2-18-1029 (SAN MATEO COUNTY HARBOR DISTRICT) MARCH 6, … · SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94015 PHONE: (415) 904-5260 FAX: (415) 904-5400 WEB: W11a 2-18-1029 (SAN MATEO COUNTY HARBOR DISTRICT)

STATE OF CALIFORNIA—NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY GAVIN NEWSOME, GOVERNOR

CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION NORTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT OFFICE

45 FREMONT STREET, SUITE 2000

SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94015

PHONE: (415) 904-5260

FAX: (415) 904-5400

WEB: WWW.COASTAL.CA.GOV

W11a

2-18-1029 (SAN MATEO COUNTY HARBOR DISTRICT)

MARCH 6, 2019

EXHIBITS

Table of Contents

EXHIBITS

Exhibit 1 – Location Map

Exhibit 2 – Existing Site Photos

Exhibit 3 – Proposed Hoist Plan

Exhibit 4 – Harbor District Approval

Exhibit 5 – Public Access in Area

Exhibit 6 – Commercial Fishing Community Comments

Exhibit 7 – California Fish and Game Commission Comments

Exhibit 8 – Johnson Pier Common Area Passageway

Exhibit 9 – Correspondence

Pillar Point Harbor

Johnson Pier

Exhibit 1 2-18-1029

Page 1 of 1

Three Captains Hoist

Morning Star Fisheries Hoist

Work/Impound Dock

Pillar Point Seafood Hoists

Fish Buyers Building

Fueling

Storage

Exhibit 2 2-18-1029

Page 1 of 3

Fish Buyers Building

Exhibit 2 2-18-1029

Page 2 of 3

Existing Hoist Three Captains Hoist

Existing Hoists Pillar Point Seafood Existing Hoist

Morning Star Fisheries

Exhibit 2 2-18-1029

Page 3 of 3

Location for New Hoist Edge of the South Side of

Johnson Pier

Aerial Photo Location for New Hoist

South Side of Johnson Pier

Exhibit 3 2-18-1029

1 of 2

Plan View New Hoist Location

South Side of Johnson Pier

Elevation View New 19-ft Tall Hoist

Three Captains in Fish Buyers Building

Exhibit 3 2-18-1029

2 of 2

Resolution No. 18-15of the

San Mateo County Harbor Districtto

Authorize Three Captains Seafood to Install and Use a Hoist on theSouth Side of Johnson Pier

Whereas, in March, 2013, the San Mateo County Harbor District (District) entered into alease with Three Captains Sea Products, Inc. (Three Captains) for a fish buying facility onJohnson Pier (the. Lease); and

Whereas, in March 28, 2014, the San Mateo County Harbor District's then Harbor Masterauthorized Three Captains to install a hoist on the south side of Johnson Pier for a one-yeartrial period, in accordance with the terms of the Lease; and.

Whereas, after the one-year trial period ended, the hoist was removed and the District'sBoard of Harbor Commissioners (Commission), at its meeting on October 5, 2016, ultimatelyapproved a request by Three Captains to install a hoist on the north side of Johnson Pier;and

Whereas, at a special meeting on February 5, 2018, the Commissionconsidered the impactsof Three Captains' additional hoist on the operations of Johnson Pier and rescinded its earlierapproval for Three Captains to install a hoist at the location on the north side ofJohnson Pier;and

Whereas, Three Captains disputed the Commission's February 5, 2018 action, among otherthings, and subsequently Three Captains and the District submitted a dispute regarding thehoist to binding arbitration, pursuant to the terms of the Lease, and the arbitrator on October12, 2018 issued a Final Award, directing the District to authorize Three Captains to install asecond hoist on the south side of Johnson Pier.

Now Therefore, be it resolved that the Board of htarbor Commissioners of the San MateoCounty Harbor District authorizes Three Captains to install and use a second hoist at thesouth sidelocation originally approved by the Harbor Master on March 28, 2014 describedon the map attached as Exhibit A to this Resolution; and

Be it Further Resolved, that the Board of Harbor Commissioners of the San Mateo CountyHarbor District finds the installation of the hoist at the location specified on Exhibit A iscategorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant toCEQA Guideline 15300 et seq. ; and

Be it Further Resolved, that the Board of Harbor Commissioners of the San Mateo CountyHarbor District authorizes and directs the General Manager to take all actions necessary togive effect to this Resolution and to ensure continued safe operations of Johnson Pier.

Resolution No.18-15 Authorize Three Captains Seafood to Install and Use a Hoist on the South Side ofJohnson Pier

Exhibit 4 2-18-1029

1 of 3

Approved this 17th day of October 2018 at the regular meeting of the Board of Commissionersby a recorded vote as follows:

For: Chang Kiraly, Mattusch, Larenas

Against: Brennan

Absent: Bemardo

Abstention:

ttested BOARD OF HARBOR COMMISSIONERS

/< - tebbie Gehre

Deputy Secretiroini;i Chan

President

i.u^iraly ^

Resolution No.18-15 Authorize Three Captains Seafood to Install and Use a Hoist on the South Side ofJohnson Pier

Exhibit 4 2-18-1029

2 of 3

Exhibit A

Hoist location on Johnson Pier

10/17/18

Exhibit 4 2-18-1029

3 of 3

1

2 3

4

1. Perched Beach 2. Johnson Pier Main Stem 3. Public Access Path Along Harbor Area 4. Shoreline Beach Area

3

Public Access

Exhibit 5 2-18-1029

1 of 1

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 1 of 19

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 2 of 19

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 3 of 19

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Mve V-

Printed Name and Signature:

Address: fI 1v\g^ 0 1 A\/

CM^cSZ^

SqI _AIk ^ WeL (><iYears Fishing: ^ 5Q|

Home Port: _by CQ-,Printed Name and Signature:

Address:

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing:

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signature:

Address:

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing:

Home Port:

5874814.

t

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 4 of 19

Printed Name and Signature:

Address:

h)mtlKVessel Name:

Fisheries: i

Years Fishing: ^ ^Home Port:. H-hU^ A/QoV

Printed Name and Signature:,

Address: C-^Vessel Name:.

Fisheries:

Years Fishing:

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signature:. fii'i.l L'0U.^€mOAddress: 1^681 S4'

/Vessel Name

Fisheries:

\ I

Years Fishing:

Home Port:

I 6

5874814 IExhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 5 of 19

Printed Name and Signature:

Address: h/Uci 6^l/\dVessel Name:_ C£^

Fisheries: _ rA.c^i / J^lYears Fishing:

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signature:

Address ^T. HM8

Vessel Name

Fisheries:ies:^Siato

Years Fishing:

Mh6y^ho(/T£f?lSyHome Port

Printed Name and Signature:

Address: 1^^^

Vessel Name: Cn M\ j/Fisheries: ^Q-0

Years Fishing: l^c>/^ yQAA5=^

Home Port: K-j

|7

5874814 IExhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 6 of 19

' X x.rA-Address: "7^-^ A^ 4^\-f^\^/^Vessel Name:_

Fisheries: (^ r'X> /^Years Fishing: •^2-

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signature:

Address:

Vessel Name: cCt-v, C3 ): j C^6 AFisheries

Years Fishing:.

Home Port:_

Printed Name and Signature:,

Address: PO 6c><. ^OaWa C./V tW<^3>7Vessel Name:_ ^AN/g:

Fisheries: _ cr" (Lc>hl (KcM" (,0^Years Fishing: ^

Home Port:

18

5874814.1Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 7 of 19

isnst.re: /^CPrinted Name and Sign

Address: ^H AvfcVessel Name:

Fisheries: &MlYears Fishing: O" '̂

Home Port: <5r^ ^

Printed Name and Signature:

Address

Vessel Name:

Fisheries :

Years Fishing: JL.

Home Port:

Printed Namie and Signature: So

Address: :^(0

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:(

Years Fishing:

Home Port:

r^eJ-H 6-A/A^30 +

i 9

5874814 ! Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 8 of 19

Printed Name and Signature:.

Address:

Vessel Name:.

Fisheries:

me: ^ >.—^

d-r-c4? SYears Fishing:

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signature:.

Address: ^ Lo/T/^g ^ rTVessel Name:

Fisheries

Years Fishing: -4£

Home Port: fnUr 7"

Printed Name and Signature:

Address:"^^ | VNaoq

Vessel Name:_ V^^V^e^ K^otT

Fisheries: SwA-f^r-) » o-^

Years Fishing: __rX

Home Port: P. PA V)o,t^b3»^

5874814Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 9 of 19

Address; ^-3J^Vessel Name:^3^^SV'W.^W%

Fisheries: N{^^<\%V7:sJVv

Years Fishing:

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signaiure:

Address: _ HAVO/yVp-

Vessel Name: AjuLL^. <l STAc^Fisheries: P<:<fevi S-koP^ts, i^-hAJl

Years Fishing:

Home Port:_ f^LL Ah po/nr?

Printed Name and Signaiu e:

Address:

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing: le? ..

Home Port:.

5874814 !Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 10 of 19

Printed Name and S'gnaiure: MIAddress:

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing: 40

Home Port Csiv%. ayj^ [kl4 -Meo/^-^

Printed Name and SignaturG:_

Address: -h^-oK St^ Ck 44'Vessel Name: (Sc^Th^ Gh^Fisheries: gyj ^i-Ar^AA-

5'Years Fishing:

Home Port:__

Printed Name and Signature:

Address:.

Vessel Name:

Fisheries: ^Years Fishing:

Home Port:_

5874«MExhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 11 of 19

Printed Name and

Vessel Name;

Fisheries:

Years Fishing:

Home Port

Signatijre: (2-lgW^ R .Address: vWUK^^rKTu-vr __togrA

Printed Name and 5igna:Lira:_

Address:

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing:

Home Port

4t)^ GjVt'^Tv^/oc) f/^0

Printed Name and Signatu

Address:

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing: _

Home Port:

5874814 Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 12 of 19

cso 2(^7

location, It will allow easier access for all of the flsherman that deliver to threeCaptains because they will not have to transport sear and fish through thebuildingto and from our vessels.

In summary, the addition of tWs hoist will have no adverse impacts on any of fishing orsbOftfishlng aedvities to' or from Johnson Pier or PHIar Point Harbor. Indh^ually andcollectively vVe strongly support the waiver and request that the California coastal commissionapprove Coastal Development Permit (COP) Waiver 2-14-i502rW.

Thank you.

Printed Name and Signature: ^ ^

Address: «VS4- Y { lJ

vS ^ ^ ~ "Vessel Name: L

Fisheries: ]Years Fishing: l ><:,?

^ ^ !J > II •

Home Port: ^ C\

.-'v V

AddfMs: '

^ (=Vessel Name: X

Fisheries: A * ^

VbarsFishing: X

Home Port: -jio

f 0 c I 2

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 13 of 19

Prints Name and Siiaiature; ^ Vv V i )

Address: »^Vessel Name: ^Fisheries: ^ fn

uYears Fishing:

Hbme Port: t ^ ^!i> /

Printed N^eand Signature: ^ t\kr / .1'[ My ^^ / /'Address: i J '- •» >^tA P/x- .

Ve^ Name:j: ( i (;,. 1^) ^ ^

j (X. {fi-l /; t\/^ ^^ ^fisheries: y

Years Fishing: ^

Home Port: Ti I'A 1

Printed Name and Signature:^ »i ^ / |3 ) k '̂r ' '" I

Address: I t * ^a.. <r ^vessel Name; ^ t̂ i \ ^ C.Fisheries: v ^ ^ \'-^

Years Fishing: f ,

Home Port: ^ I ^

V 17

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 14 of 19

Printed Name and Signaturdft^^/^ .uAddress:—f f C> L. .

Vessel Name:

Fisheries:

Years Fishing ^<? —7

Home Port: —

Printed Name and Sifineture:

Address: /S V'3 CA/ L-j^iyVessel Name:_ M)S-h^Fisheries:. CP-^BYears Fishing: ^ O

Home Port:

Printed Name and Sliinature:^i.t^/i^_ /? /Addr«s: 3-^fo iSrSvtp

Vessel Name: fIv^ TSySLAJFisheries: CJij9-Q^. trl^l/laJ^ 'THaiv /..Years Fishing; *30 "f-

Home Poit.Qa>to<^

'̂ .••r:'- IS

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 15 of 19

Printed Narne and Signature: • v A .v

if />• 0 /•"• ^5...Address: ^y/Tigk Q:,

Vessei Name:e)> /J

Flsliei-tesi /" c

Yeai^ Fishing: • . ^ .

Hdme Port: hfM. /$

Printed Name and Signature: tTz-A^n^ Coras'Address:. 35^:? ^ AftA ^r.sf=cArVessel Nam^i

Fisheries:.

Veai3 Fishing:

: AHome Port

Printed Name and Siiaiature: 1/ ^

, Address; W^Q:hrn^r^' Ve$se) Name:

Pisfteriai; f O? g4^ i^ ^Years Fishing:

Home Port:

?• 3 I] € I 6

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 16 of 19

Printed Natneand Sl^ature: I" >i 'y<:yi/vt h^iiAa//^J- •' _

Address: \t O 'A.k .

Vessel Name: A ll\^tj. Lr'cJ

Fisheries: Ci f if ^ j / itr-J"!> ^ V

Yeains Fishrne:

Home Port S Atf^

Printed Name and Signature:/ J *7—*•''C 0^^ Kt^iL.JOyl/

Address:

#

Vessel Name: ^ ^ AAA. >^5. 2Fistenes: "^/v/ , , /-'//

Years Fishlnff: ^ O/

••K1

Home Port: P / J^yL-s/

/Printed Name andSignature^

Address: i' / VS *yiY"^PAtr^f^r^) ^5> > v> TJk^ 7<n.

VeKel Name;^

Fisheries;

Y^ars Fishing;.

Home Porti Ct!/'/ •^-

P ? g •« J 4

Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 17 of 19

Printed Name and Sfeiiatufe;

Address: 5"

Vessel Name:

Fisheries: .

Years Fishing; /^

Home Port:

Printed Name and Signature:

Address: it A tAVessel Name:

Fisheries: _

YearsFbhing:

Home Port:__

Printed Narne and SlBnature:Z/»M/ Pagtln^H .7/L ^ .^LL^ -gt-^Address; t3f H^4L^Aic PifiL

Vessel Name: Sedt^

Fisheries: JT/v//^-irdPt l^U^jc <£,rtn

Years Fishing: Yi^A-at^

Home Port: H-al4- t^m ei/M

p £i fT & j 3Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 18 of 19

PrintedNameandSlgnatureJ?^.^^ p ^

9^>B/^ mi q mi» -fa^-

Vessel Name: P/> fltrAnP.Fisheries: ^r^Vl^g*^ Al,t/u/ /y>r)^ Az.ae/f-j»a.<fYears Fishing:

Home Port: ./^ .

Printed tilame and Signature: ^ ^t\\\'^

Address: <?/0g- :rortjiSeiA PieA. uliC

Vessel Name: iA.T^JtAUhS-'̂ ~~Fisheries: r , A-L.&^^ff

Years Fishing: ^g> -f

Hbitie Port;_ Pa//0 T

^ yPrinted Name and Signature: i? ^ V Ln^H T JOLOr. *7.Signature: r/;? Or.

Address: v^r-tiL QisJ^^Ayt^

Vessel Name:^

Pisheries;

Years Fishing; ^

/^-•

Home Port: r.iy£/{XA.

15Exhibit 6 2-18-1029

Page 19 of 19

Exhibit 7 2-18-1029

1 of 2

Exhibit 7 2-18-1029

2 of 2

Joh

nso

n P

ier

For

kli

ft T

rave

l, M

in.

15’ w

ide

Exhibit 8 2-18-1029

1 of 1

Board of Harbor Commissioners

Sabrina Brennan, President Edmundo Larenas, Vice President

Nancy Reyering, Secretary Tom Mattusch, Treasurer

Virginia Chang Kiraly, Commissioner

John Moren, Interim General Manager William Parkin, District Counsel

504 Avenue Alhambra, Ste. 200, P.O. Box 1449, El Granada, CA 94018 (650) 583-4400 T F (650) 583-4614

California Coastal Commission 45 Fremont Street, Suite 2000 W12b San Francisco, CA 94105

RE: Application #2-18-1029 Dear Members of the Commission: The San Mateo County Harbor District appreciates all of the work Commission Staff have historically done, and continue to do, to support projects to benefit the public and fisheries at Pillar Point Harbor. The Staff Report for the above referenced item states that “…the Harbor District thoughtfully considered all options to address their tenant’s concerns, including these adjacent businesses, and ultimately decided that the hoist location was appropriate and would allow all of their tenants, including the Applicant, adequate services on the pier.” As a point of clarification, the District has previously expressed safety concerns regarding the installation of an additional hoist on the already very congested Johnson Pier terminus. After initial support, the Harbor Board of Commissioners denied Three Captains’ request to install an additional hoist on Johnson Pier. As a result of a legal dispute, an arbitrator’s binding decision calls for the District to support the hoist installation, and the District does so here. As described below, the District is taking an alternative approach to resolve congestion and safety issues that are present on the pier. The District brings these matters to your attention because it is concerned that its support of this Coastal Development Permit would lead the public to believe that the District is no longer concerned about the safety and congestion issues that are present on Johnson Pier. To the contrary, the District has begun taking action that would lead to future improvements to ameliorate safety and congestion issues on Johnson Pier. At the December 19, 2018 District Board of Harbor Commissioners meeting, the Board voted to move forward with plans, and fund from District reserves, a complete reconfiguration of the Johnson Pier terminus. The District has already hosted two public meetings, in which all Fish Buyer tenants, including Three Captains, were in attendance. At these two productive and amicable meetings a plan solution to use as a starting point was agreed upon by all. The District already has a consultant working on a design/engineering proposal for Board consideration. We look forward to bringing these improvements to the Commission for consideration. Thank you for your attention to these matters. John Moren Interim General Manager San Mateo County Harbor District [email protected]

Exhibit 9 2-18-1029

Page 1 of 1