Top Banner
1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia M. Newman Balch & Bingham LLP [email protected] [email protected]
19

1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

Dec 29, 2015

Download

Documents

Patrick Hubbard
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

1

TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS

MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE

April 16, 2010

Armin J. MoellerDinetia M. Newman

Balch & Bingham [email protected]@balch.com

Page 2: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

2

INTRODUCTION TO CRITICAL ISSUES

• What is the Hospital’s Objective?– Interoperable EHR system by which

hospital/professionals can meaningfully use certified healthcare technology

– Species of IT contract– Goal: something which does not

currently exist– Qualify for EHR incentive payments

• What is EHR Vendor Promising?– Functional EHR system?– “Best efforts” or “Commercially

reasonable efforts”?– Disconnect between EHR vendor

advertising and contract terms• Schedule/Time of the Essence?

– What excuses delay?

Best

Effort,

Inc.

Hope for the

Best

EHR Vendor

Page 3: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

3

INTRODUCTION TO CRITICAL ISSUESContinued

• Defects/Delays – Notice of Cure/Period of Cure?– What is end point?– Material breach of contract?

• Dispute Resolution– Mediation? Arbitration? Compulsory? Courts?– Venue? Limitations?

• What is a Material Breach?– Time of the essence?– Nonconforming deliverables jeopardize success of

project?

Page 4: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

4

INTRODUCTION TO CRITICAL ISSUESContinued

• Warranty Provision– What is being warranted? Functional EHR system?

• Duration?– Software free of material defects?– Useable for its intended purpose?– Performance being warranted?– Not materially deviate from contract specifications?

• Limitation of Liability– Typically, strict LOL provisions

Page 5: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

5

INTRODUCTION TO CRITICAL ISSUESContinued

• Where are Broken Promises, Misrepresentations And Failure?– Documentation– Notice and demands to vendor– Follow through– Overcoming hospital breach/lack of assistance and

substantial performance defenses• Avoiding Looking Stupid About What Was the

Bargain

Page 6: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

6

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS

• Definitions• Specifications• License Terms• Warranties• Change in Law• Support and Maintenance• Confidentiality, Privacy &

Security• Disclaimers• Limitation of Liability and

Indemnification

• Acceptance Testing/Milestone Payments

• Pricing/Financing• Dispute Resolution• Final Thoughts

Page 7: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

7

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – DEFINITIONS

• Location • Important Definitions

– “Contract” or “Agreement – related documents – Purchased products: Equipment, Software, Third Party

Software– Effective Date– Live Date– Documents– Loss– Travel Expenses– Maintenance and/or Implementation Services– Clinical Content & Medical Necessity Content

Page 8: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

8

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS - SPECIFICATIONS

• Have appropriate hospital IT person confirm sufficiency of specifications

• Assure all functionalities are covered in contract

• If possible, link specifications to HITECH meaningful use requirements

• Warranties will be based on specifications

Page 9: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

9

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – LICENSE TERMS

• Named User or Concurrent User Licenses• Intellectual Property Issues

– Vendor indemnification if infringement alleged

• Termination of Licenses– Provisions allowing hospital to terminate

licenses– Transition assistance to new EHR vendor

• Move data to new server• Vendor provide copy in user-friendly format

• Ownership of data upon license termination

Page 10: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

10

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – WARRANTIES

• Warranties based on specifications• Interoperability

– With existing software and interfaces owned by hospital, health system

– With software of other health care providers/suppliers

• Certified currently and in future• Compliance with “meaningful use” criteria

– Continuing through various Stages

• Compliance with all applicable HITECH, HIPAA and other laws and regulations

• No viruses; security protections

Page 11: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

11

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – WARRANTIES (cont.)• Remedies on breach of warranty

– Repair– Replace– Re-perform– Refund of project costs, incentive payments– Penalties– Timing, broadening of remedies

• Disclaimers– Use by trained personnel– “Garbage in, garbage out”: no control over content– Custom add-ons– Vendor does not practice medicine– No control over internet: interruptions, errors, lack of

security

Page 12: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

12

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – CHANGE IN LAW

• Law likely to change prior to EHR “go live” date and thereafter

• Important to negotiate pre-purchase– Without negotiation, leverage might shift to

vendor

• Terms– Who bears risk of change– What will costs be if change occurs – Whose responsibility is cost

• Upgrades, new functionalities, installation• Implementation fees,

Page 13: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

13

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – SUPPORT & MAINTENANCE

• Timing of support: 24/7, answer questions• On site/off site – remote diagnostics• Updates, new product versions• Consistency of personnel• Training – type of training• Limits on price increases

– Termination ability of hospital to terminate maintenance/support

– Limits on vendor termination rights

• Remedies

Page 14: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

14

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS –CONFIDENTIALITY, PRIVACY &

SECURITY• Business Associate Agreement– Remedies on breach– Timing of breach notice– Termination issues

• Data destruction, return by BA• Confidentiality of non-PHI

Page 15: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

15

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – LIMITATION OF LIABILITY &

INDEMNIFICATION

• Limitation of Liability• Disclaimers of Implied Warranties• Carve-outs

– HIPAA privacy or security breach– Failure to achieve “meaningful use” on timely

basis

Page 16: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

16

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – ACCEPTANCE TESTING & MILESTONE

PAYMENTS• Acceptance Testing

– Stages or milestones– Testing methods– Risk spreading

• Final overall acceptance– Timing

• Remedies for non-acceptance• Milestone Payments

– Risk spreading– Increase in hospital leverage and avoidance of refund

requests

Page 17: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

17

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – PRICING

• Pricing• Payment Terms

– Limits on increases

• Expenses• Financing by vendor

– Pros• Opportunity to spread out payments if milestone

payments not negotiable– Cons

• Obligation to pay does not end if EHR fails to perform as anticipated or meet meaningful use standards

• Potential limited access to medical records maintained by system.

Page 18: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

18

KEY CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS – FINAL THOUGHTS

• Initial hospital gap analysis important• Compliance with “meaningful use” objectives is

evolving target• Certification standards – continued unknown• Important for vendor to have “stake” in game• Important to know vendor: strengths, weaknesses

of product, ability to deliver product as per contract• Important to control negotiations, contracting

process• Project management team critical• Continued communication between hospital/vendor

important – frequent meetings, relationship• Schedules, timing of implementation important

Page 19: 1 TOP STRATEGIES FOR NEGOTIATING EHR AGREEMENTS MISSISSIPPI HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION’S 2 ND ANNUAL HEALTH LAW CONFERENCE April 16, 2010 Armin J. Moeller Dinetia.

19

Dinetia M. NewmanBalch & Bingham LLP

401 East Capitol Street, Suite 200Jackson, Mississippi  39201

[email protected] (601) 965-8169 – Phone

(888) 594-5407 – Fax(662) 891-8935 – Cell

Armin J. MoellerBalch & Bingham LLP

401 East Capitol Street, Suite 200

Jackson, Mississippi  [email protected]

(601) 965-8156 – Phone(888) 594-5405 – Fax(601) 906-1083 – Cell

THANK YOU!!

Presented by: