A DISSERTATION REPORT On RETAIL BANKING STRATEGIES INVERTIS INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, BAREILLY 2011 DECLARATION I, PRABHAT KUMAR do hereby declare that the Dissertation report titled: “RETAIL BANKING STRATEGIES” Is a genuine research work undertaken by me and it has not been published anywhere earlier. It has been completed under the guidance of Mrs. Rachna Sexena (Faculty), IIMS Bareilly. Date: Place: (PRABHAT KUMAR)
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
A DISSERTATION REPORT
On
RETAIL BANKING STRATEGIES
INVERTIS INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, BAREILLY
2011
DECLARATION
I, PRABHAT KUMAR do hereby declare that the Dissertation report titled:
“RETAIL BANKING STRATEGIES”
Is a genuine research work undertaken by me and it has not been published anywhere earlier.
It has been completed under the guidance of Mrs. Rachna Sexena (Faculty), IIMS Bareilly.
Date:
Place:
(PRABHAT KUMAR)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Every work requires a diligent effort not only on the part of the person directly involved in
the successful completion of the work but also the ones who are willing to help and
guidance. In the same regards, I would like to thank my Faculty Guide, Mrs. Rachna
Sexena who has been a constant support in the working of the project.
Furthermore, I would like to express my gratitude to the employees of ICICI Bank who
helped me towards the successful completion of this dissertation and without whose help,
the completion of this report would not have been possible.
(PRABHAT KUMAR)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 1: Introduction
Introduction to Retail Banking
Chapter 2: Objectives and Methodology
Chapter 3: Case- ICICI Bank
Distribution Strategies
Product centric Strategies
ICICI Branding
Chapter 4: Innovations by other banks
Savings Account
Home Loans
Credit Cards
Auto Loans
Chapter 5: Customer Preference Survey
Recommendations
Chapter 6: Conclusion
Chapter 7: Executive Summary
Chapter 8: References
Annexure: Question Savings Account
Home Loans
Credit Cards
Auto Loans
Chapter 5: Customer Preference Survey
Recommendations
Chapter 6: Conclusion
naire
INTRODUCTION
Retail Banking
Retail banking is typical mass-market banking where individual customers use local
branches of larger commercial banks. Services offered include: savings and checking
accounts, mortgages, personal loans, debit cards, credit cards, and so forth.
Before Internet era, consumers largely selected their banks based on how convenient the
location of bank’s branches was to their homes or offices. With the Advent of new
technologies in the business of bank, such as Internet banking and ATMs, now customers
can freely chose any bank for their transactions. Thus the customer base of banks has
increased, and so has the choices of customers for selecting the banks.
This is just the beginning of the story. Due to globalization a new generation of private
sector banks and many foreign banks have also entered the market and they have
brought with them several useful and innovative products. Due to forced competition,
public sector banks are also becoming more technology savvy and customer oriented.
GROWTH IN RETAIL BANKING
Bankers have been increasingly shifting focus to retail banking to increase profitability
and reduce delinquency rates. Customer shifting, cost pressure and increased
competition are some of the reasons for this shift in focus. Retailing is now favored
because of better norms, lesser asset quality problem and low NPA. Further it offers
many opportunities and potential for credit expansion.
The size of the retail market is Rs 50,000 crore which includes credit card spending of
Rs10,000 crore. The markets for the other goods are Housing loan at Rs 25,000 crore
(30% CAGR), Personal Loan at Rs 4000 crore (10-15% CAGR) and auto loans at
Rs75,000 crore (5% CAGR)
Moreover, Non-traditional competition, market consolidation, new technology, and the
proliferation of the Internet are changing the competitive landscape of the retail banking
industry. Today’ retail banking sector is characterized by following:
•Multiple products (deposits, credit cards, insurance, investments and
securities)
•Multiple channels of distribution (call center, branch, Internet and kiosk)
•Multiple customer groups (consumer, small business, and corporate)
Today, the customers have many expectations from bank such as
(i) Service at reduced cost
(ii) Service “Anytime Anywhere”
(iii) Personalized Service
With increased number of banks, products and services and practically nil switching
costs, customers are easily switching banks whenever they find better services and
products. Banks are finding it tough to get new customers and more importantly retain
existing customers.
According to a research by Reichheld and Sasser in the Harvard Business Review,
5% increase in customer retention can increase profitability by 35% in banking
business, 50% in insurance and brokerage, and 125% in the consumer credit card
market. Therefore banks are now stressing on retaining customers and increasing
market share.
What do the banks need ?
The banks now need to find out what to sell, whom to sell, when to sell, how to sell
and how to be different to increase profitability.
Banks need to differentiate themselves by adding value-added service, offerings and
building long-term relationships with their customers through more customized products,
enhanced value offerings, personalized services and increased accessibility. Banks also
need to identify customers and products that would be most profitable and target
customers with products that are most appropriate to their needs and serve the
customers with greater cost efficiency.
Banks also need to find out the avenues for increased customer satisfaction, which leads
to increased customer loyalty. This may be explained better from two initiatives bank took
in the past:
1. Earlier what drove many bankers to invest in ATMs was the promise of reduced
branch cost, since customers would use them instead of a branch to transact
business. But what was discovered is that the financial impact of ATMs is a
marginal increase in fee income substantially offset by the cost of significant
increases in the number of customer transactions. The value proposition, however,
was a significant increase in that intangible called customer satisfaction. The
increase in customer satisfaction has translated to loyalty that resulted in higher
customer retention and growing franchise value.
2. Bankers invested in Internet banking, believing that the Internet was a lower-cost
delivery channel and a way to increase sales. Studies have now shown, however,
that the primary value of offering Internet banking services lies in the increased
retention of highly valued customer segments. Again customer satisfaction drives
the value proposition.
Thus, banks need to retain existing customers with enhanced personalized services and
products, which best suits their needs and satisfies them the most.
Potential for Retail in India: Is sky the limit?
The Indian players are bullish on the Retail business and this is not totally unfounded.
There are two main reasons behind this.
Firstly, it is now undeniable that the face of the Indian consumer is changing. This is
reflected in a change in the urban household income pattern. The direct fallout of such a
change will be the consumption patterns and hence the banking habits of Indians, which
will now be skewed towards Retail products.
At the same time, India compares pretty poorly with the other economies of the world
that are now becoming comparable in terms of spending patterns with the opening up of
our economy. For instance, while the total outstanding Retail loans in Taiwan is around
41% of GDP, the figure in India stands at less than 5%. The comparison with the West is
even more staggering. Another comparison that is natural when comparing Retail sectors
is the use of credit cards. Here also, the potential lies in the fact that of all the consumer
expenditure in India in 2001, less than 1% was through plastic, the corresponding US
figure standing at 18%.
But how competitive are the players?
The fact that the statistics reveal a huge potential also brings with it a threat that is true for
any sector of a country that is opening up. Just how competitive are our banks? Is the
threat of getting drubbed by foreign competition real? To analyze this, one needs to get
into the shoes of the foreign banks.
Going by international standards, a large portion of the Indian population is simply not
“bankable” – taking profitability into consideration. On the other hand, the financial
services market is highly over-leveraged in India.
Competition is fierce, particularly from local private banks such as HDFC and ICICI, in the
business of home, car and consumer loans.
There, precisely lie the pitfalls of such explosive growth. All banks are targeting the
fluffiest segment i.e. the upwardly mobile urban salaried class. Although the players are
spreading their operations into segments like self- employed and the semi-urban rich, it is
an open secret that the big city Indian yuppies form the most profitable segment. Over-
dependence on this segment is bound to bring in inflexibility in the business.
What about the foreign giants?
The foreign banks have identified this problem but there are certain systematic risks
involved in operating in the Retail market for them. These include regulatory restrictions
that prevent them from expanding their branch network. So these banks often take the
Direct Selling Agent (DSA) route whereby low-end jobs like sourcing or transaction
processing are outsourced to small regional layers. So now on, when you see a loan
mela or a road show showcasing the retail bouquet of an elite MNC giant, you know that a
significant commission earned out of any such booking gets ploughed back to our own
economy. Perhaps, one of the biggest impediments in foreign players leveraging the
Indian markets is the absence of positive credit bureaus.
In the west the risk profile can be easily mapped to things like SSNs and this information
can be publicly traded. PAN is a step in this direction but lot more work need to be done.
What has been a positive step towards this is a negative file sharing started by a
consortium of 11 banks. However, as a McKinsey study points out actual write-offs on
NPAs show a strong negative correlation with sharing of positive information. On top of
this, the spend-now-pay-later “credit culture” in India is just not picking up. A swift legal
procedure against consumers creating bad debt is virtually nonexistent.
Finally, the vast geographical and cultural diversity of the country makes credit policy
formulation a tough job and it simply cannot be dictated from a Wall Street or a Singapore
boardroom! All these add up to the unattractiveness of the Indian retail market to the
foreign players.
So over the past few years, in spite of the entry of MNCs in many industries, Retail
Banking has seen a flurry of panicky exits. Fewer than 40 remain in India and their share
of total bank assets currently 7.2% is falling. Those that remain might be thought to be
likely buyers of Indian banks.
Yet Citibank, HSBC and Standard Chartered—all in India for more than a century, and
with relatively large retail networks—seem to have no pressing need to acquire a local
bank.
Established foreign banks have preferred to take over customers or businesses from
other
foreign banks that want to leave. Thus HSBC, in recent years, has acquired customers
from France's BNP, Germany's Deutsche Bank and Japan's Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi.
ABN Amro took over Bank of America's retail business.
So all for the keeping then?
This will perhaps be the most wrongful inference that can be drawn from the above. We
just cannot afford to look inwards and repeat the mistakes that were the side effects of the
nationalization of the Banking System. A growing market can never be an alibi for lack of
innovation. Indian banks have shown little or no interest in innovative tailor-made
products. They have often tried to copy process designs that have been tested, albeit
successfully, in the West.
Each economic culture has its own traits and one who successfully adapts those to the
business is the eventual winner. A case in point is the successful implementation of
micro-credit networks in Bangladesh. Positioning a bank as a tech-savvy financial vendor
in a country where Internet penetration is an abysmal 1.65% can only add to the over-
leveraging as pointed out earlier. The focus of the sector should remain in
macroeconomic wealth creation and not increasing the per capita indebtedness that will
do little but add to the NPA burden. Retail Banking in India has to be developed in the
Indian way, notwithstanding the long queues in front of the teller counter in the SBI Joka
branch.
NEW PRIVATE BANKS: STRATEGY PAYING OFF
In the words of Chanda Kochchar, Executive Director, ICICI Bank “ Fast growth in retail is
not because of sheer passion for numbers, Rather, it’s the result of strategic thinking.”
•Push retail growth by upping market shares and tapping new customers.
•Lower credit risk by tighter controls and better analysis
•Leverage balance sheet strength and strong corporate relationships
•Follow the customer worldwide and build scalable model for global rollout.
I. PUSH RETAIL GROWTH BY UPPING MARKET SHARES AND
TAPPING NEW CUSTOMERS.
The key dimensions of ICICI’s retail strategy for increasing its market share are:
•Innovative products
•Parity pricing
•Customer convenience through a vast range of delivery channels.
•Operational efficiencies, strong processes and customer focus.
•Cross-selling of the entire range of credit and investment products and banking
services to existing customers is a critical aspect of our retail strategy.
Since initial investments are high in Retail, fast growth and thereby economies of scale
help ICICI make profits much earlier. And today, the bank’s incremental retail business is
30% the size of the industry and its operating costs are said to be among the lowest.
While the distribution network enables the bank to add numbers, stringent credit practices
help control quality and robust back office and use of technology help improve
efficiencies.
OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCIES
If the bank is adding 10,000 new customers everyday and if a customer does 70 to 75
transactions per year, then the bank must run an assembly- line like operation to process
transactions. Incredibly ICICI actually does it.
Hub And Spoke Model
ICICI employs a hub-and-spoke model to improve its operational efficiencies. It has set up
a centralized back office and 18 regional back offices (so called “factories” by the bank) to
do account opening, mailing of account statements, issuing of credit cards and ATM
cards, cheque books etc.
For instance, to process more than one crore cheques a month, which the bank does, the
cheques are scanned at the regional hubs. That helps speed up the process without
adding more employees.
Impressively the bank’s team actually studies assembly line operations and shopfloor
operations of manufacturing companies like Ford and Hyundai Motor to improve the
turnaround time.
Standardization Of Processes
In ICICI bank, although distribution is decentralized, risk control is centralized. Credit is
separate from sales, which means while the sales team is responsible for getting new
business, it is the credit team working on the central credit policy, which approves or
rejects customer acquisitions.
In case of mortgages, there is a structured field investigation process to check on the
legal documents and property valuation. All that helps to keep a close watch on retail
credit quality and explains why the bank’s retail net NPA is 0.75%.
Since the processes are standardized, they are not just scalable but also replicated
across functions. For instance, earlier when a customer applied to open an account, a
three- week waiting period was involved. IN that time, his cheque book, ATM card and pin
number would arrive in seven separate envelopes, because the process was manual.
Adopting a “straight through” processing system lowered the waiting time to five days and
reduced the mail load to one envelope. Starting a few months ago, customers are now
given a pre-printed welcome kit when they open an account and the cards are activated
the next day.
Besides, every quarter, the bank projects the increase in customer base and transactions
for the next quarter and accordingly increases its backoffice bandwidth.
CUSTOMER SERVICE STRATEGY
ICICI has the special account called “Value Added Savings Account:. Under this, if the
customer has more than Rs10,000 balance in his savings bank account that excess will
be transferred to Value Added Savings Account.
From that day onwards, he will be given fixed deposit interest rate on the remaining
balancr. As same as HDFC bank deposits, no entry load or exit load will be charged on
customers. Moreover customers can have access to ICICI Direct.com for share trading.
Besides it is offering various Tax saving schemes namely ICICI pension plan, ICICI
Safety bond, Tax Saving mutual fund schemes and so on.
PRODUCTS
During fiscal 2003, ICICI had continued their focus on retail deposits. This has reduced
funding cost and has enabled them to create a stable funding base, with over 4.7 million
deposit customers. Following a life stage segmentation strategy, ICICI Bank offers
differentiated liability products to various categories of customers depending on
their age group.
For e.g.: Young Star Accounts for children below the age of 18 years, Student Banking
Services for students.
As the leading provider of retail financial services, we are constantly striving to provide
products and services that enable customers to fulfill their financial requirements.
II. LOWER CREDIT RISK BY TIGHTER CONTROLS AND BETTER
ANALYSIS
While the distribution network enables the bank to add numbers, stringent credit practices
help control quality and robust back office and use of technology help improve
efficiencies.
In ICICI bank, although distribution is decentralized, risk control is centralized. Credit is
separate from sales, which means while the sales team is responsible for getting new
business, it is the credit team working on the central credit policy, which approves or
rejects customer acquisitions.
In case of mortgages, there is a structured field investigation process to check on the
legal documents and property valuation. All that helps to keep a close watch on retail
credit quality and explains why the bank’s retail net NPA is 0.75%.
III. FOLLOW THE CUSTOMER WORLDWIDE AND BUILD SCALABLE
MODEL FOR GLOBAL ROLLOUT.
To diversify risk across geographies, the bank in the last two years has been increasing
its global footprint and following the Indian corporate customers overseas, where it has
set up seven representative offices or branches with applications put in for two more in
South Africa and Bangladesh, and a subsidiary in Russia.
Going forward the bank’s policy to consolidate its presence in existing markets,
accelerate growth, sustain profitability and build a business model to withstand the
pressures of a global rollout.
M&A as a route for growth is unlikely as the bank sees little value in acquisitions given the
bank’s own reach and equity with customers. Instead, he wants to grow it organically to
keep both costs and risks down.
IV. LEVERAGE BALANCE SHEET STRENGTH AND STRONG
CORPORATE RELATIONSHIPS
In a bid to further strengthen its balance sheet, the bank securitized assets worth RS
10,700 crore. For marginally lower realization, it takes a lot of risk off the bank’s own
balance sheet. With Basel II norms round the corner, the bank will have to access low
cost funds to protect its profit margins and cover bad loans.
ICICI’s DISTRIBUTION STRATEGY
Multi-channel driven retail customer expansion
With the market expansion and customer expansion, ICICI can’t just expand
branches. Therefore it needs to look for another delivery model making it
convenient to the customers to do banking. So it needs a model to prevent the
customer from coming to the bank and at the same time service him.
So there are various other modes like Internet, Mobile, Phone Banking. Roughly, only
30% of the transaction happens through branch, 50% through ATMs, and 10% with
phone banking and net banking, but cost wise these channels have a very low cost as
compared to a branch transaction. On a rough estimate, if at a branch ICICI has to spend
Rs50 per transaction, at an ATM it is almost 25% of the Rs50. So cost of transaction is
very low. Therefore it encourages customers to use the ATM or call up if he needs a
cheque book etc. If they want to transfer money, it encourages them to go online. ICICI
has branches open for 12 hours and migration of the customers from physical to online
saves a lot of cost to the bank
.
To cope with the growth in expansion, ICICI is sourcing almost 2 lakh customers per
month. The branches are the same and there is tremendous pressure otherwise on the
branch. Therefore, it encourages migration.
Certain core activities customer will continue to do from the branches. There are people
who come to the bank just to find out the balance. Things are improving. India being a
conservative country, things are taking time. Earlier, there were so many apprehensions
about the success of ATMs. Today, it is convenient and popular.
ICICI has almost 1700 ATMs coming up. Right now there are 300 transactions per
ATM per day. The moment it crosses 400 plus, it starts putting up an ATM.
To efficiently distribute its products and services, ICICI Bank has developed