7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 1/45 Khhgqopkfilipy kx Hqlpqvkl Eaysgv` Malzio @qfoihe Qoizavxipy gj Oas Bkm~xbiva m`qfoiheN`qfoihe/oap "@vkjp4 ^lakxa `g ogp hipa sipbgqp ~avmixxigo) ^va~kva` jgv k ~vaxaopkpigo kp k xamiokv gj pba Vaxakvhb Hgllg{qiqm go Cgg` Cgzavokoha Oapbavlko`x Ioxpipqpa gj Cgzavomaop ZQ Qoizavxipy Kmxpav`km, Mky 9 6>;6
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 1/45
Khhgqopkfilipy kx Hqlpqvkl Eaysgv`
Malzio @qfoiheQoizavxipy gj Oas Bkm~xbiva
m`qfoiheN`qfoihe/oap "@vkjp4 ^lakxa `g ogp hipa sipbgqp ~avmixxigo)
^va~kva` jgv k ~vaxaopkpigo kp k xamiokv gj pba
Vaxakvhb Hgllg{qiqm go Cgg` Cgzavokoha
Oapbavlko`x Ioxpipqpa gj Cgzavomaop
ZQ Qoizavxipy
Kmxpav`km, Mky 9 6>;6
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 2/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;
Khhgqopkfilipy kx k Hqlpqvkl ^baogmaogo
Sgv`x mkppav, ko` kp koy x~ahijia` pima ko` ~lkha xgma sgv`x mkppav
mgva pbko gpbavx, ogp fahkqxa pbay ~vgzi`a k xpkfla jgqo`kpigo gv jghkl ~giop jgv
gqv hgllahpiza ao`akzgvx, fqp vkpbav jgv pba kmficqipiax ko` hgopvgzavxiax pbay
caoavkpa io gqv ajjgvpx pg `akl sipb k si`a vkoca gj xghikl, ahgogmih ko` ~glipihkl
~vgflamx/ Vkymgo` Sillikmx ";93:5 ;928) hgioa` pba ~bvkxa “hqlpqvkl eaysgv`x”
pg `axicokpa pbgxa pavmx io k hgmmqoipy’x zghkfqlkvy pbkp ogp goly ~vgzi`a
makoiocjql ioxicbpx iopg pba ~vigvipiax ko` zklqax gj pbkp xghiapy, fqp klxg ~lky k
xicoijihkop vgla io hvakpioc pba `yokmih hqlpqvkl miliaq pbkp hgooahpx ko` xbk~ax
im~gvpkop ko` ~vgflamkpih xghikl kvaokx/; Pbqx, pba xicoijihkoha gj k hqlpqvkl
eaysgv` `gax ogp hgma jvgm pba pahboihkl gv okvvgs makoioc gj k pavm ‘ i/a/, pba
sky ip ix `ajioa` io xgma kqpbgvipkpiza xgqvha xqhb kx pba `ihpigokvy ‘ fqp vkpbav
jvgm ipx “hgm~lar valkpigox sipb gpbav, ximilkvly hgm~lar sgv`x” "@qvkop 6>>:, ~/
0) sipbio pba `yokmih hqlpqvkl miliaq io sbihb ip ~lkyx k haopvkl ko` gjpao
hgopvgzavxikl vgla/
Pbix ~k~av jghqxax go k ~kvpihqlkv hqlpqvkl eaysgv` ‘ khhgqopkfilipy -- pbkp,
`ax~ipa ipx kfxaoha jvgm Sillikmx’ gviciokl lixp gj ;;> pavmx ~qflixba` io ;93: "gv
bix vazixa` ko` ar~ko`a` lixp gj ;8; eaysgv`x ~qflixba` io ;928), sgql` og
`gqfp bkza faao iohlq`a` io koy vazixigo ba micbp bkza ixxqa` io pba ;99>x gv
lkpav "Sillikmx `ia` io ;922)/
Io xq~~gvp gj pbkp hgopaopigo, Jicqva ;k ~vgzi`ax azi`aoha gj pba cvgsioc
jva{qaohy gj pba pavm’x qxa io k xkm~lioc gj fggex fkxa` go k milligo xhkooa`
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 3/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
6
zglqmax `vkso jvgm sgvex ~qflixba` io Aoclixb "io pba QX ko` QE) fapsaao
;2>> ko` 6>;>/6 Sbila khhgqopkfilipy jivxp k~~akvx io pba ~lgppa` xkm~la `qvioc
pba akvly ;2>>x, ip vamkiox k hqlpqvklly iooghqgqx pavm qopil pba ;9:>x ko` ;93>x,
sbao sa xpkvp pg xaa k xbkv~ ko` xicoijihkop q~pqvo io ipx qxkca/ Io hgopvkxp,
mkoy pavmx kmgoc Sillikmx’ gviciokl eaysgv` lixpx "Jicqva ;f) xbgs k `ahlioa io
qxkca xpkvpioc io pba ;93>x/
UJicqva ; BAVA]
Fqp khhgqopkfilipy’x hlkim pg hqlpqvkl eaysgv` xpkpqx xpkvpioc io pba ~kxp psg
gv pbvaa `ahk`ax ix klxg fkxa` go bgs pba pavm bkx faao qxa` io pbix ~avig`, jgv
ip bkx cgoa jvgm k valkpizaly okvvgs vkoca gj k~~lihkpigox vajlahpioc k xim~la
xaoxa gj ipx makoioc "py~ihklly io`ihkpioc k hgo`ipigo sbava goa ~kvpy ix
koxsavkfla pg kogpbav jgv xgma R) pg ko ar~koxiza, kmficqgqx ko` gjpao
aoicmkpih pavm sipb hgoxi`avkfla hqlpqvkl cvkzipkx hqppioc khvgxx mkoy hqlpqvkl
`gmkiox/
Pba io`ihkpigox gj pbix `azalg~maop kva lipavklly azavysbava/ Pbava ix
bkv`ly koy kx~ahp gj gqv lizax pbkp bkx ogp faao pgqhba` fy gqv cvgsioc
gfxaxxigo sipb khhgqopkfilipy/ Sa bgl` pakhbavx khhgqopkfla jgv pba ~avjgvmkoha
gj pbaiv xpq`aopx, ko` ~vaxi`aopx khhgqopkfla jgv pba xpkpa gj pba ahgogmy5 sa
bgl` ~kvaopx khhgqopkfla jgv pba fabkzigv gj pbaiv hbil`vao, ko` ~gliha
khhgqopkfla jgv bicbav hvima vkpax5 sa `amko` khhgqopkfilipy jgv fkoeavx sbg
sa faliaza hkqxa` k jiokohikl hvixax, ko` hkll jgv cvakpav khhgqopkfilipy sbao pba
~gpbglax io gqv lghkl vgk`x cg qova~kiva`/ Sa vakhp pg kll hvimax ko` xhko`klx
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 4/45
+
+++
+
+
+
A k h b gj p b a p a v m x " h k x a x a o x i p i z a ) q x a ` i o p b i x
j i c qv a k v a ; - cv k m qo
i p x " qoi cv k m x ) / Q x k c a
j v a { q a o h y " z a v p i h k l k
ri x ) i x h gm ~ q p a ` f y ` i zi ` i o c
p b a o qm f a v gj i o x p k o
h a x gj p b a o- cv k m qoi p i o k
ci z a o y a k v f y p b a p g p k l o qm f a v gj s gv ` x i o p b a
h gv ~ q x " o qm f a v gj x h k oo a ` s gv e x ) i o p b k p y a k v /
P b a h gv ~ q x q x a ` b a v a k v a x h k oo a ` s gv e x
~ q f l i x b a ` i oA o cl i x b
p b a Q X k o ` QEj gv p b a y a k v x
+
J i c qv a; k4
Q x k c aj v a { q ao h y gj p av m“ k h h g
qo p k f i l i p y ,” ; 2 > > <6 > > >
+J i c qv a; f 4 Q x k c aj v a { q ao h y gj x al a h p a `
“ h ql p qv kl e a y s gv ` x ”
" Si l l i km
x ; 9 2 8 ) ko ` p av m“ k h h g qo p k f i l i p y ,” ; 2 > > <6 > > >
+
J i c qv a; 4 O< cv
km ko kl y x i x gj
“ k h h g qo p k f i l i p
y” ko ` x al a h p a `
h ql p qv kl e a y s gv ` x ,; 2 > > <6 > > >
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 5/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
8
"ko` azao okpqvkl `ixkxpavx+) fy hkllioc jgv xgmagoa pg fa bal` pg khhgqop, ko`
sa ar~ahp pbava pg fa khhgqopkfilipy xyxpamx io ~lkha pg ~vazaop pba vahqvvaoha
gj dqxp kfgqp koy qopgskv` fabkzigv/ Sbao pbava ix k ~vgflam, ip ix jva{qaoply
flkma` go pba lkhe gj khhgqopkfilipy/ Sbao kxea` jgv xglqpigox pg ~vgflamx, mgva
khhgqopkfilipy ix liealy pg bak` pba lixp/ Ip ix pba vkva oasx fvgk`hkxp io`aa` pbkp
jkilx pg maopigo khhgqopkfilipy io kp lakxp goa gj ipx xpgviax, ko` ip ix pba vkva
~glipihiko sbg jkilx pg iohlq`a vajavaoha pg khhgqopkfilipy io bav x~aahbax gv io bix
~vaxx valakxax/
^avzkxiza ix goa sky pg hbkvkhpavita gqv hgllahpiza gfxaxxigo sipb
khhgqopkfilipy/ ^gllipp ko` Bq~a "6>;;) bkx hlkxxijia` ip kx goa gj pba “mkcihkl
sgv`x” xbkva` si`aly fy xpq`aopx ko` ~vkhpipigoavx gj cgzavokoha/8 Pg xgma
hvipihx pba pavm “~avzavxiza” ix k mgva jippioc hbkvkhpavitkpigo/ Io bav 6>>6 Vaipb
Lahpqvax jgv pba FFH, ~bilgxg~bav Gogvk G’Oaill skx kmgoc pba jivxp pg vkixa
{qaxpigox kfgqp pba `kmkcioc iojlqaoha gj khhgqopkfilipy, ko` ~kvpihqlkvly pba
sky ip ix qo`avmioioc xghikl pvqxp io ioxpipqpigox ko` pba ~vgjaxxigox/ K yakv
akvliav, io bav Mkxxay Lahpqvax cizao jgv pba HFH, Hkok`iko ~glipihkl xhiaopixp
Dkoiha Cvgxx Xpaio vkixa` pba x~ahpav gj k mgva iopvqxiza xpkpa hgm~vixa` gj k
cvgsioc hgv~x gj “khhgqopkfilipy ~gliha” hgmmippa` pg pba im~gxipigo gj xpko`kv`x
io baklpb hkva, a`qhkpigo ko` gpbav kvakx "Xpaio 6>>6, hbk~pav 6)/ Mgva vahaoply,
Mkppbas Jlio`avx "6>;;) kvcqa` pbkp pba cvgspb gj khhgqopkfilipy ix kxxghikpa`
sipb k `ahlioa io ~qflih hgoji`aoha io gqv ~glipihkl ioxpipqpigox/ Fqp ba klxg pgge
ogpa gj pba jkhp pbkp bix oackpiza zias gj pba cvgsioc iojlqaoha gj khhgqopkfilipy
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 6/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
0
skx k `ixpiohply miogvipy ~gxipigo, k jkhp vajlahpa` io pba pipla gj bix ~iaha4 “@kvioc
pg fa @koial”/0
Fqp pba valkpizaly vahaop amavcaoha gj khhgqopkfilipy pg hqlpqvkl eaysgv`
xpkpqx ix kx ~qttlioc kx ip ix im~gvpkop jgv gqv hgm~vabaoxigo gj hbkocax pbkp kva
pkeioc ~lkha io pba `gmkiox gj ~glipihx ko` cgzavokoha/ Bava ix k pavm pbkp bkx
faao ~kvp gj pba mg`avo cgzavokoha ~kvk`icm jgv oakvly k millaooiqm "xaa
@qfoihe ;992 ko` falgs), fqp bkx goly gj lkpa fahgma pba ihgoih mkoijaxpkpigo gj
“cgg` cgzavokoha”/ Sbila pvakpa` ~gxipizaly jgv `ahk`ax kx k `axivkfla
hbkvkhpavixpih gj pba mg`avo `amghvkpih xpkpax, pbava bkza faao og oas mkdgv
pbagvapihkl fvakepbvgqcbx io pba xpq`y gj ~glipihx gv cgzavomaop pbkp bkx ~qxba`
khhgqopkfilipy pg pba jgvacvgqo` kx pba ~vaamioaop ~qflih zklqa/ Ogv bkx ipx
vahaop vixa pg clgfkl xkliaoha faao pba vaxqlp gj koy hgbavaop xghikl mgzamaop gv
vajgvmixp i`aglgcy5 io jkhp, pba ~qxb jgv cvakpav khhgqopkfilipy xaamx pg fa k ~giop
gj kcvaamaop io azao pba mgxp ~kvpixko ko` `izi`a` ~glipihkl hgoparpx/ Io pbkp
vackv`, khhgqopkfilipy bkx pvqly fahgma k “cgl`ao hgoha~p” "Fgzaox, Xhbillamkox
ko` ‒p Bkvp 6>>2)/
Sbkpazav pba hkqxa gj khhgqopkfilipy’x amavcaoha kx k hqlpqvkl eaysgv`,
pbava ix lippla `gqfp pbkp ipx oasly ckioa` im~gvpkoha kx k hqlpqvkl ihgo bkx
pvkoxjgvma` ipx jgvm ko` jqohpigo io cgzavokoha ko` ~glipihx/ Khhgqopkfilipy ix og
lgocav mavaly k qxajql ioxpvqmaop pg fa ~qlla` jvgm pba ~glihy gv mkokcamaop
pgglfgr pg `akl sipb xgma x~ahijih ~vgflam/ Pbava ix ogs pba kqvk gj lacipimkhy
kxxghikpa` sipb ipx qxa, azao ij ip ix gfzigqxly ko iok~~vg~vikpa ioxpvqmaop jgv pba
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 7/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
1
dgf/ Io k``ipigo, gzav pba ~kxp xazavkl `ahk`ax pbava bkx `azalg~a` k xpvgoc
faliaj io pba hk~khipy gj khhgqopkfilipy pg khbiaza xgma gj gqv mgxp bicbly zklqa`
gfdahpizax/ Ar~vaxxa` kx pba “~vgmixax gj khhgqopkfilipy” "@qfoihe ko`
Jva`avihexgo 6>;;), pbaxa iohlq`a qo{qaxpigoa` ‘ ko` gjpao qoxqfxpkopikpa` ‘
kxxqm~pigox pbkp zkvigqx jgvmx gj khhgqopkfilipy sill vaxqlp io k mgva
`amghvkpihklly vax~goxiza cgzavomaop, im~vgzamaopx io pba ajjihiaop ko`
ajjahpiza ~avjgvmkoha gj cgzavomaop kcaohiax, k mgva apbihkl ~qflih xahpgv
sgvejgvha, ko` pba aobkoha` hk~khipy gj cgzavomaop pg caoavkpa dqxp ko`
a{qipkfla ~glihy gqphgmax/
Kx pg pba klpavkpigox gj jgvm, sipbio gvckoitkpigox ko` ~vgcvkmx, pba
pvk`ipigokl fqvakqhvkpih mahbkoixmx gj khhgqopkfilipy fkxa` go pba hvakpigo gj
khhgqop-cizioc valkpigoxbi~x ko` va~gvpioc ~vgpghglx "a/c/, xaa Ekqjmko ;9:;)
bkza faao va~lkha` fy azao mgva `abqmkoitioc im~avxgokl bicb-xpkeax
kxxaxxmaop ~vgcvkmx `vizao fy k lgcih gj mapvihx `axicoa` pg ~qxb ~avjgvmkoha
jgvskv` sipb lippla hgoxi`avkpigo jgv pba k`zavxa im~khp xqhb ko k~~vgkhb ix
bkzioc go khhgqopkfla kcaop "xaa Tqfgjj ;922 ko` Bqmmal 6>>25 klxg Afvkbim
6>>8, 6>>9)/
Io xbgvp, cizao ipx amavcaoha kx k hqlpqvkl eaysgv`, sa hko og lgocav valy
go gqv eogsla`ca gj khhgqopkfilipy io ipx gl`av, xim~lav jgvm/ Sbkp sa kva `aklioc
sipb ix ogp mavaly k xap gj ioxpipqpigokl kvvkocamaopx gv mkokcavikl mahbkoixmx,
fqp k hqlpqvkl ~baogmaogo pbkp ix `gmiokpioc ko` hgoxqmioc gqv pvk`ipigokl
ogpigox gj cgzavokoha/ Gqv caoavkl gfdahpiza bava ix pg aobkoha gqv
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 8/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
:
qo`avxpko`ioc gj pbix amavcaop jgvm gj khhgqopkfilipy kx ip valkpax pg pba `gmkiox
gj cgzavokoha ko` ~glipihx/
Sillikmx’~vgdahpbk`kximilkv~qv~gxa/Bixk~~vgkhbpgpbahqlpqvkl
eaysgv`xbicblicbpa`iobixpsga`ipigoxskxpg~vgzi`axbgvpaxxkyxpbkpar~lgva`
pba`ihpigokvy"mgxpgjpaopbakqpbgvipkpizaGrjgv`Aoclixb@ihpigokvy )aopvygjpba
pavmko`alkfgvkpajqvpbavgopbaivbixpgvihkl`azalg~maop,ar~ko`a`qxkca,
arpao`a makoiocxko`cvgsiocxicoijihkohakxhqlpqvklkvpijkhpx/Qo`avlyiocbix
k~~vgkhb,bgsazav,skxkmapbg`glgcihkl`ilammkcaoavkpa`fypbajkhppbkpba
skxximqlpkoagqxly`akliocsipbxim~lasgv`xpbkpbk`kppkioa`pbaxpkpqxgj
im~gvpkophqlpqvkl~baogmaoksipbhgoxi`avkflaxymfglihko`kjjahpizazklqa/
@qviocpbaHgl Skv,jgvarkm~la,pbakhpgjhklliocxgmagoak“xghiklixp”
hgql`fakxim~la`axhvi~pizakhp,gv"qo`avhavpkiohivhqmxpkohax)iphkofa~kvpgjk
xicoijihkop~glipihkl~avjgvmkohasipb~gpaopikllyoackpizaxghiklhgoxa{qaohaxjgv
pbgxafaiocxpicmkpita`sipbpbak~~allkpigo/Sillikmx’axxkyxkppam~pa`pgfvi`ca
pba`amko`xgjbkziocpg aklsipbpbabixpgvihklhbkocaxiopbamakoiocgjpba
sgv`sbilakvpihqlkpiocpbapavm’xamavcaohakxk~vgmioaopeaysgv`"xaa@qvkop
6>>:)/
Sajkhakximilkv`ilammkiogqvajjgvpxpgqo`avxpko`khhgqopkfilipy/Pba
caoavklk~~vgkhbpkeaobavaixpgjghqxgopba~a icvaagjkhhgqopkfilipy‘pbkpix,ip
bixpgvihklvggpxko``azalg~maop‘sbilakoklytiocipxarixpaohakxkoiohvakxiocly
im~gvpkopjakpqvagjgqvhgopam~gvkvy~glipihklko`cgzavokohahqlpqvax/
X~ahijihklly,sahgoxi`avkhhgqopkfilipyiopbvaa`ixpiohpfqpvalkpa`hqlpqvkljgvmx4
kxksgv`sipb`ajiokflahbkvkhpavixpihx5kxkhgoha~pqklpvg~a5ko`kxkx~aahbkhp/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 9/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
3
Arkmioiocpba~a`icvaagjkhhgqopkfilipyioakhbgjpbaxahqlpqvkljgvmxogpgoly
cizaxqxioxicbpiopgpbafvgk `imaoxigoxko`hgopam~gvkvy~gsavgjpbapavm,fqp
~giopxkxsallpgpbafkvviavxsajkhaiokppam~piocpgqo`avxpko pbixim~gvpkop
eaysgv`ko`ipvglaiocgzavokoha/
Ko`PbaoPbavaskx“PbaSgv ”
Pbavakvapbvaag~pigoxg~aopgpbgxasbgsgql`koklytapba~a icvaagjkoy
~kvpihqlkvsgv /Jivxp,goahkojghqxgopba`ajioipigoxgjjava`iokqpbgvipkpiza
`ihpigokviaxgvhkvajqllyhgllahpa`jvgmgpbavxgqvhax/Xahgo`,sahkoar~lgvapba
apymglgcihklgvicioxgjpbasgv /Jioklly,sahkoxaaeioxicbppbvgqcbxpq`iaxgjk
pavm’xqxkca/
Pba`ajioipigo4Xaaeiock`ajioipigojgvpbix“ogpgvigqxlykmficqgqx”"Fvggex
;991)pavmhko~vgzazavyjvqxpvkpioc,ko`gjpaovaxqlpxiok`g~pigogjkzavxigo
pbkp`aama`faxpxqipa pgpbaokvvgsly`alioakpa`pg~ihkpbko`/Qojgvpqokpaly,
pbixpkhpihcaoavkpax~vgflamxgjhgoha~pqklgmixxigogvhgmmixxigo"hj/,Eagbkoa
6>>8)/
Safaciogqvxakvhbjgvmakoiociopbaqxqkl~lkha,sipbpbakqpbgvipkpiza
Grjgv`Aoclixb@ihpigokvy 4
Pba{qklipygjfaiockhhgqopkfla5likfilipypgkhhgqopjgvko`koxsavjgvgoa#x
hgo`qhp,~avjgvmkohagj`qpiax,aph/"iomg`avoqxagjpaosipbvackv`pg
~kvlikmaopkvy,hgv~gvkpa,gvjiokohikllikfilipypgpba~qflih,xbkvabgl`avx,
aph/)5vax~goxifilipy/Jva{/sipbmg`ijyiocsgv /
Pbvaaogpkflajakpqvaxgjpbkp`ajioipigoiohlq`a4";)ipixkokfxpvkhpogqo
`axicokpiockimmkpavikl“{qklipy”gvhbkvkhpavixpih5"6)ipx`ajioipigoixxpvgoclypia`
pgxyogoymx,i/a/,likfilipy,koxsavkfilipy,vax~goxifilipy5ko "8)ipixgjpao
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 10/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
2
khhgm~koia fyk“mg ijyiocsgv`”pbkpajjahpizalyvao`avxipmakoiocjqlgolyio
hgoparp/Pbaxa~giopx,io`izi`qkllyko`pgcapbav,mkeaxpbapkxegj`ajioioc
khhgqopkfilipy~vgflamkpihkpfaxp/
Pbajivxp~vgflamixpbkpq~gohlgxaxhvqpioygoavaklitaxpbkppba`ajioipigo
facxpba{qaxpigogjsbkphgoxpipqpax“khhgqopkflaoaxx”vkpbavpbko~vgzi iockoy
xqfxpkopizafkxixjgvk`ajioipigo/Sbkpixpbaokpqvagjpbkp{qklipygv
hbkvkhpavixpih7Pbaxpkpagj“faiockhhgqopkfla”sgql`xqjjihaijpbavaskxxgmasky
gjhbkvkhpavitiocpbkphgo`ipigo,fqpsbkpsakva~vgzi`a`ixhivhqlkv41
khhgqopkfilipyixsbkpipmakoxpgfakhhgqopkfla,ko`faiockhhgqopkflaixsbkpip
makoxpg~gxxaxxkhhgqopkfilipy/Pbixixk`ajioipigocgiocogsbava,va{qivioc
valikohagopbaxahgo`jakpqvagjpba`ajioipigo4xyogoymx/
Kxsaxaafalgssbaok``vaxxiockhhgqopkfilipykxkhgoha~p,pbaGA@
`ajioipigo’xvalikohagoxyogoymxmkeaxkcgg``aklgjxaoxaiopbakppam~ppg
`azalg~kmakoiocjqlqo`avxpko`iocgjpbapavm5fqpipixksakefkxixjgvk
`ajioipigopbkppvqly`ijjavaopikpaxpbasgv`sipbiopbaliocqixpihhgmmqoipy/Pbixix
mgxpazi`aopsbaosapvypg`aklsipbpbasgv`iopvkoxlkpigogvgqpgjx~ahijih
hgoparpx/
KlpbgqcbAoclixbx~akeavxpkeapbapavmkhhgqopkfilipyjgvcvkopa`,jas
lkocqkcaxbkzakoa{qizklaopsgv`/Qopilvahaoply,vgmkohalkocqkcaxpvkoxlkpa
khhgqopkfilipykx“vax~goxifilipy”,ko`lkocqkcaxlieaDk~koaxako`mg`avoBafvas
valia`gokseskv`pvkoxlipavkpigoxsbaooahaxxkvy"mgvagopbkp~giopfalgs)/Pg
favax~goxifla‐pg~gxxaxxpba{qklipygjvax~goxifilipy‐ gaxogphgmmqoihkpa
sbkpipmakoxpgfakhhgqopkfla,koxsavkfla,likfla,gflica`,aph/Xyogoymxkva
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 11/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
9
gjpaomgvaximilkvpbkopbaykvaa{qizklaop,ko`pbkpck~"pba ixximilkvipy)hko
~vgzapvgqflaxgma,ogpgolykhvgxxlkocqkcafgqo`kviaxfqpklxgkhvgxxhgoparpx/
Sbihbfviocxqxpgpbapbiv`jakpqvagjpbaGA@`ajioipigo‐ipxogpkpigopbkp
pbasgv`khhgqopkfilipyixjva{qaoplykhhgm~koia`fykmg`ijyiocpavm,a/c/,
~glipihklkhhgqopkfilipy,jiokohiklkhhgqopkfilipy,hgv~gvkpakhhgqopkfilipy,lackl
khhgqopkfilipy,aph/Bavapbasgv`’x`ajioipigoixxqvvao`ava`pgipxhgoparpqklita`
makoiocx,ko`pbqxpgpbazkvigqxxyogoymxkxxghikpa`sipbpbgxaxappiocx/Iolks,
khhgqopkfilipyixlikfilipy5io~glipihxipixkoxsavkfilipyko`vax~goxizaoaxx5io
jiokohako`hgv~gvkpacgzavokoha,ipixji`qhikvyvalkpigoxbi~xko`ji`alipy5aph/
Sbkpazavxqfxpkopizamakoiocmicbpfaiopbasgv`khhgqopkfilipyixgzavsbalma
ko`xqfgv`iokpa`pgpba amko`xgjpbax~ahijihpkxeaozivgomaop/
Iopavaxpiocly,pbapbvaa~vgflamxsipbpba`ajioipigobicblicbpa`bavahko
bal~ar~lkiopbavalkpizaakxasipbsbihbkhhgqopkfilipyskxalazkpa`pghqlpqvkl
eaysgv`xpkpqx/Pbalkhegjkoyiobavaop`ajiokflahbkvkhpavixpihpbkphkokhpkxko
kohbgvjgvpbaogpigogjkhhgqopkfilipyvao`avxipzqloavkflapgkxxqmiock
fvgk`aoa makoiocpia`pgaipbavpbamg`ijyiochgoparpxko gvpbaxyogoymxsipb
sbihbpbasgv`ixgjpaokxxghikpa`/
Gviciox4Mqhbioxicbphkogjpaofackioa`fypqvoiocpgksgv ’xapymglgcy
‐kxakvhbjgvmakoiocioipxgvicioxko`vggpx/Fqpbavapggsahgojvgopko
kmficqipyjgxpava`fypbazavyxpvqhpqva"gvmgv~bglgcy)gjpbasgv`/Kmgoc
xpq`aopxgjapymglgcy,ksgv`xqhbkxkhhgqopkfilipyixvackv`a`kxkhgm~larogqo
gjpsg~kvpx"a/c/,iopbaGA@,pbak`dahpizakhhgqopkfla%pbaxqjjir-filipy )ko`pba
apymglgcihklpkxexaamxxim~laaogqcb‐jio ko`hgmfioapbamakoiocjqlvggpxgj
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 12/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;>
akhbsgv`/Pbaoarpxpa~,bgsazav,~vgzaxxgmasbkpmgvahbkllaocioc,jgvpba
sgv`’xvggpxpao`pgdqxpijykmqhbokvvgsavxaoxagjsbkpkhhgqopkfilipymakox
pbkohgmmgohgopam~gvkvyqxkcaim~liax/
Jgvpbak`dahpizakhhgqopkfla,pbavggpxkva`aa~"Gl`Jvaohb)ko``aa~av
"Lkpio)/Pba aa~vggpxkvaiopbaGl Jvaohb,ko kvahgmmgolyhipa`kxxpill
kogpbavhgm~larpavm,pbazavfkhgopav "k-%hgopav ),pghgqop,pgvahego/Pbix,io
pqvo,ixlioea`pgpbaLkpiozavfhgm~qpkva,pghgm~qpagvhklhqlkpa/Pkeaolipavklly,
kokhhgqopkfla~avxgoix“kfla”"bkxpbahk~khipy)pggjjavkokhhgqopgvvahegoioc
gjxgmaxgvp,ko khhgqopkfilipyhkofaxaaoiopbkpvkpbavlimipa`licbp4kx
hbkvkhpavitiocxgmagoabkziocpba{qklipygjfaiockflapg~vgzi`akvax~goxapg
pbgxahklliocjgvkhgqopgvhklhqlkpigo/:
Iofkxihpavmx,kokhhgqopkfla~avxgoixko“khhgqopkop”iopbaxpvihpaxp,mgxp
lipavklko lacklixpihxaoxagjpbkpsgv 3/Pbalkfalskxgohajgvmkllyk~~lia pg
pbgxaio`izi`qklxhklla`pgpaxpijyfajgvapbahgqvpfahkqxapbaymkiopkioa`pba
fggexjgvkoaopav~vixapbkpskx~kvpgjxgmalackl ix~qpa/Ijpbavaixkxaoxagj
{qklipiaxqxqkllykppvifqpa`pgpbak~~allkpigo“khhgqopkfla~avxgo”"xgmagoasipb
khhgqopkfilipy)‐vax~goxifilipy,gflickpigo,likfilipy,aph/‐pbaykvaogpiobavaopio
pbamakoiocx`aviza`jvgmapymglgcihklvggpx/Ijpbavaixkoyxaoxagj axicokpioc
xgmagoasipbvax~goxifilipy,ipixpbaim~lihkpigopbkppbakhhgqopkopsilljqljillpba
vglagjgjjaviocpbaar~ahpa`“hgqop”go amko`/
Iopbixxaamioclypviziklaravhixaioapymglgcy,koim~gvpkop~giopxpko`xgqp4
ogpbiociopbasgv`’xgvicioxxq~~gvpxipxhgopam~gvkvyqxakxkbicbavxpko`kv`fy
sbihbpgg~avkpagvdq`caio`izi`qklx,cvgq~x,gvokpigox/Pbahbkvkhpavixpihgj
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 13/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;;
khhgqopkfilipyskxokvvgslykxxghikpa`sipbpbakhpigoxgjkoio`izi`qklaockca kx
kfggeeaa~aviopbaokxhaop~vgjaxxigoklgjkhhgqopioc/
Gohakckiosahkopqvopgpbaixxqagjpvkoxlkpigoa{qizklaohypgbicblicbp
pba~giop/IoJvaohb‐pbazavylkocqkcajvgmsbihbkhhgqopkflako khhgqopkfilipy
kva`aviza`‐pbaxpko`kv`pvkoxlkpigoxjgvfgpb~vgzi`axgmasbkp`ijjavaop
makoiocx/Iosi`alyqxa `ihpigokviax,pbapvkoxlkpigojgvkhhgqopkflaixvax~goxkfla,
kogpkflafgsiopba`ivahpigogjmakoioc`aviza`jvgmxpko`kv`Aoclixbqxkca"xaa
falgs)/Lggeq~pbaJvaohbpvkoxlkpigojgv“khhgqopkfilipy”,bgsazav,ko pbavaixk
mgvalipavklkxxghikpigosipbpbaGl`Jvaohbvggpxiopba~bvkxalkva``ipigo`a
hgm~pax‐pbavao`aviocgjkhhgqopx/Goahkobkv`lyflkmapbgxahgm~iliocpba
pvkoxlkpigoxiopbaxa`ihpigokviaxjgvpbahgojqxigopbixhkqxax/Pbaivhbgihaxvajlahp
kpavmpbkpixoaipbavjivmly`ajioa fyogvkohbgva`ioipapymglgcihklvggpx/
Qxkca4Ijoaipbav`ihpigokvy`ajioipigoxogvapymglgcihklkoklyxixhkobal~qx
sipbpbamakoiocgjkhhgqopkfilipy,saoaa`pgpqvopg~vkcmkpihx‐pba
arkmiokpigogjmakoioc aviza`jvgmqxkca/Pbavakvaxazavklkoklypihk~~vgkhbax
pgpbaxpq`ygjsgv`qxkca,2fqpqo`avpbabak`iocgj~vkcmkpihxkvapbgxapbkp
am~bkxitapbavglagjhgoparpioxbk~iocmakoioc/
PbaCggclaxhkooa`fggex`kpk"xaaJicqva;)hkofaqxa`pgio`ihkpa
makoiocx`aviza`jvgmsgv`qxkcakpkmgvahgoparpqklita`lazal/Kxogpa`iopba
hgmmaopxkfgqppba`ajioipigogjkhhgqopkfilipy,pbapavmgjpao`avizaxipxmakoioc
jvgmpbak`dahpizaxipixkxxghikpa`sipb/^qvxqiocpbkplgcih,Jicqva6pvkhexpba
~bvkxax“hgv~gvkpakhhgqopkfilipy”,“khhgqopkflacgzavomaop”,9ko`“jiokohikl
khhgqopkfilipy”xioha;29>qxiocpbaAoclixblkocqkcahgv~qx`azalg~a`fypba
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 14/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;6
Cggcla~vgdahppakm/Pba~lgppa`~kppavoxjgllgspbamgvacaoavklpvao`xioJicqva;
valkpa`pgpbaqo{qklijia pavmipxalj,fqppbajio`iocxklxgvajlahpxgmaiopavaxpioc
zkvikpigoxvalkpa`pgpba{qaxpigogjmakoioc/Ipixogpxqv~vixiocpgxaajiokohikl
khhgqopkfilipyamavcajivxpko`mgxp~vgmioaoplygzavpbixarpao`a ~avig`,ko`sa
hkox~ahqlkpapbkppbavaixxgmavalkpigoxbi~fapsaaoipxjivxpghhqvvaoha`qviock
pimahbkvkhpavita`fygqvjivxpmkdgvokpigosi`aahgogmihko`fkoeiochvixax/Pba
~bvkxa“hgv~gvkpakhhgqopkfilipy”xaamxpgbkzaipxioipiklfggxp`qviocpba;91>x
sbaopba~gsavgjhgv~gvkpigoxfahkmakmkdgvixxqa,ko`cizaoxbijpioc~glipihkl
ziasx`qviocpba;9:>x,ipixogpxqv~vixiocpbkpcgzavomaopkhhgqopkfilipyxpkvpxpg
`vksiohvakxiocvajavaoha`qviocpba;93>x/Sbilapbajio iocxxbgql`fapvakpa`
sipbhkqpigocizaopbaokpqvagjpba`kpkxap,akhbgjpbaxapvao`lioaxio`ihkpaxdqxp
bgsxaoxipizapbasgv`khhgqopkfilipybkxfaaopg~glipihklko`ahgogmih
hgo`ipigox/;>
UJicqva6BAVA]
Gjhgqvxa,ogpiociohvakxa`jva{qaohygjqxkcaixogppbaxkmakxkoklytioc
pbamakoiocxgjsgv`x`aviza`jvgmxqhbqxkca/Pbamgxphgmmgo~vkcmkpihx
k~~vgkhbaxbkzafaaokxxghikpa`sipbpbahgoha~pgj“lkocqkcackmax,”k
~avx~ahpiza`azalg~a fypba~bilgxg~bavLq`sicSippcaoxpaioiobixlkpavsgvex
";9:2)pbkpbkxbk`k~vgjgqo`ajjahpgopbaxpq`ygjsbkpsgv`x“mako”/Kxsipb
gpbav~vkcmkpihxk~~vgkhbax;;,pbaam~bkxixixgopbavglapbkphgoparp~lkyxio
`apavmioiocpbamakoiocgjsgv`xko`pbaivvalkpa``ixhgqvxax/Mgvagzav,ba~gxipx
pbkppbavakvamkoyxqhbckmaxcgiocgokpkoy~giopiopimako`x~kha‐akhb
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 15/45
+++++
+
+
A k h b gj p b a p a v m x " h k x a x a o x i p i z a ) q x a ` i o p b i x
j i c qv a k v a 6 - cv k m qoi p x " f i cv k m x ) / Q x k c a
j v a { q a o h y " z a v p i h k l k ri x ) i x h gm ~ q p a ` f y ` i zi ` i o c
p b a o qm f a v gj i o x p k o h a x gj p b a o- cv k m qoi p i o k
ci z a o y a k v f y p b a p g p k l o qm f a v gj s gv ` x i o p b a
h gv ~ q x " o qm f a v gj
x h k oo a ` s gv e x ) i o p b k p y a k v /
P b a h gv ~ q x q x a ` b a v a k v a x h k oo a ` s gv e x
~ q f l i x b a ` i oA o cl i
x b p b a Q X k o ` QEj gv p b a y a k v x
+
J i c qv a6 4 Q x k c aj v a { q ao h y gj m a ` i k p a ` j gv m x gj “ k h h g qo p k f i l i p y ,”
; 2 > > ?6 > > >
+
J i c qv a6 4 O? c
v km+ ko kl y x i x gj
m a ` i k p a ` j gv m x gj “ k h h g qo p k f i l i p y” ,
; 2 9 > ?6 > > >
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 16/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;8
hvakpiock ixpiohpsgvl`sipbiosbihbsag~avkpa,ko`iosbihbsa`azalg~ ixpiohp
qo`avxpko iocxgjsbkpsgv xko`hgoha~pxmako/
Pbagopglgcihklim~lihkpigoxgjpbix~avx~ahpizakvaxicoijihkop,jgvioajjahp
Sippcaoxpaiokxxavpxpbkppbavaixogam~ivihkl“vaklipy”pgqxakxkvajavaoha~giop,
goly`ijjavaopvaklipiaxvajlahpa`io‐ko`xbk~a`fy‐pbalkocqkcackmaxakhb
`azalg~xiox~ahijihxghikliopavkhpigox/;6Ipjgllgsxpbkppbazavyi`akpbkppba
makoiocgjxgmasgv`gvhgoha~phkofahk~pqva`iok`ajioipigoixkfxqv`,ko`pba
~vgflamxgjkmficqipyko`ogo-a{qizklkohaiopvkoxlkpigokvaakxilyk~~vahikpa`/
Pbqx,pba“hbkmalago-liea”"Xiohlkiv;991)ko`“azavar~ko`ioc”"Mqlcko6>>>)
okpqvagjkhhgqopkfilipyixdqxppbkp‐~kvpgjpbaokpqvagjksgv`qxa iozkvigqx
lkocqkcackmax/
Pbavakvamkoyeio`xgjlkocqkcackmaxpbkpqxa"ko`xbk~apbamakoiocgj)
khhgqopkfilipy ,ko`pbgxavalazkoppgpba~vaxaopajjgvpghhqvsipbiopbahgoparpgj
`ixhgqvxaxko okvvkpizaxkfgqpcgzavokoha/Sbilasaqxapbapavmxiogqv`kily
lizax,pbahgoha~pxgj“`ixhgqvxa”ko`“okvvkpiza”kvakoklypihpgglxiopbabko`xgj
liocqixpxko`~bilgxg~bavx;8iopavaxpa iobqmkohgmmqoihkpigo/Jgvpbam,
`ixhgqvxaxkvapbamgxpcaoavkljgvmgjlkocqkca-fkxa zavfklhgmmqoihkpigo
~vg`qha`kxkmakoxpgcaoavkpakvax~goxajvgmpbavahaizioc~g~qlkpigo/;0
Okvvkpizaxkvak~kvpihqlkvjgvmgj ixhgqvxafkxa gopbaqxagj“xpgviax”;1"fvgk`ly
`ajioa`),ko`sipbiopbahgoparpgjxqhbxpgviaxgjcgzavokoha,sahkoxaabgspba
makoiocgjkhhgqopkfilipybkxfaaoklpava`jvgmpbahgvaGA@`ajioipigo"“{qklipygj
faiockhhgqopkfla”)‐k ajioipigopbkpkllfqp`ixk~~akvxkxpbasgv`ix
pvkoxjgvma`pbvgqcbkzkviapygjokvvkpizamakox/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 17/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;0
UJicqva8BAVA]
Ioxgma`ixhgqvxax,pbasgv`ixioxpipqpigoklita` fyfaiockxxghikpiocsipb
hgoxpipqpigoklko`alahpgvklkvvkocamaopx axicoa`pghgoxpvkioko hgopvglpba
~gsavgj~glipihklkqpbgvipiaxfyvao`aviocpbammgvakoxsavkflako`vax~goxiza/
Mgvapbkodqxpmahbkoixmx"xaafalgs),pbaxakvvkocamaopx~vgzi`akjvkmasgve
sipbiosbihbkhhgqopkfilipyixpgfakhbiaza`,azaoijkoygvkllpba~lkyavxiozglza`
lkhe"gvoazavkhbiaza)pba“{qklipygjfaiockhhgqopkfla”/Pbixixpba`ixhgqvxagj
`amghvkpihkhhgqopkfilipy,ko pbalkocqkcackmapbkppkeax~lkhasipbioipvkixax
khhgqopkfilipypgpbalazalgjpbalacipimitiocxpko`kv`"i/a/,ao`x)jgvmg`avo
cgzavokoha/Ipixxq~~gvpa fykokvvkpizaiosbihbpbavaixkoim~lia`~vgmixapbkp
xqhbkvvkocamaopxsillvaxqlpiocvakpav`acvaaxgj`amghvkpihcgzavokoha/
Iogpbav`ixhgqvxax,khhgqopkfilipybkxfaaomahbkoita` ‐pbkpix,
vahgojicqva kxkmakoxjgvjkhilipkpiochgopvgl/Sbilapbaioxpipqpigokljgvmix
`axicoa`pgkhbiazakoxsavkfilipy,vax~goxizaoaxx,aph/,bavagvckoitkpigokl
kvvkocamaopx"a/c/,biavkvhbiax,fqvakqhvkhiax,kq`ipx,va~gvpioc)kva axicoa`pg
xglihipgfa`iaohako`cvakpavajjihiaohy/Iopbixlkocqkcackma,pgfakhhgqopkflaix
pgfaxqfdahppgkhpizahgopvgl,fqpjvgmpba~avx~ahpizagjpbgxahbkvca`sipb
mkokciocgvckoitkpigox,ipjgxpavxk~gxipizaokvvkpizagjhgopvgl/
Iokpbiv`py~agj`ixhgqvxa,khhgqopkfilipybkxfaao dqvi`ihita` ko`
iohgv~gvkpa iopgpbalkocqkcackmaxgjfgpbhvimioklko`hizillacklxyxpamxkx
sallkxpbajgvmklita`xkohpigoioc~vghaxxsipbiogvckoitkpigox/Bavapba
qo`avlyiocokvvkpizaixpbkpkhhgqopkfilipy~vg`qhaxdqxpihajgvpbgxazihpimita`fy
mklihigqxgv`kmkciocfabkzigv/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 18/45
@ixhgqvxajghqxa`
go
Okvvkpiza Khhgqopkfilipykx Arkm~lax
Ioxpipqpigoklitkpigo ^vgmixagj
`amghvkhy
Kvvkocamaopx
"qxqklly
hgoxpipqpigokl)
iopao`a`pghgoxpvkio~gsav
ko`jgxpav
koxsavkfilipyko`
vax~goxizaoaxxgj
gjjihiklx
Hgoxpipqpigomkeioc"Bkfavmkx
6>>;k,6>>;f),Xalj-VaxpvkioiocXpkpa
"Xhba`lav,@ikmgo`*^lkppoav;999)5
Khhgqopkfilipyjgvqmx"Fgzaox6>>3),Bgvitgopklkhhgqopkfilipy"G’@gooall
;992)
Mahbkoitkpigo ^vgmixagj
hgopvgl
Makoxqxa`pg
gzavxaako``ivahp
g~avkpigoxko`
fabkzigvsipbio
gvckoita`hgoparp/
K`mioixpvkpizahgopvgl"Ekqjmko
;9:3)5Fqvakqhvkpitkpigo"Aixaoxpk`p
;9195Mkvegjj;9315Fkvgo,Fqvpgo*
Bkooko;9995Bqmmal6>>2)Vqlax
"Ek~lgs;996),Va~gvpioc"Hgooglly*
Byo`mko6>>05Hgg~av*Gsao
6>>3),Kq`ipioc"Kxbpgo;99>5^gsav
;9995Xhbskvpt*Xqliptakoq-Eaoko6>>6))
Dqvi`ihitkpigo ^vgmixagj
dqxpiha
Jgvmklitkpigo
"qxqkllylacklio
okpqva)gjvqlaxko`
~vgha`qvax
`axicoa`pg`akl
sipbqo`axivkfla
ko`qokhha~pkfla
fabkzigv/
Jgvmklipy"Xpiohbhgmfa6>>;),
Vqlamkeioc"Eavsio6>>8),
Hvimioklitkpigo"@aeeav6>;;),
Aojgvhamaop"Mklgoa6>;>)5Pvqpb*
Vahgohilikpigo"Kllko*Kllko6>>>5
Xkveio6>>>)
Iohaopizitkpigo ^vgmixagj
~avjgvmkoha
Xpko`kv`xko`
mapvihx`axicoa`pg
iojlqaohafabkzigv/
P[M"Tfkvkhei;992)5^avjgvmkoha
makxqvamaop"Bkpvy6>>:)5
^avjgvmkohamkokcamaop"@qfoihe6>>1),Xpko`kv`x"Ekxxal6>>2),
Jicqva84@ixhgqvxaxko`OkvvkpizaxgjKhhgqopkfilipy
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 19/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;1
Ioxpillkogpbav`ixhgqvxa,khhgqopkfilipybkxfaaoiohaopizita` ‐pqvoa`iopg
kxapgjfaohbmkvexgvmapvihxkckioxpsbihb~avjgvmkohaixmakxqva /Bava,pba
makoiocgjkhhgqopkfilipyfahgmaxpbafkxixjgvkxxaxxmaopiokoajjgvppg~vgmgpa
"gvjgvha)k dqxpmaopxio~avjgvmkohaiogv`avpg`amgoxpvkpapbkpgoabkxfahgma
mgvakhhgqopkfla/Pbaokvvkpizaixfkxa`gokziasgjbqmkookpqvapbkpkxxqmax
io`izi`qklxsillvax~go`iok~gxipizaskypgiojgvmkpigokfgqppbaiv~avjgvmkoha/
Sbkpixiopavaxpiockfgqppbaxa`ixhgqvxaxixpbkppbaykvajva{qaoplykfgqp
mgvapbko`axhvi~pigoxgjcgzavokoha"~qflih,~vizkpako`pbiv`xahpgv)5pbaykva
klxgcaoavkpiocokvvkpizaxgjvajgvm/Sbapbavjghqxa`gokppkioiocbicbavao`x
"`amghvkhyko`dqxpiha)gvfkxihmakox"jkhilipkpiochgopvglgvaobkoha
~avjgvmkoha),`ixhqvxizajgvmxgjkhhgqopkfilipyixhlgxalypia`pgajjgvpxpgfvioc
kfgqphbkocako`vajlahpziasxpbkpkhhgqopkfilipy"bgsazavipix`ajioa`)ixaipbav
lkheiocgvioxqjjihiaopqo`avhqvvaophivhqmxpkohax/Iopbixvackv`,sipbiopbaxa
lkocqkcackmax,khhgqopkfilipyhkvviaxpbafqv`aogjfaiocaipbavpbahkqxagvhqva
jgvsbkpkilxpbacgzavokohaxyxpam/
Sagfzigqxlylakvokcgg``aklmgvakfgqppbamakoiocgjkhhgqopkfilipyfy
valyiocgo~vkcmkpihx,mgxpxicoijihkoplypbkppbasgv``vksxipxmakoiocjqloaxx
ogpjvgmipx`ajioa`hgopaop,fqpjvgmipxhgoparpko`jqohpigoklipy"gv
`yxjqohpigoklipy)sipbiopbavaklmgjmg`avojgvmxgjcgzavokoha/Kckio,sahko
xaapbkppbixpao`aohypgfahgoparpqklita`ko`jippa`iopg`ijjavaop`ixhqvxiza
jgvmkpxbal~xar~lkiosbykhhgqopkfilipyskxxqipkflagjhqlpqvkleaysgv`xpkpqx/
Pba{qaxpigokxpgsbyipkppkioa`pbkpxpkpqxsbaoip i`vamkioxqokoxsava /
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 20/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;:
Hgoha~pqklitiocKhhgqopkfilipy
Kxkhqlpqvkleaysgv`,khhgqopkfilipyixmgvapbkomavalyk`ixpiohpko
“`ajiokfla”pavm/Ipixklxgkppbahaopavgjk~gsavjqlhgoha~pqklhgoxpvqhppbkp~lkyx
kmkdgvvglaiobgssa~avhaizapbag~avkpigoxgjcgzavomaop/Iopbixxahpigosa
arkmioapbaokpqvagjpbkphgoha~pqklhgoxpvqhppgxaaijiphkok``pggqv
qo`avxpko iocgjpbahqlpqvkl~vimkhygjkhhgqopkfilipykmgocpbkphlkxxgjpavmx
pbkpxbk~agqvqo`avxpko iocgj~glipihxko`cgzavokoha/
Safaciofyvapqvoiocpgkhaopvkljkhpkfgqppba`ajioipigogjpbasgv`
khhgqopkfilipy,i/a/ipixkpavmhbkvkhpavita`fykoarha~pigokllybicb`acvaagj
xyogoymipy/Sbapbavsajghqxgopbapy~ihkl`ajioipigoxgvpbaajjgvpxpgpvkoxlkpa
pbixzavyAoclixb'koclihkosgv`,sajio jva{qaopvalikohagoxazavklhgmmgo
xyogoymx‐sgv xpbkpqxavxgvpvkoxlkpgvxkhha~pkxxqjjihiaoplyximilkvio
“makoioc”pgxqfxpipqpajgvkhhgqopkfilipy/Sbkppbixxyogoymihhgo`ipigoim~liaxix
pbkpgqvajjgvpxpg`azalg~kmakoiocjqlqo`avxpko`iocgjkhhgqopkfilipykxk
hqlpqvkleaysgv mkyva{qivapbkpsakfko`gogqvjghqxgopbasgv`~avxako
vaxapipgopbamgvacaoavklhgoha~p gjkhhgqopkfilipypbkpbkxamavca`iovahaop
yakvx/
Ioipx~qvaxpjgvm,kxyogoymgjgoasgv`ixkogpbavpavmpbkphkofaqxa`
iopavhbkocakflysipbpbajivxpvackv`laxxgjhgoparp/Pbaykva"kckio,iopbaxpvihpaxp
xaoxa)i`aopihkliomakoioc/K“fkhbalgv”ixko“qomkvvia`mko”,k“mgpbav”ixk
“jamkla~kvaop”,“hkv”ixko“kqpgmgfila”,aph/Fqpixkhhgqopkfilipyi`aopihkl iopbix
skypgvax~goxifilipy,likfilipy,koxsavkfilipy,aph/7Ogp{qipa,ax~ahikllyiolicbpgjpba
hgoparpqklzkvikpigoioqxkcagjakhbgjpbgxapavmx/Iogqvhgm~larko`
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 21/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;3
iopavhgooahpa`sgvl`,Ihkofavax~goxiflajgvxgmaazaop"a/c/,pbamkvvikcagjpsg
~ag~lasbgmapgokfqxfahkqxaI`i ogppkeapbaxakpfapsaaopbam)sipbgqp
faiocbal pgkhhgqopjgvip"ogvsgql`Ifalikflajgvsbkpazavmixaviaxpbkpmicbp
fajkllpbahgq~laiopbayakvxpbkpjgllgs)/Oazavpbalaxx,pbavaixxgma`acvaagj
gzavlk~iomakoiockmgocpbaxapavmxkxpbaykva~qppgqxaioazavy`kylkocqkca
ckmax/Pbaymkyogpfaxyogoymxiopba“~qvixp”xaoxa,fqppbayxbkvaklazalgv
`acvaagjxyogoymipy/;:
Jgvgqv~qv~gxax,sbkpixim~lia`fypbabicb`acvaaxyogoymipy
hbkvkhpavitiockhhgqopkfilipyko`valkpa`pavmxixpbai`akgjkcaoavkl
hgoha~pqklitkpigopbkppiaxpbampgcapbav`ax~ipapbaivkqpgogmgqxarixpaohaio
zkvigqxlkocqkcackmaxko``ixhgqvxax/Ioliaqgjjio`iocpba~a icvaagj
khhgqopkfilipyiopbasgv`,~avbk~xsasilljio`ipiopbahgoha~pqklhkpacgvygj
pavmxgjsbihbipix~kvp/
Ioipxmgxpfkxihqxa,khgoha~pix`ajioa kxxgmafkxihqoipgjpbgqcbp
vajlahpiocko“i`ak”/Iolarihgcvk~by,ip“hgoxpipqpaxkokfxpvkhpigojvgmkoqmfavgj
i`akxkfgqpio`izi`qklvajavaopx”pbkpxbkvaxgmapbiociohgmmgo"Xzaoxéo6>>9,~/
6;8)/Fqppgcvkx~pbaokpqvako`im~gvpkohagjpbahgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipy,sa
oaa`pgcgkfipjqvpbavko``apavmioabgspbakxxghikpa`pavmxvalkpapgakhbgpbav
iokhqlpqvklxaoxa/
Xgmakoklyxpxlggejgvxgmahgvapavmkvgqo`sbihbhgoha~pqklitkpigox
`azalg~kxoapsgvex"Mgppavapkl/6>>6)gviobiavkvhbihklvalkpigoxbi~x"Silla
6>>6)/Gpbavxxaahgoha~pxamavciocjvgmkzkviapygjmapk~bgvihklpvg~ax"xaa
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 22/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;2
Mgvcko;92>,;928),ko`jgvgqv~qv~gxaxpbixk~~vgkhb~vgzaxmgxpqxajqlix
~vgzi`iocioxicbppgbgspbasgv`khhgqopkfilipyvalkpaxpgipxxyogoymihvalkpigox/
Jgvarkm~la,pbaxyogoymihhbkvkhpavgjkhhgqopkfilipyixjva{qaoplypvakpa`
mapgoymihklly,kxijipixgoakmgocxazavkliopavhbkocakflapavmxpbkpvgqcbly
hgozayxpbaxkmamakoioc/Sabakvpbixhgoha~pqkl`azihakpsgvesbaova~gvpavx
qxapbasgv`khhgqopkfilipyioliaqgjmgvagfpqxa"kplakxpjgvpbalky~avxgo)pavmx
xqhbkxlackllikfilipygvpghgmmqoihkpapbamakoiocgjji`qhikvyvalkpigoxbi~x/Pbix
k~~vgkhbixklxgvajlahpa ioajjgvpxpgjio`ko`k~~lyk~~vg~vikpapvkoxlkpigoxgjpba
pavmkhhgqopkfilipy,ko`bkx~vgzaoiohvakxiocly~vgflamkpihkxpba`amko`jgv
mgva~vahixalkocqkcaixva{qiva`fyko`iohvakxioclyclgfklita`ahgogmy/Pbqx,kx
Fvktilfahkmamgvakhpizaiopbaclgfklahgogmyko`g~avkpa`mgvako`mgva
sipbiopbalackljvkmasgvexaxpkflixba`kx~kvpgjpbaSPG,ipxpvk`agjjihiklxko
lacklar~avpxfahkmajvqxpvkpa`fypbalkhegjkoa{qizklaoppavmio^gvpqcqaxapbkp
hk~pqva`pbaKoclg-Kmavihkohgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipy/Pbavaxqlpskxkxqhhaxxjql
ajjgvppgcappbapavmkhhgqopkfilipygjjihikllykhha~pa`kx~kvpgjpbajgvmkl
larihgo/;3
Kogpbavvalazkopmapk~bgvihklpvg~a"xyoah`ghba)sgql`iozglzaziasioc
khhgqopkfilipykx~kvpgjkcaoavkljkmilygjpavmxpbkpxaamxghlgxalyvalkpa`pbkp
koygoahgql xpko`iokxkmakoiocjqlva~vaxaopkpigogjpbamgvacaoavklhgoha~p
pbkppiaxpbampgcapbav/Pbqx,xiohakhhgqopkfilipyix~g~qlkvly~avhaiza`pgfako
iobavaophbkvkhpavixpihgj`amghvkhy,ipixogpxqv~vixiocpgbakvxgmagoaxpkpapbkp
pbavaixklkhegjkhhgqopkfilipyiopba~glihymkeioc~vghaxxsbaopbaykhpqklly
iopao`pgbicblicbppbalkhegj`amghvkpihg~aooaxxgv~qflihio~qp/Pbixmix`ivahpa`
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 23/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
;9
qxagjpbapavmkhhgqopkfilipyhkovaxqlpiohgojqxigoko`mixqo`avxpko`iocxio
k``ipigopgiok~~vg~vikpavax~goxaxpgpbahgm~lkiopx/Mgvaxicoijihkoply,pba
xyoah`ghbak~~vgkhbfacxpba{qaxpigogjsbkpmgvacaoavklhgoha~p
khhgqopkfilipyko`ipxvalkpa`pavmxkva~kvpgj/
Iok``ipigo,pbavavamkioxpba{qaxpigogjsby,kmgocpbixcvgq~gjvalkpa`
xyogoymx,khhgqopkfilipyhqvvaoplybgl`xxqhbk~vgmioaop~lkha/Havpkioly,pbava
kvagpbavmamfavxgjpbixxyogoymihhlkxxgjsgv`x"a/c/,vax~goxifilipy4xaaFgzaox
;992)pbkpkvaogpkx~kvghbikliopbaivgvicioko`kvajkvmgvapvkoxlkpkflakhvgxx
mkoylkocqkcax/Iok` ipigo,pbavakvasgv`xiopbkpxyogoymihhlkxxjkvmgva
makoiocjqlsipbiox~ahijih`gmkioxkx“pavmxgjkvp”"a/c/,likfilipyiolks)/
Oazavpbalaxx,kplakxpsipbiopba~kxpbkljhaopqvy,ipixkhhgqopkfilipypbkpbkx
amavca`kxpbaxkliaophgoha~p‘pbaeaysgv`--kmgocpbixhgllahpigogjhgoha~px/
Goa~gxxiflavakxgosbypbahgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipybkxfahgmaxg~vgmioaop
kmgocipxxyogoymihhlkxxmkyfaipx`ixhqvxizakxxghikpigosipbsbkpkva
~avhaiza pgfabicbav~qflihzklqax/Kxpbahgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipyfahkma
okvvkpizalyiopavpsioa sipbpba~vgmixaxgj`amghvkhy,dqxpiha,ajjihiaohy"hgopvgl)
ko`cvakpavk`mioixpvkpiza~avjgvmkoha"xaaJicqva8),ipxxpkpqxkxk~qflihzivpqa
klxgvgxa,pgpba~gioppbkpipbkxhgmapg`gmiokpaipxxyogoymihhlkxxgjvalkpa`
hgoha~px/;2Sbkpazavpbavalkpigoxbi~kmgocpbahgoha~pxiopba~kxp,pbahaopvklipy
gjkhhgqopkfilipyixogssallaxpkflixba`/
KxMkveFgzaox"6>;>)bkxogpa`,khhgqopkfilipyixmgvapbkokzivpqa5ipix
klxgkmahbkoixmko`ioxpvqmaopgjk`mioixpvkpizako`~glipihkl~gsavpbkphkofa
k~~lia`pgfviockfgqp~glihyhgm~likohakxsallkxpgjgvhahbkocaxiocgzavokoha/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 24/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
6>
Oazavpbalaxx,pbaxapsgkx~ahpxgjkhhgqopkfilipykvavalkpa`/Kxkbicblyvackv`a
"zivpqgqx)~qflihzklqa,khhgqopkfilipybkxamavca`kxkmgvkljgvhasbihbhkofa‐
ko`gjpaoix‐qxa`pg~vgmgpako`jgxpavpbak~~lihkpigogjhgm~likoha
mahbkoixmxko`ioxpvqmaopxgjhbkoca/Pbixmgvkljgvhahkofafvgqcbppgfakv
pbvgqcbfgpbarpavokl~vaxxqvaxpvaxxiocpba axivkfilipygjkhhgqopkflacgzavokoha
"sbkpVgfavpOgtihe ;9hklla`“mgvkl~qll”)ko`mkokcaviklajjgvpxpgioxpillko`
iopavoklitakoapbihklhgmmipmaoppgkhhgqopkfilipysipbio~qflihkcaohiax"i/a/,
“mgvkl~qxb”)/
Iopbixvackv ,ipsgql`fakmixpkeapgxaapbavalkpigoxbi~xkmgocpbaxa
valkpa`hgoha~pxkxmavalybiavkvhbihklgvxim~lixpihkllymapk~bgvihkl/Kmgva
k~~vg~vikpamakoxjgvjvkmiocpbahqvvaop"eaysgv -fkxa`)valkpigoxbi~ixpbvgqcb
pbaxqfxpkopizamapk~bgvgjcaoqxko`x~ahiax,sipbkhhgqopkfilipyxipqkpa`kxpba
hgoha~paohgm~kxxioccaoqxpgsbihbakhbx~ahiax"xqf-hgoha~p)valkpax/Xqhbk
xhbamava{qivaxpbkpsaaxpkflixbvqlaxpbkp`ajioapbavalkpigoxbi~fapsaao
khhgqopkfilipyko`ipxxqf-hgoha~pxkxsallkxkvpihqlkpahbkvkhpavixpihxpbkp
`ixpiocqixbkmgocpba`ijjavaopx~ahiax/Kxillqxpvkpa`ioJicqva0,pba`ijjavaop
x~ahiaxhkofaxgvpa`ogpgolyfypbavalazkopxappiocxsipbiosbihbpbaykvaliealy
pgk~~akv,fqpklxgfysbapbavpbaykvavalkpa`pgkhhgqopkfilipypbvgqcbpba
~vghaxxgjmgvkl~qxbgvmgvkl~qll/
UJicqva0BAVA]
Pbixhgoha~pqkljvkmiocgjkhhgqopkfilipy~vgzi axkfvgk`avxaoxagj
makoiocpbkopbaakvliavjghqxgo`ajioipigoxko`apymglgcy/Ipklxgk``vaxxaxpba
aobkoha`"hqlpqvkl)vakhbgjpbai`akgjkhhgqopkfilipyiovahaop`ahk`ax,ko ipx
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 25/45
+++++
+
J i c qv a0 4 X ~ a h i a x gj p b a C
ao q x “ K h h g qo p k f i l i p y”
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 26/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
6;
alazkpa`xpkpqxsipbioipxjkmilygjxyogoymx/Fyziasiocipsipbiopbixcaoqx-
x~ahiaxjvkmasgve,sakvak`g~piocpbaziaspbkppg`kypbahgoha~pgj
khhgqopkfilipyaohgm~kxxax"vkpbavpbkova~lkhax)mkoygjxyogoymihpavmxko`
i`akxsipbsbihbipbkxfaaokxxghikpa`/Iohgmmgoqxkcapg`ky,pgfakhhgqopkfla
ixpgfavax~goxifla,ko`kmaokfla,ko`koxsavkfla,ko`gflica`,aph/Kxim~gvpkop,
pbixjvkmiocklxg~vgzi`axkhgoparpqklfkxixjgvqo`avxpko`iocpbazkvikpigoxio
sbkppbahgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipymakoxiozkvigqxxappiocx/
Bavakckiopba{qaxpigokvixaxkxpgbgskhhgqopkfilipykppkioa`ipx~vimkvy
xpkpqxkmgocpbahlkxxgjxyogoymihpavmx/Goaar~lkokpigojghqxaxgopbajkhppbkp
kmgocpbaklpavokpizapavmx,khhgqopkfilipyskxmgxphgm~kpiflasipbpbapbamaxgj
pbapsgmkdgvk`mioixpvkpizavajgvmmgzamaopxpbkpamavca``qviocpba;9:>x
ko`pbvgqcbpba;92>x/Jivxppbavasavapbgxasbgxkskhhgqopkfilipykxkmakoxpg
mkeacgzavomaopmgva`amghvkpihkllyvax~goxizako xghikllyvax~goxifla"a/c/,pba
“Oas^qflihK`mioixpvkpigo”5xaaMkvioi;93;ko`Jva`avihexgo;93:),ko`pbixskx
jgllgsa`fykmgzamaoppbkpvackv`a khhgqopkfilipykxkzabihlajgvim~vgziocpba
~avjgvmkohako`ajjihiaohygjcgzavomaopkcaohiaxko`~vgcvkmx"a/c/,pba“Oas
^qflihMkokcamaop”5xaaBgg`;99;,;9915klxgBgg`ko`^apavx6>>0)/@vizaopg
pbaiopallahpqklhaopavgjpbgxapsg~gsavjqlvajgvmmgzamaopx,ipixlipplasgo`av
pbkpkhhgqopkfilipyfahkma~avhaiza`kxpba~va`gmiokopmakoxjgvim~vgzioc
cgzavomaop/
Pbavakvagpbavar~lkokpigoxkxsall/Goa~gxxiflakoxsavixpbkpiopbix
“mkokcaviklkca”6>pbavaixiohvakxiockskvaoaxxko`k~~vahikpigogjpbaqpilipygj
khhgqop-ciziocmahbkoixmxko`makoxsipbiolkvcagvckoitkpigox/Kogpbav
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 27/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
66
vax~goxaixpgkppvifqpapbavixagjkhhgqopkfilipy‐~kvpihqlkvlyioipx`amghvkpih
jgvm‐pg`azalg~maopklbixpgvihklpvao`xpbkpbkzala pgipxioazipkflaamavcaoha
kxkxpko`kv`gjbqmko~vgcvaxx/6;Xpillkogpbavar~lkokpigovaliax~giopxpg
clgfklitkpigoko`kcvgsiocfaliajio"ko`gjpaojavzaophgmmipmaoppg)pba~vimkhy
gjkhhgqopkfilipyiopbamgzamaoppgskv`“cgg`cgzavokoha”io`azalg~iockxsall
kx`azalg~a`okpigox/66'68
Jioklly,sbilapbacaoqx-x~ahiaxmapk~bgv~vgzi`axkhgbavaopskypgzias
pbavalkpigoxbi~gjkhhgqopkfilipypgipxvalkpa`xqf-hgoha~px,iplakzaxlipplavggmjgv
hgoxi`aviochbkllaocaxpgipx~vimkhypbkpkvaliealyamavcajvgmpimapgpima/Pba
vaklipy,bgsazav,ixpbkphqlpqvkleaysgv`xkvaxqfdahppghbkllaocako hbkoca/
^lkooioc,jgvarkm~la,sgql ~vgfkflybk`mk`aSillikmx’hqlpqvkleaysgv`lixpio
pba;96>xko`;98>x,fqpkjpavxazavkl`ahk`axgj~vgmioaohaiplgxpipxzklqakxk
haopvklpbamaiopba~glipihklko`cgzavokohahqlpqvax"xaa@kblko`Lio`flgm
;9185klxgXhgpp;992)/Khhgqopkfilipyhkoklxglgxaip~vizilaca`~gxipigo,~avbk~xpg
pbavaamavcaohagjxgmahlkxxiheaysgv`xxqhbkxajjihiaohygv"mgvaliealy)pba
i`akgjcgzavokohapbkpbkxckioa xicoijihkop~vgmioaohasipbpbakhk`amih
hgmmqoipyfqpbkxogpfahgma~kvpgjpbamgvacaoavklhqlpqva/Fqpkp~vaxaop
pbavaixlippla`gqfppbkppbahgoha~pqklita`ogpigogjkhhgqopkfilipybkxk
jgvmi`kflabgl`gopbaskysapbioekfgqpcgzavomaopko`~glipihx/
X~akeiocgjKhhgqopkfilipy
Sbila~a`icvaakoklyxixim~liaxpbaar~lgviocgjbixpgvihklvggpx,gqv
arkmiokpigogjpbasgv`ko`hgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipybkxpbqxjkvlkhea`mqhb
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 28/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
68
bixpgvihkl`a~pb/Pbixixiolkvca~kvp`qapgpbajkhp"vajlahpa`io~kvpioJicqva;)
pbkpkhhgqopkfilipyixkvalkpizaly“mg`avo”hgoha~psipbsvippaohipkpigoxfkvalyio
azi`aohafajgvapbaakvly;9 pbhaopqvy/Sbihbfviocxqxpgkoiopavaxpioc
gfxavzkpigokfgqppbaoqmfavgjxhbglkvlysgvexpbkp`ixhqxxpbavglagj
khhgqopkfilipyiopbacgzavokohagjmkoykohiaopvacimaxkxsallkxiogpbavogo-
mg`avohgoparpx/
Xqv~vixioclyalkfgvkpajgvmxgjsbkpsapg`kyvackv`kxkhhgqopkfilipy-
fkxa`cgzavokohabkzafaaoogpa`pgarixpiokohiaophizilitkpigoxkx`ijjavaopko`
`ix~avxa kxim~aviklHbiok,TgvgkxpvikoIvko,Maxg~gpkmik,kohiaopAcy~p,pba
Cvaaehipyxpkpax,ko`kohiaopIxvkal/60Kmgockopbvg~glgcixpx,arkm~laxkfgqo`gj
jial`xpq`iaxbicblicbpiocpbasgvegjkhhgqopkfilipy-lieavalkpigoxbi~xioxghikl
cvgq~xjvgmjkmiliaxko`“~vimipiza”pvifaxpgmg`avogvckoitkpigox‐mgxp
sipbgqpkoyjgvmklxpvqhpqvax`azgpa`pgsbkpixpvk`ipigokllykxxqma`pgfa
“cgzavomaop”ioxpipqpigox/61Kx`ixhqxxa`falgs,ipixklxg~gxxiflapgpvkhapba
lioakcagjpg`ky’xkhhgqopkfilipyvacimaxpgpba~avig jvgmpba;>pbpgpba;6pb
haopqviaxsbaopbamg`avoogpigogjcgzavomaopskxioipxokxhaopxpkcax/
Pg`aklsipbpbixg~ao{qaxpigokxpgpbabixpgvygjkhhgqopkflacgzavokoha,
saoaa`pgxbijpgqvkppaopigogohakckio,pbixpimajvgmpbahgoha~pgj
khhgqopkfilipypgkoazaofvgk`avogpigopbkppkeaxiopghgoxi`avkpigopbaim~khpgj
ipxkjjahpizaokpqvakxkx~aahbkhppbkppvkoxhao`xbixpgvihklfgqo`kviax/
Iopbaxpq`ygjliocqixpihx"ko pba~bilgxg~bygjlkocqkca),xgmasgv`xkva
mgvapbkomavaxymfglxgv&xicoijiavx&qxa kxkmakoiocjqlvajavaohapgxgma
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 29/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
60
gfdahpgvxqfdahp/Pbavakvasgv`x‐ko`hgoha~px‐pbkpjqohpigokxsbkpkva
pavma`x~aahbkhpx/
Kppimax,pbaqppavkohagjsgv xhkofavackv`a`kxmakoiocjqlkhpigoxqopg
pbamxalzax,kxsbaok~kvaopxhvakmx&@go#p+&pgkhbil`kfgqppg`gxgmapbioc
`kocavgqx/Pbaxaqppavkohax,gjhgqvxa,im~lykmgvaalkfgvkpaskvoioc"a/c/,&@go#p
~qpygqvjiocaviopbkpalahpvihklgqplap+”),ko`gjpaopbayva{qivakmgvajqlly
`azalg~a xaopaoha"a/c/,pbasgv`&~kxx&ixkx~aahbkhpiopbaxaopaoha&^kxxpba
xklp,~lakxa/”)/Iopbadkvcgogjx~aahbkhpliocqixpx,pbaqppavkohax&~kxx&ko`&`go#p&
kvalghqpigokvy/
Faygo`pbalghqpigokvyqppavkoha,xpq`aopxgjx~aahbkhpx`aklsipb
xpkpamaopxpbkpva~vaxaoppba~avjgvmkohagjkokhpigo,i/a/,~avjgvmkpizax/Pba
qppavkoha&I~vgmixapgq~bgl pbalks&gv&Ygqbkzamyjqllhgmmipmaop&iozglza
khpxpbkpva{qivaogpgolykoqppavkohafypbax~akeav,fqpkokxxqm~pigopbkppbgxa
bakviocpbaqppavkohafaliazaippgfahva`ifla/Xqhb~avjgvmkpizaxkvahklla
illghqpigokvy/
Jioklly,pbavakvahavpkiopy~axgjx~aahbkhpx‐pavma`~avlghqpigokvy‐pbkp
vajlahp"ko kvahgoxpvqhpa q~go)pba~vaarixpaohagjxgmaqo`avxpko`iocgopba
~kvpgjpbabakvavvackv`iocpbaliealyhgoxa{qaohaxgjpbaqppavkohax/Sbaok
cgzavomaopgjjihikliohbkvcagjpkrhgllahpigoxpkpax&Azavyhipitaobkxkogflickpigo
pg~kypkrax,&pbaxpkpamaop`gaxmgvapbko`ahlkvakvko`gmg~ioigo5ipklxg
pviccavxkxaoxagjsbkphgoxa{qaohaxmicbpjgllgsijipixogpkhpa`q~go/Iokxaoxa,
pba~avlghqpigokvyxpkpamaophgmfioaxfgpbklghqpigokvykhp"&Ygqkvagflica`+&)
sipbkoillghqpigokvykhp"&pg~kypkrax&),fqpkpklazalgjmqpqklqo`avxpko`ioc
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 30/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
61
sbihbva{qivaxogjqvpbavalkfgvkpigopgioipikpapba`axiva`hgoxa{qaohaa/c/,jakv
caoavkpa fypbaim~lia`pbvakpgjsbkpbk~~aoxpgpbgxasbg`gogpmaappbaiv
gflickpigopg~kypkrax/
Sbapbavpkeaokxk`ixpiohpsgv`gv"mgvak~~vg~vikpaly)kxkcaoavkl
hgoha~p,khhgqopkfilipykxk~~lia`iopbavaklmgjcgzavokohabkxkxxqma`kllpbvaa
jgvmxgjx~aahbkhpx/Sbilagolykseskv`lyva`qha`pg&cizakokhhgqopgjygqv
khpigox,&pbahgoha~pbkxmkoyim~avkpizajgvmxpbkpkvahlakvlylghqpigokvy4
&Va~gvp+&,&Koxsav+&,&Vax~go`+&/^qpiolaxx amko`iocxyopkr"&^lakxafa
~va~kva pgva~gvpgogqvjiokohax,&gv&Ygqmicbpfakxea`pgvax~go`pgxgma
{qaviax&),khhgqopkfilipyixoglaxxkx~aahbkhp"iopbaxaioxpkohax,mgva
illghqpigokvy)/
Iovahaopyakvx,pbaillghqpigokvy"~avjgvmkpiza)makoiocgjpbasgv
khhgqopkfilipybkxpkeaokoazaomgvaxicoijihkoppqvokxpbasgv`bkx`azalg~a`
iopgkhqlpqvkleaysgv`sipbhgoxi`avkflavbapgvihklko amgpigokl~gsav/6:Kx
MqvvkyA`almko~giopa gqpiokoqmfavgjhlkxxihxpq iax,63pbavakvasgv`x,
lkfalx,ko`xymfglxpbkp,sbaoqxa`iovalazkophgoparpx,hkocaoavkpa~glipihkl
vax~goxaxjvgmpbamgfilitkpigogjmkxxmgzamaopxpgpbakh{qiaxhaohagj~qflih
g~ioigo/Khhgqopkfilipy‐kxfgpbsgv`ko hgoha~p‐bkxamavca`,gzavpba~kxp
pbvaa`ahk`axkplakxp,kxk~vimaarkm~lagjA`almko’xpbaxix/Bkv`lyk`kycgaxfy
pbkpgoa`gaxogpbakvxgmavajavaohapgkhhgqopkfilipyiooasxva~gvpx,ko`ipix
pbavkvacgzavomaopva~gvp,pbioepkoekoklyxixgv~glipihklx~aahbpbkp`gaxogpqxa
khhgqopkfilipykxk~avjgvmkpizax~aahbkhp"hj/,^gllipp*Bq~a6>;;)/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 31/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
6:
Mgvagzav,`ax~ipaipxkoclihkovggpx,pbaillghqpigokvy~gsavgjpbaqppavkoha
khhgqopkfilipybkxfahgmakxicoijihkopjakpqvagjgqviohvakxioclyclgfklita`
~glipihkllkocqkca/Pbixbkxfaaojgxpava ,io~kvp,fypbaamavcaohagjAoclixbkxpba
~vimkvylkocqkcagjiopavokpigoklvalkpigox,ax~ahikllysipbvackv pgpbapahboihkl
ko`lacklixpih~vgzixigoxgjpvk`akcvaamaopx"a/c/,OKJPK,CKPP,SPG)ko`gpbav
clgfklioxpipqpigox"Hvyxpkl6>>8)/Pbacvgspbko`ar~koxigogjpba“cgg
cgzavokoha”mgzamaopbkxfaaoazaomgvaim~gvpkop,jgvipbkxalazkpa`
khhgqopkfilipypgpbalazalgjkxpko`kv`makxqvajgv`apavmioiocpbalacipimkhyko`
zikfilipygjokpigoklvacimax/Iokvaklxaoxa,khhgqopkfilipybkxfahgmakoihgoih
xymfgl‐pbacgl xpko`kv ‐gjokpigoklhva`ifilipyiopbaiopavokpigoklkvaok/62
Fqpsbkpgjpbaazi`aohapbkpogo-mg`avovacimaxsavahbkvkhpavita`fy
sallaxpkflixba`xyxpamxgjkhhgqopkfilipy7Kvapbgxagfxavzkpigoxmavalyk
vajlahpigogjxhbglkvlyfikxkxbixpgvikoxko`kopbvg~glgcixpxiok`zavpaoplyk~~lyk
mg`avohgoha~pqkllaoxpgpbabixpgvihklvahgv`7Gvbkxkhhgqopkfilipyioxgmagpbav
jgvmklskyxfaaokokx~ahpgjkohiaopko`ogo-mg`avocgzavokoha7Ijgqv~a`icvaa
koklyxixgjpbapavmkhhgqopkfilipyko`ipxhgoha~pqklhgoxpvqhpbkxogp~vgzao
qxajql,~avbk~xjghqxiocgopbax~aahbkhpxpbkpqo`avliakhhgqopkfilipy-fkxa`
fabkzigvhko/
Pgpaxppbixk~~vgkhb,Ijghqxgosbkphkofavackv`a`kxpbahivhqmxpkohax
pbkpmicbpbkzamkvea`pbaamavcaohagjpbamg`avohgoha~pgjkhhgqopkfilipy/Pba
~lkhaixAoclko`ko`pbayakvix;>21/SillikmpbaHgo{qavgvbkxdqxpvapqvoa`pg
Aoclko`kjpavkoarpao`a`kfxaoha"kppao`iocpgpba`amko`xgjbixOgvmko`y
`qhby)pgjio hgoxi`avkflapqvmgilpbkppbvakpaoa`pgqo`avmioabixbkv`-sgojgv
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 32/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
63
eiocxbi~/Iok``ipigopgvakxxavpiocbix~vimkhypbvgqcbjgvhagjkvmx,Sillikmpgge
kok``ipigoklxpa~pbkp,iobio`xicbp,xaamxhaopvklpgsbkpsgql`azaopqkllyfahgma
pbaakvlymg`avoxpkpa/
PgmkeaxaoxagjbgsSillikmk~~vgkhba pba~vgflamxbajkha`ioAoclko`,
goabkxpgqo`avxpko`pbaOgvmkok~~vgkhbpgcgzavokohapbkpbkx azalg~a
xioha"kxhgo{qaviocOgvxamao)pbaypggebgl`gjpbaogvpbsaxpavoJvaohb`qhby
iopba;>pbhaopqvy/Fqil iocgopbajaq`klhgoha~pgjjaklpy,69pbaOgvmkovqlavx`i`
mgvapbkova{qivaji`alipyjvgmpbazavypg~lazalxgjpbahgo{qava jaq`kl
biavkvhby5pbayva{qiva kll~vg~avpy-bgl`iocio izi`qklxpgpkeakogkpbgjjaklpy
`ivahplypgpbahgo{qavioc`qeavkpbavpbkoio`ivahplypbvgqcbpbaivlghkllgv`/Pbix
kvvkocamaopfgpbqo`avmioa`pbajaq`klxyxpam"sbihbpao`a`pg`ix~avxa
~gsav)sbilalakziocipiopkhppbvgqcbvalikohagoipxfkxihhgm~goaopgjkgkpb-
caoavkpa jaklpykpklllazalx/^qpxim~ly,sbkpazavgkpbxfgqo`zkxxklxko`gpbav
xqfgv`iokpaxpglghkllgv`xsavapvqm~a`fypbamgvacaoavklhgmmipmaopmk`apg
pba`qhby/Pbqx,sbilaSillikmko`bix~va`ahaxxgv`qeaxbk`jkha`hbkllaocaxjvgm
fgpbsipbioko`gqpxi`aOgvmko`y,pbayxqxpkioa`ko`xpvaocpbaoa`pbaivvqla
pbvgqcbkxpvgoclybal`gkpbjaklpypbkpva{qiva`,kmgocgpbavpbiocx,kvahegoiocgj
khhgqopx"hgm~pavao`q)fyxqfgv`iokpaxsbaopbaysavahklla q~gopg`gxg/
Pvkoxjavviocxqhbkxyxpampgkoklvak`ybicbly“qohaopvklita`”jaq`klixpih
xpvqhpqva8>ioAoclko skxogmakojakp,ko`,iokll~vgfkfilipy,ipsgql`ogpbkza
bk~~aoa sipbgqppbakllaohgm~kxxiochgo{qaxppbkpskxioipikpa`io;>::ko`
lkxpa`jgvmkoyyakvxpbavakjpav/Fqpkxazi`aoha`fypbahgo ipigoxpbkp~vazkila`
q~gobixvapqvoio;>21,hgo{qaxpfyjgvhagjkvmxskx~vgziocioxqjjihiaoppg
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 33/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
62
xqxpkiobixeiocxbi~jgvbimxaljko`bixxqhhaxxgvx/^vazigqxAoclixbeiocxsava
bkv`ly“vqlavx”iopbaxaoxagjpbkppavmpg`ky,ko koyajjgvpfypba~va-Ogvmko
Hvgsopgkxxavpkhlkimgj`ivahpkqpbgvipysgql`liealymaapsipbio`ijjavaoha
qolaxxipxavza`pba~qv~gxagjpbazkvigqxjaq`kllgv`xsbghgm~vixa`pbaAoclixb
“vaklm”/
Sillikm`i`,bgsazav,kppam~ppgqxapbaOgvmkok~~vgkhb‘ko`k~~vgkhb
sbihbskxaxxaopikllyfkxa gokgkpb-pkeiocx~aahbkhp/Kjpavvakxxavpiocbix
`gmiokohapbvgqcbhgavhizamakox,io@ahamfav;>21bagv`ava`pbaogssi`aly
khhlkima`haoxqxgjbixhgo{qava`vaklmpbkp"iohgm~gxipa)ixhklla`pba@gmax`ky
Fgge/Bkxpilygvckoita`ko`bkv`lyksgvpbymg`algjhgoxixpaohyiomapbg`gv
makxqva,pbagocgiochaoxqxskxxaoppgXklixfqvysbava,ioKqcqxp;>2:,Sillikm
hgozaoa`kckpbaviocgjbixzkxxklx,kxsallkx“lko`gsoiocmaogjkoykhhgqop,”jgv
pba~qv~gxagjfgpbkheogsla`ciocpbahlkimxbabk`gokllipamxaovglla`iopba
haoxqxko`xsakviockogkpbgjjaklpypgbimko`bixvgyklbgqxa/PbixGkpbgj
Xklixfqvy‐fkhea`fypbaim~lia`pbvakpgj~qppioc gsokoyhgqopavhlkimx‐
xpko`xkxpbajgqo`kpigojgvkhhgqopkfilipykxk~avlghqpigokvyx~aahbkhphaopvklpg
pba`azalg~maopgjmg`avocgzavokoha/
Gjhgqvxa,pbgxaiokppao`kohakpXklixfqvykvaliealypgbkzaqo`avxpgg`
{qipahlakvlypbaim~lihkpigoxgjSillikm’x`amko`jgvji alipy/Ip`i iozglzak
xpvgoclyim~lia`pbvakp/Kppbaxkmapima,pbax~aahbkhpgj`ahlkviockogkpbskx
ogmavajgvmklipy/Ipbk`makoiockpkxkhvkmaopkllazalpbkpix ijjihqlpjgvmgxpgj
qxpgimkcioa/8;Pbqx,ipogpgolyva~vaxaopa`kokheogsla`cmaopgjSillikm’x
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 34/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
69
`gmiokop~gxipigo,fqpklxg~vgzi`a`kjivmjgqo`kpigojgvpbaHvgsopgpkeakhpigo
kckioxpkoygoasbgfvgeasipbpbaxkhvkmaop/
Ipxbgql`faam~bkxita`pbkp,azaosipbpba~gsavgjgkpb-pkeiockp~lky,ip
pggemgvapbkokhaopqvyjgvpbaxq~~gvpiociojvkxpvqhpqvajgvkhhgqopkfilipy"a/c/,
zkvigqx“k`mioixpvkpiza”gjjihaxxqhbkxpkrhgllahpgvxko`va~qv~gxa`xbavijjx)pg
`azalg~ko`fahgmaioxpipqpigoklita /86OgvskxpbixOgvmkok~~vgkhbpg
cgzavokohalimipa`pgAoclko`,jgvsajio`azi`aohagjximilkvhgoxgli`kpigoxgj
eiocxbi~kqpbgvipy88ioJvkohako`XihilysbavaOgvmkoiojlqaohaskxxqfxpkopikl/
Sbilapbabixpgvihklokvvkpizaxmicbpzkvy,ipxaamxvakxgokflapgkxxqmapbkppba
hvakpigogjkhhgqopkfilipy-liea~avlghqpigox~lkya`kxicoijihkopvgla/80
Xpa~~iocfkhejvgmpbix~kvpihqlkvbixpgvihklhkxa,ipix~gxxiflapgxaapba
xkmaeio gj`yokmihkpsgveiogpbav~avig`x/Sbihblak`xpgkhgodahpqva4
sbavazavpbavabkxfaaohgo{qaxpko`'gvpbaoaa`pg"va)axpkflixbvqlako`kqpbgvipy
‐sbapbaviokohiaop,ma`iazklgvmg`avoxghiapiax‐pbavabkxfaaokoajjgvppg`g
xgfyioxpilliociopbahgllahpiza~xyhbagjpbgxaxqfdahppgvqlakxaoxagjgflickpigo,
vax~goxifilipy,hgmmipmaop,gvgpbavjgvmxgjkppkhbmaopkxxghikpa`sipbpbahgoha~p
gjkhhgqopkfilipy /Jgvmkoyxghiapiaxpbixbkxfaaokhhgm~lixba`pbvgqcbpbaqxagj
gkpbxko`valicigogvxkhva`mypbx/81Jgvgpbav,mgvaxahqlkvvacimax,ipixgjpaopia`
pgpbaaxpkflixbmaopgjlacipimkhy/8:MihbalJgqhkqlp’xhgoha~pgjcgzavomaopklipy,83
ioxgjkvkxipjghqxaxkppaopigogopbaiopavoklita`eogsla`cako ogvmxgj
io`izi`qklxko`aopiva~g~qlkpigox,ixklxgvalazkopiopbixvackv /Im~lia`ioakhbgj
pbaxa~avx~ahpizaxkva~avlghqpigokvyx~aahbkhpxpbkpjgxpavkokhhgqopkfilipy-liea
`ix~gxipigo/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 35/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
8>
Kxogpa`,pbavaixkcvgsiocfg`ygjsgvegopbavglapbkpkhhgqopkfilipy
~lkya`iokohiaophizilitkpigoxko ~va-mg`avoxghiapiax/Ipix~gxxiflapbkppbaxa
xpq`iaxvajlahplipplamgvapbkoim~gxipigogjko“khhgqopkfilipy”laoxgoeogsofqp
bicblyiopav~vapkflajkhpxkfgqpg~avkpigoxgjcgzavokohaiopbgxahgoparpx/Ijpbkpix
pbahkxa,sakvaio`kocavgj`ixpgvpiocpbgxabixpgvihkljkhpxpgjipgqvmg`avo
jvkmasgveko`~avx~ahpiza/ 82Pbavajgva,kppbixdqohpqva,pbahkxajgvpvkhiocpba
~a`icvaagjkhhgqopkfilipykxkx~aahbkhpixfaxpxaaokxkhgodahpqvava{qivioc
jqvpbavarkmiokpigo/
Ko`yap,kxaamioclyqovalkpa`lioagjvaxakvhbxaamxpgk``hva`ifilipypg
pbakhhgqopkfilipy-kx-hqlpqvkl-x~aahb-khppbaxix/Pbacvgsiociopavaxpiomgvkl
~xyhbglgcyko`hgm~lamaopkvysgvegjoaqvgxhiaopixpxbkxcaoavkpa`jio`iocxpbkp
mkyxq~~gvppbahgopaopigopbkpkhhgqopkfilipyixvggpa`ogpioioxpipqpigoxko`
mahbkoixmxgjhgm~likohasbihbmgxpxpq`aopxgjcgzavokohakvagfxaxxa`,fqp
vkpbaviogqvamgpigoklko`kjjahpizavax~goxaxpgsgv x,hgoha~px,ko kxxghikpa`
fabkzigvklvalkpigoxbi~x/
Pbixixogpkoasi`ak/Io;319,K`kmXmipbgfxavza`pbkpk“mgvklfaiocix
kokhhgqopkflafaioc”‐kxpkpamaoppbkphkofavackv`a`kxpbahgvai`akq~go
sbihbkxghiklko`apbihklpbagvygjkhhgqopkfilipyhkofahgoxpvqhpa`/89Iozkvigqx
jgvmx,ximilkvgfxavzkpigoxbkzafaaohaopvklpgpbasgvegj~bilgxg~bavxko`xghikl
xhiaopixpxjgvcaoavkpigox/0>Sbkppbixim~liaxixpbkpkhhgqopkfilipyixmgvapbkok
hgopam~gvkvyhqlpqvkl~baogmaogo,ko`mkyiojkhpfamgvajqo`kmaopklpgxghikl
ko`~glipihkllijapbkosaimkcioa/Ijpbixixpbahkxa,pbaokxpq`ygjkhhgqopkfilipykx
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 36/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
8;
khqlpqvkl~baogmaogova{qivaxqxpgvalygomgvapbkodqxppbaeio`gj~a`icvaa
koklyxixkxxghikpa`sipbpbaar~lgvkpigogjeaysgv`x/
Hgohlqxigo‘gvmkyfaogp…/
Iopbaxpq`ygjkhhgqopkfilipy--kxsallkxgjcgzavokohaiocaoavkl--ko
gfxaxxigosipbhgoha~pxko`makoiocixgjpao`ixmixxa`kxaxgpavihkpfaxp,ko`k
skxpajqlkhk`amiharavhixakpsgvxa/Khhgqopkfilipyixsbkpsapbioeko`xkyipix,
pbakvcqmaopcgax,xgsbyiodahpfgpbavxgmafqpiohgoxa{qaopiklpviziklipiaxiopg
pba~vghaxx7Ixo#pipaogqcbpgg~avkpasipbkmqpqklqo`avxpko`iockxpgsbkp
khhgqopkfilipymakoxiopba~vaxaophkxagvhivhqmxpkoha7
Pbavaixmqhbpgfaxki`jgvxqhbhvipihixmx,ax~ahikllyiolicbpgjpba
valkpizalymioimklim~khpxqhbxpq`iaxbkzabk`gopbaqxagjkhhgqopkfilipyiopba
~vkhpihagjcgzavokoha/Sbkpkhhgqopkfilipy“vakllymakox&mgvagjpaopbkoogpbkx
lipplapg`gsipbsbkpipmakoxpgfa~avhaiza`kxkhhgqopkflagvpgjaalkhhgqopkfla/0;
Pbajkhppbkpmgxpajjgvpxpg`aklsipbpbamakoiocgjkhhgqopkfilipypao pgfa
`vizaofykoar~lihiplyhvipihklkcao`k‐fgpb~glipihklly,kxiopbahkxagjg~~gxipigo
pg~vgcvkmxxqhbkxOgHbil`LajpFabio`5ko`~bilgxg~bihklly,kxiopbahkxagj~gxp-
mg`avohvipihklpbagviax‐bkza~qxba`xqhbxpq`iaxpgpba~avi~bavygjpba
khk`amih“mkioxpvakm,”pbqxlimipiocpbaivkhhaxxifilipypgsi`avkq iaohax/
Oazavpbalaxx,pbavaixxicoijihkopzklqapghgopioqa`ar~lgvkpigogjpbgxa
hgoha~pxko "io~kvpihqlkv)“hqlpqvkleaysgv`x”06pbkp~lkyxqhbkhaopvklvglaio
bgssapbioekfgqpko`hgo`qhpcgzavokohaiopba~qflih,~vizkpa,ko`ogo~vgjip
kvaokx/Khvipihkl~avx~ahpiza,ogmkppavbgskoogyiocgvxaamioclyaxgpavih,hko
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 37/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
86
vkixa{qaxpigoxko`ixxqaxkfgqpsi`alykhha~pa`~vkhpihaxgjcgzavokohapbkpmicbp
gpbavsixafagzavlggea`/08Pbayhkoklxgbicblicbpqo`avlyiockxxqm~pigoxpbkp
bal~ar~lkiosbykhhgqopkfilipy-fkxa`~vgcvkmxko ~glihiaxgjpaojkilpgkhbiaza
pbaiviopao`a`cgklx/00^avbk~xmgxpim~gvpkopiopbalgocvqo,pbayhkokhpkxko
iopallahpqklhbahegopbapao`aohypggzavhgmmippgkhhgqopkfilipy"sbapbaviopba
jgvmgjoas~qflihmkokcamaopgvcgg`cgzavokoha)kxPBAxglqpigopgkllgvmkoy
gjpba~vgflamxgjmg`avocgzavokoha/01
Pbkpxki`,pbaiopaopgjpbix~kvpihqlkvaravhixaskxjghqxa`laxxgohvipi{qa
pbkogokmgvacaoavklar~lgvkpigogjkhhgqopkfilipyxaaoiopbalicbpgjhqlpqvkl
xpq`iax/Pbaxkliaohagjkhhgqopkfilipyiopg`ky’xcgzavokohakvvkocamaopxko gqv
`kilylizaxixkoaxpkflixba`jkhp,ko sajqohpigosipbiopbixsgvl`gjkhhgqopkfilipy
kxijsahgm~vabao`ko`jqllycvkx~ipxg~avkpigoxko`im~lihkpigox/Fqpxhvkphbioc
pbaxqvjkhagjkhhgqopkflacgzavokohapbvgqcbkokoklyxixgjmakoiocko`"iopba
~vaxaopioxpkoha)~a`icvaaio`ihkpaxpbkpsaeogslipplakfgqpsbkpliaxfaoakpbpba
vbapgvih/Kpxgma~giop‐ko`pba~vaxaopixkxcgg`kxkoy‐saoaa`pg`azalg~k
mgvapbgvgqcbqo`avxpko`iocgjdqxpsbkpsakvaaockca`iosbaosaxqfmippg
pbaqvcapgvao`avkllpbiocx“khhgqopkfla/”Ioxbgvp,saoaa`pg`azalg~kqxajql
pbagvygjkhhgqopkflacgzavokohapbkpsilliojgvmgqvjqpqvahbgihax/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 38/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
88
Vajavaohax4
UGA@}/“Grjgv`Aoclixb@ihpigokvyGolioa/”bpp~4''sss/ga`/hgm'/Kvixpgpla/;99;/GoVbapgvih4KPbagvygjHizih@ixhgqvxa/Pvkoxlkpa`fyCagvcaK/
Eaooa`y/OasYgve4Grjgv`Qoizavxipy^vaxx/Kxplay,S/Cvkbkm,ko`Vkymgo`J/Tkmmqpg/;996/GvckoitkpigoXhiaoha,
Mkokcavx,ko`LkocqkcaCkmax/GvckoitkpigoXhiaoha8,og/04008-0:>/
Fkhbvkhb,^apav,ko`MgvpgoX/Fkvkpt/;9:6/PsgJkhaxgj^gsav/PbaKmavihko
^glipihklXhiaohaVazias 1:,og/04903-916/Fkvfavix,^apav/;992/PbaOas^qflihMkokcamaopko`kOasKhhgqopkfilipy/
^qflihK`mioixpvkpigo3:,og/8401;-03>/Fgqv`iaq,^iavva/;99;/Lkocqkcako`Xymfglih^gsav /Pvkoxlkpa`fyCiogVkymgo`/
A`ipa`fyDgboF/Pbgm~xgo,ko`MkppbasK`kmxgo/Hkmfvi`ca,MK4
Bkvzkv`Qoizavxipy^vaxx/Fgzaox,Mkve/;992/Pba[qaxpjgvVax~goxifilipy4Khhgqopkfilipyko`Hipitaoxbi~io
Hgm~larGvckoixkpigox/Hkmfvi`ca"QE)4Hkmfvi`caQoizavxipy^vaxx/Fgzaox,Mkve/6>;>/PsgHgoha~pxgjKhhgqopkfilipy4KhhgqopkfilipykxkZivpqako
kxkMahbkoixm/SaxpAqvg~ako^glipihxSaxpAqvg~ako^glipihx88,og/14
90:-9:3/Fgzaox,Mkve,PbgmkxXhbillamkox,ko`^kql‒PBkvp/6>>2/@gax^qflih
KhhgqopkfilipySgve7KoKxxaxxmaopPggl/ qflihK`mioixpvkpigo2:,og/;4
661-606/Fvghemiav,Daox,ko`VgmBkvva/;993/Okvvkpiza4^vgflamxko`^vgmixaxgjko
Klpavokpiza^kvk`icm/VaxakvhbgoLkocqkca*XghiklIopavkhpigoVaxakvhbgoLkocqkca*XghiklIopavkhpigoVaxakvhbgoLkocqkca*XghiklIopavkhpigo8>,
og/046:8-628/
Fvggex,Pbag/;991/ Khhgqopkfilipy4IpKll@a~ao`xgoSbkpYgqMako/Hlijpgo,OD4Keek`^vaxx/
Fqvcaxx,D/K/6>>2/SbaoIxHivhqlkvipyIo@ajioipigoxFaoico7 bilgxg~bihkl[qkvpavly
^bilgxg~bihkl[qkvpavly 12,og/68;46;0-688/Hkvmgok,Xklzk`gv,ko`Mkbmgq`Attkmal/6>>3/Khhgqopiocko khhgqopkfilipyio
kohiaophizilitkpigox4Maxg~gpkmikko kohiaopAcy~p/ Khhgqopioc,Kq`ipioc* KhhgqopkfilipyDgqvokl 6>,og/;4;33-6>9/
Hkvok~,Vq`glj/;911/Makoiocko`XyogoymyioOkpqvklLkocqkcax/ ^bilgxg~bihkl
Xpq`iax4KoIopavokpigoklDgqvokljgv^bilgxg~byiopbaKoklypihPvk`ipigo:,og/8488-03/
Hvyxpkl,@kzi`/6>>8/AoclixbkxkClgfklLkocqkca/Hkmfvi`ca,QE5OasYgve4
Hkmfvi`caQoizavxipy^vaxx/@kbl,VgfavpK/;91:/ K^vajkhapg@amghvkpihPbagvy /Hbihkcg,IL4Qoizavxipygj
Hbihkcg^vaxx/@kbl,VgfavpK/,ko`HbkvlaxA/Lio`flgm/;918/^glipihx,Ahgogmihx,ko`Saljkva4
^lkooiocko`^glipihg-ahgogmihXyxpamxVaxglza`IopgFkxihXghikl^vghaxxax/
OasYgve4Bkv~avPgvhbfggex/@kbl,VgfavpKlko/;992/Go@amghvkhy /OasBkzao4YklaQoizavxipy^vaxx/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 39/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
80
@kbl,VgfavpKlko/6>>;/Bgs@amghvkpihixpbaKmavihkoHgoxpipqpigo7 OasBkzao4
YklaQoizavxipy^vaxx/@iocsavpb,Elkqx,ko`^bili~~^kppfavc/6>>:/ClgfklCgzavokohakxk^avx~ahpiza
goSgvl`^glipihx/ClgfklCgzavokoha;6,og/64;21-6>8/@gqclkx,Mkvy/;996/Vixeko`Flkma4AxxkyxioHqlpqvklPbagvy /Lgo`go5OasYgve4
Vgqpla`ca/@vqheav,^apavJ/;910/Pba^vkhpihagjMkokcamaop /OasYgve4Bkv~avko`Vgs/@vqheav,^apavJ/;923/Mkokcamaop4Pba^vgflamxgjXqhhaxx/ Khk`amygj
MkokcamaopArahqpiza;,og/;4;8-6>/
@vqheav,^apavJav`ioko`/;999/MkokcamaopHbkllaocaxjgvpba6;xpHaopqvy /OasYgve4Bkv~avFqxioaxx/
@qfoihe,MalzioD/;992/HlkvijyiocKhhgqopkfilipy4KoApbihklPbagvyJvkmasgve/Io^QFLIHXAHPGVAPBIHX4JIO@IOCKO@IM^LAMAOPIOCZKLQAX ,a`x/Hbkvlax
Xkm~jgv`,Ogal^vaxpgo^vaxpgo,ko`H/K/Fgix,:2-2;/Laihbbkv`p,OXS,
Kqxpvklik4PbaJa`avkpigo^vaxx'Vgqpla`ca/@qfoihe,MalzioD/,ko`B/CagvcaJva`avihexgo/6>;;/Iopvg`qhpigo/Io Khhgqopkfla
Cgzavokoha4^vgflamxko`^vgmixax,a`x/MalzioD/@qfoihe,ko`B/CagvcaJva`avihexgo,ri-rrr/Kvmgoe,OY4M/A/Xbkv~a/
@qvkop,Klko/6>>:/Vkymgo`Sillikmx’xEaysgv`x4iozaxpickpiocmakoiocx‒gjjava`,
jalpjgv,paxpa ,hgojivma`,kxxavpa`,{qklijia`,hbkoca`’/Hvipihkl[qkvpavly 02,og/04;-6:/
Afvkbim,Kloggv/6>>8/Khhgqopkfilipyio vkhpiha4MahbkoixmxjgvOcgx/Sgvl`
@azalg~maop 8;,og/142;8-269/Afvkbim,Kloggv/6>>1/KhhgqopkfilipyMyg~ik4LgxiocXicbpgjGvckoitkpigokl
Lakvoioc/Ogo~vgjipko`ZglqopkvyXahpgv[qkvpavly 80,og/;41:-23/Afvkbim,Kloggv/6>>9/^lkhiocpbaOgvmkpizaLgcihxgjKhhgqopkfilipyio“Pbihe”
^avx~ahpiza/ KmavihkoFabkzigvklXhiaopixp 16,og/:4221-9>0/
A`almko,Mqvvky/;921/^glipihklLkocqkcako` glipihklVaklipy/^X ;2,og/;4;>-;9/A`almko,MqvvkyD/;933/ glipihklLkocqkca4Sgv`xPbkpXqhhaa`ko`^glihiaxPbkp
Jkil /OasYgve4Khk`amih^vaxx/
A`almko,MqvvkyD/;922/Hgoxpvqhpiocpba^glipihklX~ahpkhla/Hbihkcg4QoizavxipygjHbihkcg^vaxx/
Aixaoxpk`p,X/O/;92;/HqlpqvklPvk`ipigoxko`^glipihkl@yokmihx4PbaGvicioxko Mg`axgjI`aglgcihkl^glipihx/BgfbgqxaMamgviklLahpqva/PbaFvipixbDgqvokl
gjXghiglgcy 86,og/64;11-;2;/
Aixaoxpk`p,X/O/6>;;/PbaKriklhgoqo`vqm4fapsaaopvkoxhao`aopklzixigoxko`zihixxipq`axgjpbaivioxpipqpigoklitkpigox4hgoxpvqhpizako``axpvqhpiza
~gxxifilipiax/ KoëlixaXghikRLZI,og/;9946>;-6;3/
Alxpav,Dgo/;999/KhhgqopkfilipyioKpbaoiko^glipihx/Io@AMGHVKHY, KHHGQOPKFILIPY,KO@VA^VAXAOPKPIGO ,a`x/K`km^vtasgvxei,Xqxko
HkvglXpgeax,ko`Favokv`Mkoio,618-632/Hkmfvi`ca,Q/E/5OasYgve4Hkmfvi`caQoizavxipy^vaxx/
Azkox-^viphbkv`,A/A/;90>/PbaOqav,k`axhvi~pigogjpbamg`axgjlizalibgg`ko`
~glipihklioxpipqpigoxgjkOilgpih~ag~la/Grjgv`4KppbaHlkvao`go~vaxx/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 40/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
81
Attkmal,Mkbmgq`/;993/Khhgqopioc,Hgopvglko`Khhgqopkfilipy4^valimiokvy
Azi`aohaJvgmKohiaopAcy~p/Hvipihkl^avx~ahpizaxgoKhhgqopioc2,og/:41:8-:>;/
Jkvv,Dkmax/;926/BixpgvihklHgoha~pxio glipihklXhiaoha4PbaHkxagj“Vazglqpigo”/ KmavihkoDgqvoklgj^glipihklXhiaoha6:,og/04:22-3>2/
Jioealxpaio,LksvaohaX/;991/SbkpixClgfklCgzavokoha7ClgfklCgzavokoha;,og/848:3-836/
Jlio`avx,Mkppbas/6>>6/XbijpiocpbaFklkoha7^kvlikmaop,pbaArahqpizako pba
FvipixbHgoxpipqpigo/ glipihklXpq`iax1>,og/;468-06/
Jlio`avx,Mkppbas/6>>6/CgzavokohaioSbipabkll/^qflihK`mioixpvkpigo^qflih K`mioixpvkpigo2>,og/;41;/
Jlio`avx,Mkppbas/6>;;/@kviocpgfak@koial/ K`mioixpvkpigo*Xghiapy K`mioixpvkpigo*Xghiapy 08,og/14191-:;9/
Jva`avihexgo,B/Cagvca/;93:/PbaLioakcagjOas^qflihK`mioixpvkpigo/
K`mioixpvkpigo*Xghiapy 2,og/64;09-;30/Jvia`vihb,HkvlD/,ko`BgvsiptMgvpgo/;9:2/XgmaPbgqcbpxgoPbaValkpigogj
^glipihklPbagvypgKopbvg~glgcy/PbaKmavihko^glipihklXhiaohaVazias :6,og/6418:-101/
Jqeqykmk,Jvkohix/6>;;/Pbagvicioxgj~glipihklgv`av4jvgm~vabqmkopimaxpgpba
JvaohbVazglqpigo/OasYgve4Jkvvkv,Xpvkqxko`Civgqr/Ckvoav,FvykoK/6>;;/ K`ihpigokvygjmg`avolacklqxkca/OasYgve4Grjgv`
Qoizavxipy^vaxx/
Bgg`,Hbvixpg~bav/;99;/K^qflihMkokcamaopjgvKllXakxgox7 qflih K`mioixpvkpigo:9,og/;48-;9/
Bgg`,Hbvixpg~bav/;991/Pba“Oas^qflihMkokcamaop”iopba;92>x4ZkvikpigoxgokPbama/ Khhgqopioc,Gvckoitkpigoxko`Xghiapy 6>,og/6'8498-;>9/
Bgg`,Hbvixpg~bav,ko`Cqy^apavx/6>>0/PbaMi``laKciocgjOas^qflih
Mkokcamaop4IopgpbaKcagj^kvk`gr7 Dgqvoklgj^qflihK`mioixpvkpigoVaxakvhb*Pbagvy ;0,og/846:3-626/
Bqmmal,Vkl~b^/6>>2/PbaFqvakqhvkpihAr~aviaoha4Pba^gxpmg`avoHbkllaoca/
Kvmgoe,O/Y/4M/A/Xbkv~a/Dgboxgo,Xkmqal/;311/ K`ihpigokvygjpbaAoclixblkocqkca4iosbihbpbasgv`xkva
`a`qha`jvgmpbaivgvicioklx,ko`illqxpvkpa`iopbaiv`ijjavaopxicoijihkpigoxfyarkm~laxjvgmpbafaxpsvipavx4pgsbihbkva~vajira`,kbixpgvygjpba
lkocqkca,ko`koAoclixbcvkmmkv /Lgo`go4^viopa`fyS/Xpvkbko,jgvD/ko`
^/Eok~pgoUaph/]/Eagbkoa,VgfavpG/6>>8/PbaHgoha~pgjKhhgqopkfilipyioSgvl`^glipihxko`pba
QxagjJgvha/MihbickoDgqvoklgjIopavokpigoklLks 60,og/04;;6;-;;0;/
Lkxxsall,Bkvgl @/,ko`KfvkbkmEk~lko/;91>/ gsavko`Xghiapy4KJvkmasgvejgv^glipihklIo{qivy /OasBkzao,HP4YklaQoizavxipy^vaxx/
Mkhkcog,Jkfvitig,ko`@gqclkxSklpgo/6>>2/PbaKvcqmaopkpizaXpvqhpqvagj^avxqkxiza@ajioipigox/ApbihklPbagvyko`Mgvkl^vkhpiha;;,og/14161-109/
Mkvioi,Jvkoe,a`/;93;/Pgskv`kOas^qflihK`mioixpvkpigo4PbaMioogsfvgge
^avx~ahpiza/Xhvkopgo^K4Hbko`lav^qflixbioc/Mkqsx,MihbkalE/,ko`^billi~xOalxgo/;991/Qo`avxpko`iocLkocqkcaCkmax/
GvckoitkpigoXhiaoha:,og/84866-880/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 41/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
8:
Mihbal,Dako-Fk~pixpa,YqkoEqiXbao,Kzizk^vaxxavKi`ao,K vikoZavax,MkppbasE/
Cvky,CggclaFggexPakmPba,Dgxa~b^/ iheapp,@klaBgifavc,@koHlkohy,^apavOgvzic,DgoGvskop,Xpazao^ioeav,MkvpioK/Ogske,ko`Avat
LiafavmkoKi`ao/6>;;/[qkopipkpizaKoklyxixgjHqlpqvaQxiocMilligoxgj@icipita`Fggex/Xhiaoha88;,og/:>;04;3:-;26/
Mgvcko,Ckvapb/;92>/^kvk`icmx,Mapk~bgvx,ko ^qttlaXglziocioGvckoitkpigoPbagvy/ K`mioixpvkpizaXhiaoha[qkvpavly 61,og/04:>1-:66/
Mgvcko,Ckvapb/;928/MgvagoMapk~bgv4SbySaHkoogpHgopvglPvg~axio
K`mioixpvkpizaXhiaoha/ K`mioixpvkpizaXhiaoha[qkvpavly 62,og/04:>;-:>3/
Mgppav,K`ilxgoA/,Mgqvk`a,Klaxxko`vg /X/,Yioc-HbaocLki,ko`^kvpbk@kxcq~pk/6>>6/Pg~glgcygjpbahgoha~pqkloapsgvegjlkocqkca/ byxihklVaziasA
^byx/Vaz/A^VA :1,og/:4>:1;>6/Mqlcko,Vihbkv`/6>>>/‒Khhgqopkfilipy’4KoAzav-ar~ko`iocHgoha~p7 qflih
K`mioixpvkpigo32,og/84111-138/
G’Oaill,Gogvk/6>>6/ K[qaxpigogjPvqxp /Hkmfvi`ca4Hkmfvi`caQoizavxipy vaxx/ ^gllipp,Hbvixpg~bav,ko`^apavBq~a/6>;;/“PkleiocKfgqpCgzavomaop/”/^qflih
MkokcamaopVazias^qflihMkokcamaopVazias ;84:0;-12/Vaihbaofkhb,Bkox/;91;/PbaZavijikfilipyPbagvygjMakoioc/^vghaa`iocxgjpba
KmavihkoKhk`amygjKvpxko`Xhiaohax2>,og/;40:-:>/
VihŘqv,^kql/6>>>/PbaDqxp /Hbihkcg4QoizavxipygjHbihkcg^vaxx/Vgfavpx,DaooijavPglfavp/;926/ KhhgqopkfilipyioKpbaoikoCgzavomaop /Mk`ixgo,
SI4QoizavxipygjSixhgoxio^vaxx/
Vq`vqm,@kzi`/6>>1/JvgmOkvvkpizaVa~vaxaopkpigopgOkvvkpizaQxa4Pgskv`xpbaLimipxgj@ajioipigo/Okvvkpiza;8,og/64;91-6>0/
Xkhbx,Xpa~baoA/6>>:/JvgmXp/IzaxpgHyfavx~kha4PbaMg`avo@ixpgvpigogjpbaMa`iazkl‒LksMavhbkop/’/ KmavihkoQoizavxipyIopavokpigoklLksVazias 6;,
og/14:21-2;6/
Xkyskv`,Hbkvlax/;930/PbaVahaiza`@ixpiohpigofapsaao vkcmkpihx,Xamkopihxko`Xyopkr/Jgqo`kpigoxgjLkocqkca;;,og/;493-;>0/
Xhgpp,DkmaxH/;992/XaaiocLieakXpkpa4BgsHavpkioXhbamaxpgIm~vgzapbaBqmko
Hgo`ipigoBkzaJkila` /OasBkzao4YklaQoizavxipy^vaxx/Ximgo,BavfavpK/;911/KFabkzigvklMg`algjVkpigoklHbgiha/[qkvpavlyDgqvoklgj
Ahgogmihx:9,og/;499-;;2/Ximgo,BavfavpK/;932/Vkpigoklipykx^vghaxxko kx^vg`qhpgjPbgqcbp/Pba
KmavihkoAhgogmihVazias :2,og/64;-;:/
Xiohlkiv,Kmko`k/;991/PbaHbkmalagogjKhhgqopkfilipy4Jgvmxko`@ixhgqvxax/ Khhgqopioc,Gvckoitkpigoxko`Xghiapy 6>,og/6'846;9-683/
Xlkqcbpav,Kooa-Mkvia/6>>6/ClgfklCgzavomaopOapsgvex,ClgfklIojgvmkpigo
Kcaohiax,ko`@ixkccvackpa`@amghvkhy/MihbickoDgqvoklgjIopavokpigoklLks 60,og/04;>0;-;>31/
Xpklokeav,VgfavpH/;93>/^vkcmkpihx/Xyopbaxa66,og/;4636-629/Xpaio,DkoihaCvgxx/6>>6/PbaHqlpgjAjjihiaohy /Pgvgopg4BgqxagjKokoxi^vaxx/
Xpazaoxgo,HbkvlaxLaxlia/;983/PbaAmgpizaMakoiocgjApbihklPavmx/Mio`Oas
Xaviax0:,og/;2;4;0-8;/Xzaoxéo,Fg/6>>9/ Kbko`fggegjlarihgcvk~by4pbapbagvyko`~vkhpihagj`ihpigokvy-
mkeioc'FgXzaoxao/OasYgve4Hkmfvi`caQoizavxipy^vaxx/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 42/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
83
Pkmfikb,X/D/;9:2/PbaMkcihkl^gsavgjSgv`x/Mko8,og/64;31-6>2/
Pbgm~xgo,Mihbkal,Vihbkv`Allix,ko`KkvgoSil`kzxey/;99>/HqlpqvklPbagvy /Fgql`avHG4Saxpzias^vaxx/
zgo@gvoqm,@aiv`va@igoyxik/;993/PbaXpvkicbpko`pbaHvggea`4LacklKhhgqopkfilipyioKohiaopCvaaha/HglqmfikLksVazias 93,og/14;028-;1;2/
Saixx,PbgmkxC/6>>>/Cgzavokoha,Cgg`Cgzavokohako`ClgfklCgzavokoha4Hgoha~pqklko`KhpqklHbkllaocax/Pbiv`Sgvl`[qkvpavly 6;,og/14391-2;0/
Sil`kzxey,Kkvgo/;9::/Pba^glipihklAhgogmygjAjjihiaohy4Hgxp-faoajipKoklyxix,
XyxpamxKoklyxix,ko`^vgcvkmFq`capioc/ qflihK`mioixpvkpigoVazias 6:,
og/04696-8;>/Sil`kzxey,Kkvgo/;938/Ij^lkooiocixAzavypbioc,Mkyfaip’xOgpbioc/^glihy
Xhiaohax0,og/64;63-;18/Sillikmx,Vkymgo`/;93:/Eaysgv`x4kzghkfqlkvygjhqlpqvako`xghiapy /OasYgve4
Grjgv`Qoizavxipy^vaxx/
Sillikmx,Vkymgo`/;928/Eaysgv`x4kzghkfqlkvygjhqlpqvako`xghiapy /Lgo`go4Jgopkok^k~avfkhex/
Sippcaoxpaio,Lq`sic/;9:2/ bilgxg~bihklIozaxpickpigox/Pvkoxlkpa`fyC/A/M/Koxhgmfa/OasYgve4Mkhmillko/
Svgoc,@aooixB/;939/ gsav4IpxJgvmx,Fkxax,ko`Qxax/OasYgve4Bkv~avko`
Vgs/Tqfgjj,Xbgxbkok/;922/IopbaKcagjpbaXmkvpMkhbioa4PbaJqpqvagjSgveko`
^gsav /OasYgve4FkxihFggex/
;Gopba~gsavgjsgv`xio`ijjavaophgoparpx,xaaFgqv`iaq;99;,Pkmfikb;9:2,ko`
6Pbixkoklyxixixfkxa`gofggexxhkooa`fyCggclakx~kvpgjipxajjgvppg`icipitapbabgl`iocxgjmkdgvlifvkviax5xaabpp~4''sss/cggcla/hgm'cggclafggex'lifvkvy/bpml/Kmkdgvxqf-
~vgdahpkima`kpjkhilipkpiocpbaqxagj`kpkcaoavkpa`fypbaCggclaFggexLifvkvy^vgdahpixvajlahpa`
iopba“O-Cvkm”ioipikpizaar~lkioa`kpbpp~4''fggex/cggcla/hgm'ocvkmx'iojg/XaaMihbal,apkl/6>;;
jgvjqvpbavalkfgvkpigo/8Iok``ipigopgkhhgqopkfilipy,^gllippko`Bq~ajghqxgo“cgzavokoha”ko`“oapsgvex”/Sbkp
pbaxamkcihklsgv`xxbkvaixk“bicb`acvaagjkfxpvkhpigo,kxpvgocly~gxipizaogvmkpizahbkvca,k
xaamiockfilipypg`ixxglza~vazigqx`ilammkxko`fiokvyg~~gxipigoxko`kmgfilipykhvgxx
`gmkiox…/”
0KlxgxaaAfvkbim6>>1gopba“myg~ih”okpqvagjkhhgqopkfilipysipbgvckoitkpigox/
1XaaFqvcaxx6>>2jgvpbahkxajgvhivhqlkvipyio`ajioipigox/
:Pbavalkpigoxbi~gjkhhgqopkfilipypgipxGl`JvaohbvggpxixhlakvavioXkmqalDgboxgo’x
;311 K@ihpigokvygjpbaAoclixbLkocqkcaiosbihbba`ajioaxpbasgv`“hgm~pifla”kx“vak`ypgciza
kokhhgqop”/BaogpaxpbavajavaohaxgqvhakxXbkeax~akva"Dgboxgo;311)/3Gvicioklly"h/;1pbhaopqvy),ioFvipixblkspbapavm“khhgqopkop”`axicokpa`koy
“`ajao`kopiokokhpigogjkhhgqop”"i/a/,koygoahk~kflagjfaiocbal`pgkhhgqopiomkppavxgjpvqxp,
xqhbkxiojiokohiklvalkpigoxbi~x)/Fypba;:pbhaopqvyipskxqxa`pg`axicokpakoygoa"`ajao`kopgv
sipoaxx)sbgmk`akliziocpbvgqcbpbaeaa~iocgjkhhgqopx5azaopqkllypba`axicokpigoskxk~~lia`
pgpbgxalackllyhavpijia`kxkhhgqopkopx"iohgopvkxppgfggeeaa~avx)/XaaCkvoav6>;;,~/;;3/
2PbaCggclafggexhko~vgdahphipa`akvliav"xaaJicqva;)bkxg~aoa`q~pba~gxxifilipygjk
mgvaam~ivihkllyfkxa`arkmiokpigogjsgv`qxkcapbkpcgaxfaygo`mavajva{qaohyhgqopx5xaa
Mihbalapkl/6>;;/Kppbixdqohpqva,bgsazav,pbahk~khipypgjio`hva`iflako`valikflakxxghikpigox
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 43/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
82
kmgocsgv`xko`i`akxixlimipa`,ko`pbaxicoijihkohagjpbakoklyxixxbgql`fak~~vgkhba`sipb
hkqpigo/
9Pba~bvkxaaopava`iopgpbaziasavskxcgzavomaopkhhgqopkfilipy,fqppbkpskx
iopacvkpa`fypba~vgcvkmsipbpbamgvahgmmgolyqxa`“khhgqopkflacgzavomaop”/
;>Jgvxpillkogpbavio`ihkpigogjqxkca~kppavox,saxgqcbppgjio`gqpijpbasgv`khhgqopkfilipy‐ogpiokoypvkoxlkpa`jgvmgvpvkoxlipavkpa`‐k~~akva`iojgvaicolkocqkcafggex
pbkpkva~kvpgjpbaCggclaFggex`kpkfkxa/Kckio,sipbkll`qahgoxi`avkpigojgvpbalimipkpigoxgj
pbixmakxqva,ipskxhlakvpbkppbasgv`bk`hvgxxa`lkocqkcafkvviavxko`fahgma~kvpgjpba
`ixhgqvxaiokplakxppbvaaAqvg~akolkocqkcax4Jvaohb,Cavmkoko`X~koixb/Hlakvly`qviocpba~gxp-
Sgvl`SkvPsg~avig`,fqpax~ahikllyxiohapbaakvly;93>x,pbasgv`ipxaljbkxfahgmaclgfklita`‐
pbavaxqlp,~avbk~x,gjKoclg-Kmavihko`gmiokohagjpbalacklkx~ahpxgjclgfklitkpigokxsallkxipx
iojlqaohaiogpbavkx~ahpx"hqlpqvkl,xghiklko`~glipihkl)gjpbahgoxpkoplyar~ko`iociopavokpigokl
kvaok/
;;Gopba~vkcmkpihxk~~vgkhb,xaaXpklokeav;93>/Sbilapbapavm“xamkopihx”ix
qo`avxpgg`si`aly,pbapavm~vkcmkpihxixogpko`xqjjavxjvgmhgojqxigosipb~vkcmkpixm/Pba
pavmxkva~kvpgjkjgqo`kpigoklpvihbgpgmyjivxpkvpihqlkpa`fyHbkvlax^aivhako`alkfgvkpa`gofy
~bilgxg~bavHbkvlaxMgvvix5Xkyskv`,;930/
;6Sbilapbai`akgjlkocqkcackmaxbkxfaaok~~lia`fvgk`lykppbalazalgj`ixhi~lioaxko`jial`xhbkvkhpavita`fy~kvk`icmx"Kxplayko`Tkmmqpg;996),Sippcaoxpaiolimipa`bixarkm~laxpg
zavy`apkila`ioxpkohaxgjxghikliopavkhpigoxko`azaopx"Mkqsxko`Oalxgo;991)/
;8Jgvkcaoavklgzavziasgjpbalgcihko`xpvqhpqvagj`ixhgqvxako`okvvkpizakoklyxax,xaa
Fvghemiavko`Bkvva,;993/
;0Jgvarkm~la,khlkxxih`ixpiohpigoio`ixhgqvxaxpq`iaxixfapsaaopba`iklahpihklko`
vbapgvihkljgvmx/@iklahpihxixkjgvmgj`ixhgqvxa`axicoa`pgcaoavkpaeogsla`cako`pvqpb,sbila
vbapgvihixiopao`a`pg~avxqk`a/Pbahlkxxihparpgopbix,gjhgqvxa,ixKvixpgpla’xGoVbapgvih";99;)/
;1Gopbaokpqvagjokvvkpizaxko`pbaivvalkpigoxbi~pglkocqkcackmax,xaaVq`vqm6>>1
;:Kppaopigopgixxqaxgjxyogoymipyko`makoiocvakhba`jazav~iphb`qviocpbalkpa;90>x
ko`pbvgqcbpba;91>x/Pba`afkpapbkppgge~lkhaskxpbavaxqlpgj{qaxpigoxvkixa`kfgqp
“makoioc”kmgocjgvmavmamfavxgjpbaZiaookHivhla/XaaVaihbaofkhb;91;/Kmgocpbamgva
alkfgvkpaar~lihkpigoxskx~vaxaopa`fyVq`gljHkvok~";911)iosbihbba`ixpiocqixbaxfapsaao
makoiocx`aviza`jvgm“arpaoxigo”ko`“iopaoxigo”,sipbpbalkppavjghqxa`goxyogoymihmakoioc/;3Fvktil"ko`^gvpqcklkxsall)bkxam~gsava`xgmaioxpipqpaxko`khk`amihaopipiaxpg
gzavxaako`vacqlkpapbajgvmkl^gvpqcqaxalarihgo/
;2Pbavaixbixpgvihkl~vaha`aopjgvpbixxipqkpigoio~kvlikmaopkvyxyxpamxiosbihbpba
hgoha~pgj“mioixpaviklvax~goxifilipy”fahkmapbaxpko`kv`makxqvagjsbkpsasgql`pg`kypavm
“cgg`cgzavokha”5xaaFkvfavix;9925klxgJlio`avx6>>6,6>>6k
;9Xaabixalkfgvkpa`ixhqxxigogjapbihxiouOgtihe,;92;,(638>}/
6>^avbk~xoggoaio`izi`qklixmgvahlgxalykxxghikpa`sipbpbavixagjmkokcaviklixmpbko
^apav@vqheav,sbgxasgvejvgmpbaakvly;91>xgoskv`"xaa@vqheav,;910,;999)ckzaiopallahpqkl
xbk~ako``ivahpigopgpbixkca/Goagjbixmgxpkvpihqlkpavajlahpigoxgopbakcagjmkokcamaopix
jgqo`io@vqheav,;923/
6;Pbixoag-Bacalikoziasixva~vaxaopa`iopbasgvegjJvkohixJqeqykmk5xaaax~ahiklly
Jqeqykmk6>;;)/
66Gopbaamavcaohagjpbixko`valkpa`i`akx,xaaSaixx,6>>>/KlxgxaaJioealxpaio;991ko`@iocsavpbko`^kppfavc6>>:gopbafvgk`avhgoha~pgjclgfklcgzavokoha/
68Gjhgqvxa,pbavabkxfaaoxgma~qxbfkhekmgocpbgxasbgfackopgxaapba`kmkcagqv
gzavsbalmioc~vaghhq~kpigosipbkhhgqopkfilipybkxsvgqcbp"G’Oaill6>>65Jlio`avx6>;;5klxg
Xpaio6>>6)/Fqpfahkqxagjipamavcaohakxk~gsavjqlhqlpqvkleaysgv`,xqhbhgm~lkiopxkfgqp
bkziocpg`aklsipb“pggmqhb”khhgqopkfilipy`gogpcapkxmqhbkppaopigokxpbay`axavza/
60Pbix~giopixmk`aar~lihiplyfyX/O/Aixaoxpk`pkfgqp“Kriklhizilitkpigo”pbkp
“hvyxpkllita`”`qviocpbapbgqxko`yakvxjvgm1>>FHApbvgqcbpbajivxphaopqviaxgjpbaHgmmgo
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 44/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
89
Avk5xaaAixaoxpk`p;92;,6>;;/Gpbavvalazkopxpq`iaxgjkhhgqopkfilipyiokohiaophizilitkpigokva
jgqo`ioHkvmgokko`Attkmal6>>35Alxpav;9995Attkmal;9935Vgfavpx;9265ko`zgo@gvoqm,
;993/
61Laicbpgoko`Elqhebgbo,jgvarkm~la,jgqo`kxpvgoc“xbkmahqlpqva”kmgocpbaOkzkdg
sbihbea~pzkvigqxkhpgvxiohbahe,sbilakxpq`ygjpbaYkbckovalpa`pgpba~gsavgjkjgvmgj“~qflihg~ioigo”kxpbafkxixjgvaojgvhiocpvifklgv`avko`vqlax"fgpbhipa`ioJvia`vihbko`Mgvpgo
;9:2)/Gpbavmkdgvxpq`iaxiopbixvackv`hkofapvkha`pgAzkox-^viphbkv`’x";90>)sgvegopbaOqav
gjXq`ko/Bixsgvelki`pbajgqo`kpigojgvpbasgvegjMkvy@gqclkxko`bavhgm~kvkpizahqlpqvkl
sgvegoflkmako`vixe"xaa@gqclkx;996)sbihb,iopqvo,ixpbafkxixjgvhqlpqvklpbagvy5xaa
Pbgm~xgoapkl/,;99>/
6:Gopbaamgpiza~gsavgjsgv`x,xaaMkhkcogko`Sklpgo6>>25klxgXpazaoxgo;983}/
63Jgvarkm~la,xaaA`almko;93;,;933,;922/
62Ipxaamxpgxbkvapbkpxpkpqxsipb“pvkox~kvaohy”"kogpbavhko`i`kpajgveaysgv`xpkpqx)
ko`“`amghvkhy”"goagjSillikmx’gviciokleaysgv`x)‐klpbgqcbgoasgql`bkzak`ijjihqlp
qopkocliocpbgxapbvaaxymfglxgjokpigoklxpko`iociopbaiopavokpigoklkvaok/
69Bixpgvikoxgjma`iazklAqvg~ajio`pbaogpigogj“jaq`klixm”pgfabicblyhgopaxpa`,ko`
pbixkoklyxixixgjjava`sipbpbkphkzakpiomio`/XaauFkvao`xa,6>>8,(:06905Sbipa,;931,(3>3285Fvgso,;930,(00;6;5Bykmx,;993,(01:9;}/
8>Xaapba`axhvi~pigoiouSkvvao,;920,(68269}/KlxgxaauHkm~fall,;931,(22:>3}/
8;XaauKckmfao,6>;>,(981>:}/Pbapbabixpgvihkl~gsavgjkqpbx,xaauX~qvv,6>>;,
(;82;2}/
86Gpbavjkhpgvxsavakpsgvepbkpsgql`lak`pgpba`amixagjpbapvk`ipigokljaq`klxyxpam,
ko`pba`azalg~iocmahbkoixmxgjeiocxbi~jilla`kcvgsioczgi`uPbgvoa,;919,(;;>0>;}/
88Gopbavixagjpba“k`mioixpvkpizaeiocxbi~,”xaauBgllixpavko`Fkl`sio,;932,(90::}/
80^kqlVihgaqv’xkppam~ppgpvkhapba~a`icvaagjpbaJvaohblacklhgoha~pgjvax~goxifilipy
~vgzi`axkmgvacaoavih`axhvi~pigogjpba~vghaxxiozglza`/Jgvbim,pbaeaykhpixpbkpgj“im~qpioc”
kogflickpigo"gv~vgbifipigo)fkxa`goxgmakhpigofykokcaop,ko`ijpbagflica`khpixogp
hgm~lapa`‐gvpba~vgbifipa`khpixhgmmippa`‐xqhbkhpxkva“~qpgo”pbaio`izi`qkl’x“khhgqop”
kxxgmapbiocjgvsbihbbagvxbahkofabal`vax~goxifla/IokoalkfgvkpiocogpaVihgaqvbicblicbpx
pbamkdgvvgla~lkya`fypba“mapk~bgv”gjkokhhgqopiopbix~vghaxx/XaauVihŘqv,6>>>,(8>2;,~~/;1-;:}/
81Pbahlkxxihxpq`ygjpbavglagjmypbxioxghiapyixuJvktav,;91;,(;6>2}5gopba
“xghiglgcihkljqohpigo”gjmypbx,xaauHkm~fall,;93>,(;;3;>0}/
8:Xaa,jgvarkm~la,uFao`ir,;932,(338>2}/
83uJgqhkqlp,;99;,(0;:9}5klxguVgxa,6>>>,(;6919}/
82Xaau^g~~av,;929,(33;915^g~~av,;990,(1032>}/
89Jgvk~valimiokvyar~lgvkpigogjpbixzias,xaau@qfoihe,6>;>,(16>39/Pba{qgpaixjvgm
pbajivxpa`ipigogjPbaPbagvygjMgvklXaopimaopx,^kvpIII,Hbk~pav;5uXmipb,;319,(802>}/Ip
vak~~akvxiozkvigqxjgvmxioklllkpava`ipigoxarha~pjgvpba:pb";39>)/
0>Kmgoc~bilgxg~bavx,khhgqopkfilipygvkxgmasbkpximilkvixpbajghqxgjhgoxi`avkpigox
gjbgsio`izi`qklxkvaxbk~a`fypbaivvalkpigoxbi~xsipbpba“Gpbav”5jgvkvahaopzavxigo,xaa
uFqplav,6>>1,(1;:62}/Kmgocxghiklxhiaopixpx,goahkomkeapbahkxapbkpsgvexjvgmcvko`xghikl
pbagviax"a/c/,^kvxgox)pgfabkzigvklahgogmihx"a/c/,Ekboamko,Pbklav,Kiavly)kvahlgxalyvalkpa`pgXmipb’xhaopvkl~vamixa/
0;Ipixogpxqv~vixiocpbkppbacvgsiocfg`ygjsgvegokhhgqopkfilipyio~xyhbglgcyko`
gvckoitkpigofabkzigvbkx`vksomgxpgjpbakppaopigo5xaauPaplgheapkl/,6>>3,(;>02205Bkllapkl/,
6>>3,(;3;2:5Bghbskvpavapkl/,6>>1,(;0363}/
06Pbapavmixqxa`bavaiopbahqlpqvklxpq`iaxxaoxa5xaauSillikmx,;921,(8980}/
08Jgvarhallaoparkm~la,xaauBqm~bvayapkl/,;998,(9:;25Millav,;990,(0882}5klxg
uVgxa,;999,(8;03,~~/;1>-;11}/
7/31/2019 Accountability as Cultural Keyword
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/accountability-as-cultural-keyword 45/45
@qfoihe,1'68';6
00Xaapba`ixhqxxigogjpba”~vgmixaxgjkhhgqopfilipy”iou@qfoihe,6>>8,(0;695@qfoihe,
6>>8,(0:;>5@qfoiheko`Ykoc,6>;;,(;>8;02}/
01Vahaopbixpgvyixxpvasosipbpbahgv~xaxko`k`zavxahgoxa{qaohaxgjk`mioixpvkpiza
vajgvmxalazkpa`pgpbalazalgji`aglgcy/Xaa,jgvarkm~la,uSil`kzxey,;938,(;09>;}/
Related Documents
