Top Banner

of 48

Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

Jun 01, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    1/48

    EN BANC

    ABAKADA GURO PARTY LIST (FormerlyAASJAS) OFFICERS SAMSON S.ALCANTARA a! ED "INCENT S. ALBANO#

    G.R. No. $%&'%

    Petitioners, Present:

    DAVIDE, JR., C.J.,

    PUNO, PANGANIBAN, QUISUMBING,

    YNARES-SANTIAGO,

    SANDOVAL-GUTIERRE,

    - !ers"s - #ARPIO, AUSTRIA-MARTINE, #ORONA, #ARPIO-MORALES,

    #ALLEJO, SR., A#UNA, TINGA, #$I#O-NAARIO, and GAR#IA,JJ.TE ONORABLE E*ECUTI"ESECRETARY EDUARDO ERMITA+ONORABLE SECRETARY OF TEDEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CESARPURISIMA+ a! ONORABLECOMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL RE"ENUEGUILLERMO PARAYNO# JR.#

    Res%on&ents.

    ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '

    A,UILINO ,. PIMENTEL# JR.# LUISA P.EJERCITO-ESTRADA# JINGGOY E.ESTRADA# PANFILO M. LACSON#ALFREDO S. LIM# JAMBY A.S. MADRIGAL#AND SERGIO R. OSMEA III#

    G.R. No. $%&/'0

    Petitioners,

    - !ers"s -

    E*ECUTI"E SECRETARY EDUARDO R.ERMITA# CESAR ". PURISIMA#SECRETARY OF FINANCE# GUILLERMO L.PARAYNO# JR.# COMMISSIONER OF TEBUREAU OF INTERNAL RE"ENUE#

    Res%on&ents.

    ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    2/48

    ASSOCIATION OF PILIPINAS SELLDEALERS# INC. re1re2e3e! 4y 532 Pre25!e3#ROSARIO ANTONIO+ PETRON DEALERS6ASSOCIATION re1re2e3e! 4y 532 Pre25!e3#RUT E. BARBIBI+ ASSOCIATION OF

    CALTE* DEALERS6 OF TE PILIPPINESre1re2e3e! 4y 532 Pre25!e3# MERCEDITAS A.GARCIA+ ROSARIO ANTONIO !o57 4825e228!er 39e ame a! 23yle o: ;ANB NORTSELL SER"ICE STATION N. DOMINGO

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    3/48

    CORPORATION re1re2e3e! 4y 532 "5e-Pre25!e3 :or O1era35o2# JOSELITO F.FLORDELI=A+ MOTORISTS6 ERITAGECORPORATION re1re2e3e! 4y 532 "5e-Pre25!e3 :or O1era35o2# JOSELITO F.FLORDELI=A+ PILIPPINE STANDARD

    OIL CORPORATION re1re2e3e! 4y 532 "5e-Pre25!e3 :or O1era35o2# JOSELITO F.FLORDELI=A+ ROMEO MANUEL !o574825e22 8!er 39e ame a! 23yle o:;ROMMAN GASOLINE STATION

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    4/48

    BATAAN GO"ERNOR ENRI,UE T. GARCIA#JR.

    G.R. No. $%&0'

    Petitioner,

    - !ers"s -

    ON. EDUARDO R. ERMITA# 5 952 a1a53ya2 39e Ee835e Sere3ary+ ON.MARGARITO TE"ES# 5 952 a1a53y a2Sere3ary o: F5ae+ ON. JOSE MARIOBUNAG# 5 952 a1a53y a2 39e OICComm5225oer o: 39e B8rea8 o: I3eralRee8e+ a! ON. ALE*ANDER ARE"ALO#5 952 a1a53y a2 39e OIC Comm5225oer o: 39eB8rea8 o: C823om2#

    Pro(")*+te&:

    Res%on&ents. Se%te(er , //0

    ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '

    D E C I S I O N

    AUSTRIA-MARTINE=#J.

    T1e e'%enses o2 *o!ern(ent, 1+!in* 2or t1eir o3e4t t1e interest o2 +)), s1o")& e

    orne 5 e!er5one, +n& t1e (ore (+n en3o5s t1e +&!+nt+*es o2 so4iet5, t1e (ore 1e

    o"*1t to 1o)& 1i(se)2 1onore& in 4ontri"tin* to t1ose e'%enses.

    -Anne Roert J+46"es T"r*ot 788-89

    ;ren41 st+tes(+n +n& e4ono(ist

    Mo"ntin* "&*et &e2i4it, re!en"e *ener+tion, in+&e6"+te 2is4+) +))o4+tion 2or e&"4+tion, in4re+se&

    e(o)"(ents 2or 1e+)t1

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    5/48

    R.A. No. ?@@8 is + 4onso)i&+tion o2 t1ree )e*is)+ti!e i))s n+(e)5, $o"se Bi)) Nos. @000 +n& @8/0,

    +n& Sen+te Bi)) No. ?0/.

    House Bill No. 3555

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    6/48

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    7/48

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    8/48

    re4o((en&+tion o2 t1e Se4ret+r5 o2 ;in+n4e, to r+ise t1e VAT r+te to , e22e4ti!e J+n"+r5 , //, +2ter

    +n5 o2 t1e 2o))o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    9/48

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    10/48

    Se!er+) (e(ers o2 t1e $o"se o2 Re%resent+ti!es )e& 5 Re%. ;r+n4is Jose%1 G. Es4"&ero 2i)e&

    t1is %etition 2or certiorarion J"ne @/, //0. T1e5 6"estion t1e 4onstit"tion+)it5 o2 R.A. No. ?@@8 on t1e

    2o))o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    11/48

    *oo&s e'4ee&in* P,///,///.//, +n& t1e 0 2in+)

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    12/48

    In 4ontr+st, + &ire4t t+' is + t+' 2or

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    13/48

    @ Insertin* t1e %ro!ision i(%osin* + 8/ )i(it on t1e +(o"nt o2 in%"t t+' to e

    4re&ite& +*+inst t1e o"t%"t t+' +n&

    In4)"&in* t1e +(en&(ents intro&"4e& on)5 5 Sen+te Bi)) No. ?0/ re*+r&in*

    ot1er =in&s o2 t+'es in +&&ition to t1e !+)"e-+&&e& t+'.

    Petitioners no< esee41 t1e #o"rt to &e2ine t1e %o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    14/48

    +2ter t1eir 4o(%osition. T1e Presi&ent s1+)) &esi*n+te t1e (e(ers o2 t1e Sen+te P+ne) in

    t1e 4on2eren4e 4o((ittee

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    15/48

    :or8m :or 39e e:oreme3 o: 39e2e 53eral r8le2 o: Co7re22# 9e39er o82e orSea3e. Parl5ame3ary r8le2 are merely 1roe!8ral a! 539 39e5r o42erae 39eo8r32 9ae o oer. ?9a3eer !o8432 39ere may 4e a2 3o 39e :ormal al5!53y o:Re1. A3 No. ''% m823 4e re2ole! 5 532 :aor. T1e #o"rt reiter+tes its r")in*inArroyo vs. De +enecia, vi.:

    B"t t1e a2e2# 4o39 9ere a! a4roa!# 5 ary57 :orm2 o:e1re225o# all !ey 3o 39e o8r32 39e 1oer 3o 585re 53oalle7a35o2 39a3# 5 ea357 a la# a o82e o: Co7re22 :a5le! 3oom1ly 539 532 o r8le2# 5 39e a42ee o: 29o57 39a3 39ere a2 a5ola35o o: a o2353835oal 1ro525o or 39e r57932 o: 1r5a3e5!55!8al2. In Os&e(a v. Pendatun, it

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    16/48

    Ne!ert1e)ess, 3"st to %"t (in&s +t e+se t1+t no )+t+nt irre*")+rities t+inte& t1e %ro4ee&in*s o2 t1e

    i4+(er+) 4on2eren4e 4o((ittees, t1e #o"rt &ee(s it ne4ess+r5 to &

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    17/48

    +sore& 5 *ener+tion,

    tr+ns(ission, +n& &istri"tion

    4o(%+nies.

    With regard to 70& li'it on in%ut ta( )redit

    Pro!i&es t1+t t1e in%"t t+'4re&it 2or 4+%it+) *oo&s on

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    18/48

    to +4t on t1e s+(e 5 sett)in* s+i& &i22eren4es +n&or &is+*ree(ents. T1e Bi4+(er+) #on2eren4e

    #o((ittee +4te& on t1e &is+*reein* %ro!isions 5 (+=in* t1e 2o))o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    19/48

    +**re*+te +46"isition 4ost 2or s"41 *oo&s, e'4)"&in* t1e VAT 4o(%onent

    t1ereo2, e'4ee&s one (i))ion Pesos 7P,///,///.//: PROVIDED,

    1o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    20/48

    %ro%ose& 5 t1e t

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    21/48

    . . . it is

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    22/48

    it

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    23/48

    T1e +r*"(ent &oes not 1o)&

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    24/48

    39e a35oal 1er21e35e. Bo39 5e2 are 39ere4y ma!e 3o 4ear o 39e ea3me3 o:289 la2.@@ 7E(%1+sis s"%%)ie&

    Sin4e t1ere is no 6"estion t1+t t1e re!en"e i)) e'4)"si!e)5 ori*in+te& in t1e $o"se o2

    Re%resent+ti!es, t1e Sen+te

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    25/48

    to s"%%)e(ent o"r 4o"ntr5Hs serio"s 2in+n4i+) %ro)e(s, +n& i(%ro!e t+' +&(inistr+tion +n& 4ontro) o2 t1e

    )e+=+*es in re!en"es 2ro( in4o(e t+'es +n& !+)"e-+&&e& t+'es. As t1ese 1o"se i))s

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    26/48

    )on*er e VAT-e'e(%t, t1e 4ons"(er

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    27/48

    T1e +ss+i)e& %ro!isions re+& +s 2o))o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    28/48

    SE#. /9. V+)"e-+&&e& T+' on S+)e o2 Ser!i4es +n& Use or Le+se o2

    Pro%erties

    7A R+te +n& B+se o2 T+'. T1ere s1+)) e )e!ie&, +ssesse& +n&

    4o))e4te&, + !+)"e-+&&e& t+' e6"i!+)ent to ten %er4ent 7/ o2 *ross

    re4ei%ts &eri!e& 2ro( t1e s+)e or e'41+n*e o2 ser!i4es: 1ro5!e!# 39a339e Pre25!e3# 81o 39e reomme!a35o o: 39e Sere3ary o: F5ae#29all# e::e35e Ja8ary $# /''%# ra52e 39e ra3e o: al8e-a!!e! 3a 3o3ele 1ere3 ($/)# a:3er ay o: 39e :ollo57 o!535o2 9a2 4ee2a352:5e!.

    (5) al8e-a!!e! 3a olle35o a2 a 1ere3a7e o: Gro22 Dome235

    Pro!83 (GDP) o: 39e 1re5o82 year eee!2 3o a! :o8r-:5:39 1ere3 (/ Q) or

    (55) a35oal 7oerme3 !e:553 a2 a 1ere3a7e o: GDP o: 39e1re5o82 year eee!2 oe a! oe-9al: 1ere3 ($ ). 7E(%1+sis s"%%)ie&

    Petitioners +))e*e t1+t t1e *r+nt o2 t1estand-by authorityto t1e Presi&ent to in4re+se t1e VAT r+te

    is + !irt"+) +&i4+tion 5 #on*ress o2 its e'4)"si!e %o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    29/48

    Petitioners Pi(ente),et al.+!er t1+t t1e Presi&ent 1+s +(%)e %o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    30/48

    Nonet1e)ess, t1e *ener+) r")e +rrin* &e)e*+tion o2 )e*is)+ti!e %o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    31/48

    o2 + %+rti4")+r 4o(("nit5. In C+5(+n !s. So"t1+r&, t1e S"%re(e #o"rt o2 t1e Unite&

    St+tes r")e& t1+t t1e )e*is)+t"re (+5 &e)e*+te + %o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    32/48

    #)e+r)5, t1e )e*is)+t"re (+5 &e)e*+te to e'e4"ti!e o22i4ers or o&ies t1e %o

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    33/48

    "%on + s%e4i2ie& 2+4t or 4on&ition. It )e+!es t1e entire o%er+tion or non-o%er+tion o2 t1e r+te "%on

    2+4t"+) (+tters o"tsi&e o2 t1e 4ontro) o2 t1e e'e4"ti!e.

    No &is4retion

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    34/48

    In t1e %resent 4+se, in (+=in* 1is re4o((en&+tion to t1e Presi&ent on t1e e'isten4e o2 eit1er o2

    t1e t

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    35/48

    (+ni2est)5 4on3e4t"r+), +s t1ese (+5 not e'ist +t +)). T1e #o"rt &e+)s

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    36/48

    Petitioners o!io"s)5 o!er)oo=e& t1+t in4re+se in VAT 4o))e4tion is not t1e only4on&ition. T1ere

    is +not1er 4on&ition, i.e., t1e n+tion+) *o!ern(ent &e2i4it +s + %er4ent+*e o2 GDP o2 t1e %re!io"s 5e+r

    e'4ee&s one +n& one-1+)2 %er4ent 7 .

    Res%on&ents e'%)+ine& t1e %1i)oso%15 e1in& t1ese +)tern+ti!e 4on&itions:

    . VATGDP R+tio .9

    T1e 4on&ition set 2or in4re+sin* VAT r+te to 1+!e e4ono(i4 or 2is4+)

    (e+nin*. I2 VATGDP is )ess t1+n .9, it (e+ns t1+t *o!ern(ent 1+s uacy &i4t+te& t1e nee& 2or + r+ise in

    re!en"e.

    T1e %rin4i%)e o2 2is4+) +&e6"+45 +s + 41+r+4teristi4 o2 + so"n& t+' s5ste(

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    37/48

    ;irst, )et (e e'%)+in t1e %osition t1+t t1e P1i)i%%ines 2in&s itse)2 in ri*1t no

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    38/48

    +n en+4t(ent is ual Protection 'lauses

    Petitioners Asso4i+tion o2Pilipinas S1e)) De+)ers, In4., et al.+r*"e t1+t Se4tion 9 o2 R.A. No.

    ?@@8, +(en&in* Se4tions / 7A7, / 7B, +n& Se4tion o2 R.A. No. ?@@8, +(en&in* Se4tion

    7# o2 t1e NIR# +re +ritr+r5, o%%ressi!e, e'4essi!e +n& 4on2is4+tor5. T1eir +r*"(ent is %re(ise& on t1e

    4onstit"tion+) ri*1t +*+inst &e%ri!+tion o2 )i2e, )iert5 o2 %ro%ert5

    http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2005/sep2005/168056.htm#_ftn66http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2005/sep2005/168056.htm#_ftn67http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2005/sep2005/168056.htm#_ftn68http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2005/sep2005/168056.htm#_ftn66http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2005/sep2005/168056.htm#_ftn67http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2005/sep2005/168056.htm#_ftn68
  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    39/48

    3nput #a* is &e2ine& "n&er Se4tion /7A o2 t1e NIR#, +s +(en&e&, +s t1e !+)"e-+&&e& t+'

    &"e$ro&orpaid5 + VAT-re*istere& %erson on t1e i(%ort+tion o2 *oo&s or )o4+) %"r41+se o2 *oo& +n&

    ser!i4es, in4)"&in* )e+se or "se o2 %ro%ert5, in t1e 4o"rse o2 tr+&e or "siness, 2ro( + VAT-re*istere&

    %erson, +n& Output #a* is t1e !+)"e-+&&e& t+' due on t1e s+)e or )e+se o2 t+'+)e *oo&s or %ro%erties or

    ser!i4es 5 +n5 %erson re*istere& or re6"ire& to re*ister "n&er t1e )+

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    40/48

    As e+r)ier st+te&, t1e in%"t t+' is t1e t+' %+i& 5 + %erson, %+sse& on to 1i( 5 t1e se))er,

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    41/48

    *ross re!en"e. C1en Pres. A6"ino iss"e& E.O. No. 8@ i(%osin* + / (")ti-st+*e t+' on +)) s+)es, it

    Provided, T1+t t1e in%"t t+' on *oo&s %"r41+se& or i(%orte& in + 4+)en&+r (ont1

    2or "se in tr+&e or "siness 2or

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    42/48

    Cit1 re*+r& to t1e 0 4re&it+)e

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    43/48

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    44/48

    t1e %ro!ision. Petitioners, +s %etro)e"( &e+)ers, +re not t1e on)5 ones s"3e4te& to t1e 0 2in+)

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    45/48

    &i22erent 4onse6"en4es. C1i)e t1e i(%)e(ent+tion o2 t1e )+< (+5 5ie)& !+r5in* en& res")ts &e%en&in* on

    oneHs %ro2it (+r*in +n& !+)"e-+&&e&, t1e #o"rt 4+nnot *o e5on&

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    46/48

    Neit1er &oes t1e )+< (+=e +n5 &istin4tion +s to t1e t5%e o2 in&"str5 or tr+&e t1+t

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    47/48

    A)) t1ese

  • 8/9/2019 Abakada Guro Party List vs. Ermita Original

    48/48