4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
ma rltiw mni11 8Jn{T .Mfa 'ba5ta eu cii .e.i b1si erriaa ecu evac{ 1eamikr rtaiibni eE{
abis1 ibiriw ie1a e1irIw a io1 baer{a riiamnei o bne abIei lo anniet cii eariavba Iaitirii
atmnei-iaaijp lo maei±a a ab1ei Iaiini ir1ir1 r1tiw emil aev aimIt 9Off ievewoH .qu da r{DJJa aerueIJbrn o Iqqa o r{mrorl eia 831 iehaiamb rbijB •'ps tomi oh ebiaah erI rbirlw
lo eDmIeada enlt ff1 10 eeibiaduia 11 ierliie cliiw miar{t aeibiadija 'tiDaqa3 mliiw abIei eaa .Diloq
ff0 fciemmnevo eu d eilthLbneqXe bexfl oi\ eno a lo etD9TIe eu eiaqmo rnerli eW
d bebivoiq eaievef cii 93(191911th sr{t lo aebi cia au aevt air{T .aeibiadira (1s bmia iDaqa3
-il8q9b rI31eb 911 i d eftoqoiq inemelqmi oi ihir,fflib bna xsfqmoo if t nuiB191 iii ne)1B 3d b1uod eui) ' ifi8qrno3 bebeIe i811 eeJ&ta (
— I aq tO1) üoQ 311T beanthb 3bi1oq 131qmi 311i o inm -13 3d blisow buboiq nojt819rI9 inIeTIu3 101 a9thIbBI flofi3Ubolq 9fflhJfOV iii ffl3ffliVfIi w3n o beiimfnoz
stB1unommo3 eo1q aiiijba1unam bna abicboiq fi0ftB19fl9 X9fI iol hoqque 11 9VO81 ot 31dii no IEnoiilbnoD bi&Jue 9fLt aeAam emIT .1Ioibubo1q 3muIov oi bei8lianom9b in3mtimmo) o Lv1 3rLt if iiw
.ibiedue tioJ3qEo a hsq iii 8B bei91q13tni 3d 5& ii iBrlJ 08 noiiiezupDE 'fb8qao
tarli bnfI W a aa b9IIbeqa eia eibiadua i{t nia anrrurxrii owt i{t
iiitibneqxe iDaqaD bria ü1 sn er{ ro heT aqmi 9vitiaoq a 2arI ibiadne Io airit
jborn iiro nI !ibiadna tbaqa a ai i n91{w ton tud 12L ioI ei 'biadna nr{w arrnft id
ndu'x io'i anoh91iU .asibiadija 'tiDsqaD narIt saivI siom sbivcriq oi bnst asibiadue 1S . rioibs ni bsaaljDaib sia *iow
iaubriI 3f{T . -aitini 1o sri mod Jiaqa sfiup buta 9883 niasistrii na asbivoiq aubni Isasq aR sr{T
frisrntasv 1aunino3 no abrisqeb favivna dDirlw ni viiaubni bsa1ns3no3 Ir1iri a ci tI .svit
riahoqmi Ia19va aathqaD IseI ew ibii{w Jthorn elqmia B qoleveb ew !rIoibee air{f ru
arLt eirrosx o abesir ibina rurni erli lesi ew a'uf .raubth afqaib Isnaq sfl erli o eW .bIei r1Br1 eru&b o isiase ai rnut iii rbirlw tiDBqBD ruBrf erI&{3 o ieieas ai ticqrro
nI .bexfi eus b!ei bria r{tod nin horia eri I 1 ew thr{w rü ari emuaaa eioeisrI
.neaorb ed ri& blei' nin riol erit iii bruB eIdBi1Bv ai ti3aqED rmi nuribem erit llso ew tar{w
.lirpe ed taxjm abIei run hor{a bus nun nol 1,born a rbia lo state bseta erit ni eaiuo 10
evsnled cmiii nuevi ca bIeii bnia tiDaqaD i±tiw nui horla erit ni tarli leel ew brIo3e
ot euboiq ot ienltedw ci rioiabeb lno iienlt !crrr{T .nievi 88 eiiq e!at bnia levthitsqrnoo
amill vifagenr sia atfioiq Ii bna ;eiiboiq cmiii viserunoru ew atftoiq II io
n1oiaiDeb cir{t nblam nI .tiD8qaD eaoorb en{t run nrusibem silt iii isvewoH .eDuboIq ton oh
oc a 1V1 lo aeqt weni qoleveb ot (L$I moi1 ha ada ew tar{t eLtot4 .Jiiqtuo ca 119w
.tnlsmsvolqrni aasooiq iol ci (L$I lno silt
iier{t nranit isnfirI bIsii nevi a nriatta ot ieiaae ti brth bIeii riirI a ritiw cmiii biir{T
.1ItaoD ci abIeii ni tnsmevoiqrrui içia ievewoH .eblei iswol nItiw cmiii oh ascii ento nuitaixe
won iettam on abIsi ui tnemevo-iqmi 'nia lo ctao evitiaoq eia sierit tar{I bemuaca ocla 81 tI
ni level etirth a ot eblsic silt lo eDr1sievnoD ctinnieq noitqmilcea iettal suiT .Iamicsiinfini
.aetata basta emoc
.iiDaqaD itaubrii lo noiturlovs silt turoda cnoitasusp iewcna ot lebom silt eai ot niciw eW
kriiiue beau 1i iaqao amii1 tasi erit sisuiw e1qmaxeieJriuo a lo lnuift 1etaibommi (11w iebaei ieveb eiIT" ai tI .iaoo Ianiiarn uui tioffa nadt iedh1 eohq a iii aiIuai 11a ta beau ion Ii iud etfloiq eviMen iii etluaei
airfi 10 aethorb tiDBqBo taut riiworf a lo aicianoD inemuis eufT .earia ieveri 11kw eea clEft tail i woled bouia .ebam ieven eia brth1
0I
TI
iiJ}J ?GJq uq cbciç? '
o c BGL mni jjiø o rrrnçe o bLoqncGq oiiçbrr !U 2JJOLç LJ oL
JOJJOtAIJ }JJ2 JffL4JJGL 2G2 O bLoqncou wrrç bGLoLmGq on iupj rrnç CO2
bGLc6lIç o 'a LG rncG bu€p JJAG p cpecq€q i bJxGJ2 LG
p 9ç innç coç o ci bGL nuç jp coLL€abouq2 q6 4JJ OIJJ?
OLGL 4O }JAG OJJG AipJG miiç O bLoqrrcJou c p€ jLeç i\' mJça u€q
2u€jq o jjJ€ bLoqrrcçou bLoce2 cu p ponp oj p€u combo€q o
J1CJJ JLUJ2 JJAG IJJLJ1JJ C02ç O + C bLO2 LG }JIT2
= 00
£c() = ( + (j)
(C) ?(+ )
() (+ ) —
() =
(-)rIB
svii o aaoorb mifi i Ii srkt oM (1) avIoa dDirlw iorb 'iDSqa3 r1 aIDiq9b ari'I oorb Iliw emil DneH soc . sd teum run ttorla efli ni etftoiq au baqaD Hi
.run hoc{a 9rLt ni 'iDaq8D ii5f{t ha 3JJbo1q ou
e4iJ e!ool mae eidJ ou noifuloe er{u ienriam cirlu ni aiuiDaqaD iiiif eeoofb emil ha cA
(\ c...
'd be±orl9b eia b ahv3I muhdiIirrp rLT .rrwiidihirrp9 chasM uornrroD a
no as aIvsI 'tiDaqaD ic{irI aooih Ihiw ebI9i1 iriir{ r{tiw emil usrf iuoM .V ,... , I =
.beqx5 bluow
riu$J noi 3Iff ,.8
er{u Hi moDuJJO 9r1t alDells eir{ woci niilai al3vsl bl9i1 iier1 aOOf{D emil mn nol r1t nI
ci Ivl ou bl9i ati Hiaiai lo (! bI9i cluiw mill a ou uaoD edT .arun mijibem bna fioc{a
id HeVI mio'x lanoibruJI lahuDitIaq a eelau eicLf uar{t ernucas Ihiw eW .(' J)1 d befoneb
LJTIJ bLoUç2 LG !AGU p?. () mGqpim LJ1IJ bLojçe p? () uq jou r.m bLoUç2 p (e) p
3asD Dhmmv 911T 1.1.
f9ham 5rIT .01 lo fraqa a aoor{D amifi rLfod !rba9 . lo ab1si rivi as nmma grit iii
ia afioiq run fior{a bris ai rrnkI r{3a lo 8OD Jaruiarri run horla 'V1 ai r{tiw hata of iiq maa erif run W .001 ra aflIoiq run rrmibm bria firm isq 04 m afao3 fbaqaD .iba O11
of eeth 'fi3aqaD lo 19v31 &fafa ibafa &df of &aob ai rbkr{w of &ah abIeiY .aJIal
UH nivoiqmi-bIeii rio Iutibrrqx9 brrar{ isrifo er{f nO .CI.81 of aEIal siiq sliriw 8.01
10 sulav thhafa a moil ao. of 'IIa3ifarria1b ella1
senoqasi sfaibsrnmi srlf I mifI of o? id rIoifiawpDa fiDaqaD lo taoD srlf scicbsi sw risrlW
eirlf of sanoqesi ru .T.0I of fiDaqaD riSCoriD srlt ru saaeiDni na ci ruoifaisfi faill erit iii
bleii ni aaef ataevni I'. noLtibba ru .01 wolecl ilfr{ile tiDaqaD qeeI of ci eiorb 1tiDaqaD
siom ateevrui a eliriW !eDrfsJJpsarIoD a as blsis iewol a earl bus sioled ruarlt (13&HI uIfVO1qffui
rIoitDubel 'h of sanoqesi Hi iJoq on nItiw fault rrioil dial oafs GJI ui tnismfaevni eti K nar{t
scout woled sis aiedmuri sesrit lo r{toH .8.1 efasvrui a bria 1.I ataevrui l\ HaitinI iii
.'piloq 1o srisads erif ru iuozo bkrow dDirlw
emif isvO .'a iswol bria etfioiq aao1 &I. saiai of ci biadHa sift 1o theIe JDaqmi sifT
a fault ci airlf io1 nocasi silT .tuonlijoirlt saii elirlw hal of nied neult fiud ecu effioiq aI .() rruoiI frisbive ci as friernfasvni tiDsqa3 asaiuorie ( asubei rbirlw) ibiadua fiDaqaD
suiT .efaoD fiDaqaD rio 'biadira suit d ucuu oafs eia ([$I ob of aevitrieDni ievewoH
fr{uoulf ed ria noitairpe emIT .('') Hi H5VL noifibnoo iebio tail sift moil trueiaqqa ci noaaei
nivoiqmi blei lo filsnied laruiiarn srlf etsupe of rrr'ulI lo tiaq silt rio niaoorb as lo
II .(.)'1 faoD laniiam eti r{fiw I
< (.)(.)'i + + st 'I
er{T . ui nieaeiDeb as fileried laniiam sr{f 1o irilrlt riaD ew bsvarlsd flew ci nneldoiq silt
.bleii laifirui nevi na rruoi1 nitraia noifaDftiDsqa iuro iol ui niaasnru ai taoD laniiam
iDiq9b bns ! 891Lri'I ibiadua O21 iii aerIir{ bns 98& ijbiadua DBBD 5rb Eli
eaois ennfi ow 9r1t io smit 1o nointh a as arltaq floiq rim hor{a bns tbsqsD er{
.eoiiarI9Da 99ifI
9a60 DiiJn1miaA 9rlT
In9tx9 r{ rroda 1aa ot tnstioqrni ai i atr1iani Irj1au thivoiq 3voda anoitaIxjmia r{ 91MW
trIll moa Ia& oT .3afrlnvbsaib Isiirii ria Ja rli9d A rrnft d b3fiibom is rLt rbir{w o .a io . bus A 4. lo ab1ii Io 83111Ev nihaa iol ariothahrmia ixro bsqi w air1 no
siom BnsDfiinia 289Vrii A .3rIIoYI9vo ilwola 81 3ansvbEaib 1sitini aA Diloq na hrorliiW
s rI9rIW .9io9d as fsIa \bs9a 3ithmma sr1 ta 9vms aurrift owt 5ñt bris a nsr{ (XX ui
iirrirrna rI ru as b3niado eis abe1l9 10 bnbl maa i1 ri9vi ai lo biadua tiDsqaD
1ev9woH .ibiadija er1f ot 91sb allal 8'1 3voda Eliri[5ffi91 eliriw (1M iii tn3ma9vni %'K .38S3
anaiv 81. 1 mill lo tarli wof5d aruiamsi A mill lo bl9i 3f{t anoiaiii 08 13fia I9V9
H .anoifsii ' ilno ieiis a lo 98o1{J aaaqiua ab1ei '1\ biadH8 its r1iw aairioo itT
.15viJD9qa91 bits 1@8. ta sia abl9i rI anoifaii 08 lo bn3 9f1
ow er{t iii a3Dfl3i3lIib erli vjinam ot mne,a lno ablei laitini er{t iii aentemm'as a11fIT
dtiw qu rb&) ot 1S. lii 1ivser1 aevm ot absen A mill aerthemmaa 1sitini r1tiW .aeiiloq
b1si' .A tkraei a as bits 13L ob ot eVthnsDm erit aeDubel biadua iosqa A .H mill
!bna ;(11 ob o aevirIerui erLt 893r151{fl9 biadija (11 na 881iTIO3 H .'a woled anismei
sifT .aboiieq lo iedmuci llama a iii 'a e1ahevo 'fiDaqaD bits afIoiq run hoi{a blei 'A
its ei nioq rbae !ruiaA . emr'1 iii bsbiqeb eia 385D 3rLtemnraa erIt i-li ab1si lo ioivar{d
918 eier1t !a1ft ts bria rIia5eiDni aiswla eia ableiY .H bits A iol ab1sr lo 9IJISV 9Vth519L
ieaolD rirvorn aob er{ 'd bebiqeb as emit ievo iellsma ts sasr1 tud bleii iii aerIsdD eisl
ili Io I3vf aaoi ri aiai of d Iliw bT1 aibemmi io baqmi &r{t Xbi8dua 9mFt 5no 8
xri ertt Lii bvomi ai biedii 9rli n9rlw iird 4taq on ati 9voda eldahav biat b bTb on ai eiej{ eau ew Ieborn er{t nI .beni&taua ed ton fl83 alevef ier{irf eaerfi boiieq
evarl aeiDifoq eaerLt ar1t naem on aeob air{1 ievewoH .ea 'baea ef1t no Difoq dorIa eno
.aebiloq owi erI iebnu tneieIIib iiev ai etaa beJa ot uftaq eri :e1be on
(level meiolav-ba tnel8viupe erli a beilqqa) biadnce £ a lo beTbe en erl atolq 0
eiijf1 erI ni enif berfaab edT .eaa thferrirrna ed iii 'tbaqa of bna (1 o beilqqa neriw
eitrtibneqxe 121 ai bna c1sk io biadna iallob tOfla-efIO a 89Viee1 tt neriW (biadra
eiuibneqxe 'tiDaqaD arni11 eflt ni eDnelelIib eu atolq enil bed3tarl-aao1D edT ."Diloq triouliiw
evar{ aenif beob bna biloa suiT .biadzja 12 air1t tisodtiw bna r1tiw (biaduca erI o ten)
eW .noitiainpa iD8qaD idI biadua torla-eno a ai 'Diloq edi neriw anoi aeiqietrri srnaa
.rner{t moib beii&Ini ed Li83 'iDaqaD bna ablsi o dtaq erIt enia atolq eaer{t no 2LrDOi
(11 no euribneqxe ni eaaeini etaibernrni na Lii ahraei (1 no tneqa iallob A
eiui'I ni nwor{a aa aiallob .1 tuoda id aeaii &iutibnsqxe ten iar1t oa aiallob urods o .oiloq on rltiw tadt woled alla'i ü1 no siictibneqxs boheq niwollo1 eu ni eaiuro 10 .0
ni atluaei airiT .astanimob bslIe tDaqmi sr{t tarIt oa . tuoda lno ai noibubei airit ievewoH
11 suit b bells tzaqrni suit isvosioM .rltaq 1Difoq on silt evoda nil abfeii lo rItaq sift
eiui'J ni riworfa 28 rf±aq iloq on ati evoda ii saiai ot ai siutibneqxs JiDaqsD no biadua
tiDaqaD ni nitaevni bo taoD srl eDubsl abIsii iedid isiliae beaauDaib 88 eauraed ai airlT .0
ati evoda aeif oala 1tiDaqaD auufT .tiDaqa3 ni tasvrii ot svitneni istaei a ni tinasi oa bna
.988D airit ni rLtaq Diloq on
a lo teTIe tDaqmi 118 ni aluaei biadua fiDsqaD a no tneqe iallob a aa1tnoD nI
-Xe eao ebiow xer{to nI !8'.— tuoda o noztiaiujxia iaqa rio eurtibneqxe iii no
tnemnivo 9rkt d 1utibcisqx5 aviiq 1o tuo ctibwox3 ai siclt aa !. 'lcio d ath eirrtibnsq
viJrrth rl eoribi ibiadua iiosqso a as aIL6 (12 rio 9rnibrr9qx9 rxoiiibbs ciT .bkadcra
bTI 9vuJiaoq llama a ai 9IerLi aboil9q nup9adria cii .13il1a b9u1a as (1SM cli taevrii ot
smxt ivo JJo aebal rbiclw rlaq iDiloq on i{ o 3vifali aeicthibriqx baqa3 bria 1i no
.aboiq ifal moa iii viari riimo3d xufibriqx iDaqaD erL rliiw
(level rn5lolav-ba cilaviLrp9 sc{t as bsilqqa) biadria 1 a o hTI sr{ ato1q 01 iiiflI beijbei bli aI\ mifi rkiw 988D Di1mrrraa rLt cii iiDaqaD of bits (1S21 o bilqqa n5rlw
arlt ori taiiI uii'I cii as cioiasiqIrri maa c{ vsrl 8VWD ixo1 clT .C. ot . moil
'io 1s1 rio irrtibrieqx cii aaeirii eaibemrrii its cii ailiJael I12M no tnqa isilob a b9rf ash r{ d riwor{a as aisIIob 88. thoda d aaii 1LribrI9qx9 n ar{ oa 80.1 lrio
rrnH) biaal c{ Ii amift 3i1mm1aa r{tiw ar{I lIaDI air{t briaaibciri oT .ujfI 9r1 cii end
rlDsD ot iebio cii baeda ai ibiriw mifi erit rtarlt (11 no eiom abrieqa i uo qoib on aeob (1\
ei eviacieqxe eiom erf eriob ai far{ 13 eiom sr{ cioibrud ao t1s1 X3VciOD a thtiW .qrr
as arlothibrlo3 lathirii lo fciebneqebni em aeJa1a ibaea arli ha1 erI arrlq airLT .OtL ierlta?i
oni etalarisif (1 no biadija isliob cievi a slsm e*rarn erli cli niamei arrnfi er as rioI
• (erxo Di1temrrva ecu ot belaqmo3 as) eaa Ditemmaa en cii 55ii9D19 icielaviupe ieflsma a
enli eas Dniernrnaa er{i cii aeibiadua (1 lo aaecieviiDee en{ eicbei aioisI rliod eliniW
noitiampDa iiDsqaD eio1ed aA .riiamei eaa Di1terrlm8 ecu cii nwaib anoiaulonoD eviisiulaup
woled eIla'i eirrtibneqxe ü1 aboiieq ineupeadua cii bits biadua (1L erli id bsa1IfoDrie ai
.lla is biadija on riJiw
ieM .eiuiibcieqxe 1 aeaisi nenit bria aeDubel 'fIaitirri mllob a lo vbiadua iiDaqaD A
cii .@8. lno d aeaii eiuiibcieqxe aaoi erli as 18. ftroda d alliI 'iiDaqaD no eiuiibneqxe
erli evoda eaii ion aeob 'ciiDaqaD no eiuiibneqxe isvewon1 988D Dniemm1a enit of iasifnoD
aeibiadua I1s1 tarli iaeija audi anoiialumia eaen{T .aboheq fneupeadua cii level off
•3th ot IBLimie aTIs awode i. ai bbii aA mifi exedw easo eJsibem19ni erfT'
xJa 0818 er1T .iiicaqa bna eb1i' aiai o i mia r1 Ii aeibi8dua 'iD8q8D 9tanimob
haqmi tn iia1 a svai1 aa ea& Di mm'a r{ iii a15v1 iaei evar{ aeibiadira GI .aDnatam1JD1 9831{t iebnzj hTI
a*u3m9}1 rübuI3rzoD .0
noiaiinimbs nohii1D ri r{r{w no 1ia1 buDo1 88ff 8Iriaq no e!adth DiIduq erIT
nI .'Di1oq 1aFxteubni biawo fiaita io vo1orfffDst aic latch lo noiomoiq 19v913 ai evthaitini
r{ lo noillim QQ1) noiPcnjhoiq 9mtclov 9omoiq o a3ibiadtc8 rfrfw nirnaxe ew 88if1O3
kri itcO .5vib1 iom ia (viaifirii rft lo noilfirn 81) a3ibiedua G$I io (viaifini