Top Banner
P r o g e t t o START COCAINA VERONA CONGRESS 2006 A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine Bertoncelli Sara R egionale sulle D ipendenze sservatorio O D ipendenze sservatorio O P r o g e t t o START COCAINA COCAINA VERONA WORKSHOP 2006
43

A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

Feb 14, 2019

Download

Documents

vannhi
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

A preliminary feasibilitystudy for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine

Bertoncelli Sara

R egionale sulleD ipendenze

sservatorio O D ipendenze

sservatorio O

P r o g e t t o

STARTCO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Page 2: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006 Index

- Aim of the study- Target- Methodology- Results

Page 3: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006 General aim of the study

Preliminary processing of the data collectedthrough self-administrated questionnairesaimed at investigating:

1. acceptability2. reasons3. doubts

about anti-cocaine vaccine trial.

Page 4: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Specific objectives

1. Investigate the perception of efficacy of the anti-cocaine vaccine by professionals and cocaine users

2. Investigate trial acceptability3. Investigate reasons and doubts about joining

the trial4. Evaluate the warranties that both the targets

consider necessary in order to join the trial5. Identify the information that professionals and

cocaine users think are necessary beforejoining the trial

6. Compare the opinions of the two targets aboutsame areas of investigation

Page 5: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Target

1. Drug abuse professionals:

PhysicianPsychologistPsychiatristNurseSocial workerEducatorResearcherSociologist

2. Cocaine users

Page 6: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Methodology

Self-administration of questionnaires at thetwo target populations (drug abuseprofessionals and cocaine users) afferent thefollowing services in Italy:

1. Drug abuse services2. Therapeutical communities3. Social cooperatives4. Narcotics Anonymus (Self-help Association)

Page 7: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Enti coinvolti

ASL N. 1 Benevento - U.O.S. Dipendenze patologiche Telese TermeAS N. 4 – U.O.C. SerT CosenzaASL NA 4 - U.O. Complessa SerT di Nola distretto 73ASL N. 5 - SerT di Rivoli - Dipartimento Patologia delle Dipendenze Collegno TOASL N. 5 - Comunità Terapeutica Lucignolo & Co RivoliAS N. 7 – SerT CatanzaroAUSL N. 8 Dipartimento delle Dipendenze di SiracusaAST N. 11 – Dipartimento delle Dipendenze Reggio CalabriaULSS N. 20 Dipartimento delle Dipendenze di Verona (SerT1; SerT2; SerT3)ASL Bergamo – SerT Bergamo 2 MartinengoASL Brescia – SerT BresciaASL Como – Sert Appiano GentileASL Cremona – SerD CremaAUSL FG2 - SerT di Cerignola – Dipartimento Dipendenze PatologicheUSL Modena - SerT di Mirandola (Dipartimento di Salute Mentale - Settore

Dipendenze Patologiche)AUSL Parma – SerT di ParmaASL Varese - Dipartimento delle DipendenzeASUR zona 3 – SerT di CampobassoNarcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo aiuto

Page 8: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Areas of the questionnaire

1. Perception of efficacy of the anti-cocaine vaccine2. Importance assigned to psychological support3. Importance assigned to privacy and anonymity4. Perceived risk of the tempation of overcoming the anti-

cocaine vaccine barrier5. Perceived efficacy of a possible preventive vaccine6. Perceived problems of the controls respect7. Perception of a possible social discrimination (having to go

to the drug abuse service, positivity to anti-cocaineantibodies)

8. Acceptability of the trial 9. Reasons in favour of joining the trial10.Doubts about joining the trial11. Perception of efficacy of pharmacological therapies in the

treatment of drug abuse12.Warrenties necessary to take part in the trial13.Necessity of more information on anti-cocaine vaccine

Page 9: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Results: subjects interviewed

A total number of 344 subjects repliedto the questionnaires, amongst whom:

170 drug abuse professionals174 cocaine users

Page 10: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Cocaine users’ features

Cocaine consumers are mainly male (89,1%) and the mean age of the groupis 33 years. The mean age of the first use of cocaine is 18 years.

Gender distribution (%)

89,1

9,8 1,1

male female no answer

Page 11: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Education (%)

Employment (%)

Marital status (%)

Cocaine users’ features

5,7

49,434

5,7 5,2

primary school secondary schoolhigh school universitytraining school

60,4

23

10,94,6

1,10

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

single married separate divorced no answer

1,1 4

61,5

30,5

2,9

no answer student empolyed unemployed retired

Page 12: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Current cocaine use (%)

At present Cocaine consumers mainly don’t use cocaine or use itoccasionally (75,3%)

Cocaine users’ features

37,9 37,4

23,6

1,10

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

no use occasional continuous no answer

Page 13: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Amongst cocaine consumers currently using cocaine, 50% refer snort as mainway of taking it. To be pointed out that in these percentages are countedpeople using more than one way of taking, too.

Current way of cocaine taking (%)

Cocaine users’ features

0,6

1,7

20,7

26,4

27

50

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Intramuscolar

Oral

Inhalation

Intravenus

Smoked

Snorted

Page 14: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

26,4% of cocaine consumers refer having not use cocaine in the last 30 days

Frequency of cocaine use in the last 30 days (%)

Cocaine users’ features

24,7

9,2

19

9,2 10,9

0,6

26,4

0

10

20

30

no use 1-3 monthl y 1 weekl y mor e t i mes a

week

dai l y mor e t i mes a day no answer

Page 15: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Use of other substances in the last 30 days (%)

The more frequently substances used in the last 30 days are cannabis (29,9%) and alcohol (24,2%). To be noted that in these percentages are counted people usingmore than one substance, too. 29,9% of the sample refers not having used othersubstances.

Cocaine users’ features

1,7

2,3

2,3

2,9

2,9

20,7

21,8

24,2

29,9

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

mushrooms

ecstasy

amphetamine

buprenorphine

benzodiazepine

methadone

heroine

alcohol

cannabis

Page 16: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Treatments in the past 12 months (%)

Treatments in the past (%)

Cocaine users’ features

58

39,1

2,9

yes no no answer

37,9

9,25,2 4,66,3

36,8

0

5

10

1520

25

30

35

40

one none more thanthree

two no answer three

Page 17: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Type of treatment in the last 12 months (%)

Cocaine users’ features

1,7

10,3

14,9

25,9

32,8

8,6

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

No answer

Other

Sel f -help

Phar maco/ psycho

Psychological

Phar macological

The therapy most frequently referred in the last year is the pharmacologicaltreatment (32,8%), followed by the psychological one (25,9%). People whohave referred more than one treatment are also included in the calculationof the percentages. 36,8% have not been submitted to treatment in the previous 12 months.

Page 18: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Professionals’ features

Gender distribution (%)

Professionals’ mean age is 45 years

Marital Status (%)

Working agency (%)

35,3

64,1

0,6

male female no answer

71,2

15,9

5,9 2,9 2,91,2

married single separate

divorced no answ er w idow ed

94,1

4,7 0,6 0,60

20

40

60

80

100

sert rehabilitationcentre

socialcooperative

no answerr

Page 19: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Profession (%)

Years of Operativeness (%)

1,8

2,2

2,4

4,7

12,4

13,5

15,9

22,4

24,7

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

psychiatrist

no answer

researcher

sociologist

educator

social worker

psychologist

nurse

physician

2,3

5,3

12,4

12,9

17,1

23,5

26,5

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

no answer

less than 1 ys

more than 20 ys

from 1 to 5 ys

from 16 to 20 ys

from 6 to 10 ys

from 11 to 16 ys

Professionals’ features

Page 20: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006 Perception of efficacy (%)

According to most consumers and professionals (59,8% and 87% respectively) the anti-cocaine vaccine for the cocaine addiction treatment can be useful only if associated with psychological support.

1,8 0,6 3,514,4

5,2 2,9

17,76,5

87,6

59,8

0

20

40

60

80

100

Useful alone too Useful only withpsychological

support

Irrelevant anyway Demaging Hesitating

Professionals Users

Page 21: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006 Perception of vaccine benefit (1)

Overcoming drug-abuse (%)

37,154,662,9

45,4

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no

Professionals Users Reducing craving (%)

62,437,6

54,645,4

020406080

100

yes no

Professionals Users

Page 22: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

17,27,1

92,982,8

0

2040

6080

100

yes noProfessionals Users

Preventing relapse (%)

Preventing overdose (%)

55,3 44,732,8

67,2

020406080

100

yes noProfessionals Users

The question included the possibility to provide more replies on the vaccine utility. 3,5% of professionals and 12,6% of users replied “I don’t know”.

Perception of vaccine benefit (2)

Page 23: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

21,2

4,1 0,6 1,2

64,4

20,1

5,20,6

9,7

72,9

0

20

40

60

80

Alwaysassociat ed

can beassociat ed

no necessary not t o beassociat ed

Hesit at ing

professionals Users

Association of the vaccine with psychological support (%)

Users and professionals confirm the necessity to associate the vaccine withpsychological support in order to make it effective.

Page 24: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

82,9

6,5

77,6

810,6 14,4

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no Hesitating

Professionals Users

Necessity of complete anonymity (%)

According to users and professionals it is necessary to guarantee the anonymity during the trial.

Page 25: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

64,7

25,3

64,4

20,1 15,510

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no hesitating

Professionals Users

Risk of overcomingthe vaccine barrier (%)

According to most users and professionals, many would try to overcome the barrier of the blocking effect of the vaccine by taking higher doses of cocaine.

Page 26: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Perception of the efficacy of a possiblepreventive vaccine (%)

24,7

50

25,3

37,440,8

21,8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

yes no hesitating

Professionals Users

The majority of both the groups think that vaccinating people at risk whohave never used cocaine is ineffective in order to avoid the use in the future. Yet, it must be pointed out that a high percentage is not sure and that users are in favour of the preventive vaccine (37,4%).

Page 27: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

24,7

50

25,3

37,440,8

21,8

0

20

40

60

80

yes no hesitat ing

Professionals Users

Controls too demanding? (%)

Both the groups think that being submitted to weekly periodical controlsduring the trial isn’t too demanding for the patients.

Page 28: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

40,6

58,8

0,6

46,6 45,4

8

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no hesitating

Professionals Users

60,6

35,9

3,5

27

62,1

10,9

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no hesitating

Professionals Users

Possible risk of social discrimination (%)

Fear of discriminationas obstacle to partecipation (%)

Risk of social discrimination? (%)

Page 29: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Anti-cocaine antibodies positivityas a problem? (%)

37,6

8,3

55,8

14,9

54,1

29,3

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no hesitatingProfessionals Users

55,3

3843,6

18,4

31,8

12,9

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no hesitating

Professionals Users

Anti-cocaine antibodies positivity as a problem (%)

Anti-cocaine antibodies positivity as obstacleto partecipation (%)

Page 30: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

76,4

8,315,3

57,5

23 19,5

0

20

40

60

80

100

yes no hesitating

Professionals Users

Acceptability of the trial (%)

76,4% of the professionals would suggest to a close person the partecipationin the cocaine vaccine trials. 57,5% of the users would be willing to beenrolled. To be pointed out the high percentage of hesitation amongst users(19,5%).

Page 31: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

0,8

1,5

1,5

2,7

3,8

4,6

5,4

6,9

7,7

9,2

15,4

19,9

26,1

27,7

38,5

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

It's not def ini tive

A good motivation

Anonymity

None

Scienti f ic data on ef f icacy

Fai lure of pr evious tr eatment

Overcoming drug-abuse

Preventing r isks connected to cocaine use

Receiving also a psychological suppor t

Saf ety/ Toler abi l i ty of vaccine

Improving Quali ty of l i f e

No answer

Testing drug-f r ee state

It's the only pharmacological therapy

Blocking cocaine ef f ects

Reasons pro-trial by professionals (%)

Amongst professionals who have expressed a positive opinion towards trials, the three mostfrequent reasons are: the action of the vaccine which contrasts the effects of the cocaine, reinforcing the reason for not using it (38,5%); the fact that is the only therapy available forthe treatment of cocaine dependence and that could be effective; at last the possibility of reaching a drug free state. Each professional can have expressed more favourable reasons.

Page 32: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

2

2

3

5

6

9

10

10

12

13

19

43

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50

None

No Answer

Saving money

Not having alternative

Preventing / reducing craving

Knowing not to perceive effects

Preventing risks connected to cocaine use

Having an help/feeling more sure

Testing its efficacy

Having the security not to relapse

Change life

Overcoming drug-abuse

Reasons pro-trial by consumers (%)

Amongst users who have expressed a positive opinion towards the trials, the mostfrequent reason is to be able to overcome drug dependence (43%), followed by the hopeto change life and recover the important relations (19%). Each user can have expressedmore reasons pro-trial.

Page 33: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

7,1

14,3

35,7

64,3

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

No answer

None

Risks for physical health

It's still a trial/uncertainty

Doubts of the professionals on the partecipation to trial (%)

Amongst professionals who have expressed a negative opinion towards the trial the most frequent doubt is the uncertainty of the experimental phase(64,3%), followed by the fear for the health risks (35,7%).

Page 34: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

2,5

2,5

5

7,5

7,5

10

10

10

10

12,5

17,5

17,5

17,5

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

Fear of overdose

All

Not sure about wanting to stop use

None

Risks for physical health

Fear about not stopping of complusion to use

No answer

Doubts about its efficacy

Temptation to overcome vaccine barrier

Wanting to use cocaine

Fear of social discrimination

I don't need vaccine

It's still a trial/uncertainty

Doubts of the consumers on the partecipation to trial (%)

Amongst users who have expressed a negative opinion towards the trial, the most frequentdoubts are (17,5%): the uncertainty associated with the trial phase; the perception of being able to manage without the vaccine and the fear of being discovered, discriminatedand of having legal problems for the positivity at anti-cocaine antibodies.

Page 35: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

59,4

26,5

1,8 2,47,6

2,4

59,8

8,6 7,52,3

20,1

1,7

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Suggested Enoughsuggested

Not suggested Less suggested Hesitating No answer

Suggestion of pharmacological therapiesfor drug abuse

The use of pharmacological therapies is suggested for the treatment of drug abuse both by most of professionals (59,4%) and users (59,8%).

Page 36: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Warrenties necessary to take part in the trialby professionals (mean value)

Level of importanceMin Max

3,3

3,5

3,8

3,9

3,9

4

4

4,2

4,4

1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5 4 4,5 5

Anonymity

Information about social effects

Insurance cover

Information about psychological effects

Efficacy

Privacy

Psychological care

Information about physical effects

Medical care

Professionals retain necessary warrenties to take part in the trial givingpatiences medical and psychological care and clear information about physicalhealth.

Page 37: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

3,7

3,7

4

4,1

4,3

4,3

4,5

4,6

4,7

1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5 4 4,5 5

Information about social effects

Anonymity

Privacy

Insurance cover

Efficacy

Psychological care

Medical care

Information about psychological effects

Information about physical effects

Min Max

Level of importance

Warrenties necessary to take part in the trialby users (mean value)

Users retain necessary warrenties to take part in the trial receiving clearinformation about physical and psychological health and having a medical and psychological care.

Page 38: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Necessity of other information (%)

5045,9

4,1

41,4

56,9

1,70

10

20

30

40

50

60

Yes No No answer

Professionals Users

Page 39: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

0,6

0,6

0,6

1,2

1,8

1,8

2,9

2,9

3,5

10

12,4

37,1

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

Pr eventive vaccination

Avai labi l i ty of Ig anti-cocaine f or over dose

Over coming vaccine bar r ier

Atti tude of the Minister y of health

Use of other substance as an alter native to cocaine

Psychological ef f ects

N of possible administr ations/ r isks

Pr of essional tr aining

Vaccine inter actions with other dr ugs

Physical health r isks

Futur e tr ial pr otocol

Pr evious exper imentation data

Professionals: necessary information

Amongst the information that the professionals consider missing and necessary, at first place there are the scientific data on previous trials, followed by more details on future trial protocol and on the health risks.

Page 40: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

2,9

4

4

5,2

5,7

16,1

19

19,5

0 5 10 15 20 25

Legal impl ication of anti-cocaineantibodies positive r esults

Over dose r isk

Psychological ef f ects

Par tecipation detai ls

Vaccine composition

Ef f icacy data

Closer detai ls

Physical ef f ects

Users think it is necessary to receive more information on health risks, a generaldeepening, more data on previous trials and on direct experiences of the vaccine efficacy.

Consumers: necessary information

Page 41: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Conclusions (1)

1. The acceptability of the anti-cocaine vaccine trial is high both byprofessionals and cocaine users. The three most frequent reasons pro-trial by professionals are: the action of the vaccine which contrasts the effects of the cocaine, reinforcing the reason for not using it; the factthat is the only therapy available for the treatment of cocainedependence and that could be effective; at last the possibility of reachinga drug free state. Amongst users who have expressed a positive opinion towards the trial, the most frequent reasons are: being able to overcomedrug dependence, followed by the hope to change life and recoverimportant relationships. Both refer as main reason fon not acceptabilityof the trial the uncertainty connected to the experimental phase of the vaccine;

2. The utility of the anti-cocaine vaccine is referred by both the tragets in reaching and maintining a drug-free state (overcoming dependence) and preventing relapse;

3. According to most consumers and professionals the anti-cocaine vaccine, for the cocaine addiction treatment, can be useful and effective only ifassociated with psychological support which remain indispensable;

Page 42: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

Conclusions (2)

4. The questionnaire has also permitted to identify doubts and fears aboutthe trial, in order to give clearer and specific information in the future, making easier the process of decison making;

5. In detail, professionals and cocaine users think it is necessary to receivemore data on previous experimentations (efficacy, safety, tolerability, number of subjects involved, risk of overcoming the vaccine barrier, interactions with other drugs, use of other substances in alternative of cocaine, etc) and on the future trial protocol (admission criteria, duration, place of trial, etc);

6.6. FearFear of social of social discriminationdiscrimination by cocaine users is one of the main reasonfor the unacceptability of the trial (for example: going to a drug abuseservice for the administration of the vaccine; legal implications for the positivity at anti-cocaine antibodies), thus is to be considered with greatattention;

7. Finally, it is necessary to give a clear information about the anti-cocainevacccine mechanism of action, in order to improve its efficacy and toreduce unreal expectations on “magic” solution of the dependence onlythanks to having been vaccinated.

Page 43: A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti ... · A preliminary feasibility study for the trial of anti-cocaine vaccine ... Narcotici Anonimi - Associazione di auto-mutuo

P r o g e t t o

STARTC

OC

AIN

AVERO

NA C

ON

GRESS 2

006

CO

CA

INA

CO

CAIN

AVERO

NA W

ORKSH

OP

2006

THANKS THANKS THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTIONFOR YOUR ATTENTIONFOR YOUR ATTENTION