A National Comparison of Laparoscopic versus Open Colectomy Using NSQIP

Spectrum Health

1

A National Comparison of Laparoscopic versus Open Colectomy Using NSQIP

Anthony J Senagore M.D, M.S., M.B.A.VP/CAO, Spectrum Health

Professor of Surgery, Michigan State UniversityGrand Rapids, MI

Spectrum Health

Anxiety About Health Care ($$)

Employers: premiums growing at 2-3x wages; affecting profits and competitiveness

Consumers: higher out-of-pocket costs keeping real wage growth down; fear of losing insurance; lack of information for confident decisions

Insurers: pressure from employer customers to control rising costs

Doctors and Hospitals: Medicare reimbursement rates; administrative challenges of data collection, performance measurement and reporting

Spectrum Health

Spectrum Health

Defining Value

Risk Adjusted Comparison Outcomes defined Resource Consumption Transparency of Reporting

Hospital/Physician Comparison Informed Consent

Spectrum Health

Complex Interactions:Quality

Hospital Systems Diagnostic Equipment/access Staffing OR equipment

Operative Technique Postoperative Care

Preoperative Evaluation/Optimization Enhanced Recovery Protocols Post-Discharge care plans

Spectrum Health

Sources of Surgical Cost

Hospital Issues Beds Personnel OR’s Diagnostic

equipment

Doctor Issues # admissions/ LOS Complications Case volume/mix Duration of Surgery Equipment used Tests ordered Readmissions

Spectrum Health

Potential Administrative Data Sources

CMS National Inpatient Census

Premier ACS-NSQIP Surgical Risk Formulae

Spectrum Health

What is NSQIP

30 day observational database Trained and audited nurse evaluators 121 sites in the US (academic and

community hospitals)

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Model vs Others

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open

Kennedy et al. Ann Surg 2009;249: 596–601

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open

Kennedy et al. Ann Surg 2009;249: 596–601

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open

Kennedy et al. Ann Surg 2009;249: 596–601

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open

Kennedy et al. Ann Surg 2009;249: 596–601

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open

Kennedy et al. Ann Surg 2009;249: 596–601

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open: Outcomes

Senagore et al. DCR 2009 52: 183-6

Spectrum Health

NSQIP Lap v Open: ? cohorts

Senagore et al. DCR 2009 52: 183-6

Spectrum Health

Departmental length of stay1991-19991991-1999 19991999 3-6/2000 3-6/2000

nn LOSLOS nn LOSLOS nn LOSLOS

DRG 148DRG 148study team study team 17841784 9.59.5 185185 8.68.6 6262 5.7 *5.7 *other CR teamsother CR teams 64596459 9.89.8 824824 8.88.8 162162 10.110.1LaparoscopicLaparoscopic 2424 3.2 *3.2 *

DRG 149DRG 149study teamstudy team 742742 6.46.4 6969 5.25.2 4444 3.5 †3.5 †other CR teamsother CR teams 22562256 6.46.4 327327 5.15.1 111111 4.54.5LaparoscopicLaparoscopic 1818 2.5 *2.5 *

DRG 148 & 149DRG 148 & 149study teamstudy team 25262526 8.68.6 254254 7.77.7 106106 4.7 4.7 §§other CR teamsother CR teams 87158715 8.98.9 11511151 7.77.7 273273 7.77.7LaparoscopicLaparoscopic 4242 2.92.9 **

* * pp<0.0001; † <0.0001; † pp=0.002; =0.002; §§ pp<0.001, Student’s t test<0.001, Student’s t test

Delaney, Fazio, Senagore et al, Br J Surg, 2001

Spectrum Health

The Future ??

Spectrum Health

Conclusion

Belief in a system approach Align stakeholder incentives Understanding Cost/Quality Impacts Report OUR Value Proposition