2021 HKDSE HISTORY Briefing Session

2021 HKDSE HISTORY

Briefing Session

Paper 2 Question 6

Question 6

Criteria

Highest band

of

performance

Marks

- Coherent presentation with reasonable and balanced discussion of the extent

of the effectiveness of international organisations in tackling the problems of

population and resources in the second half of the 20th century, discussion is

supported by good use of solid historical examples that stretch a considerable

period of time.

A 23-25

- Shows a good understanding of the question, clearly examines the extent of

the effectiveness of the efforts of international organisations in tackling the

problems of population and resources in the second half of the 20th century,

discussion is supported by reasonable use of historical examples that stretch a

considerable period of time..

B 20-22

- Shows a good understanding of the question, and produces a good attempt of

examining the extent of the effectiveness of international organisations in

tackling the problems of population and resources in the second half of the

20th century, but discussion is slightly lopsided and contains underdeveloped

arguments. Historical examples cover a considerable period of time.

C 17-19

- Shows a general understanding of the question, attempts to discuss the

achievements and / or limitations of international organisations in tackling

the problems of population and resources in the second half of the 20th

century, but obviously lopsided and marred by rough content.

D 14-16

Assess the effectiveness of the efforts made by international organisations to tackle the

problems of population and resources in the second half of the 20th century.

- Shows an awareness of the question, attempts to discuss the achievements

or limitations of international organisations in tackling the problems of

population and resources in the second half of the 20th century, but marred

by lopsidedness and rough content.

E 11-13

- A general account of the efforts made by international organisations in

tackling the problems of population and resources in the second half of the

20th century, with one or two lines that causally touch upon their

effectiveness.

E/F 9-10

- A general narration of the efforts of international organisations in tackling

the problems of population and resources in the second half of the 20th

century, without any attempts to assess their effectiveness.

F 5-8

- Shows little understanding of the question, with no distinction made

between relevant and irrelevant materials.

- Containing very few relevant facts.

- Very poorly organised and difficult to understand, with annoying mistakes

in writing/spelling important personal and place names.

U 0-4

The following aspects may be covered:

- Achievements: Slowing down population growth, increasing food production, etc.

- Limitations: Population growth not fully controlled in developing countries, uneven

distribution of wealth in the world, etc.

第 6 題

標準最高

表現層級分數

- 表述連貫清晰，能合理和均衡地討論20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上的成效程度。能以實質例證支持有關討論，史例能涵蓋有關時期的相當時段。

A 23-25

- 能明瞭題旨，清晰探討20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上的成效程度。史例能涵蓋有關時期的相當時段。

B 20-22

- 能明瞭題旨，在探討20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題的成效程度上表現不俗，但討論略側重於成效或局限，及 /或包含未成熟的論點。史例能涵蓋該時期的不少部分。

C 17-19

- 對題旨有一般性的瞭解，嘗試探討20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上的成就及 /或局限，惟討論有明顯的側重，內容粗疏。

D 14-16

評估20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上所作努力的成效。

- 對題旨略有瞭解，嘗試探討20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上成就或局限，惟內容粗疏及失於側重。

E 11-13

- 主要敘述20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上的努力，僅有一兩行輕輕觸及其成效程度。

E/F 9-10

- 概述20世紀下半葉國際組織在處理人口與資源問題上的努力，未能評估其成效。

F 5-8

- 對題旨幾無瞭解，未能區分相關及無關之材料。

- 絕少相關之史實。

- 組織極為紊亂，難以理解，重要人名及地名有嚴重錯別字。

U 0-4

答案可涵蓋以下方面：- 成就：人口增長減慢、糧食產量增加等- 局限：發展中國家人口增長仍未完全受控、全球財富分布不均等

Good performance 表現良好

Able to provide a balanced answer and

discuss the effectiveness of the efforts made

by international organisations, including

inter-governmental and non-governmental.

能展示均衡的答案，及討論國際組織(政府間組織和非政府組織等)所作努力的成效。

Good performance 表現良好

Clear introduction

Good performance 表現良好Clear discussion

about the problem,

efforts and

effectiveness

Good performance表現良好Discussing about the limitation of both inter-governmental organisationand non-governmentalorganisationto tackle the problem of resources

Room for improvement 可改善之處

Did not focus on the question word ‘assess’ and the key word

‘effectiveness’, but merely included the efforts made by

international organisations or narrated the reasons for the

emergence of the problems of population and resources.

未能將答卷焦點放於提問用語「評估」及關鍵詞「成效」上，僅包含國際組織所作努力或陳述人口和資源問題上的成因。

Room for improvement 可改善之處

嘗試討論問題及努力，但粗疏

嘗試討論成效，但粗疏

Room for improvement 可改善之處

嘗試討論局限，但粗疏

Room for improvement 可改善之處

1. Only

mentioned IGO

(UNICEF) but

no NGO

2. Achievement

of international

organization

only discussed

in the last 2nd

paragraph

3. No discussion

about

limitation at all.

Room for improvement 可改善之處

1. Only

mentioned IGO

(UNICEF) but

no NGO

2. Achievement

of international

organization

only discussed

in the last 2nd

paragraph

3. No discussion

about

limitation at all.

Room for improvement 可改善之處

1. Only

mentioned IGO

(UNICEF) but

no NGO

2. Achievement

of international

organization

only discussed

in the last 2nd

paragraph

3. No discussion

about

limitation at all.

Room for improvement 可改善之處

1. Only

mentioned IGO

(UNICEF) but

no NGO

2. Achievement

of international

organization

only discussed

in the last 2nd

paragraph

3. No discussion

about

limitation at all.

Good performance 表現良好

1/5

Good performance 表現良好

2/5

Good performance 表現良好

3/5

Good performance 表現良好

4/5

Good performance 表現良好

5/5

Room for improvement 可改善之處

Room for improvement 可改善之處