Top Banner
Pavement Performance
62

10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Aug 25, 2018

Download

Documents

hoangkhuong
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Page 2: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: Highway Research Board Special Report 732

Page 3: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 3

Page 4: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: http://www.fhwa.dot.gov 4

Page 5: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 5

Page 6: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 6

Page 7: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 7

Page 8: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 8

Page 9: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Source: WSDOT Pavement Guide Interactive CD-ROM 9

Page 10: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Present Serviceability Rating

“The judgment of an observer as to the current ability of a pavement to serve the traffic it is meant to serve”

10

Page 11: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Present Serviceability Rating

11

Page 12: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Acceptable Ride Quality

PSR Acceptable?

3.0 88%

2.5 45%

2.0 15%

12

Page 13: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Measuring Roughness

Straightedge

Slope Profilometer

CHLOE Profilometer

13

Page 14: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

CHLOE Profilometer

Source: State Library and Archives of Florida14

Page 15: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Slope Variance

22

6

1S SnSV 10

n 1

S = slope (radians)

15

Page 16: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Pavements

16

Page 17: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Rigid Pavements

17

Page 18: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Rut Depth

Source: www.halifax.ca/Works/AsphaltDefectGuide.html18

Page 19: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Pavements

19

Page 20: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Cracking

Source: www.asphaltrescue.com20

Page 21: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Patching

Source: www.asphaltrescue.com21

Page 22: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Pavements

22

Page 23: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Rigid Pavements

23

Page 24: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Present Serviceability Index

PC01.0RD38.1SV1log9.103.5PSI 2

PC09.0SV1log8.141.5PSI

Flexible Pavements

Rigid Pavements

24

Page 25: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Very good

Good

Fair

Poor

Very poor

5

4

3

2

1

0

PSI

ESALS (log scale)

Limit for Low-Volume Roads

Limit for High-Volume Roads

25

Page 26: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

5

4

3

2

1

0

PSI

ESALS (log scale)

Acceptability Limit

75% Time

40%Drop

40%Drop

12% Time

Each $1 spent onmaintenance here

Ends up costing $4if delayed to here

26

Page 27: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

5

4

3

2

1

0

PSI

ESALS (log scale)

Acceptability Limit

27

Page 28: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHTO Design Equation

(Flexible Pavements)

Page 29: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wp 4.2 4.2 1.5

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

W 29

p

Page 30: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceability

tt 4.2 4.2 1.5 Wp

pt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

30

Page 31: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Performance

9.365.93 4.33

9.364.7918

10 1 1 0.64 118 1

SN SN

3.23

5.19 518 .193.23

0.081 18 1 10940.4 0.41 1 1

SN SN

31

Page 32: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

5.1910940.4

SN 118

9.t 36Wp 4

0..2

64.2 1.5

4 SN 1

32

Page 33: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

5.19

10940.4SN 1

t 189.36

4.2 p W4.2 1.5 0.64 SN 1

33

Page 34: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t 18

10 105.19 9.364.2 p 1094 Wlog 0.4 log4.2 1.5 SN 1 0.64 SN 1

34

Page 35: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t10

1810 9.36

5.19

4.2 plogW 4.2 1.5log 10940.64 SN 1 0.4

SN 1

35

Page 36: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t10

9.3610 18 10

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W log 0.64 SN 1 10940.4SN 1

36

Page 37: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Pavement Performance

Wt

terminal serviceabilitypt

InitialConstruction

failure

4.2

1.5

t10

10 18 10

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.4SN 1

37

Page 38: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Performance

t10

10 18 10

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.4SN 1

1966

38

Page 39: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Average Mean Temperature (July) 24.5°C (76oF)

Average Mean Temperature (January) -2.8°C (27oF)

Annual Average Rainfall 837 mm (34 in)

Average Depth of Frost (for fine-grained soil) 711 mm (28 in)

Climate

39

Page 40: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

AASHO Road Test

Soil Classification A-6

Percent Passing a #200 Sieve 82%

Liquid Limit 31%

Plasticity Index 16%

Average Degree of Saturation 85%

Average CBR 2.9

Subgrade

40

Page 41: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Performance

1972

t

10

10 18 10

5

i

.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.

1log 0.372 S 3.

S 1

0R4

N

41

SubgradeSupportFactor

RegionalClimateFactor

Page 42: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Regional Factor

42

Condition R value

Roadbed materials frozen to a depth of 5 in. or more (winter)

Roadbed materials dry (summer and fall)

Roadbed materials wet (spring thaw)

0.2 – 1.0

0.5 – 1.5

4.0 – 5.0

Page 43: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Regional Factor

43

Page 44: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Soil Support Value

44

Page 45: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Flexible Performance

1986

10

t10

10 18 10

5.19

R

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 10940.4S

2.32log M 8.07

N 1

45

SeasonallyAdjustedResilientModulus

Page 46: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Design Equation

18 TW w

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

46

Page 47: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Design Equation

810 101log log TW w

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

47

Page 48: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Predicted Pavement Life

t

10

10 10 10 R

5.19

T

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log 9.36log 1 0.20 2.32log M 8.071S 0940.4

1

N

SN

w

48

Page 49: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

Page 50: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Design Equation w/ FS

18 RTw FW

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

Factorof

Safety

50

Page 51: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Design Equation w/ FS

10 10 10log log logTt RW w F

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

Factorof

Safety

51

Page 52: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10FR

52

Page 53: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10FR

53

Page 54: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10FR

54

Page 55: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

wT Wt

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

55

Page 56: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

2 2 2o w nS S S

log10FR =

56

Page 57: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

2 2 2o w nS S S

P(fail)

log10FR =

57

Page 58: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Reliability

wT Wt

ZRSo

P(fail)

PredictedTrafficLevels

PredictedPavement

Life

log10Wt log10Wt 58

Page 59: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Design Equation

R 0

10

10 18 10 10 R

5.19

4.2 plog4.2 1.5log W 9.36log SN 1 0.20 2.32log M 8.0710940.SN 1

Z S4

1993

59

Reliability

Page 60: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Recommended Reliability

Functional Classification Urban Rural

Interstate and Other Freeways 85 – 99.9% 80 – 99.9%

Principal Arterials 80 – 99% 75 – 99%

Collectors 80 – 95% 75 – 95%

Local 50 – 80% 50 – 80%

60

Page 61: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

ReliabilityReliability

(%) ZRReliability

(%) ZR

50 -0.000 93 -1.476

60 -0.253 94 -1.555

70 -0.524 95 -1.645

75 -0.674 96 -1.751

80 -0.841 97 -1.881

85 -1.037 98 -2.054

90 -1.282 99 -2.327

91 -1.340 99.9 -3.090

92 -1.405 99.99 -3.75061

Page 62: 10 - AASHTO Design Equation (Flexible) (2015) - AASHTO Design Equation... · the current ability of a pavement to ... Flexible Pavements Rigid Pavements 24. ... Construction failure

Standard Deviations

Source Flexible Rigid

AASHO Road Test Sn 0.35 0.25

AASHO Road Test So 0.45 0.35

Typical Range for So 0.40 – 0.50 0.35 – 0.40

62