bull 011 12 bull 011 0 u bull bull 0 bull ~
bull m bullbullbull
bull bull bullbull _
bull 0 bull bullbull bull bull bullbull bull bull ro bull ~ ~ bull ~ bull w ~ bull bull 11 ~
sectJf G ~ EIocraquoo ~
Son c_
LI GHTING
APPUCAILrD
U RRIIOBY
11_ entire emIory __ by he lJIiily
- -OM
101)
bull (1)01) ~ 10)
- bull 1~4t (IHn) oro bull -II) I)
OM 11 0 1middot1 bull 1 10)
bullbull 0 U I
0 rr o o 101) OM 2~ (D ~I)
101) 101) bull I)
10) lUll
- - bull m
_ co PIIc -_ 2100S-E
alt bull
bull W ~ bull O~ ~
bull w ~ bull 011 0 12 bull 011 0 ~ bull 0 bull bull = bull bullbullbull
bullbull bullbull bull 0 bullbull bull o o w bull O o bull o oro bull o o ~ bull o~ bull o w ~ bull o o bull bull 11 0 ~
sectJf G amp EIomo ~
Son c_
U GHTING
APPUCAILrD
U RRIIOBY
11_ OM entire temIory __ by he lJIiily
- -OM
101)
(1)01)
~ I) ~ 1~4t (IHn) oro -II) 11
OM 1 1 0 Inl l bull 1 10)
bullbull on H I
0 rr o
o
1001)
~M (D ~ I ) ore 1 01) ~ 101) bull I)
10) 410 lUl l
- m
_
11_ co PIIC -_ 2100S-E
--
alt bull
bull 0ltgt ~ bull ~ ~
bull m ~ bull 0_11 0_ 12 bull 0_11 0 1 bull m 0 bull bull bull m bullbullbull
bullbull bullbull -
bull 0 0 bull o o w bull O o ~ bull om oro bull o ~ bull o~ bull o ~ bull o o bull bull _II
11000
sectJf G amp EIomo ~
Son c_
U GHTING
APPUCAILrD
U RRIIOBY
11_ OM entire temIory __ by he Uliily
- -OM
101)
bull (1)01) ~ IW)
- 1~4t (IHn) bull 1-0 I)
OM 1 1 0 Inl l bull 1 102)
bullbull on -
0 rr 1001) OM ~M (D ~ I I ore 1 01) 101) bull IW)
= 10) 410 lUl l
-
_
11_ COO PIIC -_ 2100S-E
--
alt bull
bull m ~ bull ~ ~
bull m ~ bull 0_11 0_ 12 bull 0_11 - bull m 0 bull bull ~
bull m 0
bullbull bullbull -
bull 0 ~
bull w bull ~ bull - ro bull ~ bull bull ~ bull ~ bull bull bull _II bull
11000
sectJf G amp EIomo ~
Son c_
U GHTING
APPUCAILrD
U RRIIOBY
11_ OM entire temIory __ by he lJIiily
- -OM
101)
bull (1)01) ~ IW)
~ 1~4t (IHn) bull 1-0 11
OM 1 1 0 Inl l bull 1 102)
bullbull on -
0 rr 1001) OM ~M (D ~ I I ore 1 01) 101) bull IW)
= 10) 410 lUl l
-
_
11_ COO PIIC -_ 2100S-E
--
alt bull
bull ~ bull ~ ~
bull m ~ bull 0_11 12 bull 0_11 _10 bull 0 0 bull bull ~
bull m 0
bullbull bullbull -
bull 0 ~
bull w bull ~ bull - ro bull ~ 0gt ~ bull bull ~ bull w ~ bull bull bull _II bull
11000
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
120 Appendix F SDGampE LS-2 Rate Schedule
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 73
January 4 2010
bullbull ~
o o bull I o bullbull o bull on bull bull bullbull bull o bull L
m~ ~ bullbull
bullbull - bullbullbull bull bullbull bull - bull - bullbull bull ~
Strtt StnrIgt -- bullbull - bullbull - bullbull
---~
~ ~ ~ =
(llQ1j ~ = (IIjl1 ~ = ~ ~ ~ = ~ = ~ ~ -
bull bull bull bull bullbull I~OI ~ bullbull fO(lll R bullbull (O(lll R bullbull
---shy_-
o q o = o bull = bullbull o ~ bull o bullbull I bull bullbull bull
00 bull
bull bull
0 01 -0
bullbull bullbull W bull O O
~
bullbull bull
_--------
lGl1TllG STJIEET oNQ I1IGHWY bull ctlSTOllElH)NlIED IiSTAUAIJONS
_l_
llGi1JllG middot mEET H[) ltlGHWy CVSIQIlElH)NlIED IliSTAUAIKlIiS
---
---
llGi1JllGmiddot mEET Hi[) HtGHWy CVSIQIlElH)NlIED IliSTALAIKlIiS
---
llGi1JllGmiddot mEET ampH[) HtGHWy CVSIQIlElH)NlIED IliSTALAIKlIiS
---
llGi1JllGmiddot mEET ampH[) HtGHWy CVSIQIlElH)NlIED IliSTALAIKlIiS
---
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 74
January 4 2010
~
j
bull ~
1
I
Fl
~ ~ middot1 o bull lt u
~I ~ I
I ~
-
lt
lt
[
-
O liP1I S ~II _ M~~ M ~ _
Bii811 B15811 6666 6666
fJ1l8t fJ1l8t 0000 0000
H~~ HH ~~~~ ~5~
li il iifl li il iifl 000 _ 000 _
------
66
laquo
~ij oo
~
lt -
I 11 J ~ lII II tI oOO ___ ~M~~
-- 666Bl88 ii 8~ 6666lt36666
oogt1gtl1la~ 000000000000
=-=-=-=-=- ij ~ ~ ~~Hh
~~~Baq8~~~8~ OOO ___ N bull bull bull bull bull bull m
O~fF1 ~U~ 00000000000 _
bull
i I
U iI iu h_ SiliC~
-11 I ~~ ~~ m lli - J -ell li~ -I ilt i
gt k~
o _
- -
l l[~ If l~
I L
I j
j I
-Ii l I
i II
o bull
1
-bull
o
o
I 11 JI ~ 11 1 ~ OOO ___ ~M
g88~ g~8~ ~~ ~~~o ~B 8~a~~8 QOOQ QOQO 00 DO OOO o OOOOO
Ilt1Ii~Bl~8Hli81i Do ___ e NM ~
~lHl l (Il illl 1 _ _ 0-
li l l II II I IIII ~ ~~ ~Sll l
i I I
j
I
i II
o bull
1
-bull
o
I n ~ ~ 111 ~ ooo ___ ~ ~
fJrlSgt fHl S t 1gt po
0 ill iiHl lOillilfl - - 0 -
111ll ll 1111 11111111 ~~ n~lll
bull
i I i
j
I I
i il
o bull
1
-bull
bull
I 111 ~ ~ 111 ~ ooo ___ ~ ~
fJrlSgt ~Hl8t ~t
111 11 11111111111111 ~~ n~lll
bull
i I i
j
I I
i il
o bull
1
-bull
bull
- - - I 1iI~ Ji ~ II I ~ ooo ___ ~ ~
~S8~ g~8~ ~~ ~~ ~ o ~~ a~~~~8 Q~QQ QQQQ PO DO OOOOOOOOOO
lil l lIIIIIIII~ ~~ n~l5l
i I i
j
I I
i II
o bull
1
-bull
o
- - - IIliil Ji~lII I ~ ooo ___ ~ ~
gG8~ g~8~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~8~~~~~ Q~QO OQOQ 00 DO OOOOOOOOOO
0 -
lil l l IIIIIIIIi~ ~~ n~ll
i I i
j
I I
i II
o bull
1
-bull
o
- - - IIliilJi~lII I ~ ooo ___ ~ ~
gG8~ g~8~ ~~ ~~~~~~8~~~~~ Q~QO OQOQ 00 DOOOOOOOOOOO
0 -
lilllIIIIIIIIi~ ~~ n~ll
i I i
j
I I
i II
Adva
nce
d S
tree
t Li
ghting T
echnolo
gie
s Ass
essm
ent
Pro
ject
Pag
e 75
Cla
nto
n amp
Ass
oci
ate
s I
nc
J
anuar
y 4
2010
sect8
f
Son
~ lt
300amp
E-
o
_C
_
LIG
HT
ING
R_
C
oI
PU
C
-H
o_
212
S3-
E
MIl
S (
Co
n_
I
UtiM
y ()
i b~
Com
pIIf
1Y
(UD
e)
Too
R
me
Mo
wn
-
elu
de bull
y
P
ilt_
ltO
OY
nOd
y cI
Iorq
eo
l agt
SO
ltiol
ed _
S
dgted
uIe
EE
CC
an
d S
clle
do
e O
VIR
_BC
100
potm
eltl1
01
W-
lt R
eo
ou
ree
B
on
d C
-g
eI_
I
C
Dir
eltt A
-
cusO
Oll1
eR
e
xem
pt
fro
m
he
TRA
C laquo
gtm
pOne
tl1
bullbull
del
ined
RtlI
e I
_ D
e1ro
tio
ns
l
A F
-
tI
i
Fee
Dil
le
o
f 5
71l
MI
be a
pp
[io
d t
o
he
moo
lhly
bri
r9gt
eamp
rul
alelt
l
--
higt
olt
heW
Ie
10lt
w
ollt
gtm
eB
_he
laquogtIraquo
Ora
te _
he
City
01
San
)
ego
S
uch
Fra_
Fee o
rr
I
be
so
lie
led
am
_
os
_ it
em t
o Igt
il r
en
de
red
to
lt11
wo
lOllle
B
SP
EC
IAL
CO
tlD
lTIO
OS
bull
Re
a1
1o
mp
ot
ter
on
gin
oI m
lOll
b
y laquoI
b_
R
elll
01 g
r
an
d k
ImO
gtaire
eq
uip
mem
II
tIich
d
be
biJ
ed 1
0 O
he 0
0S
0m
ef a
t h
e m
an
camp
ctco
laquos
CU
TlaquoI
tty p
ub
[_ ~ re
taill
p
Ius~ 1
amp
lt
ae
0
1 gr
at
the
0
11
rep
tece
me
nt
_Of
_
ce oerviampe i
s _
to
~ Io
mp
o mo_
by 1he
u
tility
pri
or to
Jo
oe
10
1979
IM
eo
wiI
I
b
e Ju
mio
Io
ed
-e
h
e ~
01
tIW
y
un
du
e _
lt
If
bull
o
Oltgt
Ud ~ b
eca
use
0I~
~ ~ O
f _
Ie
C
Ium
ish
n
otal
l o
wn
m
oin
_
lOA
equi
pmef
11
be
yoO
O
tfle
cetl
ni
po
int
01
co-n
ecIi
on e
(ltlt
pI1o
r
Iin
i1ed
mm
nen
nce
bullbull p
rovO
eltj
1 T
ype
of S
lt1y
k bull
S
etvi
lte
to
roo
1ipi
e Io
mp
o w
il b
e
ppi
eltl
he
bullbull u
bllt
laquo
gtro
d
vo
ltag
e O
f
lthe
opti
on o
f 1h
e u
tHv
48
0 v
ol
S
eM
ce t
o
Io~ w
i be
su
ppli
ed o
oIy ~om e
xist
ing
a
re
bull
1lt9I
n 0
BI
lUIio
o _
wi
b
e r
om
to d
o)l
iQlt
_
i
n
cord
_ h
e ub
fli
ctgt
ng o
eheW
le e
su
in a
ppro
ltir
nolO
ly 4
103
5 bu
min
ltj
Igtoo
rs p
olt
5 R
oIoc
ho
o o
f F
tltW
eo
Rd
oco
_ 0
1 Ut
i~ f
cili
he
laquo
1-
eq
or _
01
~ r
equ
ir
lO
wi
be n
wle
pr-
IIle =
1
P
)3
he
acr
uol
COO
tlI i
oooJ
Ultl
by
1
Ol1
y fo
r o
uch
010lt
__
oa
o
N
o
-
---
----
-
sect8
f
Son
a
amp
E_~
-
~
UG
HIIN
G
R_
C
aIP
UC
-
t
2
12
53
-E
MI
U (C
on
tru
elt
l)
Util
1y
Dis
-n
oo
Com
pany
(U
De
) T
oo
Rat
e sh
own
_
elu
de bull
Y
aJ
pik
ob
le lt
OO
YO
Od
y ~
l agt
SOC
iole
d _
Sch
edul
e pound
EC
C a
nd
Sdl
eltlc
(e [)
IIR
_BC
I~ 0
W3
Ief R
eoltgt
ltou
s B
on
d C
lgtof
9ll_
I
Cer
um
Dir
ect A
cees
s cu
olO
meB
exe
mpt
fro
m 1
Ie
TR
AC
laquogtm
pltgtn
etll
80
ltIe
Iine
d
R
I _
DeI
irltI
iono
l
FllIt
lltoO
se F
ee p
te
rrm
al
A F
nIgt
cI
F
ee [
)il
efen
tal
of
57
6
will
be
0
th
e m
oo
lNy b
poundirgt
p c~ltu1alOd U
IgtIe
lt Ih
io o
che
WIe
fo
lt
l CU$~
hi
h
e ltO
IJgtO
__
al
1he
CO
) o
f S
an D
iog
o
Su
ch F
_
F
ee
rno
reltf
fiJo
lsl
gto
l b
e n
die
ltelt
l am
ad
de
d o
s
_ iI
em t
o 1
41
renlt
eltt
ltd t
o
lt11 ~
spt
CL
IIL
CO
tlD
O
OS
_
RIo
1 01
iIIm
po o
n
0fIII
inaI
_
by laquo1_
b_
R
epia
cem
ltn
o
f gr
a
kr
n01
He
equi
lm
on
-t
lid
lwll
be
trie
d t
o
lt
US
om
eft
to
e ~
-
tty p
ub
I_ IU
W
toil
e plu
s ~ W
elt
lt
Cle~ 0
1 11
3
th
e m
e o
Ilarn
l re
ptac
emen
t
~ la
mp ~ce _
_
to
n
ltaO
Oel
lCen
I iI
Impo
mo
itI8
ine
d I
ly 1
Ie
utii
ity p
rior
J
un
e 10
19
79
Mn
llen
anoe
_
fri
II
b
e Ju
mio
IoeO
_ t
he ~
t
IWy
an
WId
ue
haza
R
Of
_
oOltgt
Ud
~ b
eca
use
0
bOO
~ h
e9gtt
Of
_ 0
C
om
laquo
I r
-
o
taII
O
W
and
_
oA
eqoi
pmM
I IJ
eyoO
O
tile
lte
ltla
I po
int
01
oom
ecbO
O e
ltct
pl1
or
fOlY
i1eltl
-l
ra
~
1 T
5
effi
lte
5e
ltvi
lte
toO
Ot
Jpio
an
po w
il b
e su
PI
ltl
he
bullbull u
bllt
laquo
gtrod
ary _
II Of
op
Iioo
0
tIy
48
0 i
ltlIIgt
S
efY
ilte
to
Ion
vo w
i b
e w
pp
Iied
onl
y ~om o
mtir
oj
_ ci
rltU
D
bull 1
Qf
Burrgt
ioo
5eM
lte
w
it
be
from
to
dofl
i9ll
_ n
O
KC
Ofd
_
1he ub~
ilct
mg
l
e e
su
in o
pprn
xim
oeI
4
16
51
un
nlt
j Igt
oltn
polt
ye
S R
efIX
Q
I F
Klt
ieJ
R
_ l
JIii
ys
falt
Olaquo
ltU
SIo
trlolt
o Je
ltl
Of -
01
~01 r
eqoi
r
lO
riJ
be
mod
e ~ I
Ile c
ut P
III
he
acr
ulll
com
inlt
umltl
by
lthe
uti
lt
for
reI
oc_
0
N 0
---
--------
- -- -
Ii Ii i II iii i I ~ middot I I 1 j I -1 E I j
I I I-I Ill jl I h _ I I I j I I I I
j j h I j ~ i H i middotfli I H I III I I I ~
1
lt
I l ~H
I
I ~ j I j fI II 11 I I J iii l~ illi 1 1i J- bull I II bull i I i l bull ) I ~ I I gt Ij
I ~ fl i I t lj tIll ~ I ~ - t ~ 1 8 ~~ ~~~ l~ ~
II II I i II I I I middot1 -II I Ii 11 II Ii I _I bull 1 1
1- il Ill I I 1- Il 11 111-1-1 i= 11- ~1 Ii ~ g l l middot ~ ~ ti 5 bull ~J ~Ij I~ 1 g 1 bullbull ~ o ~ U b E bull - -
j
II
Ii II
~ 11
i 0 I
- -- -
-
j j II
i 0
~--------------------------~ l
- -- -
~
j j
~
~--------------------------~
-
II
i 0 l
- -- -
j j
e
~--------------------------~
-
II
i 0 l
- -- -
-
j j II
e
i o
0
l
Adva
nce
d S
tree
t Li
ghting T
echnolo
gie
s Ass
essm
ent
Pro
ject
Cla
nto
n amp
Ass
oci
ate
s I
nc
Pag
e 76
J
anuar
y 4
2010
IIG trrlNG STE EET AtgtD HIGHWAY _ CIJSTQ~ E R-OWNEO INSTA l I AllONS
SPcClIIL COtlDlTOOS (COtttinuedI
bull
9 TjmeltI Aux ~ QevM M oolelt This ___ is ovaOable undef condiliom ted beIowltJf a roottffj cIgtorge 01 $06 1 pe- - pi _live ~ 01 $ampl 00 peshyX) pe- ltoo~ac pi c nefIY CIIorQegt biI ed 1he roeo ted in Sclleltlgtle A
a A Sandofd aIioo ilia coo 01 - limed - power lt10_ in Oj on a wotome--owned n ~ pole
b This is on~ ov_ to go ~ -e _orne 01 ro lor OJ -eel ~ _ A _en SeMlte Awkation onlt Ale-ernet11 is required lor _ in 00IjIIflCti0n willi wslCmef_ IighIirlg polegt
e The customer will own and he roq ed timed a)(fiory power _pielt onlt 1he in_timed - power _pOor _ remain 1he IOle p-operty u1 cusomer
d The installation uI he appIic Ightirro ltIecoraliongt _ I be in aecordorllte willi LIii1ygt speciIIeotiom
bull The proYisiom 01 __ 0ilooii be oltoord willi he LIility Rtlle 141 P~ and CurtaiImett Pr-o Section Bl a
t The appIie _ _ opeeity he n umber 01 limed auxiiory power _ requirelt Biling be based on he -unit ltIelaquogtrolioo ~ and 00urgt 01 ~ speci(gtelt1 by 1he appIiea 1he Seltvilte AwJilta_ and A~reemetlt The pe--un _tion W8~_ Il1gt01 laquolaquo1 1he maooacltoreR lOO-watt ling for eaell de
AI he lime 01 _ltliorl 01 _ ibolty power ~ and mootIlly 1herealer ootI such _ auxiliary __ adaplef IIao beef1 ~ 1he wstomer will be required 10 poy
lhe mon~~
00 CMe Mal no 0 oermisoion 10 instal Ied ltleoonolioo for wtI1 0 limed - power _ - 00 he cuotomer-ltgtomed polegt ~ 1he appIiean any aIdiiooolrqltgt
LM~~-==------~~~C ~----_ ===~~~ - CM R OgtDOlt R- ______ _
IIGtmNG S UlEET AtgtO HlGHWAY _ C IJSTOII ER-OWNE O INSTA l I AllON S
S PEC VIL C QljDOO S (Cotrtinued)
bull
9 TjmeltI All ~ tleyilaquo Mrlt nus _ io v~ under the ~ onlt cotIIOOoos Ied below of moolhi) -lIe 01 $O1l1 ~ _ plus on _live ctwqo 0 $00 00 PI 0lt00UgtIgtOf ltOO~OltI_ pM Energy CIIor_ biIod 1he ro totOlt in Slt~ A
bull ~ _ IrIsIo1aioo Ihol coos 01 - Iimed --- powo-r lt100lt in bull 1 00 a ltustorr--ownecI1 nefl IitI1ir01 polo
b This 1111 io ~ _ 10 g- ogeoeieo 1110 0 01 eoord f -eel ~ogxo A _ ~Iion ond Agr_ IS ~ f()( _ in ~_ willgt _ _ -owned IigIgtIing poles
lt Tho ~ and _ tile -q 0lt limed power _pielt onlt 1he tolIed limed -- pow- _plOI 1IoII-emoin 1he solo proporty of the cuSlorrJOf
d Tho _ _ of owIiean1lo r-1lltir9 _ olio_ be in accorOirlttlte willgt iCygt
specikotiom
bull Tho pOoiampioMallln _ be ocoorn willgt 1he tlliiitot RtlIo 141 P- om Ca-toilrnorll PrOYisrons SeltIion Bl bull
f Tho appOcarll _ spoltity nunber 01 limed iory powo-r _ reqJir llltl BiIirgtj be gtnod on Pf-unil lt10lt010100 ~ om oorr 01 oP oOOn __ by awIlt 1he _ AgtpampaOOn om A9feemotJI Tho p-ugt deoonrlion wa~_ 1ho1 eeed 1he manufocliJltoR JOO-watl rating lor ech ltIovice
AI 1he lime 01 Irion 011110 trued ~ power odojl1or om -rIlly ~ UIod ouch trned -- _ odoplft lias beelt1 rerooveltI 1he be eqIRltIlO IY II-e mo~ rhOfQe
In IIltgt case 11 he -- 0 oelmiuioo 10 inotalliol1led lt10001 lor use _ bull timod ruioty pow- _gt10lt _ on _-owned poles q owl _ -lt9
L_ bullbull ~_=~ ____ -~~~ ~ ____ _ ===~~~ - CI- R ~- -------
IIGtmNG S TR EET AND HIGHWAY _ C lJSTOII ER-OVgtNE O INSTAl I AllotJS
S PEC W C OtlDI1OO S (CooIinued)
bull
9 Timelt Au fltgtwelt tleyilaquo MIOIelt lln _ ia va~ under the t=m ond condiIioos taled below of 1OOlltli) -lIe SO1l1 ~ _ plus _live ltIIarqe 0 $ampl 00 po-0lt00UgtIgtOf ltoo~act _ pM Energy CIIor_ biIed the telt in Slt~ A
bull ~ Stanilord in middot Ihol coos1 on - limed --- power ltlelice 0lt1 00 a ltustorr--owned ned ~ polo
b This note ia ~ _ 10 90- ogeocieo life the a reltoltd for _ IighOOg ~ A written Service AppkatJon and Agrm IS ~ for _ oorloolt willgt wlomelt-owned IighIing poles
lt The CUSIltgtrl1elt ~ onlt he roq ted timed U)(i~Y power _pielt ond the _ timed -- pow- _pier ligtoii the sole fly of the CUSlanef
d The _ _ of owIi ~ oeror-o _ _ be in conlalttlaquo willgt illgt specikotioos
e The proyenioioM lin _ be oceornonlte willgt the tlliflty RtlIe 141 P- om Cmell1 Pr- Section BI bull
f The O(IIliiltartl _ speltity nunbef aI limed iory power _ reqJired Bilinj be boiled OIl Pf-unil ltIeltOlO1 w- om oorr oper ___ by the 0(IIliilt the _ Akrloon om A9feemeIlI The p-ugt ltIeoonItioo WlI~_ Iho eeed lMflUIct lJfef JOO-watl raling lor ech ltlevice
AI the lime aI ion 01 the tingted 0lXMfy power - om -dHy thereol-er umi such trned - pow- od_ lias beelt1 ~ the ltus be rltqlRlt110 IY toe ~~ rhOfqe
in the ltnrgttno of 10 installiol1led ltleOOl8IIoo lor wiII1 bull limed ruiofy pow- _gtlei _ OIl the w_-owned poles q the owl _ _ r91
L_ bullbull ~_=~ ____ -~~~ ~----d ===~~~ - R OODOlt R- ______ _
IIGtmNG STR EET AND HIGHWAY _ ClJSTOII ER-OVgtNE O INSTAl I AllotJS
S p ECW COtlQfIlOOS [CooIinued)
bull
9 nW Avril ~ Oevilaquo Moolelt ThIS _ is bullbullbull 1_ under the ond condiIioos ted below of moolhi) -lIe aI SO1l1 ~ ltlevice plus _live ltIIArqe 0 $60 00 pelt 0lt00Ugt1pelt ltoo~act _ pM Energy CIuIrqegt biIed the eo ted in Slt~ A
bull ~ SllInilard 1n latioo Ihol comist alan __ timed - power ltlelice in tallod 00 a ltomelt-owned omoltroeflIol~ed 1itIJ polo
b Thio e is ~ _ 10 90 ogeoltieo e the aI reroltd of _ IigIgt[ng ~ A written Sefvilte Appkolioo ond Agot os reqJired of _ in ~ willgt wlomelt-omed lighting poles
lt The CUSIoIl1eI wiI _ instal he -q ted timed C power _pielt ond the in_ timed -- pow- _pier ligtoii er m the sole propefly oj CUSlon1ef
d The _ Iioo oj the 8(IIliicant3 ~ ltIerora sIIol be in Itlt dartlte willgt itfs speciklltiom
e The prooioioM aI _ _ be in lICoortIonce willgt the tlliflty RtlIe 14 1 prohitJilions -I CImetlI Pr Sec1ion Bl
f The appIicartt _ speltity the nunber aI timed ioIy power _ reqJired Bilinj wiI be boiled on the Pf-unit ltIelaquogtr w~ and 00uIs aI ope ___ by the awIlt the SeMce Ai ea ond A9feemem The p-ugt ltIeoonI1ioo W8~_ sIIo1 001 eeed -octlJfefmiddot JOO-watl rating lor ech ltlevice
AI tho lime aI _ion 01 the imed auxMfy power - ond ly theeo-er IOgtIi trned - pow- adopter lias beelt1 retnIgtoeltI the customer will be ~ 10 IY
the ~~
In case 1 the -nno of oe instal liQl1ted ltleoonolloo lor use wiI11 timed llUXiiory pow- _aer _ on the wSlomef-omed poles q the 8(IIliicant _ _ 191
L_ bullbull ~_=~ ____ -~~~ ~----d ===~~~ - R
R No ______ _
IIGtmNG S TR EET AND H1GlfoiAY _ C USJQII ERQINE O INSTAl I AllotJS
S p ECW COtlQfIlOOS [Coolinued)
bull
9 nW Au f9welt PeYiClO Mooe ThIS _ is vaiable under the ond condiIioos taled below Of rootlltlly -lIe SO1l1 ~ ltleYce plus _live ltIIarqe 0 $60 00 pelt cOOUgtgtOf ltoo~ac _ pM Energy CIIIIrqegt biIed the eo ted in Slt~ A
bull ~ SllInilard 1n latioo Ihol comnt on __ timed - power ltlelice in tallod 00 bull ltustomelt-owned I~ed 1itI1 polo
b Thio e is ~ _ 10 90 ogene life the cuslome -eroltd Of ~ _ 1igIgt[ngme A written Sefvice AppkatJoo ond Agot IS reqJired Of _ in oolnlt_ willgt wlomelt-omed lighting poles
lt Tho IiI _ install he -q ted timed uxi- power _pielt ond Ihe instoned timed -- pow- _pier ligtoii er the sole property oj cusIC
d Tho _ tJoo oj the O(IIliiltarh ~ derorooons silo_ be in conlalttlte willgt -iCygt specffilt1IIiom
bull Tho prOiioioM _ _ be in ocoornaolte willgt the tIIifl RtlIe 141 P- om CImetl Pr Section Bl
f Tho O(IIliiltartt _ specify the nunbef aI timed ioIy power _ reqJired BilinQ wiI be boiled on the Pf-uoil ltIelaquogtralioo wampttagtO ond oon oper1ion __ by the 0(IIli~ the SeMce Ailta ond A9feement Tho P ltIecoratioo wa~_ sIIo1 not eeeltI he octlJfef JOO--watI rating lor bullbull ch ltlevilte
Al tho lime aI _ion 01 the trned ouxMry power - ond ly lhereal IOgtIi trned ouxibry pow- ad_ lias beelt1 rerrIDoeltI Ihe rootornef be r~ 10 IY
the ~i) In cue 11 the no of oe to instal liol1led ltIe lor use wiII1 bull timed auxi1Ot) pow- _Jlef _ 00 the wSlomef-omed poles ~ Ihe O(IIliicont _ _ 191
L_ bullbull ~_=~ ____ -~~~ ~----d ===~~~ - CI- R OIIoDOlt R No ______ _
IIGtmNG S TRE ET AND H1GlfoiAY _ C USJQII ERlgtNE O INSTA l I AllotJS
S p ECW COtlQfIlOOS (Coolinuedl
bull
8 If 0 ~_ IiQhgt e ot ~ 10 ~ GI Ihe
- ~ be ct bull 1Um-on fee 01 $1000 polt 1911 r 0 mniIrltlm
odiion to he _ Re--Eolobhll- Fee ond credit
9 n nell Au f9welt PeYiClO Moolelt ThIS _ is vol_ under he I ond condiIions bled below Of 0 rootlltli) -lIe $1111 1 ~ ltleYco plus _live cIIarqe 0 $60 00 polt CeounlgtOf ltoo~ _ pM Energy CIuIr_ 0lt1 0lt1 in Slt~ A
bull A Stanilard 1n latioo Ihol comnt ~ timed - power ltlelice intallod 00 o ltustomelt-owned I~ed 1iItI1 polo
b Thio e is ~ _ 10 9OvemmeotIII ogene e reroltd Of ~ _ lightlll IIOMclt A written Service Appkatioo ond Agreement IS reqJired Of _ oolnlt_ willgt rusl0me0--omed lighting poles
lt The CUSIomelt IiI __ ttgte roq od timed uxi- ry power _pielt ond Ihe _ timed - pow- _pier Ilgto1l er sole propltr1y ol onlOf
d The -Iotioo 01 the O(gtIlIi ~ oero-o sIIol be dartlte with -iCygt specffilt1IIioo
e The prOoioioM _ sIIaI be ocoornargtlte with he tlliflty RtlIe 141 ~ -I CImetl PI SecOOn B1
f The appIilt3rtt _ specify the nunber timed iory power _lt0 reqJirod BitinQ wiI be boiled on the Pf-uoil ltIelaquogtralioo w~ ond 00urgt oper_ speciIIed by lthe awt~nl Service Alpiea ond ~t The P ltIecoratioo wa~_ 01gt0 1 no eeod he ocILfer JOO-watlrating J- ech ltlevice
At he lime d _ion 0 trneltI ouxMry power odajXelt ond ~ lhereo-er IOgtti trneltI - power ad_ lies beelt1 rerrllgtleltl Ihe cus be r~ 10 proy
he ~~
In cue 11 no d 10 instal liol1telt1 ltleoor lor use wiII1 timed auxi pow- _gtIelt _ 00 tile wSlorrlef-omed paleo ~ opplicoot Y _191
L_ bullbull ~_=~ ____ -~~~ ~----d ===~~~ - CI- R OIIoDOlt R No ______ _
IIGtmNG STR EET AND H1GlfoiAY _ C USJQII ERlgtNEO INSTA l I AllotJS
S p ECW COtlQfIlOOS (Coolinuedl
bull
8 If 0 ~ IiQhgt e ot ~ to ~ GI
- wi be 0ltJjecI bull 1Um-on fee GI $1000 pelt 1911 r 0 mniIrltlm
odiion to the _ Re--Eotobhllment Fee ond credit
9 n nell Au f9welt PeYiClO Moolelt ThIS _ io voUblo under the t ond condiIions bled below Of 0 rootlltli) -lIe $1111 1 ~ ltleYtce plus _live cIIarqe 0 $60 00 pelt CeounlgtOf ltoo~act _ pM Energy C_ ed ed in SltheOOIe A
bull A Stanilard 1n IBiioo _ comnt on - timed - power ltlelice intallod 00 o ltustomelt-owned I~ed 1iItI1 polo
b Thio e io ~ _ to 90~ ogene e leroltd Of ~ _ lightng IIeNiclt A written Service Appkotioo ond Agrt IS reqJired Of _ oolnlt_ willgt ruslomelt-omed lighting poles
c The CUSIltgtrl1eI IiI __ ttgte roq ted timed uxi- ry power _pielt ond stoned timed - pow- _pier ligtoii ernlm sole proporty oj onlOf
d The _ tioo oj the O(gtIlIi ~ oeco-o sIIol be dartlte with -iCygt specinltotioo
e The prOiioions tin sIIaI be ocoornargtlte with tlliflty RtlIe 141 P- -I C-toimerl PrOYisoorlgt Section Bl
f The O(gtIlIilt3rtt _ specify the nunber timed iory power _lteB reqJired Biting wiI be boiled on the Pf-uoil ltIelaquogtralioo w~ ond 00urgt opel_ speciIIeltI by lthe awt~nt Service Alpi eo ond ~t The P ltIecoratioo wa~ __ not eeed rnonuroctlJfer JOO-watlrating J- ech ltlevice
At tho lime d _ion 01 trued ouxMry power - ond~ eol-er IOgtti trned - pow- ad_ IIa been I~ customer wi be I~ 10 proy
he ~~
In cue 011 no d 10 instal liol1led ltleoor lor use wiII1 timed llIJd-y pow- _gtIelt _ 00 the ruSlorrlef-omed paleo ~ opplicoot Y arIdiIIooaIrgttl
L_ bullbull ~_=~ ____ -~~~ ~----d ===~~~ - CI- R OIIoDOlt R ______ _
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 77
January 4 2010
~
Ol
I ~ o 0 bull bull ~ ~ IZ 51
01
1- i l 1 bull Hl j1 middotl ll ~ ll ~ ~ i ~ l Ii II IlII I If ll lJ iii WI iilill i 1 H jli j J ~lt1 if I ~l iiI ~ ~ ~ _ __ ~ u~usect ~ g li middot ii
H II ~ii 1SH I ~ J ~ji ~gt H iij ~ r l I p ~~ i lIBl Jlll i ii filllt i ii l ii i~ I I j I H 11 Ill Ii I hI I I H illl ii l Hl
I 11 fli I h Ij - I d I I ~ -Ir middot t I
I 1 I ~ I ~ II W j l I R 1~ Ii i E -- p - f2 ~ ~q ~ i ll ~ lll~ jlHI Ii
A H Wl j loWl II Ilj
I
I 11 II 1 ltOI 1
t I
~ ~ gt5 n u $ ~$ I~~_ ~ I ~ z ~ j
1i1 oj
I fi
I
~
I l l
l
j
I
j
II
I I
I 0 0 bull bull gt
J
lt
I e
d
~r i t t l I
II
gt i ~ ~
J
I
gt i ~ ~
J
I
gt i ~ ~
J
I
Adva
nce
d S
tree
t Li
ghting T
echnolo
gie
s Ass
essm
ent
Pro
ject
Pag
e 78
Cla
nto
n amp
Ass
oci
ate
s I
nc
J
anuar
y 4
2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
130 Appendix G City of San Diego Life Cycle Cost Analysis
Life Cycle Cost Analysis (LCC) bull Identify 20 year recurring costs bull Evaluate which technology LED or Induction Emerges
Assumptions bull No Ballast bull No Photo Electric Cell bull No other costs are considered in this analysis
Calculate Lamp Replacement Costs bull Lamp Life Determines Frequency of Changes bull Cost of Lamps are Weighted by
Inflation
bull End of 20 Year Period Identified by Fractional Lamp Life
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 79
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Lamp Inflation Factor bull ldquo 1rsquos rdquo Identified for Each Lamp Replacement bull For year 20 account for the partial consumption of the lamp with a decimal
or fraction bull Lamp Inflation Factor considers Lamp Life and Inflated bull Lamp Factor = Maintenance Factor
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 80
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Note End of Life Fraction for Lamp Life gt 20 Years
bull
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 81
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Lamp Inflation Factor bull Lamp inflation is the product of the annual inflation and lamp costs bull The inflation rate can be easily modified
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 82
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
20 Year Life Cycle Costs - Identify the Component Costs bull Initial Fixture + Installation bull Energy with Inflation bull Maintenance Costs (Lamp Costs) bull No Ballast Photo Electric Cell or other costs are considered in this analysis
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 83
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Various Item Costs - Identify the Component Costs bull Material Costs bull LS -2 Rates from SDGampE bull Energy with Inflation at 20 Year Average bull Weighted Lamp Costs
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 84
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Calculate California Energy Commission (CEC) Payback
bull bull For Retrofits do not subtract the cost of existing technology bull Must be less than 10 Years for CEC Loans
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 85
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Calculate Paybacks using Life Cycle (LC) Analysis
bull bull For Retrofits may not subtract the cost of existing technology
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 86
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Compare Paybacks Among HPS Induction LED - Surprising Results bull Lamp Costs bull Inflation Dependent LC Costs bull LED at 3500 Kelvin Donrsquot Payback
Email Chris Hudson CHudsonSanDiegogov for Spread Sheet to Calculate Your
Costs
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 87
January 4 2010
Advanced Street Lighting Technologies Assessment Project
Conclusion bull The Economic Results Point to Induction bull Retrofits with 3500K LED Donrsquot Payback bull Each Agency would have unique conditions which are not considered in our
analysis bull Note LED Costs and Wattage were increased due to Color Temperature
Clanton amp Associates Inc Page 88
January 4 2010