Top Banner
3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component None, Poly, Metal What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor Orthopedic Surgery Residency Program Director Shoulder & Elbow Surgery Columbia University New York, NY Winter SKS: Shoulder, Knee, and Sports Meeting Friday, Feb 23rd, 2018 7:10am 2 Disclosures Consultant – Acumed, Wright/Tornier, Zimmer/Biomet JSES, JBJS, JAAOS, JOR, JSEA – Reviewer JAAOS Shoulder/Elbow Deputy Editor Orthobullets.com – Author Big Problem = Opportunity for Big Impact Glenoid component frequently (70%) develops lucent lines and loosening TSA projected 333% increase 2011-30 (Padegimas CORR 2015) Ethical Dilemma: balancing new technology vs proven techniques Revision burden will be large
10

2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

Apr 23, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

1

Glenoid Component ‐ None, Poly, Metal ‐What Will Last the Longest? 

Charles M. Jobin, MDAssociate Professor Orthopedic Surgery

Residency Program Director

Shoulder & Elbow Surgery

Columbia University

New York, NY

Winter SKS: Shoulder, Knee, and Sports MeetingFriday, Feb 23rd, 2018 7:10am

2

Disclosures

Consultant – Acumed, Wright/Tornier, Zimmer/Biomet

JSES, JBJS, JAAOS, JOR, JSEA – Reviewer

JAAOS Shoulder/Elbow Deputy Editor

Orthobullets.com – Author

Big Problem = Opportunity for Big Impact

Glenoid component frequently (70%) develops lucent lines and loosening

TSA projected 333% increase 2011-30 (Padegimas CORR 2015)

Ethical Dilemma: balancing new technology vs proven techniques

Revision burden will be large

Page 2: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

2

New Technology

New:

Glenoid designs

Fixation concepts

Materials

Studied biomechanically, in animal models, and in patients

…But long term superiority over existing techniques is relatively unknown…

4

Poly vs Metal‐Backed: Survivorship

Mayo registry, 1542 TSAs with 6 glenoid typesRevision Survivorship: 5, 10, 15 years

Neer II all-poly (n=99): 96%, 96%, and 95% Neer II metal-backed (n=316): 96%, 94%, and 89%Cofield 1 metal-backed ingrowth (n=314): 86%, 79%, and 67% Cofield 2 all-poly keeled (n=497): 99%, 94%, and 89% Cofield 2 all-poly pegged (n=358): 99% at 5 years only

Conclusions: Survival best with cemented all-polyethylene (Fox JSES 2009)

5

Mid‐Long Term Pegged Poly Outcomes

6

330 TSA, 7.2 yrs f/u

Revision free survival99% at 5 years83% at 10 years

Radiographic poly survival92% at 5 years43% at 10 years

Failure risk: Walch A2, B2, C, <65 yrs old

High mid-term Xray and clinical failure for pegged poly

Page 3: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

3

Glenoid Fixation Options : Current Market

Cemented Pegs (in-line or spread)

Cemented Keel

Ingrowth Metal (pegs, post, cage...)

Hybrid Cement pegs and Ingrowth metal

Metal backed (ingrowth post + screws)

Posterior Augment (wedge, step, half-wedge)

Metal: is it Back?

“metal backed” in-growth glenoids had 50% failure by 10 years (Cofield JBJS 2008)

New designs: metal-poly technology (“hybrid”)

...are we repeating history?

...or is this the holy grail?

8

42% of TSA patients are B2 (Churchill JSES 2015)

Posterior erosion

Posterior subluxation

Laxity of posterior capsule

Posterior wear = Worse functionGlenoid looseningPosterior instability(Walch JSES 2010)

Can Glenoid Fixation overcome Retroversion/Wear?

Page 4: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

4

Reaming to Correct Posterior Wear: “ream the high side”

10

Partial version correction: bone preservation

Full version correction: bone removalB2 Arthritic Wear

Aggressive reaming / version correction21% glenoid loosening at 8 years

Conclusion: Less reaming better, preserve bone!

But Less Reaming = Uncorrected Retroversion

Post-op retroversion >15 deg5x odds of osteolysis around peg(Iannotti JBJS 2013)

12

Page 5: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

5

Solution: Hemi for Arthritis?

969 shoulders

TSA 97% satisfied

HHR 80% satisfied

TSA poly revision (<2%)

Convert painful hemi to TSA (8%)0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

HHR TSA

Sat

Unsat

Radnay JSES 2007

“Ream and Run” – Concentric Reaming

Matsen series: 176 shoulders>5 yrs f/u (ave 10 years)

16% revisionSST 10 ± 2.6 (89% improved >30%)

Rothman Experience: 24 shoulders>2yr follow up, (ave 3.7years)

25% revision at 2.7 yrsSurvivors: SANE 74%, PSS 82.9, SST10.4

Columbia Experience: 29 shouldersave 17 yrs f/u.

26% revisionSurvivors: ASES 70, Neer satisfaction 25%Improved with concentric >> eccentric glenoid

Solution: Glenoid FixationPeg “Around Growth” Fins ‐ Outcomes

Churchill JSES 2010: 20 TSA, 5 yrs, 75% bone growth between fins

Groh JSES 2010: 83 TSA, 2 yrs, 29% bone growth between fins

Arnold JSES 2011: 35 TSA, 3.5 yrs, CT. 91% bone growth between fins

Wirth JBJS Am 2012: 44 TSA, 3 yrs, 68% bone growth between fins

Vidil EJOST 2013: 26 TSA, 80% bone growth between fins.

Parks JSES 2016: 76 TSA 3 yr XR follow up 50% bone growth around fins

Conclusions: Bone grows around poly fins in 30-90% at mid-term follow up

15

Page 6: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

6

98 TSA with 2nd Gen TM glenoid (2011 – 2015)

3 centers, postoperative Xrays: 0, 1, 2 yrs, and latest follow up

Early Outcomes of a 2nd Generation Porous Tantalum‐Backed Glenoid: A Multi‐Center Cohort Study

2015 CSES Biennial Meeting David Kovacevic, Charles M. Jobin, Janice J. He, Rolando Izquierdo, Ryan J. Krupp, Craig C. Satterlee, Jonathan K. Kazam, William N. Levine

Solution: Glenoid Ingrowth Fixation ‐ Outcomes

RLL at 2 years 0.6±1.1

28% no RLL change

57% decrease in RLL score from

post-op = INGROWTH

Metal debris 11% at 2.8yrs

Debris despite solid ingrowth

2% with catastrophic failure

metal fragmentation

RLL Grade 1 1 Year Follow-Up

Radiolucency and Metal Debris

68 TSA, 2 yr, no cement

92% min or zero RLL

44% with metallic debris, increased with time

no component dissociation

(Endrizzi JBJS 2016)

18

Grade 1: debris

Grade 2: axillary debris

Grade 3: breakage

Page 7: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

7

Does Glenoid Bone Ingrow?

6 of 351 glenoids retrieved at 1.2 years during revision not for glenoid failure

Histology: significant evidence of bone ingrowth

19

Outcomes: Hybrid Ingrowth central peg

20

83 TSA, > 2 yr, Ave FU 3.2 yrs

Retrospective Case Control

40 all-poly pegged vs 43 ingrowth hybrid

RLL similar: hybrid, 1.0 ± 0.4 vs pegged, 1.6 ± 0.3

Complications similar 2-7% (not glenoid)

Hybrid Ingrowth Glenoid 

Retrospective case-control: 92 TSA (46 hybrid cage, 46 UHMW pegged), >2yr FU

No dissociation of poly to cage, 1 aseptic UHMWPE peg loose

RLLHybrid cage (14%), ave RLL score 0.2UHMW pegged (28%), ave RLL score 0.6

Hybrid cage equal to UHMWPE pegged in short-mid term

(Bull HJD 2015)

21

Page 8: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

8

22

Normal Posterior B2 wear TSA with anterior “high-side” reaming

TSA with posterior augmented glenoid

Posterior Augment: Correction to “Normal” Theory

• Restore Balance

• Restore cuff tension / joint line

• Preserve glenoid vault bone

• Sheer to compression

Sabesan et al, JSES 2013

Posterior Augment Wedge

24 TSA w posterior wedge 2 years follow-up

Control: historic TSA

Pain, ROM and Outcomes Scores = no differences

Augment: 60% RLL, ave score 1.1

Non-Augment: 33% RLL, ave score of 0.4

(Bull HJD 2015)

23

Posterior Augment Outcomes

22 TSA, Case Series, 3 yr follow up

Pre-op retroversion 23.5° (CT)

Xray: 66% had bone between central peg fins28% had no bone6% had osteolysis

Mean RLL score 0.5

3 episodes of prosthetic instability

Conclusions: Early results are encouraging

(Favorito JSES 2016)

24

Page 9: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

9

Posterior Wedge Augment ‐ Outcomes?

25

Half-wedge implant mimic B2 to preserve subchondral bone and minimize bone removal during reaming.

Clinical outcomes: no published outcomes to date

Knowles JSES 2015Churchill JSES 2015

Increased critical shoulder angle (CSA) -> more vertical deltoid pull -> superior loading -> glenoid component loosening

61 TSA, 5.0 +/- 2.2 yr follow up

Critical Shoulder Angle >35 deg = 4x risk glenoid loosening

Superior Edge Loading?

Glenoid Technology Hype Outcome data Survivorship~10 year

Metal Backed low Long term – poor results 50%

All Poly Peg/Keel medium Long term – moderate results

85%

Metal Ingrowth medium Short‐mid term – excellent ingrowth but debris + catastrophic failures

?

Hybrid Metal Ingrowth

high Short term – good results ?

Posterior Augment high Short term ? ?

27

Putting It All Together

Page 10: 2018 2 Jobin TSA Glenoid Componenet short · 2018-03-09 · 3/9/2018 1 Glenoid Component ‐None, Poly, Metal ‐ What Will Last the Longest? Charles M. Jobin, MD Associate Professor

3/9/2018

10

Need for USA Registry

28

Capture everyone’s outcomes

Removes some biases

Informed decisions from large numbers

Thank You!

[email protected]

29