Top Banner
A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen , Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH GROUP ELECTROMAGNETICS
33

A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

Apr 15, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND

INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS

Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste

DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY

RESEARCH GROUP ELECTROMAGNETICS

Page 2: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

OUTLINE

• Motivation

• Proposed technique

• Examples

• Conclusions

2

Page 3: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

OUTLINE

• Motivation

• Proposed technique

• Examples

• Conclusions

3

Page 4: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

MOTIVATION

Smaller & faster electronics

New solutions such as 3-D ICs

4

Increasing complexity,

functionality,

power constraints, …

signal integrity,

Page 5: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

MOTIVATION

Many challenges

Rigorous modeling increasingly essential !

5

Heat distribution Signal integrity (crosstalk, dispersion, distortion, …)

Page 6: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROBLEM STATEMENT

- Finite conductivity, skin effect, proximity effect

difficult to model broadband

- Solved in 2-D [1, 2] using a Dirichlet-to-Neumann operator

- Open question in 3-D

- Recently proposed for 3-D cylinders and cuboids [3, 4]

6

[1] D. De Zutter and L. Knockaert, IEEE MTT, vol. 53, pp. 2526-2538 (2005)

[2] T. Demeester and D. De Zutter, IEEE MTT, vol. 56, pp. 1649-1660 (2008)

[3] M. Huynen, M. Gossye, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, IEEE AWPL, vol. 16, pp. 1052-1055 (2017)

[4] M. Huynen, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, accepted for IEEE MWCL

Page 7: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

OUTLINE

• Motivation

• Proposed technique

• Examples

• Conclusions

7

Page 8: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

8

Original situation

Field equivalence principle

Equivalent situation

Page 9: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

9

Electric field integral equation

Test and basis functions

Page 10: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

10

Discretization

Page 11: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

11

Discretization

Page 12: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

12

Discretization

Page 13: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

13

Discretization

Via partial integration:

Average potential

on each rectangle

Page 14: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

14

Circuit interpretation

Still 2 sets of unknowns:

-

-

Page 15: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

15

3-D Dirichlet-to-Neumann operator [3, 4]

[3] M. Huynen, M. Gossye, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, IEEE AWPL, vol. 16, pp. 1052-1055 (2017)

[4] M. Huynen, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, accepted at IEEE MWCL

Differential surface admittance operator

Page 16: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

16

Normalization of

Magnetic eigenfunctions ofWavenumber of

Page 17: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

17

Discretization

Page 18: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

PROPOSED TECHNIQUE

18

Circuit interpretation

Only 1 set of unknowns left:

-

Page 19: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

OUTLINE

• Motivation

• Proposed technique

• Examples

• Conclusions

19

Page 20: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: PARALLEL CONDUCTORS

20

Normalized resistance = total resistance (3-D) / length

Pouillet DC resistance

Proximity effect fan out

Page 21: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: PARALLEL CONDUCTORS

21

Normalized inductance

[1] D. De Zutter and L. Knockaert, IEEE MTT, vol. 53, pp. 2526-2538 (2005)

Increasing length 2-D results

Page 22: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RIGHT-ANGLED CORNER

22

right-angled corner cuboid

Page 23: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RIGHT-ANGLED CORNER

23

right-angled corner

Page 24: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RIGHT-ANGLED CORNER

24

Proximity effect crossover

Resistance

Finite difference method (FDM) DC value

Page 25: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RECTANGULAR LOOP

25

Page 26: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RECTANGULAR LOOP

26

[5] U. R. Patel, S. V. Hum and P. Triverio, IEEE 21st Workshop on SPI, pp. 1-4 (May 2017)

Resistance

Confirmation of rigorous modeling

of 3-D effects

Page 27: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RECTANGULAR LOOP

27

[5] U. R. Patel, S. V. Hum and P. Triverio, IEEE 21st Workshop on SPI, pp. 1-4 (May 2017)

Inductance

Faulty meshing unphysical kink

Page 28: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RECTANGULAR LOOP

28

Resistance

Smaller loop stronger proximity effect

Page 29: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

EXAMPLE: RECTANGULAR LOOP

29

Inductance

Page 30: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

OUTLINE

• Motivation

• Proposed technique

• Examples

• Conclusions

30

Page 31: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

CONCLUSIONS

Novel 3-D interconnect modeling tool Based on BIE (without volume meshing)

Fully 3-D differential surface admittance operator

31

Validation and applications Application to PCB and IC interconnect structures

Accurate modeling of corners

Broadband extraction of R- and L-parameters

Thoroughly compared to industry standards

⇒ Rigorous approach for skin effect, proximity effect, etc. in 3-D

interconnects

Page 32: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

FURTHER READING

2-D:D. De Zutter and L. Knockaert, “Skin effect modeling based on a differential surface admittance operator”, IEEE MTT, vol. 53, pp. 2526-

2538 (2005)

T. Demeester and D. De Zutter, “Quasi-TM Transmission Line Parameters of Coupled Lossy Lines Based on the Dirichlet to Neumann

Boundary Operator”, IEEE MTT, vol. 56, pp. 1649-1660 (2008)

3-D:M. Huynen, M. Gossye, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, “A 3-D Differential Surface Admittance Operator for Lossy Dipole Antenna

Analysis”, IEEE AWPL, vol. 16, pp. 1052-1055 (2017)

M. Huynen, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, “Boundary integral equation study of the influence of finite conductivity on antenna

radiation using a 3-D differential surface admittance operator”, ACES Symposium - Italy (March 2017)

M. Huynen, D. De Zutter and D. Vande Ginste, “Rigorous full-wave resistance and inductance computation of 3-D interconnects”,

accepted at IEEE MWCL

32

Page 33: A FULLY 3-D BIE EVALUATION OF THE RESISTANCE AND ...€¦ · INDUCTANCE OF ON-BOARD AND ON-CHIP INTERCONNECTS Martijn Huynen, Daniël De Zutter, Dries Vande Ginste DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION

Martijn HuynenPhD student

ELECTROMAGNETICS GROUP

E [email protected]

T +32 9 331 48 81

www.ugent.be

www.imec.be

Universiteit Gent

@ugent

Ghent University