7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
1/80
20012.0608 Eyeo Festival, Minneapolis
A MOVEMENT IN 3 PARTS
1.Shock And Awe
2.Algorithm Critique3.New Aesthetics And its
Discontents
http://mariuswatz.com
http://twitter.com/mariuswatz
http://mariuswatz.com/http://twitter.com/mariuswatzhttp://twitter.com/mariuswatzhttp://mariuswatz.com/7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
2/80
20012.0608 Eyeo Festival, Minneapolis
Note: Parts of this presentation has been edited since it was presented
at Eyeo. In particularly, the New Aesthetic section was largely ad-libbed
live, so I have added some slides to represent my oral rantings on thesubject.
This post-editing carries with it the temptation to make the presentation
look better than it actually was, which I will admit to succumbing to on
certain pages. I hope this breach of academic conduct will be forgiven
given that the intention is to clarify my thoughts on the topics discussed.
Besides, Im not an academic.
Consider it a lesson in the infinitely rewritable and endlessly undoable
nature of digital writing (which in itself could be considered a New
Aesthetic phenomenom.)
Marius Watz,
New York, June 11, 2012
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
3/80
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
4/80
ALSO KNOWN AS:
The Loved And Lost Mix
ALSO KNOWN AS:
Evig eies kun det tapte Mix
(Thats Ibsen to you.)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
5/80
Shock & Awe - 853 slides, 4:23
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
6/80
2012.0213 mwatz.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
7/80
2012.0213 mwatz.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
8/80
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
9/80
2012.0213 mwatz.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
10/80
SOUNDTRACK CREDITS
1.Organ Donors: Throw A Diva (DJ IsaacMix)
2.Skrillex: Scary Monsters And Nice
Sprites
3.Blutonium Boy: Make It Loud
Mix by: DJ Kutski
Defender Against The Evil Forces Of Anything Less
Than 140 Beats Per Minute
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
11/80
2.ALGORITHM CRITIQUE
ALSO KNOWN AS:
How to not make friends on the creative
code circuit.
(Thankfully, like reality TV stars, Im
not here to make friends.)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
12/80
2012.0213 mwatz.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
13/80
SOME DISCLAIMERS
1.I am not the Algorithm Thought Police.
2.Im not telling anybody what to do or
how to do it.
3.Im not even talking about you.
(Really, Im not. Dont be so vain.)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
14/80
Christopher Wool, And If...
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
15/80
OUR PROBLEMATIC FRIENDS
- Circle packing- Reaction diffusion
- Fractals (yes, all of them)
- Strange attractors
- Voronoi / Delaunay diagrams- Flocking / boids
- Game of Life (+ other CA)
- Polygon subdivision
- Iso-surfaces aka blobs
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
16/80
OUR PROBLEMATIC FRIENDS
All of these are awesome (and beautiful)tools. But they are not neutral vessels.
Algorithms provide the means to produce
specific outcomes, typically throughgenerative logic or data processing. But
in the process they leave their distinct
footprints on the result.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
17/80
THE IDEA OF STANDARDS
Jazz standards are musical compositionswhich are an important part of the
musical repertoire of jazz musicians, in
that they are widely known, performed,
and recorded by jazz musicians, andwidely known by listeners.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
18/80
THE IDEA OF STANDARDS
There is nothing wrong with standards,in fact they verify the richness of a
cultural field.
However...
A preset is not the end point of creative
thought.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
19/80
ALGORITHMS AND DATA AS FOUND
OBJECTS
Untreated and unmodulated, a standard
algorithm is just a found form - a preset
structure producing preset results.
THE TEMPTATION
Upon discovering an elegant algorithmthat yields compelling visual results
(say, circle packing or reaction-
diffusion) there is a strong temptation
to exploit it as-is, crank out a seriesof images and call it a day.
Problem is, the kid down the block often has the same idea.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
20/80
ALGORITHMS AND DATA AS FOUND
OBJECTS
Untreated and unmodulated, a standard
algorithm is just a found form - a preset
structure producing preset results.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
21/80
ALGORITHMS AND DATA AS FOUND
OBJECTS
Similarly, many data sources have
striking intrinsic forms:
- Audio waveforms- FFT time series (aka landscapes)
- Networks
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
22/80
CRITICAL USE OF ALGORITHMS
Considering the use of such presetforms must be a part of any critical
computational creativity.
Most importantly:- Craftmanship (trite, I know)
- Originality
- Credible claim to authorship
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
23/80
UNLESS YOU CAN MAKE IT *ROCK*,
STAY AWAY. (AND IF YOU DONT
THINK ALGORITHMS CAN ROCK, WEHAVE NOTHING TO TALK ABOUT.)
What I meant: Well, make it rock.
(It seems obvious, doesnt it?)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
24/80
YES, HEAVY USE OF STANDARD
ALGORITHMS IS BAD FOR YOU.
What I meant was: If you use standard
algorithms w/o modification, its the
algorithm talking.
If any CS student can walk into a lab and
reproduce your results in an hour, any
notion of claiming credible authorship is
questionable.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
25/80
INSTANTLY KNOWABLE AND
INFINITELY MASTERABLE (GOLAN LEVIN)
Unlike a pencil or a piano, an algorithm
is rarely (if ever) instantly knowable or
infinitely masterable.
More commonly it is a terra incognita,
the features of which must be discovered
through experimentation.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
26/80
ALGORITHMS ARE SYNTAX & LANGUAGE
Speaking through algorithms, yourthought patterns and modes of expression
are shaped by their syntax.
I dare you: Try speaking German without being influenced by the
structure of the language.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
27/80
FALLACY: USE OF PSEUDO-RANDOM
CODE STRUCTURES IMPLIES A LOSS OF
AUTHORSHIP
Despite the tenacious claims of certain
artists, use of aleatory algorithms does
not result in an authorless work.
Randomness is just another material
property.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
28/80
ON THE OTHER HAND: CO-DISCOVERING
WITH MACHINES DOES HAPPEN. A LOT.
A typical scenario:
1. Articulate generative gesture
2. Explore the obvious and non-obvious
potential of said gesture
3. Modulate parameters to find optimal
parameters, introducing principles of
chance to produce interesting accidents
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
29/80
MULTIPLICITY ISNT COMPLEXITY.
Multiplicity is the uber-motif of currentdigital generative art - especially the
scene around Processing. Look through the
Flickr Processing pool and try to find
an image that isnt some kind of swarm,
cloud, cluster, bunch, array or aggregate
[..]
Mitchell Whitelaw, More is More: Multiplicity and Generative Art
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
30/80
THE EXPERIENCE OF MAKING A
SERIES OF AWESOME YET ULTIMATELY
PROBLEMATIC IMAGES.
In which I walk through the creation of
a series that I ultimately dont trust.
Also, examples of co-discovery withmachines.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
31/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Color effects produced by
manual Photoshop trickery
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
32/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Color effects produced by
manual Photoshop trickery
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
33/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Color effects produced by
manual Photoshop trickery
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
34/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Color effects produced by
manual Photoshop trickery
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
35/80
Color effects produced in
code by OpenGL shaders
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
36/80
Color effects produced in
code by OpenGL shaders
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
37/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Hatch shader applied
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
38/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Hatch shader applied
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
39/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Hatch shader applied
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
40/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Mission achieved: Geometry
and color all code-based.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
41/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Mission achieved: Geometry
and color all code-based.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
42/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Mission achieved: Geometry
and color all code-based.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
43/80
Deformed Modelbuilder mesh
sketches, June 2012
Mission achieved: Geometry
and color all code-based.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
44/80
PROBLEM:
I dont trust these images or my ownimpulse in creating them. I will likely
never publish them as artworks.
I ask myself:
1.Are these images just sexy pixels?
2.Will I still like them in a year?
3.Do 3D rendered stills have a place in mypractice?
4.Is it just the algorithm talking?
5.Are shaders just Photoshop filters?
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
45/80
CO-DISCOVERING WITH
MACHINES
I now have a Makerbot Replicator 3D
printer on my desk, pushing me that much
further into the future.
Problem: Big prints were showing splits.
Resulting serendipity: Lattice structuresoptimized to avoid solid mass.
P b bilit L tti (2012)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
46/80
Probability Lattice (2012)
Parametric objects intended for
lo- 3D printing (Makerbot)
Probability Lattice (2012)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
47/80
Probability Lattice (2012)
Parametric objects intended for
lo- 3D printing (Makerbot)
Probability Lattice (2012)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
48/80
Probability Lattice (2012)
Parametric objects intended for
lo- 3D printing (Makerbot)
Probability Lattice (2012)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
49/80
Probability Lattice (2012)
Parametric objects intended for
lo- 3D printing (Makerbot)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
50/80
3.THE NEW AESTHETIC AND
ITS DISCONTENTS
ALSO KNOWN AS:
Making friends with eruptions of the
digital into the physical.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
51/80
CONTEXT
Tumblr maintained May 2011- May 2012 byJames Bridle et.al.
At its core, NA is an ethnographic
experiment documenting (often accidental)byproducts and consequences of digital
technology, specifically effects of
technology on physical / social / economic
/ political / personal space.
Bridle: [..] Ive been collecting images and things that seem to approach
a new aesthetic of the future [..] Consider this a mood-board for unknown
products.
[ADDED POST-EYEO]
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
52/80
CONTEXT #2
March 2012: NA panel at SXSW, Austin(feat. Bridle, Aaron Cope, Joanne McNeil, Kevin Slavin & Ben Terrett.)
Bruce Sterling posts a provocative
response on his Wired blog, The Creators
Project publishes a series of responsesto Sterling, other writers and bloggers
chime in with an astonishing range of
interpretations of just what NA might
mean.
Consequence: NA becomes a meme/fad, loved and hated equally. It also becomes
a handy soapbox for public grandstanding, giving rise to a multitude of
highly subjective and often contradictory interpretations. Much hilarity
ensues.[ADDED POST-EYEO]
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
53/80
CONTEXT #3
My own view: Bridle etc. are correct inidentifying symptoms of a shift in how we
experience a reality that increasingly
presents itself as a messy layer cake
of physical and virtual space, where .The claim that these constitute a New
Aesthetic is more credible
Btw: Many of these phenomena were predicted by 1990s cybertheory but
sounded ridiculous at the time due to a discourse tainted by intensehyperbole. NA requires no such exaggerated fiction or hard sell, as
the objects and processes it deals with are frighteningly real, having
surreptitiously come into existence without most of us even noticing.
[ADDED POST-EYEO]
2012.0506 new-aesthetic.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
54/80
James Bridle
new-aesthetic.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
55/80
James Bridle
2012.0504 new-aesthetic.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
56/80
James Bridle
2012.0504 new-aesthetic.tumblr.com
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
57/80
James Bridle
2012.0406 Creators Project response
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
58/80
Edited by Julia Kaganskiy
In response to Bruce Sterling, texts by
Greg Borenstein, Kyle Chayka, James George,
Kyle McDonald, Jonathan Minard, Marius Watz
Immaterials: The Ghost In The Field (2009)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
59/80
Spatial visualization of RFID radio eld
Timo Arnall, Jack Schulze, Einar Sneve - Touch (AHO)
Immaterials: The Ghost In The Field (2009)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
60/80
Spatial visualization of RFID radio eld
Timo Arnall, Jack Schulze, Einar Sneve - Touch (AHO)
Immaterials: Light painting WiFi
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
61/80
Timo Arnall, jrn Knutsen, Einar Sneve - Touch (AHO)
Light painting WiFi eld
Aram Bartholl: Map (2006)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
62/80
Aram Bartholl: Map (2006)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
63/80
Aram Bartholl: Dust (2011)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
64/80
Aram Bartholl: 1H (2008)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
65/80
Aram Bartholl: 1H (2008)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
66/80
Aram Bartholl: 1H (2008)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
67/80
Aram Bartholl: Dust (2011)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
68/80
Aram Bartholl: Dust (2011)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
69/80
Clouds, documentary by Jonathan Minard,
James George (shot w/ Kinect+SLR, 2012)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
70/80
James George (shot w/ Kinect+SLR, 2012)
Clouds, documentary by Jonathan Minard,
James George (shot w/ Kinect+SLR, 2012)
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
71/80
James George (shot w/ Kinect+SLR, 2012)
FIRST LETS ADDRESS THE HATRED
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
72/80
FIRST, LETS ADDRESS THE HATRED
FOR THE TERM THE NEW AESTHETIC
For 15 minutes or so NA was a flashpoint
for technoculture debate, with important
cameos from art/tech theorists as well as
art world luminaries (who on the wholehated the whole thing...)
The love/hatred expressed for the NA meme
complex would suggest that it somehow
challenges the status quo, making people
uncomfortable in the process. How can that
be a bad thing?
[EDITED POST-EYEO]
THE HATRED FOR THE TERM THE NEW
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
73/80
THE HATRED FOR THE TERM THE NEW
AESTHETIC
Most of the hatred seems to stem from a
widespread misperception slash kneejerk
reaction that new implies better,
more significant or a replacement forall other forms of aesthetics.
Which makes no sense.
BUT
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
74/80
BUT...
There is no doubt that the artifacts
identified as New Aesthetic (by Bridle &
others) exist.
Computer glitches, AR markers, invisible
wireless+radio fields, social media
artifacts and interactions (tweets, pokes,
checkins, adds) impact our lives every day
in a myriad of oh-so-real ways.
Some of which are less than awesome, by the way. Noone knows what the
fallout of drone warfare and state-sponsored cyberwar will be, but its
unlikely to be a pretty picture.
[EDITED POST-EYEO]
MORE IMPORTANTLY
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
75/80
MORE IMPORTANTLY...
Pretty much everybody at this conference
live, breathe and make their living from
creating New Aesthetic artifacts every
day.
And typically we dont give it even a
moments thought.
SO WHY GO ON ABOUT THE NEW
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
76/80
SO WHY GO ON ABOUT THE NEW
AESTHETIC?
Because we are the (often enthusiastic)
creators of New Aesthetic artifacts, and
as such we need to take responsibility for
them.
We might not be designing killer drones or
missile guidance systems, but we are all
part of the technocrat elite.
[ADDED POST-EYEO]
NEW AESTHETIC AND POLITICS
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
77/80
NEW AESTHETIC AND POLITICS
A more valid complaint: NA is a
continuation of the technocrat hegemony of
middle-class white guys. This is hard to
refute.
There is every reason to apply gender/
race/class critique to NA. Despite the
cute images of glitch and retro game art,
the implications of NA artifacts must be
recognized as deeply political.
Sadly: Im a technocrat white guy and likely to stay that way.
[ADDED POST-EYEO]
NA AND THE (WHITE) MALE GAZE
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
78/80
[EDITED POST-EYEO]
NA AND THE (WHITE) MALE GAZE...
A curious claim related to a feminist
reading of NA: Surveillance and computer
vision allows men to experience feminine
objectification through a technological
version of the male gaze.
I rather tend to doubt this, as most men dont feel violated by CCTV.
There is undoubtedly a need for a feminist critique of NA, but this is too
simplistic.
IMPERFECT CHILDREN NEED LOVE TOO
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
79/80
IMPERFECT CHILDREN NEED LOVE TOO
Clearly the NA meme as it stands is far
from perfect. Bastard child of a thousand
authors, it is full of contradictions and
theoretical cul-de-sacs.
But it does provide a useful flashpoint
for much-needed discussion of the strange
ways in which technology infects our lives
and cultural/social/political space.
Ignorance may be bliss, but its also
irresponsible.
[ADDED POST-EYEO]
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
7/31/2019 20120610 A Movement in 3 Parts. (1.Shock & Awe, 2.Algorithm Critique, 3.The New Aesthetic And Its Discontents) - Marius Watz - Eyeo 2012
80/80
Marius Watz is:
http://mariuswatz.com
http://twitter.com/mariuswatz
http://mwatz.tumblr.com
http://generatorx.nohttp://workshop.evolutionzone.com
http://flickr.com/photos/watz
New York, June 2012
http://mariuswatz.com/http://twitter.com/mariuswatzhttp://mwatz.tumblr.com/http://generatorx.no/http://workshop.evolutionzone.com/http://flickr.com/photos/watzhttp://flickr.com/photos/watzhttp://workshop.evolutionzone.com/http://generatorx.no/http://mwatz.tumblr.com/http://twitter.com/mariuswatzhttp://mariuswatz.com/