CHEP DISCUSSION FORUM Thurs 18 th Oct 2012, 1.15-2.15pm, Videolink Undergraduate Dissertation Supervision: Managing Preparation, Support & Expectations. Sally Cook & Wendy Saunderson A. CONTEXT & PROBLEM B. MANAGING EXPECTATIONS C. PROVIDING ON ONLINE SUPPORT SYSTEM ‘ODISSY’
21
Embed
18th october chep df slides undergraduate dissertation supervision
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
CHEP DISCUSSION FORUMThurs 18th Oct 2012, 1.15-2.15pm, Videolink
Undergraduate Dissertation Supervision:
Managing Preparation, Support & Expectations.
Sally Cook & Wendy Saunderson
A. CONTEXT & PROBLEM
B. MANAGING EXPECTATIONS
C. PROVIDING ON ONLINE SUPPORT SYSTEM ‘ODISSY’
CONTEXT & PROBLEM
• Tens of thousands of UG students complete Dissertations in UK HEIs each year (across the Arts, Humanities, and Social, Natural and Behavioural Sciences)
• Despite the significance of Dissertation re. student learning & staff workload: there is a paucity of guidelines, Supervision Sessions are not subject to peer-review, and are rarely observed by QAA auditors.
(Rowley and Slack, 2004; Todd et al., 2005)
VARIABLE STANDARDS & PROVISION
• HUGE VARIATIONS in the nature, approach, attitudes, concerns, provision, strategies and experience of both Supervisor and Supervisee:
But
• COMMON CHARACTERISTICS and COMMON CHALLENGES / PROBLEMS
COMMON / KEY CHARACTERISTICS
• Student-determined topic; Self-directed learning;• Independent/individual work + Tutor support; • Typically includes empirical research component;• Involves prolonged & sustained engagement.• USUALLY:• 20 credits - 200 hrs - Final year 1/6• 5 – 10,000 words; No taught component• Dissertation Handbook/BB; Individual supervision• No formal Supervisor training or guidance
COMMON CHALLENGES / PROBLEMS Delayed start / delay in choosing topic; Poor time management; Failure to fully engage with the process; Dissertation as ‘unknown entity’; Balancing workload – 1 out of 6 modules; Lacking self-confidence for independent work; Unsure of Supervisor-Supervisee relationship; Unrealistic (misinformed) expectations; Fear of not knowing what is required, and Fear of being unable to meet requirements.
Risk of under-achievement& dissatisfied students
SUPERVISOR’S ROLE
• ACADEMIC GUIDANCE: advice on suitability, feasibility, scale/scope of study; conceptual/ theoretical issues; ethical issues; research methodology; structuring; presentation.
• AS ‘MOTIVATOR’: setting tasks and deadlines; managing expectations; providing feedback.
Do we have a clear idea of our role? Boundaries?
Time commitment? Depends on number of Supervisees?
Or our own research/workload? Awareness of
acute disparities between & within subjects/Faculties?
BOUNDARIES & BALANCE
Where does the Supervisor Role & Responsibility start and end?
• How much is enough?Students do need a certain amount of guidance, support and
encouragement to gain confidence to apply their skills to complete.
• How much is too much?Spoon-feeding infantalises students and stifles original thought:
are we teaching / producing ‘technicians or technologists’?
For Discussion…
A. MANAGING EXPECTATIONS (& ‘FEARS’)B. PROVIDING AN ONLINE SUPPORT SYSTEM ‘ODISSY’
• What ARE students’ expectations?• Where do they come from?• How realistic are they?• How often do students expect supervision?• By which means? Which types do they prefer?• How realistic/realisable are their expectations?• What are students biggest fears/concerns?
How often is private face-to-face Supervision expected?
Twice per Week
Every Week Every Fortnight Every 2-3 Weeks
Once per Month
2
63
31
2 3
Expected duration of each private face-to-face Supervision
10-15 mins 15-30
mins 30-60 mins 1 hour 2 hrs
5
36
43
14
2
Weekly Supervision
10-15 mins 15-30
mins 30-60 mins 1 hour 2 hrs
513
67
105
Fortnightly Supervision
UG Students’ ‘Greatest Fears/Concerns’ at start of final/Dissertation Year
Not being able to understand certain aspects of dissertation; not having enough time or 1-to-1 sessions with Supervisor
That I won’t get a high enough grade; that I won’t pick the right dissertation title; that I won’t get enough guidance and support from my Supervisor
Biggest fear is juggling Uni work with 2 jobs; failing; not understanding the work; time management.
Doing something wrong in my dissertation and wasting time by not being able to fully understand it; Not having enough one-to-one time with my Supervisor
That I will fall behind and not do my best and that my Supervisor won’t be interested in my topic; it will be hard to balance work & Uni
Biggest fear is everything snowballing if I get stuck on one piece of work; time management; balancing dissertation with other modules
School of Environmental Sciences: Geography, Env. Science & Marine Science BSc
• 30 credits to 20 credits• S1 to S2• scheduled Yr. 2 preparation sessions• dissertation ‘log’ – minimum contact• Online Dissertation Support System
(ODISSY) - supported by CIES/CHEP
• guidance on research & writing up• expected standards• contradictory advice• independence• S1 workload• credits vs. expectations• supervisor knowledge / interest• supervisor availability
ODISSY student surveys & focus group
• improve student engagement• assist time management• centralise resources & advice• make better use of supervision time• enable visualisation of process
& progress
Development of ODISSY – aims:
• visual interface: journey• break into manageable ‘chunks’• indicate progress• consistent online information (timetable, C/A criteria, explanations & advice, ‘how to’ guides, links to podcasts & web sites, exemplars etc.)
• tools for communication & management
Main Features of ODISSY
ODISSY: feedback so far…
• overview of process• relevance of advice and links• convenience • consistency• exemplars
in regular use (2012 graduates)57% used at least weekly: 80% at least monthly> 80% found map interface useful (¾) ½ said it (maybe) helped time management
Key questions: any answers to…?
• optimum timing for engagement (S1 / S2 / long-thin)
• credits: effort vs. degree classification• student preparation Yr 2 / 3• expected minimum supervisory contact • level of support (independence / spoon-feeding)