12 th June 2013 ACO. The future of drainage There’s more to drainage than meets the eye
Mar 10, 2016
12th June 2013
ACO. The future
of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Andy Buchan– Divisional Managing Director– ACO Building Drainage
The UK’s leading supplier of stainless steel drainage
systems for the internal and external built
environments.
□ Providing unparalleled technical expertise
□ Supporting architects, engineers and contractors
ACO has a strong history of success in supporting the
design and build of some of the most important
construction products in the UK.
ACO meets the need of its customers ands supply
chain partners through a collaborative approach –
solving problems!
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Raising the profile and
importance of hygienic
drainage.
Acting as agents of
change in partnership
with industry experts.
Headline, Verdana Fett 20 P. Maximal
zwei Zeilen. Zeilenabstand 1,1 Zeilen.
“Drainage is a critical component
affecting the hygienic performance
of food production. Effective
drainage helps mitigate hazards
from the external environment and
is central to the safe and hygienic
operation internally”
Applied and Environmental
Microbiology Volume 72
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Food safety
Cost reduction
Sustainability
Health and safety
Convenience/indulgence
Provenance/speciality
Campden BRI | Key trends
Food | UK’s No.1
Manufacturing Sector
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Costs £6bn per year
Accounts for 35% of all family doctor consultations
NHS | Key trends
Infectious Disease | UK’s No.1
Call on Doctors!
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Future drivers
Increase in food processing
Increase in external consumption
Consumer confidence
Reduced tolerance to infection
A need for openness and scrutiny
UK Food Sector
Listening and learning
to ensure we design
products that help
clients protect their
employees
Focus on kitchen and food
Providing
solutions to help
clients to protect
their food safety
& their brands
Focus on kitchen and food
Working in
partnership to
help clients
reduce costs
Focus on kitchen and food
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Geoff Ward– TD CFCIEH CMIOSH MRSPH FRSTMH FCSI - Chairman of Commercial Services CIEH Ltd
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
“How I learnt the
Importance of Drainage for Kitchens!”
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
A Career in Environmental Health
• It all started in the Army.....
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Manchester City Council I started at the bottom.....
• Pest Control and Drainage Examiner (2i/c!)
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Qualified EHO
• City Centre District Inspector – Law Enforcer...
• Default Works Officer – Putting right the wrongs....
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The black mop brigade!
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The world of FOG.......
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Where we are today • FOG – 1000 years to replace all the drains...
• Technical innovation in the kitchen......
• FCSI design......
• ACO Innovation and standards setting....
• The regulatory drivers – EU, USA, Emerging Economies, Global Economy
• Enforcement v Self policing
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Emerging Economies....
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
No wonder people get ill.....
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Martin Fairley - Research Director – ACO Technologies Plc
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Headline, Verdana Fett 20 P. Maximal
zwei Zeilen. Zeilenabstand 1,1 Zeilen.
The Paradigm is changing:
New global challenges
Legislative impact on design
The Global Challenges
Urbanisation:
Increase of covered surfaces
and water run off
Climate change:
More frequent and extreme
weather events
Infrastructure:
Limitations in sewer systems
Water Quantity
Too much: In the UK, there are currently 490,000 properties at significant risk of flooding. If we don’t increase action to reduce flood risk, an additional 350,000 more properties (making a total of 830,000) will be at significant risk of flooding by 2035 due to climate change. Too little: The total annual river flow in England and Wales could drop by 10 to 15 per cent by 2050, with 80 per cent less water in some rivers during the summer months.
http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/homeandleisure/climatechange/31802.aspx
Urbanisation
Urbanisation world-wide
30%
1960
70% in Europe 70% world-wide in 2050
1980
40%
2011
50%
2025
55%
Effects of Urbanisation on Water Cycle
15% infiltration | >50% surface runoff
>50% infiltration | 10% surface runoff
Flooding in Europe
Maplecroft 2011 Water stress indicator
http://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/326DB915874DAFCE852577D8005234ED-map.pdf
Water stress: total water use: renewable supply
Quality of water
Legislative response
EU Water Framework
Directive
SuDS National Standard Consultation…headlines
National Standards for SuDS as required in Schedule 3 of FWMA 2010 –for England (Welsh Gov’t will produce own set)
Requires construction work with drainage implications to be approved by SAB before commencement.
Amends Water Industry Act 1991 – the right to connect to sewer will be conditional on SAB approval
SAB to adopt and maintain drainage (more than one property).
The standards deal with DESTINATION – QUANTITY – QUALITY and FUNCTIONALITY
Destination hierarchy
Infiltrate
Watercourse
Surface water sewer
Combined sewer
5mm of any event not to discharge to SW body or
sewer” (DEFRA b.2)
SuDS components for QUALITY
Source: Ciria C687 pp 27-29
1. Filter drain
6. Retention
pond
7. Green roof
8. Soakaway
9. Rainwater
harvesting
10. Permeable
pavement
11. Attenuation
systems
12. Channels
and rills
13. Bio-
retention
14. Infiltration
trench
15. Filter strip
2. Swale
4. Detention
basin
3. Trench
5. Wetland 16. Rain
garden
Water quality
benefit
Key issues
Managing surface runoff – dense urban
infrastructure
Preventing sewer backflow
Other causes of sewer overflow - FOG
Thames Water spends £12 million a year clearing around 55,000 sewer blockages across London and the Thames Valley.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/walls-of-fat-removed-from-londons-sewers-2025528.html
FOG a complex problem P
oli
tical
•Capital intensive
Water Industry
•Social eating habits
• Economic
restructuring
•Diverse FSE Growth
•FSE concentration
•Consumer wealth
•Convenience eating
FOGc
Stakeholders
Problematic FOGc
•Climate change
•Rainfall intensity
•Sewerage infrastructure
•Combined systems
•Non-local WWTP
•Single
technology
Standard
•Imperfect
knowledge
•Non-verified
solutions
•Disparate kitchen
practices
• Regulations
allow ‘other’
solutions
• Performance
measurement
issues
Technologies and Standards for FOG
management
Grease management products
Separation
Separation and
biological
Direct injection
of bacteria
Grease
Removal /
Mechanical
BS EN 1825
… But…commonly used product Only one
Standard exists
CE Marked product – Compulsory from July
2013
BS EN 1825 with manual cleaning and
sampling
BS EN 1825 with fully automated
cleaning, evacuation and refill
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Dr John Holah– Campden BRI
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Food hygiene and the
role of drains
Dr. John Holah,
Business Development Project Manger - Hygiene, Campden
BRI
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Key trends for the food industry
• Food safety
• Cost reduction
• Sustainability
• Health and wellness
• Convenience/indulgence
• Provenance/speciality
What is Food Safety?
What hazards do we need to control
• Microorganisms
• Allergens
• Glass and hard plastics
• Specific chemicals
• Biological
• Chemicals
• Foreign bodies
Food Poisoning
The genus Listeria
• Listeria monocytogenes, L. innocua, L. ivanovii*,
L. seeligeri*, L. welshimeri*, L. grayi
• Morphology: Gram positive, non-sporing short rod
• Isolated from: soil, vegetation, faecal material, sewage, water,
• Temperature: -0.4oC - 43oC
• pH: 4.4 (30oC)/5.0 (5oC) - 9.6
• NaCI: growth 10% (aw0.94), survival 25% (aw0.84)
• Mild flu-like illness, abortion/still births (pregnant
women), meningitis (children and adults), endocarditis,
peritonitis, conjunctivitis, septicaemia, local abscess formation,
death
Listeria and drains - history
• 1990 – 10,000 environmental swab
samples in high risk areas for Listeria
• Levels
– Cleaning equipment 47%
– Drains 23%
– Floors 17%
– Food production surfaces 2%
Drain/floor
interfaces
I have been involved in
the closure of 5 factories
because of drains!!
Sources and vectors of
pathogens
• Sources - where they come from • Raw materials
• Environmental and product contact surfaces,
particularly if they are unhygienic ally designed
(drains)
• People
• Air
• Vectors - ways in which they are spread
1985 – Hygienic design for food safety is only 25 years old
Product contamination vectors
• AIR (and other gases)
• CONTACT SURFACES - e.g. hands,
clothing, conveyor belts, packaging,
equipment and utensils
• LIQUIDS - e.g. condensation, food grade
lubricants, biological fluids and water
(splashes, drips, direct contact)
Product
contamination
Loading
Transfer rate
Frequency
Normal/Illness
Recontamination
Contamination
Accidental
Continuous
Wet/dry Contact pressure
Stickness Contact time
Hand washing
Factors affecting
contamination
transfer e.g.
hand contact
Hygienic Infrastructure • Hygienic design of factories
• Factory site
• Factory building (including
drains)
• Segregation
• Process lines
• Hygienic design of
equipment and utensils
• Personal hygiene
• Transport
Hygienic practices • Maintenance
• Personal hygiene
• Cleaning and disinfection
• Allergen control
• Environmental sampling
methods
• Pest control
• Foreign body control
• Waste disposal
How do we control hazards
G
Goods
in
Goods
out
Wet
store
Dry
store Despatch
store
Administration and amenities
Site (1)
Food
prep
Low risk/
GMP
High care/
Risk
Prim
ary
packagin
g
Pro
duct
deconta
min
ation
Process line
(2) (4)
(3)
Perimeter fence
Challenge
Barriers
Drains connect the
inside of the
factory to the
sewer
•Size and choice appropriate to
liquid flows
•Adequate falls
•1 in 50 to 1 in 100
•Number and design of drains <5m
apart
Drainage Criteria
(Wet sector)
Drains and
segregation
• Liquids – draining from high to
low risk
– no back flow
– rodding from low risk
EHEDG Building design
High risk
Low risk
Rodding / jetting access
High Risk area drainage
Sewer
Automated Backflow valve – highly
recommended
High Risk
area
Low Risk
area
Low Risk area
drainage
How to prevent
Listeria ingress?
EHEDG Building design
The floor and drain is a
total solution
Good drain
design
Disseminate or collect?
EHEDG Building design
ACO design study –
migration of
microorganisms from
drains
1 - EC Reg. No. 1935/2004:
Materials and articles intended to
come into contact with food
• Food contact materials shall be safe. They shall not
transfer their components into the food in quantities that
could endanger human health, change the composition of
the food or deteriorate its taste or odour
• 17 groups established: active and intelligent materials,
adhesives, ceramics, cork, rubbers, glass, ion-exchange
resins, metals and alloys, paper and board, plastics,
printing inks, regenerated cellulose, silicones, textiles,
varnishes and coatings, waxes, wood
• FDA Regulations CFR Title 21
• Drains primarily stainless steel
2 - Positive relationship between
surface finish (RA) and
cleanability
RA = 0.5µm
RA = 1.0µm
RA = 3.0µm
Stainless steel, cold rolled 2B finish = 0.5µm
Staphylococcus aureus
When is a hole a surface?
>10µm? >2-10µm?
6 - Drainage
8 – General cleanability
•Stainless steel
•Crevice free welding
•Gasket seal – no metal-
to-metal joints
•No foreign bodies
•Drainable
•Cleanable – radiused
corners
•Fully sealable (dry
applications?)
Hygienically designed?
US ice-cream association 1988 – cannot use high
pressure cleaning systems
Vectors from drains
Contamination spread of a
range of cleaning systems
Cleaning system Height (m) Distance (m)
High pressure 3.55 7.0
Low pressure hose 2.25 4.0
Floor scrubber drier 0.47 1.5
Manual brushing 0.24 0.55
Manual wiping 0.23 0.35
Other vectors:- air movement, vehicular traffic, footwear,
cleaning equipment, peoples hands
Drain future needs
• One integrated floor unit – falls, surface
finishes, drains
• New products - Hygienically designed
drains with accessible parts
• Research - Movement of
microorganisms from sewer into factory?
• New opportunities - Cleaning methods
post trap
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Peter Jennings – Technical Director – ACO Building Drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
THERE‘S MORE TO DRAINAGE THAN MEETS
THE EYE EVENT
Eur Ing Peter Jennings BSc CEng FIMechE
Technical Director
CIEH, London
12 June 2013
HYGIENIC DRAINAGE FOR FOOD
PROCESSING APPLICATIONS
Seminar objectives
Minimising specification risks for hygienic drainage
in food processing areas:
Regulations & terminology for commercial kitchens &
food preparation areas
Typical drainage configurations and applications areas
Principal bacteria & pathogens found in food production
areas
Drainage design to minimise bacteria & pathogen traps
Material selection for food processing drainage
elements
Useful references & further learning
Summary
Questions
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Duncan Hepburn– Food Service Consultancy Society
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Drainage guide
for the
Commercial Kitchen
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Why a Drainage Guide
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The development
Principal Kitchen Areas
• Storage & preparation
• Production & cooking
• Dishwashing
• Disposal
What’s in the Guide
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Information
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The First Edition
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Eric Partington– Consultant – EHEDG (The European Hygienic Engineering & Design Group) / Nickel Institute
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
Eric Partington European Consultant to the Nickel Institute
Chairman of EHEDG Sub-Group Materials of Construction
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
3
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
4
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
5
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
10
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
11
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
12
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
16
Determination of the operating environment:
- the food
- the cleaning regime
Knowledge of materials behaviour
Selection of materials
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
18
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
19
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
21
Which plastic?
Which elastomer?
Which ceramic?
Which composite?
Which metal?
Which stainless steel?
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
23
Martensitic stainless steels
13% Chromium; high carbon
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
24
Ferritic stainless steels
17% Chromium; low carbon
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
25
Austenitic stainless steels
18% Chromium; 10% Nickel
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
26
Duplex stainless steels
22% Chromium; 5% Nickel
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
27
Super-austenitic stainless steels
20% Chromium; 22% Nickel; 4% Molybdenum
The European Hygienic Equipment and Design
Group
EHEDG
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
28
1 Microbiologically safe continuous pasteurization of liquid food 2 A method for assessing the in-place cleanability of food processing equipment. 3 Microbiologically safe aseptic packing of food products. 4 A method for the assessment of in-line pasteurisation of food processing equipment. 5 A method for the assessment of in-line sterilisability of food processing equipment. 6 The microbiologically safe continuous flow1 thermal sterilisation of liquid foods. 7 A method for the assessment of bacteria-tightness of food processing equipment. 8 Hygienic equipment design criteria. 9 Welding stainless steel to meet hygienic requirements. 10 Hygienic design of closed equipment for the processing of liquid food. 11 Hygienic packing of food products. 12 The continuous or semi-continuous flow thermal treatment of particulate foods. 13 Hygienic design of equipment for open processing.
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
29
EHEDG Technical Guidelines, 1994
1 Microbiologically safe continuous pasteurization of liquid food 2 A method for assessing the in-place cleanability of food processing equipment. 3 Microbiologically safe aseptic packing of food products. 4 A method for the assessment of in-line pasteurisation of food processing equipment. 5 A method for the assessment of in-line sterilisability of food processing equipment. 6 The microbiologically safe continuous flow thermal sterilisation of liquid foods. 7 A method for the assessment of bacteria-tightness of food processing equipment. 8 Hygienic equipment design criteria. 9 Welding stainless steel to meet hygienic requirements. 10 Hygienic design of closed equipment for the processing of liquid food. 11 Hygienic packing of food products. 12 The continuous or semi-continuous flow thermal treatment of particulate foods. 13 Hygienic design of equipment for open processing. 14 Hygienic design of valves for food processing. 15 A method for the assessment of in-place cleanability of moderately sized food processing equipment. 16 Hygienic pipe couplings. 17 Hygienic design of pumps, homogenisers and dampening devices. 18 Passivation of stainless steel. 19 A method for assessing the bacterial impermeability of hydrophobic membrane filters. 20 Hygienic design and safe use of double-seat mixproof valves. 21 Challenge tests for the evaluation of the hygienic characteristics of packing machines for liquid and semi-liquid products, 2000. 22 General hygienic design criteria for the safe processing of dry particulate materials. 23 Production and use of food-grade lubricants (Part 1 and 2) 24 The prevention and control of Legionella spp. (incl legionnaires disease) in food factories 25 Design of mechanical seals for hygienic and aseptic applications. 26 Hygienic engineering of plants for the processing of dry particulate materials. 27 Safe storage and distribution of water in food factories. 28 Safe and hygienic water treatment in food factories. 29 Hygienic design of packing systems for solid foodstuffs. 30 Guidelines on air handling in the food industry. 31 Hygienic engineering of fluid bed and spray dryer plants. 32 Materials of construction for equipment in contact with food. 33 Hygienic engineering of discharging systems for dry particulate materials. 34 Integration of hygienic and aseptic systems. 35 Hygienic welding of stainless steel tubing in the food processing industry. 36 Hygienic Engineering of Transfer Systems for Dry Particulate Materials 37 Hygienic Design and Application of Sensors 38 Hygienic Engineering of Rotary Valves in Process Lines for Dry Particulate Materials. 39 Design Principles for Equipment and Process Areas for Aseptic Food Manufacturing 40 Hygienic Engineering of Valves in Process Lines for Dry Particulate Materials 41 Hygienic Engineering of Diverter Valves in Process Lines for Dry Particulate Materials
EHEDG Technical Guidelines, 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
31
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
33
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
34
Belgium Denmark Germany France Italy the Netherlands the Nordic countries (Finland, Sweden, Norway) Poland Spain Switzerland
EHEDG Regional Sections, 1989
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
39
Belgium Denmark Germany France Italy the Netherlands the Nordic countries (Finland, Sweden, Norway) Poland Spain Switzerland
EHEDG Regional Sections, 2013+
Armenia Czech Republic Japan Lithuania Macedonia Mexico Russia Serbia Taiwan Thailand Turkey the Ukraine
Bulgaria Brazil China India Croatia Latvia Romania Uruguay USA
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
43
Benefits of EHEDG membership EHEDG creates a source of, and a platform for the exchange of, excellence in hygienic engineering. It facilitates networking on an international level and its training material is developed by internationally-recognised experts in the field. EHEDG influences global standards and rules and has real impact on regulatory bodies. EHEDG can provide equipment certification by EHEDG-accredited test institutes; demonstration that EHEDG Guidelines have been observed has added to defence arguments in court. EHEDG produces reference publications like its Yearbook and publishes in scientific journals and trade magazines.
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013 Eric Partington - Selection of Materials and the EHEDG
45
Belgium Denmark Germany France Italy the Netherlands the Nordic countries (Finland, Sweden, Norway) Poland Spain Switzerland
EHEDG Regional Sections, 2013+
Armenia Czech Republic Japan Lithuania Macedonia Mexico Russia Serbia Taiwan Thailand Turkey the Ukraine
Bulgaria Brazil China India Croatia Latvia Romania Uruguay USA UK?
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Dr Russell M. Green – PhD., M.Sc., B.A. (Hons), M.C.I.E.H. - lecturer and worked as a HACCP consultant both in the UK and for the World Health Organisation (WHO)
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The Role of Prerequisites in a HACCP Food Safety Management System
Dr. Russell M. Green PhD. MSc. BA. (hons). CFCIEH
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Total Food Safety (Taylor & Kane, 2003)
HACCP
Significant Risks
Prerequisite Programme
GMP/GHP General Hazards
Equipment
Facilities
Design & Construction
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Article 4 Prerequisites
General hygiene requirements for all food businesses as laid down in Annex 11
Article 5 HACCP
A food safety management system based on HACCP principles contained in the
Codex Alimentarius
Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 29th April 2004.
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
1. Assemble HACCP Team 2. Describe Product 3. Identify Intended use 4. Construct Flow Diagram 5. On-site Confirmation of Flow Diagram 6. Identify hazards 7. Identify Critical Control Points (CCPs) 8. Establish Critical Limits for CCPs 9. Monitor CCPs 10. Establish corrective actions where monitoring
shows CCP out of control 11. Verification procedure for 1-5 above 12. Document & record
Logic Sequence for the application of HACCP Codex Alimentarius
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 Annex 11 1. Premises: clean, in good repair & condition 2. Suitable layout, design, construction 3. Adequate WCs/WHBs 4. Suitable & sufficient ventilation 5. Adequate natural and/or artificial lighting 6. Adequate drainage facilities 7. Changing facilities 8. Separate storage for cleaning materials
Prerequisites
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Permit adequate maintenance, cleaning &/or disinfection, avoid or minimise airborne contamination.
Protect against accumulation of dirt, contact with toxic materials
Permit good food hygiene practices & protect against pest control
Provide suitable temperature control
Layout, design & construction
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Drainage facilities are to be adequate for the purpose intended. They are to be designed & constructed to avoid the risk of contamination. Where drainage channels are fully or partially open, they are to be so designed as to ensure that waste does not flow from a contaminated area towards or into a clean area, in particular an area where foods likely to present a high risk to the final consumer are handled
EC Regulation 852/2004, Annex 11 Drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Failure to comply with this legislation can result in:
•Food Hygiene Letters •Improvement Notices •Prohibition Notices •Closure of the business •Prohibition of persons to run a food business
•Adverse Publicity
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Lebanese Restaurant, Warwick District Council 31st August 2012 Fined £400 for food labelling offences then:- ‘Defendant disappeared before sentencing for other offences’
Prohibited Persons: Failure to ensure that drainage facilities were adequate for the
purpose intended Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Article 4,
Annex 11, Chapter 1, para8
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Takeaway,
Blackpool Council
21st October 2012
Fined £350 + £150 costs + £15 victim surcharge
‘..a putrid smell coming from a blocked drain ..’
Prohibited Persons: Failure to ensure that drainage facilities were adequate for the
purpose intended Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Article 4,
Annex 11, Chapter 1, para8
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Takeaway Restaurant,
Fylde Borough Council
2nd January 2013
Fined £250 + £100 costs + £15 victim surcharge; curfew order for 16 weeks 8pm/6am
‘..gulley appears to be connected to a rain water drain..’
Prohibited Persons: Failure to ensure that drainage facilities were adequate for the
purpose intended Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Article 4,
Annex 11, Chapter 1, para8
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Chinese Restaurant,
Torfaen Council
8th October 2010
Fined £440 + £100
Voluntary closure
‘Basement food preparation area & storage areas covered in raw sewage’
Other Prosecutions:
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Fishmonger,
Peterborough City Council
EHN September 2010
Business closed
‘..open drains at the back of the premises…
could attract rodents ’
Other Prosecutions:
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Takeaway,
King’s Lynn Borough Council
16th January 2009
Fined £7000 + £820 costs
‘..open drain ….given access to rats’
Other Prosecutions:
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Takeaway,
Arun Council
November 2004
Fined £6,500 + £5,916 costs
‘..blocked drain in the WC….pungent faecal
odour throughout’
Other Prosecutions:
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Robert Bentley– Product Manager Performance Flooring / Engineered Waterproofing, BASF
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Cleaning up on Slips
and Trips: Resin
Flooring
Robert Bentley - Product Manager BASF
Performance Flooring and Engineered Waterproofing
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Resin flooring?
There are many different types of resin flooring available.
Epoxy, polyurethane, pMMA………
However, the leaning choice in the food and beverage industry is HEAVY DUTY POLYURETHANE.
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
What is UCRETE® ?
In principle the UCRETE Heavy Duty Polyurethane Resin Binder System is produced by adding water to a traditional polyurethane and controlling the ensuing reaction in the mixer.
This is the chemistry that ICI effectively patented.
You cannot buy this chemistry off the shelf.
UCRETE is unique to BASF Construction Chemicals
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
UCRETE® Industrial Flooring
Key Properties
Rapid installation and Moisture Tolerant
Non-tainting
Hygienic and as Cleanable as Stainless Steel
Temperature Resistant
Slip resistant
Chemically Resistant
Monolithically Bonded
Wear and Impact Resistant
Long low maintenance service life
ALL KEY REQUIREMENTS
IN THE FOOD AND
BEVERAGE INDUSTRY
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Permanently wet and often greasy environments are widely encountered in the food and beverage industry
Commercial kitchens
Vegetable and salad wash and prep
Bottling halls
Wash bays
Permanent immersion in water can cause some resin floors to fail even when no aggressive chemicals are present.
The Food Industry Environment
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The range of temperatures encountered in the food industry which
can impact on the floor is extreme
In freezers down to – 40 oC
Under frying lines to + 150 oC
In Clean In Place (CIP) areas
Cleaning of vessels
Under pasteurisers
Often extreme thermal shock is involved for example in the partial
cooking and quenching of vegetables
The Food Industry Environment
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
4 mm Fully resistant to 70 ºC
6 mm Fully resistant to 80 ºC and light steam clean
9 mm Fully resistant to 120 ºC and full
steam clean
12 mm Fully resistant to 130 ºC
occasional spillage up
to 150 ºC and full steam clean
Temperature Resistance by Thickness
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There is a wide range of chemicals that can impact on the floor
Organic acids from fruit and oxidizing fats
Inorganic acids for cleaning
Strong alkalis from cleaning
Flavours and essences
Sugars and salts
Alcohol
Bleaches and sanitizers
The Food Industry Environment
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
UCRETE is resistant to the following chemicals commonly encountered in the food and beverage industry:-
30% Lactic acid lactic acid in milk
100% Oleic acid at 60 oC acids from oils and fats
50% Citric acid fruit acids
50% Acetic acid vinegar and sauces
Alcohol (Ethanol) wines and spirits hand wash
50% Sodium hydroxide for cleaning
30% Nitric acid for cleaning
15% Sodium hypochlorite for disinfection
UCRETE Chemical Resistance
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The Food Industry Environment
It is unsurprising then given the working environment that cleaning
and slip and trips is such a major issue.
Constantly wet, greasy and debris prone environments present
significant challenges on a daily basis for factory operators.
However, the correct specification of flooring finishes and the
implementation of appropriate cleaning regimes can help to
significantly improve safety and hygiene.
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Slips Trips and Falls
Slip accidents are a major
source of industrial injury
20% of all industrial injuries in
the UK result from slips
In the food industry slips occur
at 6 times the average for
industry as a whole
Slips and trips account for 35%
of “major injuries” in the food
industry
Slip Resistance
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Slips Trips and Falls
Compensation culture is growing and as a result so are the costs
of injury claims
Health and Safety legislation requires companies to do
everything possible to minimise the risk of slip accidents
The Health and Safety at Work act 1974 states
– Employers/employees must not endanger themselves or
others, this includes taking steps to control slip and trip
risks
Slip Resistance
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Measurement of slip resistance
The action of slipping is the result of a
complex set of forces. A lot of research
has been conducted which has led to
many test methods
Two properties are commonly measured
– Surface roughness
– Coefficient of friction
Slip Resistance
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Two methods
Pendulum tester - EN13036 Pt 4
Tilting Ramp test - DIN51130
Coefficient of Friction
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
EN13036 Pt 4 Slip resistant testing
4S rubber
0 - 24 high slip potential
25 - 35 moderate slip potential
36 + low slip potential
Coefficient of Friction
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Measures slip
resistance directly on a
tilting ramp.
R10: 10o -19o
R11: 19o - 27o
R12: 27o - 35o
R13: >35o
DIN 51130 Ramp test
Coefficient of Friction
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
UCRETE DIN51130 EN13036-4 (Wet)
HPQ R11 35 - 45
UD200 R11 40 - 45
DP10 R11 40 - 50
DP20 R13 45 - 55
Slip Resistance
4S rubber
0 - 24 high slip potential
25 - 35 moderate slip potential
36 + low slip potential
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
UCRETE® Solutions for the Food Industry Slip Resistance is a Balance
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Remove debris
Temperatures in excess of 50 oC
required to mobilise fats
Degreasing agents require time to
work
Mechanical action helps shift dirt
Cleaning solution and soil must be
removed
Cleaning
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Mechanical scrubber drying machines
are preferred method of cleaning
Cleaning
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
UCRETE® DP10
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Defined profile floors with a
macro-textured surface can be
easier to clean than floors with a
finer texture
UCRETE floors can be cleaned
to a standard comparable to
stainless steel (confirmed by
independent testing – Campden
BRI)
Textured Floors are Easy to Clean!
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Accumulation of debris on floor - engineering solution?
Infrequent or inadequate cleaning
Steep or complex falls
Pushing racks and bins
Reaching, leaning, stretching
Poor footwear - worn out? not cleaned?
Fats / grease being walked or trafficked into areas with low profile floors
Factors affecting Slips Trips and Falls
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Heavy and hard wheeled traffic is widely encountered in the food
industry
Bins with small hard plastic wheels
Steel wheeled tray racks
Pallet trucks
Mixing vessels
Often traffic is concentrated in key areas, at doorways, at oven
thresholds, under mixing heads, for example
These types of wheels can massively reduce the long term slip
resistance of flooring.
Retention of Slip Resistance: Durability
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
For a long lived floor like
UCRETE retention of slip
resistance is important.
For this we have selected the
toughest aggregates
Retention of Slip Resistance: Durability
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye’
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
UCRETE Floors for the food industry
There are many 20 - 30 year old UCRETE floors still in service
There are many independent test reports/approvals which
demonstrate the suitability of UCRETE for the food industry.
There are references in many countries and with many major
international brands.
UCRETE® Solutions for the Food Industry
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
ACO. The future of drainage
Andy Buchan– Divisional Managing Director– ACO Building Drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Major practices are gearing up for the whole scale move over to BIM. SME’s are less reluctant – but understand the need to change. Contractors see the benefits as well as Architects. Academia is developing BIM related courses. Software suppliers are actively pushing solutions. Results from completed projects are actively being marketed There is worldwide interest in the UK BIM scene. BIM is not just for the building- it includes infrastructure Keith Howells of Mott Macdonald, equated BIM with the Excel spread sheet, warning,
“If you’re not using BIM in five years time, you’ll probably be out of business
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
The ACO BIM Survey Conclusions:
• Revit and Civil 3D are the most used. • Specification Data is “a must”. • Maintenance and Operation information is a key factor. • Web based downloads seem favourite. • 50% of respondents involved with BIM NOW. • Infrastructure Professionals responses reflected similar
needs and requirements.
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
What’s next? • Cleanability!
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
Empirical ‘industry‘
research into the
failure mechanism of
the interface
between channel,
gully and floor
structure…
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
2013 EHEDG Yearbook
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013
ACO. The future of drainage
There’s more to drainage than meets the eye!
ACO Conference – 12th June 2013