1 REPORTABLE/NON-REPORTABLE IN THE HIGH COURT ...

Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

1

REPORTABLE/NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

ON THE 31st DAY OF DECEMBER, 2021

BEFORE

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE TARLOK SINGH CHAUHAN,

&

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATYEN VAIDYA

CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. 3894 OF 2021 ALONG-WITH CONNECTED

MATTERS

CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. 3894 OF 2021

REENA KUMARI D/O SH. GURUCHARAN SINGHR/O VILLAGE BARI, P.O. RAJA KA TALABTEHSIL FATEHPUR, DISTRICT KANGRA H.P. 176051

AND

STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEFSECRETARY, SHIMLA-2.

THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHALPRADESH THROUGH ITS SECRETARY

THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT,GOVERNMENT OF H.P. SHIMLA-02, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

2. CIVIL WRIT PETITION (ORIGINAL APPLICATION) NO. 34 of 2019

Between:-

1. PAWAN KUMAR S/O SH. RATTANLAL VPO SALWANA, TEHSIL SUNDERNAGAR, DISTT. MANDI, PIN NO.175018, ROLL NO. 511494.

2. AMAN GAUTAM S/O SH. HANSRAJGAUTAM, VILL. LUHUNOO, TEHSIL &DISTT. BILASPUR, H.P. PIN NO. 174001,ROLL. 501042.

3. NIKHIL SHARMA S/O SH. ROSHANLAL SHARMA, WARD NO. 04, HOUSE NO. 3.158, TEHSIL & DISTT. HAMIRPUR,

::: Downloaded on - 14/04/2022 10:10:00 :::CIS

Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

2

H.P. PIN NO. 177001 ROLL. 504235.

4. PRIYANKA SHARMA D/O SH. RAJ KUMAR,VILL. BHAGOT, P.O. SANED, TEHSIL & DISTT. HAMIRPUR, H.P. PIN NO. 176043, ROLL. 504462

5. RAHUL S/O SH. BHAG MAL VILLAGE & POST OFFICE DARKOTI. TESHILKOTKHAI, DISTT. SHIMLA HP. PIN NO. 171202, ROLL NO. 515500. 6. PREM LATA D/O SH. MAST RAMC/O LAXMI NIWAS SANDALESTATE # STATE CHAKKER SHIMLA 171005, ROLL. 516117 6.

7. ISHWAR DUTT S/O SH. DULA RAMC/O JAGDAMBA NIWAS LOWERDEVNAGAR, KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-171009, ROLL NO. 514074.

8. NEERAJ BHARDWAJ S/O SH. OM DUTTVILL. KANTBARI, P.O. DALESH, TEHSIL ANNI, DISTT. KULLU, H.P. 172025 ROLL NO. 514986.

9. PRAVEEN KUMAR SHANDIL S/O SH. LEELA RAMSHANDIL VILL. SORIA(CHALYAWANI) P.O. MANGOO, TEHSIL ARKI, DISTT. SOLAN, H.P. PIN NO.171102 ROLL NO. 519231

10. NANAK CHAND S/O SH. REWAT RAM,VPO SADHOT, TEHSIL SARKAGHAT, DISTT. MANDI H.P. PIN NO. 175037 ROLL NO. 504151

11. NARESH KUMAR S/O SH. LEKHRAM V.P.O. PANESH,TEHSIL & DISTT. SHIMLA H.P. PIN.NO. ROLL NO. 514913, PIN NO. 171011

12. KIRAN SAINI KASHYAP D/O SH.AMAN NATH SAINI SINGH COTTAGE,LOWER KAINTHU SHIMLA-171003(H.P.) 514342


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

3

13. SANDEEP THAKUR S/O SH. UDHAMSINGH VILLAGE MUNDRUP.O. RATTI TEHSIL BALH, DISTT.MANDI, H.P. PIN NO. 175008, ROLL NO. 512058

14. ANU KUMARI, W/O SH.BHAVENESHWAR LAL, VILL.GHIANAKHURD, P.O. JHEOL, TEHSILDHARAMSHALA, KANGRA, PIN NO.176001

15. RAM SINGH S/O SH. JEET SINGH,VILL GALOG, PO DHAIR, TEHSILANNI, DISTT. KULLU, HP PIN 172025ROLL NO. 515648

16. SANJEEV KUMAR S/O SH. DEV RAJVILL. KORI, P.O. CHANOUR, TEHSILDEHRA, DISTT. KANGRA, HP PIN NO. 177113, ROLL NO. 507411

17. DEEPAK KUMAR, S/O SH. BIDHISINGH, VILL KHORAR, PO GALORE,TEHSIL NADAUN, DISTT. HAMIRPUR,HP PIN NO.174001, ROLL NO. 503651

18. NAVEEN SINGH S/O SH. GIANCHAND, VILL & P.O. BARINJHERWAN,TEHSLIL GHUMARWIN, DISTT.BILASPUR H.P. 174021, ROLL. NO.

19. RAJAN MEHTA S/O SH. SURENDERMEHTA, VILL. & P.O. SANJAULI,SHIMLA 171006.

20. ANU THAKUR S/O SH. BIAS DEV,VPO SARKAGHAT, DISTT. MANDI175024

21. VIVEK KUMAR S/O SH. PRITAMCHAND, VILLAGE HATLI LARHAPOST OFFICE & TEHSIL GALORE,DISTT. HAMIRPUR, H.P. 177026.

22. MUNNI DEVI W/O SH. SUDHIRVERMA, C/O DR. SUBHASH TOMAR


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

4

DURGA MEDICAL HALL NEAR OLDBUS STAND RAJGARH, SIRMOUR, H.P.173101 ROLL NO. 517646

23. SANJEEV KUMAR S/O SH. RAMESHCHAND, VPO UTPUR. TEHSIL &DISTT. HAMIRPUR PIN NO. 177022ROLL NO. 504842

24. GAJINDER KUMAR THAKUR S/OSH. SURESH KUMAR THAKUR VILL.DANOON PO SUNDLA, TEHSILSALOONI, DISTT. CHAMBA PIN NO.176312 ROLL NO. 502494

25. SANJEEV KHAN S/O SH. ROSHANKHAN R/O VILL. KUMHARNU,P.O.BALH KAWAR, TEHSIL LAD-BHAROL, DISTT. MANDI, PIN 176126,ROLL NO. 512096

26. RAVINDER THAKUR S/O SH.BALDEV SINGH THAKUR, WARD NO. 2,HOUSE NO. 239, DISTT. HAMIRPURH.P. ROLL NO. 504687. 27. AJAY KUMAR, S/O SH. BALDEVSINGH THAKUR R/O VILL. JAKHOOL,P.O. KANGOO, TEHSIL SUNDERNAGAR, DISTT. MANDI, PIN 175018ROLL. NO. 509618

28. PANKAJ THAKUR S/O SH.DAMODER DAS VILL. JODHA P.OSAJAOPIPLU TEH & DISTT. MANDI.

29. PRASHANT NAYAK S/O SH. PURANCHAND VILL. BHARYARA, P.ODADHOG TEH JOGINDER NAGARDISTT. MANDI (H.P.)

30. AMBKA THAKUR S/O SH. NEERATRAM, MAIN ROAD DHALPUR NEARNARU CLINIC TEH. & DISTT. KULLU.

31. VINOJ PAL S/O SH. ROOP SINGHVPO BHALYANI TEH & DISTT. KULLU175103 (H.P.)


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

5

32. RAHUL THAKUR S/O SH. AMARCHAND VILL. MAKRENA P.O & TEHJOGINDER NAGAR DISTT. MANDI175015

33. ANUJ MAHANT S/O SH. ROSHALLAL VILL & P.O PADHAR DISTT.MANDI 175012.

34. PANKAJ SHARMA S/O SH. CHUNNILAL VILL & P.O RIWALSARDISTT.MANDI 175023.

35. ANKUR S/O. SH. RAJENDER KUMARWARD NO. 1 KACHAAL JAGGIAN P.O& TEH JAISINGHPUR DISTT. KANGRAH.P.

36. MAHESH KUMAR S/O SH. BHAINURAM VPO SAINTHAL TEH. JOGINDERNAGAR DISTT. MANDI.

37. SAPNA SHARMA D/O SH. SUNEHARILAL, VILLAGE GURONU, POJOGINDERNAGAR, DISTT. MANDI HP-175015.

38. DEEPAK RAMPAL C/O LDM OFFICEUCO BANK, NEAR RANA HOTELBILASPUR (H.P)

39. AJAY KISHORE S/O SH. NANDKISHORE VILL. GALOG TEH ANNIDISTT. KULLU (H.P.)

40. NARENDER KUMAR S/O SH. SHIVRAM VILL. KHANYOG P.O. SERIKOTHI TEH SADAR DISTT. MANDI175038.

41. VIKAS SHARMA S/O MAHESH DATTHOUSE NO. 112 WARD NO.KALYANPUR P.O & TEH. RAMPURDISTT. SHIMLA (H.P.)

42. PRAKASH CHAND S/O SH. PURANCHAND SET NO. 51 CHARITONESTATE SUMMER HILL SHIMLA.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

6

43. NARESH KUMAR S/O SH. KANIYARAM C/O PURAN CHAND SET NO.51CHARITON ESTATE SUMMER HILL SHIMLA.

44. VINOD KUMAR S/O SH. DEEP RAMSHARMA VILL. KAYALU P.O. GUMMAVIA BASANTPUR TEH & DISTT.SHIMLA.

45. MEENAKSHI SHARMA W/O SH.SATISH KUMAR VILLAGE PEOTHATEH. ARKI P.O. SHALAGHATDISTRICT- SOLAN -173208 ROLL. NO.-514757

46. PANKAJ KUMAR S/O SH JOGINDERSINGH, VILLAGE BHATOLIPHAKORIAN, TEHSIL DEHRADISTRICT KANGRA, 176028

47. RAJ KUMAR VILLAGE VILLAGEBAG, TEHSIL SARKAGHAT DISTRICTMANFI 175026

48. PAWAN KUMAR S/O SH KISHORILAL, VILLAGE DEHLUHAR, P.O.DOHAG, TEHSIL JOGINDERNAGARDISTRICT MANDI.

49. REENA W/O SH SANJAY SHARMAVILLAGE SALAM P.O. JABRI TEHSILAND DISTRICT SHIMLA.

50. RAKESH KUMAR S/O SH DILLARAM VILLAGE BASA P.O. NERWADISTRICT SHIMLA 171210

51. SEEMA DEVI D/O SHRI KESHAVRAM VILLAGE AND POST OFFICEKIRTOO TEHSIL THEOG DISTRICTSHIMLA

52. MEENAKSHI D/O AMAR SINGHVILLAGE KOTLI, P.O. SHALAGHATTEHSIL ARKI DISTRICT SOLAN.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

7

53. KALPANA DEVID/O SH SANT RAM THAKUR DABROGICOTTAGE, NEAR VIJAY TRADESVIKAS NAGAR, DISTRICT SHIMLA

54. MOHIT MAHAJANS/O SH BRIJESH MAHAJAN, JANSALIBAZAR, CHAMBA

55. SANDEEP KUMARSON OF SHRI BHAG SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BADDU,WARD NO. 1, POST OFFICE & TEHSILGHUMARWIN, DISTRICT BILASPUR, H.P. 174021

56. PRADEEP KUMARSON OF SHRI BHAG SINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BADDU,WARDNO. 1, POST OFFICE & TEHSIL GHUMARWIN, DISTRICT BILASPUR, H.P. 174021.

57. SONU PALSON OF SHRI BAGGA RAM, VILLAGEGAH, POST OFFICE PAPLOA, TEHSILJHANDUTTA, DISTRICT BILASPUR, H.P. 174017.

58. VIVEK SHARMASON OF SHRI LAXMI NAND, VILLAGEPANOL, POST OFFICE AMARPUR,TEHSIL GHUMARWIN, DISTRICT BILASPUR, H.P. 174021.

59. ANJNA KUMARIWIFE OF SANJEEV KUMAR SHARMA,VILLAGE PANIYALA, POST OFFICEKOTHI, TEHSIL GHUMARWIN,DISTRICT BILASPUR H.P. 174021.

60. ABHIMANYU SINGH,SON OF SHRI JEEVAN SINGHTHAKUR, VILLAGE KUTWA, TEHSIL ANNI,DISTRICT KULLU, H.P.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

8

61. RAJNEESH SHARMAS/O GHANSHYAM DAS SHARMA R/O VILLAGE CHAILLEY VILLAGECHALLEY P.O. CHAILEYSUMMERHILL TEHSIL SHIMLA.

62. LOVE KUMAR SHARMAS/O SH. RAJENDER PAL SHARMA,VILL. DARYOTA, PO BHIRA, TEHSIL & DISTT. HAMIRPUR, HP-177001 ROLL NO. 503961.

63. LOKESH RAWATS/O SH. BALBIR SINGH RAWAT, WARD NO. 3, NEAR MASZID,NALAGARH, DISTT. SOLAN, HP-174101. ROLL NO. 518999.

64. MANISH KUMARS/O HOSHIAR SINGH VPO-BHINDLA TEHSIL BANGANADISTRICT UNA HIMACHAL PRADESH-177039 ROLL NO.519940.

65. KIRAN KUMARI SHYAMD/O SH. ASHOK SHYAM. Y.K. NIWAS, JAWAHAR COLONY,BHATTAKUFFER, SANJAULI, SHIMLA-171006 ROLL. NO.514341.

66. NANDNI CHAUHAND/O SH. JAG MOHAN W/O SH. ISHWENDER THAKUR,MOHINDRA COTTAGE, UPPERSTREET NAHAN, DISTT. SIRMOUR, HP 173001. ROLLNO. 517652.

67. AJAY KUMARS/O SH. HARI RAM, VILL. TRAMBI (CHAHARI), POREWALSAR, TEHSIL BALH, DISTT. MANDI, HP. ROLL NO. 509616.

68. RAVINDER CHAUHANS/O SH. MEGH SINGH CHAUHAN,


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

9

VILL. MORDUGH, PO TIKROO. TEHSILJOGINDER NAGAR, DISTT. MANDI, HP. ROLL NO. 511922.

69. RAJESH KUMARS/O SH. LACHHMAN SINGH, H. NO. 138, DIARA SECTOR, PO &TEHSIL SADAR, DISTT. BILASPUR, HP-174001 ROLL NO.501756.

70. ANIL KUMARS/O SH. RAI SINGH VILLAGE ROHIN PO-DHIRWINTEHSIL BHORANJ DISTT. HAMIRPUR-176045

71. SANJAY KUMAR S/O HARI CHANDVILLAGE- TYOG PO-SIDHPUR TEHSILSARKAGHAT (DHARMPUR) DISTT.MANDI-175040

72. ARCHANA SHARMAW/O S/O AJAYBHARDWAJ R/O VILLAGE BHOUNGP.O. ROURI VIA TOTU SHIMLA.

..PETITIONERS

AND

I. STATE OF H.P. THROUGHPRINCIPAL SECRETARY PERSONNELH.P. SECRETARIAT CHOTTA SHIMLA.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFFSELECTION COMMISSION HAMIRPURDISTRICT HIMACHAL PRADESHTHROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

3. MS BABITA D/O SH RAI SINGHVILLAGE CHAINDAL P.O. DARKOTIDISTRICT SHIMLA(AT SR. NO 839)

4. MAMTA THAKUR D/O SH RAJKRISHAN, C/O POOL OFFICE HPUSUMMER SHIMLA (SR NO. 943)SHIMLA


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

10

Sr.No. Roll No.

Name TotalMarks

Department Allotted

5. 501003 ABHISHEK CHANDEL 164 HEALTH

6. 501008 ABHISHEK THAKUR 158 I & PH

7. 501015 AJAY KUMAR 157 HEALTH

8. 501023 AJAY KUMAR 156 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

9. 501026 AJAY KUMAR DHIMAN 149 AGRICULTURE

10. 501061 ANJANA KUMARI 173 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

11. 501069 ANIL KUMAR 160 I & PH

12. 501080 ANIL KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

13. 501093 ANITA KUMARI 138 SC&ST DEV .CORPORATION

14. 501164 ARUN KUMAR 136 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

15. 501177 ASHOK KUMAR 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

16. 501191 BALBIR SINGH 159 FINANCE (T&A)

17. 501196 BALVIR SINGH 139 AGRICULTURE

18. 501204 BANDNA SHARMA 174 DC OFFICE MANDI

19. 501210 BHAWNA DEVI 173 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

20. 501220 CHAMAN LAL 162 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

21. 501230 CHHOTA RAM 144 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

22. 501231 CHHOTA RAM 148 HPSEBL

23. 501262 DHARMENDER KUMAR 154 HOME GUARD&CIVIL DEFENCE

24. 501282 DIVESH KUMAR 155 PANCHAYATI RAJ

25. 501287 GAURAV SONI 161 TRANSPORT

26. 501299 HARI DASS 144 HEALTH

27. 501312 INDU 181 HIGHER EDUCATION

28. 501318 JAI LAL 144 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

29. 501359 KANCHANA DEVI 157 HPSEBL

30. 501369 KASHMIR SINGH 162 I &PH

31. 501372 KAVITA DEVI 149 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

32. 501381 KISHORI LAL SHARMA 162 HEALTH

33. 501396 KULVINDER SINGH 154 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

34. 501455 MANOJ KUMAR 155 FOOD &CIVIL SUPPLIES


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

11

35. 501473 MEENAKSHI 156 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

36. 501474 MEENAKSHI 158 HIGHER EDUCATION

37. 501528 NARESH KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

38. 501551 NEELAM KUMARI 153HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS WORKER

39. 501569 NEHA KAUNDAL 134 PROSECUTION

40. 501575 NIKKU RAM 137 INDUSTRIES

41. 501580 NISHA DEVI 164 HP BOSE

42. 501590 NISHA THAKUR 159 HEALTH

43. 501591 NISHA DEVI 145 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

44. 501615 PANKAJ KUMAR 140 HPSEBL

45. 501635 PARVEEN KUMAR 153 DC OFFICEL&S

46. 501670 POONAM KUMARI 174 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

47. 501725 RADHA KRISHAN 134 FINANCE (T&A)

48. 501750 RAJENDER SINGH 166 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

49. 501758 RAJESH KUMAR 142 FOREST

50. 501768 RAJNI KANT 147 HIGHER DUCATION

51. 501773 RAKESH KUMAR 145 HPSEBL

52. 501785 RAKESH KUMAR 156 HEALTH

53. 501816 RAVINDER KUMAR 140 FINANCE(T&A)

54. 501904 SANJAY KUMAR 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

55. 501910 SANJEEEV KUMAR 165 HIGHER EDUCATION

56. 501913 SANJEEV KUMAR 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

57. 501940 SAPNA DEVI 157 AGRICULTURE

58. 501965 SATYENDER SINGH 170 PLANNING

59. 501967 SAURAV SHARMA 178 HIGHER EDUCATION

60. 501987 SHALINI JASWAL 137 PANCHAYATI RAJ

61. 502001 SHASHI PAL 136 INDUSTRIES

62. 502038 SONIKA 168 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

63. 502040 SONU DEVI 154 INDUSTRIES


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

12

64. 502041 SONU KUMAR 144 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

65. 502049 SUDHA 158 HPSEBL

66. 502059 SUMAN KUMAR 140 HIGHER EDUCATION

67. 502063 SUNEEL DATT 163 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

68. 502068 SUNEEL KUMAR 152 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

69. 502076 SUNIL KUMAR 173 HIGHER EDUCATION

70. 502110 SURENDER 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

71. 502121 SURESH KUMAR 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

72. 502133 TANUJ SHARMA 156 Municipal CORPORATION DHARAMSALA

73. 502134 TANVI THAKUR 166 AGRICULTURE

74. 502138 JEEWAN LATA 154 HIMUDA

75. 502159 USHA KUMARI 148 HPSEBL

76. 502193 VIKASH SHARMA 175 HIGHER EDUCATION

77. 502220 VINOD KUMAR 154 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

78. 502224 VINOD KUMAR 169 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

79. 502234 VIPIN SHARMA 158 HIGHER EDUCATION

80. 502250 YASHODA DEVI 142 HEALTH

81. 502257 RAVI SHANKAR 153 HIGHER EDUCATION

82. 502302 ABHISHEK BAROTRA 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

83. 502330 ANCHAL 138 HPSEBL

84. 502336 ANIL KUMAR 170 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

85. 502360 ANKUSH KUMAR 137 CO-OPERATION

86. 502368 ANUP KUMAR 138 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

87. 502370 ANUPAM SHARMA 167 DCOFFICECHAMBA

88. 502419 BHUPINDER SINGH 143 DCOFFICECHAMBA

89. 502428 BOBBY KUMARI 148 HPSEBL

90. 502442 CHANDER KANTA 137 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

91. 502443 CHANDER MANI 141 HPSEBL

92. 502445 CHANDRESH KUMAR 137 FINANCE (T&A)


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

13

93. 502469 DEVINDER KUMAR 162 HPSEBL

94. 502489 DIPESH BHARDWAJ 135 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

95. 502509 HITENDER SINGH 153 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

96. 502531 HARINDER KUMAR 167 HIGHER EDUCATION

97. 502542 KALYAN SINGH 158 DC OFFICE KANGRA

98. 502543 KAMAL SINGH 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

99. 502556 KARTIKEY CHONA 164 HPPWD

100. 502558 KAVITA 161 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

101. 502566 KHEM PAUL 147 HPSEBL

102. 502582 KULDEEP SINGH 158 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

103. 502629 MANOHAR LAL 170 HPSEBL

104. 502631 MANOJ KUMAR 154 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

105. 502633 MANOJ KUMAR 137 INDUSTRIES

106. 502635 MANOJ KUMAR 140 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

107. 502640 MARUT BAKSHI 156 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

108. 502650 MEERA KUMARI 160 HIGHER EDUCATION

109. 502663 MUKESH KUMAR 144 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

110. 502664 MUKESH KUMAR 180 HPPWD

111. 502670 MUNISH KUMAR 147 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

112. 502677 NARENDER KUMAR 158 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

113. 502680 NARESH KUMAR 144 I &PH

114. 502684 NAVEEN KUMAR 186 HIGHER EDUCATION

115. 502703 OM PRAKASH 157 AGRICULTURE

116. 502721 PAPPU RAM 140 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

117. 502725 PARMESHWARI DEVI 161 HPSEBL

118. 502764 PRAMOD KUMAR 156 FOREST

119. 502775 PRITAM SINGH 146 HPSEBL

120. 502791 RADHA KUMARI 151 HIGHER EDUCATION

121. 502802 RAJEEV KUMAR 150 HPPWD

122. 502803 RAJEEV KUMAR 139 HEALTH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

14

123. 502819 RAJU 160 FINANCE (T&A)

124. 502830 RAKESH KUMAR 163 FOREST

125. 502842 RAMESH KUMAR 157 I &PH

126. 502856 RAVI KUMAR 159 HPSEBL

127. 502878 RITA KUMARI 149 HIGHER EDUCATION

128. 502945 SHAKTI PRASAD 120 HEALTH

129. 502987 SUBHASH KUMAR 156 HIGHER EDUCATION

130. 503004 SUNITA DEVI 142 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

131. 503017 SURENDER KUMAR 140 PANCHAYATI RAJ

132. 503023 SURESH KUMAR 153 I &PH

133. 503030 SURYA PAL 138 CO-OPERATION

134. 503036 TANUJ KUMAR 142 HPSEBL

135. 503067 VIJAY SINGH 172 HIGHER EDUCATION

136. 503078 VIKAS VERMA 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

137. 503081 VIKRAM SINGH 163 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

138. 503088 VINOD KUMAR 141 HPSEBL

139. 503090 VINOD KUMAR 139 FINANCE (T&A)

140. 503094 VIPAN KUMAR 151 HPPWD

141. 503111 YASHPAL SINGH 155 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

142. 503131 MUKESH KUMAR 140 HPSEBL

143. 503179 ABHISHEK KUMAR 169 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

144. 503201 AJAY KUMAR 142 HPSEBL

145. 503257 AMAN SHARMA 159 HPSEBL

146. 503269 AMIT KUMAR 139 HPSEBL

147. 503271 AMIT KUMAR 166 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR



150. 503301 ANAMIKA SHARMA 170 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

151. 503333 ANIL KUMAR 176 HIGHER EDUCATION

152. 503337 ANIT KUMAR 166 DC OFFICE HAMIRPUR


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

15

153. 503383 ANJU CHAUDHARY 160 HPSEBL

154. 503386 ANKIT GUPTA 155 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

155. 503407 ANSHUL KAUSHIK 157 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

156. 503442 ARVIND KUMAR 155 FOREST

157. 503444 ARPANA SHARMA 167 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

158. 503462 ARUN KUMAR 167 HIGHER EDUCATION

159. 503468 ARUN KUMAR 153 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

160. 503494 ASHISH KUMAR 156 DC OFFICE KANGRA

161. 503496 ASHISH KUMAR 162 HPSEBL

162. 503501 ASHISH SHARMA 166 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

163. 503508 ASHOK KUMAR 151 HIGHER EDUCATION

164. 503509 ASHOK KUMAR 139 HP BOSE

165. 503511 ASHOK KUMAR 157 FINANCE (T&A)

166. 503516 ASHU BHATIA 156 HPSEBL

167. 503536 ASWANI KUMAR 148 HPSEBL

168. 503553 BABITA THAKUR 158 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

169. 503613 CHAMAN LAL 148 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

170. 503618 CHAMPA KUMARI 162 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

171. 503626 CHANDER SHEKHAR 162 HEALTH

172. 503644 DEEP KUMAR 171 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

173. 503652 DEEPAK KUMAR 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

174. 503653 DEEPAK KUMAR 124 FINANCE (T&A)

175. 503658 DEEPAK SHARMA 140 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

176. 503665 DEEPIKA PRAVESH 181 DCOFFICE BILASPUR

177. 503686 DIKSHA GUPTA 172 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

178. 503710 DINESH KUMAR 134 HIGHER EDUCATION

179. 503722 DUNI CHAND 132 FINANCE (T&A)

180. 503756 HARJINDER SINGH 154 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

181. 503765 HOSHIAR SINGH 136 CO-OPERATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

16

182. 503771 INDU PATYAL 152 HP BOSE

183. 503776 ISHA 167 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

184. 503795 JITENDER KUMAR 143 FOREST

185. 503845 KAMLESH KUMARI 144 HIGHEREDUCATION

186. 503851 KANCHAN KUMARI 143 HPSEBL

187. 503857 KANCHNA DEVI 155 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

188. 503863 KAPIL DEV 151 HIGHER EDUCATION

189. 503869 KARAM SINGH 161 FOREST

190. 503873 KARTAR CHAND 177 HIGHER EDUCATION

191. 503907 KRISHAN CHAND 139 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

192. 503932 KUMARI KALPNA 137 HPSEBL

193. 503989 MAMTA DEVI 148 HEALTH

194. 503998 MANDEEP KUMAR 140 HEALTH

195. 504009 MANISH KUMAR 180 HPPWD

196. 504012 MANISH KUMAR 152 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

197. 504024 MANJEET KUMAR 153 HEALTH

198. 504025 MANJEET KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

199. 504033 MANJU 157 HEALTH

200. 504045 MANOJ KUMAR 156 HEALTH

201. 504059 MANOJ KUMAR 138 INDUSTRIES

202. 504063 MANOJ KUMAR 142 HPSEBL

203. 504088 MEENU DEVI 154 URBAN DEVELOPMENT

204. 504128 MUKESH KUMAR 141 HP BOSE

205. 504135 MUKESH KUMARI 140 HPSEBL

206. 504141 MUNISH KUMAR 135 HEALTH

207. 504160 NARESH DHATWALIA 163 HPSEBL

208. 504185 NAVJEET SINGH 165 HPPWD

209. 504195 NEELAM KUMARI 157 HEALTH

210. 504202 NEELAM KUMARI 153 SC& STD EV.CORPORATION

211. 504212 NEERAJ CHAUHAN 177 DC OFFICE HAMIRPUR


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

17

212. 504231 NEHA THAKUR 160 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

213. 504259 NISHA KUMARI 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

214. 504272 NITIN KUMAR GUPTA 159 HPSEBL

215. 504282 OM SHARAN 141 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

216. 504310 PANKAJ KUMAR 156 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

217. 504336 PAWAN KUMAR 157 I & PH

218. 504339 PAWAN KUMAR 162 HPSEBL

219. 504340 PAWAN KUMAR 155 HIGHER EDUCATION

220. 504405 POONAM SHARMA 163 HP BOSE

221. 504432 PRAVEEN KUMAR 153 SC& STDEV.CORPORATION

222. 504444 PRITAN DEVI 146 HEALTH

223. 504455 PRIYANKA CHAUHAN 142 DC OFFICE HAMIRPUR

224. 504480 PUSHP RAJ 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

225. 504481 PUSHP LATA 139 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

226. 504484 PUSHPA DEVI 158 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

227. 504486 PUSHPINDER 145 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

228. 504509 RAJ KUMAR 137 I & PH

229. 504513 RAJ KUMAR 135 HOMEGUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

230. 504518 RAJAN CHOUDHARY 151 HIGHER EDUCATION

231. 504537 RAJENDER KUMAR 134 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

232. 504554 RAJESH KUMAR 166 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

233. 504569 RAJKRISHAN DHIMAN 152 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

234. 504597 RAKESH KUMAR 156 PANCHAYATI RAJ

235. 504603 RAKESH KUMAR 155 ELECTION

236. 504609 RAKESH KUMAR 137 I &PH

237. 504610 RAKESH KUMAR 157 FINANCE (T&A)

238. 504613 RAKESH RANA 157 HPSEBL

239. 504634 RANBIR SINGH 145 HPSEBL

240. 504655 RASEED MOHAMMAD 139 HOMEGUARD & CIVIL DEFENCE


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

18

241. 504657 RASHPAL SINGH 140 HPSEBL

242. 504665 RAVI KUMAR 172 DC OFFICE HAMIRPUR

243. 504677 RAVINDER KUMAR 117 HPSEBL

244. 504698 REENA KUMARI 140 HEALTH

245. 504725 REKHA DEVI 157 HPSEBL

246. 504750 RITA DEVI 141 HEALTH

247. 504796 SAMIKSHA SHARMA 158 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

248. 504847 SANJEEV PATIAL 161 I &PH

249. 504848 SANJEEV RANA 147 FOREST

250. 504857 SANTOSH KUMAR 135 I &PH

251. 504870 SAPNA 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

252. 504888 SAPNA RANI 137 HEALTH

253. 504903 SATISH KUMAR 140 HPSEBL

254. 504904 SATISH KUMAR 158 I &PH

255. 504968 SHASHI BALA 153 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

256. 504970 SHASHI KANT 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

257. 504982 SHASHI PAUL 138 HEALTH

258. 505024 SHIWALI KATOCH 157 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

259. 505029 SHOBHA SHARMA 170 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

260. 505031 SHRIKANT KUMAR 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

261. 505124 SUNIL KUMAR 139 HPSEBL

262. 505129 SUNIL KUMAR 142 HEALTH


264. 505195 SURJEET SINGH 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

265. 505203 SUSHEEL KUMAR 157 HIGHER EDUCATION

266. 505244 TILAK RAJ 141 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

267. 505299 VIJAY KUMAR 144 HPSEBL

268. 505301 VIJAY KUMAR 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

269. 505305 VIJAY KUMAR 144 DC OFFICE HAMIRPUR

270. 505307 VIJAY KUMAR 154 SOCIAL JUSTICE &


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

19

EMPOWERMENT


272. 505316 VIKAS BHARADWAJ 145 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

273. 505318 VIKAS KAUSHIV 156 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

274. 505331 VIKASH KUMAR 138 FINANCE (T&A)

275. 505378 VINOD VERMA 158 HPSEBL

276. 505432 VIVEK PURI 170 HPSEBL

277. 505450 SURJITENDER 138 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

278. 505453 VINAMAR PRASHAR 154 URBAN DEVELOPMENT

279. 505546 AJAY KUMAR 134 DCOFFICE UNA

280. 505557 AJAY KUMAR 157 DC OFFICE KANGRA

281. 505558 AJAY KUMAR 140 I &PH

282. 505562 AJAY KUMAR 142 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

283. 505572 AJEET KUMAR 142 DC OFFICEKANGRA

284. 505579 AKSHAY KAPOOR 140 HEALTH

285. 505587 AMAN 138 HPSEBL

286. 505615 AMIN CHAND 138 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

287. 505622 AMIT DOGRA 171 HIGHER EDUCATION

288. 505627 AMIT KUMAR 156 DC OFFICE KANGRA


290. 505630 AMIT KUMAR 162 HP BOSE

291. 505632 AMIT KUMAR 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

292. 505644 AMIT RANA 176 HIGHER EDUCATION

293. 505666 ANIL KUMAR 145 FOREST

294. 505674 ANIL KUMAR 146 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

295. 505680 ANIL KUMAR 149 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES


297. 505695 ANISH KUMAR 149 HPSEBL

298. 505700 ANISH KUMAR 139 FINANCE (T&A)


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

20

299. 505747 ANKUR SINGHOTRA 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

300. 505749 ANKIT DOGRA 171 DCOFFICEKANGRA

301. 505765 ANKUSH KUMAR 136 DC OFFICE KANGRA

302. 505773 ANOOP KUMAR 155 CO-OPERATION

303. 505792 ANUJ KUMAR 150 HEALTH

304. 505806 ANURADHA CHOPRA 164 HP BOSE

305. 505841 ARUN SINGH 134 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

306. 505844 ARUNA DEVI 144 HP BOSE

307. 505854 ARVIND SOOD 145 HPSEBL

308. 505887 ASHISH WALIA 160 DC OFFICE KANGRA

309. 505902 ASHWANI KUMAR 164 I &PH

310. 505904 ASHWANI KUMAR 135 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

311. 505921 AVINASH CHAUDHARY 138 HPSEBL

312. 505924 AVINASH KUMAR 161 I &PH

313. 505930 AVNEESH KUMAR 145 DC OFFICE KANGRA

314. 505949 BALBIR KUMAR 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

315. 505994 BIPAN SINGH 150 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

316. 505997 BIRANJANA KUMARI 134 HIMUDA

317. 506010 CHANDER SHEKHAR 152 HIGHER EDUCATION

318. 506080 DINESH KUMAR 162 HP BOSE

319. 506106 GAURAV KUMAR 139 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

320. 506110 GAURAV SHARMA 156 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

321. 506133 GURMEET KUMAR 141 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

322. 506134 GURMEET SINGH 161 AGRICULTURE

323. 506151 HEM RAJ 152 I & PH

324. 506173 ISHWAR DASS 122 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

325. 506179 JAGDISH CHAND 138 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

326. 506181 JAGDISH CHAND 115 HEALTH

327. 506187 JASBIR SINGH 158 HPPWD


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

21

328. 506193 JASVIR KUMAR 136 PANCHAYATI RAJ

329. 506197 JATINDER KUMAR 137 HEALTH

330. 506205 JITENDER KUMAR 132 AGRICULTURE

331. 506237 KALPNA KUMARI 142 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

332. 506244 KAMAL CHOUDHARY 163 HP BOSE

333. 506245 KAMAL DEEP 141 HPSEBL

334. 506262 KAMLESH KUMAR 154 HIMUDA

335. 506276 KAPIL DEV 154 LAND RECORDS

336. 506293 KAVISH KONDAL 152 HIGHER EDUCATION

337. 506325 KRANTI KUMAR 144 ELEMENTAR EDUCATION

338. 506361 KUSUM KUMAR 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

339. 506394 MADHU BALA 137 HEALTH

340. 506400 MAHINDER SINGH 146 HPSEBL

341. 506408 MAMTA KUMARI 156 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

342. 506429 MANISH KUMAR 141 I &PH

343. 506441 MANJEET KUMAR 140 I &PH

344. 506470 MANOJ KUMAR 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

345. 506483 MAYA DEVI 154 HIMUDA

346. 506488 MEENADEVI 133 HOMEGUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

347. 506489 MEENA DEVI 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

348. 506512 MINAKSHI THAKUR 140 INDUSTRIES

349. 506513 MITAKSHI 138 DC OFFICE KANGRA

350. 506520 MOHINDER PAL 134 HIGHER EDUCATION

351. 506542 MONIKA DEVI 158 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

352. 506548 MONIKA KUMARI 138 CO-OPERATION

353. 506567 MUKUL 156 DC OFFICE KANGRA

354. 506568 MUNEESHA 143 INDUSTRIES

355. 506586 MUNISH KUMAR 145 HPSEBL

356. 506612 NARINDER KUMAR 143 HEALTH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

22

357. 506614 NARINDER SINGH 147 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

358. 506641 NEEL KAMAL 161 DCOFFICEKANGRA

359. 506674 NIDHI SHARMA 161 DCOFFICEKANGRA

360. 506713 NITIN KUMAR 136 TRANSPORT

361. 506714 NITIN THAKUR 179 HIGHEREDUCATION

362. 506715 NITISH 147 DC OFFICE KANGRA

363. 506739 PANKAJ BHATIYA 134 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

364. 506745 PANKAJ KUMAR 141 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

365. 506752 PANKAJ KUMAR 145 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

366. 506772 PARDEEP KUMAR 140 HEALTH

367. 506787 PARVEEN KUMAR 136 CO-OPERATION

368. 506833 POOJA KUMARI 154 HOME GUARD & CIVIL DEFENCE

369. 506868 PRAVEEN KUMAR 181 HP BOSE

370. 506873 PRAVESH BHATIA 163 HPSEBL

371. 506916 PUSHPINDER 140 I &PH

372. 506931 RAHUL 142 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

373. 506937 RAHUL KAPOOR 145 DC OFFICE KANGRA

374. 506948 RAJ KUMAR 163 DC OFFICE KANGRA

375. 506949 RAJ KUMAR 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

376. 506953 RAJ KUMAR 147 HPSEBL

377. 506959 RAJAN KAPOOR 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

378. 506981 RAJEEV KUMAR 155 DC OFFICE KANGRA

379. 506987 RAJENDER KUMAR 163 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

380. 506990 RAJESH CHAND 145 HPSEBL

381. 506997 RAJESH KUMAR 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

382. 507013 RAJEEV KUMAR 160 HPSEBL

383. 507033 RAJ KUMBER KATOCH 159 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

384. 507098 RAMAN KUMAR 139 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

23

385. 507105 RAMAN SINGH 166 HPSEBL

386. 507110 RAMESHWAR 155 INDUSTRIES

387. 507117 RANBIR SINGH 145 HPSEBL

388. 507128 RANJEET SINGH 139 HPSEBL


390. 507185 RAVINDER KUMAR 162 FOREST

391. 507204 REENU 134 HIMUDA

392. 507218 RENU BALA 138 DC OFFICE KANGRA

393. 507228 REVEK KUMAR 140 FOREST

394. 507239 RINKU KUMAR 150 HPSEBL

395. 507249 RISHU CHOUDHARY 138 HPSEBL

396. 507251 RITA CHOPRA 136 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

397. 507267 ROHIT DHIMAN 139 HEALTH

398. 507281 ROHIT RAJAN 168 HP BOSE

399. 507293 RUCHI SHARMA 156 DC OFFICE KANGRA

400. 507341 SANDEEP KUMAR 151 DC OFFICE KANGRA

401. 507348 SANDEEP KUMAR 137 FINANCE (T&A)

402. 507349 SANDEEP KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

403. 507363 SANDHYA DEVI 153 HP BOSE

404. 507373 SANJAY KUMAR 143 I &PH

405. 507398 SANJAY KUMAR 145 DC OFFICE KANGRA

406. 507400 SANJEET KUMAR 149 DC OFFICE KANGRA

407. 507403 SANJEEV KUMAR 145 FOOD & CIVIL SUPPLIES

408. 507419 SANJEEV KUMAR 155 HP BOSE

409. 507427 SANJEEV KUMAR 163 HEALTH

410. 507449 SAPNA 160 HPSEBL

411. 507481 SARV JEET 143 I &PH


413. 507492 SATISH KUMAR 157 I &PH

414. 507503 SAURABH SHARMA 171 DC OFFICE KANGRA


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

24

415. 507519 SEEMA DEVI 144 HIGHER EDUCATION

416. 507574 SHASHI PAUL 137 HPSEBL

417. 507585 SHESHAV 134 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

418. 507620 SHIVANI 134 LAND RECORDS

419. 507621 SHIVANI 141 FINANCE (T&A)

420. 507625 SHIVANI MISHRA 175 FOOD & CIVIL SUPPLIES

421. 507646 SOM DUTT 134 LAND RECORDS

422. 507648 SONIA 135 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

423. 507656 SONIKA KUMARI 143 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

424. 507667 SUBHASH CHAND 139 ANIMALHUSBANDRY

425. 507670 SUDERSHANA KUMARI 152 HIGHER EDUCATION

426. 507676 SUDHIR KUMAR 151 HPSEBL

427. 507677 SUDHIR KUMAR 146 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

428. 507684 SUKHRAM 136 AGRICULTURE

429. 507697 SUMAN KUMAR 134 PROSECUTION

430. 507699 SUMAN KUMARI 132 HEALTH

431. 507702 SUMEET KUMAR 177 HIGHER EDUCATION

432. 507713 SUNIT KUMAR 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

433. 507722 SUNEEL KUMAR 137 HPSEBL

434. 507737 SUNIL KUMAR 125 DC OFFICE KANGRA

435. 507786 SURENDER KUMAR 152 FINANCE (T&A)

436. 507787 SURENDER SINGH 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

437. 507789 SURESH KUMAR 137 TECHNICA LEDUCATION

438. 507795 SURJEET KUMAR 156 HPSEBL

439. 507807 SUSHIL KUMAR 152 PLANNING

440. 507810 SUSHIL KUMAR 143 HPSEBL

441. 507818 SUSHMA KUMARI 145 I &PH

442. 507872 VANDANA SHARMA 167 HIGHER EDUCATION

443. 507898 VIJAY KUMAR 157 TECHNICAL EDUCATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

25

444. 507900 VIJAY KUMAR 133HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS

445. 507901 VIJAY KUMAR 154 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

446. 507902 VIJAY KUMAR 159 DC OFFICE KANGRA

447. 507908 VIJAY KUMAR 161 HPSEBL

448. 507947 VIKRANT KATOCH 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

449. 507950 VINAY KUMAR 145 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION


451. 507974 VINOD KUMAR 143 HPPWD

452. 507977 VINOD KUMAR 140 DC OFFICE KANGRA

453. 507996 VIPAN KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

454. 508001 VIRENDER 146 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

455. 508013 VISHAL 138 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

456. 508027 VISHAL PAL 157 HPSEBL

457. 508029 VISHAL SAINI 137 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

458. 508043 VIVEK KUMAR 146 DC OFFICE KANGRA

459. 508048 VIVEK SINGH 98 CO-OPERATION

460. 508068 ABHINANDAN KUMAR 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

461. 508125 AMIT KUMAR 146 I &PH

462. 508195 KARAM SINGH 146 HP BOSE

463. 508220 NAGENDER SINGH 143 DC OFFICE KINNAUR

464. 508247 PURAN KUMARI 138 DC OFFICE KINNAUR

465. 508269 RAVINDER SINGH 141 I & PH

466. 508272 SANAM ZNAGMO 137 SC&STDEV. CORPORATION

467. 508328 SUMAN KUMAR 121 HPSEBL

468. 508369 AJAY KUMAR 163 HPSEBL

469. 508379 AMAN DOGRA 145 DCOFFICE HAMIRPUR

470. 508382 AMAR SINGH 139 HPSEBL

471. 508395 ANITA 149 ELEMENTARYEDUCATION

472. 508401 ANITA DEVI 141 HPSEBL

473. 508406 ANITA KUMARI 145 AGRICULTURE


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

26

474. 508433 ASHA DEVI 162 FOREST

475. 508488 BHUPENDER SINGH 174 HIGHEREDUCATION

476. 508497 BIRBAL 137 HPSEBL

477. 508501 BODH RAJ 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

478. 508504 CHAMAN LAL 145 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

479. 508511 CHANDRIKA KAPOOR 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

480. 508519 CHHERING DIKI 140 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

481. 508521 CHIRANJILAL SHARMA 159 HIGHER EDUCATION

482. 508530 DILIP KUMAR 172 FOREST

483. 508568 DHARAM DASS 169 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

484. 508574 DHARMENDER VERMA 169 FOREST

485. 508578 DHARMENDER SINGH 175 HIGHER EDUCATION

486. 508624 GHANSHYAM SINGH 150 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

487. 508659 HEMP RAKASH 149 PANCHAYATIRAJ

488. 508683 HOSHIYAR SINGH 164 DCOFFICEMANDI

489. 508699 JAGDISH KUMAR 140 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

490. 508712 JHABE RAM 148 AGRICULTURE

491. 508732 KAMLA DEVI 139 HEALTH

492. 508750 KEHAR SINGH 143 HPSEBL

493. 508763 KISHAN LAL 121 HPSEBL

494. 508785 LAKSHMANI DEVI 159 I &PH

495. 508813 LOT RAM 154 PROSECUTION

496. 508844 MANOJ KUMAR 167 HIGHER EDUCATION

497. 508849 MANISH SHARMA 155 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

498. 508851 MANJU KUMARI 142 FOREST

499. 508879 MINAKSHI THAKUR 166 HPSEBL

500. 508880 MINENDER SINGH 158 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

501. 508883 MOHAN LAL 153 SC&STDEV. CORPORATION

502. 508904 NARENDER KUMAR 161 FOREST

503. 508922 NEELAM 149 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

27

504. 508934 NEERJA SHARMA 155 DC OFFICE UNA

505. 508939 NEHA KUMARI 162 HIGHER EDUCATION

506. 508969 OM DUTT 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

507. 509000 POONAM 144 HPSEBL

508. 509015 PRANAV THAKUR 161 DC OFFICE KANGRA

509. 509038 PURAN CHAND 157 FOREST

510. 509045 PUSHP RAJ PURAN 152 HPSEBL

511. 509046 PUSHPA DEVI 148 HPSEBL

512. 509054 RACHANA BRAMTAH 136 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

513. 509056 RACHNA THAKUR 160 HPSEBL

514. 509082 RAJESH KUMAR 143 I &PH

515. 509091 RAJESH THKAUR 173 HIGHER EDUCATION

516. 509095 RAJNEE KUMARI 137 I &PH

517. 509116 RAMANA 166 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

518. 509118 RAMESH KUMAR 172 DC OFFICE MANDI

519. 509141 REENA 155 PANCHAYATI RAJ

520. 509172 RISHI RAJ 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

521. 509174 RITA THAKUR 159 AGRICULTURE

522. 509183 ROOM SINGH 164 HPSEBL

523. 509190 RUBIYA KUMARI 160 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

524. 509193 RUMLA DEVI 154 CO-OPERATION

525. 509220 SANJOG SINGH 157 HPSEBL

526. 509223 SANTOSH KUMAR 153 HPSEBL

527. 509227 SARITA THAKUR 180 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

528. 509237 SAVITA 150 HPSEBL

529. 509250 SHALINI 162 HPSEBL

530. 509255 SHASHI VERMA 167 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

531. 509284 SOM DEV 154 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

532. 509295 SONIA THAKUR 162 HEALTH

533. 509299 SUBHASH KUMAR 153 SC & ST DEV.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

28

CORPORATION

534. 509316 SUNIL KUMAR 155 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

535. 509326 SUNITA BODH 137 HIGHER EDUCATION

536. 509333 SUNITA RAVAT 146 HPSEBL

537. 509344 SURENDER SINGH 173 HIGHER EDUCATION

538. 509347 SURESH KUMAR 151 HIGHER EDUCATION

539. 509349SURINDER KUMAR

134 PROSECUTION

540. 509356 SWEETY 151 HPSEBL

541. 509368 TARUN KUMAR 143 HPSEBL

542. 509369 TARUN THAKUR 157 HPSEBL

543. 509385 THAKUR DASS 142 FINANCE(T&A)

544. 509387 THULLU RAM 139 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

545. 509396 TRISHLA DEVI 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

546. 509409 USHA THAKUR 169 HIGHER EDUCATION

547. 509420 VARYAM SINGH 156 I &PH

548. 509422 VED PRAKASH 160 HPSEBL


550. 509452 VINOD 145 HPSEBL

551. 509481 YASH PAL THAKUR 160 HIGHER EDUCATION

552. 509483 YOG RAJ 153 PROSECUTION

553. 509495 TANZIN 141 DCOFFICE SIRMOUR

554. 509528 KAPIL DEV 141 FOREST

555. 509609 AJAY KUMAR 144 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

556. 509620 AJAY KUMAR 129 DC OFFICEMANDI

557. 509623 AJAY SHARMA 155 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

558. 509625 AJEET KUMAR 150 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

559. 509638 AMAN DEEP 164 HPPWD

560. 509644 AMAR CHAND 134 HOME GUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

561. 509647 AMAR SINGH 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

562. 509650 AMARJEET SINGH 137 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

29

563. 509661 AMIT KUMAR 152 DC OFFICE MANDI

564. 509666 AMIT KUMAR 153 HEALTH

565. 509682 ANAND MURTI 138 HPSEBL

566. 509735 ANITA KUMARI 159 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

567. 509746 ANJANA DEVI 158 HPSEBL

568. 509784 ANOOP KUMAR 153 DC OFFICE UNA

569. 509800 ANURADHA 124 HPSEBL

570. 509802 ANURADHA 140 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

571. 509804 ANURAG 139 FOREST

572. 509841 ASHISH KUMAR 144 HPSEBL

573. 509842 ASHISH KUMAR 167 DC OFFICE MANDI

574. 509859 ASHWANI KUMAR 141 HPSEBL

575. 509895 BANDANA DEVI 139 I &PH

576. 509897 BANDANA THAKUR 155 PANCHAYATI RAJ

577. 509905 BANITA KUMARI 156 HPSEBL

578. 509923 BHAGAT RAM 160 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

579. 509930 BHARAT ARORA 153 MUNICIPALCORPORATIONDHARAMSALA

580. 509938 BHARATI SHARMA 159 HEALTH

581. 509945 BHARTI 161 WOMEN &CHILD DEV.

582. 509949 BHAVAN KUMAR 155 HORTICULTURE

583. 509952 BHAVNA DEVI 124 HEALTH

584. 509978 BHOPENDER KUMAR 136 LANDRECORDS

585. 509981 BHUP SINGH 154 CO-OPERATION

586. 510015 BODH RAJ 156 FOREST

587. 510016 BOBBY KUMAR 143 HEALTH

588. 510021 BRIJ LAL 140 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

589. 510026 CHAMAN 142 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

590. 510043 CHAMAN PRAKASH 161 AGRICULTURE

591. 510046 CHAMPA DEVI 161 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

30

592. 510063 CHANDER MANI 138 AGRICULTURE

593. 510065 CHANDER SINGH 140 HEALTH

594. 510068 CHANDNI 162 FOREST

595. 510076 CHARAN JIT 164 DC OFFICE MANDI

596. 510084 CHET RAM 154 HPSEBL

597. 510087 CHETAN 173 HIGHER EDUCATION

598. 510092 CHETNA TANDON 168 DC OFFICE MANDI

599. 510115 DALIP KUMAR 141 HPSEBL

600. 510118 DILIP SINGH 165 HIGHER EDUCATION

601. 510130 DAULAT RAM 158 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

602. 510139 DEEP KUMAR 151 HPSEBL

603. 510143 DEEP RAJ 151 TRANSPORT

604. 510157 DEEPAK KUMAR 163 DC OFFICEL &S

605. 510204 DHANI RAM 150 SC & STDEV.CORPORATION

606. 510222 DHARMENDER SINGH 155 HORTICULTURE

607. 510224 DHEERAJ KUMAR 144 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

608. 510242 DIMPLE KUMARI 143 HPSEBL

609. 510248 DINA NATH 152 HPSEBL

610. 510249 DINA NATH 146 DC OFFICE MANDI

611. 510274 DIVENDER SINGH 154 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

612. 510298 DURGI DEVI 153 DC OFFICE MANDI

613. 510308 GAGAN SHARMA 172 DC OFFICE MANDI

614. 510321 GAURAV KUMAR 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

615. 510335 GHAN SHYAM 135 YOUTH SERVICES & SPORTS

616. 510370 GOPAL SINGH 146 AGRICULTURE

617. 510374 GOVERDHAN SINGH 138 HPSEBL

618. 510381 GULAB SINGH 154 RURALDEVELOPMENT

619. 510389 GUR DEV 137 HPSEBL

620. 510394 HAMIR SINGH 158 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

31

621. 510395 HANS RAJ 163 HPSEBL

622. 510398 HANS RAJ 152 HPSEBL

623. 510411 HARISH SHARMA 158 HEALTH

624. 510420 HARISH KUMAR 138 HEALTH

625. 510421 HARISH KUMAR 172 I &PH

626. 510426 HARISH KUMAR 170 HPSIDC

627. 510434 HARSH LATA 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

628. 510456 HEM RAJ 171 DC OFFICE MANDI

629. 510462 HEM RAJ 160 FOREST

630. 510463 HEM RAJ 145 HIGHER EDUCATION

631. 510474 HEMANT 156 HEALTH

632. 510481 HEM LATA 154 SC& STDEV. CORPORATION

633. 510486 HET RAM 149 HIGHER EDUCATION

634. 510487 HET RAM 149 HIGHER EDUCATION

635. 510521 INDER SINGH 145 HPPWD

636. 510555 JAI PAL 134 HOME GUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

637. 510556 JAI PAL 173 DC OFFICE MANDI

638. 510583 JHAVE RAM 141 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

639. 510585 JITEDNER SINGH 159 TOWN & COUNTRYPLANNING

640. 510629 KAKU 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

641. 510637 KALPANA SIHAL 138 HEALTH

642. 510650 KAMAL KISHORE 143 HPSEBL

643. 510654 KAMAL PARKASH 158 I &PH

644. 510656 KAMAL SHARMA 157 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

645. 510668 KAMLESH KAUSHAL 137 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

646. 510689 KANTA DEVI 141 TECHNICALEDUCATION

647. 510721 KESHAV RAM 155 HIGHEREDU CATION

648. 510722 KEWAL KRISHAN 147 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

649. 510725 KHAZANA RAM 153 HOME GUARD & CIVIL DEFENCE


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

32

650. 510734 KHEM RAJ 153 DC OFFICE CHAMBA

651. 510735 KHEM RAJ 155 CO-OPERATION

652. 510738 KHEEM RAJ 158 HPSEBL

653. 510745 KHEM SINGH 136 HOME GUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

654. 510763 KIRAN KUMARI 135 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

655. 510771 KISHAN CHAND 148 HEALTH

656. 510780 KRISHAN DEV 142 I &PH

657. 510790 KRISHAN KUMAR 134 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

658. 510800 KUKU RAM 135 CO-OPERATION

659. 510801 KULBHUSHAN THAKUR 158 HEALTH

660. 510806 KULDEEP CHAND 145 HPSEBL

661. 510819 KUMARI ANJANI 163 HP BOSE

662. 510839 KUSHAM LATA 160 HEALTH

663. 510869 LALIT KUMAR 160 DC OFFICE KANGRA

664. 510870 LALIT KUMAR 158 I &PH

665. 510872 LALIT KUMAR 146 DC OFFICE MANDI

666. 510890 LATA DEVI 141 FOREST

667. 510898 LAVISHA SHARMA 167 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

668. 510905 LEELA DHAR 152 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

669. 510906 LEELA DHAR 153 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

670. 510908 LEELA DHAR 185 HPSEBL

671. 510913 LEKHRAJ 158 HEALTH

672. 510930 MADAN KUMAR 143 I &PH

673. 510932 MADAN LAL 158 HPSEBL

674. 510946 MAHENDER KUMAR 145 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

675. 510955 MAHESH KUMAR 158 HEALTH

676. 510983 MAN SINGH 143 HPSEBL

677. 510985 MANEESH KUMAR 156 FOREST

678. 511006 MANJEET SEN 161 DC OFFICE MANDI


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

33

679. 511013 MANJU DEVI 161 HPSEBL

680. 511015 MANJU DEVI 159 HEALTH

681. 511019 MANJULA KUMARI 154 INDUSTRIES


683. 511035 MANOJ KUMAR 155 PANCHAYATI RAJ

684. 511121 MOHAR LAL 158 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

685. 511122 MOHAR LAL 145 HIGHER EDUCATION

686. 511170 MUNISH KUMAR 140 DC OFFICE MANDI

687. 511175 MUNSHI RAM 155 FOREST

688. 511178 NAG DEV 159 FINANCE (T&A)

689. 511189 NAND LAL 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

690. 511200 NARENDER KUMAR 159 AGRICULTURE

691. 511215 NARESH KUMAR 153 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

692. 511227 NARESH KUMAR 138 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

693. 511233 NARESH KUMAR 158 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

694. 511242 NASEEB KUMAR 125 HPSEBL

695. 511263 NEEL KAMAL 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

696. 511300 NEERAJ KUMAR 141 AGRICULTURE

697. 511301 NEERAJ KUMAR 162 HPSEBL

698. 511320 NEK RAM 161 HP BOSE

699. 511334 NIRMLA DEVI 178 HIGHER EDUCATION

700. 511361 NISHA KUMARI 142 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

701. 511366 NISHANT THAKUR 173 HIGHER EDUCATION

702. 511390 OM PARKASH 110 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

703. 511391 OM CHAND 142 HPPWD

704. 511392 OM PARKASH 159 HPSEBL

705. 511396 OM PRAKASH 171 PROSECUTION

706. 511398 OM PRAKASH 153 DC OFFICE L&S

707. 511406 OM PRAKSH 152 DC OFFICE MANDI


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

34

708. 511421 PALLVI 138 DC OFFICE BILASPUR

709. 511427 PANJKU RAM 138 FINANCE (T&A)

710. 511436 PANKAJ KUMAR 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

711. 511484 PAWAN KUMAR 135 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

712. 511493 PAWAN KUMAR 161 FINANCE (T&A)

713. 511522 POOJA DEVI 144 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

714. 511527 POOJA DEVI 169 I &PH

715. 511538 POONAM 155 INDUSTRIES

716. 511549 PRADEEP KUMAR 125 HEALTH

717. 511561 PRAKASH CHAND 159 HEALTH

718. 511564 PRAKASH CHAND 123 INDUSTRIES

719. 511582 PRATIBHA THAKUR 180 HIGHER EDUCATION

720. 511584 PRATIMA VERMA 155 ELECTION

721. 511621 PREM SINGH 155 HORTICULTURE

722. 511643 PRIYANKA KUMARI 158 HEALTH

723. 511655 PROVINA 141 HEALTH

724. 511673 PUSHAP RAJ 154 PROSECUTION

725. 511678 PUSHPA DEVI 149 HEALTH

726. 511686 RADHA DEVI 159 HEALTH

727. 511702 RAJ KUMAR 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

728. 511725 RAJENDER KUMAR 135 DC OFFICE UNA

729. 511734 RAJENDER PAL 138 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

730. 511735 RAJENDER SINGH 166 DC OFFICE MANDI

731. 511741 RAJESH KUMAR 160 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

732. 511745 RAJESH KUMAR 169 HPSEBL

733. 511759 RAJESH KUMAR 146 DC OFFICE MANDI

734. 511767 RAJNI 173 DC OFFI E MANDI

735. 511777 RAKESH KUMAR 156 FOREST

736. 511785 RAKESH KUMAR 163 DC OFFICE MANDI

737. 511793 RAKESH KUMAR 135 LABOUR COMMISSIONER


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

35

738. 511872 RANBIR SINGH 147 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

739. 511874 RANDHIR SINGH 172 DC OFFICE MANDI

740. 511880 RANVEER SINGH 157 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

741. 511892 RAVI KUMAR 155 INDUSTRIES

742. 511905 RAVI THAKUR 172 HPPWD

743. 511936 REENA KUMARI 156 HEALTH

744. 511986 RITU KUMARI 159 HPSEBL

745. 512012 ROSHAN LAL 156 I &PH

746. 512059 SANGEETA 179 HIGHER EDUCATION

747. 512066 SANJAY KUMAR 159 HPSEBL

748. 512068 SANJAY KUMAR 149 HP BOSE

749. 512070 SANJAY KUMAR 167 DC OFFICE MANDI

750. 512073 SANJAY KUMAR 138 PLANNING

751. 512078 SANJAY KUMAR 141 HPSEBL

752. 512084 SANJAY KUMAR 135 LAND RECORDS


754. 512130 SANTOSH KUMAR 170 HIGHER EDUCATION

755. 512147 SAPNA DEVI 152 HIGHER EDUCATION

756. 512148 SAPNA DEVI 139 HPSEBL

757. 512150 SAPNA DEVI 177 DC OFFICE MANDI

758. 512161 SARITA 176 DC OFFICE MANDI

759. 512288 SITA DEVI 145 HIGHER EDUCATION

760. 512332 SUDESH KUMAR 144 HPSEBL

761. 512334 SUKH DEV 109 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

762. 512342 SUMAN KUAMRI 160 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

763. 512349 SUMEET KUMAR 138 TECHNICAL EDUCATION


765. 512373 SUNIL KUMAR 155 LABOUR COMMISSIONER



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

36

767. 512386 SUNIL KUMAR 156 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

768. 512387 SUNIL KUMAR 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

769. 512389 SUNIL KUMAR 156 FINANCE (T&A)

770. 512390 SUNIL KUMAR 159 AGRICULTURE

771. 512428 SUNNY RAWAT 160 HEALTH

772. 512434 SURAT RAM 140 HPPWD

773. 512441 SURINDER KUMAR 138 HEALTH

774. 512445 SURESH CHAND 153 DC OFFICE L &S

775. 512460 SURESH KUMAR 144 DC OFFICE MANDI

776. 512468 SURJEET SINGH 129 HPSEBL

777. 512479 SUSHEEL KUMAR 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

778. 512501 SWEETY 162 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

779. 512527 TEK CHAND 141 DC OFFICE MANDI

780. 512533 TEK CHAND 157 HPSEBL

781. 512535 TEK SINGH 158 INDUSTRIES

782. 512550 TILAK RAJ 153 HPSIDC

783. 512551 TILAK RAJ 160 HPSEBL

784. 512552 TILAK RAJ 167 HPSEBL

785. 512557 TULSI DEVI 163 HP BOSE

786. 512560 TWARU 149 HIGHER EDUCATION

787. 512588 USHMA KUMARI 143 HPSEBL

788. 512607 VED PARKASH 151 DC OFFICE KANGRA

789. 512611 VED PRAKASH 146 TRANSPORT

790. 512614 VEENA KUMARI 137 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

791. 512637 VIJAY KUMAR 160 DC OFFICE MANDI

792. 512639 VIJAY KUMAR 144 HEALTH

793. 512650 VIJAY PRAKASH 157 HPSEBL

794. 512655 VIJAY SINGH 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

795. 512656 VIJENDER KUMAR 131 I & PH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

37

796. 512659 VIKAS KUMAR 135 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

797. 512667 VIKRAM KUMAR 153 HOME GUARD & CIVIL DEFENCE

798. 512685 VINOD KUMAR 145 FOREST


800. 512690 VINOD KUMAR 135 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

801. 512718 VIRENDER THAKUR 162 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

802. 512734 VIVEK THAKUR 154 HP PERC

803. 512735 VIVEK THAKUR 178 FINANCE(T&A)

804. 512750 YAMINI SHARMA 158 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

805. 512852 ABHISHEK KAPOOR 160 HPSEBL

806. 512863ADITYA KUMAR ALIAS 134

HPBUILDING&OTHERSCONSTRUCTIONS BOARD

807. 512869 AJAY 155 ELECTION

808. 512878 AJAY KUMAR 164 FOOD &CIVIL SUPPLIES

809. 512909 AKSHIKA SHARMA 155 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

810. 512911 ALKA DEVI 151 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

811. 512917 AMAN DEEP NEGI 144 DC OFFICE KINNAUR


813. 512957 AMIT KUMAR 163 HORTICULTURE

814. 512964 AMIT VERMA 162 ECONOMIC ADVISOR

815. 512971 ANKUR SONI 159 HPSEBL

816. 512976 ANAMIKA 156 FINANCE (T&A)

817. 512979 ANARKALI 153HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS

818. 512988 ANIL 137 PANCHAYATI RAJ

819. 513008 ANIL KUMAR 160 HEALTH

820. 513015 ANIL KUMAR 160 I &PH

821. 513016 ANIL KUMAR 154 CO-OPERATION

822. 513026 ANITA 137 I &PH

823. 513042 ANITA KUMARI 137 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

824. 513044 ANITA KUMARI 157 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

38

825. 513078 ANJANI 147 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

826. 513091 ANJU 157 HPSEBL

827. 513094 ANJU BODH 137 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

828. 513130 ANNU 136 PANCHAYATI RAJ

829. 513131 ANOOP CHAUHAN 155 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

830. 513137 ANU 153 HP BACKWARD CLASSES & FINANCE DEV.

831. 513145 ANU VERMA 160 URBA NDEVELOPMENT

832. 513151 ANUJ VASHISHT 166 FOREST

833. 513187 ARCHNA SHARMA 154 URBAN DEVELOPMENT

834. 513224 ARVIND SHARMA 172 HPSEBL

835. 513232 ASHA DEVI 143 FINANCE(T&A)

836. 513241 ASHIMA SHARMA 158 HPSEBL

837. 513244 ASHISH 142 DC OFFICE MANDI

838. 513254 ASHOK KUMAR 135 DC OFFICE KANGRA

839. 513258 ASHOK KUMAR 146 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

840. 513259 ASHOK KUMAR 155 HORTICULTURE

841. 513279 ASHWANI KUMAR 167 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

842. 513281 ASHWANI PAL 142 FOOD & CIVIL SUPPLIES

843. 513306 BABITA 156 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

844. 513330 BALBIR SINGH 163 TOWN & COUNTRY PLANNING

845. 513332 BAL DEV 141 HPSEBL

846. 513355 BHAG CHAND 158 FOREST

847. 513360 BHAGAT RAM 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

848. 513375 BHAVANA 167 HPSEBL

849. 513376 BHAVANA DEVI 139 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

850. 513425 BHUPENDER KUMAR 157 HPSEBL

851. 513427 BHUPENDER SHARMA 164 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

852. 513432 BHUPENDER KUMAR 137 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

853. 513443 BHUVNESHWAR 158 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

39

854. 513444 BHUVNESHWARI 140 HPSEBL

855. 513464 BRIJ LAL 166 DC OFFICE MANDI

856. 513465 BRIJ LAL 144 HPSEBL

857. 513470 BUDHI SINGH 160 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

858. 513472 CHAAND KUMARI 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

859. 513495 CHANDER KANT 174 HIGHER EDUCATION

860. 513498 CHANDER KANTA 186 HPSEBL

861. 513522 CHARAN JEET SINGH 161 HEALTH

862. 513545 DALEEP KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

863. 513547 DALEEP KUMAR 139 FOREST

864. 513552 DALIP KUMAR 163 HPSEBL

865. 513576 DEEPAK 146 HIMUDA

866. 513603 DEEPIKA BHARDWAJ 162 FINANCE (T&A)

867. 513604 DEEPIKA DEVI 177 PLANNING

868. 513629 DESH RAJ 154 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

869. 513642 DEVENDER MEHTA 156 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

870. 513648 DEVENDER SINGH 162 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

871. 513649 DEVENDER SINGH 163 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

872. 513708 DIMPLE 154 URBAN DEVELOPMENT

873. 513710 DIMPLE 162 YOUTH SERVICES & PORTS

874. 513720 DINESH 173 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION


876. 513747 DINESH SHARMA 157 FOREST

877. 513758 HEMANT KUMAR 148 HPSEBL

878. 513759 POONAM SHARMA 161 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

879. 513801 DINESH SINGH 154 HOMEGUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

880. 513803 DINESH THAKUR 156 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

881. 513829 GAJENDER SINGH 151 HPSEBL

882. 513868 GEETESHWER VERMA 162 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

40

883. 513929 HARINDER KUMAR 156 TRANSPORT

884. 513953 HARISH THAKUR 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

885. 513974 HEM LATA 160 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

886. 513982 HEM LATA 167 FOREST

887. 513987 HEM PARKASH 153 PRISON & CORRECTIONALSERVICES

888. 513999 HEMANT KUMAR 152 HIMUDA

889. 514017 HEM RAJ 144 HEALTH

890. 514019 HEM RAJ 153 SC &ST DEV.CORPORATION

891. 514028 HIRA BHUSHAN 156 FOREST

892. 514045 HOSHIAR SINGH 155 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

893. 514046 HOSHIYAR SINGH 157 HIGHER EDUCATION

894. 514054 INDER SINGH 167 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

895. 514083 JAGDISH CHAND 134 HEALTH

896. 514084 JAGDISH KUMAR 168 HIGHER EDUCATION

897. 514097 JAINAND SINGH 140 DC OFFICE KINNAUR

898. 514110 JANESHWER THAKUR 156 HIGHER EDUCATION

899. 514134 JITENDER KUMAR 153HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS WORKER

900. 514143 JITENDER THAKUR 157 HPSEBL

901. 514164 JYOTI SHARMA 154 URBAN DEVELOPMENT

902. 514181 KAKU RAM 138 HPSEBL

903. 514193 KALPNA THAKUR 162 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

904. 514207 KAMAL KISHORE 159 FOREST

905. 514226 KAMLESH KUMARI 142 HPSEBL

906. 514238 KANHAIYA LAL 155 PANCHAYATI RAJ

907. 514254 KAPIL THAKUR 158 HPSEBL

908. 514259 KARAN DEEP 144 HPSEBL

909. 514263 KARTIK 156 FOREST

910. 514287 KAVITA RANI 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

911. 514288 KAVITA THAKUR 174 HIGHER EDUCATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

41

912. 514292 KEWAL KRISHAN 154 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

913. 514304 KHEM RAJ 139 HPSEBL

914. 514306 KHEM SINGH 145 HPSEBL

915. 514311 KHOR SINGH 165 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

916. 514334 KIRAN KANWAR 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

917. 514340 KIRAN KUMARI 147 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

918. 514360 KISHOR KUMAR 138 FINANCE (T&A)

919. 514366 KRISHAN DUTT 146 HIGHER EDUCATION

920. 514376 KRISHNA DEVI 170 PLANNING

921. 514385 KULDEEP 139 FINANCE (T&A)

922. 514398 KULDEEP KUMAR 158 I &PH

923. 514414 KUMAR SINGH 157 I &PH

924. 514430 KUMARI LATA 154 HPPERC

925. 514448 KUMARI SUMAN PAL 141 HPSEBL

926. 514461 KUSUM SHARMA 162 FINANCE (T&A)

927. 514471 LAL CHAND 141 FOREST

928. 514482 LALIT KUMAR 153 HP BACKWARD CLASSES

929. 514496 LALITA KUMARI 144 HPSEBL

930. 514502 LAJVANTI 174 HIGHER EDUCATION

931. 514522 LAYAK RAM 165 HIMUDA

932. 514530 LEELA DASS 142 HPSEBL

933. 514532 LEENA DEVI 171 HPSEBL

934. 514541 LOKENDER KUMAR 162 HPSEBL

935. 514542 LOKENDER SHARMA 157 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

936. 514551 MAAN SINGH 148 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

937. 514552 MADAN GOPAL 165 HPSEBL

938. 514555 MADAN LAL 136 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

939. 514556 MADAN LAL 154 LABOUR COMMISSIONER


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

42

940. 514557 MADAN LAL 143 HPSEBL

941. 514566 MADHU BALA 148 PLANNING

942. 514568 MADHU BALA 165 HPSEBL

943. 514592 MAHESH KUMAR 146 HEALTH

944. 514593 MAHESH KUMAR 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

945. 514607 MAMTA 134 ECONOMIC ADVISOR

946. 514609 MAMTA 159 HEALTH

947. 514620 MAMTA THAKUR 154 HPPERC

948. 514625 MAN BHAWAN 167 HIGHER EDUCATION

949. 514639 MANISH SHARMA 160 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

950. 514648 MANISHA SHARMA 122 WOMEN &CHILD DEV.

951. 514659 MANJOO KUMARI 145 HPSEBL

952. 514668 MANJU KUMARI 172 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

953. 514687 MANOHAR LAL 161 HPSEBL

954. 514688 MANOHAR LAL 138 FOREST

955. 514695 MANOJ KUMAR 162 HEALTH



958. 514708 MANOJ KUMAR 151 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES



961. 514736 MEENA DEVI 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

962. 514737 MEENA KUMARI 153 HP BACKWARD CLASSES &FINANCEDEV.

963. 514742 MEENAKSHI 141 FOREST

964. 514743 MEENAKSHI 161 HPSEBL

965. 514753 MEENAKSHI 160 FOREST

966. 514759 MEENAKSHI THAKUR 157 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

967. 514780 MEGHA SHARMA 170 HPPWD


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

43

968. 514790 MINENDER SHARMA 157 HPSEBL

969. 514806 MOHINDER RAJ 142 HPSEBL

970. 514824 MONIKA DEVI 134 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

971. 514827 MONIKA JAGYAN 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

972. 514848 MUKESH KIMTA 166 PRINTING&STATIONERY

973. 514850 MUKESH KUMAR 138 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

974. 514873 MUNISH KUMAR 153 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

975. 514879 NAGESH THAKUR 165 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

976. 514888 NARENDER 152 HIGHER EDUCATION

977. 514896 NARENDER KUMAR 163 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

978. 514900 NARENDER KUMAR 170 WOMEN &CHILD DEV.

979. 514921 NARPAT RAM 134 ELECTION

980. 514928 NAVEEN KUMAR 158 TRANSPORT

981. 514930 NAVEEN KUMAR 169 DCOFFICE SHIMLA

982. 514946 NEELAM 184 HIGHER EDUCATION

983. 514959 NEELAM KUMARI 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

984. 514978 MEENA KUMARI 169 HIGHER EDUCATION

985. 515000 NEETU KUMARI 162 HPSEBL

986. 515008 NEHAGARG 155 CO-OPERATION

987. 515050 NIRMLA 173 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

988. 515075 NISHA KUMARI 156 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

989. 515093 NITIN SHARMA 161 SC & ST DEV. CORPORATION

990. 515114 OMPRAKASH 134 DC OFFICE KANGRA

991. 515118 OMPRAKASH 154 CO-OPERATION

992. 515139 PANKAJ CHANDEL 164 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

993. 515140 PANKAJ CHAUHAN 169 PLANNING

994. 515150 PANKAJ KUMAR SHARMA 182 PLANNING

995. 515173 PARDEEP KUMAR KAUSHAL

152 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

44

996. 515185 PARVEEN 138 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

997. 515206 PAWAN KUMAR 163 FINANCE (T&A)

998. 515216 PAWAN KUMAR 136 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

999. 515218 PAWAN KUMAR 158 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1000. 515220 PAWAN KUMAR 147 HPSEBL

1001. 515244 POOJA SHARMA 142 DCOFFICE SHIMLA

1002. 515248 POONAM SHARMA 175 HIGHEREDUCATION

1003. 515297 POONAM KUMARI 157 HEALTH

1004. 515317 PRADEEP KUMAR 159 HEALTH

1005. 515318 PRADEEP KUMAR 167 FOREST

1006. 515323 PRADEEP SHARMA 165 ELEMENTAR YEDUCATION

1007. 515326 PRAKASH 156 FOREST

1008. 515335 PRAMILA KUMARI 158 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1009. 515340 PRATIBHA 158 HPSEBL

1010. 515358 PREETAM SINGH 153 DCOFFICE SHIMLA

1011. 515360 PREETI 135 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1012. 515371 PREETI SHARMA 161 HEALTH

1013. 515391 PREM SINGH 177 HPPWD

1014. 515402 PRIYARAJ 146 PLANNING

1015. 515406 PRIYNKA 160 HPSEBL

1016. 515424 PRIYANKA SHARMA 139 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1017. 515442 PROMILA THAKUR 159 HPSEBL

1018. 515452 PUNEET 144 FOREST

1019. 515459 PURAN CHAND 186 HIGHER EDUCATION

1020. 515470 PUSHPA DEVI 143 HPSEBL

1021. 515482 RACHNA THAKUR 140 HPSEBL

1022. 515495 RAGHAV SOOD 145 HPSEBL

1023. 515505 RAHUL RITHWAN 175 HIGHER EDUCATION

1024. 515514 RAJKUMAR 157 HEALTH

1025. 515521 RANJANA VERMA 135HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

45

1026. 515530 RAJEEV 154 HIMUDA

1027. 515533 RAJEEVDHIMAN 134 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

1028. 515543 RAJENDER KUMAR 142 HEALTH

1029. 515551 RAJESH 146 FOREST

1030. 515577 RAJINDER KUMAR 159 HPSEBL

1031. 515578 RAJINDER KUMAR 147 FOREST

1032. 515620 RAKESH KUMAR 133 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

1033. 515624 RAKESH KUMAR 168 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1034. 515638 RAKSHA DEVI 167 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

1035. 515641 RAMGO PAL 159 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

1036. 515669 RAMAN VERMA 172 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1037. 515670 RAMANAND 145 HEALTH

1038. 515678 RAMESHWAR KUMAR 172 FOOD & CIVIL SUPPLIES

1039. 515691 RANJANADEVI 155 INDUSTRIES

1040. 515698 RANJEET MASTANA 135 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

1041. 515701 RANJEET SINGH 121 HPSEBL

1042. 515705 RANJNA MASHTA 169 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1043. 515716 RAVIKANT 149 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1044. 515725 RAVIJA 170 HIGHER EDUCATION

1045. 515736 RAVINDER SINGH 171 HIGHER EDUCATION

1046. 515768 REENA SHARMA 179 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1047. 515778 REENU SHARMA 160 HEALTH

1048. 515785 REETA DEVI 161 HPSEBL

1049. 515788 REETU DEVI 140 HEALTH

1050. 515805 REKHA KASHYAP 141 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1051. 515831 RICHAS IRKECK 170 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

1052. 515850 RITESH KUMAR 163 HPSEBL

1053. 515852 RITIKA CHAUHAN 157 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

46

1054. 515856 RITU 137 FINANCE (T&A)

1055. 515898 RUCHIKA SHARMA 143 HPSEBL

1056. 515938 SANDEEP KUMAR 163 PRINTING & STATIONERY

1057. 515946 SANDEEP SHARMA 136 AGRICULTURE

1058. 515962 SANGEETA 161 HPSEBL

1059. 515966 SANGEETA 136 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

1060. 515984 SANJAY KUMAR 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

1061. 516000 SANJAY KUMAR 134 HOMEGUARD & CIVIL DEFENCE

1062. 516004 SANJEEV 153HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS


1064. 516032 SANTOSHA DEVI 154 HPSIDC

1065. 516052 SAPNA DEVI 135 DC OFFICE KANGRA

1066. 516058 SAPNA THAKUR 154 LAND RECORDS

1067. 516061 SARASWATI 140 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1068. 516069 SARITA DEVI 161 FOREST

1069. 516075 SAROJ 163 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.


1071. 516093 SATISH BUNDEL 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

1072. 516114 SEEMA DEVI 147 HPSEBL

1073. 516135 SHALINI 144 DCOFFICE SHIMLA

1074. 516141 SHALINI SHARMA 169 HIGHER EDUCATION

1075. 516181 SHASHI SHARMA 152 HIGHER EDUCATION

1076. 516187 SHEELA DEVI 140 HEALTH

1077. 516189 SHEELA DEVI 146 DC OFFICE KINNAUR

1078. 516236 SHRAWAN KUMAR 143 HEALTH

1079. 516244 SHUSHANK SHARMA 177 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1080. 516255 SITADEVI 156 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

1081. 516262 SITARAM 166 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

1082. 516291 SONIA SHARMA 159 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

47

1083. 516307 SUBHASH SHARMA 155 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1084. 516311 SUDESH KUMARI 164 HIMUDA

1085. 516325 SUJATATHAKUR 183 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1086. 516328 SUKH RAM 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

1087. 516350 SUMIT KUMAR 156 ECONOMIC ADVISOR

1088. 516363 SUNEELA DEVI 154 SC& STDEV.CORPORATION

1089. 516367 SUNIL DUTT 155 ELECTION

1090. 516375 SUNIL KUMAR 136 CO-OPERATION

1091. 516378 SUNIL KUMAR 169 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1092. 516380 SUNIL KUMAR 158 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1093. 516390 SUNIL KUMAR 158 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

1094. 516401 SUNITA 155 INDUSTRIES

1095. 516402 SUNITA 158 HPSEBL

1096. 516420 SUNITA KUMARI 152 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1097. 516431 SUPRIYA 153 DC OFFICE KINNAUR

1098. 516433 SUPRIYA VERMA 161 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1099. 516446 SURENDER KUMAR 161 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1100. 516454 SURENDER SINGH 158 FOREST

1101. 516463 SURESH KUMAR 135 CO-OPERATION

1102. 516465 SURESH KUMAR 166 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1103. 516471 SURESH KUMAR 156 INFORMATION & TEC.

1104. 516478 SURJEET KUMAR 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

1105. 516486 SUSHEEL KUMAR 170 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1106. 516488 SUSHIL KUMAR 160 FINANCE (T&A)

1107. 516494 SUSHIL SHARMA 177 PLANNING

1108. 516521 TAMANNA KUMARI 139 HPSEBL

1109. 516527 TARACHAND 162 HEALTH

1110. 516542 TEJINDER KUMAR 156 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1111. 516552 TENZIN NORBU 137 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1112. 516573 UMESH KUMAR 147 I & PH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

48

1113. 516630 VEENA DEVI 158 HPSEBL

1114. 516640 VIDYA SAGAR 155 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1115. 516643 VIJAY 157 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1116. 516650 VIJAY KUMAR 170 DC OFFICE SHIMLA


1118. 516655 VIJAYPAL 152 HPSEBL

1119. 516674 VIKAS 152 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1120. 516679 VIKAS MEHTA 174 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1121. 516686 VIKRAM SINGH 156 FINANCE (T&A)

1122. 516701 VINEET THAKUR 155 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1123. 516730 VIPIN SIRKECK 160 HPSEBL

1124. 516734 VIRENDER 140 FOREST

1125. 516740 VIRENDER KUMAR 159 HPSEBL

1126. 516746 VISHAL BHARDWAJ 160 HPSEBL

1127. 516758 YAMAN KUMAR 135 HORTICULTURE

1128. 516779 YOGRAJ 154 HIMUDA

1129. 516788 YOGESH KUMAR 149 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

1130. 516792 YOGESH SHARMA 147 HPSEBL

1131. 516804 CHUNILAL 155 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1132. 516809 SAPNA DEVI 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1133. 516825 ADITI GUPTA 159 HPSIDC

1134. 516832 AJAY CHAUHAN 155 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

1135. 516841 AJAY KUMAR 166 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1136. 516859 AMAN SHARMA 153 PROSECUTION

1137. 516872 AMIT KUMAR 155 INDUSTRIES

1138. 516893 ANIL 140 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1139. 516899 ANILKUMAR 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

1140. 516911 ANIL KUMAR 151 RURAL DEVELOPMENT



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

49

1142. 516918 ANIL SHARMA 139 HPSEBL

1143. 516931 ANITA DEVI 150 HPPWD

1144. 516945 ANJANA SHARMA 156 HPSEBL

1145. 516966 ANKUR CHAUHAN 160 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1146. 516975 ANUJ 138 CO-OPERATION

1147. 516984 ANURAG SHARMA 154 CO-OPERATION

1148. 516989 ARJUN BHARDWAJ 138 HPSEBL

1149. 516995 ARTIPUNDIR 158 HEALTH

1150. 517003 ARUN KUMAR 153 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1151. 517007 ARUN KUMAR 141 HEALTH

1152. 517012 ARUN SHARMA 137 HOME GUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

1153. 517014 ARVIND KUMAR 157 HPSEBL

1154. 517023 ASHOK CHAUHAN 169 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1155. 517040 AVINISH 167 HPSEBL

1156. 517050 BABLIDEVI 156 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

1157. 517054 BABLU 141 HPPWD

1158. 517063 BALBIR SINGH 156 HIGHER EDUCATION

1159. 517064 BALDEV 149 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1160. 517072 BALRAJ 137 CO-OPERATION

1161. 517075 BALWANT SINGH 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

1162. 517079 BARURAM 152 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1163. 517080 BARURAM 154 HOME GUARD & CIVILDEFENCE

1164. 517091 BHAGWAN SINGH 143 HPSEBL

1165. 517097 BINTURAM 141 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

1166. 517104 CHAMAN LAL 145 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1167. 517121 DALIP 143 INDUSTRIES

1168. 517131 DEEP CHAND 152 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1169. 517136 DEEPAK KUMAR 151 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1170. 517138 DEEPAK KUMAR 153 HIGHER EDUCATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

50

1171. 517158 DEVENDER SINGH 148 RURALDEVELOPMENT

1172. 517168 DHEERAJ KUMAR 147 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1173. 517169 DHIRAJ TOMAR 154 ANIMAL HUSBANDRY


1175. 517182 DINESH KUMAR 149 HPSEBL

1176. 517185 DINESH KUMAR 145 FOREST

1177. 517192 DINESH KUMARI 143 CO-OPERATION

1178. 517212 GAURAV CHAUHAN 149 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1179. 517219 GEETA RAM 149 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1180. 517223 GOPAL SINGH 110 DC OFFICE SHIMLA

1181. 517235 GURUDUTT SINGH 137 CO-OPERATION

1182. 517261 HEMANT KUMAR 155 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1183. 517281 HONEY KASHYAP 149 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

1184. 517296 ISLAM 156 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1185. 517309 JAIINDER SINGH 167 DCOFFICE SIRMOUR

1186. 517310 JAIPAL 146 HIGHEREDUCATION

1187. 517313 JAIPRAKASH 157 HPSEBL

1188. 517315 JAIPRAKASH 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

1189. 517325 JAVEDALI 165 HIGHER EDUCATION

1190. 517329 JITENDER SINGH 154 INDUSTRIES

1191. 517337 JYOTI SHARMA 138 HPSEBL

1192. 517343 KAKU RAMS HARMA 140 FOREST

1193. 517352 KAMALKUMAR 137 CO-OPERATION

1194. 517355 KAMAL RASHMI KHAN 151 HPSEBL

1195. 517357 KAMALSINGH 149 HIGHER EDUCATION

1196. 517359 KAMAL JEET SINGH 153 PROSECUTION

1197. 517362 KAMLESH 154 HOMEGUARD & CIVI LDEFENCE

1198. 517385 KAPIL DEV 145 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1199. 517396 KARAM SINGH 162 HPSEBL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

51

1200. 517398 KARUN SHARMA 164 HPSEBL

1201. 517407 KAVITA SHARMA 153 HIGHER EDUCATION

1202. 517411 KESHWANAND 136 RURALD EVELOPMENT

1203. 517419 KIRAN BALA 157 FOREST

1204. 517422 KIRAN BALA 155 CO-OPERATION

1205. 517430 KIRAN DEVI 141 HPSEBL

1206. 517455 KULDEEP SINGH 145 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1207. 517500 LEELA DEVI 142 FOREST

1208. 517508 LUBNANAZ 139 FINANCE (T&A)

1209. 517516 MAHESH KUMAR 146 DCOFFICE SIRMOUR

1210. 517540 MANDEEP KUMAR 171 DCOFFICE SIRMOUR

1211. 517544 MANISH KUMAR 138 HPSEBL

1212. 517548 MANISH KUMAR 157 FOREST

1213. 517568 MANJANASINGH 160 HPSEBL

1214. 517571 MANJEET KUMARI 164 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1215. 517588 MAYA RAM 144 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1216. 517616 MOHAN SINGH 166 HIGHER EDUCATION

1217. 517619 MOHDASHRAF 140 HPSEBL

1218. 517629 MONIKA CHAUHAN 159 HPSEBL

1219. 517637 MUKESH KUMAR 155 INDUSTRIES

1220. 517638 MUKESH KUMAR 133 HIGHER EDUCATION

1221. 517640 MUKESH KUMAR 149 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1222. 517641 MUKESH KUMAR 145 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

1223. 517645 MUNISH KOLESH 137 FINANCE (T&A)

1224. 517651 NAMIT KUMAR 171 HIGHER EDUCATION

1225. 517655 NARENDER 144 HEALTH

1226. 517657 NARENDER KUMAR 157 INDUSTRIES

1227. 517659 NARENDER KUMAR 161 CO-OPERATION

1228. 517663 NARENDER SINGH 159 CO-OPERATION

1229. 517665 NARESH CHAND 158 I & PH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

52


1231. 517676 NARESH SHARMA 142 FOREST

1232. 517685 NEELAM KUMARI 153 SC& ST DEV.CORPORATION

1233. 517687 NEELAM CHAUHAN 136 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

1234. 517714 NEETU SAINI 154 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

1235. 517722 NEHAPUNDIR 159 FINANCE (T&A)

1236. 517728 NIDHI TOMAR 153 SC & STDEV.CORPORATION

1237. 517750 NITESH CHAUHAN 171 HIGHER EDUCATION

1238. 517754 NITESH BHATIA 137 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

1239. 517766 PAKIZA 139 HIMUDA

1240. 517770 PANKAJ KUMAR 121 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1241. 517775 PANKAJ SHARMA 149 HPSEBL

1242. 517778 PRAKASH CHAND 141 HPSEBL

1243. 517779 PARMEET 140 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1244. 517783 PARVEEN 141 FOREST

1245. 517785 PARVEEN KUMAR 138 FINANCE (T&A)

1246. 517786 PARVEEN KUMAR 148 HPSEBL

1247. 517796 POOJA DEVI 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1248. 517803 POOJA THAPA 159 HPSEBL

1249. 517817 POONAM SHARMA 164 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1250. 517828 PRADEEP KUMAR 142 HORTICULTURE

1251. 517851 PRAVEEN KUMAR 171 HIGHER EDUCATION

1252. 517854 PRAVESH KUMAR 135 HIMUDA

1253. 517869 PRIYAMDA BHARDWAJ 142 HPSEBL

1254. 517889 PUNAM DEVI 139 HEALTH

1255. 517893 PURAN SINGH 161 HPSEBL

1256. 517903 RACHNA RAWAT 156 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

1257. 517908 RAGHUBIR SINGH 159 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1258. 517918 RAJKUMAR 146 HIGHER EDUCATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

53

1259. 517921 RAJESH KUMAR 136 INDUSTRIES

1260. 517941 RAJESH KUMAR 162 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

1261. 517964 RAJUALI 159 FOREST

1262. 517976 RAKESH KUMAR 159 AGRICULTURE

1263. 517987 RAMAN PUNDER 164 AGRICULTURE

1264. 517993 RAMESH KUMAR 142 HEALTH

1265. 517996 RAMESH SHARMA 158 HPSEBL


1267. 518053 REENA DEVI 153 PROSECUTION

1268. 518059 REKHA DEVI 154 FOREST

1269. 518070 RENU SHARMA 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

1270. 518071 RENU THAKUR 158 HPSEBL

1271. 518080 RITA DEVI 160 HEALTH

1272. 518102 SOHAN SINGH 154 INDUSTRIES

1273. 518125 SAMIKSHA KUMARI 177 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1274. 518128 SANCHIT SHARMA 155 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1275. 518153 SANGEETA KUMARI 147 HIGHER EDUCATION

1276. 518154 SANIYA RAM 134 DC OFFICE L&S

1277. 518158 SANJAY SINGH 133 CO-OPERATION

1278. 518185 SATISH KUMAR 154 FOREST

1279. 518196 SAVITRI DEVI 154 LANGUAGE & CULTURE

1280. 518208 SEEMA DEVI 162 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1281. 518218 SHAMBHU RAM 157 HIGHER EDUCATION

1282. 518223 SHARVAN KUMAR 162 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1283. 518224 SHASHANK MOHAN 139 HEALTH

1284. 518232 SHIKHA VIKRAM 156 FOREST

1285. 518233 SHILPA 156 CO-OPERATION

1286. 518246 SHIVRA JSINGH 153 PRISON & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES

1287. 518248 SHUBHAMDHIMAN 140 HPPWD

1288. 518258 SIDHARTH KASHYAP 134 HOMEGUARD &


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

54

CIVILDEFENCE

1289. 518268 SONAM KUMARI 174 HIGHER EDUCATION

1290. 518302 SUMAN KUMARI 141 I & PH

1291. 518314 SUNIL DUTT 141 I & PH


1293. 518339 SURENDER SINGH 159 TOWN & COUNTRY PLANNING

1294. 518345 SURESH PAL 143 INDUSTRIES

1295. 518346 SURINDER KUMAR 166 HEALTH

1296. 518348 SURJEET SINGH 148 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1297. 518349 SURJEET SINGH 156 FINANCE (T&A)

1298. 518351 SURJEETSINGH 140 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1299. 518357 SUSHILSHARMA 136 CO-OPERATION

1300. 518381 TARUNA GAUR 144 HPSEBL

1301. 518385 TARUN SHARMA 170 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1302. 518407 VANITA TOMAR 136 CO-OPERATION

1303. 518410 VARUN SHARMA 158 INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

1304. 518439 VIKESH KUMAR 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

1305. 518443 VIKRAM SINGH 134 SC & ST DEV. CORPORATION

1306. 518445 VIKRAM SINGH 147 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1307. 518450 VIKRAM SINGH 153HP BUILDING & OTHERS CONSTRUCTIONS

1308. 518454 VIKRAM SINGH 154 HPSIDC

1309. 518461 VINAY SINGH NEGI 166 DCOFFICE SIRMOUR

1310. 518465 VINOD KUMAR 136 DCOFFICEKANGRA


1312. 518480 VINOD KUMAR 161 FOOD & CIVIL SUPPLIES

1313. 518481 VINOD MALVIYA 137 HEALTH

1314. 518486 VIPIN SHARMA 139 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1315. 518515 VISHALSINGH 151 FINANCE (T&A)

1316. 518517 VIVEK KUMAR 150 CO-OPERATION


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

55

1317. 518547 APALIKA 165 HPSEBL

1318. 518549 SHEETAL BHATIA 139 HPSEBL

1319. 518583 AARTI THAKUR 165 HPSEBL

1320. 518605 AMARDEEP 143 HPSEBL


1322. 518615 AMRISH KUMAR 138 HORTICULTURE

1323. 518619 ANILCHAND 140 I & PH

1324. 518627 ANILKUMAR 146 FINANCE (T&A)

1325. 518630 ANILKUMAR 167 HPPWD

1326. 518677 ARUNA BHARDWAJ 158 HEALTH

1327. 518691 AYUSHGUPTA 177 YOUTH SERVICES & SPORTS

1328. 518700 BALVINDER CHOUDHARY 149 INDUSTRIES

1329. 518728 BHUPENDER SINGH 161 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

1330. 518743 CHANDER PAL 143 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1331. 518789 DHEERAJ KUMAR 104 HPSEBL

1332. 518814 GHANSHYAM 166 HPSEBL

1333. 518823 HARISH KUMAR 143 HEALTH

1334. 518852 JAGMOHAN SINGH 142 HIGHER EDUCATION

1335. 518868 JITENDER KUMAR 153 SC&ST DEV.CORPORATION

1336. 518911 KAPILDEV 159 HPSEBL

1337. 518924 KAVITA SHARMA 151 LAND RECORDS

1338. 518953 KULDEEP 142 HEALTH

1339. 518957 KULDEE PKUMAR 153 HOME GUARD &CIVILDEFENCE

1340. 518996 LEELA DATT 158 HIGHER EDUCATION

1341. 519005 MADHUBALA 167 HPSEBL

1342. 519007 MAHENDER SHARMA 159 HEALTH

1343. 519040 MEENA DEVI 154 SC&ST DEV.CORPORATION

1344. 519052 MEERA DEVI 153 SC&ST DEV.CORPORATION

1345. 519068 MONIKA KUMARI 134 I &PH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

56

1346. 519071 MONIKA SHARMA 170 HIGHER EDUCATION

1347. 519079 MUNISH KUMAR 156 DC OFFICE KANGRA


1349. 519109 NEELAM 155 INDUSTRIES

1350. 519117 NEERAJ 164 FOREST

1351. 519134 NETAR SINGH 154 CO-OPERATION

1352. 519159 NIVEDITA 154 RURAL DEVELOPMENT

1353. 519176 PANKAJ KUMAR 147 PLANNING

1354. 519213 PRADEEP KUMAR 160 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

1355. 519239 PRERNA GUPTA 169 I & PH

1356. 519256 PUNAMLATA 160 I & PH

1357. 519275 RAHULVERMA 172 HIGHER EDUCATION

1358. 519278 RAJKUMAR 148 HPSEBL

1359. 519283 RAJENDER 165 I &PH

1360. 519313 RAKESH KUMAR 140 AGRICULTURE

1361. 519336 RAVINDE RKUMAR 164 TOWN & COUNTRY PLANNING

1362. 519353 RESHMA DEVI 153 HOME GUARD & CIVILDEFENCE


1364. 519392 SANGITA SHARMA 164 DC OFFICE SIRMOUR

1365. 519396 SANJAY KUMAR 179 LABOUR COMMISSIONER

1366. 519397 SANJAY KUMAR 165 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

1367. 519418 SATISH KUMAR 158 TRANSPORT

1368. 519420 SATISH PAL 158 HEALTH

1369. 519424 SAVITA 164 HPSEBL

1370. 519457 SHIV KUMAR 162 HPSEBL

1371. 519485 SONIKA 140 HEALTH

1372. 519490 SANJEEV KUMAR 167 ECONOMIC ADVISOR

1373. 519509 SUMIT SHARMA 149 HIGHER EDUCATION



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

57

1375. 519535 SUNITA KASHYAP 159 HPSEBL

1376. 519556 SUSHEEL KUMAR 165 HPSEBL

1377. 519566 TAPENDER SINGH 149 I &PH

1378. 519572 TARUNBALA 103 HIGHER EDUCATION

1379. 519607 VED PRAKASH 159 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

1380. 519627 VIKAS SHARMA 167 HPSEBL

1381. 519641 VINAY SINGH 160 HIGHER EDUCATION

1382. 519653 VINOD KUMAR 167 FINANCE (T&A)

1383. 519656 VINOD SHARMA 150 HIGHER EDUCATION

1384. 519665 YACHANA SHARMA 169 HIGHER EDUCATION

1385. 519671 YASHPAL 157 WOMEN & CHILD DEV.

1386. 519755 ANILKUMAR 156 INDUSTRIES

1387. 519765 ANKUSH SHARMA 169 DCOFFICE UNA

1388. 519808 BIYASDEV 148 HIGHER EDUCATION

1389. 519811 CHANDERJEET 165 ELEMENTARY EDUCATION

1390. 519814 DALJIT SINGH 141 I &PH

1391. 519818 DAULAT RAM 137 WOMEN&CHILD DEV.

1392. 519823 DEEPAK KUMAR 134 ECONOMICADVISOR

1393. 519835 DHRUVALIASDATARAM 174 FOREST

1394. 519890 JYOTI 154 DCOFFICE UNA

1395. 519898 KAMAL KISHORE DHIMAN 143 HPSEBL

1396. 519915 KULDIP CHAND 141 FINANCE (T&A)

1397. 519953 MANU THKAUR 164 DC OFFICE UNA

1398. 519957 MOHAMMAD ASLAM 141 STATE ELECTION COMMISSION

1399. 519977 MUNISH KUMAR 138 DC OFFICE UNA

1400. 519982 NARESH KUMAR 153 DC OFFICE UNA

1401. 520016 PANKAJ SHARMA 155 DC OFFICE UNA

1402. 520025 PARVEEN KUMARI 124 HPSEBL

1403. 520074 RAJVEER SHARMA 137 DC OFFICE UNA


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

58

1404. 520086 RAMESH CHAND 144 FOOD & CIVILSUPPLIES

1405. 520133 SACHIN KUMAR 171 HIGHER EDUCATION


1407. 520146 SANJEEV KUMAR 147 DC OFFICE KANGRA

1408. 520148 SANJEEV KUMAR 138 DC OFFICE KANGRA

1409. 520150 SANJEEV KUMAR SINGH 134 CO-OPERATION

1410. 520160 SARITA KUMARI 172 HPSEBL

1411. 520180 SHAM SUNDER 141 HIGHER EDUCATION

1412. 520187 SHAYREE 126 SOCIAL JUSTICE & EMPOWERMENT

1413. 520235 SUSHMA DEVI 153 DC OFFICE UNA

1414. 520242 UPASANA NEGI 157 TECHNICAL EDUCATION

1415. 520264 VINOD KUMAR 161 LAND RECORDS

1416. 520265 VINOD KUMAR 137 CO-OPERATION

1417. 520278 YASH PAL 172 HPPWD

.......RESPONDENTS

3. LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 43 OF 2021

H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION THROUGH

ITS SECRETARY HAMIPUR-177001, HP

..APPELLANT

AND

1. SHUBHAM THAKUR S/O SH. LAKSHI SINGH THAKUR,

VILLAGE P.O. GUMMA, THESIL SUNNI DISTT. SHIMLA HP.

2. SHIFALI RANA D/O SH. SUBASH CHAND RANA

R/O VERMA NIWAS CEMETERY SANJAULI TEHSIL AND

DISTT. SHIMLA HP

3. NISHA D/O SH. GIRDHARI LAL


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

59

R/O COSTAPAN, NEW BUILDING SET NO. 7

LAKKAR BAZAR SHIMLA HP

4. AMIT KUMAR SHARMA S/O LAXMI KANT SHARMA

R/O VILLAGE SADHORA POST OFFICE BALDYAIN

TEHSIL AND DISTT. SHIMLA HP

5. DINESH SINGH S/O SH. PRAKASH CHAND

VILLAGE JAKHUNI, PO BEHR KUTHERA

TEHSIL JAWAN DISTT. KANGRA HP

6. HITESHI SHARMA D/O BALDEV SHARMA

RESIDENT OF VILLAGE ARLOT P.O. HALOG

DHAMI TEHSIL & DISTT. SHIMLA, H.P.

..RESPONDENTS

7. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH

ITS CHIEF SECRETARY.

8. GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY PERSONNEL.

..PERFORMA RESPONDENTS

4. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No. 2329 of 2021

Between:

SHESH RAM,S/O SHRI NOK SINGH, R/O VILL. KHAROHAN, P.O. THANA, TEH. THUNTHUNAG, MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS SECRETARY.

3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENTGOVERNMENT OF H.P., SHIMLA-2


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

60

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

ABHINAY KATAOCH,S/O KULDEEP CHAND KATOCH,R/O VILL. KHUDLI, P.O. RAKKER,TEH. BAIJNATH, DIST. KANGRA,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND



3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENTGOVERNMENT OF H.P., SHIMLA-2THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS.

6. CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. 2420 of 2021Between:

SUDESH KUMAR, S/OSHER SINGH, R/O VILL. & P.O. SUNHI, TEH. BAGOH, DIST. KANGRA,HIMACHAL RPADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND


2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

61

ITS SECRETARY.


...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

VIKAS BHARDWAJ,S/O VIJAY KUMAR, RESIDENT OF V.P.L. NABAHI, VILLAGE, THOUR, TEH. SARKAGHAT, DIST. MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.

8. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No. 2422 of 2021Between:

RAKESH KUMAR, S/O ROSHAN LAL, R/O VILL. CHUBHANI, P.O. VALAYA, TEH. SUNDER NAGAR, DIST. MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

62

HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.



...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

RIPPU DAMMAN,S/O SHRI ASHUTOSH KUMAR, RESIDENT OF VPO DAULATPUR, TEHSIL KANGRA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

ATUL SHARMA, S/O SANTOSH SHARMA, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND POST OFFICE BIRBAGHER, TESHIL TIHRA SUJANPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

63




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

SUNIL KUMAR, S/O SH. DHARAM DUTT, R/O VILLAGE AND P.O. BHARNATEHSIL THEOG, DISTT. SHIMLAHIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

RAJEEV KUMAR, S/O SH. PREM CHANDVILLAGE CHOGAN, P.O. BIR,


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

64

TEHSIL BAIJNATH, DISTT. KANGRA,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

KULWANT SINGH, S/O SH. LAJJA RAM, VILLAGE SHAUNGR, P.O. BAGSHARTEHSIL KARSOG, DISTT. MANDI,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

65


Between:

RAJESH KUMAR, S/O SH. UTTAM RAM, VILLAGE DHOGI, P.O. CHOWAITEHSIL ANNI DISTT. KULLU, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

SUNIL KUMAR, S/O HET RAM, R/O VILLAGE BAGENTI, P.O. KIARTEHSIL THEOG DISTT. SHIMLA H.P. 171222.

….PETITIONER

AND




Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

66


...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

NARESH KUMAR, S/O SH. SUNDER SINGHVILLAGE PANJORI, P.O. HALLAN,TEHSIL SHAILAI, DISTT. SIRMOUR,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

ANIL KUMARS/O JALAM SINGH, R/O VILLAGE GATTA, P.O. SANGNA,TEHSIL SANGRAHA, DISTT. SIRMOURH.P. 173022.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

67

HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.



...RESPONDENTS.

18. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No.3142 of 2021Between:

RAHUL KUMAR,S/O SH. RAM LOTAN, R/O HOUSE NO. 1288/5 MOHALLAAMARPUR NAHAN HP 133001.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

AKSHAT BHASKER,S/O SH BRIJ LAL BHASKER,R/O HOUSE O. 977/5 JANKI VATIKA AMARPUR MOHALLA NAHANHP 173001.

….PETITIONER


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

68

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


VIKAS SHARMA,S/O SH NAND LAL, R/O VILLAGE JADEOG,P.O. SANDHU, TEHSIL THEOG,DISTT. SHIMLA H.P. 171222.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


KAMAL S/O SH. BUDH RAM,R/O VILLAGE BHALONA, P.O. BHALONA, TEHSIL SANGRAHA,DISTT. SIRMOUR, H.P. 173032.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

69

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

SHANTA KUMAR,D/O SH. SEVA RAM CHAUHAN,R/O VERMA NIWAS, DHOBI GHAT P.O. SANJAULI TEHSIL & DISTTSHIMLA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

70

YOGRAJ,S/O SH. MOTI RAM, VILL KHADVI, P.O. JAON, TEHSIL ANNI, DISTT. KULLU,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND




...RESPONDENTS.


Between:

DEEP KUMAR,S/O SH. BHAWANI DUTT,R/O VILLAGE SHAH PO CHOURIDHARTEHSIL KARSOG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTT HAMIRPUR, H.P. THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS.

25. CIVIL WRIT PETITION (ORIGINAL APPLICATION) NO.6985 OF 2020

Between:


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

71

SH. AJAY THAKUR,S/O SH. KHEM SINGH,AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE THATI, P.O. KOT, TEHSIL DHARAMPUR, DISTT. MANDI, H.P.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HP THROUGH SECRETARY(PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HP, SHIMLA HP.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFFSELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHALPRADESH THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS.

26. CIVIL WRIT PETITION (ORIGINAL APPLICATION)No. 7681 of 2020

Between:-

MS. ANURADHA DEVIDAUGHTER OF SH.GANPAT RAM, R/OTIKKAR, TUTI KANDI,P.O. CHAURA MAIDAN,TEHSIL AND DISTRICTSHIMLA-171004.

…PETITIONER

AND

1. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

…RESPONDENTS

27. CIVIL WRIT PETITION (ORIGINAL APPLICATION) No. 2394 of 2020

Between:-


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

72

ASHA DEVI D/O SH.NARINDER KUMAR, W/OSH. ABHISHEK THAKUR,VPO PANDOL, TEHSIL LADBHAROL, DISTRICTMANDI, H.P.

…PETITIONER

AND

1. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH THE SECRETARY (PERSONNEL)TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.

….RESPONDENTS.


Between:-

SAPNA S/O SH. ROSHANLAL, VILLAGECHHAPROT, P.O. BASSI,TEHSILJOGINDERNAGAR,DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

…PETITIONERAND

1. HIMACHAL PRADESH SUBORDINATE SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.,

THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF

HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA…RESPONDENTS.


Between:-


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

73

SH. ROHIT SHARMA S/O SH. KEWAL KRISHAN, R/O VILLAGE NARIANA, P.O. HARETA, TEHSIL NADAUN, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.

…PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY (PERSONNEL)TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, HAMIRPUR.

..RESPONDENTS.


Between:-

1. BHAVNESH KUMAR SON OF SH. MANOHAR LAL, R/O VILLAGE LASSI, P.O. CHHATRI, TEHSIL THUNAG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

2. ANIL SON OF SH. DIURU RAM, C/O THAKUR DASS, R/O VILLAGE MALYANA, SHIMLA, H.P.

3. BARU RAM SON OF SH. JEET RAM, C/O T.R. SHARMA, R/O GORKHU LODGE, KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-9, H.P.

…PETITIONERS

AND

1. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P., THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

…RESPONDENTS.


Between:-

DINESH KUMAR S/O SH. RANJIT SINGH, R/O VILLAGE DAR, POST OFFICE KASHMIR,


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

74

TEHSIL NADAUN, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P. …PETITIONER

AND

1. HIMACHAL PRADESH SUBORDINATE SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P., THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH SECRETARY(PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHALPRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

…RESPONDENTS.

32. LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No . 119 of 2021

Between:

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY, SHIMLA-2.

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS SECRETARY PERSONNEL, SHIMLA-2.

3. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR-177001.

……..APPELLANTS

AND

VIVEK THAKUR, S/O SH. SOHAN SINGH,VILLAGE SAHAJ, PO JASSAL, TEHSILKARSOG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

..........RESPONDENT






Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

75

……..APPELLANTS

AND

JANESH KUMAR, S/O LATE SH. RAJINDER SINGH, R/O PRINCO LODGE, INDER NAGAR,DHALLI, SHIMLA, H.P.






……..APPELLANTS

AND

KIRTY DEEP KHIMTA, S/O SH. BALWANT SINGH, R/O VILLAGE ASTANDLI, PO DOCHI,TEHSIL JUBBAL, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.






……..APPELLANTS

AND


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

76

SUSHIL CHAUHAN, S/O SH. SURJEET SINGH, VILLAGE KHANI, PO TANDI, TEHSIL ANNI, DISTT. KULLU, H.P.



HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION THROUGH ITSSECRETARY, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR-177001, H.P.

……..APPELLANT/PETITIONER

AND

1. GEETA DEVI, D/O SH. BALDEV RAJ, R/O VILLAGE SARLI, PO GEKHALI, TEHSIL AND DISTT. CHAMBA, H.P.

......RESPONDENT/PETITIONER

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

..........PROFORMA RESPONDENTS


HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION THROUGH ITS SECRETARY,HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR-177001,H.P.


AND

1. MOHINDER SINGH, S/O SH. LAL CHAND, R/O VILLAGE BIASAR, PO BIASAR, TEHSIL AND DISTT. CHAMBA, H.P.


2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

77

( PERSONNEL ) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.





AND

1. INDRA DEVI, S/O SH. SUNDER, VILLAGE CHAKHAR, PO AND TEHSIL ARKI, DISTT. SOLAN, H.P.


2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY ( PERSONNEL ) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.





AND

1. SH. PURUSHOTAM KUMAR, S/O SH. CHHAJU RAM, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BURATA, PO AND TEHSIL BANJAR, DISTT. KULLU, H.P.


2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

78

( PERSONNEL ) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.





AND

1. INDRA DEVI, S/O SH. SUNDER, VILLAGE CHAKHAR, PO AND TEHSIL ARKI, DISTT. SOLAN, H.P.


2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY ( PERSONNEL ) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.






……..APPELLANTS

AND

ROHIT KAUNDAL, S/O SH. UTAM SINGH,VPO PUTRIYAL TENSIL NADAUN, DISTT.HAMIRPUR, H.P.




Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

79




……..APPELLANTS

AND

SAVITA KUMARI VERMA, W/O RAVEESHCHANDEL, VERMA NIWAS, NEAR FORESTCHOWKI KASUMPATI, SHIMLA, H.P.



1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS CHIEF SECRETARY, SHIMLA-2.



……..APPELLANTS

AND

SHASHI KUMAR, S/O SH. VIRI SINGH R/OVILLAGE KOON, PO KOT TUNGLE, TEHSILKOTLI, MANDI, H.P.






Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

80


……..APPELLANTS

AND

PRADEEP KUMAR, S/O SH. MAAN SINGH,VPO BANI, TEHSIL BARSAR, DISTRICTHAMIPUR, H.P.






……..APPELLANTS

AND

ANIL SHARMA, S/O SH. SATYA PALSHARMA, VILLAGE BHATER, PO MOHIN,TEHSIL AND DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H.P.






……..APPELLANTS

AND


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

81

KIRAN THAKUR, W/O VIRENDER SINGHTHAKUR, D/O SH. PRATAP SINGH THAKUR,MONIKA NIWAS CEMETERY ROADSANJAULI, SHIMLA, H.P.






……..APPELLANTS

AND

PANKAJ SHARMA, S/O SH. H.R. SHARMA,R/O SHARMA HOUSE, KAGNA DHAR,BELOW BCS, NEW SHIMLA, H.P.




……..APPELLANT

AND

1. MAHESH THAKUR, S/O SH MEHAR SINGH, R/O BHAGAT SINGH HOSTEL ROOM NO. 319, HIMACHAL PRADESH UNIVERSITY SHIMLA,H.P.

......RESPONDENT

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY ( PERSONNEL ) TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

82

3. ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT, HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.




……..APPELLANT

AND

1. CHUDA MANI, S/O SH. DHAN RAM, VILLAGESANARLI, POST OFFICE BAINTHAL, KARSOG, DISTT. MANDI, H.P.

......RESPONDENT

2. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGHCHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

3. THE PERSONAL DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF H.P. SHIMLA-02, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

4. THE SOCIAL JUSTICE AND EMPOWERMENTTO THE GOVERNMENT OF H.P. THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY.

5. THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAXES ANDEXCISE, BLOCK NO. 30, SDA COMPLEX KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-09,HP.

6. THE DIRECTOR HEALTH SERVICE, HEALTHAND FAMILY WELFARE DIRECTORATE, SDA COMPLEX KASUMPTI SHIMLA-09, HP.

7. THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS (HOFF) HIMACHAL PRADESH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

83

FOREST DEPARTMENT, TALLAND, SHIMLA- 171001.

8. THE DIRECTORATE TREASURIES, ACCOUNTS AND LOTTERIES, BLOCK NO. 23 SDA COMPLEX, KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-171009 HP. THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR.


50. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No. 4903 of 2021.

Between:-

SAROJ KUMARI, OF SH. DALEEP THAKUR, RESIDENTOF THAKUR VILLA, DHAINDA, POST OFFICE TOTU.TEHSIL AND DISTRICT SHIMLA, H.P.

...PETITIONER.

AND

HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR. H.P.THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

….RESPONDENT.

51. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No.5078 of 2021.

MANJUSHA GANDHI, D/O LATE SH. SHYAMLAL GANDHI, V.P.O KASHLOG, TEHSIL ARKIDISTRICT SOLAN PIN-171102.

.....PETITIONER

AND


2. THE HP STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF HP SHIMLA 02, THROUGH SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS.



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

84

SH. KRISHAN LAL S/O MADAN LAL R/OVILLAGE JAMTHAL TEHSIL SADAR,DISTT.BILASPUR, H.P.

…. PETITIONER

AND

1. THE STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHCHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF H.P.SHIMLA-171002.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR,HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITSSECRETARY.

3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-02, THROUGHITS SECRETARY.

4. THE SOCIAL JUSTICE AND EMPOWERMENT TOTHE GOVERNMENT OF H.P. THROUGH ITSSECRETARY.

5. THE COMMISSION OF STATE TAXES AND EXCISE,BLOCK NO. 30, SDA COMPLEX, KASUMPTI. SHIMLA-9. H.P.

6. THE DIRECTOR HEALTH SERVICES, HEALTH ANDFAMILY WELFARE DIRECTORATE, SDA COMPLEX.KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-9. H.P.

7. THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OFFORESTS, HIMACHAL PRADESH FORESTDEPARTMENT, TOWLAND, SHIMLA-171001

8. DIRECTOR TREASURIES. ACCOUNTS ANDLOTTERIES, BLOCK NO. 23 SDA COMPLEX,KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-171009. H.P. THROUGH ITSDIRECTOR.

…...RESPONDENTS


SH. PUNEET S/O SH. RANJEET SINGH, AGRICULTURIST AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS, RESIDENT OF VPO SAKRI, TEHSIL DEHRA, DISTT. KANGRA, HP 176027.

…...PETITIONER.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

85

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH SECRETARY(TECHNICAL EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OFHIMACHAL PRADESH.

2. THE SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

3. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSIONHAMIRPUR, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, HAMIRPUR,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

…...RESPONDENTS.


SH. BINNI S/O SH. AMAR CHAND, AGRICULTURISTAGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, RESIDENT OF VPOGANDHARI, TEHSIL JHANDUTTA, DISTT.BILASPUR HP 174029.

…....PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, THROUGH SECRETARY(TECHNICAL EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OFHIMACHAL PRADESH.

2. THE SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENT OFHIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

3. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSIONHAMIRPUR, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, HAMIRPUR,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

…..RESPONDENTS.


RINKU DEVI W/O SH. GIRDHARI LAL, D/O SH. PHOOLCHAND, VPO KARANA, TEHSIL ANNI, DISTRICT MANDIH.P.

….PETITIONER.

AND


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

86

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEFSECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHALPRADESH, SHIMLA.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTT. HAMIRPUR, H.P. THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

…..RESPONDENTS.


1. YUV RAJ S/O SH. BRIKAM SINGH, R/O VILL. LAHROD, P.O.SANGALWARA, TEHSIL THUNAG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS.

2. DEVENDER KUMAR S/O SH. ROSHAN LAL, R/O VILL.RUHARA, P.O. SANGALWARA, TEHSIL THUNAG, DISTRICTMANDI, H.P. AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS.

....PETITIONERS

AND

1. STATE OF H.P. THROUGH SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TOTHE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR THROUGH ITSSECRETARY.

….RESPONDENTS.

57. CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. 5189 OF 2021.

SARITA DEVI D/O SH. DAYA RAM, R/O H. NO. 222,BHALENA 161, TEHSIL SANGARH SIRMAUR, H.P. 173023

...PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH SECRETARY(TECHNICAL EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OFHIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.

2. THE HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPURTHROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

..RESPONDENTS.



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

87

REKHA KUMARI W/O SHRI BALDEV SINGH, RESIDENT OFV.P.O. BASANTPUR, TEH. SARKAGHAT, DISTRICT MANDI,HIMACHAL PRADESH.

...PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEFSECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHALPRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS SECRETARY.

3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF H.P.,SHIMLA-02, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS


KAMAL THAKUR, S/O SHRI BISHANSINGH, RESIDENT OF VILLAGECHANYANA, TEH. PACHHAD, P.O.BHELAN, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

...PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEFSECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHALPRADESH, SHIMLA-2.



...RESPONDENTS


ROOP SINGH S/O SH. SHIV RAM, VILLAGE DAWANA, P.O.MAHOG, TEHSIL KARSOG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

...PETITIONER.

AND


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

88


2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, H. P. THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

...RESPONDENTS


NETER SINGH S/O SH. DURGA DASS, VILLAGE BHANWAS,P.O. JAROL, TEHSIL THUNAG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

...PETITIONER.

AND




...RESPONDENTS


NARENDER PAL SHARMA S/O SH. GIAN CHAND SHARMA,R/O BADWAL, P.O. BOONI, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, 177048

...PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITSSECRETARY (TECHNICAL EDUCATION) TO THEGOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-171002.

2. THE HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR,HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN.

...RESPONDENTS

63. CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. 6410 OF 2021


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

89

PAWAN KUMAR SON OF SH. DEEP RAM VILLAGE AISHA,P.O. DHAROGRA, TEHSIL SUNNI, DISTRICT SHIMLA, H.P.

..PETITIONER.

AND

HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,THROUGH ITS SECRETARY HAMIRPUR, DISTRICTHAMIRPUR, H.P.

...RESPONDENT.


NIDHI BHARDWAJ W/O SUNIL THAKUR R/O VILLAGEMANGHECH, P.O. GHANAHATI, TESHIL AND DISTRICTSHIMLA, H.P. 171014.

….PETITIONER.AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEFSECRETARY, SHIMLA-2.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHALPRADESH THROUGHITS SECRETARY.


….RESPONDENTS.65. CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO. 6465 OF 2021.

PALLVI SHARMA W/O ASHISH SHARMA R/O VILLAGEGARGHON PALASHON, P.O. BAG PASHOG, TEHSILPACHHAD, DISTRICT SIRMOUR, H.P. 173024.

….PETITIONER.

AND





Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

90

….RESPONDENTS.


SUNIL THAKUR S/O SH. RAJINDER THAKUR, R/O VILLAGEMANGHECH, P.O. GHANAHATTI, TEHSIL AND DISTRICTSHIMLA, HIMACHAL PRADESH-171004.

...PETITIONER.

AND




….RESPONDENTS.


AMAR SINGH, S/O SHRI TEK SINGH, RESIDENT OFVILLAGE CHHANYERA, P.O. PANGNA, TEH. KARSOG, SUBTEHSIL PANGNA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

...PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS CHIEFSECRETARY, TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHALPRADESH, SHIMLA-2.



….RESPONDENTS.



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

91

SAHIL VERMA S/O SH. RAMESH VERMA, R/O 111/1A BYEPASS ROAD KATHER, NEAR MEGA STORE SOLAN BASAL(48) CHAMBAGHAT SOLAN (HP) 173213.

...PETITIONER.

AND




….RESPONDENTS.


PRIYANKA WALIA W/O ANKUSH WALIA C/O AMAR NATHWALIA VPO PAPROLA TEH. BAIJ NATH DISTRICTKANGRA, (H.P.) 176115.

...PETITIONER.

AND




….RESPONDENTS.


REENA KUMARI D/O SH. BASU DEV, R/O VILLAGE. BASLA,P.O. BRAHMPUKHAR, TEHSIL SADAR, DISTRICTBILASPUR PIN-174001.

...PETITIONER.

AND



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

92



….RESPONDENTS.


SH. NARINDER KUMAR S/O SH. SAWROOP CHAND,OCCUPATION AGRICULTURIST, AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,RESIDENT OF VPO JASSI, TEHSIL BAROH, DISTRICTKANGRA, H.P. 176054.

...PETITIONER.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH SECRETARY(TECHNICAL EDUCATION) TO THE GOVERNMENT OFHIMACHAL PRADESH.

2. THE SECRETARY (PERSONNEL) TO THE GOVERNMENTOF HIAMCHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

3. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,THROUGH ITS SECRETARY, HAMIRPUR, HIMACHALPRADESH.

….RESPONDENTS.


Between:-

GOVIND SHARMAS/O SH. HIRA SINGH SHARMARESIDENT OF KAMAL COTTAGE SHAKTI VIHARPANTHAGHATI BEOLIA, SHIMLA TEHSIL &DISTRICT SHIMLA, H.P.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHSECRETARY (TECHNICAL EDUCATION)TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,SHIMLA-171002.

2. THE HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPURTHROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

93

..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

SH. DHEERAJ THAKURS/O LATE SH. SURINDRE SINGH THAKURRESIDENT OF OM BHAWAN, SOOD BUILDINGLOWER CHAKKAR, TEHSIL AND DISTRICTSHIMLA (H.P.)

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY (PERSONNEL)TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,SHIMLA-2.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

SAHIL S/O SH. PYARE LALR/O VILLAGE KASMARI POST OFFICEDEOTHI, THESIL RAMPUR BUSHAHAR,DISTRICT SHIMLA, H.P.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHCHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR(H.P.) THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

SH. SURESH KUMARS/O SH. BALDEV SINGH,R/O VILLAGE KOLLAR, P.O. KOLLAR,


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

94

TEHSIL PAONTA SAHIB, DISTRICTSIRMAUR, H.P.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY (PERSONNEL)TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,SHIMLA-2.

2. HIMACHAL PRADESH STAFF SELECTIONCOMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

AMAN GAUTAMS/O SH. HANS RAJ GAUTAMR/O VILLAGE LUHNOO KHAIRIAN NEAR LUHNOOCRICKET GROUND, P.O. BILASPUR TEHSIL SADARDISTT. BILASPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH 174001.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITSSECRETARY.

3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT,GOVERNMENT OF H.P. SHIMLA-02,THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

ANIL THAKURS/O SH. MAHENDER SINGHVILLAGE AND P.O. KANDAGAI, TEHSIL ANNIDISTT. KULLU HIMACHAL PRADESH.

….PETITIONER

AND


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

95

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-2.



..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

DURGA SINGHS/O SH. JAGAR SINGHR/O VILLAGE GEHAL P.O. KORAG,TEHSIL SANGRAHA, DISTT. SIRMOUR,H.P. 173023.

….PETITIONER

AND




..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

SOM DUTTS/O HIRA NANDR/O VILLAGE PAJAL, P.O. PIRANTEHSIL JUNGA, DISTT. SHIMLA 173217.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

96

ITS CHIEF SECRETARY, SHIMLA-2.



..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

RACHNA KUMARID/O SH. SURJIT SINGHR/O VILLAGE SHANI, P.O. TANDISUB TEHSIL NITHER DISTT. KULLU, H.P. 172033.

….PETITIONER

AND




..RESPONDENTS


Between:-

PRATAP SINGHS/O SH. HIMAT RAMR/O VILLAGE THUNAGI, P.O. CHHTRITEHSIL THUNAG, DISTRICT MANDI, H.P.

….PETITIONER

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGHITS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

97

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,HAMIRPUR, DISTT. HAMIRPUR, H.P.THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

..RESPONDENTS


VAIBHAV SHARMAS/O SH. S.K. SHARMA R/O NEAR GURUDARA BHAWANUPPER BAZAR SOLAN, NITIN DAILY NEEDSDISTT. SOLAN HP

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITSCHIEF SECRETARY, SHIMNLA-2.

2. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

3. THE PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT,GOVERNMENT OF H.P., SHIMLA-02 THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.

83 CIVIL WRIT PETITION (ORIGINAL APPLICATION)NO. 7585 OF 2019

1. AKSHAY SHARMA SON OF SHRI DAVINDER KUMAR SHARMA,R/O RAMA BHAWAN NEAR BINDER COLONY JUBDI DHAR DHALLI SHIMLA.

2. ANKUSH SHARMA SON OF SHRI NARENDER KUMAR,RESIDENT OF KHUBJA BHAWAN GOHAN LOWER CEMETERY ROAD SANJAULI SHIMLA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

3. SANDEEP KUMAR SON OF SHRI VILLAGE BUDDU,POST OFFICE & TEHSIL GHUMARWIN BILASPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

4. MANISH KAPOOR SON OF SHRI ROSHAN LALR/O VILLAGE SAYAND, POST OFFICE LOHARADISTRICT MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

5. SANDEEP KUMAR SON OF SHRI BHAG SINGHRESIDENT OF VILLAGE BUDDU, POST OFFICE & TEHSIL GHUMARWIN, DISTRICT BILASPUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

98

6. RAJ KUMAR SON OF SHRI DESH RAJR/O TEHSIL SARKAGHAT BAG (175) MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

7. PANKAJ SHARMA SON OF SHRI CHUNI LAL,RESIDENT OF VILLAGE REWALSAR, DISTRICT MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

8. VIRENDER KUMAR SON OF LATE SHRI SANT RAM,RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MATYARA, TEHSIL BALDWARA, DISTRICT MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

9. PANKAJ KUMAR SON SH. JOGINDER SINGHVPO BHATALI PHAKARIAN, TEHSIL DEHRA DISTRICT KANGRA, H.P

10. MOHIT MAHAJAN, SON SHRI BRIJESH MAHAJANR/O MOHALLA JANSALI, POST OFFICE & DISTRICT CHAMBA HIMACHAL PRADESH.

11. SUSHIL CHAND KATOCH SON OF SH. PRAKASH SINGH KATOCH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BHAGOT, POST KUTHERA, TEHSIL GHUMARWIN, DISTRICT BILASPUR.

12. ABHIMANYU SINGH SON OF SHRI JEEVAN SINGH THAKURRESIDENT OF VILLAGE KUTWA, POST OFFICE KAMAND TEHSIL ANI, DISTRICT KULLU, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

13. ABHISHEK KAUNDAL SON OF SHRI MANSA RAMRESIDENT OF VILLAGE THARU, POST OFFICE AND TEHSIL NAGROTA BAGWAN, DISTRICT KANGRA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

14. SANJEEV KUMAR SON OF SHRI DEVIRESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAMNAGAR…..

....PETITIONERS.

AND

1. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH THROUGH CHIEF SECRETARYTO THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH.

2. SECRETARY PERSONNEL TO THE GOVERNMENT OFHIMACHAL PRADESH.

3. H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION, HAMIRPUR,DISTRICT HAMIRPUR, THROUGH ITS SECRETARY.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

99

4. BAL KRISHAN SON OF SHRI MEGH RAMRESIDENT OF VILLAGE DIMO, POST OFFICE SARAIN TEHSIL CHOPAL DISTRICT SHIMLA.

5. SHRI PRADEEP KUMAR SON OF SHRI TARA CHAND,RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KOT, POST OFFICE BALINDI, TEHSILKARSOG, DISTRICT MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

6. SHRI BUNESHEWAR SINGH,VPO SINDSALI, TEHSIL CHIRGAON, DISTRICT SHIMLA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

7. SHRI HARSH KUMAR SON OF SHRI PRADEEP KUMAR,RESIDENT OF VILLAGE ALWAH, POST OFFICE BADORG, TEHSIL THEOG, DISTRICT SHIMLA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.

8. MR. PARNEET SHARAM SON OF SHRI VASUDEV SHARMARESIDING AT DIVYA COTTAGE, NEAR JAIN TRADERS, PANTHAGHATI, SHIMLA 171009.

9. MR. KULDEEP SHARMA SON OF SHRI RAJ KUMAR SHARMA,RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KOTI, POST OFFICE MARHANA, TEHSIL GHUMARWIN, BILASPUR.

10. MS. JYOTI, DAUGHTER OF SHRI DINESA KUMAR,RESIDENT OF PUNJAB HOUSE, GHORA CHOWKI, SHIMLA-171005.

11. MRS. SAVITA VERMA, DAUGHTER OF SHRI GOPAL VERMA,R/O VERMA NIWAS, NEAR FOREST CHOWKI, GORKHU-LODGE,KASUMPTI, SHIMLA-171009.

12. MRS. VANITA D/O SHRI PARMANAND,R/O BAGHAL NIWAS, CONVENT VIEW AREA,CHOTA SHIMLA, SHIMLA-2

13. MR. RAJEEV KUMAR SON OF SHRI PREM CHANDRESIDENT OF VILLAGE CHOGAN, POST BIRTEHSIL BAIJNATH, DISTRICT KANGRA.

14. MR. JANESH KUMAR SON OF LATE SHRI RAJINDER SINGHR/O PRINCE LODGE, INDER NAGAR, DHALLI, SHIMLA-171012.

15. MR. PANKAJ SHARMA SON OF SHRI H.R. SHARMA,R/O SHARMA HOUSE, KANGADHAR, BELOW BCS NEW SHIMLA171009.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

100

16. MR. RAM DAYAL SON OF SHRI CHAMAN RAMRESIDENT OF VILLAGE MANDOHTA, POST OFFICE BHARARU, TEHSIL JOGINDERNAGAR, DISTRICT MANDI.

17. MR. SUSHIL CHAUHAN SON OF SHRI SURJEET SINGHRESIDENT OF VILLAGE KHANI, POST OFFICE TANDI TEHSIL ANNI, DISTRICT KULLU.

18. MR. RAKESH KUMAR SON SHRI NARIANVILLAGE GICHHNA, POST OFFICE MAKRAOG,TEHSIL CHOPAL, DISTRICT SHIMLA-171211.

19. MR. VIVEK THAKUR SON OF SHRI SOHAN SINGH THAKUR, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SAHAJ, POST OFFICE JASSAL,TEHSIL KARSOG, DISTRICT MANDI-175009.

20. MR. KULWANT SINGH SON OF SHRI LAJJA RAMRESIDENT OF VILLAGE SHAUNGI, POST OFFICE, RESIDENT BAGSHAR, TEHSIL KARSOG, DISTRICT MANDI-175009.

....RESPONDENTS

MR. DILIP SHARMA, MS. RANJANAPARMAR, MR. SANJEEV BHUSHAN, MR.ANKUSH DASS SOOD, MR. AJAYSHARMA AND MR. V.S. CHAUHAN,SENIOR ADVOCATES WITH MR. KARANSINGH PARMAR, MR. RAKESHCHAUHAN, MR. RAJNEESH K. LAL, MR.AJAY KASHYAP, MR. ANAND SHARMA,MR. ANIL KUMAR, MR. AJAYCHAUHAN, MR. RAKESH K. DOGRA,MR. NARESH VERMA, MR. VIKASRAJPUT, MR. PANKAJ SAWANT, MR.MANISH SHARMA, MS. REETAHINGMANG, MR. PRAVEEN KUMARCHANDEL, MR. SANJAY SINGH, MS.ARCHNA DUTT, MR. VISHAL SINGHTHAKUR, MR. DIGVIJAY SINGHTHAKUR, MS. VEENA SHARMA, MR.ABHISHEK SHARMA, MR. NARENDERREDDY, MR. NEERAJ SHARMA, MR.HEMANT KUMAR THAKUR, MR.SANJAY SINGH, MS. SEEMA K.GULERIA, MR. SHYAM SINGHCHAUHAN, MR. AMIT JAMWAL, MR.R.L. VERMA, MR. NARESH KUMARVERMA, MR. DHEERAJ KANWAR,ADVOCATES, FOR THE PETITIONER(S)IN THE RESPECTIVE PETITIONS.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

101

MR. B.C.NEGI, SR. ADVOCATE WITHMR. SANJEEV KUMAR AND MR.ANGREZ KAPOOR, ADVOCATES, FORTHE APPELLANTS IN LPA NOS. 41, 42, 43,62, 63, 64, 70 AND 71 OF 2021.

MS. SUCHITRA SEN, ADVOCATES, FORTHE APPELLANTS IN LPA NOS. 116 TO126 OF 2021.

MR. ASHOK SHARMA, ADVOCATEGENERAL WITH MR. RAJINDERDOGRA, SENIOR ADDITIONALADVOCATE GENERAL, MR. VINODTHAKUR, MR. SHIV PAL MANHANS,MR. HEMANSHU MISRA, ADDITIONALADVOCATE GENERALS AND MR.BHUPINDER THAKUR, DEPUTYADVOCATE GENERAL, FOR THERESPONDENTS-STATE.

MR. SANJEEV KUMAR, MR. ANGREZKAPOOR AND MS. SUCHITRA SEN,ADVOCATES, FOR THE RESPONDENT-H. P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION,IN THE RESPECTIVE PETITION(S).

MR. ANKUSH DASS SOOD, SENIORADVOCATE WITH MR. RAJNEESHK.LAL, ADVOCATE, FORRESPONDENT NO.1 IN LPA NO. 43 OF2021.

MR. ANKUSH DASS SOOD, SR.ADVOCATE WITH MS. SHWETAJOOKLA, MR. ONKAR JAIRATH, MS.SHALINI THAKUR, MR. NAVEEN K.BHARDWAJ, MR. AJAY SHANDIL, MR.ANIL KUMAR GOD, MR. AVINASHJARYAL, MR. J. L. BHARDWAJ, MS.YOGITA DUTTA, MR. MALAYKAUSHAL, MR. RAKESH KUMARDOGRA, MR. VINOD CHAUHAN, MS.KIRAN SHARMA, MR. K. C.SANKHYAN, MR. RAJ KUMAR NEGI,MR. SUNIL KUMAR, MS. RICHASHARMA, MR. JAI RAM SHARMA, MR.NARESH K. SHARMA, MR. TARUNSHARMA, MR. ARVIND, RAJENDERTHAKUR, MS. REETA HINGMANG, MR.ANAND SHARMA, MR. ANIL THAKURAND MS. SEEMA K. GULERIA,


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

102

ADVOCATES, FOR THE RESPONDENTSIN THE RESPECTIVE PETITIONS.

Reserved on: 08.12.2021Decided on: 31.12.2021

____________________________________________________________________These petitions coming on for hearing this day, Hon’ble Mr. Justice

Satyen Vaidya, passed the following:

O R D E R

All these petitions are being decided together by a common judgment as

identical questions of fact and law are involved.

The questions, posed for determination herein, have arisen from

happening of events which have sequentially continued for inordinate period of

more than six years.

2. Government of Himachal Pradesh had created posts of Junior Office

Assistant (Information and Technology), Class-III, Non-Gazetted [for short,

“JOA (IT”)] for recruitment in its various Administrative Departments. Common

Recruitment and Promotion Rules (for short, “2014 Rules”) for the post JOA (IT)

were notified on 24th December, 2014. The minimum educational and other

qualifications for the direct recruitment were prescribed as under: -

(a) ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATION:-

(i) 10+2 from a recognized Board of School Education/University.

(ii) One year Diploma in Computer Science/Computer Application/Information Technology from a recognizedUniversity/Institution.

(iii) Computer typing speed of 30 words per minute in English or 25 words per minute in Hindi.

OR

(i) 10+2 from a recognized Board of School Education/University.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

103

(ii) ‘O’ or ‘A’ level Diploma from National Institute of Electronics & Information Technology (NIELIT).

(iii) Computer typing speed of 30 words per minute in English or 25 words per minute in Hindi.

(b) DESIRABLE QUALIFICATION(S).- Knowledge of customs, manner and dialects of Himachal Pradesh and suitability for appointment in the peculiar conditions prevailing in the Pradesh.”

3. The Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission (for short

“HPSSC”) vide Advertisement No. 30/2015 dated 13.02.2015 invited

applications from the eligible candidates for appointment to 1421 posts of

JOA(IT). Though the prescribed minimum essential qualifications were

as per R&P Rules, still, besides the candidates having qualifications as per

advertisement, a large number of candidates falling under one of the

following categories were also provisionally admitted by HPSSC:

(i) Those who either held qualification higher to the prescribed

qualifications;

(ii) those who were having prescribed qualifications but from

institutes which were not considered as recognized;

(iii) those who held qualification equivalent to the prescribed

qualification.

This anomalous situation was result of the prevalent procedure

which required applications to be submitted online without supporting

documents merely on the basis of declaration of candidate made in the

online recruitment applications. However, there was clear stipulation in

the advertisement that the candidates must ensure their eligibility in

respect of category, experience, age and essential qualification(s) etc. as


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

104

per requirement of the post advertised to avoid rejection at later stage.

4. Having received the applications from large number of candidates

whose educational qualifications were not strictly in accordance with the

prescription made either in the 2014 Rules or the advertisement, HPSSC

started to seek clarification from the State Government since as far back

as 4.11.2015, when for the first time HPSSC sought clarification from

State Government by posing questions as under:

“1. Whether a certificate or diploma issued by any registered institute

operating within the state of H.P. or from outside the state is valid

for determining eligibility for recruitment to the post of Junior

Office Assistant (IT) or such certificates issued by recognized

institutes are to be accepted.

2. A list of registered/recognized institutes whose diplomas/certificates

are valid/recognized for determining eligibility for the post.

3. Any other clarification/guidelines as deemed fit in respect of the

recruitment to the post.”

The process seeking clarification continued thereafter as is evident

from series of correspondence dated 25.02.2016, 27.12.2016, 29.5.2017,

3.6.2017, 24.6. 2017 and 14.7.2017 available on record of CWPOA 34 of

2019 (Pawan Kumar and others Vs State of H.P and others).

5. In absence of any decision from the State Government, HPSSC

continued with selection process. A written objective type test was held on

10.04.2016. Total 12473 candidates qualified the test and were called to

undertake Skilled Typing Test. 10271 candidates appeared for the Skilled

Typing Test and 4092 candidates qualified and were called for interviews

which were scheduled from 13.05.2017 to 12.07.2017. Candidature of all


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

105

candidates, except those who were found to be holding qualification

strictly as per 2014 Rules, were rejected. Faced with the situation, some of

persons with rejected candidature approached the then State

Administrative Tribunal (for short, “Tribunal”) against their rejection by

way of OA Nos. 2830, 2989, 2994, 2998, 3009 and 3026 of 2017 and an

order dated 30.6.2017 came to be passed by the Tribunal in following

terms:

Heard.

Notice in all the original applications except O.A. No.2994

of 2017, which is accepted by Ms. Archna Dutt in O.A. Nos.2830

and 3026 of 2017 and Mr. Raj Kumar Negi in O.A. Nos.2989,

2998 and 3009 of 2017, learned Standing Counsel, respectively.

2. All these matters being inter-connected, shall stand

clubbed together.

3. On an oral prayer made on behalf of the applicant(s), State

of Himachal Pradesh through the Secretary (Personnel) to the

Government of Himachal Pradesh, is ordered to be impleaded as

co-respondent No.2 in all the original applications except O.A.

No.2998 of 2017. Copies supplied. Amended memos of parties be

filed by the next date of hearing. The Registry also to reflect this

order in the list of parties in all the original applications except

O.A. No.2998 of 2017.

4. Notice on behalf of respondent No.1-State in O.A. No.2998

of 2017 and newly added respondent No.2 in other OAs is also

waived by Mr. Gaurav Kochhar, learned Dy. AG.

5. Replies be filed within four weeks.

6. In terms of the previous order dated 28.06.2017 passed in

O.A. No.2994 of 2017, Bhavnesh Kumar and others Versus

Himachal Pradesh Staff Selection Commission, the learned

Standing Counsel for the respondent-Commission has filed


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

106

instructions dated 29th June, 2017, which are taken on

record.

7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties on the prayer on

behalf of the applicant(s) for interim relief.

8. The process for recruitment to the post of Junior Office

Assistant (IT) has been initiated by the respondent-Commission.

The requisite qualifications for the post are as under:-

“EDUCATIONAL QUALIFICATION:-

(i) 10+2 from a recognized Board of School Education/

University.

(ii) One year Diploma in Computer Science/Computer

Application /Information Technology from a recognized

University/Institution.

(iii) Computer typing speed of 30 words per minute in

English or 25 words per minute in Hindi.

OR


University.

(ii) ‘O’ or ‘A’ Level Diploma from National Institute of

Electronics & Information Technology (NIELIT).


English or 25 words per minute in Hindi.

OR


University.

(ii) Diploma in Information Technology (IT) from a

recognized ITI/Institution.


English or 25 words per minute in Hindi.”

9. All the applicants are 10+2. However, the nomenclatures

of the one year diploma held by them in Computer is not in

consonance with the nomenclature of the diploma mentioned in the


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

107

aforesaid educational qualifications. However, prima facie, it is

made out that they are holding one year diploma in Computer. In

such circumstances, there shall be a direction in the interim to the

respondent-Commission to permit the applicant(s), who admittedly

have already appeared in the written/typing test, to appear in the

interview, provisionally. However, their result shall not be

declared and instead kept in a sealed cover till the matter with

regard to equivalence of the diploma held by them with the

diploma required as per the aforesaid educational qualifications is

considered and decided by the newly added respondent No.2-State,

which shall be done as expeditiously as possible, but within a

reasonable timeframe.

10. It shall be the responsibility of each of the applicants to

produce certified copy of this order before the Secretary to

respondent No.1-Commission forthwith.

All these original applications were later registered as CWPOA Nos.

2253, 2289, 2290, 2388, 2394 and 7681 of 2020 in this Court after

abolition of the Tribunal.

6. On 21.8.2017, the State Government directed HPSSC to go ahead

with the recruitment process in terms of decision taken by the equivalence

committee formed for the purpose. The communication dated 21.08.2017

reads as under: -

“I am directed to refer to your letter No. HPSSC 8(2)-862/15-

13161 dated 14th July, 2017 and also the other references seeking

clarification on the subject cited above and to say that the matter has

been considered at the Government Level in compliance of the directions

passed by the Hon'ble Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal in OA

No. 2994 of 2017 and other various similar OA's pending adjudication

before the Hon'ble, Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal that the

applicant(s) be permitted to appear in the interview, provisionally and


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

108

their result should be kept in sealed cover till the matter with regard to

equivalence of the diploma held by them with the diploma required as per

prescribed educational qualification in rules is considered and decided by

the State. While passing these orders the Hon'ble Himachal Pradesh

candidates are holding one year diploma in Computer though

nomenclature of the one year diploma held by them in Computer is not in

consonance with the nomenclature as prescribed. The Government after

having detailed examination and convening a meeting of all concerned

departments has arrived at the following decisions:

(1). All such candidates having one year Diploma in Computer or

higher qualification in Computer Science/Application/IT from any

private Institution like from. Society under Societies Act. Rashtrya

Saksharta Mission IT programme/Skill Development Programme

etc. be considered for final selection subject to having successfully

passed their skill test i.e. Typing Test on Computer and after

having obtained their undertaking/declaration certifying that they

had attended the classes/diploma course by attending the classes

regularly.

(2). That the Computer Science is not limited to the specific

nomenclature of Diploma prescribed in the R&P Rules, as such,

the Diplomas in Computer and other Higher Qualifications

belonging to Computer Science/application Irrespective of their

nomenclature be also considered for final selection subject to

having successfully passed their skill test i.e. Typing Test on

Computer and alter having their undertaking/declaration certifying

that they had attended the classes/diploma course by attending the

classes regularly. There may be instance where certificates are

issued instead of diploma, In: such cases, the Commission is to

ascertain and ensure that subjects stadled, are at par with one year

Diploma course in Computer Science/Application/IT.

(3). The date of personal interview of the candidate concerned in

the instant case be treated as valid date for evaluation/


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

109

consideration/acceptance of his/her diploma/ essential

qualification.

(4). With regard to educational qualification, as informed during

the meeting, the Commission has sought clarification of

equivalence in some cases from the concerned authorities,

therefore, the Commission need to proceed further in accordance

with the clarification/decision obtained from the State Level Board

of Equivalence Committee/H.P. Board of School Education by

accepting the qualification of such candidate(s) for this job if that

is found equivalent to 10+2 and valid for pursuing higher studies.”

The decision so taken and conveyed was subsequently approved by

the State Cabinet on 18.09.2017.

7. In pursuance to the above noticed decision of the Government,

HPSSC reviewed the selection process and allowed those candidates to be

considered for selection, who had earlier been rejected. Appointments

were accordingly offered and made. Consequently, many candidates

though eligible as per R&P Rules, could not find place in the merit of

selected candidates. This triggered another round of litigation. Some of

these candidates approached the Tribunal by way of OA No. 5543 of 2017

which later came to be registered as CWPOA 34 of 2019 in this Court and

is also being decided herein. Since this Original Application was filed

after declaration of final select list of HPSSC and all the selected persons

were impleaded as private respondents with the aid of order 1 Rule 8 of

the Code of Civil Procedure.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

110

8. Thus, following two sets of litigations arose out of selection

process undertaken by HPSSC for posts of JOA (IT) under Post Code 447

(hereinafter referred to as “JOA 447”)

(i) OA Nos. 2830, 2989, 2994, 2998, 3009 and 3026 of 2017

(later registered as CWPOA Nos. 2253, 2289,2290,2388,2394 and

7681 of 2020 in this Court after abolition of the Tribunal) by

candidates whose candidature for JOA 447 was rejected by HPSSC

for not possessing qualification as per R&P Rules.

(ii) OA No. 5543 of 2017 (later registered as CWPOA 34 of

2019 in this Court) by candidates who failed to find their names in

select list as a consequence of decision dated 21.8.2017

9. The above-mentioned litigation gave rise to the issue, Whether

the decision dated 21.8.2017/18.9.2017 of State Government qualified

the test of legality and fairness, if so, whether the selections made by

HPSSC to JOA 447, in pursuance to such decision, were valid?

10. For adjudication of above question, in the first instance, we

propose to consider the challenge raised by petitioners in CWPOA No. 34

of 2019 which has been filed for following reliefs:

“i. That Annexure A-2 clarification dated 21st ofAugust 2017 issued by respondent number 1 may bequashed and set aside. Further Annexure A-3 officeorder dated 8 of September 2017 may also bequashed and set aside.

ii. That the respondent number 2 may be directed toprepare merit list of candidates possessing essentialand minimum qualification mention in theadvertisement No.3/2015 dated 13.2.2015 andrecommend their names for recruitment.”

11. Petitioners in CWPOA 34 of 2019 have raised following grounds

for seeking the reliefs as noticed above:


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

111

a) Respondents could not have prescribed additionalmode of selection.

b) There was no power to relax the R&P Rules vis-a-visessential qualification.

c) The entire exercise was done with oblique motive toallow the ineligible candidates.

d) It nullified the effect of R&P Rules.e) Those persons also became eligible who had acquired

minimum qualifications on dates subsequent to the lastdate of submission of applications.

f) The changes in R&P Rules could be made only by dueprocess of law.

12. The genesis of dispute can be traced from the following expression

used in 2014 Rules:-

“One year Diploma in Computer Science/Computer Application/Information Technology from a recognizedUniversity/Institution”.

Firstly, there appeared to be a confusion with respect to import of

expression “recognized University/Institution” and secondly, in respect

of diploma qualification having been held by the candidates under

different nomenclatures. The dispute arose when many candidates

applied for JOA 447 claiming to have Diploma in the same subjects as

prescribed in 2014 Rules but with different nomenclature and the other

dispute was raised in respect of authority which was to recognize the

institutes issuing requisite Diploma. Another area of discord was created

by the candidates having higher qualification. As evident from the said

clause of 2014 Rules, no specific nomenclature of required diploma was

prescribed. It was mentioned only as diploma in computer

science/computer application/information technology, whereas more than

one type of curriculum could be said to have satisfied the requirement in

this behalf. As regards recognized university is concerned, there could not


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

112

be any dispute regarding the authority having jurisdiction to recognize the

university, but it was totally unclear as to which was the authority whose

recognition was valid vis-a-vis the institution prescribed by 2014 Rules.

13. Before adverting to the merits of ground or objections raised in

CWPOA No.34 of 2019, it is relevant to notice that Original Application

was filed before the Tribunal after the process of appointments to the post

of JOA (IT) (post code-447) was completed by respondents. Noticeably,

neither the selection process undertaken by HPSSC for JOA 447 nor the

selections made thereby are under challenge. It is also to be noticed that

the decision of the State Government dated 21.08.2017 to allow candidates

for selection other than the candidates having qualification strictly as per

the R&P Rules was ratified and confirmed by an ex-post facto sanction

granted by the State Cabinet on 18th September, 2017 and such decision of

the Government has also not been assailed. Simply, the prayer made in the

original application seeking directions to HPSSC to prepare merit list of

candidates possessing essential and minimum qualification mentioned in

the advertisement No.3/2015 dated 13.02.2015 may not suffice in the

absence of the reliefs as noticed above

14. In the aforesaid backdrop, we now proceed to consider the

objections raised by petitioners in CWPOA 34 of 2019. A challenge has

been laid to the competence and power of the State Government to relax

R&P Rules and also to prescribe additional mode of selection. It has been

contended that change in R&P Rules could not be made by administrative

instructions without adoption of due process as envisaged under law. The


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

113

contention so raised by the petitioners deserves rejection, for the reasons

that firstly the 2014 Rules, vide Clause 18 reserves power of relaxation in

favour of State Government. The relevant Clause reads as under: -

“18. Power to relax.- Where the State Govt. is of the opinionthat it is necessary or expedient to do so, it may, by order forreasons to be recorded in writing and in consultation with theHimachal Pradesh Public Service Commission, relax any ofthe provision(s) of these rules with respect to any class orcategory of person(s) of post(s).

By virtue of decision dated 21.08.2017 confirmed by State Cabinet on

18.09.2017, it was decided that the category of persons sought to be

selected required elaboration. This power to relax is vested in the State

Government, in case State Government finds it necessary or expedient to

do so. The only prescription that appears to have been lacking in the

instant case is that the Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission was

not consulted before the aforesaid decision. The right of consultation with

Public Service Commission is prescribed by Article 320(3) of the

Constitution, however, the Proviso to Article 320 empower the Governor

of State to make Regulations specifying matters exempted from prior

consultation process of the Public Service Commission. In exercise of such

powers “The Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission (Exemption

from consultation) Regulations, 1973” have been framed. As per

Regulation 3 thereof the exemption from consultation extends to services

and posts specified in Schedule to such Regulations and clause 8(i) of the

Schedule relates to selection and recommendation for making recruitment

to Class III posts, excepting certain categories which in any case does not


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

114

include the post of JOA(IT). Thus the relaxation of 2014 Rules undertaken

by the State Government was within its competence and powers.

15. Secondly, it is evident from the facts detailed hereinabove that the

prescriptions of requisite qualification be it in 2014 Rules or in the

advertisement could not be said to be unambiguous. The subjects of

Computer Science or Information Technology cannot be restricted only to

the nomenclature used in R&P Rules/advertisement. Both these subjects

carry within them more than one type of curriculum. Thus, in the absence

of any clarity as to the kind of curriculum required as pre-condition for

eligibility, the decision of the State Government dated 21.08.2017 read

with cabinet decision dated 18.09.2017 cannot be faulted. In addition,

there was also no clarity as to the authority whose recognition was valid,

vis-a-vis, the institutions competent to award requisite Diploma. The

repeated correspondence inter-se the HPSSC and the State Government is

evidences this fact. Further, the material discussed by the equivalence

committee appointed by the State Government also warrants the same

conclusion. Support can be drawn from the fact that common R&P Rules

for the post of JOA (IT) have been amended by the State Government in

2020 (for short, “2020 Rules”), the relevant extract thereof reads as under:

“(a) ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATION(S):(i) Should have passed 10+2 from a recognizedBoard of School Education/University.

ORMatriculation from recognized Board of SchoolEducation with one/two year'sDiploma/Certificate from an Industrial TrainingInstitute (ITI) in Information TechnologyEnabled Sectors (ITES) as notified by DirectorGeneral of Employment & Training (Govt. ofIndia) from time to time or three years Diplomain Computer Engineering/Computer Science/IT


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

115

from Polytechnic as approved by All IndiaCouncil for Technical Education (AICTE);”

Record reveals that one of the considerations for amendment of these

Rules was the imprecise provision as to the exact kind of diploma required

and also the authority which was empowered to authorise the institutions

to award the requisite diploma. The 2020 Rules now appears to have

clearly prescribed the institutes whose diploma will be valid as also the

nomenclature of the diploma as will be relevant for considering the

selection and appointment to the post of JOA (IT).

16. Thirdly, it cannot be ignored that multifarious litigations had

erupted as a result of the ambiguous 2014 Rules and the posts of JOA (IT)

involved therein were required to be filled on urgent basis. The number of

posts advertised as well as their usefulness in almost all the departments of

the Government underlined the importance and urgency involved.

Apparently, Class-III, Non-Gazetted posts of JOA (IT) became necessity

in all the departments as a result of advent of computerization and

information technology. In order to cope with the requirements of

personnel having basic knowledge in computer, these posts were created.

The records further reveal that even after the selection process undertaken

for JOA 447, hundreds of more posts of JOA (IT) came to be advertised

later through advertisement for post codes 556 and 817.

17. Fourthly, the exercise to constitute equivalence committee was

under taken in pursuance to the judicial order passed by the Tribunal on

30.6.2017. This order was never assailed by anyone including the

petitioners in the instant petition. This being so, the deviation made by the


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

116

State Government from R&P Rules in the aforesaid manner cannot be

faulted.

18. Last but not the least, there is nothing on record from which it can

be inferred that the impugned action of the State Government/HPSSC had

some extraneous motive or was not bonafide. The contention of the

petitioners that the entire exercise of respondents was with oblique motive

to allow ineligible candidate is to be ignored without any tangible material

on record in support or substantiation thereto.

19. The contention raised by the petitioners that by the aforesaid action

of the respondents, those persons also became eligible who had acquired

the eligibility after the cutoff date prescribed in the advertisement is also

required to be rejected for the reason that the petitioners have miserably

failed to provide details in respect of such category of persons. In absence

of such details no relief can be granted to the petitioners particularly in the

view of the nature of dispute that involves more than one categories of

candidates. The contention of petitioners, if was to be upheld, would have

required such category of persons to be identified separately. Even

otherwise there is no trite law that the employer cannot change the

prescription during continuation of selection process. This can be said with

more certainty in the given facts and circumstances of the case where there

was urgency and the time taken to amend ambiguous Rules would have

caused prejudice to the employer.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

117

recruitment/selection process cannot be made subject matter of judicial

review merely on the ground that the employer has changed/ amended the

rule(s) after initiation of the process. Reference in this regard can be

placed on judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Maharashtra

Public Service Commission Through Its Secretary; Ashok Tukaram

Barde Vs. Sandeep Shriram Warade and Others; Suhas Sudhakarrao

Lavhekar and Others Etc. Etc., (2019) 6 SCC 362, wherein it has held

as under:

[9] The essential qualifications for appointment to a post are for

the employer to decide. The employer may prescribe additional or

desirable qualifications, including any grant of preference. It is the

employer who is best suited to decide the requirements a candidate

must possess according to the needs of the employer and the nature

of work. The court cannot lay down the conditions of eligibility,

much less can it delve into the issue with regard to desirable

qualifications being at par with the essential eligibility by an

interpretive re-writing of the advertisement. Questions of

equivalence will also fall outside the domain of judicial review. If

the language of the advertisement and the rules are clear, the Court

cannot sit in judgment over the same. If there is an ambiguity in

the advertisement or it is contrary to any rules or law the matter

has to go back to the appointing authority after appropriate orders,

to proceed in accordance with law. In no case can the Court, in the

garb of judicial review, sit in the chair of the appointing authority

to decide what is best for the employer and interpret the conditions

of the advertisement contrary to the plain language of the same.

To similar effect is exposition made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in State

of Madhya Pradesh Vs. Raghuveer Singh Yadav, (1994) 6 SCC 151,

which reads as under:


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

118

[5] It is not in dispute that Statutory Rules have been made

introducing Degree in Science or Engineering or Diploma in

Technology as qualifications for recruitment to the posts of

Inspector of Weights and Measures. It is settled law that the State

has got power to prescribe qualifications for recruitment. Here is a

case that pursuant to amended Rules, the government has

withdrawn the earlier notification and wants to proceed with the

recruitment afresh. It is not a case of any accrued right. The

candidates who had appeared for the examination and passed the

written examination had only legitimate expectation to be

considered of their claims according to the rules then in vogue. The

amended Rules have only prospective operation. The government

is entitled to conduct selection in accordance with the changed

rules and make final recruitment. Obviously, no candidate acquired

any vested right against the State. Therefore, the State is entitled to

withdraw the notification by which it had previously notified

recruitment and to issue fresh notification in that regard on the

basis of the amended Rules.

21. Thus, the contentions raised by petitioners in CWPOA No. 34 of

2019 are rejected and the process of selection and appointment already

concluded by the respondents against Post Code 447 is upheld. In view of

the declaration of selection process for Post Code 447 as legal and valid,

the petitions i.e. CWPOA No. 2253, 2289, 2290, 2388, 2394 and 7681 of

2020 have been rendered infructuous as the relief sought in all such


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

119

petitions was to allow the persons other than those having qualifications

strictly as per R & P Rules/advertisement in the selection process.

22. While the selection process for JOA 447 was still experiencing the

turmoil of rival claims, as detailed above, HPSSC, undertook yet another

process for selection of 1156 posts of JOA (IT) in pursuance to

advertisement No. 32-3/2016 dated 18.10.2016 (post code 556)

(hereinafter referred to as JOA 556) for brevity, out of which 85 posts

were to be filled on regular basis in Excise Department and the rest were

to be filled on contract basis. The Essential Minimum Qualification this

time also remained as per prescription of 2014 Rules. Again, the online

applications were submitted by all categories of candidates, as in the case

of JOA 447, and the already existing confusion aggravated. As noticed

above, the selection process for JOA 447 stood completed in September,

2017 from perspective of respondents, notwithstanding, pending litigation

for rival claims. Faced again with dilemma, HPSSC once again sought

clarification from the State Government regarding criteria to be adopted

for selection process against post code 556. In response, the State

Government vide letter dated 19.03.2018 directed HPSSC to implement

the clarification earlier issued vide communication dated 21.8.2017 in the

on-going process against post code 556 also. Contents of letter dated

19.3.2018 read as under:

“I am directed to refer to your letters No. HPSSC-C92)970/16 dated01.01.2018 & 16-02-2018 on the subject cited above and to say that since theposts of Junior Office Assistant (IT), Class-III (Non-Gazetted) have beenadvertised under different post codes i.e. Post Code 447 and 556 but are to befilled up under one set of common Recruitment and Promotion Rules for thepost and as such carry one or similar cadre. It has been decided that theclarification dated 21-08-2017, issue by this department on the directions ofHon’ble Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal in respect of post code


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

120

447, be also implemented in the on going process under post code 556, beingrecruitment for the same post with similar provisions of rules. However, theclarification/instructions dated 21-08-2017 are under challenge before theHon’ble Court, as such, its implementation will be subject to final outcome ofHon’ble Court orders so passed in case of post code 447 in the pendingmatters.”

23. The aforesaid decision of State Government prepared another

battle grounds for rival claimants. CWPOA No. 7585 of 2019 titled

Akshay Sharma Vs State of H.P. and others is one such petition which has

been filed by the candidate claiming right of selection strictly as per 2014

Rules. Whereas, petitions filed by candidates seeking benefit of decision

taken by the State Government on 21.8.2017 for JOA 447 and made

applicable to JOA 556 vide communication dated 19.3.2018 are CWPOA

6985 of 2020, CWP No. 2329 of 2021, CWP No.2361 of 2021, CWP No.

2420 of 2021, CWP No. 2421 of 2021, CWP No. 2422 of 2021, CWP No.







3892 of 2021, CWP No. 3893 of 2021, CWP No. 4032 of 2021, CWP

No.4033 of 2021, CWP No. 4349 of 2021, CWP No.4387 of 2021, CWP

No. 4503 of 2021, CWP No. 4621 of 2021, CWP No. 4903 of 2021, CWP





Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

121



No.6557 of 2021, CWP No. 7179 of 2021, CWP No. 7203 of 2021, CWP

No. 7209 of 2021, CWP No. 7213 of 2021, CWP No. 7234 of 2021 and

CWP No. 7743 of 2021.

In addition to above, a number of petitions, filed by candidates who had

sought benefit of relaxation granted by Government, were allowed by

learned Single Judge of this Court on different dates as detailed hereafter

and the judgments passed by learned Single Judge have been assailed in

Letter Patent Appeals before this Court which are being decided in the

bunch of instant matters. The details of such cases in tabulated form are as

under:

Sr.N

o

LPA No. CWP No. Titled Decided on

1 41/2021 2567/2019 HPSSC VsChandermani

19.3.2021

2. 42/2021 2246/2019 HPSSC VsMahesh Thakur

19.3.2021

3. 43/2021 20/2019 HPSSC VsShubham Thakur

6.4.2021

4. 62/2021 1342/2020 HPSSC VsPurshotamKumar

6.4.2021

5. 63/2021 2721/2019 HPSSC Vs AmitPanwar

6.4.2021

6. 64/2021 2775 of 2019 HPSSC Vs Indradevi

6.4.2021

7. 70/2021 3240 of 2019 HPSSC VsMohinder Singh

6.4.2021

8. 71/2021 3239 of 2019 HPSSC Vs GeetaDevi

6.4.2021

9. 116/2021 2548/2021 State Vs SushilChauhan

7.7.2021

10. 117/2021 2552/2021 State Vs KirtiDeep

7.7.2021

11. 118/2021 2550/2021 State Vs JaneshKumar

7.7.2021

12. 119/2021 2559/2021 State Vs VivekThakur

7.7.2021

13. 120/2021 2558/2021 State Vs PankajSharma

7.7.2021

14. 121/2021 2551/2021 State Vs KiranThakur

7.7.2021

15. 122/2021 2564/2021 State Vs AnilSharma

7.7.2021

16. 123/2021 2554/2021 State Vs PardeepKumar

7.7.2021

17. 124/2021 2547/2021 State Vs 7.7.2021


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

122

Shashikala18. 125/2021 2549/2021 State Vs Savita

Kumari7.7.2021

19. 126/2021 2553/2021 State Vs RohitKaundal

7.7.2021

24. Despite communication dated 19.3.2918 from State Government

to the HPSSC, the selections for JOA 556 were ultimately made strictly in

accordance with 2014 Rules. Noticeable, a sequence of events took place

after publication of JOA 556 Advertisement which ostensibly made the

HPSSC to ignore directions of Government. A glance at such events shall

be material to understand the background.

24.1. An Original Application No. 2644 of 2018 (CWPOA 7585 of

2019) titled Akshay Sharma Vs State of Himachal Pradesh and others was

preferred before the Tribunal laying challenge to the communication dated

9.3.2018 of the State Government. On 16.8.2018 the Tribunal passed

interim order in OA 2644 of 2018 in following terms:

“In the facts and circumstances, materials on record and interest ofjustice, subject to keeping fifteen posts of Junior Office Assistantvacant post for the applicants and final outcome of the originalapplications, respondent No.3-Commission shall be free to declarethe result of the process for recruitment to the post of Junior OfficeAssistants.”

The order dated 16.8.2018 was assailed before this Court in CWP

1964/2018, which was disposed of in following terms vide order dated

28.8.2018:

“In this background, we clarify that the appointments to the posts ofJunior Office Assistant (Code 556) shall be strictly in accordancewith the Common Recruitment & Promotion Rules for the posts ofJunior Office Assistant (Information Technology), Class-III (Non-gazetted) in various Departments of Himachal Pradesh Government,as also Advertisement No. 32-3/2016 and not in terms ofcommunication, dated 19th March, 2018.”

Thus, the respondents were directed to make recruitments for JOA 556

strictly as per R&P Rules.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

123

24.2 A review of judgment dated 28.8.2018 of this Court in CWP

1964/2018 was sought by those candidates who supported the

communication dated 9.3.2018 of the State Government. Review Petition

82 of 2018 was decided in following terms on 5.11.2018:

“5. Be that as it may, as the matter is sub-judice before the learnedTribunal and the Committee which has submitted its report on21.08.2017, has been so constituted by the learned Tribunal, itsrecommendations, can be looked into by the learned Tribunaluninfluenced by any observations made by this Court in theperspective of the Common Recruitment & Promotion Rues, in thebackdrop of the controversy involved in the application before it.”

The effect of judgment dated 16.8.2018 in CWP 1964/2018 was diluted

and the matters were left open to be decided by the Tribunal.

24.3 Another Original Application No. 7397 of 2018 titled Naresh

Kumar and others came up for hearing before the Tribunal on the ground

that candidates with higher qualification could not be considered for

selection as settled by Supreme Court in Zahoor Ahmed Rather Vs

Sheikh Imtiaz Ahmed [ (2019) 2 SCC 404 ] and an order dated

21.12.2018 came to be passed by the Tribunal directing HPSSC to make

selections against post code 556 strictly as per Common R&P Rules and

also in consonance with decision of Supreme Court in Zahoor Ahmed

Rather (Supra). This order became subject matter of challenge in CWP

161 of 2019 titled Bhupinder Sharma Vs State of H.P. and others before

this Court. An interim order dated 11.1.2019 was passed in CWP 161 of

2019 to the following effect:

“Meanwhile, the operation of impugned order dated 21.12.2018(Annexure P-7), passed by Himachal Pradesh AdministrativeTribunal, in O.A. No. 7397 of 2018, shall remain stayed. However,the Staff Selection Commission shall only allow the eligiblecandidates to participate in the process.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

124

24.4. On 23.2.2019 HPSSC declared result of post code 556. Total 596

candidates were selected taking into consideration the R&P Rules and

remaining 2400 candidates were rejected. Aggrieved against their ouster

from selection process, many rejected candidates approached The Tribunal.

On 26.2.2019 the Tribunal directed status quo to be maintained with

regard to issue of appointment letters in pursuance to declaration of result

of post code 556 by HPSSC in OA No. 677/2019 (CWPOA 20 of 2019).

Aggrieved against order dated 26.2.2019 passed by the Tribunal a group

of selected candidates approached this Court by filing CWP 629 of 2019.

24.5. Certain candidates whose applications were rejected by the HPSSC

on the ground that they had not acquired the technical qualification from a

recognised institute filed application in CWP 161/2019 as interveners. On

21.5.2019 Division Bench of this Court passed an interim order in CWP

161/2019 in following terms:

“In some of the matters, which have been adjourned for 17.6.2019,

learned Advocate General has sought time for constitution of

committee to examine equivalence of academic/technical

qualification. Let the said committee comprising of 3 to 5 experts be

constituted within two weeks, which will examine all the issues

regarding recognition and genuineness of the qualifications, which

are claimed to be equivalent or higher than those prescribed under

the Recruitment and Promotion Rules. The question whether

equivalent qualification will be eligible for the advertised post is

kept open to be decided at the appropriate stage. Meanwhile, it

shall be discretion of the State Government to offer appointment to

the selected candidates strictly in order of merit on contract basis

(and not against regular posts) provided such candidates are

possessing qualification strictly as per R&P Rules. These


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

125

appointments will be a stop gap arrangement and subject to

outcome of these writ petitions”

24.6. The committee appointed by the Government vide proceedings

dated 15.6.2019 considered three issues and made its recommendations in

following terms:

(i) Equivalence of the academic/ technical qualifications prescribed

under the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Junior Office

Assistant (IT)

Recommendation

Thus, keeping in view the facts and circumstances narrated as above the

committee unanimously concluded that no equivalent qualification can be

considered/ recommended in the absence of specific clause to this effect in

the R&P Rules.

(ii) Recognition of the institutions imparting trainings and running

courses in computer/ IT related subjects;

Recommendation

Thus, keeping above in view, the committee agreed that only qualification

obtained from recognised institute be considered for recruitment for

JOA(IT) and ZONE OF CONSIDERATION/ selection cannot be expanded

after start of selection process.

(iii) Higher qualification vis-à-vis the minimum essential qualifications

prescribed under the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post.

Recommendation

Hence, the committee was in consensus that the candidates with higher

qualification cannot be considered for appointment to the post of JOA(IT)

under the existing R&P Rules.

24.7. A division bench of this Court decided CWP 161/2019 and 629

/2019 by a common judgment dated 29.08.2019. So far as the claim of the

candidates with higher qualifications is concerned, the same was declined


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

126

on merits, however, the claim of candidates having qualified from

institutes not considered recognized by State/ HPSSC was left open. The

HPSSC while declaring the result of post Code 556 had declared only

those candidates successful who fulfilled the prescribed essential

qualifications as per R&P Rules. On 17.09.219, HPSSC declared the

revised result. Thus, in pursuance to the selection process for post Code

556 only those candidates were selected who strictly held the

qualifications as per Advertisement and R&P Rules.

25. On 20.08.2019, amendment was proposed in 2014 Rules. The

candidates holding the equivalent qualifications for post Code 556

approached this Court by way of CWP No. 2246 of 2019, in which interim

direction was issued vide order dated 11.09.2019 in the following terms: -

“In the interim, the appointments, if any, of the selected candidate(s)

against the post of J.O.A(IT) post code-556, shall be subject to the

order to be passed in the application on the next date of hearing

after taking on record the version of the respondents.”

26. On 06.12.2019, the State Government directed the HPSSC to treat

the recruitment process for post Code 556 concluded with directions to re-

advertise/filled the unfilled and new posts after Notifications/Publication

of new common R&P Rules, which were said to be under active

consideration of the Department of Personnel. The writ petitions were

filed with the reliefs identical to CWP No. 2246/2019. On 15.10.2020, a

Division Bench of this Court in a bunch of matters lead case being CWP

No. 2246 of 2019, again reiterated that the selections made pursuant to the

Notification in issue would remain subject to outcome of these petitions.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

127

The R&P Rules were finally amended and fresh Advertisement for the

post of JOA(IT) was issued against post Code 817 on 21.09.2020. On

15.10.2020 in bunch matters referred to hereinabove, the following order

was passed by this Court:-

“Pursuant to Advertisement No.36-2/2020, dated 21.09.2020, issued by

respondent-HPSSC, to the posts of Junior Office Assistant (IT), the

respondent-H.P. Staff Selection Commission, Hamirpur, is permitted to

proceed with the recruitment process, however, the final result shall not

be announced without permission of this Court. Application stands

disposed of.”

27. The HPSSC declared the result of Written Objective Type

Screening Test against post Code 817 and provisionally shortlisted total

19024 candidates for typing skilled test.

28. Thus, three successive Advertisements were issued by the HPSSC

for recruitment to the post of JOA(IT) but as the irony would have been,

none of the selection processes have attained finality. There is challenge

to the final selection made in post Code 447 by those who held the

qualifications strictly in terms of R&P Rules. Challenge to selection

process for post Code 447 is also there by the candidates who claimed

equivalent qualifications as per R&P Rules but remained unsuccessful.

The selection process against post Code 556 had also been challenged by

those who either held higher or equivalent qualifications or qualifications

from institutes considered not recgnised. As regards the persons with

higher qualifications probably their fate stands sealed by the judgment

passed by a Division Bench of this Court in CWP No. 161 of 2019, but all

other challenges were still alive.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

128

29. As regards the selection process for JOA 447, we already have

held the decision of State Government dated 21.8.2017 and 18.9.2017 as

also the selections/appointments made in pursuance thereto as legal and

valid. Now the next question which remains to be decided relates to the

selection process undertaken by the HPSSC for JOA 556 and the conduct

of respondents-State in respect thereof. As noticed above, the

advertisement for the Post Code 556 for 1156 posts was issued by the

HPSSC on 18.10.2016. Total 85 posts out of advertised posts were to be

filled on regular basis and rest on contract basis. The prescribed minimum

essential qualification was again as per R & P Rules and, therefore, in the

same language as in the case of Post Code 447. Despite the

communication of the State Government to HPSSC dated 19.3.2018 to

adopt the same procedure in selection process as was adopted in selection

process of Post Code 447 in pursuance to the Government decision dated

21.8.2017 read with 8.9.2017, the selections and appointments were made

by applying the 2014 Rules strictly. Thus, the allowance given to

candidates in selection process of Post Code 447 was withdrawn in

selection process of Post Code 556. The reason, as appears from the

record, was various interim orders passed by Tribunal/Courts from time to

time and also the constitution of another Equivalence Committee by the

State Government, which had recommended to apply the 2014 Rules

strictly without deviation. Noticeably, out of 1156 advertised posts only

596 candidates were declared qualified, selected and appointed.


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

129

30. Evidently, the reason for constitution of another equivalence

committee was an interim order passed on 21.5.2019 by a Division Bench

of this Court in CWP No. 161 of 2019. The second Equivalence

Committee had given its recommendations on 15.6.2019.

31. The question that arises for determination is whether the

application of different set of rules contemporaneously for the same post

by the respondents is justified? The only defence the respondents are

relying is an interim order passed by Division Bench of this Court on

21.5.2019 in CWP No. 161 of 2019 and the consequent constitution of

second equivalence committee. The perusal of aforesaid order, however,

reveals that there was no direction from this Court as such for appointment

of equivalence committee. It was specifically noticed that the learned

Advocate General had sought time for constitution of Committee to

examine equivalence of academic/technical qualification. It was in this

context that this Court ordered for appointment of an equivalence

committee required to examine all issues regarding recognition and

genuineness of the qualifications which were claimed to be equivalent or

higher than those prescribed under the R & P Rules. It is worth noticing

that vide same order the question whether equivalent qualification will be

eligible for the advertised post was kept open to be decided at the

appropriate stage. In this view of the matter, the respondents cannot be

allowed to take shelter of aforesaid order dated 21.5.2019 passed in CWP

No. 161 of 2019 and especially when even while disposing of the said writ


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

130

petition finally this Court had left the question of equivalence and

recognition institutes open.

32. There is nothing on record to suggest that the State Government

having once issued communication dated 19.3.2018 had ever issued any

correspondence subsequently to withdraw the directions issued to HPSSC.

In absence of such an exercise, it is not understandable as to on what basis

the HPSSC declared the result by considering the qualifications strictly as

per the R & P Rules. Probably, this had resulted in view of interim orders

passed in different applications/petitions filed before the Tribunals/Courts.

Be that as it may be, the question as posed above is still alive. The mere

fact that second equivalence committee was constituted and it had

recommended to apply the 2014 Rules strictly cannot be held sufficient

reason for the respondents to ignore their earlier decision dated 21.8.2017

made applicable to Post Code 556 vide communication dated 19.3.2018.

Indisputably, these decisions were neither withdrawn nor nullified by any

subsequent act of the State Government. Once the State Government had

exercised its power to relax the R & P Rules, there had to be a conscious

decision again of the State Government to revert back to the original

position, which is clearly missing in the instant case. There is nothing on

record to suggest that the recommendations made by second equivalence

committee were even considered by the Government/ employer much less

accepted at any stage. That being so, the recommendations of second

equivalence committee cannot by themselves have the effect of nullifying

the decision dated 21.8.2017/9.3.2017 made applicable to Post Code 556


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

131

vide communication dated 19.3.2018. Thus, the denial of the right to all

persons similarly situated to those, who were considered for selection in

Post Code 447 from outside the purview of 2014 Rules is clearly arbitrary

and needs to be interfered with.

33. Thus, the HPSSC is directed to re-cast the merit list for JOA 556

by including all categories of candidate as was done for JOA 447 on the

basis of decision of Government dated 21.8.2017/18.9.2017 and further

made applicable to JOA 556 vide communication 19.3.2018 except the

candidates with higher qualification, who have already been held ineligible

vide judgment dated 29.8.2019 of a Division Bench of this Court in CWP

161/2019. These selections for JOA 556 shall be made by taking into

account the entire number of vacancies advertised for JOA 556 and the

decision of the Government/HPSSC to close the selection procedure for

JOA 556 is set aside and quashed.

34. Since the Common R&P Rules stand amended by 2020 Rules and

the cause of persistent confusion for the time being appears to have been

removed, as a necessary consequence selection for JOA 817 shall take

place in accordance with 2020 Rules, however, the selection process shall

not include the selection for posts which were left over from advertised

posts of JOA 556 as the said posts have already been directed to be filled

through selection process of JOA 556.

35. In view of above discussion and directions, all the petitions

considered herein are decided accordingly:


Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

132

(a) CWPOA 34 of 2019 is dismissed. CWPOAs 2253, 2289, 2290,

2388, 2394 and 7681 of 2020 have been rendered infructuous.

(b) CWPOA No. 7585 of 2019 titled Akshay Sharma Vs State of H.P.

and others is dismissed

(c) CWPOA 6985 of 2020, CWP No. 2329 of 2021, CWP No.2361 of

2021, CWP No. 2420 of 2021, CWP No. 2421 of 2021, CWP No.

2422 of 2021, CWP No. 2423 of 2021, CWP No. 2426 of 2021,

CWP No. 3111 of 2021, CWP No. 3112 of 2021, CWP No. 3116

of 2021, CWP No. 3133 of 2021, CWP No. 3134 of 2021, CWP

No. 3137 of 2021, CWP No. 3141 of 2021, CWP No. 3142 of





No. 4032 of 2021, CWP No.4033 of 2021, CWP No. 4349 of 2021,

CWP No.4387 of 2021, CWP No. 4503 of 2021, CWP No. 4621 of





No. 5674 of 2021, CWP No. 5760 of 2021, CWP No. 5761 of


6410 of 2021, CWP No.6557 of 2021, CWP No. 7179 of 2021,



Hig

h Court

of H.P

.

133

of 2021, CWP No. 7234 of 2021 and CWP No. 7743 of 2021 are

allowed.

(d) LPAs 41/2021, 42/2021, 43/2021, 62/2021, 63/2021, 64/2021,

70/2021, 71/2021, 117/2021 to 126/2021 filed by HPSSC or/and

the State Government are dismissed. The judgments passed by

learned Single Judge are upheld subject to modification that

directions issued in said judgments shall be read in consonance

with the directions issued hereinabove by this Court. No orders as

to costs. Misc. applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.

(Tarlok Singh Chauhan) Judge

December 31, 2021 (Satyen Vaidya) (naveen) Judge


1 REPORTABLE/NON-REPORTABLE IN THE HIGH COURT ...

Documents