Page 1
images/logoetsf
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitationsCarbon Nanotubes and Graphene layer systems
Francesco Sottile
Laboratoire des Solides IrradiesEcole Polytechnique, Palaiseau - France
European Theoretical Spectroscopy Facility (ETSF)
Strasbourg, 27 August 2008
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 2
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Outline
1 Introduction
2 Electron Energy Loss SpectroscopyLinear response within DFT
3 Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene
4 Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 3
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Outline
1 Introduction
2 Electron Energy Loss SpectroscopyLinear response within DFT
3 Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene
4 Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 4
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Introduction
Theoretical Spectroscopy Group (ETSF)
Results on Nanotubes and Graphene:
Coordinator: Christine GiorgettiRalf HambachXochitl LopezFederico IoriV.Olevano, A. Marinopoulos, L. Reining, F. SottileExperiments: Thomas Pichler group (Dresden)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 5
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Outline
1 Introduction
2 Electron Energy Loss SpectroscopyLinear response within DFT
3 Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene
4 Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 6
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 7
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Energy Loss Function
d2σ
dΩdE∝ Im
ε−1
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 8
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 9
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 10
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 11
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 12
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 13
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Spectroscopy: Electron Scattering
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 14
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Outline
1 Introduction
2 Electron Energy Loss SpectroscopyLinear response within DFT
3 Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene
4 Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 15
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
System submitted to an external perturbation
Vtot = ε−1Vext
Vtot = Vext + Vind
E = ε−1D
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 16
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
System submitted to an external perturbation
Vtot = ε−1Vext
Vtot = Vext + Vind
E = ε−1D
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 17
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
System submitted to an external perturbation
Vtot = ε−1Vext
Vtot = Vext + Vind
E = ε−1D
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 18
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Definition of polarizability
not polarizable ⇒ Vtot = Vext ⇒ ε−1 = 1polarizable ⇒ Vtot 6= Vext ⇒ ε−1 6= 1
ε−1 = 1 + vχ
χ is the polarizability of the system
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 19
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Definition of polarizability
not polarizable ⇒ Vtot = Vext ⇒ ε−1 = 1polarizable ⇒ Vtot 6= Vext ⇒ ε−1 6= 1
ε−1 = 1 + vχ
χ is the polarizability of the system
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 20
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Definition of polarizability
not polarizable ⇒ Vtot = Vext ⇒ ε−1 = 1polarizable ⇒ Vtot 6= Vext ⇒ ε−1 6= 1
ε−1 = 1 + vχ
χ is the polarizability of the system
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 21
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Definition of polarizability
not polarizable ⇒ Vtot = Vext ⇒ ε−1 = 1polarizable ⇒ Vtot 6= Vext ⇒ ε−1 6= 1
ε−1 = 1 + vχ
χ is the polarizability of the system
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 22
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
interacting system δn = χδVext
non-interacting system δnn−i = χ0δVtot
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 23
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
interacting system δn = χδVext
non-interacting system δnn−i = χ0δVtot
Single-particle polarizability
χ0 =∑ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ
∗i (r
′)φj(r′)
ω − (εi − εj)
hartree, hartree-fock, dft, etc.
G.D. Mahan Many Particle Physics (Plenum, New York, 1990)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 24
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
interacting system δn = χδVext
non-interacting system δnn−i = χ0δVtot
χ0 =∑ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ
∗i (r
′)φj(r′)
ω − (εi − εj)
i
unoccupied states
occupied states
j
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 25
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
interacting system δn = χδVext
non-interacting system δnn−i = χ0δVtot
m
Density Functional Formalism
δn = δnn−i
δVtot = δVext + δVH + δVxc
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 26
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
χδVext = χ0 (δVext + δVH + δVxc)
χ = χ0
(1 +
δVH
δVext+
δVxc
δVext
)δVH
δVext=
δVH
δn
δn
δVext= vχ
δVxc
δVext=
δVxc
δn
δn
δVext= fxcχ
with fxc = exchange-correlation kernel
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 27
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
χδVext = χ0 (δVext + δVH + δVxc)
χ = χ0
(1 +
δVH
δVext+
δVxc
δVext
)δVH
δVext=
δVH
δn
δn
δVext= vχ
δVxc
δVext=
δVxc
δn
δn
δVext= fxcχ
with fxc = exchange-correlation kernel
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 28
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
χδVext = χ0 (δVext + δVH + δVxc)
χ = χ0
(1 +
δVH
δVext+
δVxc
δVext
)δVH
δVext=
δVH
δn
δn
δVext= vχ
δVxc
δVext=
δVxc
δn
δn
δVext= fxcχ
χ = χ0 + χ0 (v + fxc) χwith fxc = exchange-correlation kernel
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 29
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
χδVext = χ0 (δVext + δVH + δVxc)
χ = χ0
(1 +
δVH
δVext+
δVxc
δVext
)δVH
δVext=
δVH
δn
δn
δVext= vχ
δVxc
δVext=
δVxc
δn
δn
δVext= fxcχ
χ =[1− χ0 (v + fxc)
]−1χ0
with fxc = exchange-correlation kernel
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 30
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability
χδVext = χ0 (δVext + δVH + δVxc)
χ = χ0
(1 +
δVH
δVext+
δVxc
δVext
)δVH
δVext=
δVH
δn
δn
δVext= vχ
δVxc
δVext=
δVxc
δn
δn
δVext= fxcχ
χ =[1− χ0 (v + fxc)
]−1χ0
with fxc = exchange-correlation kernel
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 31
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability χ in TDDFT
1 DFT ground-state calc. → φi , εi [Vxc ]
2 φi , εi → χ0 =∑
ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ∗
i (r′)φj (r′)
ω−(εi−εj )
3
δVH
δn= v
δVxc
δn= fxc
variation of the potentials
4 χ = χ0 + χ0 (v + fxc) χ
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 32
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability χ in TDDFT
1 DFT ground-state calc. → φi , εi [Vxc ]
2 φi , εi → χ0 =∑
ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ∗
i (r′)φj (r′)
ω−(εi−εj )
3
δVH
δn= v
δVxc
δn= fxc
variation of the potentials
4 χ = χ0 + χ0 (v + fxc) χ
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 33
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability χ in TDDFT
1 DFT ground-state calc. → φi , εi [Vxc ]
2 φi , εi → χ0 =∑
ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ∗
i (r′)φj (r′)
ω−(εi−εj )
3
δVH
δn= v
δVxc
δn= fxc
variation of the potentials
4 χ = χ0 + χ0 (v + fxc) χ
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 34
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability χ in TDDFT
1 DFT ground-state calc. → φi , εi [Vxc ]
2 φi , εi → χ0 =∑
ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ∗
i (r′)φj (r′)
ω−(εi−εj )
3
δVH
δn= v
δVxc
δn= fxc
variation of the potentials
4 χ = χ0 + χ0 (v + fxc) χ
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 35
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
Polarizability χ in TDDFT
1 DFT ground-state calc. → φi , εi [Vxc ]
2 φi , εi → χ0 =∑
ij
φi (r)φ∗j (r)φ∗
i (r′)φj (r′)
ω−(εi−εj )
3
δVH
δn= v
δVxc
δn= fxc
variation of the potentials
4 χ = χ0 + χ0 (v + fxc) χ
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 36
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
RPA and other approximations
fxc =
δVxc
δn“any” other function fxc = 0 7→ RPA
Local field effects
χ =(1− χ0v
)−1χ0 ; χ0
GG′
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 37
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
RPA and other approximations
fxc =
δVxc
δn“any” other function fxc = 0 7→ RPA
Local field effects
χ =(1− χ0v
)−1χ0 ; χ0
GG′
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 38
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Linear Response Approach
RPA and other approximations
fxc =
δVxc
δn“any” other function fxc = 0 7→ RPA
Local field effects
χ =(1− χ0v
)−1χ0 ; χ0
GG′
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 39
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Outline
1 Introduction
2 Electron Energy Loss SpectroscopyLinear response within DFT
3 Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene
4 Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 40
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Actual work at the Theoretical Spectroscopy Group
EELS of semiconductors
IXS and CIXS of semiconductors and metals
EELS of nanotubes and graphene layers
EELS and IXS of strongly correlated systems (Hf, V oxydes)
RIXS spectroscopy
User projects
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 41
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Actual work at the Theoretical Spectroscopy Group
EELS of semiconductors
IXS and CIXS of semiconductors and metals
EELS of nanotubes and graphene layers
EELS and IXS of strongly correlated systems (Hf, V oxydes)
RIXS spectroscopy
User projects
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 42
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
EELS of nanotubes: plasmon dispersion
Questions
theoretical understanding of electronic excitations of SWNTplasmon dispersion
SWNT and graphene. Strong connection and analysis
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 43
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
EELS of nanotubes: plasmon dispersion
VA-SWCNT
diameter: 2nm
nearly isolated
Kramberger, Hambach, Giorgetti, Rummeli, Knupfer, Fink, Buchner,
Reining, Einsarsson, Maruyama, Sottile, Hannewald, Olevano, Marinopoulos,
Pichler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 196803 (2008)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 44
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
EELS of nanotubes: plasmon dispersion
2nm is big!!
linear dispersionreminds us the Dirac
cone
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 45
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
EELS of nanotubes: plasmon dispersion
2nm is big!!
linear dispersionreminds us the Dirac
cone
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 46
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Numerical simulations
ab-initio calculations
DFT ground-state calculations (LDA)
Independant Particles polarizability: χ0
RPA Full polarisability: χ =[1− χ0υ
]−1χ0
Dielectric function ε−1 = 1 + vχ
energy loss function −Imε−1(q, ω)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 47
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Independent particle picture
energy loss in graphene(in-plane, q = 0.41A)
0 2 4 6 8 10energy loss (eV)
- Im
ε-1
(a
rb. u
.)
IPA =⇒ given by χ0:interpretation in terms ofband-transitions
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 48
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Independent particle picture
energy loss in graphene(in-plane, q = 0.41A)
0 2 4 6 8 10energy loss (eV)
- Im
ε-1
(a
rb. u
.)
IPAπ−π∗ at K
bandstructure
M K Γ M-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
Ene
rgie
(eV
)
π∗
π
σ
σ∗
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 49
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
RPA: random phase approx.
energy loss in graphene(in-plane, q = 0.41A)
0 2 4 6 8 10energy loss (eV)
- Im
ε-1
(a
rb. u
.)
IPAπ−π∗ at KRPA given by χ:
no interpretation byband-transitions
contributions from K
mixing of transitions
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 50
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
RPA: random phase approx.
energy loss in graphene(in-plane, q = 0.41A)
0 2 4 6 8 10energy loss (eV)
- Im
ε-1
(a
rb. u
.)
IPAπ−π∗ at KRPAwithout "K"
given by χ:no interpretation byband-transitions
contributions from K
mixing of transitions
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 51
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Plasmon dispersion
01-Im(1/ε) [arb. u.]
0
2
4
6
8
10E
nerg
y lo
ss [e
V]
0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1
momentum transfer q (1/Å)
0
2
4
6
8
10
π-pl
asm
on p
ositi
on -
Ene
rgy
(eV
)
RPAIPA
q=0.408 1/Å
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 52
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.84
5
6
7
8
9
VASWCNT
(a) Experiment
0momentum transfer q (1/Å)
4
ener
gy lo
ss (
eV)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 53
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.84
5
6
7
8
9
VASWCNT
(a) Experiment
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
graphene-1L
(b) Calculation
0momentum transfer q (1/Å)
4
ener
gy lo
ss (
eV)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 54
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.84
5
6
7
8
9
VASWCNTbulk-SWCNT
(a) Experiment
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
graphene-1L
(b) Calculation
0momentum transfer q (1/Å)
4
ener
gy lo
ss (
eV)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 55
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.84
5
6
7
8
9
VASWCNTbulk-SWCNT
(a) Experiment
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
graphene-1Lgraphene-2L
(b) Calculation
0momentum transfer q (1/Å)
4
ener
gy lo
ss (
eV)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 56
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene: Conclusions
Graphene can be studied to get quantitative information aboutVA-SWNT
Vice-versa is also true!
Bulk (bundled) nanotubes can be studied using double layer graphene
High q measurements are applicable to probe intrinsic properties ofindividual objects within bulk arrays.
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 57
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene: Conclusions
Graphene can be studied to get quantitative information aboutVA-SWNT
Vice-versa is also true!
Bulk (bundled) nanotubes can be studied using double layer graphene
High q measurements are applicable to probe intrinsic properties ofindividual objects within bulk arrays.
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 58
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene: Conclusions
Graphene can be studied to get quantitative information aboutVA-SWNT
Vice-versa is also true!
Bulk (bundled) nanotubes can be studied using double layer graphene
High q measurements are applicable to probe intrinsic properties ofindividual objects within bulk arrays.
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 59
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
SWCNT vs. Graphene: Conclusions
Graphene can be studied to get quantitative information aboutVA-SWNT
Vice-versa is also true!
Bulk (bundled) nanotubes can be studied using double layer graphene
High q measurements are applicable to probe intrinsic properties ofindividual objects within bulk arrays.
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 60
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Outline
1 Introduction
2 Electron Energy Loss SpectroscopyLinear response within DFT
3 Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene
4 Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 61
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Ab initio simulation of electronic excitations
Advantages and limits√
reliable√
predictive
× cumbersome
Actual developments in the group
multiwall nanotubes - stacking of graphene layers (1 postdoc)
towards more complex systems - strongly correlated (2 postdocs)
different spectroscopies (X-ray ?) (1 postdoc)
spatial resolution EELS (PhD thesis)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 62
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Ab initio simulation of electronic excitations
Advantages and limits√
reliable√
predictive
× cumbersome
Actual developments in the group
multiwall nanotubes - stacking of graphene layers (1 postdoc)
towards more complex systems - strongly correlated (2 postdocs)
different spectroscopies (X-ray ?) (1 postdoc)
spatial resolution EELS (PhD thesis)
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 63
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 64
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Discontinuity of the loss function
2 4 6 8 10energy loss (eV)
0
1
2
3
4
5S
(q,ω
) (1
/ keV
) 3
8/3
7/3
2
5/3
4/3
1
2/3
1/3
0
q1=0 q
3
k0
k
q
elastic inelastic
energy loss S(q, ω) ingraphite (AB)
q along c-axis
for multiple Brillouinzones
discontinuity:→ dispersion→ peak vanishes
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile
Page 65
Introduction Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy Applications: Nanotubes and Graphene Perspectives
Discontinuity of the loss function
2 4 6 8 10energy loss (eV)
0
1
2
3
4
5S
(q,ω
) (1
/ keV
) 3
8/3
7/3
2
5/3
4/3
1
2/3
1/3
0
q1=1/8 (~0.37 1/Å) q3
k0
k
q
elastic inelastic
energy loss S(q, ω) ingraphite (AB)
q along c-axis
for multiple Brillouinzones
discontinuity:→ dispersion→ peak vanishes
Ab Initio calculations of electronic excitations Francesco Sottile