Top Banner
2 0 17. 06 . 25 31Vol.31总第12212 =>?@A>B"C,D9E æçè éê ëì í îïð ñòó !"#$%&'()*+,- 611731 ./ô4õö÷øjù}úûÈüý6ôþíg9ÿ!í"ÎÈ#4$©3%Ö&'¨()*+,-ÂÃ. /Rz0ô4õ1234õÈ ZEBRA ÿ2ÉÅ*40ô4õPQR5678*0>9ô4õ:'ô4 õô;<4õÈ=>ô?½4õ@ABô4õCD6CDPnEPRF()6àW012ô4õ*040¨ '3456TM911  789:;A  7<=61001-9006201702-0012-05 !B= @%(>%"## (/ C(?,91 6$**"%,"# D,*' 2,>'E 4)*"%1"?,$*" $)? F(D 0"1;"%$*9%" TANG Guangsheng牞 LIN Jiu牞 YANG Jun牞 FANG Yuan牞 LIU Hongyi牞 YIN Wanshan 牗 Central Research Academy of Dongfang Electric Corporation牞 611731牞 Chengdu牞 China牘 Abstract牶 Sodium batteries gain great attention in largescale stationary energy storage field such as integration of renewable power resources and smart electricalgrid due to naturally abundance and low cost of sodium material. This paper introduces hightemperature sodium batteries牞 including sodiumsulphur battery and ZEBRA battery牞 and then reviews some kinds of sodium batteries with intermediate and lowtemperature牞 such as intermediatetemperature planar sodium battery牞 solidstate sodium battery牞 sodium molten salt battery and aqueous sodiumion battery. The recent rapid technological progress in sodium batteries are promoting their application in energy storage field. Key words牶 Sodium Batteries牷 intermediatetemperatur e牷 lowtemperature牷 energy storage >?@A2017 - 02- 20 N¡¢£öØÝ 2016GZ0149PBCD(÷(#øöbúBCDEûüý1981 - ),22013 %'()*+,-þde(-k4512-37Tÿ)9:;<=>?@ABCdDE Ëgâ!g ]AM4N°ã"iØÎÕZgâ×Í#gâ_t «$%&A]sPKPQ'(ô!ï)*^Q^cdZ+!g iji) ,-. g®á / g â( 0 «bx X ! gzá);01234Ä567«ûÊ;h¿ {®:°K8Eê¿9ï!g N ABc-;â/gâ2ÈZ/:! k;;<?bc;ùâ!{=«¯$ %&Aûbc>Veí?@o,½$% A®£>;<8?,BÏCË!g?y ÄZjæ?>;<dy>D;<« ZEBRA ;<úæWXE³Ã×8Å260℃ ~ 350℃ ß4N 3%Q>;<:F7å[ Ãy(GhZË ûL?Å¡>; <ÀË>;<>HI;<«>Y;<J7å?ÅZ¸jÿK°¾LÐÅ> ;< /·]>æ?Å>;< óx Ð4M1  ¤¥¦#§ 1 1  ¦¨#§ >D;<|PNõOP) 1968 %MùQ |WZ>;<>D;<]D«bc> ÇV] Beta ÔQRS>D;
5

A>BC,D9E...2 017.06.25 第31卷Vol.31总第122期 16 xNŠfí,—bcYžßÀ‡ç. λ-MnO2« NaTi2(PO4) 3Š`V,Na2SO4œœlŠ;rl,æ lzšˇ—[ˆ LiYž‡ç.。؈deýü、

May 19, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: A>BC,D9E...2 017.06.25 第31卷Vol.31总第122期 16 xNŠfí,—bcYžßÀ‡ç. λ-MnO2« NaTi2(PO4) 3Š`V,Na2SO4œœlŠ;rl,æ lzšˇ—[ˆ LiYž‡ç.。؈deýü、

2 017.06 .25

第31卷Vol.�31总第122期

12   

=>?@A>B"C,D9E

æçè

 éê

 ëì

 �í

 îïð

 ñòó

!"#$%&'()*+

,,-

611731

./

:ô4õö÷øjù}úûÈüý6ôþí

,g9ÿ!�í"ÎÈ#�4$©3%Ö&'¨�()*+,-

。ÂÃ.

/Rz0ô4õ

,12Rô34õÈ

ZEBRA4õ

,ÿ2ÉÅ*40ô4õPQR56

,78*0>9ô4õ

、:'ô4

õ

、ô;<4õÈ=>ô?½4õ

。@ABô4õCD6CDPnEPRFg¨�()6àW

。012

:ô4õ

;*0

;40

;¨�

'3456

:TM911         789:;

:A         7<=6

:1001-9006(2017)02-0012-05

!B= @%(>%"## (/ C(?,91 6$**"%,"# D,*' 2,>'E

4)*"%1"?,$*" $)? F(D 0"1;"%$*9%"

TANG Guangsheng牞 LIN Jiu牞 YANG Jun牞 FANG Yuan牞 LIU Hongyi牞 YIN Wanshan牗 Central Research Academy of Dongfang Electric Corporation牞 611731牞 Chengdu牞 China牘

Abstract牶 Sodium batteries gain great attention in largescale stationary energy storage field such as integration of renewable power

resources and smart electricalgrid due to naturally abundance and low cost of sodium material. This paper introduces hightemperature

sodium batteries牞 including sodiumsulphur battery and ZEBRA battery牞 and then reviews some kinds of sodium batteries with

intermediate and lowtemperature牞 such as intermediatetemperature planar sodium battery牞 solidstate sodium battery牞 sodium molten

salt battery and aqueous sodiumion battery. The recent rapid technological progress in sodium batteries are promoting their application

in energy storage field.

Key words牶 Sodium Batteries牷 intermediatetemperature牷 lowtemperature牷 energy storage

 >?@A

:2017-02-20 N¡¢£

:ö�ØÝ�

2016GZ0149,PBCD(�÷(���#øö��Rùb�ú

。 BCDE

:ûüý

(1981-),2

,2013%'()*+,-

,þde(-k4512-3

。7Tÿ)9:;<=>?@ABC

,�dDE

Ëgâ!g� �]AM4N

   °ã"iØÎÕZgâ×Í

、�#gâ_t

«$%&A]sPKPQZ£'(ô

,!g� 

ï)*^Q^cdZ�+

。!g� iji�)

,g«-.g®á/�gâ(0«bxX!g

,zá�);01234

、Ä567«ûÊ;h¿

{®:�

,°K

,8Eê¿9�ï!g� N�

ABc�

。�-;âQá/�gâ2ÈZ/:!

g� 

。k;;<?bc;ùâ!{�=«¯$

%iØ&A�û

,bc>Veí?@o,½$%

�A®£

,>;<8?

、,BÏCË!g?�y

�Z���j

。æ?>;<�dy>D;<«

ZEBRA;<úæWX

,E³Ã×8�Å

(260℃ ~

350℃)ß4N

[1]。3%Q

,>;<:�F7å[

Ã�y�(�GhZË� 

,ûL?Å�¡>;

<

、ÀË>;<

、>HI;<«��>Y�;<

,J7å?�Å�Z¸j

。�ÿK°¾LÐ�Å>

;<� 

,/·]>�æ?�Å>;<� óx

Ð4M

。1 

¤¥¦#§

1 1 ¦¨#§

>D;<|�PNõOP)

1968%Mù

,Q

|��WZ>;<

。>D;<bö]D«bc>

N�ÁÇV

,]

BetaÔ�QRS�fí

,>D;

Page 2: A>BC,D9E...2 017.06.25 第31卷Vol.31总第122期 16 xNŠfí,—bcYžßÀ‡ç. λ-MnO2« NaTi2(PO4) 3Š`V,Na2SO4œœlŠ;rl,æ lzšˇ—[ˆ LiYž‡ç.。؈deýü、

2 017.06 .25

第31卷Vol.�31总第122期

13   

<4NÅo8

300℃ ~ 350℃u¸

,$�4N;P

º»�

1 78 ~ 2 706 V[1]。>D;<TðZTíU

(�V�

NGKOP

,ÖQ�?W[[X´7Ð>

D;<Y(�ZOP

。ë

1983%̼

,NGKOP

Gk9r;hOPçN

,(D

ABBOPÇó�]

� 

,z%¬%úOZAB{)8

2002%´7�

(�

。NGKZ߯>D;<Z[£yç;Û`0

4 500Û

,Ë�� á0

15%

。��

2015%

5&

\

,NGKOP8�?º»ZÎ"a8Î>D!g

;]^%

250_

,Ð�{þ

530 MW(þç

3 7GWh),

�g���0%�

150 MW。:

1(a)ú<Ð

NGKOP>D;<�J«V/:

;:

1(b)Ó¥<ЯY(G`!g;]

[2]。

(a)�J;<s}~V/:

      (b)Y(G`!g;]

     

3

1  NGK©ª¦¨#§

¿Z:�

,>a;<k?(C>a­bIA

B}ë

2006%̼çNÌM>D;<

,()

2009

%�%�

2 MW�J;<?æ±

,2012%>a

;<

、>a;hOP]s>a­bIAB}cç

�*Ð>D;<!g� OP

[3]。9:;<)

2011%̼DE>;<AM

,(Dd¿

IonotecO

PÇó

BetaÔ�QRSYV¤� 

,���8Ì

¥

50 kWh>D;<!gÏe<ºG`

。1 2  ZEBRA

ZEBRA;<ì�>fg�h;<

,¯ÇV�

bc>

,ÁViÒ.�g�h

,(ÏÈ�H�Z

NaAlCl4 IN�jk;rl

,fí�µµ�

BetaÔ

�QRS

,¯V/L:

2(a)}<

[4]。ZEBRA;<

�W4NÅo�

300℃mn

,�ZQ�ú

BetaÔ�

QRS�;ÕË«Ë

NaAlCl4 I(H�

157℃)H�

]GgkÀËÁViÒ.óx>Y�æH

。ZEBRA

ZÌo;P�

2 58 V,/4ûg{�

788 Wh / kg,´µûg{Ó01

120 Wh / kg,ûF

G�

130 ~ 160 W / kg[1]。ZEBRA;<k>D;<

�û

,påõ�Q4�ÒÌ1ÐÄ,Z�A

,V

°Q;<Z;�-?iý4�qr

,;<zyÄ

6ZO%y«O%çgh

,½;<s�-��;

ÕõË·q»;<ZÅƳ

(a);<}~V/:

                (b);âÏe

   

3

2  ZEBRA#§

ZEBRA;<|�P�2

MAS - DEAOP´7

BÏ{�

,¯�W;âÏeL:

2(b)}<

[4]。MAS - DEA

OP7�²=,`

FIAMM SonickOP

tu

,¯��Üw�I�Âh;<

。2010%

,ß

¿

GEOPvxóí>fg�h;<Üw

,(få

Ð[\Þwx

DurathonTM,¶8

2015%

GE°»{

�Ð8OþÎ*4yZö�

。2017%

1&

,^z

=>vxk

GEOPT

Durathon;<ö�{|çN

}~

,��Î*çùOP

,#ø8

18\&-e�

,ï�di�8;0!g

、$�;]sÂh;<

2 '«¥¦#§

2 1 '¥¬­¦#§

æ?Z>D;<×d8

300℃ ~ 350℃Z�Å

4N

,±�ZGxÅoJPQ[�¦Z��«4

��f

。ûL�

,¬D�>8KÅo4NF�y

6�ZÓÔÒ

,éGËÌÁV=÷J«;<��

¨ÌV���Ò

,±±×d8l�Z���

Mo、Cr

®bcaçb�À

。8K�Åß

,¬D�>J

Ïv

BetaÔ�QRSfíÒgZ��

。Gx%5

?[�RSY�î

,H­D«H­>J��?i

ágê�����®[�¦�c-M

。°K

,à

�;<ZGxÅo·)>D;<Z��

、4�«

� 'ycd=�

。3%Q

,iÆ¿ZlZAB³�§Ðá8?

�Åo4NZ>D;<

。¯?

,߿3�-��

¿X´.<

(PNNL)8ß¿gâ�Z�úß8ÌM

Page 3: A>BC,D9E...2 017.06.25 第31卷Vol.31总第122期 16 xNŠfí,—bcYžßÀ‡ç. λ-MnO2« NaTi2(PO4) 3Š`V,Na2SO4œœlŠ;rl,æ lzšˇ—[ˆ LiYž‡ç.。؈deýü、

2 017.06 .25

第31卷Vol.�31总第122期

14   

  (b)�J;<}~

            (c)ÀÇ;<�

3

3  PNNL¬­¦#§

(~ 150℃)>D;<

。PNNLýþZ;<�¥

µ�

BetaÔ�QN�ÀËfí

,±µ�B�E�

E��N�ÁV;rl

,S«

Na2S4 8B�E�E

��?y�Z�ro

,ñlz$%�Ï

NaIIQ

��;rlZY�I;Ò

。:

3(a)�

PNNL"#

ZVW;<<=:

,�Ð��;<ZFGõÒ;

<}~Pæ?ZYX}~û�Ð�¡}~

,fí

�no

600 μmZ

BetaÔ�QRSm

[5]。o;<8

150 ℃4N

,�¼û�{�

450 mAh / g,8;÷�

o�

2 23 mA / cm2ß�£Ð

60Û]-�{�úG

�¥,)

70%。PNNL#ø·;<Ògóxûó

,(fåÐ,òó;<«;<Ïe�Z"# ¡

,L:

3(b)«

3(c),Ö�FÌ¥Ð?Å�¡

ZEBRA

;<Z´.AB

[4]。uY´��Z�¡>;<z

y,{Z� hf×d¢Z

,¥±

PNNL��FG

�o?�Å>;<ZÌM�RÐÄ¿Z£os

 ¡

。2 2 

®¯¦#§

ÀË>;<µ�ÀJbc>N�;<ÇV

,GxÅo8bc>H�]ß

。|3ß¿

Ceramatec

OPfåÐÀË>;< ¡�?

,¯;âÏe�

20 ~ 40 kWh,Jø�¤¥,³

,;<GxÅo8

90℃]ß

。�B>;<×8

300℃mnZ�ÅG

x

,;ViÒ.B)§ZlË

,�y�ÓÔÒ«

y¦Ò

,±

CerametcOPZp�8);<8Á�

ÅoGxF;<�L�À˱iQ§lË

,:

4�

CeramatecOPÀË>;<VW

[6]。CeramatecZß

o;âÏeá]]

5 kWZFGGx

4 h,�£�

 0

3 650Û

,Ë�� ^%

10%

。20 kWhZ;

â�?��§$�

2 000�

,ì�o;§$

100�

,�·);<Z� qÍQ��o;§$

�)

3ßb

,±�B;01�¨|Z�o;��þ

8ßb

。·)

20 kWh;âÏeQ�

,ᾩ©$

Xª�FË�«¬B/ô

、­.e/ô

、'«®

¯K

、*JZ°Æ

、±²ô«

33³

60 W´µ¶

Oi¸Ø4N

4 h,Öá$%-.g;¡a³,h

M;ôóxy;

,°K·)Xª\ã�¨Äy®

Çh

  (a)�J;<

                (b);<<ºÏe

3

4  Ceramatec©ª®¯¦#§

CeramatecOPP[·¸²¹,-Zº»)

1976%¼*

,|̼DE>D;<� ZAB

,éÃ�M²Nõ½IOP}u¾

。�ÍZlJZ

�;<(i¼çGÂwç

,�dQ°�;<Z,

³

、c{]s«ú;<?i}×Z¿à./�-�

L

。;)]>ÀÁ

,CeramatecZ:�A§Ð�yÂ

,GhZXª;âÜw

。;<fíµ�

NASICONd

e

,k

BetaÔ�Q�û

,NASICON�yÃÄ}

~

,á´7

NaY�8ª«:§ZI;

,ñl¯7

ÅÒ«7�½Ògô6

;;<ÇVde�ÀJb

c>

,�д7>Y�8ÀË>«RSfí¸Z

æI

,ÇVzµ�Ðyô;rl

;;<ÁV��

�de

[7]。CeramatecOP|3²ß¿Æ%ÇwR

SU(

CoorsTecOPtu

,��¯ÈßZÉcU

(

,]fóÀË>;<Z�(�ó5

。2 3 

¦°±#§

V�ÊË;4cçr',-AMÐ[æ>H

Page 4: A>BC,D9E...2 017.06.25 第31卷Vol.31总第122期 16 xNŠfí,—bcYžßÀ‡ç. λ-MnO2« NaTi2(PO4) 3Š`V,Na2SO4œœlŠ;rl,æ lzšˇ—[ˆ LiYž‡ç.。؈deýü、

2 017.06 .25

第31卷Vol.�31总第122期

15   

I;<

,o;<µ�iá�ZHIN�;r¿

,�yg{�o�«4�Òg¿Z��

,}µ�Z

HIZH��

61℃,8;<Ë�%5?×ϧ1

90℃[8]。P)éæ;<�y�0

290 Wh / LZg{

�o]sý×ÌÍ«¸

,»á]VN�³Jø«

Îc{Z;<�?

。HI�yiá�

、ºÏMÒ

«�Y��oZõ�

,ÊË;4�FÌMåÐ�

H�Z

(FSO2)2N ÐbcI

(�ÿ?Ñ�

FSAI

)。NaFSA

«

KFSAú�HI�?|yÒÓi�)8

100℃mn4NZ>;<

,E³Z�H��

334 K

(61℃),HIZbrÅo�

463 K,¯§�-ÔÕ

130 K(334 ~ 463 K),±¯;�-ÔÕ�

5V,8;<yç;;Pº»Z�-®£

。C;<úO

B)%yõËF

,HIJM�br¨�Ïç.õ

,Ë;<s�

。;<ÇV�bc>a>çb

,ÁV

iÒ.�

NaCrO2,fíµ�Ö×Ø«xayôR

S¬hí

,;r¿µ�

NaFSA - KFSAHI

,L

:

5(a)}<

。;<Zy;��;P�

3 5 V,ç

;��;P�

2 5 V,;<4NÅo�

90℃。$%

ÙX;<ZåæÚÛQ�

,;<8

100% DOD(M

;vo

)ß$%Ð

100Û�£

,8

90% DODF;

<z%

1 000Û�£�{ýè²

,(½zá]8Ü

F¸Zz\Ê

15C(50 A / cm2)Z�FGç;

。2010

%

,ÊË;4AMV¤åÐ�{�

1 kWh、;P�

12 VZVW;<��

(lWòó�

150 mm ×

180 mm × 40 mm),P

4\�{�

250 WhZ�J

;<Ýc±�

,o;<��Zûg{�

167 Wh / kg,g{�o�

270 Wh / L。�\�J;<s~

20\Á

Vm

(ÁV=÷J�QÞ

)«

20\ÇVm

(ÇV=

÷Jµ���ßàZQÞ

),ÁÇÞm?¸�RS

fíbÌ

,çI)[\Qáâ

,/3yHI(ã

2��

。:

5(b)ú<Ð

36 kWh;â�?´.:

,¯n>��

250 Wh�J;<äm

[8]。ñl

,ÊË

OPzµ�

5 Ah�{Zws;<óxÐêö4�

Òåæ

,stÏåI��Â

、!æ

、á�«�ç

,}Mú<;Pxyè�¨�

,Öxy��

、éê®7H

。éæ;<Zg{�o�©$;;<

Z

2ë

,$%Íj�7yV��;ÂI;Y�;<

Zabu[

。ÊË;4�°��ïéæ;<i�

)Õ¹YxìZ;ÂO5«Êí!g:�

,��

cç,¡VN}óx0���±ZÌM

,ÒÓu

î´7{�«´µi�

  (a);<}~<=:

            (b)36 kWhÏes�J;<

3

5 ²³#`¦°±#§

2 4 ´µ¦¶�#§

>Y�;<�yûg{�

、$%�A«!{

@��

,��3%Q!gTðABZ§�u

[

。>Y�;<k;Y�;<}~V/"Á

,Ç

Vde�dyðde«%ñbcÔ�.

(ûL

Na2Ti3O7 « Sb2O4)®,ÁVde�dyÀõZ>

;%ñbcÔ�.

、ÏòY�WÁVde

(ûL%

ñbcób>I

),;r¿µ��y>Y�Zyô

�ôa³>I©ªZÀËÏç.

[9]。3%Q��

;rl>Y�;<\1(E]á

,�ûyô�ô

;rl>Y�;<

,��;rl>Y�;<Z4

�Òô�

、��ô�

          (a);<Z�~ê

                  (b);<Ïe�

3

6 ´µ¦¶�#§

8��>Y�;<Tð

,��F7åQÐ[

XTíU(

———ß¿

Aquion EnergyOP

。oOP

�*)

2007%

,()

2013%þÌÐûõ

·�öT

eZ

3 500÷ß�­ù

,­ùÐ[�

7 500÷ß�

�)yøÎ"

。;<µ�iÒùN�ÇV

,ýú

Page 5: A>BC,D9E...2 017.06.25 第31卷Vol.31总第122期 16 xNŠfí,—bcYžßÀ‡ç. λ-MnO2« NaTi2(PO4) 3Š`V,Na2SO4œœlŠ;rl,æ lzšˇ—[ˆ LiYž‡ç.。؈deýü、

2 017.06 .25

第31卷Vol.�31总第122期

16   

xN�fí

,ÐbcY�ûÀ�ç. λ - MnO2 «

NaTi2(PO4)3 �ÁV

,Na2SO4 ��l�;rl

,ñ

lz�ÏÐ[Ã

LiY��ç.

。éÃdeýü

、iá�«ýýþÒ,ÿ

[10]。o

Aquion EnergyOP

ýþ

,¯��;rl>Y�;<Z�£� �

3 000Û

(100%ç;vo

),g{�G�

85%

(DC),4NÅo�

- 5℃ ~40℃,y;úOF¸�

8 h,±ç;úOF¸�

16 h,º�¼ç;0!"

1234«-.g(0

。k�B>D;<�û

,o;<ý×�Å«ú

、ýá�«ÓÔÒ.¿

,c

)�¿4�Z�Å4N;<

。P);<AM«�

(�F¸ÊÜ

,� À�zW8�¬hf×d¢

Z

,ûLo;<Zûg{i©

25 Wh / kg,¯ûg

{«g{�oÃû#b$;<z�

。8¿Z:�

,á$%hgâ(�y¢OPk

Aquion EnergyOPçNfó��>Y�;<Z�

(�ó5

,2015%

5&Ú

1���±eÈæ��

。3%Q

,8��>Y�;<ÖÌ¥Ð[Ã<ºi

�45

,�WZûLß¿&z'

1 MWhY0-.

gù;0�?

。á$%hgâOPÓÌ¥Ð"Á

Z<º

,ûLá$

10 kWhü(!gëM;�?«

%hyv

0 72 kWh-.g�*o´�?

。��>

Y�;<ÁB)�:�ÕÙñ

,P)o� å7

ÊË«�(fóZF¸Ü

,8;<Õ� ®£Ò

«BÏ��ZáâÒ:�z×ó[)./

[11]。

3 Hm

�i·æ?�#gâ_tPQZgâ«£'

,8Eº»Z�)�Ð[*6+Zá/�g

â,BÏÌM`�,÷

。!g� N�á/�g

â2È«;g;0i�?iáa=Z[£

,ï�

1^Q^cdZN�

。8-¬�-g;â?

,°

�y!{@ï«$%�AZ>ùâ

,>;<8,

BÏ!gi�?�y���j

。>D;<:�

,V�

NGKOP�z´7Y(�

,±¿Z>a;<

«9:;<Ö8øVfÂ>D;<AM«<ºi

;ZEBRA;<

(>fg�h;<

):�

,ß¿

GE

OP«¿ZOPçNÁ8./�(�ÂN

。ËW

?�Å>;<� Á8iØF7

,?Å�¡>;

<ÁBAMÙñ

,ÀË>;<«>HI;<ÁB

�(�� ÌMÙñ

,��>Y�;<ÓB)�

(��:Ùñ

。¯~0JêE·!g� cdÒ

ÀÁZÏ6

,]sù�«� 1>;<:§Z2

3

,>;<i4ï5Q67M¥FÍ

,¯� ï

V8�Ê«�Ý

,j0ï8,BÏ!g?Ì1ô

ϳ´Zi�

Xn78

:[1]K B Hueso,M Armand, T Rojo. High temperature sodium

batteries:status,challenges and future trends[J]. Energy &Environmental Science,2013,(6):734-749

[2]NGK Insulator. NAS Energy Storage System:Sodium Sulfer Battery[J / OL],https: / / www. ngk. co. jp / nas /,2017-01-18

[3]ìd9

,Å:;

,<=

,®

.>;<ZABkÌM7õ

[J].!

g(-k� 

,2013,2(3):81-90[4]J P Lemmon. Planar ZEBRA Battery for Renewable Integration and

Grid Applications [J / OL], http: / / energyenvironment. pnnl.gov / presentations / pdf / Planar%20Zebra. pdf,2017-01-18

[5]X C Lu,B W Kirby,W Xu,et al. Advanced intermediate -temperature Na -S battery[J]. Energy & Environmental Science,2013,(6):299-306

[6]R Wright. New battery could change world,one house at a time[J /OL],http: / / www. heraldextra. com / news / new -battery -could-change-world-one-house-at-a-time / article_ b0372fd8 -3f3c-

11de-ac77-001cc4c002e0. html,2017-01-18[7] C Boxley,G Coors, J J Watkins. Solid-state sodium-based

secondary cell having a sodium ion conductive ceramic separator

[P]. US:8859141[8]

Ë>?P

,@AJE

,BCï[D

,et al.�­EFrlF<

のGH

[J]. SEIテクニカルレビュI

,2013,181(õJ

):27-33[9]V Palomares,P Serras,I Villaluenga,et al. Na - ion batteries,

recent advances and present challenges to become low cost energy

storage systems[J]. Energy & Environmental Science,2012,5(3):5884-5901

[10]J F Whitacre,S Shanbhag,A Mohamed,et al. A Polyionic,Large-Format Energy Storage Device Using an Aqueous Electrolyte

and Thick - Format Composite NaTi2(PO4)3 / Activated CarbonNegative Electrodes[J]. Energy Technology,2015,3(1):20-31

[11]KL

,MNÖ

,MO

,®

.��>Y�;<Z7õs¥Ó

[J].!g(-k� 

,2016,5(3):317-323