ACOE Staff Report Portola Academy Petition Appeal Dec 2012

7/30/2019 ACOE Staff Report Portola Academy Petition Appeal Dec 2012

1/78

\RDG]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ Gaos|is Wgaffd !Fg|fcis 3=?3 ]i|n|nfh.Gaos|is ]i|n|nfh fh O}}iod - I(G(


2/78

GAOS\IS WGAFFD IRODYO\NFH WY@@OS^ SI]FS\

BFS

\RDG]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ Gaos|is Wgaffd !Fg|fcis 3=?3 ]i|n|nfh.

Gaos|is ]i|n|nfh fh O}}iod - I(G(


3/78

]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ Ligi`cis ??$ 3=?3

]oki?

OHOD^WNW WY@@OS^\ai Odoìlo Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfhw Gaos|isWgaffd Sirni{ \io` gf`}di|il o |afsfykasirni{ ohl ohod~wnw fb |ai ilygo|nfhod$ f}iso|nfhod$ ohl bnhohgnod nhbfsò|nfh gfh|onhil nh |ai}i|n|nfh o}}iod fb ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ Gaos|is Wgaffd !Fg|fcis 3=?3 }i|n|nfh.( \ai }i|n|nfh {owsirni{il nh ?> osiow$ {n|a w}ignbng gsn|isno nh ioga idiìh|( Cidf{ osi |ai so|nhk siwyd|w(

Gsn|isno |ao| Igiilw

Siqynsil W|ohlosl

Gsn|isno |ao| @ii|w

Siqynsil W|ohlosl

Gsn|isno |ao| Bondw |f

@ii| Siqynsil W|ohlosl

? ?79 7?

\ai Sirni{ \io` bfyhl |ai }i|n|nfh lnl hf| gfh|onhsiowfhocd~ gf`}siaihwnri liwgsn}|nfhw nhwfì fb |ai siqynsil osiow( Cowil fh |ai gsn|ngod ho|ysi fb |ai gsn|isno !n(i( w|ylih|w {n|alnwocndn|niw$ Ihkdnwa dioshisw$ sognod&i|ahng codohgi$ w|os|-y} cylki|$ gowa bdf{.$ |ai Sirni{ \ioàow gfhgishw |ao| |ai}i|n|nfhisw osi li`fhw|socd~ yhdnjid~ |f wyggiwwbydd~ n`}diìh| |ai}sfkso` wi| bfs|a nh |ai }i|n|nfh ow {sn||ih( W|obbw Sirni{ Gaigjdnw|$ nhgdylil ow O}}ihln O$gfh|onhw li|ondil ohod~wnw fb ioga Idiìh|&Wig|nfh$ os|ngydo|nhk |ai w|sihk|aw ohl {iojhiwwiw fb|ai gaos|is wgaffdw }sf}fwod( \ai |io` li|is`nhil |ao| |anw gaos|is }i|n|nfh {ow ris~ wn`ndos |f|ai gaos|is }i|n|nfh wyc`n||il c~ \RDG nh Fg|fcis 3=??( O gf`}oso|nri ohod~wnw$ gfhlyg|ilob|is |ai |io`w sirni{$ bfyhl |ao| wfì fb |ai osiow |ao| bondil nh |ai }sirnfywd~ wyc`n||il}i|n|nfh o}}iod odwf bondil |anw }i|n|nfh sirni{( O |ocdi wy`òsnunhk nwwyiw sonwil }sirnfywd~ c~|ai Dnris`fsi Roddi~ Efnh| Yhnbnil Wgaffd Lnw|sng|$ OGFI$ ohl |ai W|o|i Cfosl fb Ilygo|nfh nwnhgdylil ow O}}ihln C(

\ai }i|n|nfh lfgyìh| ì| |ai `nhn`y` gsn|isno nh |ai bfddf{nhk osiow5

@iowysocdi W|ylih| Fy|gfìw W|ylih| ]sfksiww @iowysiìh| Kfrishìh| W|syg|ysi I`}df~ii _yodnbngo|nfhw Aiod|a ohl Wobi|~ Ol`nwwnfhw Siqynsiìh|w Ohhyod Bnhohgnod Oyln|w Wyw}ihwnfh ohl I}ydwnfh W|obb Si|nsiìh| W~w|i` O||ihlohgi Od|isho|nriw Liwgsn}|nfh fb I`}df~ii Snka|w

Lnw}y|i Siwfdy|nfh ]sfgiww Docfs Sido|nfhw Gdfwysi ]sfgilysiw

\ai }i|n|nfh lfgyìh| lnl hf| ìi| |ai `nhn`y` gsn|isno nh |ai bfddf{nhk osiow5

Ilygo|nfh ]sfkso` Sognod " I|ahng Codohgi Bnhohgnod ]doh Bogndn|niw


4/78


]oki3

W}ignod Ilygo|nfhCOGJKSFYHL

\ai Odoìlo Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfh siginril o }i|n|nfh o}}iod bsf` |ai \sn-Roddi~Dioshnhk Gfs}fso|nfh !\RDG. bfs gfhwnliso|nfh fb oy|afsnunhk n|w gaos|is wgaffd }i|n|nfh bfs

]fs|fdo Ogoli`~( \RDG }i|n|nfhil |ai Dnris`fsi Roddi~ Efnh| Yhnbnil Wgaffd Lnw|sng|!Lnw|sng|. |f f}ih o J-1 wgaffd {n|a o}}sfnò|id~ 2;= w|ylih|w nh n|w bnsw| ~ios fb ihsfddìh|(\anw }i|n|nfh {ow lihnil c~ |ai Lnw|sng| fh Fg|fcis ?2$ 3=?3( ]i|n|nfhisw wyc`n||il oh o}}iod |f|ai Odoìlo Gfyh|~ Cfosl fb Ilygo|nfh !Gfyh|~ Cfosl. fh Fg|fcis ?>$ 3=?3( O }ycdng aiosnhk{ow aidl nh |anw ò||is fh Hfri`cis ?$ 3=?3( O||ogail ow O}}ihln C|f |anw si}fs| nw o |ocdi wy`òsnunhk |ai òefs nwwyiw sonwil c~ |ai rosnfyw cflniw sirni{nhk |ai}sirnfyw }i|n|nfh$ {n|a hf|iw sikoslnhk |ai òhhis nh {anga |afwi nwwyiw aori ciih ollsiwwil(

Odoìlo Cfosl fb Ilygo|nfhw Sfdi

[aih gfhwnlisnhk oh o}}iod$ n| nw |ai sfdi fb |ai Cfosl yhlis Ilygo|nfh Gfli Wig|nfh


5/78


]oki7

!9. |ai }i|n|nfh lfiw hf| gfh|onh siowfhocd~ gf`}siaihwnri liwgsn}|nfhw fb |ai O-]

Siqynsi`ih|w(

Sirni{ ]sfgiww

N| nw fys i}ig|o|nfh |ao| {aih o }i|n|nfhis wyc`n|w o }i|n|nfh fh o}}iod$ |ao| |ai~ aori wyc`n||il

o }doh |ai~ cidniri goh ci wyggiwwbydd~ n`}di`ih|il( Ilygo|nfh Gfli Wig|nfh


6/78


]oki(


7/78


]oki9

n| nw hf| gdios |ao| |ai oksiiìh| ih|n|diw \RDG |f fggy}~ |ai ]fs|fdo go`}yw {n|a ohi{ gaos|is(

2( \ai }i|n|nfh bondw |f ollsiww oliqyo|id~ liwgsnci W}ignod Ilygo|nfh nhw|syg|nfh( ]i|n|nfhisw w|o|i oh nh|ih|nfh |f ci }os| fb |ai Id Lfsolf Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfh

Gaos|is Wgaffd WID]O$ cy| }sfrnli hf lfgyìh|o|nfh fb oggi}|ohgi nh|f |ai WID]Obfs |ai 3=?7-3=?< wgaffd ~ios fs fb |ai w|o|yw fb |ains o}}dngo|nfh bfs ì`ciswan}(!Oksiiìh|w {n|a ILGFI WID]O bfs |ai f|ais \RDG wgaffdw osi nhgdylil(.

]i|n|nfh nhgdyliw hf liwgsn}|nfh fb af{ wisrngiw bfs w|ylih|w {n|a NI]w {ndd cilidnrisil ohl {af {ndd }sfrnli |ai`( \aisi nw hf }doh bfs }sfbiwwnfhod liridf}ìh|bfs sikydos gdowwsff` |iogaisw |f ihwysi |ains ocndn|~ |f `flnb~ gdowwsff` nhw|syg|nfhohl wy}}fs| f|ais w}ignod ilygo|nfh byhg|nfhw(

Cylki| bfs w}ignod ilygo|nfh nw wi}oso|id~ w|o|il cy| hf| |nil |f oh~ }sfkso`liwgsn}|nfh( \aisi nw hf lnwgywwnfh fb dnjid~ hiilw fb |oski|il }f}ydo|nfh$ od|afyka\RDG aow òh~ ~iosw fb i}isnihgi wisrnhk w|ylih|w nh |ai gf``yhn|~$ nhgdylnhk|afwi {n|a w}ignod hiilw(

Hf liwgsn}|nfh fb hf|nbngo|nfh }sfgiww nh }i|n|nfh fs wo`}di @FY {n|a ILGFIWID]O(;( \ai }i|n|nfhisw osi li`fhw|socd~ yhdnjid~ |f wyggiwwbydd~ n`}diìh| |ai }sfkso`(

_yodnbngo|nfhw fb |ai bfyhlnhk ksfy} ohl ji~ wgaffd wn|i diolisw osi hf| nhgdylil ohllf hf| iw|ocdnwa |ai go}ogn|~ fb |ai fskohnuo|nfh |f ìi| |ai wnkhnbngoh| gaoddihkiwbognhk |ai wgaffd$ nhgdylnhk5 nh|ih|nfh |f f}ih o| bydd wnui !2;3 w|ylih|w nh ksoliw J-1.$ f}iso|i ow oh DIO bfs }ys}fwiw fb w}ignod ilygo|nfh$ ohl nhgfs}fso|i }sfksoìdiìh|w hf| i`}df~il o| f|ais \RDG wn|iw !o lyod dohkyoki n`ìswnfh }sfkso`$wisrngi dioshnhk ohl os|w nh|ikso|nfh.(

\ai }i|n|nfh gfh|onhw hf frisodd }doh bfs w|os|-y} ohl liridf}ìh| fb |ai }sfkso`: hfwgailydi fs owwnkhìh| fb siw}fhwncndn|niw(

Cowil fh GLI lo|o$ }i|n|nfhisw aori `nhnòd i}isnihgi {n|a Ihkdnwa Dioshisw nh|ains 3 inw|nhk gaos|is wgaffdw ohl aori hf }doh |f oll wnkhnbngoh| go}ogn|~ fh |ainsw|obb bfs Ihkdnwa Dohkyoki Liridf}ìh|(

Nh olln|nfh |f n|w 3 f}iso|nhk wgaffdw$ ohl |ai }sf}fwil ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~$ \RDG aow3 gaos|is }i|n|nfhw }ihlnhk !Ogogno J-9 ohl Ogogno @nlldi Wgaffd. }ihlnhk cibfsi|ai Hi{ Eisywodi` Wgaffd Lnw|sng| nh Woh Efoqynh Gfyh|~$ {anga n| odwf }sf}fwiw |ff}ih nh |ai bodd fb 3=?7( Nh |ai ]sf}( 7> bogndn|niw siqyiw| bfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ ohl o||ai }ycdng aiosnhk$ \RDG dioliswan} odwf w|o|il |ao| n| }dohw |f sidfgo|i n|w 3 inw|nhkwgaffdw bfs bodd 3=?7 |f hi{ bogndn|niw |ao| siqynsi olln|nfhod gfhw|syg|nfh( \aigo}ogn|~ fb |ai fskohnuo|nfh |f wn`yd|ohifyw wyggiwwbydd~ sidfgo|i n|w 3 inw|nhk

wgaffdw ohl f}ih 7 hi{ wgaffdw nw goddil nh|f qyiw|nfh c~5f Ocwihgi fb oh~ liwgsn}|nfh nh |ai ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ }i|n|nfh fb |ai f|ais

}i|n|nfhw }ihlnhk ohl }dohw |f ìi| |ai liòhlw fb 7 wn`yd|ohifyw wgaffdf}ihnhkw(

f Hf }doh bfs olln|nfhod w|obbnhk nh \RDG òhokiìh| bfs sidfgo|nfh ohlwnkhnbngoh| i}ohwnfh(

f Ocwihgi fb o cylki| bfs |ai w|os|-y} ~ios bfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ !wii cidf{.( O gf``fh bnhohgnod siwisri |f wy}}fs| gowa bdf{ ohl gfh|nhkihgniw bfs odd 7

}sf}fwil hi{ wgaffdw(


8/78


]oki2

Wafydl |ai Gfyh|~ Cfosl lignli |f o}}sfri |ai }i|n|nfh$ gfhln|nfhw wafydl ci nhgdylil nh |ai@FY |f ollsiww |aiwi ohl f|ais libngnihgniw$ nhgdylnhk$ cy| hf| dn`n|il |f$ |ai liridf}ìh| ohlwyc`nwwnfh fb |ai bfddf{nhk5

Oh n`}diìh|o|nfh }dohw$ nhgdylnhk lo|iw$ siwfysgiw ohl siw}fhwncdi nhlnrnlyodw bfs |aiòefs osiow fb {fsj hiilil bfs o wyggiwwbyd wgaffd w|os|-y}(

Wgf}i ohl wiqyihgi bfs |ai wgaffdw }sf}fwil gyssngydy`( Lond~ ohl {iijd~ nhw|syg|nfhod wgailydiw$ c~ ksoli( W}ignod ilygo|nfh ohl Ihkdnwa Dioshnhk n`}diìh|o|nfh }dohw$ sibdig|nhk }sfeig|il

ihsfddìh| fb w|ylih|w {n|a |aiwi hiilw ohl nhgdylnhk li|ondil cylki|w w}ignbng |f |aiwi}sfkso` idiìh|w(

Sirnwil ìowysocdi }y}nd fy|gfìw |f nhgdyli ìowysiw ohl |oski|w bfs ioga ksoliwisril$ bfs wnkhnbngoh| w|ylih| wycksfy}w$ ohl bfs w|ylih|w {n|a w}ignod hiilw(

Oh owwiwwìh| godihlos( Gf`}di|i w|obbnhk }doh$ {n|a qyodnbngo|nfhw ohl sigsyn|ìh|&ansnhk |nìdnhi( Oh y}lo|il sigsyn|ìh| ohl ihsfddìh| godihlos$ ohl }doh bfs sigsyn|ìh| w|so|ikniw |f

o||sog| o lnriswi w|ylih| cfl~(

Gfssig|il ohl y}lo|il bnhohgnod }doh$ nhgdylnhk o w|os|-y} cylki|$ ohl oh frisodd \RDGcylki| gdosnb~nhk |ai orondocdi gowa siwisriw nh dnka| fb f|ais \RDG og|nrn|niw

Bogndn|niw oksiiìh| {n|a |ai Lnw|sng| fs f|ais diwwfs( Risnbngo|nfh fb ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~w ì`ciswan} nh |ai ILGFI WID]O(

GFHGDYWNFH

Nb |ai Gfyh|~ Cfosl nw nhgdnhil |f o}}sfri |ai gaos|is }i|n|nfh ob|is gfhwnliso|nfh fb odd ow}ig|w fb|ai gaos|is }sf}fwod$ n| nw sigf`ìhlil |ao| |ai Gfyh|~ Cfosl fhd~ o}}sfri |ai gaos|is yhlisgis|onh |is`w ohl gfhln|nfhw |ao| {ndd ollsiww |ai libngnihgniw nh |ai }i|n|nfh lfgyìh|( \aigfhln|nfhw wafydl odwf nhgdyli |ao| o @i`fsohly` fb Yhlisw|ohlnhk !@FY. ci wnkhil c~ odd

}os|niw {anga {ndd nhgdyli w}ignbng gfhln|nfhw$ |nìdnhiw ohl }si-f}ihnhk siqynsiìh|w( Bys|ais$nb |ai }i|n|nfhisw bond |f ìi| oh~ fb |ai gfhln|nfhw ow wi| bfs|a nh |ai @FY$ |ai Gaos|is ]i|n|nfhwaodd ci liiìl hf| ksoh|il c~ |ai Gfyh|~ Cfosl fh |ai ksfyhlw |ao| n`}diìh|o|nfh fb odd fb|ai gfhln|nfhod siqynsiìh|w nh bydd osi higiwwos~ bfs |ai wyggiwwbyd n`}diìh|o|nfh ohlf}iso|nfh fb |ai wgaffd(

\ai Gaos|is Wgaffd ]i|n|nfhisw aori siqyiw|il oh nhn|nod |is` fb bnri ~iosw$ {anga nw |aiòn`y` oddf{il c~ do{( Nb |ai Gfyh|~ Cfosl o}}sfriw |ai ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ Gaos|is Wgaffd]sf}fwod$ |ai |is` fb |ai gaos|is oy|afsnuo|nfh wafydl ci nhgdylil nh |ai `f|nfh( \ai }i|n|nfhw|o|iw n| }dohw |f f}ih nh |ai bodd fb 3=?7(

O}}ihln O5 Gaos|is Wgaffd ]i|n|nfh Sirni{ Gaigjdnw|O}}ihln C5 Wy`òs~ fb Nwwyiw bsf` ]snfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ ]i|n|nfhO}}ihln G5 Gf`}osnwfh fb \sn-Roddi~ Dioshnhk Gih|is Gaos|is Wgaffd Li`fkso}angwO}}ihln L5 Olln|nfhod Nhbfsò|nfh ]sfrnlil c~ Dnris`fsi Roddi~ Efnh| Yhnbnil WgaffdLnw|sng|


9/78

O]]IHLNQ O

]sf}fwil Gaos|is Wgaffd5 ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~

]sf}fwil Dfgo|nfh5 3$ 3=?3

]ycdng

Aiosnhk!7= lo~w bsf`

sigin}|.

Lo|i Lyi

Hfr( ?1$ 3=?3

Lo|i Aidl

Hfr( ?7$ 3=?3

Lignwnfh c~ Cfosl fb

Ilygo|nfh!2= lo~w bsf` sigin}|$ `o~ ci

i|ihlil 7= lo~w nb oksiil c~

}i|n|nfhis!w. ohl OGFI.

Lo|i Lyi

Lig( ?1$ 3=?3

7= lo~ i|ihwnfh |f

Lo|i fb Cfosl LignwnfhLig( ??$ 3=?3

Cndd Co|gaidfs

Dnris`fsi Roddi~ YWL]afhi

>39-===

OllsiwwLo|i fb Cfosl Og|nfh5

3


10/78

Gaos|is ]i|n|nfh Hoì5 ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ Gf`}di|i ]i|n|nfh Siginril5 Fg|fcis ?>$ 3=?3

Dikihl5

Siqynsil |f ci nhgdylil nh gaos|is }i|n|nfh ohl&fs @i`fsohly` fb Yhlisw|ohlnhk W|sfhkd~ wykkiw|il |f ihwysi |ao| gaos|is idiìh|w osi siowfhocd~ gf`}siaihwnri

?

Hf|i5 \anw gaigjdnw| nw liwnkhil |f kynli |ai sirni{ fb gaos|is wgaffd }i|n|nfhw( \asfykafy| |ai irodyo|nfh$ |ai }i|n|nfhisw siw}fhwi nwso|il ow Igiilw$ @ii|w$ fs Bondw |f @ii| |ai gsn|isno siqynsil bfs ioga w}ignbng osio( \ai bfddf{nhk so|nhk libnhn|nfhw osi ywil |f kynli

|ai owwiwwìh|(

Igiilw Siqynsil

W|ohlosl5

\ai siw}fhwi sibdig|w o |afsfyka yhlisw|ohlnhk fb ji~ nwwyiw ohl nhlngo|iw go}ogn|~ |f f}ih ohl f}iso|i o

qyodn|~ gaos|is wgaffd( \ai wig|nfh ollsiwwiw |ai |f}ng {n|a gfhgnwi$ w}ignbng ohl oggyso|i nhbfsò|nfh |ao|

waf{w |afsfyka }si}oso|nfh$ }siwih|nhk o gdios$ siodnw|ng }ng|ysi fb af{ |ai wgaffd i}ig|w |f n`}diìh| ohl

f}iso|i n|w }sfkso`(

@ii|w Siqynsil

W|ohlosl5

\ai siw}fhwi nhlngo|iw wfdnl }si}oso|nfh ohl ksow} fb ji~ nwwyiw |ao| {fydl ci gfhwnlisil siowfhocd~

gf`}siaihwnri( Frisodd n| gfh|onhw òh~ fb |ai gaosog|isnw|ngw fb o siw}fhwi |ao| igiilw |ai siqynsil

w|ohlosl$ od|afyka n| ò~ siqynsi olln|nfhod w}ignbngn|~$ wy}}fs| fs idocfso|nfh nh }dogiw(

Bondw \f @ii|

Siqynsil W|ohlosl5

\ai siw}fhwi ollsiwwiw wfì fb |ai widig|nfh gsn|isno$ cy| dogjw ìohnhkbyd li|ond ohl siqynsiw n`}fs|oh|

olln|nfhod nhbfsò|nfh nh fslis |f ci siowfhocd~ gf`}siaihwnri( N| li`fhw|so|iw dogj fb }si}oso|nfh$ nw

yhgdios$ fs f|ais{nwi sonwiw wycw|oh|nod gfhgishw ocfy| |ai }i|n|nfhisw yhlisw|ohlnhk fb |ai nwwyi nh gfhgi}|

ohl&fs ocndn|~ |f n`}diìh| fs ìi| |ai siqynsiìh| nh }sog|ngi(

Il Gfli 7( [ao| n| @iohw |f ci oh Ilygo|il ]iswfh nh \ai 3?w| Gih|ys~> Fceig|nri fb ihocdnhk }y}ndw |f cigfì widb-`f|nro|il$ gf`}i|ih|$ dnbidfhk dioshisw Q> Gdios dnw| fb kihisod ogoli`ng wjnddw ohl qyodn|niw n`}fs|oh| bfs oh ilygo|il }iswfh Q> Gdios dnw| fb kihisod hfh-ogoli`ng wjnddw ohl qyodn|niw n`}fs|oh| bfs oh ilygo|il }iswfh Q?=-?1


11/78


Dikihl5


3

Bfyhl

fh

}oki5Irodyo|nfh Gsn|isno O-]

Igiilw

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

@ii|w

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

Bondw \f

@ii|

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

h&o 9( Olln|nfhod Siqynsiìh|w bfs Gaos|is Wgaffdw Wisrnhk Anka Wgaffd W|ylih|h&o Af{ Gaos|is Wgaffd {ndd nhbfs` }osih|w ocfy| |ai |sohwbisocndn|~ fb gfyswiw |f f|ais

}ycdng anka wgaffdw

h&o Af{ Gaos|is Wgaffd {ndd nhbfs` }osih|w ocfy| |ai idnkncndn|~ fb gfyswiw |f ìi| gfddikiih|sohgi siqynsiìh|w

Ilygo|nfh ]sfkso` Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

Frisodd$ |ai gaos|is }i|n|nfh ìi|w `fw| fb |ai `nhn`y` siqynsiìh|w nh |anw wig|nfh( Knrih |ai bog| |ao| |ai \RDG gyssih|d~ f}iso|iw |{f gaos|is

wgaffdw$ |aisi {ow oh i}ig|o|nfh |ao| |ai }i|n|nfh siw}fhwiw {fydl aori nhgdylil `fsi ìohnhkbyd li|ond ohl f|ais olln|nfhod nhbfsò|nfh |ao|

li`fhw|so|il |ains yhlisw|ohlnhk fb ji~ nwwyiw ohl go}ogn|~ bfs f}iso|nhk o qyodn|~ gaos|is wgaffd(

Liwgsnci w|ylih|w {af` |ai gaos|is {ndd o||i`}| |f ilygo|nfh

\oski|il w|ylih| }f}ydo|nfh nw kihisodd~ liwgsncil ow yhliswisril( Dfgo|nfh bsf` {anga |ai wgaffd nh|ihlw |f lso{ w|ylih|w nw nlih|nbnil o|ai Lnw|sng|w Eyhg|nfh J-1 wgaffd$ cy| |ai ollsiwwiw fb bo`ndniw {n|a w|o|il nh|isiw|il !dnw|il nh |ai ]sf}fwn|nfh 7> bogndn|niw siqyiw| siginril

bsf` \RDG ohl ohod~uil c~ |ai Lnw|sng|. nhgdyli fhd~ o wòdd }sf}fs|nfh !o}}sfnò|id~ 2). bsf` |anw dfgo|nfh( !Wii O}}ihln G(.

]i|n|nfh gfh|onhw hf ohod~wnw fb }isbfsòhgi fb w|ylih|w nh |oski|il }f}ydo|nfh$ f|ais |aoh fy|-lo|il nhbfsò|nfh fh {afdi-wgaffd}isbfsòhgi o| widig|il wgaffdw( !Y}lo|il }isbfsòhgi lo|o fh wgaffdw sibisihgil fh }k( ; waf{w òh~ osi hf{ òjnhk O^](.

Hf ohod~wnw fb }isbfsòhgi c~ ksoli$ wyceig| ò||is fs wnkhnbngoh| wyc-ksfy}w nw nhgdylil(Csfol fy|dnhi fb |ai gyssngydy` gfh|ih|

Gyssngydy` gfh|ih| nw liwgsncil fhd~ {n|a sibisihgi |f w}ignbng |i|cffjw$ odnkhil {n|a gf``fh gfsi( Fy|gfìw ohl i}ig|o|nfhw osi kihisoohl hf| w}ignbng |f ksoliw( Hf o}}ihln nw nhgdylil {n|a wyceig| ò||is gfh|ih| fs wjndd liridf}ìh| i}ig|o|nfhw(

Cowil fh |ai nhbfsò|nfh }sfrnlil nh |ai }i|n|nfh$ n| nw yhgdios nb |ai bfyhlisw osi {idd riswil nh |ai Gf``fh Gfsi W|o|i W|ohloslw ohl |aii}ig|o|nfhw |ao| cf|a |ai }sog|ngi ohl gfh|ih| w|ohloslw aori bfs odd w|ylih|w(

]i|n|nfh nhgdyliw hf ìh|nfh fb |sohwn|nfhod jnhliskos|ih gyssngydy` fs yhnqyi nhw|syg|nfhod hiilw(Liwgsn}|nfh fb nhw|syg|nfhod o}}sfogaiw ohl w|so|ikniw

]i|n|nfh nhgdyliw liwgsn}|nfhw fb wfì }sfkso` idiìh|w ohl nhw|syg|nfhod o}}sfogaiw !os|w nh|ikso|nfh$ gyd|ysodd~ sidiroh| }ilokfk~$ i|g(.(Af{iris$ |aisi osi hf io`}diw fb |ai ywi fb |aiwi w|so|ikniw nh |ai gdowwsff` fs fb |ai }sfbiwwnfhod liridf}ìh| }dohhil |f wy}}fs|

|iogaisw nh ywnhk |ai`(

\ai }i|n|nfh nhgdyliw hf lond~ wgailydi fs liwgsn}|nfh fb af{ |ai rosnfyw }sfkso` idiìh|w {ndd bn| nh|f |ai lo~&{iij$ wyga ow \ai DioshnhkGih|is$ os|w nh|ikso|nfh$ wisrngi dioshnhk$ ohl nh|isrih|nfhw bfs w|sykkdnhk w|ylih|w(

Nh |ai ocwihgi fb wgailydiw$ |aisi nw o dogj fb gdosn|~ ocfy| |ai lnbbisihgiw ci|{iih |ai }sfkso` w|syg|ysiw c~ ksoli$ wyga ow {anga ksoliw osinh widb-gfh|onhil gdowwsff`w$ nb gfsi cdfgjw {ndd ci ywil$ ohl af{ os|w ohl wisrngi dioshnhk nh|ikso|nfh {ndd ci òhokil( \ai o`fyh| fb |iogai

}si}oso|nfh |nì nw odwf yhw}ignbnil(

Nhw|syg|nfhod liwnkh fs w|so|ikniw cowil y}fh wyggiwwbyd }sog|ngi fs siwiosga

Siwiosga fh gyd|ysodd~ siw}fhwnri |ioganhk nw }sfrnlil nh |ai o}}ihln( Os|w nh|ikso|nfh gf`}fhih| nhgdyliw ibbig|nri }sog|ngiw$ cy| n`}diìh|o|nfh dogjw w}ignbngn|~( ]i|n|nfh dogjw w|sfhk |asfyka-dnhi liwgsncnhk af{ |ai }sfkso`ò|ng idiìh|w wisri |ai |oski|il }f}ydo|nfh fb yhlis-wisril w|ylih|w( [a~

{isi |aiwi idiìh|w gafwih bfs |aiwi w|ylih|w6

Liwgsnciw nhw|syg|nfhod w|so|ikniw bfs w}ignod ilygo|nfh$ Nhwybbngnih| Ihkdnwa }sfbngnih| w|ylih|w$ i|g(

N| o}}iosw |ao| }i|n|nfhisw aori o gdios w~w|i` bfs nlih|nb~nhk w|ylih|w bfs S|N nh|isrih|nfhw( O}}( L gfh|onhw bdf{gaos| fb wy}}fs|w bfsw|sykkdnhk w|ylih|w !S|N. ow {idd ow wo`}diw fb WW\ lfgyìh|o|nfh(

Od|afyka |ai }i|n|nfh aow oh i}ohlil liwgsn}|nfh fb n|w }sfkso` bfs Ihkdnwa Dioshisw |f nhgdyli 7 f}|nfhw$ li}ihlnhk fh |ai hiilw fb ihsfddiw|ylih|w$ |aisi osi qyiw|nfhw siònhnhk$ nhgdylnhk5

f Af{ |iogaisw {ndd olo}| |ains gyssngydo |f ìi| |ai hiilw fb Ihkdnwa Dioshisw ohl {ao|$ nb oh~ wy}}fs| |ai~ {ndd aori bfs |anw {fsj6f Af{ {ndd }ydd-fy| }sfkso` ci n`}diìh|il |f orfnl dfww fb n`}fs|oh| dioshnhk |nì fh gfsi ogoli`ng gyssngydy`6f [af {ndd diol |ai ibbfs| |f n`}diìh| 7 f}|nfhw bfs IDw6f [aih ohl fh {ao| cownw {ndd |ai lignwnfh ci òli |f nhgdyli |ai lyod dohkyoki n`ìswnfh f}|nfh6f [ao| siwfysgiw {ndd ci hiilil |f liridf} |ai lyod-n`ìswnfh }sfkso`6f Af{ {ndd w|ylih|w ci }dogil nh |ai lyod-n`ìswnfh }sfkso`6

Ilygo|nfhod ]andfwf}a~ ohl ]sfkso`

Nh|ikso|nfh fb os|w ohl wisrngi dioshnhk {n|a |soln|nfhod gfsi gdowwiw nw lnwgywwil$ cy| hf io`}diw fb |anw nh|ikso|il o}}sfoga osi knrih( N| nwyhgdios {aih ohl af{ |ai nh|ikso|nfh fggysw bfs odd ksoliw wisril(


12/78


Dikihl5


7

Il Gfli


13/78


Dikihl5


$ 3=?3

Dikihl5


9

lfgyìh| ow siqynsil c~ Do{ nhgdylnhk |ai Hf Gandl Dib| Cianhl Og|(

h&o Nlih|nbniw oh~ hfh-gfsi$ hfh-gfddiki }si} |ioganhk }fwn|nfhw w|obbil c~ hfh-gis|nbnil

|iogaisw$ odfhk {n|a siqynsil qyodnbngo|nfhw(Q

I`}df~ii _yodnbngo|nfhw Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

\anw wig|nfh ìi|w |ai `nhn`y` siqynsil w|ohlosl$ cy| knrih |ai si{sn|i fb |ai ilygo|nfhod }sfkso` gf`}fhih|$ n| {fydl ci siowfhocdi |f i}ig| `fli|ond nh |ai w|obbnhk }doh(

\aisi nw o dogj fb gdosn|~ fh w|obbnhk {aih gf`}osnhk |ai |i| fb |ai }i|n|nfh {n|a |ai cylki| owwy`}|nfhw ohl w}siolwaii|w( \ai cylki| nhgdyliw 7|iogaisw$ cy| |ai }i|n|nfh waf{w 37 gdowwiw( \aisi nw hf w}ignbng oddfgo|nfh fb |ai f|ais ; |ioganhk }fwn|nfhw(

\ai w}ignod ilygo|nfh cylki| nhgdyliw 7 siwfysgi w}ignodnw|w$ cy| |aisi nw hf ohod~wnw fb |ai w}ignod hiilw }f}ydo|nfh |f wy}}fs| |ai w|obbnhk( Yhgdios nb o Rngi ]snhgn}od nw nhgdylil nh |ai w|obbnhk fs {ao| |ai wnui |asiwafdl nw bfs ollnhk |anw }fwn|nfh$ iw}ignodd~ knrih |ao| |ai wgaffd }sf}fwiw |

f}ih o| bydd go}ogn|~(

Od|afyka wgaffd oh|ngn}o|iw o wnkhnbngoh| }f}ydo|nfh fb Ihkdnwa Dioshisw$ |aisi nw hf w|obbnhk w}ignbng |f |ai ID }sfkso` !nhgdylnhk |ai }sf}fwil lyon`ìswnfh cndnhkyod }sfkso`.(

O }fwn|nfh fb ]sfkso` Olrnwfs o}}iosw fh |ai \RDG fskohnuo|nfh gaos|is$ cy| |aisi nw hf efc liwgsn}|nfh fs cylki| bfs |anw }fwn|nfh( Nhgdyliw hf }sfbiwwnfhod liridf}ìh| godihlos(

Il Gfli


15/78


Dikihl5


2

2


16/78


Dikihl5


;

2> Wgf}i ohl |n`nhk fb oyln|$ ow {idd ow siqynsil lnw|sncy|nfh fb gf`}di|il oyln| Q2> ]sfgiww bfs siwfdrnhk oyln| igi}|nfhw ohl libngnihgniw |f |ai wo|nwbog|nfh fb |ai

Odoìlo Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfhQ

Ohhyod Bnhohgnod Oyln|w Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

\anw wig|nfh ìi|w |ai `nhn`y` siqynsil w|ohlosl$ cy| olln|nfhod li|ond {fydl ci o}}sf}sno|i }snfs |f wgaffd f}ihnhk( \ai }sfgiww bfs siwfdrnhk oyln| igi}|nfhw ohl libngnihgniw sibisw |f |ai wo|nwbog|nfh fb |ai Lnw|sng|$ hf| OGFI( Nb |ai gaos|is nw o}}sfril$ |anw

{fydl hiil |f ci gfssig|il(

\ai \RDG c~do{w w}ignbngodd~ }sfrnli bfs oh Oyln| Gf``n||ii |f widig| |ai nhli}ihlih| oyln|fs$ ohl |f sirni{ oyln| igi}|nfhw( \ai Oyln|Gf``n||ii nw hf| sibisihgil nh gaos|is }i|n|nfh( \ai c~do{w ohl |ai gaos|is dohkyoki wafydl ci sigfhgndil(

Il Gfli


17/78


Dikihl5


1

Il Gfli


18/78


Dikihl5


>

Il Gfli


19/78


Dikihl5


?=

wgaffd ~ios(

\ai }i|n|nfh dogjw ohod~wnw fb dnjid~ w}ignod hiilw }f}ydo|nfh ohl hf }doh nw liwgsncil bfs w|obbnhk$ |sonhnhk ohl wisrngi lidnris~ bfs w}ignod ilygo|nfh!W}ignod ilygo|nfh nwwyiw osi odwf ollsiwwil cidf{(.

Cowil fh GLI lo|o$ }i|n|nfhisw aori `nhnòd i}isnihgi {n|a Ihkdnwa Dioshisw nh |ains 3 inw|nhk gaos|is wgaffdw ohl aori hf }doh |f oll wnkhnbngohgo}ogn|~ fh |ains w|obb bfs Ihkdnwa Dohkyoki Liridf}ìh|(

\ai }i|n|nfh gfh|onhw hf }doh bfs liridf}nhk w}ignbng owwiwwìh|w: |aisi nw hf owwiwwìh| godihlos: ohl hf }sfbiwwnfhod liridf}ìh| liwgsncil bfol`nhnw|isnhk owwiwwìh|w fs bfs ywi fb lo|o ohl lo|o ohod~wnw |ffdw(

\ai bnhohgnod lfgyìh|w gfh|onh hyìsfyw wòdd issfsw !nlih|nbnil cidf{.$ sonwnhk qyiw|nfhw ocfy| |ai go}ogn|~ fb |ai fskohnuo|nfh( Nh olln|nfh |f n|w 3 f}iso|nhk wgaffdw$ ohl |ai }sf}fwil ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~$ \RDG aow 3 gaos|is }i|n|nfhw }ihlnhk !Ogogno J-9 ohl Ogogno @nlldi

Wgaffd. }ihlnhk cibfsi |ai Hi{ Eisywodi` Wgaffd Lnw|sng| nh Woh Efoqynh Gfyh|~$ {anga n| odwf }sf}fwiw |f f}ih nh |ai bodd fb 3=?7( Nh |ai ]sf}( 7>

bogndn|niw siqyiw| bfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ ohl o| |ai }ycdng aiosnhk$ \RDG dioliswan} odwf w|o|il |ao| n| }dohw |f sidfgo|i n|w 3 inw|nhk wgaffdw bfs bodd

3=?7 |f hi{ bogndn|niw |ao| siqynsi olln|nfhod gfhw|syg|nfh( \ai go}ogn|~ fb |ai fskohnuo|nfh |f wn`yd|ohifyw wyggiwwbydd~ sidfgo|i n|w 3 inw|nhk

wgaffdw ohl f}ih 7 hi{ wgaffdw nw goddil nh|f qyiw|nfh c~5

f Ocwihgi fb oh~ liwgsn}|nfh nh |ai ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ }i|n|nfh fb |ai f|ais }i|n|nfhw }ihlnhk ohl }dohw |f ìi| |ai liòhlw fb 7wn`yd|ohifyw wgaffd f}ihnhkw(

f Hf }doh bfs olln|nfhod w|obbnhk nh \RDG òhokiìh| bfs sidfgo|nfh ohl wnkhnbngoh| i}ohwnfh(f Ocwihgi fb o cylki| bfs |ai w|os|-y} ~ios bfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~ !wii cidf{.(f Issfsw nh |ai gf`cnhil cylki| bfs |ai }ihlnhk Ogogno gaos|is wgaffdw nlih|ngod |f ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~( !Ogogno cylki| !siqyiw|il ohl

siginril bsf` \RDG. nw nlih|ngod |f |ai cylki| }siwih|il bfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~(.

f O gf``fh bnhohgnod siwisri |f wy}}fs| gowa bdf{ ohl gfh|nhkihgniw bfs odd 7 }sf}fwil hi{ wgaffdw(

SI_YNSIL WY]]DI@IH\OD NHBFS@O\NFH

Bnhohgnod ]doh

Bfyhl

fh

}oki5

Irodyo|nfh Gsn|isno

Igiilw

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

@ii|w

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

Bondw \f

@ii|

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

O}} D ]sf}fwil bnsw| ~ios f}iso|nfhod cylki| QO}} D W|os|-y} gfw|w QO}} D Gowa bdf{ bfs bnsw| |asii ~iosw Q

O}} D Bnhohgnod }sfeig|nfhw bfs bnsw| |asii ~iosw QO}} D ]dohhnhk Owwy`}|nfhw QO}} D Hy`cis&|~}iw fb w|ylih|w QO}} D Hy`cis fb w|obb QO}} D Bogndn|niw hiilw QO}} D Gfw|w fb odd òefs n|i`w osi nlih|nbnil ohl {n|anh siowfhocdi òsji| sohkiw QO}} D Sirihyi owwy`}|nfhw nh dnhi {n|a w|o|i ohl bilisod byhlnhk kynlidnhiw QO}} D Sirihyi bsf` wfb| wfysgiw diww |aoh ?=) fb fhkfnhk f}iso|nfhod gfw|w QO}} D \nìdnhi oddf{w {nhlf{ bfs sibisihgil ksoh| o}}dngo|nfhw |f ci wyc`n||il ohl byhlil Q

Bnhohgnod ]doh Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

\anw wig|nfh ìi|w |ai `nhn`y` siqynsil w|ohlosl$ cy| wfì gdosnbngo|nfh ohl gfssig|nfh {fydl ci o}}sf}sno|i }snfs |f wgaffd f}ihnhk(

W|os|y} gfw|w {isi hf| gdiosd~ nlih|nbnil$ ow lnwgywwil cidf{( \ai hy`cis fb }sfeig|il B\Iw nw hf| gdiosd~ w|o|il$ ow lnwgywwil ocfri( Cylki| bfs 7= |iogaisw bfs 37 gdowwsff`w$ {n|a hf gdios i}doho|nfh fb

f|ais }fwn|nfhw(

Doski yhi}donhil nhgsiowi nh Gdowwnbnil Wy}}fs| wodosniw ci|{iih 3=?7-?< ohl 3=?


20/78


Dikihl5


??

Hf| gdios af{ |ai i}ihwiw bfs \RDG òhokiìh| !gih|sod fbbngi byhg|nfhw. osi gaoskil |f |ai wgaffd( Rosnfyw gf`}fhih|w fb |ai bnhohgnod }doh hf| gaigjil ohl sigfhgndil5 cylki|$ gowa bdf{$ ohl `yd|n-~ios }sfeig|nfhw aori nhgfhwnw|ih| sirihy

owwy`}|nfhw: gowa bdf{ bsf` ~ios-|f-~ios ywil ihlnhk gowa nhgdylnhk oggsyodw nhw|iol fb w|sonka| gowa( Sirihyiw fh gowa bdf{ w|o|iìh|w

igiil |ai sirihyiw fh |ai bnhohgnod }sfeig|nfhw c~ ,93J ohl ,?73J bfs 3=?7-?< ohl 3=?


21/78


Dikihl5


?3

Ohhyod F}iso|nhk Cylki| Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

\anw wig|nfh ìi|w |ai `nhn`y` siqynsil w|ohlosl$ cy| wfì gdosnbngo|nfh ohl gfssig|nfh {fydl ci o}}sf}sno|i }snfs |f wgaffd f}ihnhk(

W|obbnhk }doh lfiw hf| |sogj {n|a }sfkso` hiilw( ]sfkso` nhgdyliw os| nhw|syg|nfh$ i}ohlil }sfkso` bfs Ihkdnwa Dioshisw$ wisrngi dioshnhk ohlf|ais bio|ysiw$ cy| w}ignbng w|obb bfs |aiwi }sfkso`w nw hf| nlih|nbnil nh |ai cylki|(

\ai cylki| lfiw hf| gdiosd~ nlih|nb~ |ai gaos|is wgaffdw gfh|sncy|nfh |f |ai gfw| fb wisrngiw }sfrnlil c~ |ai \RDG òhokiìh| & gih|sod fbbngi( Gaos|is o}}iosw |f aori yhlisiw|nò|il cihibn|w i}ihwiw c~ o}}sf( ,?


22/78


Dikihl5


?7

\ai }sfeig|nfhw lnl hf| nhgdyli nhgsiowiw bfs OLO fs GFDO$ fs ]GWK] ksoh| byhlnhk !igi}| bfs ,?9=$=== nh ~ios 3. fs GWS J-7 byhlnhk( Nh olln|nfh$ n| o}}iosw |ao| W|o|i Df||is~ sirihyiw aori ciih yhlisw|o|il c~ o}}sfnò|id~ ,19J !|asfyka 3=?;-?1.( W|o|i W}ignod Il sirihyiw o}}ios |f ci frisw|o|il c~ o}}sfnò|id~ ,>2J !|asfyka 3=?;-?1.$ igi}| nh |ai bnsw| ~ios(

N`}og| W|o|iìh|

Bfyhl

fh

}oki5Irodyo|nfh Gsn|isno

Igiilw

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

@ii|w

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

Bondw \f

@ii|

Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

1 ]sfrnliw iw|nò|il hy`cisw fb w|ylih|w oh|ngn}o|il |f ihsfdd Q;3

Nlih|nbniw {ai|ais gaos|is {ndd siqyiw| |f }ysgaowi wy}}fs| wisrngiw bsf` OGFI fslnw|sng|

Q

Liwgsnciw wykkiw|il }sfgiwwiw ohl }fdngniw ci|{iih gaos|is ohl OGFI nhgdylnhk5 Q;3-;7 ]sfgiww$ og|nrn|niw ohl owwfgno|il biiw bfs friswnka| fb gaos|is Q19 Gfh|ih|$ }sfgiwwiw$ |nìdnhiw$ ohl irodyo|nfh gsn|isno bfs ohhyod sirni{ ohl wn|i rnwn|w Q19 Sikydos$ fhkfnhk bnwgod ohl }sfkso`ò|ng }isbfsòhgi `fhn|fsnhk ohl si}fs|nhk Q

Gfh|ih|$ }sfgiww$ |nìdnhiw ohl irodyo|nfh gsn|isno bfs gaos|is sihi{od Q ]sf}fwil wy}}fs| wisrngi hiilw ohl wykkiw|il }o~ìh|w |f OGFI fs lnw|sng| bfs

wisrngiwQ

;7 Gdiosd~ lsob|il gfh|sog|&oksiiìh| fs sibisihgi |f @FY Q;3 f Nlih|nb~ {ai|ais o siqyiw| {ndd ci òli bfs ywi fb OGFI fs lnw|sng|-f{hil bogndn|niw QO}} @ f Siowfhocd~ li|ondil diowi fs fggy}o|nfh oksiiìh| bfs }snro|id~ fc|onhil bogndn|niw Q;3 ]sf}fwil dikod w|o|yw fb wgaffd nw nlih|nbnil Q;3

Liwgsnciw |ai òhhis nh {anga ol`nhnw|so|nri wisrngiw fb |ai gaos|is wgaffd osi |f ci}sfrnlil

Q

;3 Nlih|nb~ {ai|ais wgaffd nh|ihlw |f òhoki snwj nhli}ihlih|d~ fs {ndd wiij |f wigysi

gfrisoki |asfyka |ai Odoìlo Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfh fs f|ais }ycdng okihg~Q

;7 Ollsiwwiw }f|ih|nod gnrnd dnocndn|~ ibbig|w$ nb oh~$ y}fh |ai wgaffd ohl |ai OGFI QN`}og| W|o|iìh| Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

\anw wig|nfh ìi|w |ai `nhn`y` siqynsil w|ohlosl$ cy| wfì gdosnbngo|nfh {fydl ci higiwwos~ nh |ai @FY }snfs |f wgaffd f}ihnhk(

Sihi{od }sfgiwwiw$ |nìdnhiw$ ohl irodyo|nfh gsn|isno osi hf| gdiosd~ w|o|il( Rokyi w|o|iìh| ocfy| }fwwncd~ siqyiw|nhk wisrngiw bsf` lnw|sng|: hf sibisihgi |f OGFI wisrngiw( Hf sibisihgi |f friswnka| biiw }o~ocdi |f lnw|sng| fs OGFI( O}}ihln @ diowi oksiiìh| nw hf| o}}dngocdi |f }sf}fwil hi{ gaos|is bfs ]fs|fdo Ogoli`~( Hf od|isho|nri fs cogj-y} }doh }sfrnlil wafydl |ai

}ihlnhk ]sf}( 7> bogndn|niw siqyiw| hf| siwyd| nh o wo|nwbog|fs~ oksiiìh| {n|a |ai Lnw|sng|(

Bogndn|niw

Bfyhl

fh}oki5

Irodyo|nfh Gsn|isno

Igiilw

SiqynsilW|ohlosl

@ii|w

SiqynsilW|ohlosl

Bondw \f

@ii|Siqynsil

W|ohlosl

;3 Liwgsnci |ai |~}iw ohl }f|ih|nod dfgo|nfh fb bogndn|niw hiilil |f f}iso|i |ai wnui

ohl wgf}i fb ilygo|nfhod }sfkso` }sf}fwil nh |ai gaos|is(Q

;3

Nh |ai irih| o w}ignbng bogndn|~ aow hf| ciih wigysil$ }sfrnli irnlihgi fb |ai |~}iohl }sfeig|il gfw| fb |ai bogndn|niw |ao| ò~ ci orondocdi nh |ai dfgo|nfh fb |ai

}sf}fwil gaos|is wgaffd(

Q


23/78


Dikihl5


?$ 3=?3

Dikihl5


?9

Owwysohgi W|o|iìh| |ao| Gaos|is nw bnwgodd~ siw}fhwncdi bfs bons waosi fb oh~ihgsfogaìh| fh kihisod byhlw

Q

]i|n|nfh nhgdyliw |ai bfddf{nhk owwysohgiw5 \ai gaos|is {ndd gf`}d~ {n|a odd }sfrnwnfhw fb NLIO Q

Hf w|ylih| {ndd ci lihnil ol`nwwnfh cowil fh lnwocndn|~ fs dogj fb orondocdiwisrngiw Q

[ndd n`}diìh| o W|ylih| W|yl~ \io` }sfgiww Q Oh~ w|ylih| }f|ih|nodd~ nh hiil fb Wig|nfh 9=< wisrngiw {ndd ci |ai siw}fhwncndn|~

fb |ai gaos|is wgaffdQ

Frisrni{ fb af{ w}ignod ilygo|nfh byhlnhk ohl wisrngiw {ndd ci }sfrnlil c~5 ]i|n|nfh&@FY liwgsnciw |ai }sfgiww bfs hf|nb~nhk lnw|sng| fb siwnlihgi ohl oy|afsnunhk

wgaffd lnw|sng| {aih o w}ignod ilygo|nfh w|ylih| ihsfddw$ cigfìw idnkncdi$ nhidnkncdi

ohl&fs dioriw gaos|is wgaffd

Q

Gaos|is Wgaffd Odoìlo Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfh WID]O

]i|n|nfh&@FY liwgsnciw |ai |sohwn|nfh |f fs bsf` o lnw|sng| {aih o w|ylih| {n|a oh NI]ihsfddw nh$ fs |sohwbisw fy| fb$ |ai gaos|is wgaffd

Q

W}ignod Ilygo|nfh Gf`ìh|w ohl&fs Gfhgishw

\anw wig|nfh bondw |f ìi| |ai `nhn`y` siqynsil w|ohlosl(

Hf gfhwyd|o|nfh yhlis|ojih {n|a OGFI w}ignod ilygo|nfh( ]i|n|nfhisw w|o|i oh nh|ih|nfh |f ci }os| fb |ai Id Lfsolf Gfyh|~ Fbbngi fb Ilygo|nfh Gaos|is Wgaffd WID]O$ cy| }sfrnli hf lfgyìh|o|nfh fb

oggi}|ohgi nh|f |ai WID]O bfs |ai 3=?7-3=?< wgaffd ~ios fs fb |ai w|o|yw fb |ains o}}dngo|nfh bfs ì`ciswan}( !Oksiiìh|w {n|a ILGFI WID]O bfs

|ai f|ais \RDG wgaffdw osi nhgdylil(.

]i|n|nfh nhgdyliw hf liwgsn}|nfh fb af{ wisrngiw bfs w|ylih|w {n|a NI]w {ndd ci lidnrisil ohl {af {ndd }sfrnli |ai`( \aisi nw hf }doh bfs }sfbiwwnfhliridf}ìh| bfs sikydos gdowwsff` |iogaisw |f ihwysi |ains ocndn|~ |f `flnb~ gdowwsff` nhw|syg|nfh ohl wy}}fs| f|ais w}ignod ilygo|nfh byhg|nfhw(

Cylki| bfs w}ignod ilygo|nfh nw wi}oso|id~ w|o|il cy| hf| |nil |f oh~ }sfkso` liwgsn}|nfh( \aisi nw hf lnwgywwnfh fb dnjid~ hiilw fb |oski|il}f}ydo|nfh$ od|afyka \RDG aow òh~ ~iosw fb i}isnihgi wisrnhk w|ylih|w nh |ai gf``yhn|~$ nhgdylnhk |afwi {n|a w}ignod hiilw(

Hf liwgsn}|nfh fb hf|nbngo|nfh }sfgiww nh }i|n|nfh fs wo`}di @FY {n|a ILGFI WID]O(


25/78

O}}ihlnq C

]oki ?

WY@@OS^ FB @OEFS GFHGISHW5 \RDG ]FS\FDO OGOLI@^ GAOS\IS ]I\N\NFHW 3=?? OHL 3=?3

3=?? ]i|n|nfh

DREYWL Gfhgishw

3=?? ]i|n|nfh

OG Cfosl Gfhgishw

3=?? ]i|n|nfh5

W|o|i Cfosl Gfhgishw

3=?3 ]i|n|nfh5

Gfhgishw Ollsiwwil6

Liwgsn}|nfh fb ilygo|nfhod

}sfkso` nw kihisod$ ohl dogjw

n`}fs|oh| w}ignbng nhbfsò|nfh

sikoslnhk |ai ilygo|nfhod

}sfkso`

îw - Ilygo|nfhod }sfkso`

liwgsn}|nfh sirnwil ohl i}ohlil

Nhwybbngnih| liwgsn}|nfh fb |ai

|oski|il w|ylih| }f}ydo|nfh ohl

af{ |ains yhnqyi hiilw {ndd ci

ì|: hf liwgsn}|nfh fb

nhw|syg|nfhod liwnkh odnkhil |f

|oski| }f}ydo|nfh

Nhwybbngnih| nhbfsò|nfh |f

liwgsnci af{ n| {ndd ìi| |ai

yhnqyi hiilw fb |ai w}ignbng

wycksfy} fb w|ylih|w |ai wgaffd

nh|ihlw |f ihsfdd

Hf - Liwgsn}|nfh fb |oski|

}f}ydo|nfh ohl af{ }sfkso`

odnkhw {n|a |ains hiilw siònhw

dn`n|il

Nholiqyo|i$ kihisod liwgsn}|nfh

fb |ai og|yod gyssngydy` ohl

nhw|syg|nfhod liwnkh: nwodnkhil

{n|a yhliswisril }f}ydo|nfh

|oski|il

Hf - Liwgsn}|nfh fb |ai }sf}fwil

gyssngydy` nw kihisod: hf| csfjih

lf{h c~ ksoli fs odnkhil

w}ignbngodd~ {n|a |oski| }f}ydo|nfh

Nhwybbngnih| liwgsn}|nfh fb }dohw |fìi| |ai hiilw fb Ihkdnwa

Dioshisw: bondw |f ollsiww

nhrfdri ih| fb }osih|w fb ID

w|ylih|w: nholiqyo|i liwgsn}|nfh

fb }dohw bfs ID owwiwwìh|w: ohl

sigdowwnbngo|nfh

Nhwybbngnih| }doh bfs IhkdnwaDioshisw îw - Ihkdnwa Dioshis }sfkso`liwgsn}|nfh i}ohlil |f nhgdyli 7

f}|nfhw$ }osih| sfdi ohl

sigdowwnbngo|nfh

Nholiqyo|i liwgsn}|nfh fb }dohw

bfs }sf}fwil lyod n`ìswnfh

Nhwybbngnih| li|ond$ gyssngydos

liwgsn}|nfhw$ fs }doh bfs

]os|nod Wfì olln|nfhod li|ond$

cy| }dohw bfs n`}diìh|nhk lyod


26/78

O}}ihlnq C

]oki 3

3=?? ]i|n|nfh

DREYWL Gfhgishw

3=?? ]i|n|nfh

OG Cfosl Gfhgishw

3=?? ]i|n|nfh5


3=?3 ]i|n|nfh5

Gfhgishw Ollsiwwil6

}sfkso` n`}diìh|o|nfh fb }fwwncdi lyod

dohkyoki n`ìswnfh }sfkso`

n`ìswnfh }sfkso` siònh

yhgdios

W|ylih| ohl wgaffd fy|gfìw osi

rokyi: hf| iowysocdi:

nhbsiqyih|: hf| fceig|nri: hf|

wybbngnih| |f nhbfs` nhw|syg|nfhod

lignwnfh-òjnhk

Nholiqyo|i wgaffd ohl }y}nd

fy|gfìw |ao| osi wyceig|nri$

hfh-gf``n||od$ hf| iowysocdi$

ohl yhdnjid~ |f ci o||onhil: hf

gdios i|sng |f bogndn|o|i fceig|nri

owwiwwìh| fb ogoli`ng

}isbfsòhgi

Hf - @iowysocdi fy|gfìw bfs

w|ylih|w ohl wgaffd osi dn`n|il:

okksiko|i iowysiw {n|afy|

wnkhnbngoh| wycksfy}w fs w}ignod

}f}ydo|nfhw: wfì iowysiw osi

rokyi: widig|nfh fb iowysiw ohl

|oski|w hf| wy}}fs|il

Kfrishohgi wig|nfh yhgdios ow |f

af{ cfosl {ndd ii| i}ohlil

siw}fhwncndn|niw: nhgfhwnw|ihgniw

ci|{iih gaos|is }i|n|nfh ohl

c~do{w: nholiqyo|i liwgsn}|nfh fb

af{ gfhbdng|w fb nh|isiw|

siqynsiìh|w {ndd ci ollsiwwil

]os|nod C~do{w sirnwil

Nholiqyo|i liwgsn}|nfh fb

qyodnbngo|nfhw fb ansil w|obb:

nhgfhwnw|ih| ohl gfhbywnhk efc

liwgsn}|nfhw

]os|nod liwgsn}|nfhw i}ohlil:

wfì nhgfhwnw|ihgniw {n|a cylki|

siònh

Sigsyn|ìh| ibbfs|w osi rokyid~

liwgsncil: fy|sioga }doh nw hf|

w}ignbng lfiw hf| sibdig|

yhlisw|ohlnhk fb lnriswi

gf``yhn|niw {n|anh |ai Lnw|sng|

]sog|ngiw ohl }fdngniw nh |ai

}i|n|nfh osi yhdnjid~ |f oganiri

|oski|il sognod ohl i|ahng codohgi

sibdig|nri fb |ai Lnw|sng| ow o

{afdi

Hf sigsyn|ìh| }doh hf|

}sfrnlil: irnlihgi fb nhibbig|nri

fy|sioga nh dnw| fb nh|isiw|il

bo`ndniw

Ol`nwwnfhw }fdng~ gfh|sos~ |f

w|o|i do{ {n|a siw}ig| |f

Ol`nwwnfhw }fdng~ gfh|sos~ |f îw }sibisihgiw sirnwil


27/78

O}}ihlnq C

]oki 7

3=?? ]i|n|nfh

DREYWL Gfhgishw

3=?? ]i|n|nfh

OG Cfosl Gfhgishw

3=?? ]i|n|nfh5


3=?3 ]i|n|nfh5

Gfhgishw Ollsiwwil6

}sibisihgiw: nholiqyo|i

liwgsn}|nfh fb }sfgiww&|n idnhi

w|o|i do{

Wyw}ihwnfh ohl i}ydwnfh }fdng~ nw

hf| dikodd~ gf`}dnoh| dogjw

o}}iod }sfgiww

Wyw}ihwnfh ohl i}ydwnfh wig|nfh

bondw |f ìi| w|ohlosl: dogjw

}sf|ig|nfhw bfs w|ylih|w {n|a

w}ignod hiilw

I}ydwnfh }fdng~ lfiw hf| ìi|

w|o|i do{

îw }fdng~ sirnwil

Lnw}y|i siwfdy|nfh }sfgiww bondw |f

ollsiww OGFIw sfdi: nh|ishod

gf`}donh| }fdngniw hf| liridf}il

îw gf`}donh| }sfgilysiw nh

aohlcffjw

Liwgsn}|nfh fb w|obb si|nsiìh|

}doh dogjw gdios w|o|iìh| fb

nh|ih|nfh

W|obb si|nsiìh| w~w|i`

nhgf`}di|i {n|a siw}ig| |f W\SW

ì`ciswan}: dogj fb gdosn|~ si5

]ISW

]os|nod W\SW gdosnbnil: ]ISW w|ndd

yhgdios

]i|n|nfhisw osi li`fhw|socd~

yhdnjid~ |f wyggiwwbydd~

n`}diìh|$ lyi |f yhsiodnw|ng

bnhohgnod ohl f}iso|nfhod }doh

Hf Bnhohgnod ]doh hf| sirnwil:

fskohnuo|nfhod go}ogn|~ hf|

ollsiwwil

Bnhohgnod ]doh nw hf| wfyhl fssiodnw|ng: lfiw hf| nhgdyli odd

}sfkso` idiìh|w: nhlnrnlyod gfw|

n|i`w osi yhsiodnw|ng: w|os|nhk

codohgi yhwy}}fs|il: hf w|os|-y}

gfw|w nlih|nbnil: w}ignod ilygo|nfh

i}ihln|ysiw ohl sirihyiw

yhwy}}fs|il

Nholiqyo|i Bnhohgnod ]doh {n|aissfsw nh ]GWK] ksoh| sirihyi: hf

w|os|-y} gfw|w: issfsw nh ohhyod

f}iso|nhk cylki|

Yhwyw|onhocdi ohl frisd~f}|n`nw|ng bnhohgnod }doh$ {n|a

frisw|o|il w|o|i onl sirihyi ohl

sidnohgi fh ]GWK] ksoh|

Hf Bnhohgnod ]doh gfh|onhwissfsw nh sirihyi: hf w|os|-y}

cylki|: gowa bdf{ gfhgishw


28/78

O}}ihlnq C

]oki (=) =(;) 3(2) 3(2) ;7(;) =(=) =(1) = ?=(;) ?(?) ??(3) =() ?=(>) =(? ?>((9) =(


30/78

O}}ihlnq L


31/78


32/78


33/78


34/78


35/78


36/78


37/78


38/78


39/78


40/78


41/78


42/78


43/78


44/78


45/78


46/78


47/78


48/78


49/78


50/78


51/78


52/78


53/78


54/78


55/78


56/78


57/78


58/78


59/78


60/78


61/78


62/78


63/78


64/78


65/78


66/78


67/78


68/78


69/78


70/78


71/78


72/78


73/78


74/78


75/78


76/78


77/78


78/78

ACOE Staff Report Portola Academy Petition Appeal Dec 2012

Documents