世界教育报告2010中文版

• 1. 2 0 1 0

2. 3. 4. 2 0 1 0 2010 2010 010 2 7, place de Fontenoy, 75352 Paris 07 SP, France Sylvaine Baeyens UNESCO ISBN 978-92-3-504129-3 //cld 793.10 5. 201020007,2002010 i 6. 2 0 1 0 GMRUISHendrik van der PolClaude Apkabie, Sad Belkachla, Georges Boade, Michael Bruneforth,Talal El Hourani, Friedrich Huebler, Olivier Lab, Weixin Lu, Adriano Miele, Albert Motivans,Juan Cruz Persua, Pascale Ratovondrahona, Ioulia Sementchouk, Anuja Singh, Sad OuldVoffal, Peter WalletYanhong ZhangAbdullahi Haji Abdi, Reda Abou Serie, John Aitcheson, Federico Blanco Allais,Nadir Altinok, Jane Anthony, Laban Ayiro, Gauthier de Beco, Paul Bennell, Herbert Bergmann,Desmond Bermingham, Sonia Bhalotra, Nicholas Biddle, Lyndsay Bird, Michael Bruneforth,Gwang-Chol Chang, Ian Cheffy, Luis Crouch, Santiago Cueto, Mahamadou Diarra, Janice Dolan,Marie Duru-Bellat, Jude Fransman, Franco Gamboa Rocabado, Malini Ghose, George Godia,R. Govinda, Carola Gruen, Gabriela Guerrero, Jialing Han, Ricardo Henriques, George Ingram,Francesca I. Izabel, John Kabutha Mugo, Jean-Francois Kobian, Ozge Nihan Koseleci, JuanLen, Ingrid Lewis, Luis Enrique Lpez, Siobhan Mackay, Cristina Manzanedo, Matthew Martin,Raphaelle Martinez, Geraldo Martins, Juliet McCaffery, Erika Mein, Katharina Michaelowa,Hilaire Mputu, Karen Mundy, Ismael Muoz, Samir Ranjan Nath, Katy Newell-Jones, Anna Obura,Brendan O Malley, Zipporah Ongwenyi Nyamauncho, Maciel Pereira, Susan Peters, Marc Pilon,Patrick Quinn, Alan Rogers, Sara Ruto, Alan Sanchez-Jimenez, Elisa Seguin, Nidhi Singal, DeviSridhar, Pablo Stansbery, Brian Street, Munshi Sulaiman, Tami Tamashiro, Huyen Chi Truong,Yuko Tsujita, Raul Cotera Valdes, Consuelo Vlaz de Medrano, Anna Vignoles, Dan Wagner, PeterWalletKazuhiro YoshidaIzzyBirch, Manuel Contreras, Kate Gooding, Peter Hyll-Larsen, Harounan Kazianga, Louise Meincke,Alemu Melkamnesh, Sophie Qian, Ya Ping WangKai ZhouKenneth Harttgen, Stephan KlasenMark MisselhornLuc-Charles GacougnolleBabette WilsGwang-Chol ChangNicola Chanamuto, Caine RollestonJan van RavensKwame Akyeampong, Keith Hinchliffe, Jean-Pierre Jarousse, Cynthia Lloyd,Paolo de RenzioYusuf SayedManos Antoninis, Fadila Caillaud, Luis Crouch, Caroline Dyer, David Hulme, Phillippa LeiShailen NandySteven ObeegadooOlav SeimIIEPIBEUILCandy LugazCorinne Bitoun, Aurore Hagel,Lynne Sergeant, Asuncin ValderramaAude ZeilerAnton De Grauwe ii 7. Jean-Mark Bernard,Ulrike Hanemann, Sabine KubeClinton RobinsonKenneth EklindhFlorence MigeonJustine SassYong Feng LiuFTIRobert Prouty, Kouassi SomanMamadou ThiamCatherine Dom, Steven ListerGeorgina RawleJulia Benn, Fredrik Ericsson, Valrie Gaveau, Aime Nichols,Ccile SangareSuzanne SteensenDan CoppardAsma ZubairiAlexandre Khan2010Rebecca Brite, Andrew JohnstonWenda McNevinIsabelleKiteJan WorallNino Muoz GomezSue WilliamsMariso Sanjines Kevin WatkinsSamer Al-Samarrai, Nicole Bella, Marc Philip Boua Liebnitz, Mariela Buonomo, Stuart Cameron, Alison Clayson, Diederick de Jongh, Anna Haas, Julia Heiss,Franois Leclercq, Anas Loizillon, Leila Loupis, Patrick Montjourides, Karen Moore, Claudine Mukizwa, Paula Razquin, Pauline Rose, Sophie Schlondorff, Suhad Varin. The Director 2009EFA Global Monitoring Report Team20082015 - c/o UNESCO 20077, place de Fontenoy,75352 Paris 07 SP, France 2006 [email protected] - +33 1 45 68 10 36 2003/04 - +33 1 45 68 56 41 2002 - www.efareport.unesco.orgwww.efareport.unesco.orgiii 8. 2 0 1 0 ..................................................................................................... i ..................................................................................................... ii ............................................................................. vi . ............................................................................................ 1 ..................................................................................................... 3 1 ...................................................... 16 .............................................................................................................. 19 ....................................................... 21 ....................................... 28 . ................................................................... 322 .......................................................... 38 .............................................................................................................. 41 .......................................................................................... 42. .............................................................................................. 54 . ................................... 76. .......................................................................................... 94. ...................................................................................................... 104 . ........................................................................... 119 3 ............................................................................. 132 . .............................................................................................................. 135 .......................................................................................... 138. ...................................................................................................... 164 . ...................................................................................................... 186 . iv 9. 4 ..................................................................... 214 . .............................................................................................................. 217 ...................................................................................................... 218 . .......................................................................................... 248. 5 ............................................................................. 268 ................................................................................... 271 . ..................................................................................................... 277 ...................................................................................... 278 . ............................................... 292 . ................................................................... 294 .................................................................................................. 296. .......................................................................................................... 428 .............................................................................................................. 446 ...................................................................................................... 450 . .......................................................................................................... 483 .............................................................................................................. 486v 10. 2 0 1 0 1.1.......................................................................22 . 1.2...................................................................................................23 1.3...............................................................23 . 1.4...........................................................31 . 1.5...........................................................................................35 2.1...............................................................................................44 2.2......................................................................................................45 . 2.3...........................................................................................47 2.4.......................................................................50. 2.5...............................................................................52 2.6...........................................................................52 2.7......................................................................................................................56 . 2.82015.......................................................................57 2.9....................................592.10. ...............................................592.11...............................................................................602.12...............................................................................602.13. ..................................................................................................612.14. ...............................................612.1519992007. ..........................................................................632.16...................................................................................652.17...................................................................................662.18...........................................................................................672.19...................................................................68.2.20............................702.21......................................................................................................72 .2.22...........................................................73.2.23......................................................................................................75 .2.2415.......................................................................812.25..........................................................................................................83 .2.26...................................................................83.2.27...................................................................85.2.28............................................852.29...........................................................................952.30...........................................................97.2.31...........................................................................................98 vi 11. 2.32...........................................................................992.33..................................................1002.34..................................................1012.352015.................................................101.2.36....................................................................................................105 .2.37.........................................................................................1072.38.................................................................................1082.39.........................................................................................1082.40................................................................................................................110 .2.41..........................................1102.42................................................................................................................115 .2.43.............................................................................................1162.442015..............1172.45................................................................................................................126 .2.46................................................................................................................126 .2.47.................................................................127.2.48.............................................................................1282.49.........................................................................129 3.1................................................................................................................140 . 3.2................................................................................................................142 . 3.3.........................................................143. 3.4............................................................................................................................144 3.5....................................................................................................................144 . 3.6.............................................................................146 3.7.........................................................................................147 3.8.........................................................................................148 3.9......................................1493.10.............................................................................1493.11....................................................................................................................150 .3.12.................................................................................1513.13.............................................................................................1513.1420%..............................................................................152 .3.15........................................................................................................152 .3.16....................................................................................................153 .3.17................................................................................................................................1533.18..................................................1563.19........................................................................................................157 .3.20.....................................................................157. vii 12. 2 0 1 03.21.........................................................................1593.22....................................................................................................................................1653.23............................................................................................................................1693.24.........................................................................1723.25............................................................................................................172.3.26.................................................................176 .3.27........................................................................................................179.3.28.........................................................................1833.29................................................................................................................................1873.30.............................................................................2113.31.............................................................................213 4.1.................................................................................................221 4.22010.........................................................................222 4.3.............................................................223. 4.4.................................................................................223 4.5..........................................225 4.6....................................................................................................................227. 4.7.....................................................228. 4.8.................................................................................................229 4.9.........................................................................2294.10.........................................................................................2304.11.........................................................................2364.12.........................................................................................2374.13.............................................................................2414.14.................................................................................2414.15.................................................................242.4.16.............................................................................2444.172002200836.............................................................2534.18.................................................................255.4.19.................................................................................2564.20.........................................................................................2574.21.............................................................................................263 1.12008-2010.....................................................................................22 1.2.......................................................................................30 2.119992007.......................................................51 2.219992007..........................................................................................62. 2.3 2007...................................................................................74 2.42007TVE....................................................................80. 2.519992007......................................................................................80. viii 13. 2.62000- 200715....................................................95. 2.7.................................................................113 . 2.8........................................................................................................................122 . 2.92015............................................................................................................123.2.10....................................................................................................125.2.112008-2015.......................................................................................130 3.12002.........................................................147. 3.22005. ....................................................................................148 3.3. .................................................160 3.4.................................................................................171 3.5.........................................................184. 3.62007.................................................................................212 4.1............................................................................................................................233 4.22007............................................................................................235 . 1.1...................................................................................29 2.1...............................................................................................43 2.2..........................................................................................................48 . 2.3...................................................................................49 2.4..........................................................................................................................53 . 2.5.......................................................................58. 2.6...................................................................64. 2.7......................................................................................................................66 . 2.8......................................................................................................68 . 2.9...............................................................................................692.10...........................................................................712.11. ..................................................................................................792.12...........................................................................852.13..........................................................................................................86 .2.14...............................................................................882.15...........................................................................902.16Entra 21...........................................................................................................90.2.17......................................................................................................................91 .2.18. ..................................................................................................932.19..................................................................................................................96 .2.20......................................................................................................................97 .2.21....................................................................................................................103 .2.22........................................................................................................................109 .2.23................................................................................................................................1112.24.............................................................................................113ix 14. 2 0 1 0 2.25........................................................................................................113. 2.26................................................................................................................121. 2.27.........................................................................................122 3.1..............................................147 3.2.................................................................................................148 3.3.............................................................................................158 3.4.............................................................................167 3.5.....................................................................................169 3.6.........................................................171 . 3.7................................................................................................................174. 3.8.............................................................176 . 3.9.............................................................................177 3.10.................................................................178 . 3.11........................................................................................................................180 . 3.12....................................................................................................................181. 3.13.............................................................................................183 3.14....................................................................................................................188. 3.15............................................................................................................193. 3.16..................................................195 3.17.................................................................................195 3.18. .............................................200 3.19....................................................................................................201. 3.20.........................................................................204 3.21. ................................................................................................205 3.22........................................................................................................................206 . 3.23.............................................................................208 3.24............................................................................................................212. 4.1................................................................................................................................224 4.2........................................................................................................226 . 4.3............................................................................................................227 . 4.4.....................................................................................231 4.5....................................................................................................................233 . 4.6.....................................................................................237 4.7.................................................................................238 4.8.................................................................239. 4.9.............................................................................243 4.10.............................................................246. 4.11.....................................................................................247 4.12............................................................................................................................252 4.13.............................................................................257 4.14.................................................................................................258 4.15.........................................................................260 4.16....................................................................................................................................263 4.17........................................................................................................................266 . x 15. 2010 2010 2000 19993,300 2015210010 19992015 58%54% 1985-19942000-200710%84% 2009 1.2520109,000 1.75 20077,20020155600 20092010 46 54% 101,20080% 36% 7.59 2010 1 16. 2 0 1 02010 40% 2015190 2005500180 80 22 2230200743 11 50 2620 50 70 43 0.7 6 97 160 2010 2 17. Aubrey Wade/PANOS 1 2010 1 2015 20109000 2007 20081.75 2015 XINHUA/Gamma/Eyedea Presse 20092010 46 2010 10% 208 1. 3 18. 2 0 1 0 Jeroen Oerlemans/PANOS 2030 2009 2010 800 2% 2010 IDA 2015420600 160 2010 2010 Aubrey Wade/PANOS 4 19. Alfredo Caliz/PANOS220002015 20077200 28%19991.75 100 Patrick Le Floch/Explorer/Eyedea Illustration38005 20. 2 0 1 0 Louise Gubb/Corbis 7100 20155600 20022004 2 2015 3 9: 10 2800 13% 6 21. REUTERS/Zohra Bensemra 7% 3% 2007 TIMSS 7.59 2015 190 2015 120 8100 20038001% 7 22. 2 0 1 0 3 700.7% 1601.5% Amartya Sen 110 27 110 2010 Chretien Eric/Gamma/Eyedea PresseDME 8 23. Giacomo Pirozzi/PANOS63 221722 30% 11 50% 261722 20% 50% 20% 1722 88% 20% 20%1722 43% 6%97% 25%30%6.71.8 30%9 24. 2 0 1 0 Abbie Trayler-Smith/PANOS 2 141.2515%1824 30%29% 1.667143710% 2.21 2. http://www.unesco.org/en/efareport/dme 10 25. Ami Vitale/PANOS 1,400517 20082009 1641228069% 11 26. 2 0 1 0 Handicap International 12 27. Crispin Hughes/PANOS 4 2015 20052010500 2008 20052010 1802005 Francois Perri 2007412004 2007 13 28. 2 0 1 0 REUTERS/Ahmad Masood 20102% FTI2007 UNESCO/Samer Al-Samarrai480050 14 29. 2015200870 200 20093124.91 20022004 UNESCO/Ernesto Benavides2015 15 30. 2 0 1 0 116 16 31. 2 0 1 0 Aubrey Wade/PANOS Jeroen Oerlemans/PANOS 1717 32. 2 0 1 01 19............................................................................................................................................................................... . .................................... 21 . .................................... 28 . ....................................................................................................................... 32 18 33. 2015 2010 201510 10 2015 20109,000 1990 19 34. 2 0 1 0 1 6080 20092010 46 2010 10% 200920102160 2% 2010 2010 4920092010 260 200920101,600 20 35. McCordVandemoortele2009teVelde2009Anwarul Islam 2009b2009e Kry Chamnan 20092 5%2%1502009 1.1Lalitha 35 2009b2009d 2008 2009 6%2009 e20092010800Kenia Valle1.1 Emmett2009 21 36. 2 0 1 0 1 1.1: 200842003-2009 108 04/08610/08 11/08 (%)4 01/092 07/0902003 2004 2005200620072008 2009 -2 -4200972009f 1.12008-201020062008 2009201029%1.2 () 20094 24.720.8 21.61 378 402427 2 376 322347 1.4 79.8 80.3 1.4 16.4 26.7 0.0 63.4 53.6 201520084200941. 200842008 2. 20094 20082009e2009g 1990 20002005 22 37. 12 12 10 10 (%) (%) 8 8 20084 6 6 20084 4 4 2 2 20097 20097 0 0 2007 20082009 20072008 2009 -2 -2 -4 -4 12 12 10 10 (%)20084 (%) 8 8 6 6 20097 4 420084 2 2 0 0 2007 200820092007 2008 2009 -2 -2 20097 -4 -41.2 1.32000200520092010 301 250 2006 20-1 15 (%) -2 10 -35 -40 -5-5 -6 -1020092010 2007 2002200420052007 20082009g 23 38. 2 0 1 0 1 1.32008a2008e 2009201046200820 24%2009 2013300 20101310% 20077,50020081102008 20091.25Headey20091,200160 2010 1.257,500 29,100ChenRavallion2009 2003 2008 von Braun2008 2008 17%80%Lustig2009von Braun2008 Raihan200910% 20092009 24 39. 9830140 10%Orozco2009 2009b 105% 20% 2009 1.25 200020074002009 te Velde2009 2009 Grogg2009te Velde2009 Thomson2009 2,000Hossain2009Mitchell20092009 1997Emmett2009Ferreira2009b Schady 2008 Harper 2009 1998Frankenberg 1999PaxonSchady2005a Harper2009 20083.08 Jensen200020092007c7%Ratha200925 40. 2 0 1 01 FerreiraSchady2008 MartinKyrili2009 14 1 372009Martin Kyrili2009 12 2009 125 1. 20093 2007 20095 1.3% 2009 b 26 41. 2008 2009 2009 2010 te Velde2009 27 42. 2 0 1 0 1 200927,890 1.1 Heller2005322%2009c Roy 200737 MartinKyrili20095662 3 7,860744. Panetta20092. 200870%2010100%20095. g3. 20096 44%7%Martin Kyrili2009 6. Martin Kyrili2009 28 43. 1.1 200 20092 110170 7,890 z 21 z 43 2008 90%60020101,460 1,300 z 395 z 220 z 2522009 2009 1452009Dillon2009 15% 2005 2000 1,300 25% 17% 29 44. 2 0 1 0 1 2511 1517% 11147 1.2 5 4 1711 1.4 1.2 (4 )(11 )(17 ) (5 ) 7. 3% MartinKyrili2009 30 45. 1.42009 = (11 ) == (6 )(4 ) = (4) = = ()(6 )= (1 ) Martin Kyrili2009 31 46. 2 0 1 0 1 Kaberuka2009 20094 200925 Woods2009 b 7 2030 82009c62009 800 10 30% 8. 201080 Woods2009b 20 32 47. 2009a, 2009dWoods2009b12200941,0002009 2002009b 2,830 9 10 2009718 82%1.6% 2014170Woods2009b 201080 11 Bredenkamp2009a2009b 2009109. 170Gottselig200910. 2009412. 200911. 33 48. 2 0 1 01 2009Delgado2008 201080 2 2009-201220 60 20 2% 2009dWoods2009b 20099 2009 i 200913 2009 14020 2009 2009d 1.5 2009 150% 187.95 68% 2009 14 13. 1,000 14. 20095(8820095120)Woods 2009b 34 49. 1.5 15 2004 2004 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 232009b 2009 2009dSayeh20090.7% 2009 2009232009 18 2009d 16 2009 15. 0.5105 30% 354010 16. 3320 2009 MartinKyrili2009 35 50. 2 0 1 0 1 20102009 2015160110 2009520109 2009b 20082009 2005 200920102602009 36 51. 420 2010 600 2009 2010 2010 2015 37 52. 2 0 1 0 Alfredo Caliz/PANOS Louise Gubb/Corbis38 38 REUTERS/Zohra Bensemra 2 53. 2 0 1 0 Chretien Eric/Gamma/Eyedea Presse Patrick Le Floch/Explorer/Eyedea Illustration3939 54. 2 0 1 02 41............................................................................................................................................................................... .................................................................................................. 42 ................................................................................................................. 54 ........................... 76 ....................................................................................................... 94 ...................................................................................................................................................... 104 . ...................................................................................................................................................... 119 40 55. 2015 1642000 2015 3 2015 20152015 2015 200041 56. 2 0 1 0 2 1: 56 1.78 B.1965 2007 2008 42 57. 2.1 (Bennett2008)() 45( 2007)(PPVT),78 PPVT1112Dercon[2008](WHO) ( Alderman ,2001Glewwe2001Grantham- McGregor2007) 61845(Alderman20064%12%PPVTBehrman1996Maluccio20097)8 14%20%(0.26 0.4) (Behrman2008) : Sanchez (2009)(2.1) 20151990200893045 400201578 (Sanchez2009 ) 40%(2008b) 43 58. 2 0 1 02 5 A 1 52.11.782000-200751 30% (2.1) 1,90014% (2008 b)(2.2)60%80% (Victoria2008) 830 3 A0 10 20 30 40 50 60(Victoria (%) 2008):30%1. 1. :,3A2 44 59. 2.2 2000-20071 30 25 20 15 1080% 50 // / 2.5 20081. 2008b200750%25% (Bouis2008) FAO20058.482008 9.63 (FAO2008)20084,400 ((Hossain20092008) 2008e) 2009301.25 13%550%70% (Jayatissa2009(von Braun,20082008 )a)(HauensteinSwan 2009von Braun2008)2007 45 60. 2 0 1 0 2 50201530400(Lawn2006) 60% (TheaQazi2008)80%( (2008b), 2008b) (41%)(45%)(2008b) 3,800 ( 2007b) 50 (, 2008b) 20%20% 20%50% (2008b) (Victoria2008) 100 ( 2005) 46 61. 2.3 2005350 40330201519 10(, 2003 0) 1860% 90%80% (2009)(Lawn20062008b2005)10%(2.3) (DFID2008 b)2000200440% (Masanja2008) 2000GAVI()2.13 3402000200690%(GAVI, 2009 a)(Black15%33%, 2008)(2008a) 47 62. 2 0 1 02 (GilsonMcIntyre2005Pearson, 2004) 2,374 (DeiningerMpuga, 199920052005Yates2009)(2.2) (Khan2008)20052.2 18%16% (Ruel2008) Oportunidades2001: (Fiszbein2009)(2.3)200661%5%6% 100: Yates (2009); Nabyonga (2005); Batungwanayo Reyntjens (2006); CohenDupas (2007); GilsonMcIntyre (2005);Witter (2009) 48 63. 2.3 Atencin a Crisis15%(, 2005) , 20052006:z 341.5562.4z 185 z (Heckman, 2008) 3z 5 (PaxsonSchady, 2005b) (2.4): Macours (2008)2222(Feinstein,2003)22 20% 510 (Field,2007), (Karsten, 2006)(Brooks-GunnMarkman2005EACEA2009Lesemanvan Tuijil, 2005)OECD :(ChristensenStanat, 2007; Schnepf, 2004 5,000)3449 64. 2 0 1 0 2 2.42003-200425% 110 2007 25% 100 90 80 70 33 60 10% () 50 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70 345 (, 2008b): Test de Vocabulario en Imgenes Peabody () , (Fiszbein, 2009, , 2006j ): PaxsonSchady (2005b ) 2007 1.41999 1.13(GER)33%41%(2.1) ( 2. 2005-2006, 20%, 2005)2 24% () 1710% 20%1%9% 17% :200719 (Nusche, 2009) 1450% (Cunha, 2005) (Campbell 1999 , 2008; Karoly(Leseman, 2002) 20% , 2005; , 2008a; (, Schweinhart, 12 2005) 3A) (, 2008 b) 50 65. 8 20%(Barnett2008 ) (Ackerman, 2009)3 104 4 46/ 145 , 31118,00053,000 34(Barnett, 2008)(EACEA, 2009) 3 51200760% 44 845612 2.119992007 19992007 19992007 1999 2007 19992007 ()(%) (%)(%) 113 139 24 33 412680 106 32 27 3632 25264 73 8010 7 87 45 6339 510 82 10 1553 2 3 26 15 1925 1 1 13 19 2844 37394 40 4718 37384 40 4719 3. 0.4 0.5 12 61 6711 87%4 2136 69 21 3671 EACEA, 2009 1620 22 56 6517 0.7 0.8 16 65 7413 4. 1619 22 55 6517 19206 75 82 9 9105 50 6430 3B 10 51 66. 2 0 1 0 2 2.52.6 ArnoldDoctoroff2003;12%Nusche2009Sylva200725%28%Nonoyama-Tarumi2008Barnett 2008 ? 44 55% 87%Barnett2008Barnett - Yarosz20072008a 4 19972.4 Sure Start240 (2009)2.5 2007 20%20%3434 2.6 34 25 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 : ()(20% )(20%)2.5Nonoyama-Tarumi(2008) Nonoyama-Tarumi(2008) 52 67. 2.4 40% 2006 salacuna(2)jardn infantil(23) (Larraaga, 2009; 2009e) Un 3,0005 Buen Comienzo1360 Chile Crece Contigo (Frenz2007 ) Frenz (2007); (2009e) 9 20(Froese20082007May2008) 20075 86%91%( 2009) (Heckman20061902) 53 68. 2 0 1 0 2 22015 1 20077,200 20155,600 1 22015201510% 200054%281094 2015 54 69. Maria15,4 12 7,100 1 2007 7,2002015 23 Malina12 2007 1999 Lucy12, 8 3,30019991.0520077,200 2.7 Victor 14 58%54% 2,100 63%58% 55 70. 2 0 1 02 2,200020072,000 800 : 2015 1,30028% 5,600 1,800 2001SarvaShikshaAbhiyan 2015 1,50061999-200720155,600 5 5. 20072009 ( 2.8)45%50 20 1999 (2.12)2004 10% 19992.719992007 19992007120 3001.05 100 48 6 80 ()7,200 3 396 609 40 18 452,500 203201999 20076.2010 5Ayyar2008Govinda20093 56 71. 2.8201520151201.05100 80 7,200 () 3,90060 5,60040 800 4,500202,300 019992000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 200620072008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 20151999-20071999-200735%7 (2.5) 30%200844.7 1999187. 19992007 25 1,000 UIS 2007 2009a 2950%2,200 3200930%a57 72. 2 0 1 0 2 2.5 29 2.9 2910 9 2.10511 8 77%58% 1111 200720%54%600 200520%2006 20%60% (Bruneforth2009b) 58 73. 2.9 2.10 2006 77% 58% 51% 33% 78910 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Bruneforth 2009a. 29-30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 z 6,600Bruneforth2009a.4,400 z 1,600 z 18060 80 Bruneforth 2009a59% (Bruneforth, 2009b) 60%44% 2.113,100 59 74. 2 0 1 0 2 2.11 2.12 1042007 70% 8 / / 1,200 / 0 20 40 60 80100 2009a. 2.12 2.13 1,200700 80% 36% 62%27% 0 2 0004 000 6 000 8 00010 000 2.14 () 200750 Bruneforth (2009b) 8. 60 75. 2.132.142007 20032005 100100 80 80 60 60 40 40 20 20 00 20% 20%020 40 6080100 Bruneforth (2009b)200750Bruneforth (2009b) 20% 20% 2.14 2 100% 2.21999 61 76. 2 0 1 0 2 2015 200773% 86% 2.631% 90%98% 1999 45%75%95%52.15 75% 2.15199950%200698% 2015 90%1999 70% Bennell20092.219992007 1 19992007 1999200719992007()(%) (/) 646694 82 87 0.92 0.96 559615 80 86 0.91 0.95 70 66 97 96 1.00 1.0016 13 88 91 0.99 0.9982124 56 73 0.85 0.9035 41 78 84 0.87 0.90 76 88 92 0.99 0.98 218191 96 94 0.99 0.99 214188 96 94 0.99 0.99 33 90 84 0.97 0.97 155192 74 86 0.84 0.95 70 68 92 93 0.97 0.97 32 75 72 0.98 0.99 68 66 93 94 0.97 0.9653 51 97 95 1.01 1.0026 21 91 92 0.96 0.981. 5 62 77. 2.15199920071999-2007100 1999 90 80 70 2007 (%) 60 50 40 1999 30 202030 40 5060 7080 90 100 1999 (%)5 20152015 82%2019 20051011 63 78. 2 0 1 0 2 2.6 z 199950%2007(5 80%) 36% 199910067 66% 200610083 2015 z 20% 20% 200520% z 2015100% 57% 5% (2006-2015) 115%200550%6200620%3.9%18% z 3.2%15 (2009g) (2008)10063 GPI 2.72007280.90 2.1618 200772%2005 1999100862007 64 79. 2.162007 10090 80 / 70 (%) 60 50 40 30 20 0.60 0.700.80 0.901.00 1.10 5 2007 2.17 200965 80. 2 0 1 0 2 2.172.71999-2007 19992302005320 100 90 80 70 (%)60 50 40 19 30 2006/2007 1620 13 0.50.6 0.70.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1999 20071999 2007 52.18200590 70%88% 20%3 (FilmerSchady, 2006; Fiszbein, 2009) (Zekas, 2009) 19992007 5810070100 66 81. 28%46%2.182005 8070 60 (%)5070%4052% 3020 10020%Q2 Q3Q420% UNESCO-DME (2009Al-Mekhlafy (2008)Guarcello (2006) (20062007)Kefaya (2007)Ochse (2008)32005e 19992006200773%57%110 25 2.8 32.15 25 9. 2006-2007 19992007409 67 82. 2 0 1 0 2 2.8201550060% 85% (2.19) 91 25 2.192007 9080 (%)7060Aly (2007)50Andrabi200920034030 20% 20% NWFP* *NWFPUNESCO-DME2009 68 83. 199920072.925200714 70%1999 200619992007 1.25 200772%66%10( 199928%2007103%), 20012003 2007 11 200830% 199942%200831% 4 2015: (2009); (2007a); (2007)2007b 2.94 10. 2015 11. 2007 19992006 55%200712 12. 1999 33%20062015 47%200719995.3%41%20062.4%13. 2007/2008 13 2.20 200769 84. 2 0 1 02 2.202007 100 80 (%)60 40 5001002050 0 02 0004 0006 0008 000 10 00012 000 14 000 (2007)5015 19992015 2007611 1001999 10 5 14. 14 3 70 85. 20044% 6% 7%20052.3%3.6%15 15. 2.103 2.10 85%1540% z 813 614 1520% z 20% 20% 2000 200290%16 2007 6460% PISA z 8127% 2%15 z Duman2008FerreiraGignoux2008aOtaran2003971 86. 2 0 1 02 2006 2.21 200613% 9%16. 716 2.212007120/100 80(%) 60 40 200 5 72 87. 2.222.222006100 100 905 90 80 80 70 70 60 60(%) 50 50 40 40 30 30 20 20 10 100 0 * * 100 200667%547%40%667 100667 32527(67% ) 32 27 ( ( 47% ) 40% ) 10055* : 47()73 88. 2 0 1 02 5 2007 7,100 20077,100 2.317 54% 2007 50%38%28% 5 2010200754% 201559%( BruneforthWallet, 2009) 2.23 200627%39% 200660%, 2.3. 2007 (000)(000)(000) 7179111 7092118 142712 14 6863812 6819721 136835 15 2334 41538 4 38724 819 61187 6 20066 3222626 217313853957 30 575214400918 9761 15 271 5302 4 573417. 9039 5 1031910193587 1803110 299052847937 172989 51885 5 48735 1931 41319 4 32504 1552 71452 7 30047 ( BruneforthWallet, 2009) 74 89. 2.23OtienoKOliech2007)100 23 806064 60 7572(Mingat 6039Ndem2008) 401218 208 203828 152318 21(Glick 0 105 Sahn2009) Bruneforth Wallet (2009) 2004 2015 75 90. 2 0 1 0 2 20092009d3 3 KingPalmer2008) 3 Sapir2005 ( 2008Kok2004, 2004) (2006 9) 20072008a 76 91. 1 2 3 2007 a 4 5 ( Barabasch 2009 ) 2006) 77 92. 2 0 1 02 18 2019/, 2001Gallart2008) (SENAI)2009 c(2.11) 14 15%(2008b) (JohansonAdams2004)Grubb2006 2007) (Ryan2001) 1%18. (2005)12(Adams200719. 10 b)12 18%47% 40% 20. 80%(SENCE)150 105% (Adams, 78 93. 2007bTan2006)2.111%(SENAI),21SENAIConfederaoNacional da Indstria () 27700280SENAISENAI(SENAI20092006) 2513 5% 5% 30% 14 20%45% (KahyararaTeal, 2006) (LaugloMaclean2.521. 65%102005)200716% 49 200767% 22 9% 6% 20072% 2.4 34%65%90% 6% 22. 22%35% ICSED 237 79 94. 2 0 1 0 2 2.42007TVE (000)(%) (000) (%) 518721 47 54024 46710 409125 47 37044 476 983335 49 13553 43 1616 26261 483428 40 1213 35580 442221 392 6 27453 473157 4371110891 481271 46 1112 165769 48 23658 49 1114 162324 48 22550 49 1114 3445 481109 44 3432 125705 442412 271 258547 516275 54911 1294 50 51 492 4 57253 516225 54 1011 62401 498645 43 1414 32375 486385 39 172082.519992007 (%)(%)19992007 19992007 (/) (/)(/) (/)60 0.92660.95180.96 26 1.08 52 0.89610.94110.78 18 0.96 100 1.00 1001.00551.19 67 1.29 91 1.01900.98391.21 58 1.29 24 0.82340.79 40.676 0.66 60 0.89650.92190.74 22 1.0585 0.99950.98180.93 24 1.1065 0.96781.01140.75 26 1.00 64 0.96771.01130.73 25 0.99 111 0.99 1050.96471.24 53 1.31 45 0.75520.85 70.64 11 0.7780 1.07891.08211.12 34 1.19 53 1.03581.03 61.307 1.36 81 1.07901.08221.12 35 1.19 100 0.99 1001.00611.23 70 1.33 87 0.98880.96381.18 62 1.2589A 80 95. 1590%70% 75%Garcia Fares,2008)1999 1%2%2.4 0.820.79 15 2007 44%27%39%11 940%25122.2415200715* / ///152.24 /85%1519 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 ()157(Kuczera2008;2008b) *64181 96. 2 0 1 0 2 2008a1524 1524 2009 20073,900 (LaugloMaclean,2005) 5001,770200812%200914% 15%/2009)/2009) (Adams, 2008; Brewer, 2004) 2.25152460%2009(Salehi-IsfahaniDhillon2008)152925%5(AssadBarsoum2007)2008ILO 19966,30020077,100 17%13% 202525%257001,000(Garcia12% Fares 2008) 82 97. 2.252007* 3530255 (%)(GarciaFares2008) 20151050 (Fares /2005GarciaFares2008) *2008b2009f2.2623 2008 3 (1524) 2 (2554)/ 2009) OECD 20107.3%20075.5%2009d2.2619972007 15%13% 0 51015 20 25 23. (%)/ 22%2009f2008) 58% 83 98. 2 0 1 0 2 20002008bJohansonAdams2004 2009 dKahyararaTeal, 2006)2005 2008g1/2009 ) 15242009cKamel2006Salehi-IsfahaniDhillon2008 2.12 84 99. 2.12 2.2720 2003 100100 21 298080 364413 1260 860716 100 10014concour 4040 1312 58 5220 20153529 00NazariFanni-123123(2003) (2004) (2005) (2003) (2004) (2005)HerfeiKardaneshKardanesh Fanni-HerfeiNazari( ((/) ) ) Salehi-IsfahaniEgel (2007)2003/2004 2.282.27 Nazari 2005 60 1501205040 (%) 3020 10 0 Salehi-IsfahaniEgel (2007)2024 20%4%2.28 120 Salehi-IsfahaniEgel(2007)Povey (2005 )85 100. 2 0 1 02 3% 6% 2006 Salehi-IsfahaniDhillon,2008 2008 7% 60% 32006 g2005 24 2.13 2.13. 24. - 92006GTZ 44%GTZ 1.6/45 2008d1,600 JohansonAdams2004 86 101. 2.14 GarciaFares2008 AtchoarenaDelluc2001 28313Adams2008200830 9,50080% 25 (Garcia Fares2008xxx)Haan2006Liimatainen2002 2008;COMEDAFII+20072007Wachira200870%Liimatainen, 2002 4Monk2008 25. 2008b Adams,2008 Adams2008 90% 22%2008b 87 102. 2 0 1 0 2 2.14 80%90% 1%2006 20% 5% 20052026 2% 2006 STEP : Adams (2008); / (2008c); Akyeampong (2007 ); (2004a2004b); Palmer (2007) 2007 / 2008f /2008 e 88 103. 1624(Schochet 2003)28 Jvenes 2.15 2001Entra 21 2.16 2006jCalifica62016 2416% 18 26 18%Gallart20082009b Jimenez2007 26. 101248.5 27 33 2007 ) 27. 3 35 Flores-28. Moreno2007 12%(Schochet 2003) 89 104. 2 0 1 0 2 2.15 z 1990 60% 6 Proyecto Joven 10% z 1,000 z Betcherman20042007 Gallart2008)Godfrey2007) 2.16Entra 21 z Entra 21 42%21% z 75%90% 20016 4.5 2 5,000 z Entra 2169% LasidaRodriguez (2006)24% 90 105. 2.172002200711%14%17%19932007CNN.com/US200918172015182440%200950%2009b 118242.17 (2009); (2008c); (2008) (Adams2007aBishopMae2005;Ryan2001)(Gangl2003Quintini2007 ) (Adams2007b)91 106. 2 0 1 0 2 75% Adams2007b 29 (Hoeckel2008aHoeckel 2008b)11%(KempleWillner2008 ) (Adams2007 bHoeckel2008bYoung2005 )2006) , 2009c 29. 45% 200529% 92 107. Law2008Lee2008 2.18. FredriksenTan2008 200790%6Lall20012.18 GohGopinathan (2008)393 108. 2 0 1 0 2 42015Programa Brasil50% Alfabetizado (Fasih2008KinsellaHe2009, 2008a2005)1 2015(Maddox2008 50%Oxenham2008) 2 2000 201550% (Benavot,2008Fransman,2005)7.59 2015 201530 30. 50%20157.11958319902015100 94 109. 200513 2.292080%2.197.591516% 2.6122.6 50%70%2.302 22.62000-200715 2.291 (%)2 (), 21816759, 10 20752 0.75 , 13 0.61 , 14 7.59, 17 38153 29 58, 23 10.7 7108, 27 7106 , 47 72 36391, 49 9 36 , 71 253 9 33 0.64 , 270 2820061. 2. 1002. 95 110. 2 0 1 0 2 2.19 22% 2015 z 1701665 z 9%18655%7 5101150% z 150100 z 14% Burd-Sharps (2008); (2007); (2009); (2009)12% 200087%57% 2.201.5 Fransman2005 2008aAderinoyeRogers200566% 84% 2201550%10%10% 96 111. 2.30 2.20 2000-200725%15 1 (19) *2 29%LAMP (9) * * 36%LAMP* (41) * 2009c2009d * * * * Qiao200710%2000- *200784% * * 38% 2.31* * 10% 1,950 * 2000-2007* * * 0 10 2030 40 5060 70 80 10084% (%) 400 2 1. 1985-1994 2000-2007 2. 2 1.14 1985-19942000-2007 62%19902000 13% 400( 30% NCEDR2008)97 112. 2 0 1 0 2 2.311985-19942000-2007151 -70 -60 -50 -40 -30 -20 -10 010 20 30 40 5060 70 1985-19942000-20072006199420071. 2 1985-1994 44%66%37%59%45%31. ( GPI2008)1.091.001985-1994 83179 2000-2007 2 98 113. 2.32 1985-19942000-2007151 14%7% 2 2.32 ///2000-20073040 5060 7080 90 1001985-1994 (%)56 1985-19942000-2007 1985-19942000-2007 1 2253432% 1524 1524 2.33 60% 42% 5615241517%PortaPallaisLaguna, 2007) 2000-2007 76%28%( 16%2008)24%2 94% 72%(Daswani2005)99 114. 2 0 1 0 2 2.33KinsellaHe2009 2007 100 2008 80 60 (%) 40 2.34 20 0 65%75-8465-74 55-64 45-54 35-44 25-34 15-2496% 70%100 80 60 5% (%) 40 20 2015075-8465-74 55-64 45-54 35-44 25-34 15-242015 32 5 21%4%(Cueto 2009) ( 20102007) 2015 2015 29% 34% 7.1 AlagoasMaranhoParaba and20157.1Piau200650% 2.3532. 2.35 (2008)8,100 100 115. 2.3418100 90 80 / 70 60 * (%) 50 40 30 / 20 10 / 0 2003200520052005199920052004200520002001UNESCO-DME (2009)2015 2.3520151,600331997 1520072015201526020072009d/20152015//0 1020 30 40 (%)50%19991991100201533. 22009b2001101 116. 2 0 1 0 2 2003 1988 2012210 200222009Robinson20092008b2009 85% (CONFINTEA VI) 50% 2009 (Caillods1960Hallak2004Giffard-Lindsay2008 Lindt2008) Oxenham2008 Lindt2008 2.212000 2006310 30(2008)Richmond2008 201028%40%1%7% 2003200724%Richmond2008 1%2%Lindt2008 102 117. 2.21 1,400 (Programa BrasilAlfabetizado) 2003 3,6991,000 25% 15 1 800 2008 6818 200720072008 (2009) 252009 ( 2009ActionAid2008) 8Riddell2001 20002015AderinoyeRogers,2005 Duffy2008 103 118. 2 0 1 0 2 6 1 2 3 104 119. Altinok 2008 Hanushek Woessmann20092005 TIMSS 2007 TIMSS TIMSS(DasZajonc,2008) 2.36 TIMSS TIMSS 400 10%400 550 2007 18 2.36 2007TIMSS 800TIMSS 700 600 TIMSS 500 95 904003005020010 5100TIMSS 0 () () / 50% Mullis200810th50th percentile 90th 95th105 120. 2 0 1 0 2 2.362007b70%12.3810% 40%11 2005 2000200213,388 3434811 SACMEQ70% 6 2122242.372.3840%2007101120%TIMSS20%2.37 2.39 Segundo Estudio Regional ComparativoPISAy ExplicativoSERCE34. 2006 35. 13 12008 35 106 121. 2.37TIMSS2007 1008060 ()4020 020406080 100 () () Mullis200885%2007TIMSS40%17%16 9%16 Mullis2008 36 Das2006 2008 28% 20086 201536. TIMSS 52.22 14 16107 122. 2 0 1 02 2.38 2006PISA15 100 80605 ()404203 022011406080 100 1 5 2007b 2.39 2007 100806040 52043 012012.40TIMSS406080 100TIMSS 42%525 1 4 -2008 108 123. 2.22: 100 80 60z 200615 () 40 8%5 4 20 5%3 0 z 20TIMSS200713 2 201 13% 40 1 6025% 80z 200621 100 1515 z 2006SERCE16 z PASEC 368224 2000-2002165%SACMEQ13 1TIMSSDasZajonc2008 237 1. 0.65 2. 0.38 : Bonnet (2009); Ma (2007); Mullis (2008); 10%(2007b)2.41 38 37. 38. 110% 81%2007b109 124. 2 0 1 0 2 2.40 2.412007TIMSS 2006PISA () () 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 2007bMullis2008 39 2000-200239. SACMEQ2.23 37%Dolata2004 Das 2007 2006DasZajonc2008bSchutz2008 110 125. 2.23McEwan20041999 PISA z 2000200351%15%2006FUNDEF2.412000200615(GordonVegas2005)z 20002006123%16% z 2007b 8120.250.5Das2006 1242% 23%Himaz2009 2004 Cueto2009 Bamileke PASEC48%Ewondo 56%Fehrler3Michaelowa2009 (CONAFE) 2006SERCEVegasPetrow20086%Bonnet2009 111 126. 2 0 1 0 2 2008Woliso336%AfanOromo DeStefanoJukesElaheebocus20092006 40 Mam 40 Quiche 60Dowd2009 Abadzi2006Fuchs200177 15Abadzi200540 2.2440 Abadzi2006 2.25 41 52Crouch2009 422.7 2 80%40. KudoBazan(2009) 432007RTI2008 13 Mitton200841. 6 7080 218 342. 43. 40 112 127. 2.24 z z z z Abadzi (2006)KudoBazan2009 z 20082.72.25 2005 2007 1-36 1,200 20072104071460% 2008218 429 2008328 407 3 2006318 2,206 2008357 475 z 2007 1-3 19 502 2.24 z CastroLaguna (2008); CrouchKorda (2008);Crouch (2009); Jammeh (2008); KudoBazan (2009); SambeSprenger-Charolles (2008)z 3Banerjee2008 113 128. 2 0 1 0 2 192 97Dowd, 2009 DeStefanoElaheebocus2009 Dowd2009 2008b 44 80% 50% 2008c Michaelowa2001 70%50% 2008b (Boissiere2004Scheerens2004) 1988 AslamKingdon20072003 (White2004) 44. Boissiere,200445. 20062008Benavot200414142 80% (SchumacherHoffmann2008 2005) Abadzi, 2006 45 114 129. 200740:1 2.4210A 2007/ 54: 1 ()123:1 (Ruto2009) 60% 1%2007 1999 0 20 4060 80100 120 /4640:1 /10A10A 2009 Bennell2009 90:140:1Takala2003 2.43 9020062007 17126 4 10A Zhang2008/ 1:46 1:81Mulkeen2009/80:1 60%2.42401999Yumbe11%15 10AMulkeen200931%15% 46. MulkeenChen2008 2009Ple de Dakar,b 115 130. 2 0 1 02 2.43 2005/2006 2015190 120 2015 15% 2.444%18%020 406080 100 120 140 1999190 Ple de Dakar (2009)5.4 2015 48 2009e 840 BennellAkyeampong20072015 210 2015 47. 17% 60%15%35% 19% Mulkeen2009 15%2009e2015 201548. 1908405%1,030 20152009 47e2009e 116 131. 2.4420152015 4 1999-20072007-2015 1 1 2006 0510 15 20 2008a () (%) 30%1. 19992007-0.1% 2009e 117 132. 2 0 1 02 41% MullkeenChen2008 Leu2004LewinStuart2003 118 133. 468i2716051 2005 10 110 3746 49 160 1.5%50 25012 49. (EPDC)2009 50. 20082015 51. 420062007494.755% 0.7%70 27460% /119 134. 2 0 1 02 2003 Bruns2003 362000 2002 562000 2007 52 110 2003 52. 200920Van 53RavensAggio, 2005 2003 53. 20094 4946 4 100 2.26 120 135. 2.26 2.27 z z z 2009VanRavensAggio20072008201552% 2015100%542015 2015201588%2.8 54. 42% 121 136. 2 0 1 0 2 2.846 2015 2015 2007 16% 52%95% 108%172% 100%69%100% 44% 88% 199959% 80% 2.91. 10%2.27 2006/20072013%6% 33:151:1Chang2009 122 137. 2.272.9 2.92015 4.5GDP 3GDP4.5GDP3GDP6GDP3.5GDP 20 4035 33%33% 40%113, 50013, 500 13, 500 10% 10% 25%25% 25% 50%50% 50% GDP5% GDP7.5% 33%33% 2007 106681192015 106125 16220151. 2%: 2009 123 138. 2 0 1 02 40% 58 40% 2015 GDP8.9%5.3% VanRavensAggio, 20052007 1.351.755 30%Theunynck, 2009 55. 2007bTheunynck2009325% 56. Bennell,2009a 57. 56 GDP2.53.0 57 2.958. 40:159. 3GDP5%Bundy2009aFiszbein2009a59 124 139. GDP5%7.5%Chanamuto2009 33% ChenMulkeen, 2008Mulkeen, 2009a 603 DME 1722 2.10 2008 -20153 2,860360 2007 120 2.10 * 200720070.811.1 11.94.716.62008-2015 60.4 220.4 5.1285.9127.8 413.72008-2015 7.527.5 0.6 35.7 16.051.72008-2015 3940 40 3639 4127 30 303014 11 1211 2020 20 222160. 2007 Van RavensAggio, 200520092008-2015125 140. 2 0 1 02 3 7 1 4 % (2.10) 320 620 91 61 40% 200713 2.45 1606202.45622015200715%2.46 2.46 2015 2015 13% 0 20 40 60 80 100 61. 2.90 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 (%) 62. Theunynck (2009)1.1/ 2009 2009Theunynck (2009) 126 141. 2.47 2007 46 2015 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 1416 18 2020072.2720092.47 63. 642.5% 64. 63 6420152009f 127 142. 2 0 1 0 2 a 2.4817%b 20%c70% 65 34%201564 2015 0.920151/3 2.484.54.0 200520073.53.02.52.01.51.00.50.065. 200920094 20092009f 128 143. 2015 2/3 2.49 2.11 2.4940 35 (2008-2015) (2006-2007) 36030 30160200710 (20 )160 1102520 40 15 30 10 5120 0 Constant 2007 US$ billions200520104200520102009-2009d 129 144. 2 0 1 02 2.112008-2015 (2007 10) (%)(%) (%) 5.8 6623 29 9.8 6828 48 0.6 4237 51 16.2 6627 41 8.8 6035 42 25.0 6430 42 2015 2009 2015 66%106 41%67 30% 250106 2015 66 1.5% 20082015 160 5 2005 272.49672010 666. 2008201567. 420062007494.755% 130 145. 2005 110 2.49201020152015 131 146. 2 0 1 0 3 Ami Vitale/PANOS1321 33 212 147. 2 0 1 0 Giacomo Pirozzi/PANOS Abbie Trayler-Smith/PANOS 133133 148. 2 0 1 0 3 135 ............................................................................................................................................................................... ? .................................................................................................. 138 ................................................................................................................................................ 164 ...................................................................................................................................................... 186 134 149. 1994144 1960 1 1AmartyaSen (a) (b) Sen2009vii(196011) 1. Kabeer 19482005Sayed 19892007 Klasen 2001 Ferreira Gignoux20082005f135 150. 2 0 1 0 3 1989 28 19903 2000 IV52 2015 2 2015 1990 136 151. 1 1 2 3 DME 137 152. 2 0 1 03 198929 Klasen2001 2. ICF Macro 80http://www.measuredhs.com 38 2 http://www. unicef.org/statistics/index_24302.html 138 153. 4 41722 22.001.25 4 20% 2 17 2242 20%20% 3.16317 22 4 10152230%1722 41150%2219Bourguignon 2007FerreiraGignoux2008 422005f 8410%172244 139 154. 2 0 1 03 3.1 421722 10090 2480 42 (%)70605040302010 0 2005 2003 2003200020032005 2005 2005 2003 2007200220062005200620002005 2000 200020002003 200520042006 2005 200320012004 2005 2005 2001 200520042007 2003 2005 8 68 20092 4 17224 250% 3.13.1 20% 4 4 4 4 140 155. 100 90 80 42 (%) 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 20052005 2004 20052004 2006200619992007 2005 2003 2005 20052006 20042004 20052005 200520032005 2005 200520042001 2003 2006 2000 6 38%7164 26% 90%1722 4 20%30% 17221722716 3.2 141 156. 2 0 1 03 3.2 2005 80 70 60 50 SSA20% 40 SSA20% SWA20% 30 SWA20% 20 10 SSA20% SWA20%03.42327 1722 716 SSASWA 2009 108540% 410 3.3 1722 5 20%114 4 431722 2 2 40%34 3 142 157. 3.317224 14 000 12 000 10 000 () 8 000 6 000 4 000 2 000 0010 20 3040 50607080 901004 (%)20091 10 3.585%1722 2 6 3.5 90% 60% 143 158. 2 0 1 0 3 3.4 172220052005 14 14 12 1220% 10 20% 10 88 20% 6 6 20%4 4 22 00 2009 3.5 17222 m39 85 61 83/ f 60 88 6090 42 (%) m 751951 f 9929 62 17 85 17783587 m 2694/ f53 9642 87 m17 6830 79 f 33 91 3884 m 437141 50 f 57 80 4053 02040 60 80 100 0 2040 6080 100 (2009)17222 (%) HarttgenKlasen (2009) 144 159. 90%17224 200314 12 90%1722 20%10 23.1 1.88 3.2 176 224 3.6 1.84 20% 3.2 2 1722 04 75 3.2 10 3.617224 3.247%60% 5.710 17224 11%19%200926% 145 160. 2 0 1 0 3 3.6 17224 100 80 4 (%)60 40 20 0 2009 50 13% 40%TruongHuyen2009 1722 6.7 2 Hall 23.10 1.8 Patrinos2006 1722 24 6.71.817224 146 161. 3.110% 20% 200650020%17222 18020%416%7-16 40% (2007d)Higgins(2009) (2005)83%172223.120023.73.112(%) 83 83 89 903.7 79 7617222 79 77 83 79 82 76 84 82 22 19 78 75 87 82 21 18 17 19 020 4060 80100 80 72 82 78 2 (%) 88 81HarttgenKlasen (2009) 147 162. 2 0 1 0 3 3.2 10%2015200792%20151001999 20%3.83.820%172003172222720%412106%7-1686 423.96%17220 41%2%2009 3.22005 (%)*4 (%)* 65 54 6.65.7 26 68 64 7.17.0 19 59 57 7.17.4 14 69 61 7.16.7 16 68 65 7.37.1 20 69 66 8.28.2 11 75 74 8.99.46 84 8410.0 10.13 74 72 9.09.06*1722HarttgenKlasen (2009) 148 163. 20052.1% 3.920031722415% 10% 5% 0%0% 5%10% 15% 20% 25%30% 35% 40% 45% 50% 17224 (2009) (2006) 3.10 1722430% 105%3.1186 304Alid2006217221 (2009580% 0 ) Harttgen Klasen(2009)44 149 164. 2 0 1 03 3.11 17224 100 80 4 (%) 60 40 - 20 0 * (2009)* HarttgenKlasen (2009)10%20%60% 4 10% 20%60% 2%7%1722 420% 21% 17 22 3 3.12 150 165. 20%3.1220051722 14 12 10 20% 20% 8 20% 6 20% 4 3.132 0% 20% 2 020% 20093.14 3.1320%20% 20% 20%3.15 20% 20%320% 20%0%20% 40%60% 80%100%86% 20%20%1722 200943%151 166. 2 0 1 03 3.1420%3.16 20% 20% 2* 0% 20%40%60% 20%20%1722* 2 (2009)HarttgenKlasen200912% 20%60%82% 2 3.15 *172243%17 20%2226% 97%17 20% 22212% : - 3.17 90%20%17220%20% 40%60% 3 29%41% * (2009)Harttgen Klasen (2009) 20% 152 167. 3.161722225 97 126612 741577 896309117 84 32 61 3173 4168 6 435888 196660 82 20 5767 760 20 4060 80100020 40 6080100 (%) 2 (%)2009 97% 3.17 1722 2 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / (%)1 5741 3 1 2 320% (%) 8943 32 4325 45 8842 77 (2009) HarttgenKlasen (2009)153 168. 2 0 1 0 3 0.8117%2 (McEwanTrowbridge2007) (Cueto2009)1.221.07 200730%(Altinok2009)10%10%(FehrlerMichaelowa2009)(FehrlerMichaelowa2009) 2001 PISA15 (2004) 20%20%25%30%(Vegas Petrow2008)36%55% 72%87%(VegasPetrow2008) 154 169. 20068%1619 Lochner2004Machin 17%2006 5% 11% 2007 Bridgeland2006) 10042 84% 84%72% 65%(HeckmanLaFontaine2007 ) 65% 30% 35%(TylerLofstrom2009) 2006200615%182415 14%10%20% 30% (2008) 2007b 155 170. 2 0 1 0 3 3. 18 16% 29% Vignoles2009 2008 1515%217200875% 3.18 15 6 520075 TIMSS4 48 3 2 3.191 00 5 10 15 20 25 (%)PISA SES 1 (2006a2007a) 1. 5 156 171. 2007b 3.192006 2007PISA2 6503.2010% 600 ( 5502007a) 500 450 10% 400 HanushekWmann2006 350Gonzales20083.20Nusche20092006215*2006b)402 (%)305% 70%2022006b10 0 * 2 (2007a107) (2007a)3.33. 3 20%25% 157 172. 2 0 1 03 15%20%2009 30% 2%25% 2007 34%15 24 55% 3.21 70% 50% 2007 65% NCEA2 (200732)44% 20093.38001,200 2005-2015 (2007) (2007) (2009a) 158 173. 3.21 2006 100 8060 40 2020070 10% (2008)A3.4190Biddle Mackay (2009 )20%Martin2008 3.3 159 174. 2 0 1 0 3 3.31 20%(4)(20%() 20%20% 20% 20% ) ()(%) (%) 20059.99.99.9 11.58.7 2.7 32.5 1.0 1.10.90.9 20059.29.39.29.88.2 1.6 21.5 0.9 1.40.62.3 2006 10.6 10.8 10.5 11.49.7 1.7 34.9 2.3 1.33.16.4 20045.85.95.78.03.6 4.4 40.427.4 26.428.1 50.1 20058.58.48.68.77.4 1.3 28.1 3.5 4.72.12.8 20064.66.03.47.72.2 5.6 31.647.8 33.460.5 85.0 20039.69.89.3 11.26.4 4.8 56.6 6.1 4.18.1 30.1 2005 11.2 11.1 11.2 11.7 10.4 1.4 29.4 0.6 0.70.42.0 20032.32.72.05.60.6 4.9 28.270.9 66.575.1 93.1 20054.64.84.56.62.6 4.0 32.936.6 34.538.5 64.6 20056.06.55.58.23.4 4.8 36.326.8 22.530.9 62.8 20046.46.96.08.83.5 5.3 50.821.4 16.126.2 63.9 20000.91.20.71.70.5 1.2 22.089.2 86.092.3 99.7 20042.73.91.86.71.0 5.7 32.967.3 53.079.0 92.2 20059.18.79.5 10.96.4 4.5 47.2 6.7 8.45.0 18.9 20057.27.37.18.95.4 3.5 37.812.4 11.113.4 27.2 20076.27.05.49.14.4 4.7 29.925.4 15.634.5 57.0 20044.35.53.36.32.1 4.2 23.849.2 36.559.5 84.8 2005 11.3 11.1 11.6 11.7 10.6 1.1 25.1 1.1 1.40.80.7 20079.28.79.8 10.86.2 4.6 43.0 7.9 10.3 5.5 22.0 20058.99.48.59.86.4 3.4 39.515.0 9.7 20.2 47.9 20053.13.82.57.51.6 5.9 32.961.1 51.870.2 87.4 20007.37.67.08.45.0 3.4 41.1 9.8 8.2 11.2 24.2 20055.46.24.78.12.4 5.7 30.040.4 31.648.0 80.2 2005 11.6 11.5 11.8 12.6 10.3 2.2 38.0 0.7 1.00.50.7 20037.17.56.89.23.3 5.8 52.520.3 15.923.9 67.2 19995.86.05.78.81.8 7.0 47.935.6 33.137.9 86.2 20053.54.92.35.81.0 4.8 31.756.4 39.671.1 94.5 20053.84.73.06.21.7 4.5 36.049.7 37.759.9 90.3 20056.46.46.38.53.3 5.2 45.423.2 23.423.1 59.0 20057.67.18.1 10.54.0 6.5 42.418.1 21.414.9 42.8 20057.28.16.5 11.14.2 6.9 50.223.6 15.630.7 60.1 20039.09.09.1 11.16.6 4.5 41.1 4.4 4.34.5 12.6 20055.86.25.37.23.9 3.3 39.620.6 15.326.2 56.9 2005 10.3 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.0 0.5 27.5 0.5 0.30.70.0 2007 11.5 11.3 11.8 12.1 11.4 0.6 21.6 2.0 1.92.12.5 2005 12.3 12.1 12.5 13.2 11.4 1.8 27.0 0.4 0.40.30.2 20037.57.57.59.55.4 4.1 35.212.0 12.311.7 27.6 2005 10.6 10.5 10.7 10.9 10.4 0.5 17.4 0.5 0.70.31.6 20008.28.87.78.15.9 2.3 34.613.6 9.6 17.2 42.5 20046.85.97.78.84.6 4.2 40.415.4 25.3 5.5 11.9 20075.05.74.57.22.6 4.6 46.135.7 27.642.4 79.3 160 175. (4) (2)716 20% 2 (%) (%)(%) 2.0 2.10.9 1.10.70.60.70.5 0.9 3.2 3.40.7 1.00.43.74.03.4 5.6 - 5.8 2.51.1 0.71.42.21.82.7 4.7 34.6 1.3 19.5 17.720.8 10.6 11.99.213.5 5.5 1.62.3 3.51.10.70.70.8 0.6 91.2 1.9 40.7 26.153.4 28.3 23.3 33.854.1 15.2 2.51.7 1.02.21.61.51.7 4.0 0.3 0.40.30.80.90.7 0.5 92.3 1.3 66.9 61.971.6 63.2 59.5 67.083.5 52.1 1.4 24.4 22.026.6 19.2 17.4 21.038.5 70.4 2.6 12.4 8.7 15.99.19.68.717.3 65.4 3.1 15.0 9.4 20.1 13.0 10.8 15.233.2 98.1 1.1 76.5 70.882.0 48.2 42.9 53.678.3 96.7 1.4 57.6 43.669.1 54.2 47.6 60.880.3 8.5 1.32.8 3.62.11.72.01.3 4.2 18.9 1.55.4 4.66.04.54.04.9 8.8 44.5 1.8 15.4 7.5 22.8 18.9 16.2 21.835.7 77.0 1.6 41.9 29.751.8 33.0 30.0 35.952.5 2.0 1.80.6 0.70.60.30.30.3 0.1 24.7 3.14.0 5.22.71.92.41.5 3.7 28.1 1.9 12.5 6.9 18.2 10.88.3 13.527.3 86.3 1.4 49.8 39.260.4 48.1 46.5 49.962.4 13.3 1.45.2 4.55.92.62.62.6 3.1 79.4 2.0 38.6 30.345.8 29.0 27.8 30.248.7 2.4 3.30.6 0.80.40.50.40.7 1.1 61.6 3.0 16.6 12.120.4 21.0 20.5 21.552.5 61.3 1.7 19.1 15.522.5 13.0 10.9 15.234.2 73.7 1.3 52.0 35.466.6 44.9 40.8 49.268.1 77.1 1.6 37.3 23.848.8 28.0 27.3 28.644.2 50.8 2.2 10.3 9.4 11.2 11.6 12.5 10.726.7 41.5 2.37.8 9.46.35.16.14.1 9.4 42.8 1.8 20.3 12.127.7 13.2 10.7 15.929.1 12.9 2.91.5 1.41.72.02.21.9 5.4 24.3 1.2 13.1 8.4 18.19.96.1 13.835.1 0.4 0.20.70.30.20.4 1.3 2.5 1.21.6 1.51.70.80.90.7 1.2 1.3 3.30.3 0.40.30.60.50.6 0.3 74.7 6.27.9 7.08.86.76.37.017.1 2.3 5.00.3 0.50.22.12.71.6 2.3 17.6 1.37.8 5.79.75.44.76.119.9 -30.6 2.08.2 14.7 1.75.98.53.1 5.3 54.0 1.5 21.9 14.428.2 43.9 42.3 45.569.2161 176. 2 0 1 0 3 3.3 20%(4)(20%() 20%20% 20% 20% ) ()(%) (%) 2005 10.5 10.1 10.9 11.97.3 4.7 22.5 3.2 3.92.67.0 20044.54.54.59.81.7 8.1 53.548.3 46.949.8 83.1 20046.26.55.98.64.8 3.8 29.123.6 20.626.2 37.4 20012.63.32.05.80.7 5.1 26.168.8 60.376.0 94.0 20058.88.59.1 10.76.0 4.7 52.5 9.0 10.6 7.5 22.4 2005 11.2 11.2 11.2 12.29.3 2.9 39.6 2.4 1.83.03.8 20045.76.65.08.42.0 6.4 41.337.1 27.045.9 87.6 20033.23.72.85.01.9 3.2 27.856.5 49.862.7 87.1 20005.65.75.57.73.6 4.1 32.725.1 22.027.9 56.1 20078.48.08.8 10.56.8 3.6 32.2 8.9 12.0 6.2 12.1 20065.97.15.08.73.3 5.4 40.929.9 16.839.0 67.4 20016.66.27.09.52.5 6.9 51.823.3 27.519.2 60.7 20061.72.41.25.50.6 4.9 26.376.9 68.482.8 94.7 20036.77.46.09.73.5 6.2 48.527.9 19.635.4 66.7 20075.76.55.09.02.4 6.5 34.034.5 25.942.5 84.9 2004 10.1 10.2 10.0 11.57.4 4.1 53.3 3.5 2.35.0 16.9 20039.48.9 10.0 11.06.3 4.7 55.4 5.0 6.73.2 16.3 20053.83.83.85.52.9 2.6 28.545.3 45.145.4 59.1 20008.48.98.0 11.35.9 5.4 30.810.8 8.7 12.5 17.8 20053.23.92.75.11.2 4.0 28.657.4 50.363.3 87.6 2005 11.1 10.9 11.3 11.98.3 3.6 17.1 1.1 1.31.03.8 20053.84.82.66.91.4 5.6 32.353.7 42.067.3 88.9 20053.14.82.06.60.4 6.2 31.563.5 44.675.7 98.3 20007.67.47.99.56.1 3.4 34.011.6 11.711.6 13.0 20068.07.88.29.46.4 3.0 34.7 9.1 10.6 7.7 18.8 20058.18.18.09.86.2 3.6 37.4 6.8 5.18.9 27.0 20059.6 10.39.1 10.89.2 1.6 24.9 3.7 2.25.17.7 20045.55.65.47.93.9 4.0 37.626.7 23.929.0 48.8 20056.57.25.58.24.1 4.1 34.922.3 15.730.5 64.4 2000 10.4 10.2 10.7 11.99.4 2.5 36.9 0.6 0.60.7 20038.18.87.49.26.3 2.9 28.7 7.9 3.8 12.0 21.4 20066.56.96.28.54.3 4.1 40.616.7 12.720.1 45.3 2007 13.0 12.8 13.1 13.3 12.4 0.9 21.5 0.3 0.50.20.0 20009.18.59.6 11.85.5 6.2 52.615.0 20.511.0 19.4 20028.38.48.3 10.45.3 5.2 51.0 8.7 8.78.7 29.7 20056.78.64.93.2 51.628.7 10.446.2 89.9 20016.46.76.18.94.0 4.9 39.820.3 16.024.2 46.5 20068.68.78.69.97.0 2.9 45.8 2.8 3.02.78.0 1. 1722 2. 2009 162 177. (4)(2)716 20% 2 (%) (%)(%) 7.5 2.32.3 2.52.12.21.92.5 1.5 68.2 1.4 27.5 26.328.8 17.3 18.0 16.630.0 26.5 1.1 11.0 8.3 13.49.7 10.58.912.3 88.6 1.3 65.1 56.772.1 52.7 48.4 57.075.3 19.0 2.14.8 5.93.82.63.31.9 5.2 4.0 1.72.2 1.62.71.41.51.2 0.7 - 51.9 1.4 29.9 18.839.4 10.57.4 13.634.9 75.1 1.3 40.2 33.446.5 26.7 23.3 30.244.0 74.5 3.09.2 7.4 10.89.09.09.020.528.0 3.15.6 7.34.14.44.84.0 6.5 (Madhyamanchal) 35.0 1.2 22.8 10.031.89.34.9 13.626.2 57.1 2.4 13.5 16.110.9 11.9 13.6 10.232.4 86.6 1.1 73.7 64.480.3 60.4 53.5 67.579.1 58.0 2.1 25.3 17.032.7 25.4 20.9 30.054.7 47.6 1.4 30.7 21.639.2 23.6 17.1 30.263.0 16.8 4.81.2 0.62.00.70.70.7 1.8 14.1 2.81.8 2.11.32.42.81.9 5.9 55.4 1.2 20.8 20.121.4 10.9 11.6 10.313.7 24.9 2.35.8 4.66.96.46.56.415.0 78.7 1.4 50.4 42.856.6 39.0 37.9 40.059.1 2.1 1.81.0 1.20.80.60.40.8 2.7 66.7 1.2 48.5 37.161.8 24.8 22.9 26.746.5 72.7 1.1 57.1 39.368.6 57.6 48.7 65.294.6 62.1 5.36.0 5.26.83.83.83.7 2.5 16.2 1.85.2 5.45.14.34.93.6 6.8 22.4 3.34.9 3.46.72.42.12.8 7.8 4.9 1.32.1 1.72.45.54.66.5 8.0 50.3 1.9 20.5 16.823.8 19.3 20.0 18.528.5 54.5 2.4 15.1 9.8 21.8 15.2 11.9 18.834.3 2.1 3.30.6 0.60.60.20.20.3 21.4 2.76.0 2.19.94.32.36.312.3 29.0 1.78.3 5.7 10.56.36.16.517.1 0.7 2.20.3 0.50.11.01.20.7 0.4 4.0 5.72.74.65.53.612.0 18.2 2.14.3 4.14.41.71.42.0 5.7 54.4 1.9 23.6 6.7 39.8 21.1 14.3 27.958.2 39.5 1.9 11.5 8.9 14.0 23.1 22.9 23.439.9 1.3 1.31.31.92.11.7 2.9 163 178. 2 0 1 0 3 2 200514 1.25 40% 2 3.22 164 179. 3.22 20050.7325Chen 2 000 1 80021.25Ravallion2008 1 6001.25 1 400 1 200 1 0000.73800600 4002000 1.25 (%) 5140 17 8 (2005) 0.730.93 0.950.7720095,500 20051.2512009 ChenRavallion20082009k 12% 42000 4 20092010 10% 120%122200819992007144. 200720062009g165 180. 2 0 1 03 40% 2009 2008 3.4 2006a10 2006h2007 c50 Tsujita2009 2006Ferreira c2005 Schady2008 2006b 2007bAlderman2006 Ferreira Schady 2008 Lincove2009 71420055 5. 14%2009 199711 Thomas2004 Read2008 166 181. 3.4 2003 89% 90%1722 2 Rufai2006 86 6Rufai2006Akyeampong 14 2009 14 2009 LewisLockheed200720072008Bjorkman200510Alderman2006Alderman2009 52007200841%2007 Raihan2009200211997Ravallion2008 Hossain2009 167 182. 2 0 1 03 Gunnarsson2006 Sanchez2009 1 Blanco Allais Quinn200920% 2009 2004514 1. 66 Hagemann 2006 7 5%Tufail2005 8%14% 2003 2007 2004 Blanco Allais 6 Quinn2009 2008 2009 30 Edmonds20076. 3.5 11 Gunnarsson2006 168 183. 23.55Kingvan de Walle20072005714Hallman2007 80%20%3.23372471530%20%Beegle3.2320062005714 , 29%, 21%, 32%, 18%, , 41% , 35%12% ,12%200920052005 1314 2009 169