HEALTHCARE REFORM Where Do Employers Go From Here? December 6, 2012
May 16, 2015
HEALTHCARE REFORM
Where Do Employers Go From Here?
December 6, 2012
These materials are intended to stimulate thought and discussion and to provide the reader with useful ideas and guidance in the areas of healthcare reform. The materials do not constitute, and should not be treated as, legal advice. Although we have made every effort to ensure the accuracy of these materials, neither the authors nor Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated assumes any responsibility for any individual’s reliance on the written information presented during this presentation. Laws and regulations are subject to change at any time.
This PowerPoint presentation is an educational tool that is general in nature and for purposes of illustration only. The materials in this presentation are not exhaustive, do not constitute legal advice and should not be considered a substitute for consulting with legal counsel. Cox Smith has no obligation to update the information contained in this presentation.
CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE: Pursuant to Department of Treasury Circular 230, this presentation is not intended or written to be used, and may not be used by the recipient, for the purposes of avoiding any federal tax penalty which may be asserted.
2© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
The Supreme Court’s Decision: In a Nutshell
National Federation of Independent Businesses v. Sebelius Decided on June 28, 2012 567 U.S. ___ (2012).
Authored by Chief Justice Roberts Joined in various parts by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer,
Sotomayor, and Kagan Dissented to in most parts by Justices Scalia, Kennedy,
Thomas, and Alito
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 3
The Supreme Court’s Decision: In a Nutshell
Individual mandate held not to be a valid exercise of Congress’s power under the Commerce Clause
Upheld instead under Congress’s power to “lay and collect taxes”
Medicaid Expansion: invalidated provision that threatens states with loss of Medicaid funding if fail to comply with expansion BUT expansion stands if penalty is only that states
lose new funding if do not comply
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 4
KEY DEFINITIONS
Grandfathered Coverage: Group health plan coverage existing on March 23, 2010 Applies separately to each benefit package. How to lose grandfathering:
eliminate benefits increase copay percentage increase fixed costs over prescribed amounts reduce level of employer contribution add or decrease annual dollar limits.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 5
KEY DEFINITIONS Grandfathered Coverage (cont’d)
Okay to: Add new participants Change insurance companies after 11/15/10 Change TPAs Increase premiums (without reducing employer contribution) Amend plan to comply with reform.
Notice to participants required. May amend plans to comply with law changes.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 6
August 1, 2012: Preventive Care Benefits New women’s preventive care requirements (including
contraception) effective for the first plan year after August 1, 2012
This is in addition to previously required preventive care benefits: certain evidence-based items or services; certain immunizations; for minors, certain preventive care and screenings; for women, additional preventive care and screenings
including breast cancer screening, mammography, and prevention
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 7
September 23, 2012: Summary of Benefits and Coverage (“SBC”)
SBCs must be provided as of the first day of the first open enrollment period that begins on or after September 23, 2012 (in general, the open enrollment period for 2013 plan years).
For special enrollees/new hires, SBCs must be provided beginning on the first day of the first plan year beginning on or after September 23, 2012 (for calendar year plans, January 1, 2013).
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 8
Summary of Benefits and Coverage (“SBC”)
Plan must notify enrollees of mid-year material modifications not later than 60 days prior to effective date; changes for new plan year may be disclosed in SBC in connection with open enrollment.
May be provided with SPD and other materials as long as displayed “prominently” at the beginning.
MUST use DOL template, glossary, and instructions (caveat for self-insured plans that do not fit template).
No penalties in first year if good faith efforts to comply.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 9
Disclosure of Expenses & Insurer Rebates (“Medical Loss Ratio”)
Rules apply to insurers, but may indirectly impact plan insurance costs.
Insurer must report to HHS how premium revenue is expended.
Insurer must rebate policyholders to extent that premium ratio exceeds certain thresholds.
Fiduciary duty rules govern receipt of rebates by plan sponsors.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 10
Disclosure of Expenses & Insurer Rebates (“Medical Loss Ratio”)
Note: If employees pay premiums on a pre-tax basis, rebates paid to employees in cash or in the form of a premium reduction will be considered income and subject to employment tax. A rebate paid as a premium reduction is taxable because it
reduces the employee's salary reduction contribution. A rebate paid in cash is treated as additional compensation and is taxable as such.
If premiums paid on an after-tax basis, the rebate would not be subject to employment taxes regardless of whether it was paid in cash or used to reduce the amount of the employee's health insurance premium payment.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 11
October 1, 2013: Fees for Research Trust Fund
Insurers and employers with self-insured plans pay: 2013: $1.00 times average lives covered 2014 – 2019: $2.00 times average lives covered
Purpose: Fund comparative clinical effectiveness research When: File return reporting fee by July 31 of the calendar
year immediately following the last day of the plan year. This is effective for all plan years that end on or after
October 1, 2012. Thus, a January 1 – December 31, 2012 plan will file July
31, 2013. But a February 1, 2012 – January 31, 2013 plan would not have to file until July 31, 2014.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 12
2013: Health FSA Reimbursement Limit
Current Law: No reimbursement limit required – plan sponsors may choose their limit.
A $2,500 limit applies on a plan year basis and is effective for cafeteria plan years beginning after December 31, 2012. In the case of a short plan year, the limit must be
prorated. The limit is indexed for cost-of-living adjustments for
plan years beginning after December 31, 2013.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 13
2013: Health FSA Reimbursement Limit
Cafeteria plan documents must be amended to reflect the $2,500 limit.
Cafeteria plan sponsors have until December 31, 2014 to amend their plans to conform to the new requirements, so long as the amendment is effective retroactively and the plan operates in compliance for plan years beginning after December 31, 2012.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 14
2013: Increased Hospital Insurance Tax
Current Law: Employer must withhold 1.45% for all employees as the employees’ portion.
January 1, 2013: Employee portion of FICA is increased for high income taxpayers by 0.9%. Employer portion remains the same.
Threshold depends on filing status, but employer must withhold extra percentage starting at $200,000.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 15
2013: Elimination of Tax Deduction for Medicare Part D Employer Subsidies
Current Law: Employers can deduct full amounts paid for retiree prescription drugs, including the portion that is subsidized by government and is excluded from income.
January 1, 2013: Can no longer deduct subsidized amount paid for retiree prescription drugs.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 16
2013: W-2 Reporting
An employer that issues more than 250 Form W-2s must report “cost” of employees’ health insurance on form.
Coverage under all plans (except Health FSA, HSA, Archer MSA) is aggregated.
“Cost” includes employer and employee portion: may use COBRA method to determine cost (not counting 2% administrative fee allowed under COBRA).
Reporting required for 2012 tax year (i.e., 2013 W-2).
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 17
March 1, 2013: Notification re State Exchanges
By March 1, 2013, employers must notify current employees (and future employees at time of hire) of: existing exchange’s services and contact information availability of premium assistance for exchange-
purchased insurance if employer coverage is “unaffordable” (employer contribution < 60%
Unavailability of employer subsidy for insurance purchased through exchange
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 18
Notification re State Exchanges
Premium assistance takes the form of subsidy payments to a qualified health plan on behalf of the individual.
Take the form of an advanced credit payment. Exchange will determine whether individual qualifies for
premium assistance. Has been challenged as to whether premium assistance
is available only under state exchanges or under federal exchange as well.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 19
2014: Coverage Mandate – Large Employers
Supreme Court case did not address “pay or play” provision.
An employer with at least 50 full-time equivalents must provide “Minimum Essential Coverage” or pay penalty. Coverage requirement applies to full-time employees. Full-time employees = 30 hours per week (guidance
forthcoming on determining hours of service). Counting of part time is up in the air. Aggregation rules apply when identifying “employer.”
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 20
2014: Coverage Mandate – Minimum Essential Coverage Minimum Essential Coverage:
A yet to be determined benefits package provided by any of the following four vehicles:
1. Government programs
2. Eligible employer-sponsored plans
3. Individual market plans
4. Grandfathered plans Most employer-provided group health coverage will
meet the very broad definition of “minimum essential coverage.”
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 21
2014: Coverage Mandate – Large Employers
Employers will be required to make an “assessable payment” to IRS if: Any full-time employee is certified to the employer as
having purchased health insurance through an Exchange and a tax credit or cost-sharing reduction is allowed (i.e., the full-time employee receives a subsidy)
And:
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 22
2014: Coverage Mandate – Large Employers
The employer does not offer healthcare coverage for all its full-time employees; or
Offers minimum essential coverage that either: is “unaffordable” (i.e., > 9.5% of employee’s income
per W-2, for self coverage); or Does not provide “minimum value” (i.e., employer’s
share of the total allowed “cost of benefits” < 60%, guidance pending).
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 23
2014: Coverage Mandate – Subsidies through the Exchange
The subsidy, or credit, is designed to make health insurance affordable to taxpayers who: Have a household income for the tax year that is
between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level, Cannot be claimed as a dependent by another
taxpayer, and Who are not eligible for other qualifying coverage,
such as Medicare, or “affordable” employer-sponsored health plans that offer “minimum value.”
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 24
2014: Coverage Mandate – Subsidies through the Exchange
When an eligible individual purchases insurance through the Exchange, the Exchange makes subsidy payments to the qualified health plan on behalf of the individual.
Payments take the form of an advance credit payment (“monthly premium assistance amount”) under the Internal Revenue Code.
The Exchange determines whether the individual meets the income and other requirements for advance credit payments, and the amount of the advance payments.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 25
2014: Coverage Mandate – Notice to Employee of Premium Assistance
Exchange will notify employer of applicant’s eligibility to receive subsidy.
Notice must include: Employee’s identity Notice that employee has been determined eligible for
premium assistance Statement that employer may be liable for shared
responsibility payment There is an opportunity to appeal (guidance
forthcoming on appeal process). © 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 26
2014: Coverage Mandate – Large Employers NOT OFFERING A HEALTH PLAN Applies when employer does not offer minimum essential
coverage to “its full-time employees,” which IRS proposes to interpret as “substantially” all full-time employees, with few exceptions.
Assessable payment/penalty tax = “applicable payment amount” times the number of full-time employees (less 30) during the month.
2014 “applicable payment amount” is $166.67 with respect to any month (that is, 1/12 of $2,000). Adjusted for inflation subsequently.
So for 2014, annualized penalty = $2,000 x number of full-time employees minus 30.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 27
2014: Coverage Mandate – Large Employers OFFERING A HEALTH PLAN
Penalty tax assessable payment = $250 (1/12 of $3,000, adjusted for inflation after 2014) times the number of full-time employees for any month who receive premium tax credits or cost-sharing assistance (this number is not reduced by 30).
Tax is capped at applicable penalty had no coverage been offered: $166.67 (1/12 of $2,000, adjusted for inflation after 2014), times the employer's total number of full-time employees, reduced by 30.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 28
Excise Tax on Individuals
Starting in 2014, individuals who do not have Minimum Essential Coverage will be subject to an excise tax. IRC § 5000A Amount of penalty will phase in and may vary Payment to be collected on individual’s annual tax
return
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 29
Information Returns
Starting in 2014, Employers must report insurance coverage information to the covered individual and IRS. Form will require employer to certify it offers Minimum
Essential Coverage. Form to request name and Social Security number of
all full-time employees who are covered.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 30
2014: Plan Design Reforms
No annual dollar limit on “Essential Health Benefits” on or after January 1, 2014
Maximum 90 day waiting period No pre-existing condition exclusions or limitations Grandfathered plans must provide coverage for adult
dependent child, whether or not the child is otherwise eligible for other employer-sponsored coverage.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 31
KEY DEFINITIONS
Essential Health Benefits include the following general categories of benefits (states to flesh out details):
a. ambulatory patient services;
b. emergency services;
c. hospitalization;
d. maternity and newborn care;
e. mental health and substance use disorder services, including behavioral health treatment;
f. prescription drugs;
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 32
KEY DEFINITIONS
g. rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices;
h. laboratory services;
i. preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management;
j. pediatric services, including oral and vision care; and
k. no stand-alone dental or vision.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 33
2014: Plan Design Reforms Plans may vary premium rates plan only for specific
factors, such as coverage of an individual or family, geographic area, age, and tobacco use.
Guaranteed Availability and Renewability of Coverage Insurers must accept every employer and individual in
the state who applies, and must renew such coverage.
Grandfathered plans are exempt. Clinical Trials
Cannot deny coverage for participation in clinical trials.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 34
2014: Plan Design Reforms Individual and Small Group Insurance Markets Health plans offered in the individual and small group
markets, both inside and outside of the Exchanges, must offer a core package of “essential health benefits (“EHB”).
Proposed rule defines EHB based on state-specific benchmark plan. States will select a benchmark plan from among several options identified in the proposed rule, and that all plans that cover EHB must offer benefits that are substantially equal to the benefits offered by the benchmark plan.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 35
2014: Plan Design Reforms (continued) Non-grandfathered health plans in the individual and
small group markets must meet certain Actuarial Values (“AVs”), or metal levels: 60 percent for a bronze plan, 70 percent for a silver
plan, 80 percent for a gold plan, and 90 percent for a platinum plan.
Also catastrophic-only coverage with lower AV for eligible individuals. HHS is providing a publicly available AV calculator, which issuers would use to determine health plan AVs based on a national, standard population, as required by law.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 36
2014: Plan Design Reforms
No discrimination based on health status As to benefits or coverage, including continued
eligibility, based on health status factors Health Status Factors:
health status medical condition (physical or mental) claims experience receipt of healthcare medical history
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 37
2014: Plan Design Reforms
genetic information evidence of insurability disability; or any other health factor, per HHS regulations
Grandfathered plans are exempt.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 38
2014: Plan Design Reforms
Cost-Sharing (co-pays, deductibles, co-insurance) Cannot exceed the limitations provided in the bill for
essential health benefits. Based on maximum out-of-pocket expenses for high
deductible health plans, adjusted for cost of living 2014 numbers not yet available.
Deductible: $2000 for self-only and $4000 for family Grandfathered plans are exempt.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
39
2014: Plan Design Reforms
Expanded Wellness Program Financial incentives for participation in a wellness
program can be based upon health status, including up to 30% of the cost of plan coverage.
Additionally, for any wellness program designed to promote tobacco cessation, the new proposed regulations would allow a reward up to 50% of the cost of plan coverage.
Wellness program standards apply to grandfathered plans.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
40
2014: State Exchange Reimbursement = Qualified Benefit
Reimbursement or direct payment for insurance premiums on state Exchange will be a qualified benefit under a cafeteria plan.
Exception if employer offers Exchange enrollment
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
41
2018: Cadillac Tax
Excise tax will be imposed on insurers on high cost employer-sponsored health coverage: 40% nondeductible excise tax levied on insurers,
employers (for HSAs and MSAs), and plan administrators if annual premium exceeds $10,200 for single coverage and $27,500 for family coverage
Note: This tax is calculated ONLY on the excess amount over the annual limitation (e.g., one dollar over $10,200 $0.40 tax over 12 months).
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
42
Waiting for Guidance: Automatic Enrollment
Employers with over 200 FTEs that offer health plans must automatically enroll new employees. Notice must be provided to employee of opportunity to
opt out of automatic enrollment in employer’s health plan.
Watch for Regulations. Compliance is not expected before regulations are issued.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
43
Waiting for Guidance: Discrimination Testing
Insured health plans must pass some of IRC § 105(h) discrimination testing or employer pays excise tax ($100 per day per person).
Grandfathered plans are exempt. Effective first plan year beginning on or after September
23, 2010 Government has announced nonenforcement policy
pending regulations
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
44
Waiting for Guidance: Reporting and Disclosure Requirements
Plans must submit to HHS, State Insurance Commissioner, and make available to the public, certain information, in plain language, in relation to coverage transparency:
claims payment policies and practices periodic financial disclosures data on enrollment and disenrollment
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
45
Reporting and Disclosure Requirements
data on the number of claims that are denied data on rating practices information on cost-sharing and payments with
respect to any out-of-network coverage information on enrollee and participant rights
under this title other information as determined appropriate by
HHS
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
46
Reporting and Disclosure Requirements
DOL will provide rules. Grandfathered plans are exempt from these
requirements. Effective first plan year beginning on or after September
23, 2010.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
47
Waiting for Guidance: Grants to Small Businesses for Wellness Programs
Grants from 2011 to 2015, for new wellness programs Only for employers with fewer than 100 employees working
25+ hours per week HHS to outline requirements, but will concern:
Health awareness initiatives Maximizing employee engagement Changing unhealthy behaviors and lifestyle choices Providing supportive environment.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
48
Waiting for Guidance: Efficiency Standards and Wellness Promotion Reporting Requirements
HHS to develop reporting requirements (and penalties!). Annual report submitted by group health plan to HHS and
made available during open enrollment. Report must describe activities that:
improve health outcomes prevent hospital readmission improve patient safety and reduce medical errors target health and wellness
Grandfathered plans are exempt.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
49
Waiting for Guidance: Electronic Operating Rules – Phase 1
In July 2011, HHS issued regulations adopting operating rules for two HIPAA electronic transactions. Eligibility for health plan Healthcare claim status
HIPAA-covered health plans must comply by January 1, 2013.
Regulations adopt standards developed by Council for Affordable and Quality Healthcare.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
50
2013: Electronic Operating Rules – Phase 1
Plan must maintain adequate documentation that demonstrates: the plan conducts electronic transactions for health
plan eligibility and health claim status transactions in compliance with the HHS regulations; and
the plan completed end-to-end testing for transactions with vendors (e.g., hospitals and physicians).
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
51
2013: Electronic Operating Rules – Phase 1
Plan must ensure business associates comply, too. Enforcement through periodic audits and penalties
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
52
2014: Electronic Operating Rules - Phase 2
Plans to adopt and implement uniform operating rules (established by HHS) for electronic fund transfers and healthcare payments and remittance
HHS Regulations issued January 2012 Effective date: January 1, 2014
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
53
2014: Electronic Operating Rules - Phase 2
Plans to use Unique Health Plan Identifier (“HPID”) Compliance date for large plans: October 1, 2014; small
plans: October 1, 2015 Plans can obtain HPID’s beginning October 1, 2012
through a national enumeration system. Covered entity must use HPID when it identifies a health
plan in a standard transaction.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated 54
2014: Electronic Operating Rules - Phase 3
Plans to adopt and implement uniform operating rules (to be established by HHS) for: Health claims or equivalent encounter info Enrollment and disenrollment in a health plan Health plan premium payments Referral certifications and authorizations
HHS Regulations no later than July 2014
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
55
What should I have done in 2010?
Weigh benefits of grandfathered status versus costs of continued compliance.
Evaluate cost savings of existing retiree plans (net of compliance expenses).
Determine whether your business is eligible for small business tax credit.
Establish COBRA cost method for each plan (for 2011 reporting requirement).
No dumping of participants into High-Risk Pool
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
56
What should I have done in 2010 - 2011?
Delete lifetime dollar limits on “Essential Health Benefits” from plans.
Restrict annual dollar limits on “Essential Health Benefits.”
Revisit dependent coverage provisions. Review preventive care benefits and eliminate
deductibles and co-pays. Amend plans to allow permitted rescission.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
57
What should I have done in 2010 - 2011?
Review eligible classes, differing waiting periods, differing benefits, and differing premiums to identify and weed out prohibited discrimination.
Review and amend plan claims process. Eliminate restrictions on designation of in-network
primary physicians. Eliminate restrictions on designation of in-network
primary care pediatricians.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
58
Eliminate prior authorization and in-network requirements for emergency care.
Eliminate pre-authorization for access to OB/Gyns. Confer with insurer or TPA about data collection and
reporting assistance.
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
What should I have done in 2010 - 2011?
59
COX SMITH MATTHEWS INCORPORATED EMPLOYEE BENEFITS ATTORNEYS:
Joshua A. Sutin
112 E. Pecan Street, Suite 1800San Antonio, Texas 78205
(210) 554-5500 tel(210) 226-8395 faxwww.coxsmith.com
© 2012 Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated
This PowerPoint presentation is an educational tool that is general in nature and for purposes of illustration only. The materials in this presentation are not exhaustive, do not constitute legal advice and should not be considered a substitute for consulting with legal counsel. Cox Smith Matthews Incorporated has no obligation to update the information contained in this presentation.
Mary M. PotterL. Katherine Noll
William M. FisherJillian L. Gordon
60